- 2 days ago
An 88mm shell could cripple an Abrams—but what would happen to the four crewmen inside? This military-history analysis uses a hypothetical encounter, not a documented event, to compare the feared German tank gun of World War II with the M1A1 Abrams and trace how the shell’s impact point could shape the crew’s chances.
From the Abrams’ heavily armored turret front and sloped glacis to vulnerable tracks, side armor, and rear, each possible hit reveals a different risk. The breakdown also explores the driver’s isolated position, the crew-protective ammunition bustle, and the blowout panels designed to vent fire away from them. For viewers interested in tank design, armored warfare, World War II weapons, and modern military technology, this narrated military history feature offers a seat-by-seat look at how battlefield lessons changed tank crew survivability.
From the Abrams’ heavily armored turret front and sloped glacis to vulnerable tracks, side armor, and rear, each possible hit reveals a different risk. The breakdown also explores the driver’s isolated position, the crew-protective ammunition bustle, and the blowout panels designed to vent fire away from them. For viewers interested in tank design, armored warfare, World War II weapons, and modern military technology, this narrated military history feature offers a seat-by-seat look at how battlefield lessons changed tank crew survivability.
Category
📚
LearningTranscript
00:00A German 88-millimeter tank gun could throw a 10-kilogram armor-piercing shell out of its barrel at about
00:071,000 meters per second.
00:09In the last year of the Second World War, that shell was the reason Allied tank crews studied every tree
00:16line twice.
00:17From 1,000 meters, the long-barreled version on the King Tiger was rated to punch through roughly 190 millimeters
00:25of steel laid back at an angle.
00:28Almost nothing the Allies fielded in numbers could stop it from the front.
00:32The M1 Abrams entered service in 1980, 35 years after the war that made the 88 famous.
00:40The two were never meant to fight each other, and there's no record of an Abrams crew ever being hit
00:45by one.
00:46Any video telling it as a true story is inventing it.
00:50The question keeps coming up anyway, because it's a clean way to measure how far armor came in one lifetime.
00:57So put four men inside an M1A1, hatches closed, facing a gun crew with a long 88,000 meters out.
01:05Where that one shell lands decides almost everything about what happens to each of them.
01:11And the place that ought to scare them most is a compartment the designers deliberately packed with explosives.
01:18Start with where they sit, because the seat is most of the story.
01:23The driver is alone at the front of the hull, on the center line, lying back in a semi-reclined
01:30seat.
01:30The plate above him is sloped so steeply that he can't sit upright with his hat shut.
01:37Behind and above him is the turret.
01:39The gunner sits low on the right, with his brow pressed to his sight.
01:44The tank commander sits directly behind him, a little higher, close enough to grab his shoulders.
01:49On the left, the loader works standing beside the breech of the 120mm main gun.
01:56Behind all three, past armored sliding doors, is the turret bustle.
02:02On the M1A1, it holds 34 main gun rounds.
02:06Inside, the tank is loud even when nothing is happening.
02:10The gas turbine at the back winds like a jet on a taxiway, and the four men hear each other
02:16mostly through the intercom in their helmets.
02:19The air smells of hydraulic fluid, and of whoever hasn't showered in a week.
02:24The shell matters as much as the seat.
02:27An 88 crew had a few kinds of ammunition.
02:30The standard armor-piercing round was a capped steel shot with a small explosive charge in its base,
02:37built to punch through a tank and then go off inside it.
02:41A tungsten-cored round went faster, but German crews rarely had enough of it.
02:46A shape-charge round was rated for about 90mm of armor at any range.
02:51For this, take the worst realistic case.
02:55The full-power armor-piercing round, fired from the long gun on the King Tiger.
03:00The likeliest hit is the front of the turret.
03:03A gunner aims center of mass, and on a tank facing him, that's the turret face.
03:09It's also where the Abrams carries its heaviest armor.
03:12The army has never published how much protection that adds up to,
03:16and open estimates vary so widely that quoting one here would be guesswork.
03:21Combat is a better witness.
03:23In 1991, Iraqi T-72s fired 125mm rounds at M1A1s.
03:31That gun was bigger than the 88, built decades later, and designed to kill modern tanks.
03:39A government review of the war cited army reports of several M1A1 crews taking direct frontal hits from T-72s,
03:48with minimal damage, one of them reportedly struck twice from 2,000 meters.
03:52So an 88 against the turret face very likely stays outside.
03:58That doesn't make it gentle.
04:00Even after slowing over 1,000 meters of flight, the shot arrives carrying somewhere between 4 and 5 million joules.
04:08That's about the energy of a two-ton truck hitting a wall at around 150 miles an hour,
04:14concentrated on a patch smaller than a dinner plate.
04:17The four men would hear it as one enormous bang through the hull.
04:22The loader, the only one standing, takes the worst of the jolt.
04:26Outside, the hit can strip away whatever isn't armor,
04:30starting with the window on the gunner's sight and the commander's weapon mount.
04:35A crew can come through a hit like that without a scratch, and still have a tank that can't see.
04:40A sheltered seat still pays for a hit like that, and the turret face is the gentlest version of the
04:46lesson.
04:47Drop the aim a few feet, and the shell hits the glacis, the long sloping plate in front of the
04:53driver.
04:54That slope is the reason he lies back.
04:56A steep angle forces a round to cross more armor, and gives it a good chance of glancing off.
05:02The 88's armor-piercing shot was a full-caliber steel slug, designed against the flatter plates of the 1940s.
05:11Against a modern glacis at that angle, the most probable outcome is a ricochet that howls off over the turret
05:19roof.
05:20But of the four men, the driver is the most alone.
05:24He has his own hatch, and nobody within arm's reach.
05:28If he's hurt, the turret crew can only reach him by traversing the gun until a gap opens behind his
05:35seat,
05:35then reaching through a space barely wide enough for a man in a vest.
05:39A glancing hit the turret crew would shrug off, can still leave him concussed,
05:45his periscopes cracked, steering 60-plus tons of tank half-blind.
05:50And there's a quieter target low on the tank that a 1944 gun crew knew well.
05:56The tracks.
05:58Tankers in that war learned that a tank which couldn't be penetrated could often still be stopped
06:04by breaking its track and letting everything else on the field finish the job.
06:09A tank that can't move fights only in the direction it happens to be facing.
06:15An 88 into the front idler, or the road wheels, would probably leave the Abrams parked right where it stopped.
06:22There's a real example of what that does to a crew, with no 88 involved.
06:28During Desert Storm, an M1A1 from the 24th Infantry Division bogged down in mud on the push toward the Euphrates.
06:37Its unit moved on, and the crew waited for recovery.
06:41Then three T-72s came over a rise toward it.
06:46By the account most often retold, the first T-72 hit the front of the turret and did no damage.
06:54The stuck crew killed it, then killed the second the same way.
06:58The third fired from about 400 meters, left a dent in the front armor, and pulled back behind a sand
07:05berm.
07:06The Abrams gunner found the heat of its engine in his thermal sight and fired through the berm.
07:11The crew lived.
07:13Their tank still couldn't move an inch.
07:15That story is usually told to show off the frontal armor.
07:19Read it the other way.
07:20Those men survived because every attacker happened to come at their strongest side.
07:25An 88 crew that broke a track would have time to walk its shots around to the flank.
07:31The front was built to take it.
07:33The sides were not.
07:35A shell coming in at an angle hits the turret side.
07:38On the right, that's where the gunner and commander sit.
07:41The forward part of the turret wall is still heavily armored, but the farther back and the more square the
07:47hit, the less there is in the way.
07:50Nobody outside the program knows exactly where an 88 would start getting through, and any precise figure would be a
07:57guess.
07:58What can be said is how the risk spreads.
08:01The gunner and commander are packed into one corner of the turret, within a foot or two of each other,
08:07so one bad hit there involves both men.
08:10That same closeness is what gives them a chance.
08:14The commander can reach the gunner.
08:16The loader can reach them both.
08:18If one man is hit, two others are right there to drag him up through a turret hatch.
08:24The driver, down in the hull, has none of that.
08:27If you want more of the war from the crew's seat, from Sherman's to Abrams, subscribe.
08:34Every video walks through how the men inside actually lived, fought, and got out.
08:40Because the next hit lands in the one place where later wars actually found the Abrams.
08:46Low on the side, above the tracks and below the turret, the side skirts cover a stretch of hull that's
08:52far thinner than the front.
08:53In Baghdad in August 2003, an M1A1 on patrol was hit by something that crippled it, and army officials were
09:02left puzzling over what.
09:04Reporting at the time noted the round struck just where the skirt meets the thin armor between the tracks and
09:10the turret deck.
09:11Now put the long 88 broadside to that same stretch, rated for close to 190 millimeters of angled steel at
09:201,000 meters.
09:21This is the first hit where penetration becomes a real possibility.
09:26And this is where the four men's fates start to split.
09:29If the shot gets through forward, the driver is the one in its path, and the small charge in its
09:35base was built to burst a moment after it entered.
09:39If it enters farther back, the fuel sits in the way.
09:42The Abrams keeps armored bulkheads between its fuel and its crew, plus an automatic fire suppression system.
09:50After 1991, the army's own ballistic researchers credited that system, along with the blowout panels, with keeping crews alive.
10:00Swing around to the back, and the picture gets simpler.
10:04The rear holds the engine, and its armor is far thinner than the front.
10:08An 88 there would almost certainly stop the Abrams for good.
10:12In Baghdad in 2003, by published accounts, an M1A1 was lost, when an RPG hit the rear, got into the
10:22fuel, and started a fire nobody could put out.
10:25The crew got out.
10:27The tank burned where it sat.
10:30That's a trade the designers made on purpose.
10:32Put the engine and fuel between the enemy and the crew, wall them off, and a hit from behind costs
10:39the army a tank, and sends four men home.
10:42A crew that walks away from a burning tank, can fight again.
10:46Tank crews in 1944, rarely got that bargain, which leaves the spot that should frighten these four men the most.
10:54Directly behind the turret crew, inside the bustle, sit those 34 main gun rounds.
11:01Every one is a cartridge packed with propellant.
11:04If an 88 punches through the back of the turret into that compartment, those rounds can cook off.
11:10In the tanks of the Second World War, burning ammunition was what turned a damaged tank into a gutted one,
11:17often with the crew still inside.
11:20Crews of that era learned to fear their own ammunition more than the shell coming at them.
11:26The Abrams was built around that fear.
11:28Its designers insisted the main gun rounds be stored away from the crew, behind armored bulkheads, with panels in the
11:36roof made to fail first.
11:38When the propellant goes, the pressure has one easy way out.
11:42The roof panels blow off, and the fire jets straight up into the sky, while the doors hold it back
11:49from the men.
11:50There are photographs from Iraq and Ukraine of Abrams with the bustle roaring like a blowtorch pointed upward, and crews
11:57who walked away from them.
11:59So the hit that killed whole crews in 1944 is the one the Abrams is most prepared for.
12:06In the best case, the four men would feel the heat through the doors, hear the roar above them, and
12:13climb out through the hatches while the back of their turret burned.
12:16There's one condition.
12:18The doors have to be shut, and the loader opens one every time he loads.
12:23He presses a knee switch, the armored door slides open over the ready rounds.
12:28He pulls one, and the door slides closed again.
12:32For those few seconds, nothing but air stands between three men and a rack of propellant.
12:38Good loaders keep that window very short.
12:41Whether the shell arrives inside it is luck.
12:44And after all of that, the man most likely to be hurt by an 88, might not be inside the
12:50armor at all.
12:52Tank commanders often ride with their head and shoulders out of the hatch, because no periscope matches their own eyes.
12:59A 1944 gun crew facing a tank it couldn't penetrate, would have known exactly what to do with a high
13:06explosive round.
13:07Burst it on or above the turret, where the people are.
13:11Armor that defeats the shell does nothing for the man standing above it.
13:16Put side by side, the hits tell a simple story.
13:19The front, where an 88 was most likely to land, shrugs off what was once the most feared tank gun
13:26of its war.
13:27The sides are a real gamble.
13:29The tracks and the rear cost the tank, but probably spare the men.
13:34And the ammunition, the thing that killed tank crews by the thousands in the 1940s, sits behind a door designed
13:41to turn the worst hit into one people can climb away from.
13:45None of the four gets through it alone.
13:48The loader keeps the door shut for everyone.
13:51The gunner and commander drag each other out.
13:54Someone traverses the turret to reach the driver.
13:57Here's the part worth sitting with.
13:59Almost every feature keeping these men alive exists, because designers in the 1970s had decades of burned out hulls to
14:07learn from.
14:08That includes the sloped glacis, the walled off fuel, and the blowout roof.
14:14The Abrams is safer, because earlier crews were not.
14:18So for the tankers watching, which seat would you rather be in when that 88 fires, and which hit worries
14:24you most?
14:25And for everyone else, a tank that walls its men off from their own ammunition, was paid for by crews
14:32who never had that door.
14:33Was the lesson worth what it cost to learn?