Skip to playerSkip to main content
  • 1 day ago
Over Anzio, Allied bombers filled the sky—but German troops had a different aircraft to fear: a tiny, unarmed Piper Cub. When Captain William McKay spotted a German column advancing toward the American lines, his map and radio helped direct 224 guns onto the road in minutes.

This military history story traces how American artillery observation planes evolved from a fragile experiment in North Africa into a vital part of the fighting at Anzio, Sicily, and Normandy. The Cub could spot targets, adjust artillery fire, and keep German forces cautious simply by remaining overhead. Discover why its greatest weapon was not carried onboard, and how one pilot’s view could unleash a storm of shells.

Category

📚
Learning
Transcript
00:00February 17, 1944. The Albano Road, a few miles north of the Anzio beachhead in Italy.
00:07Ten minutes past eleven in the morning. A German column is moving south out of Carrochetto.
00:13Tanks lead. Behind them walk about 2,500 men. They are heading into a hole their own army has
00:20spent the whole night and morning tearing open. In front of them, the center of the American 45th
00:25Infantry Division has been pushed back. One company of the 179th Infantry has been all but
00:32wiped out. For the men in that column, this looks like the moment the beachhead finally breaks.
00:38The sky above them has been busy since dawn. Before this day is over, Allied air forces will
00:44fly 731 sorties in direct support of the troops at Anzio. 288 of them are heavy bombers. Four-engine
00:53giants are unloading on targets up and down this same road. The column keeps moving. Then
00:59something small appears over the American side of the line. A high-wing, fabric-covered two-seater
01:04with a 65-horsepower engine. No bombs, no machine gun. It flies so slowly that a car on an open
01:12road
01:13could keep pace with it. In it sits Captain William McKay, a pilot flying for the 45th Division's
01:19artillery with a map and a radio. He circles. He looks down. He talks. 12 minutes later, the road
01:29under that column erupts. Not one battery. Not one battalion. 224 British and American guns from all
01:38across the beachhead fire on that one stretch of road. The official U.S. Army history uses a single
01:45word for what happened to the German force. It disintegrated. And the little plane does
01:51not leave. Over the next 50 minutes, McKay walks the guns onto four more targets, one after
01:57another, while the heavy bombers come and go above him. Hold on to that picture, because
02:03it is the riddle at the center of this story. On the same morning, the same German soldiers
02:09were living under hundreds of bombers. Yet, when you read the German records from that
02:13week, a strange target keeps turning up. Day after day, German air reports list a mission
02:20that sounds almost absurd next to all those bombers. The artillery spotters. An aircraft that never
02:27fired a shot was the one the German Army hunted, cursed, and learned to dread. Why? If the story
02:35of the American pilots and gunners at Anzio matters to you, like this video and subscribe
02:40to the channel. It helps more people find what the U.S. Army did there. To understand that
02:47morning, you need to know what the Germans believed they had going for them. Here is a
02:52number worth remembering, because it will come back. On the eve of this attack, the Germans
02:58had 452 artillery pieces ready to support it. The Americans and British inside the beachhead
03:05had 432. On paper, the Germans had more guns than the men they were trying to throw into
03:13the sea. They held the high ground. They could look down on the harbor and the beaches from
03:18the hills. They had picked the day and the place. And yet, something had already gone wrong
03:25for them 24 hours earlier. On the morning of February 16th, one of the regiments in the first wave was
03:32the
03:32Infantry Lehr Regiment. A demonstration unit rushed down from Germany, the kind of outfit that existed to show the
03:39rest of the Army how infantry was supposed to fight. It went forward against the 179th Infantry. American
03:583rd Division reported that its observation plane had just been shot down and asked for fighter protection. That was no
04:05accident. The official history records that the Germans made, in its words, a concerted effort to keep the highly respected
04:13Cub observation planes on the ground.
04:15German fighters were sent over the beachhead to strafe, and while they were at it, to chase down every little
04:21plane they could find.
04:23At 20 to 8 on the morning of the 17th, about 35 Fockewolves and Messerschmitts came in to bomb and
04:29strafe the front.
04:31Think about what that means. The Germans had only a limited number of fighters over Anzio. Hundreds of Allied bombers
04:38were in the air, and a share of those precious fighters was being spent hunting two-seat planes made of
04:44steel tubing and fabric.
04:46Something about this little machine had already taught the German Army a lesson, long before February. The question is what
04:53that lesson was, and why no amount of German effort could make it go away.
04:59Because the first time this plane went to war, 15 months earlier, it did not look like something anyone would
05:06fear. The first American artillery pilot to fly it into combat never made it to his assignment. He went down
05:13in flames on his very first flight. And the guns that brought him down were not German.
05:19November 9, 1942. The aircraft carrier USS Ranger, about 60 miles off the coast of French Morocco. The American landings
05:29in North Africa are one day old.
05:31On the flight deck sit three small planes the Navy has no idea what to do with. Army observation cubs.
05:39Their pilots found them in poor shape when they came aboard, and spent most of the crossing patching them up
05:44and wiring in radios so they could direct artillery.
05:48The carrier is making about 25 knots into a 35 knot headwind with submarines about. That much wind can lift
05:56a cub almost straight off the deck.
05:59Captain Ford Alcorn goes first. He later described the launch in one line. Some of the crew held the plane
06:06back while I gunned it. Then he is alone over the water, low, heading for Fadala.
06:13Now picture what the invasion fleet sees. Gunners keyed up after a day of combat, and a tiny shape putting
06:20along near the waves.
06:22Alcorn passes a destroyer at about 100 feet. Then almost the whole convoy opens fire on him, invasion markings and
06:29all.
06:30Years later, a Navy gunnery officer explained it to an Army colonel. His crew had checked the silhouette charts. No
06:37match.
06:38His assistant said it looked like a cub. And the officer asked,
06:43If you were 60 miles at sea and saw a cub putting by, would you believe it?
06:49Alcorn gets through. He reaches the coast, turns toward Fadala, and the shore opens up on him too.
06:56As he turns inland, troops of the American 2nd Armored Division hit the plane with machine gun fire.
07:02Then a burst catches his right leg and the engine. The cub begins to burn.
07:08He puts it down in a controlled crash, drags himself about 50 feet from the wreck, and watches it go
07:14up.
07:16He had been hit five times. The slugs doctors found in him were French.
07:22The other two cubs did no better. They turned north, away from the landing area, came down near a French
07:29fort, and their crews were briefly held prisoner.
07:31One of those pilots, Lieutenant John Schell, would be killed in Tunisia a few months later by a German 88.
07:39So here is the score for the first combat day of American Artillery Aviation.
07:44Three planes launched. Not one artillery mission flown.
07:48One plane burned. One pilot wounded. Two crews captured.
07:54Keep that score in mind next to the picture from Anzio.
07:58Fifteen months before Captain McKay broke a German attack from the air, this same machine looked like a joke.
08:05Too slow. Too fragile. Too strange for its own side to recognize.
08:11And nothing about the airplane changed between Fadala and Anzio.
08:15Same steel tubing. Same fabric. Same little engine.
08:20Something else changed. Tunisia is where you can watch it begin.
08:26Through that winter, the Army's handful of air observation pilots in North Africa barely got into the fight.
08:32American units went in piecemeal.
08:34Some artillery commanders had no idea what to do with their pilots,
08:38and there are accounts of air sections simply left behind in the desert without food.
08:44A few Americans flew with a British squadron just to learn the trade.
08:48Then the planners' own assumptions began to fall apart.
08:52Here is a detail that tells you more than any speech.
08:56When the program started, a pilot was expected to last over the front for about seven minutes per mission.
09:03Seven minutes.
09:05The thinking was that anything that slow and that low over a battlefield would be found and killed fast.
09:13In Tunisia, the pilots discovered they could stay up far longer.
09:19Partly because a cub could twist away close to the ground.
09:22Partly because friendly anti-aircraft guns covered them.
09:26And partly for a reason the Army's own aviation history states plainly.
09:31The enemy was afraid of the artillery that followed a spotting.
09:36Hold on to that phrase.
09:38The artillery that followed.
09:40It is the thread this whole story hangs on.
09:44March 23, 1943.
09:46El Gitar, Southern Tunisia.
09:49At dawn, the German 10th Panzer Division comes out against the American 1st Infantry Division.
09:56This is a veteran outfit and the Americans in its path belong to an army that had been badly beaten
10:01at Kasserine only a month before.
10:04Above the valley, the little planes of the 1st and 9th Division's artillery are already up.
10:10Their pilots see the German thrust forming.
10:13They talk.
10:14A barrage directed from the air helps break it.
10:18What came out of Tunisia was not a new airplane.
10:21It was a habit forming on both sides of the line.
10:25The Americans were learning to trust the man in the plane with their guns.
10:29And the Germans were learning to look up.
10:31By summer, in Sicily, the lesson had reached German headquarters.
10:36Major General John Lucas said intercepted German radio messages announced that the next day,
10:42the primary mission of their fighters would be against the American Cubs.
10:46The Cubs began flying in pairs.
10:48One pilot watching the sky while the other watched the ground.
10:52One report counted nine attacks by enemy fighters on observation planes during that campaign.
10:57Not one Cub was shot down.
11:01Think about that German order for a moment.
11:04The Luftwaffe over Sicily was outnumbered and losing aircraft every day.
11:08And it chose to give its fighters, for a day, a primary target that carried no bombs at all.
11:15No German commander makes that choice because of what the plane itself can do.
11:20He makes it because of what answers the plane.
11:23And by the time McKay was circling over the Albano Road,
11:27that answer could arrive faster than a German column could get off a road.
11:32How fast, and how, is something the Germans never fully understood.
11:37Go back to the Albano Road, ten minutes past eleven, and slow the clock down.
11:42Captain McKay is looking down at the column from a few thousand feet, maybe less.
11:46He does not need binoculars to count tanks.
11:49He has a map folded on his knee, and the map has a grid.
11:53He finds the road, finds the bend, reads off a set of numbers.
11:58Then he keys his radio.
12:00That radio is the first thing to notice.
12:03It is a small set, light enough for a sixty-five horsepower plane to carry,
12:07and it talks straight to the men who control the guns.
12:10Not to an air base.
12:12Not to a headquarters that will forward the request tomorrow.
12:15To a dugout, behind the American lines,
12:18where men sit around plotting boards with headphones on.
12:22What happens in that dugout is the part the Germans never saw.
12:26The men there do not care which gun is closest.
12:29They know where every battery in their sector sits,
12:32and they turn McKay's numbers into firing data for each one.
12:35Range. Direction. Elevation. Fuse.
12:39Then the request goes up the line to the CORE Fire Control Center.
12:43And the CORE does something no single battery can.
12:46It hands that one target to every gun that can reach it.
12:51American guns. British guns.
12:53Batteries miles apart that have never seen the Albano Road, and never will.
12:59Twelve minutes.
13:00In that time, 224 guns are laid on one stretch of road by men who cannot see it.
13:08One man can.
13:10Now picture the same moment from the road.
13:13The Germans know there is a plane overhead.
13:15They can hear it.
13:17What they cannot know is that the plane has already turned into 200 guns.
13:23There is no flash on the horizon. No warning.
13:26Nothing to tell them the next ten minutes are different from the last ten.
13:31And then the shells arrive. From every direction at once.
13:36That is the first layer of the answer. And it is a big one.
13:40The cub was never the weapon. It was the trigger.
13:43And it was wired to more firepower than any bomber in the sky could carry.
13:48Here is a second scene from that same beachhead that shows how far this went.
13:52The Army's own aviation history records that on one target at Anzio,
13:57a single aerial observer, Captain John Oswalt of the 1st Armored Division,
14:02adjusted what artillerymen call a time on target.
14:06More than 370 guns.
14:09And not only Army guns.
14:11Three cruisers offshore joined in.
14:13The American Brooklyn and the British Dido and Orion.
14:18Let me explain why time on target matters.
14:21Because it changes what the man on the ground lives through.
14:25Every gun fires at a slightly different moment, set by its distance from the target,
14:30so that every shell arrives at the same second.
14:33The guns furthest away fire first. The closest fire last.
14:38For the soldier underneath, there is no first shell to dive into a hole for.
14:44The first sound is the whole barrage landing.
14:47A bomber cannot do that.
14:50Look again at February 17th.
14:52288 heavy bomber sorties flew in support of the beachhead that day.
14:57They hit Campo Leone and targets up the Albano Road.
15:01And some of their bombs overshot and fell on the factory at Aprilia,
15:05a few hundred yards in front of the American lines.
15:08A heavy bomber dropped its load from high above on a point picked off a map hours earlier.
15:14It saw the target once, and then it was gone.
15:17The cub was there when the shells landed.
15:20If they fell short, the pilot moved them.
15:22If the Germans ran for a gully, he followed them into it.
15:26If a new column appeared ten minutes later, he started all over again.
15:31A bomber struck a target. A cub hunted.
15:35The Germans felt this in a way you can measure.
15:38Earlier, I asked you to remember that the Germans had 452 guns around the beachhead,
15:44and the Allies had 432.
15:47Here is what that near equality was worth in practice.
15:51General Eberhard von Mackensen, commanding the German 14th Army,
15:55reported afterward that at the height of the battle,
15:58for every shell his artillery fired, the Americans and British threw back 15 to 20.
16:04By the middle of February, the Allies inside the beachhead were firing about 20,000 rounds a day.
16:11Prisoners taken in that battle, the official history says,
16:14almost invariably talked about the same thing.
16:17The artillery fire.
16:19They called it terrific.
16:21They called it continuous.
16:23And Mackensen's own report, dated February 28th, put a number on it.
16:2875% of all German wounds came from shell fragments.
16:32Not bombs. Not bullets. Shells.
16:37How the Allies could fire 15 shells for every German one is a separate question,
16:42and we will come back to it, because it turns out to be the deepest part of the answer.
16:46For now, notice where the Germans themselves looked for the cause.
16:51They did not look at the guns.
16:53Guns can be counted, dug in, hidden, matched.
16:57They looked up.
16:58That is why German fighters were spending their time over Anzio chasing two-seat planes instead of bombers.
17:04They had worked it out.
17:06Somewhere above them was a man who could see, and every gun on the beachhead listened to him.
17:12Kill the man, and the guns go blind.
17:15And over Anzio, the Germans had a pilot who was very good at exactly that.
17:20By the morning Mackay went up, one Luftwaffe captain had already claimed eight artillery spotting planes over the beachhead in
17:27barely a month.
17:28His reports, intercepted and decoded by the Allies, still exist.
17:33So does the answer the Americans came up with, because the Cubs kept flying,
17:37and the German army's next request to get rid of them sounded more desperate than the last.
17:42February 13th, 1944
17:45A quarter to two in the afternoon, over the hills north of Anzio,
17:49a Messerschmitt drops out of the sky onto a small, slow plane, spotting for the guns on the beachhead.
17:56The pilot is Hauptmann Manfred Spenner, a German fighter captain with the fourth fighter wing.
18:02His target is hit, and makes a forced landing in a field.
18:06Spenner does not leave it there.
18:08He comes around for a second pass, and shoots the plane on the ground into flames.
18:14Spenner's battle report went out that afternoon, and here is the detail that makes it extraordinary.
18:19We can read it today because the Allies were reading it then.
18:23Messages like his were intercepted and decoded, and the German records from the Anzio fighting survive in that form, line
18:30by line.
18:31They give us something rare.
18:33Not what the Americans thought the Germans feared, but what the Germans actually spent their effort on.
18:40Spenner was not a man who happened to stumble on a spotter.
18:42The decoded reports list his claims against artillery spotting planes, American and British, over Anzio on the 13th, 18th, 20th,
18:54and 27th of January, then on the 6th, 8th, and 13th of February.
19:01A fighter captain, in a fighter wing that was badly outnumbered, had made a specialty of hunting aircraft that carried
19:09no weapons.
19:11Then came the German offensive.
19:13On February 16th, the day the attack opened, the German Air Command's daily report says plainly that fighters were used
19:21against artillery spotters over the beachhead.
19:24Another report, sent at 4 that afternoon, says the spotters had been attacked all day, with 4 claimed shot down
19:32so far.
19:33And on the American side, at 10 o'clock that morning, the 3rd Infantry Division radioed that its observation plane
19:40had been shot down and asked for fighter cover.
19:44So the Germans were not wrong about where the danger came from, and they were not lazy about it.
19:49They threw real pilots at the problem, on the most important days of the battle.
19:55Now look at what happened the next morning.
19:57At 20 to 8, on February 17th, German fighters hit the front again.
20:02By 10 past 11, Captain McKay was over the Albano Road, calling in 224 guns.
20:09And he stayed up for nearly an hour more, moving the fire from target to target.
20:14The official history sums up that day in a single, flat sentence.
20:19The enemy's efforts to keep down the Cub observation planes failed.
20:24Why did they fail?
20:26This is where it gets interesting.
20:28Because the answer is not that the Cubs were hard to kill.
20:31Spenner had just proved they could be killed.
20:35The answer is in how the Americans flew them, and in what a kill actually bought the Germans.
20:41Start with how they flew.
20:43Since Sicily, Cub pilots had learned to work in pairs.
20:47One man watching the ground, the other watching the sky.
20:50They stayed over their own lines, low, close to their own anti-aircraft guns,
20:56so that any fighter coming down after them flew straight into a wall of flak.
21:00And a fighter, diving at 300 miles an hour, on a plane doing 70, has only a second or two
21:07to aim before it overshoots.
21:09A Cub pilot who saw it coming could turn inside it, drop toward the treetops, and make the fighter start
21:15all over again, under the guns.
21:18The Germans paid for those passes.
21:21On the same day Spenner burned his spotter, one of his own wings Messerschmitts never came back.
21:27The report says it was probably brought down by anti-aircraft fire.
21:32Then there is the second reason, and this one matters more.
21:36Think about what Spenner actually destroyed on February 13th.
21:41One light plane.
21:43Possibly one pilot.
21:44But the eye was not the plane.
21:47The eye was a system.
21:49And a system can replace a part.
21:52A light plane cost a tiny fraction of a fighter.
21:55Within hours another one was up, and the Fire Direction Center was listening to a new voice, reading the same
22:01kind of map.
22:02The same week, German artillery shelled the beachhead airstrip at Natuno so hard that four Spitfires were destroyed as they
22:11took off, and the field had to be abandoned in daylight.
22:14A fighter needs a runway.
22:17A Cub needed a few hundred feet of field or road.
22:21You could not close its airfield, because it did not really have one.
22:26So the hunt continued, and it changed nothing.
22:30On February 18th and 19th, the German daily reports still list engagement of artillery spotters as one of the fighters'
22:38jobs.
22:40Claims against spotters appear again on the 28th and 29th.
22:44And then, on February 24th, a message went out from the German 29th Panzer Grenadier Division, stamped at 3 in
22:52the afternoon.
22:53Listen to how it reads.
22:56Request urgently the elimination of artillery spotter aircraft.
23:00And then the reason.
23:02On that single day, four of the division's guns had been put out of action by Allied artillery working with
23:08spotter aircraft.
23:10Read that again, because it is the turn in this story.
23:13A German division is not complaining that its infantry is being hit.
23:17It is complaining that its guns are being hit.
23:20The spotters had moved on from columns on the road.
23:23They were now hunting the German artillery itself.
23:27Think about what that does to a German gun crew.
23:30Every time you fire, your muzzle flash and smoke can be seen from above.
23:35If a little plane is overhead, firing is no longer just an attack.
23:39It is a signal.
23:41It says, here I am.
23:44So the German gunners came up with an answer of their own.
23:47One that no fighter could provide.
23:49It worked.
23:51It saved guns.
23:52And it saved lives.
23:53And an American infantry colonel in Normandy would later explain, in a single word,
23:59why that answer may have done the German army more damage than any shell the Cubs ever called down.
24:04June 1944, the Cotantin Peninsula in Normandy, a few days after Utah Beach.
24:12Colonel Russell Reeder commands the 12th Infantry Regiment of the 4th Infantry Division.
24:1742 years old, a West Pointer, a man who had spent years writing about how to fight, and now finds
24:24himself doing it in the hedgerows.
24:26Within a week of landing, he will be hit near Montebourg and lose his left leg.
24:32Before that happens, his regiment learned something about German artillery that Reeder wanted the whole army to know.
24:38His account went into an official War Department pamphlet called Combat Lessons, and it is worth hearing in his own
24:46words.
24:47When the division commander asked the regiments what they needed, Reeder said the answer was simple.
24:53Keep those artillery jeep planes in the air.
24:56Then he explained why.
24:59We would be taking a real pasting from their artillery until one of these planes would show up skittering across
25:05the sky.
25:06Immediately, the German artillery would stop firing. Immediately.
25:11Not after the plane called in fire. Not after a counter-battery duel. The moment it appeared.
25:17Reeder went on.
25:19One or two incautious German batteries kept firing, gave away their positions to the man overhead, and got what he
25:25called sudden death.
25:27After that, the others learned, as he put it, that discretion is the better part of valor.
25:32Even the German mortars, he wrote, would suspend fire rather than risk being spotted.
25:38Pause on that, because this is the moment the riddle starts to come apart.
25:42The German answer to the cub was silence.
25:46And silence worked.
25:48A battery that did not fire could not be found, and a battery that could not be found survived.
25:55Every German gun commander who held his fire while a cub was overhead was making a sensible decision.
26:01But add up those sensible decisions across a whole front.
26:04While the little plane circled, the German artillery was not shelling the 12th Infantry.
26:09It was not breaking up American attacks.
26:12It was not supporting German counter-attacks.
26:14For as long as one American pilot stayed in the air, a whole sector's worth of German guns took themselves
26:21out of the war without a single American shell being fired at them.
26:26The Americans noticed, and they learned to use it on purpose.
26:31The army's own aviation history describes an episode from the fighting in Italy.
26:36American troops moving up to the front had to pass through a bottleneck that German guns could see and were
26:42shelling.
26:43The solution was not a bombardment.
26:46Seven cubs were sent up.
26:48The German artillery stopped firing.
26:50The cubs stayed overhead, and the troops passed through without another round falling on them.
26:56Seven unarmed planes did what a counter-battery program might have taken hours to do.
27:03Not by destroying anything.
27:05By being there.
27:07A captured German officer in Italy gave the Americans the nickname his men used for these planes.
27:14They called them Hellraisers.
27:16And the name came, he said, from the duty NCO in a German barracks, the Unteroffizier vom Dienst.
27:23The man who walked through inspecting everything and raised Hell about whatever displeased him.
27:29Think about that choice of word.
27:32Not a killer.
27:33Not a monster.
27:34The man who is always watching.
27:37The one you cannot get away from.
27:39That is exactly how a German battalion commander described it, fighting against the Americans in the autumn of 1944.
27:47His report was captured and summarized in an American intelligence bulletin.
27:52Artillery directed by observation planes, he wrote, places fire on each of our movements.
27:58And in another passage,
28:01U.S. air observation detects every movement.
28:04Every movement.
28:06Not most.
28:07Every.
28:09Now we can begin to see why the bombers were different.
28:12Do not misunderstand this.
28:14Heavy bombers could do terrible things.
28:16On July 25, 1944, before the breakout at Saint-Lô, waves of them carpet bombed the German line.
28:23And the German armored division in their path was wrecked.
28:27But some of those bombs also fell short onto American troops.
28:31More than a hundred Americans were killed.
28:34Among them was Lieutenant General Leslie McNair,
28:37who had backed the idea of putting light planes in the hands of the artillery.
28:42From several miles up, a bomber crew could not tell one hedgerow from another.
28:47A man and a cub at a thousand feet could see a single gun.
28:51And a bomber raid ended.
28:53The planes came over, the ground shook, and then they were gone.
28:58A soldier who survived the raid could climb out and go back to his work.
29:03The cub did not end.
29:06When the program began, pilots had been expected to last about seven minutes over the front.
29:12Instead, one observer's records from Italy show an average mission of an hour and a quarter,
29:17and a longest flight of five hours, with four separate missions flown in it.
29:22On a clear day, there was always another plane, and another after that.
29:27So, from the German side, the bombers were an event you could survive.
29:31The cub was a condition you had to live under, from first light to dark.
29:37Under it, guns could not fire, columns could not move,
29:41and men could not walk upright across an open field.
29:45It did not just kill.
29:47It took away your freedom to act.
29:50Which raises an obvious question.
29:52If the little plane was so dangerous, and so slow, and so low,
29:57why not simply shoot it down from the ground?
30:00Every German infantryman had a rifle.
30:03Plenty had machine guns.
30:05The cub flew at about 70 miles an hour, often within easy range.
30:10Some Germans did try.
30:12What happened when they tried?
30:14And what happened when one American pilot decided to give the cub a weapon of its own,
30:19reveals the strangest part of this whole story.
30:22September 20, 1944.
30:25Lorraine, in eastern France, near the village of Aricourt.
30:29The 4th Armored Division is fighting off a German armored counterattack,
30:33and one of its artillery pilots has turned up over the battlefield
30:36with something no cub was ever designed to carry.
30:40Major Charles Carpenter, 32, was a history teacher from rural Illinois before the war.
30:46His cub is named Rosie the Rocketer.
30:50Lashed to its wing struts are six bazookas,
30:53three on each side, wired so he can fire them from the cockpit.
30:58That day, Carpenter dives on German armor again and again.
31:02He is credited with knocking out an armored car and four tanks.
31:07By the end of the war, the army will officially credit him with six tanks destroyed.
31:13American newspapers love him.
31:16Stars and Stripes, the Associated Press, and Popular Science all carry his story.
31:21They call him Bazooka Charlie.
31:23But buried in that coverage is a remark from Carpenter himself
31:26that matters more to our story than any tank he hit.
31:30After his fifth tank, he told Stars and Stripes what had changed.
31:34The Germans, he said, never used to bother cubs.
31:38Now, whenever he appeared, they fired at him with everything they had.
31:43Read that slowly.
31:45Never used to bother cubs.
31:48Think back to the question at the end of the last part.
31:51If the cub was slow, low, and unarmored,
31:54why didn't German soldiers just shoot it down with rifles and machine guns?
31:58Here is the surprising part of the answer.
32:00Very often, they didn't even try.
32:04It was not that they couldn't hit it.
32:06It was the arithmetic.
32:08Remember what Colonel Reeder saw in Normandy.
32:11The incautious German batteries that kept firing under a cub got, in his words, sudden death.
32:18The same rule applied to a machine gun crew.
32:21A burst of fire at a cub was a burst of muzzle flashes, seen by a man who could put
32:27200 guns on that spot within minutes.
32:29If you missed, you had told him exactly where you were.
32:33If you hit him, and he still made it home, you had told him too.
32:38And even if you brought him down, another plane would be up within the hour, looking for the same spot.
32:45So the German soldier on the ground made the same choice his artillery made.
32:49He kept his head down and let it pass.
32:53This is the deepest kind of fear there is.
32:56Not the fear of being attacked, but the fear of fighting back.
33:01That does not mean the cubs were safe.
33:03German fighter pilots, who were not sitting under American guns, kept hunting them across France.
33:10In the summer of 1944, Captain Ed Atkinson, a North Dakota farm boy flying for the 182nd Field Artillery Group,
33:18was spotting in eastern France when a group of Messerschmitts came across his cub.
33:23One turned in to attack.
33:26Atkinson dove under it.
33:27The German came around again and fired his 20mm cannon, and the rounds shot away the cub's rudder.
33:34Atkinson got the plane down hard beside a railroad embankment.
33:38He and his passenger ran and hid in a culvert under the tracks,
33:42while the fighters came back and strafed the wreck until it was destroyed.
33:46The two Americans walked out, caught a ride back to their unit on a hay wagon,
33:51and the battery had a pilot again by the next mission.
33:55Look at what that episode shows.
33:57A German fighter had to make several passes, burn fuel and time, and risk being caught by American fighters,
34:05to destroy a plane worth about $2,600.
34:08And it still did not kill the eye.
34:12The man walked home.
34:14Now go back to Carpenter.
34:16Something about his success deserves a second look.
34:20As long as the cub was unarmed, the German infantryman's safest move was to ignore it and hide.
34:26The moment it started diving on tanks, hiding stopped making sense.
34:31The plane was attacking you anyway, so you might as well shoot back.
34:36Carpenter himself saw the change in the German reaction.
34:39Bazooka Charlie was brave, and his kills were real.
34:43But the army as a whole drew the right lesson.
34:46His cub remained an exception.
34:48The thousands of other cubs went on carrying radios, not rockets.
34:53Every pound a cub carried was precious,
34:56and a pound of bazooka was a pound less for the radio, or the observer with the map,
35:01or the fuel to stay up another hour.
35:04This is the next layer of our answer, and it turns the question upside down.
35:09The cub was not feared in spite of being unarmed.
35:12It was feared because it was unarmed.
35:16Its weapon was never in the plane.
35:18Its weapon was what it could see,
35:20and what was waiting behind the American lines to act on what it saw.
35:25And that brings us to the question that unlocks the whole story.
35:28The Germans had their own light plane.
35:30Not a copy, and not an afterthought.
35:34By many measures, it was better than the cub.
35:36It could fly slower, take off shorter, land almost anywhere,
35:41and it had been in service since before the war.
35:44Generals flew in it.
35:46It rescued Mussolini from a mountaintop.
35:49So why is there almost no record of American soldiers afraid of the German version?
35:54Why did a German infantryman freeze when he heard a cub,
35:58while an American infantryman barely looked up when the German plane went over?
36:03The answer is not in either airplane.
36:05It is in a number we have already seen once,
36:08and a document the German army wrote about its own wounded.
36:11February 28th, 1944.
36:15The headquarters of the German 14th Army, in the hills above Anzio.
36:19The great offensive to throw the Allies into the sea has failed.
36:24General Eberhard von Mackensen sits down to explain to his superiors why.
36:29His report is not a speech.
36:31It is an accounting.
36:32And one line in it carries the answer to the question we have been chasing since the Albano road.
36:3875% of all German wounds, Mackensen reports, were caused by shell fragments.
36:45Now put that line next to the number I asked you to remember at the very beginning.
36:50452 German guns.
36:52432 Allied ones.
36:54The Germans had more artillery around that beachhead than the men inside it.
36:59And yet three out of every four German wounds came from Allied shells.
37:04And Mackensen himself admitted that at the peak, his gunners were outfired 15 or 20 to 1.
37:10So the difference was not the number of guns.
37:13It was two things the guns needed to matter.
37:16Shells to fire, and eyes to aim them.
37:18Five months later, in Normandy, Field Marshal Erwin Rommel wrote both of those things down in a single report.
37:26It is dated July 15, 1944, and it went up the chain toward Hitler.
37:31Rommel complained of the enemy's unrestricted command of the air over the battle area.
37:36And he wrote that German supply was now so difficult that economy was required, above all, in artillery and mortar
37:43ammunition.
37:44There it is, in the German army's own words.
37:48No sky, no shells.
37:51Now you can answer the question about the German plane.
37:54The Fieseler Storch was, in many ways, a better aircraft than the Cub.
37:58It could fly slower, land shorter, and carry more.
38:02On September 12, 1943, one of them lifted Mussolini off a mountaintop in the Gran Sasso.
38:08But put a Storch over the American lines in the summer of 1944, and think about what happens.
38:15First, it has to survive in a sky full of American and British fighters.
38:20Then, if it does, and if its observer finds a target,
38:24the guns he calls are guns that have been ordered to save their shells.
38:28The Storch was a better airplane with nothing behind it.
38:32The Cub was a weaker airplane with everything behind it.
38:36Here is what everything behind it looked like in practice from the summer of 1943 in Sicily.
38:43An American artillery officer named Major Edward Raymond told the story in the Field Artillery Journal.
38:50In a mountainous coastal sector, American units kept hearing enormous explosions
38:55coming from behind a high ridge the Germans held.
38:58Nobody could explain them.
39:00So an observation plane went up, and instead of crossing the ridge, the pilot flew out to sea,
39:06beyond the reach of German machine guns, and looked up the valley from the side.
39:11First, he found a German battery of 105mm howitzers, and two American battalions destroyed it.
39:18But the giant explosion still had no explanation.
39:21So he kept looking.
39:23At last, he worked it out.
39:26On the far side of the valley was a tunnel.
39:29Inside it, the Germans were hiding a huge railway gun.
39:32They would roll it out a short way, fire, and pull it back in to reload.
39:38What the Americans did next tells you everything.
39:41The observer did not call for a massive barrage on the tunnel.
39:45He carefully adjusted one gun from each of three battalions onto the tracks just in front of it.
39:52Then the plane flew away.
39:54And the American gunners waited.
39:57Lanyards in hand.
39:59Ten minutes.
40:01Twenty.
40:02Half an hour.
40:04Three entire battalions holding their fire for one target.
40:09Inside the tunnel, the Germans decided the shoot was over.
40:13They repaired the tracks, rolled the gun out, and fired another enormous round.
40:19That shot was the American signal.
40:21All three battalions opened at once.
40:24The railway gun was destroyed.
40:28Think about what that took.
40:29An army that could afford to keep three battalions idle for half an hour waiting for one gun.
40:35An army so sure of its ammunition and its sky that its observer could fly away and trust the guns
40:42to finish the job.
40:43That is not an airplane.
40:45That is a whole system sitting patiently behind one.
40:50And now the answer to the question in the title comes together.
40:54German soldiers feared the bombers too.
40:57But a bomber was an event.
40:59It came.
41:00It struck what it had been told to strike from high above.
41:03And it left.
41:04If you survived, it was over.
41:07The cub was a condition.
41:09The cub was a condition.
41:09It came at first light and stayed until dark.
41:13It saw a single gun, a single truck, a single man crossing a field.
41:18It never fired, so there was nothing to shoot back at except the plane itself.
41:23And shooting at it told it where you were.
41:25And the instant it spoke, every gun within range that the Americans could bring to bear, often hundreds of them,
41:33fired at the exact spot it named, with shells landing all at once and no warning.
41:38Above all, when a German soldier looked up at that little plane, he was looking at what was behind it.
41:45American factories that sent shells across an ocean faster than his own army could bring them up a road.
41:51Fighter squadrons that owned the sky over it.
41:54And a fire direction system that could turn one man's voice into a storm of steel in 12 minutes.
42:02The bombers showed the Germans American power.
42:05The cub showed them that the power was looking at them.
42:09Personally.
42:11All day.
42:13There is one last scene in this story, and it happened in the final weeks of the war, when the
42:18American cub and the German Storch finally met in the air.
42:23Neither plane was built to fight.
42:25And the outcome came down to two American lieutenants with pistols.
42:29April 11, 1945.
42:31Northern Germany, near the town of Dannenburg, not far from the Elbe River.
42:36The war in Europe has less than a month to run.
42:39Over the flat country ahead of the 5th Armored Division, a cub is flying reconnaissance.
42:43Its pilot is Lieutenant Merritt Duane Franzese, 23, a fruit farmer's son who enlisted three days after Pearl Harbor.
42:52Behind him sits his observer, Lieutenant William Martin of the 71st Armored Field Artillery Battalion.
42:58The plane is named Miss Me.
43:01This is Franzese's 142nd combat mission.
43:05Below them, they spot another small, high-winged plane.
43:09A German Fiesler Stork.
43:11For the whole war, these two machines had been doing the same job on opposite sides.
43:16Now they are alone in the same patch of sky.
43:19Neither carries a machine gun.
43:21Neither was built to fight.
43:22Franzese dives.
43:24He overtakes the Stork, and the two Americans do the only thing they can.
43:28They open fire with their Colt .45s.
43:31They empty their seven-round magazines, reload, and keep firing.
43:35The German pilot begins to circle.
43:38Franzese closes in to about 30 feet.
43:41Their bullets hit the windshield and a fuel tank.
43:44The Stork spins down and crashes into a field.
43:48Franzese lands right beside it.
43:50The two German crewmen climb out and run.
43:53The observer has been hit in the foot.
43:56Martin fires a warning shot, and the German pilot stops and puts up his hands.
44:01And then Franzese does something that tells you a great deal about the men in these little planes.
44:07He kneels down and bandages the wounded German's foot.
44:11About 15 minutes later, the two prisoners are handed over to an American tank crew.
44:17Years afterward, Franzese remembered them.
44:20I never found out their names, he said.
44:22They could have been important, for all I know.
44:24And then, more quietly.
44:26I think they thought we would shoot them.
44:30The fight near Dannenburg is often described as one of the last air-to-air victories of the war in
44:35Europe.
44:36Franzese was recommended for the Distinguished Flying Cross on April 24th.
44:40The medal did not reach him until March 13th, 1967, 22 years later.
44:48He married, went home to Washington State, and died in Chelan in 2004.
44:54The others went on with their lives, too.
44:57Ford Alcorn, the first American artillery pilot shot down in the war, carried French bullets in his leg for the
45:03rest of his life, and lived to see the little plane he flew off the Ranger become a branch of
45:08the Army.
45:09Russell Reader, who asked his division commander to keep those jeep planes in the air, lost his left leg in
45:15Normandy.
45:16He went back to West Point, spent decades there, wrote books for young readers about the Army, and died in
45:231998.
45:25Charles Carpenter, Bazooka Charlie, was diagnosed with Hodgkin's disease in 1945.
45:32Doctors gave him two years.
45:34He went back to Illinois and taught history at Urbana High School for two decades, until his death in 1966.
45:41His cub, Rosie the Rocketer, was found decades later in an Austrian aviation museum, restored, and is on display in
45:50the United States today.
45:53Now go back one last time to where this story began.
45:57The Albano Road.
45:59February 17th, 1944.
46:02Ten minutes past eleven in the morning.
46:05Two hundred and eighty-eight heavy bombers in the sky that day.
46:09And two thousand five hundred German soldiers, walking south toward a gap in the American line.
46:17Captain William McKay circles over them in a plane made of steel tubing and fabric.
46:23He has no bomb and no gun.
46:26He reads a map, and he speaks into a radio.
46:30Twelve minutes later, the column is gone.
46:33That was why German troops feared the little plane more than the bombers.
46:38A bomber could hurt them.
46:40The cub could see them.
46:42All day long.
46:43And everything the United States had built stood behind what it saw.
46:49And in the end, the plane that frightened them most was flown by young Americans, who never fired a shot
46:54at them from it.
46:55Except once, near the Elba, with a pistol.
46:58And that time, the pilot landed beside his enemy, and dressed his wound.
47:04Thank you for watching this one all the way to the end.
47:06If the story of these American pilots and the gunners who answered them meant something to you,
47:11please give the video a like.
47:13It genuinely helps the story reach people who have never heard it.
47:17Subscribe, and turn on the notification bell so you don't miss the next one.
47:21And tell me in the comments where you're watching from.
47:23If your father, grandfather, or uncle served in the Second World War,
47:27I would be honored if you wrote his name and his unit below.
47:31Maybe he flew a cub.
47:33Maybe he was on the guns that listened to one.
47:36Either way, his name belongs here.

Recommended