Skip to playerSkip to main content
  • 6 days ago
Louis Tate went into Frankston Hospital for asthma care, but a routine breakfast ended in tragedy after he suffered a severe allergic reaction. The 13-year-old had known allergies to raw eggs, nuts, and cow’s milk, and his mother says he had an anaphylaxis action plan and always carried an EpiPen. When he was given food at the hospital, he took one bite, felt tingling in his mouth, and quickly deteriorated.

This heartbreaking case later raised serious questions about hospital food handling, allergy communication, and patient safety. An inquest heard that Louis’s allergies had not been written on the kitchen whiteboard as they should have been, and the family waited years for answers about what happened. Coroner Phillip Byrne eventually found the boy died after an allergic reaction and noted problems with the hospital’s handling of his breakfast.

A powerful true story of hospital negligence, anaphylaxis, and a family’s search for the truth, this account examines how a safe place can fail to protect a vulnerable patient. It is a sobering medical tragedy and a reminder of why allergy awareness matters in every care setting.

Created for listeners searching for true story narration, hospital tragedy stories, anaphylaxis cases, medical negligence stories, and real-life family loss stories. Ideal for documentary-style storytelling, serious news commentary, and anyone interested in patient safety, allergy awareness, and heartbreaking true events.
Transcript
00:09the
00:09The hospital is where people are meant to be safest their doctors provide them with the care and medication that
00:15they need to get better
00:16But Lewis Tate didn't get the healing. He needed instead. He was served a deadly breakfast
00:23Lewis did checked into Frankston Hospital in Victoria Australia in
00:272015 because he felt sick from asthma the 13 year old and also suffered allergies to raw eggs
00:33Nuts and cow's milk, but his health concerns were well managed according to his mother Gabriel Catan
00:40Although Lewis was only a teenager. He had an anaphylaxis action plan. He always has an EpiPen
00:46Gabriel told ABC News he knew to ask hospital staffers for a safe breakfast for him to eat wheat cereal
00:53and soy milk
00:54With Lewis's mature handling of his medical needs Gabrielle likely had no problem leaving her son overnight in the hospital
01:00She departed at 1 o'clock in the morning and called to check in a few hours later around the
01:06time that he'd be eating his breakfast
01:08That was when Lewis's mother knew that something had gone terribly wrong
01:11The nurse on the other end of the line said he had a good night
01:15But he just came over to me to tell me he has a slight tingling sensation in his mouth
01:19Catan recalled with that his mother knew exactly what was happening. He was having an allergic reaction. That was quite
01:25clear
01:26Gabrielle said Lewis had only eaten a single bite of his breakfast when he felt the telltale signs and
01:32That one bite would prove to be fatal from the moment Lewis's lips began tingling the 13 year old's condition
01:39got worse
01:40Extremely quickly he died in the hospital leaving his family with nothing but questions
01:46Lewis's father Simon said we continue to struggle every day with the emptiness loss and circumstances surrounding his death
01:54But the family had a suspicion that their son's breakfast was to blame for his quick unexpected passing
02:00We strongly believe that Lewis's death should never have happened
02:04He was in the hospital at a place where he should have been safe
02:07Yet despite us providing clear and concise communications about his food. He died his father added
02:14The 13 year old's family would have to wait more than two years after their son's death to find out
02:19what had actually happened to him
02:21During the inquest they learned some upsetting details about the hospital's handling of Lewis's allergies
02:27In December of 2017 the nurse in charge of Frankston hospital's children's ward Helen Hutchins
02:33Admitted that Lewis's allergies hadn't been written on the kitchen whiteboard as they should have been
02:38She called it a failure of the system according to ABC news
02:43But coroner Philip Byrne eventually found that there was more to blame for Lewis's death than a bad breakfast in
02:49February 2018 he revealed that the 13 year old had died from a disorder called malignant hypothermia
02:56Which was an incredibly rare disorder?
02:59Malignant hypothermia occurs when a patient has an extreme reaction to the medications administered during anesthesia
03:06Symptoms of the condition include a rapid heart rate high temperature and muscle stiffness
03:11Frankston hospital staff had indeed given Lewin an anesthetic for a very specific reason
03:16He had gone into anaphylaxis after eating his breakfast according to the coroner
03:21This meant that the boy's family suspicions about his case of death were partly correct
03:27Byrne also performed further research to figure out what exactly the hospital had given Lewis to cause the allergic reaction
03:34But he believed that forensic experts did not receive the right carton of milk from the hospital
03:39Preventing them from identifying the allergen present
03:42Byrne said I'm somewhat frustrated
03:45Whether it was mistakenly cow's milk in the glass or some other contamination due to dairy product
03:50Regrettably I am unable to determine
03:53Still the family felt vindicated by the coroner's findings
03:57Ultimately, we know that if he hadn't had breakfast he would have been back home with us, and we wouldn't
04:02be here
04:03Simon the boy's father said after hearing the results of the inquest
04:07He and gabrielle did have one problem with the coroner's findings though
04:12Although burn had indeed pointed out the hospital's poor food handling procedures
04:16He did not make any recommendations for improvements in the area
04:20Lewis's parents wished he had but the coroner said he didn't need to
04:25That was because in the wake of Lewis's death the hospital had revamped its food handling guidelines
04:30The coroner believed that they were now thorough and appropriate
04:33The hospital had begun putting patients allergies into a computer system
04:37So that they wouldn't be absent from the kitchen whiteboard as Lewis's had been and
04:42Although Lewis's parents finally had the results they knew to be true all along
04:46They still plan to do more in the wake of their son's untimely death and after hearing the coroner's report
04:52They said they plan to file a civil suit against Frankston Hospital

Recommended