- 3 days ago
German soldiers disguised as American GIs were exposed not by a master spy, but by the way real Americans behaved under pressure. In the Battle of the Bulge, Operation Greif sent men in American uniforms, jeeps, and papers behind the lines, yet checkpoints, roadblocks, and quick questions kept breaking the disguise within minutes or hours.
This military history story follows Otto Skorzeny’s plan, the rushed training on American ranks and slang, and the hidden weakness in the whole operation: the Germans could copy the uniform, but not the habits of an American army made up of many accents, backgrounds, and split-second decisions. It also shows how ordinary MPs and sentries, plus counterintelligence teams, uncovered the pattern and stopped the deception.
A gripping World War II documentary-style narration for listeners who enjoy WW2 stories, Battle of the Bulge history, military deception, espionage, and frontline analysis. It is ideal for history fans, narrated war stories, and anyone searching for Operation Greif, Otto Skorzeny, American GIs, and WWII military history.
SEO: WW2 stories, military history, Battle of the Bulge, Operation Greif, Otto Skorzeny, WWII deception, American GIs, counterintelligence, narrated history, war stories, and documentary-style historical narration.
This military history story follows Otto Skorzeny’s plan, the rushed training on American ranks and slang, and the hidden weakness in the whole operation: the Germans could copy the uniform, but not the habits of an American army made up of many accents, backgrounds, and split-second decisions. It also shows how ordinary MPs and sentries, plus counterintelligence teams, uncovered the pattern and stopped the deception.
A gripping World War II documentary-style narration for listeners who enjoy WW2 stories, Battle of the Bulge history, military deception, espionage, and frontline analysis. It is ideal for history fans, narrated war stories, and anyone searching for Operation Greif, Otto Skorzeny, American GIs, and WWII military history.
SEO: WW2 stories, military history, Battle of the Bulge, Operation Greif, Otto Skorzeny, WWII deception, American GIs, counterintelligence, narrated history, war stories, and documentary-style historical narration.
Category
📚
LearningTranscript
00:00On the 18th of December, 1944, a jeep came up the road toward the bridge over the Amblev River,
00:06at the edge of a Belgian town called Iveit.
00:09The cold had teeth in it.
00:11An American sentry stepped into the road and put his hand up, and the jeep stopped.
00:17Everything about it was right.
00:19Olive drab paint, the white star, bumper markings.
00:24Three men in American uniform, American helmets, American field jackets,
00:29sitting the way tired men sit after a long day of driving.
00:33They spoke English.
00:35When the sentry asked his first question, the answer came back without a pause.
00:40Then he asked for the password.
00:42That was the whole test.
00:44One word, changed on a schedule, passed down through orderly rooms to every man standing on every road in that
00:51sector.
00:52And from the jeep?
00:55Nothing.
00:56Not a wrong word.
00:58Nothing at all.
01:00Within the hour, the three of them stood with their hands raised while military police went through the vehicle.
01:05Under the American field jackets, they were wearing German field gray.
01:09In their pockets were German paybooks.
01:12In the jeep were two Sten guns, which are British weapons,
01:16and about $900 in American currency and a thousand pounds in British notes.
01:21A strange amount of money for three enlisted men on a Belgian road in winter.
01:27Their papers gave their names as Charles W. Lawrence, Clarence Vandervoort, and George Senzenbach.
01:33Their names were Gunther Billing, 21 years old, Manfred Pernas, 23, Wilhelm Schmidt, 24.
01:43They had crossed into the American lines near Stumont.
01:46When that sentry raised his hand, by their own account under interrogation, they had been inside the American rear area
01:53for roughly 30 minutes.
01:55I want you to hold on to that number, because it is going to come back.
02:0030 minutes.
02:00And these were not ordinary soldiers picked at random.
02:04They had been selected out of roughly 2,000 volunteers.
02:07They had been screened by examination, sent to a special camp,
02:11trained for weeks in American organization, American rank badges, American drill.
02:17The men who sent them had been planning this since October,
02:20with the full authority of the German high command behind them.
02:24And they had chosen these three because they could speak English.
02:28The disguise was excellent.
02:29It lasted half an hour.
02:31And that is the question underneath this entire story.
02:35Germany could copy the uniform.
02:38The jeep, the paperwork, the insignia, the helmet, the boots, the vocabulary.
02:43All of it could be copied.
02:45And all of it was.
02:47What Germany could not copy was the American inside the uniform.
02:52Not for a day.
02:53In most cases, not for an hour.
02:57Why not?
02:59The answer you have probably heard is that somebody asked them who Mickey Mouse's girlfriend was.
03:04That is true, and we will get to it.
03:06And it is nowhere near the real answer.
03:09The real answer says something about the United States Army in 1944 that the Germans never worked out.
03:15Because if they had, they would not have tried this at all.
03:20If this is the kind of history you want more of, a like and a subscribe genuinely help it reach
03:25more people who care about what the American soldier did in the Ardennes.
03:30Now let me take you back eight weeks, to the room where this started.
03:34On the 22nd of October 1944, an Austrian SS officer named Otto Skorzeny was called to Hitler's headquarters at Rostenberg
03:43in East Prussia.
03:45You know the name.
03:46He was the man who had taken Mussolini off a mountain the year before, and it had made him famous
03:51in a way very few soldiers ever become famous.
03:55Hitler told him about the offensive.
03:57Everything west, through the Ardennes, in winter, to the Meuse, and then on to Antwerp.
04:03And Skorzeny was handed a piece of it that nobody had tried at this scale.
04:07He would raise a brigade dressed as Americans, driving American vehicles, moving ahead of the Panzers to seize the Meuse
04:13bridges before they could be blown.
04:16Alongside it, smaller teams, four men to a jeep, would go deeper, cutting telephone lines, turning road signs, carrying false
04:25orders into the American rear.
04:27The whole thing rested on one resource.
04:30Not tanks, not fuel, although the fuel would matter later.
04:33It rested on Germans, who could pass as Americans.
04:39Skorzeny went looking for them.
04:41What he found, when the volunteers were finally sorted and tested, was this.
04:46Ten men spoke English perfectly and knew American idiom.
04:50Thirty or forty more spoke it well, but did not know any slang.
04:54Another 120 to 150 spoke it moderately.
04:58And the rest, the overwhelming majority of a brigade of roughly 2,000 men, spoke almost none at all.
05:07Ten men.
05:08In an army that still had millions under arms, in a country of 80 million people, the search produced ten
05:16men who could open their mouths in an American uniform and be believed.
05:21Hold that thought, because it is the first crack in the whole enterprise, and it never once closed.
05:28But the deepest damage to Operation Greif was not done by any American.
05:33It was done six weeks before the first jeep crossed the line, by a single sheet of paper sent out
05:39from the German High Command to every headquarters on the Western Front.
05:43It was signed by a field marshal, and by the time it had finished circulating, the Americans had it.
05:49The paper went out on the 25th of October, 1944.
05:54It came from the German High Command, and it was circulated to every headquarters on the Western Front.
05:59It asked commanders to find and release soldiers with a knowledge of the English language, and, the order specified, of
06:07the American dialect.
06:09Any branch.
06:10Any rank.
06:12Volunteers to report for special duty.
06:15Stop and look at what that piece of paper is admitting.
06:18The German army, three years into a war with the United States, did not know where its American speakers were.
06:25However, it had to ask, in writing, across an entire front.
06:31In order to find men who could imitate Americans, it had to announce to several hundred headquarters that it was
06:37looking for men who could imitate Americans.
06:40About 2,000 men answered.
06:43Roughly 500 came out of the Waffen SS, around 800 from the Luftwaffe, and the rest from the Army and
06:50the Navy.
06:51That last group matters more than it looks.
06:53If you wanted a German in 1944 who had actually stood in an American street, heard American money counted out,
07:01heard how a man from Brooklyn says a sentence, and how a man from Alabama says the same sentence, you
07:07looked for a sailor.
07:08Waiters, merchant seamen, students who had spent a year abroad before the borders closed.
07:14Their English did not come from the Army.
07:16It came from a life the war had ended.
07:18They were screened at an SS camp at Friedenthal, near Oranienburg, north of Berlin.
07:24A language examination, and then the sorting.
07:27An officer candidate from the Naval Signal Service named Gunther Billing came through it.
07:32So did a 24-year-old from a Luftwaffe Signals Regiment named Wilhelm Schmidt, who volunteered and passed.
07:40You have already met both of them.
07:41They are the men standing in the cold at Eivail with their hands up.
07:45And when the sorting was finished, the result was the number I gave you a moment ago.
07:50Ten men who could hold a conversation as an American holds it, with the idiom and the slang intact.
07:56Ten, out of 2,000 who had raised their hands, out of a field army of millions.
08:02Now let me put a second number beside it, because this is where the story stops being about a commando
08:07raid and becomes something larger.
08:10In the Blue Ridge Hills of Maryland, there was a camp called Camp Ritchie.
08:14Close to 20,000 men passed through it during the war.
08:18Around 40% of them were foreign-born, and roughly 2,000 of those were refugees from Nazi Germany and
08:24Austria.
08:25The army called them military intelligence specialists.
08:29History calls them the Ritchie Boys.
08:33One of them had been born Gunther Störn in Hildesheim in 1922.
08:38He got out at 15, alone.
08:41The rest of his family did not get out, and they were murdered.
08:44In 1943, the United States Army drafted him.
08:48And before he sailed, he changed his first name from Gunther to Guy,
08:52a precaution in case he was ever taken prisoner by the country he had been born in.
08:57He landed in Normandy two days after D-Day.
09:00He spent the rest of the war sitting across from captured German soldiers,
09:05questioning them in their own language, in their own accent, with their own idiom,
09:09hearing exactly what a man was doing when he paused before answering.
09:14By the end of the war, American intelligence officers estimated that roughly 60% of the credible combat intelligence gathered
09:21in Europe
09:22came from teams trained at that one camp in Maryland.
09:26Hold the two numbers together.
09:29The United States Army could place native German speakers, born there, raised there,
09:35fluent in the slang of a particular German city, into division after division by the thousand.
09:41The German army searched an entire front and produced 10 men who could pass in the other direction.
09:48That is not a gap in language teaching.
09:50That is a difference in what the two countries were made of.
09:54America was a place you could arrive at.
09:57A boy from Hildesheim could become an American soldier
10:00and be handed a carbine and a set of questions to ask his own countrymen.
10:05There was no road running the other way.
10:08Nobody from Ohio was going to become a German.
10:12And that is the first real answer to our question, though it is only the shallowest layer of it.
10:18The men of Operation Greif were not trying to imitate a nationality with a fixed sound.
10:24There wasn't one.
10:26In an American rifle company in 1944, you could hear a Boston accent, a Texas drawl, Polish, Yiddish, Spanish,
10:35and a man from Wisconsin whose parents spoke German at the dinner table.
10:39An American sentry was not standing in the road listening for a foreign accent.
10:45A foreign accent was normal.
10:47He was listening for something else.
10:50And that something else is what this whole story is built on.
10:56There is one more thing that October order did.
10:59It went to so many headquarters, and it was phrased so plainly that it did not stay inside the German
11:05army.
11:06Word of it reached Allied intelligence.
11:10Before a single jeep crossed the line, somebody on the American side already knew that the Germans were assembling English
11:17speakers for something.
11:19It got worse for the Germans on the first day.
11:22On the 16th of December, within hours of the opening barrage, American troops near Heckhuscheid took German papers off the
11:30battlefield that described the deception plan itself.
11:34Not a rumor.
11:36Not a rumor.
11:36Documents.
11:38Skorzeny knew none of that.
11:40What he knew was that he had six weeks to turn schoolroom English into American English, and he went looking
11:45for the only place in Germany where the real article could be found in quantity.
11:50He sent his men into prisoner of war camps, Kustrin and Limburg, to live near captured G1s and listen.
11:57Three weeks of it.
11:59It worked better than you would think.
12:01And what those men carried out of those camps is the second reason they were shot.
12:05By the middle of November 1944, they were at Grafenwöhr, an army training ground in eastern Bavaria.
12:12Then, Wilsack, a few miles away, into the first week of December.
12:17The camp was closed, and the men inside it were not told what they had volunteered for.
12:22They were simply taught.
12:25The syllabus was not English.
12:27That is the first thing worth understanding.
12:29The syllabus was America.
12:31American unit organization.
12:33How a company relates to a battalion.
12:36What a regimental headquarters actually does.
12:39Who reports to whom.
12:41American rank insignia.
12:43Drilled until a man could read the difference between a staff sergeant and a technical sergeant across a road in
12:48bad light.
12:50American drill.
12:52American vehicle markings.
12:54Demolition for some.
12:55Radio procedure for others.
12:57Wire cutting for others.
12:59They were divided into three working groups.
13:02The demolition teams.
13:03The teams whose job was to kill communications.
13:06And the radio teams.
13:07Who would report American positions back to the advancing columns.
13:11And two hours a day, at minimum, on the language.
13:15They were shown American films.
13:17American newsreels.
13:19They sat in the dark in Bavaria and listened to Hollywood actors.
13:23Trying to catch the rhythm of it.
13:25The shape of a sentence.
13:27The words that never appear in a textbook.
13:30It was not enough.
13:31And Skorzeny knew it was not enough.
13:34So he did the one thing that could plausibly fix it.
13:37He sent his people to the only source of genuine American English inside the borders of the Reich.
13:43Prisoner of War Camps.
13:47Kystrin on the border.
13:49The 24-year-old from the Luftwaffe Signals Regiment.
13:55The man who will be standing in the cold at Eivail within the month.
13:59Spent three weeks in those camps refreshing his English.
14:03He told his American interrogators that himself, afterwards.
14:07It is in the report.
14:09Think about who was on the other side of that conversation.
14:12American prisoners taken in Normandy.
14:15In Lorraine.
14:15In the Hürtgen Forest.
14:17Men in their third or fourth month behind wire.
14:20Underfed.
14:21Cold.
14:21In a German camp in November.
14:25And moving among them.
14:26Men in German uniform who wanted to talk.
14:30Who wanted to hear how they said things.
14:34Here is the trap.
14:35And it is the kind of trap you can only see from the outside.
14:40The English of a prisoner is not the English of a soldier.
14:44A man in a camp talking to the people who hold him is careful.
14:49He is polite.
14:50Or he is silent.
14:52He measures what he says.
14:54Because those men control his food.
14:56And his mail.
14:57And his life.
14:59He does not talk to them the way he talks to the other three men in his hole.
15:03At two in the morning.
15:05And it is exactly that second kind of talk.
15:08Fast.
15:09Profane.
15:10Half finished.
15:11Stuffed with references to a country the listener has never seen.
15:15That an infiltrator needed.
15:17And could not get.
15:19There was a second problem.
15:21Quieter.
15:22And worse.
15:24The English taught in German schools was British English.
15:28That is where nearly all of them started.
15:30And six weeks does not scrub it out.
15:32The stories that came out of that December are small.
15:35And they are lethal.
15:37A German in an American uniform pulls up and asks for petrol.
15:41Not gas.
15:43Petrol.
15:44One word.
15:45And the man holding the can has already heard it.
15:48Another, at a mess line, reaches for the American toast and produces the words,
15:53Up your bottom.
15:55Another passes a GI heading for the latrine and offers him a cheerful British encouragement.
16:01Keep your pecker up.
16:02Which in the United States Army in 1944 means something so different that the conversation
16:08ends right there.
16:10Now notice what kind of mistakes those are.
16:13Because it matters for everything that follows.
16:16Not one of them is an accent mistake.
16:19Accent can be drilled in six weeks.
16:21And plenty of these men had good accents.
16:23Every one of those errors is a man reaching for a phrase he had memorized as a fixed block
16:29and pulling out the wrong block.
16:31He was not speaking American.
16:33He was reciting it.
16:35And the difference between speaking a language and reciting it only shows up when somebody asks
16:40you something you did not prepare for.
16:43Which is precisely what a sentry does.
16:46And there was nobody in Bavaria who could have caught those errors.
16:50That is the part that seems almost unfair to them.
16:54In a sealed camp in eastern Germany, the only people alive who could tell a man that Americans
17:00do not say petrol were Americans.
17:03And the only Americans available were prisoners of the men doing the asking.
17:08Nobody in that camp had any way to know whether what they were hearing was true or complete
17:14or two years out of date.
17:17Now look at what the syllabus did not contain.
17:20There was no instruction in how an American private speaks to a captain.
17:25Nothing about who answers first when a vehicle is stopped at a roadblock.
17:30Nothing about how many men ride in a jeep.
17:33The training covered everything that could be written down.
17:36And every item on that list was an item you could put in a manual.
17:40The thing that actually caught them was not in any manual, in any army, because no army
17:45had ever thought to write it down.
17:48On the 14th of December, the jeep teams moved out toward the front, toward Hallschlag and
17:53Stadtkiel.
17:5529 jeeps, four men in each.
17:58Skorzeny had asked for 100 jeeps.
18:00One more thing happened in that sealed camp, and it had nothing to do with the training.
18:05Men with no information and far too much time began trading a rumor about where they were
18:11really going.
18:12It was in no order.
18:14No such mission existed.
18:16But one of the men who heard it was Wilhelm Schmidt.
18:19And within a week, sitting in front of American interrogators with a firing squad in his future,
18:24he repeated it.
18:27What he said that day put the supreme commander of the Allied Expeditionary Force under guard
18:32inside his own headquarters at Christmas.
18:35On the 14th of December, 1944, Panzer Brigade 150 assembled in the woods near Bad Münstereifel,
18:43west of Bonn, and waited for the offensive to open.
18:47This was the main body, the part of the plan that was supposed to run for the Meuse in daylight
18:52in American vehicles ahead of the entire German attack.
18:56So let me show you what it actually had.
18:59Skorzeny had asked for 15 American tanks.
19:02He received two, and both were in poor condition.
19:05What he got instead were five Panthers and six armored cars of his own army, cut about with
19:11sheet metal and painted olive drab, to be passed off at a distance as American tank destroyers.
19:17He had asked for 100 Jeeps, 40 motorcycles, 120 trucks.
19:22He received about 30 Jeeps, 15 trucks, and four scout cars.
19:28A Panther weighs 45 tons.
19:31It does not look like an American tank destroyer from any angle a man would care about.
19:35And every German in that brigade knew it.
19:38The disguise was expected to hold at several hundred meters, in bad light, for as long as
19:42it took to get past.
19:44That was the margin they were working with.
19:46And because those vehicles were going to be moving among German troops who would cheerfully
19:50fire on an American tank destroyer, there had to be recognition signals.
19:55A small yellow triangle at the rear of the vehicle.
19:58Tank guns traverse to the nine o'clock position.
20:01Colored scarves, pink or blue.
20:04Helmets taken off.
20:06Blue or red torch flashes at night.
20:09Sit with that for a moment, because it is the structural flaw in the whole idea, and
20:14it never had a solution.
20:16A disguise that has to be recognizable to your own side is not a disguise.
20:22It is a costume with a label sewn into it.
20:25Every marking that kept a German from being shot by Germans was a marking an American could
20:30see.
20:31And it ran all the way down to the individual man.
20:35The men of the jeep teams carried, underneath the American field jacket, a German armband.
20:40If they ran into their own advancing troops, they opened the jacket and lived.
20:45If they were searched by Americans, that same piece of cloth was a death sentence.
20:49There was no third option.
20:52There is also a reason the German field gray was under the jacket.
20:56And it was not carelessness.
20:58Skorzeny had put the legal question to German experts.
21:01And the answer he got was that wearing an enemy uniform to deceive was a permissible ruse
21:06of war.
21:07But fighting in one was not.
21:10So his men were instructed to strip the American uniform off before they fought.
21:15That is why they wore their own underneath.
21:18And that is why a roadside search in Belgium, in December, produced men dressed in two armies
21:23at once.
21:24The American uniforms themselves came out of prisoner of war camps, along with Red Cross
21:29parcels.
21:30Three years later, in a courtroom at Dachau, that fact was read out as a formal charge against
21:36Skorzeny and nine of his officers.
21:39And the kit was incomplete.
21:40This is where the American searches began to bite.
21:44Counterintelligence men and military police going over a stopped vehicle were looking at
21:48very small things.
21:50A man with no field jacket where a field jacket belonged.
21:54No leggings.
21:55A belt that was not a regulation belt.
21:58The American uniform in 1944 was a system.
22:01And the system had a look.
22:03And a man wearing 80% of it looks exactly like a man wearing 80% of it.
22:08So the inventories taken off these teams read the way they read.
22:12German paybooks.
22:14And under the American wool, field gray.
22:29Now, I have to be honest with you, because it would be easy to tell this as a farce, and
22:33it was not a farce.
22:35With all of that stacked against them, the wrong weapons, the wrong underwear, the borrowed
22:40uniforms, the schoolroom English, the jeep teams got into the American rear, and they
22:46worked.
22:47On the 17th of December, at the Montriggi Junction, a team turned the road signs.
22:53The American 16th Infantry Regiment, moving up, went toward Malmedy instead of Waymes.
22:59Hours gone, at a moment when hours were the only currency anybody had.
23:05Near Poteau, a team told American troops their road had been cut by Germans and sent them
23:11around another way.
23:12And a regiment lost its afternoon.
23:15A team cut the telephone cable running between 1st Army Headquarters at Spa and 12th Army
23:20Group at Namur, the line between Courtney Hodges and Omar Bradley.
23:25And it stayed cut for hours.
23:28Another team put an ammunition dump into the air.
23:31Forty-odd men.
23:33That is roughly what was loose in the American rear at any one time.
23:37And they did that.
23:39So the props did not decide this.
23:42The sheet metal, and the missing leggings, and the British submachine guns all mattered
23:46at the moment of search.
23:48But something has to stop the jeep first.
23:51A vehicle that is never stopped is never searched.
23:54Somebody has to look at four men, in American uniform, speaking English, in an American jeep,
24:00on an American-held road, and decide to put his hand up.
24:04By the 19th of December, military policemen of the 769th MP Battalion had stopped another
24:11team at a bridge over the Meuse, a lieutenant named Gunther Schultz and three of his men,
24:16and taken them without a shot.
24:19The teams were coming apart now.
24:21And they were coming apart in a pattern.
24:24American counterintelligence officers, laying one capture against the next, found it.
24:29It had nothing to do with anybody's English.
24:31It had to do with which man was sitting behind the wheel.
24:34By the 18th and 19th of December, the American counterintelligence detachments working the
24:401st Army rear had something better than rumor.
24:43They had captured teams to lay side by side.
24:46The 418th detachment, under a second lieutenant named Kenneth Hardin.
24:51The 99th, under Lieutenant Howard Stevens.
24:55Men whose entire job that week was to compare one carload of prisoners against the next and
25:01find what they had in common.
25:02What they found was this.
25:05On team after team, the man driving the jeep was the worst English speaker in the vehicle.
25:12Read that again, because it is the hinge of the whole story.
25:17Not the worst shot.
25:19Not the youngest.
25:20The worst linguist.
25:22The man least able to survive a conversation.
25:26Was the man sitting exactly where every conversation was going to start.
25:31In the first team, the one taken at Ewaile, the driver was Manfred Pernas, 23 years old,
25:38from Golno in Pomerania, out of the 12th Parachute Regiment, assigned driver duties.
25:44And he was, by the American assessment of those three men, the poorest linguist in the jeep.
25:51Why would a unit that had spent six weeks preparing for precisely this moment make precisely this mistake?
25:59Because they did not think it was a mistake.
26:02They were not thinking about it at all.
26:05And that is the point.
26:07In the German army, the driver was a function.
26:10Der Fahre.
26:12He operated the vehicle for the men it belonged to.
26:15Rank sat in the other seats, gave the directions, and did the talking with anyone who needed to be talked
26:21to.
26:22So when four Germans got into an American jeep,
26:25they arranged themselves the way Germans arrange themselves in a vehicle.
26:38Now the American jeep.
26:41In the United States Army, the driver was the man who held the trip ticket,
26:45the paperwork authorizing that vehicle to be on that road, filled out, signed, carrying its unit and its destination.
26:54He was the man who dealt with the military police, because the paperwork was in his hand.
27:00And in the American army in 1944, officers well up the ladder drove themselves all the time.
27:07Because a jeep is not a staff car, and there is usually nobody to spare.
27:12So the American procedure and the German habit were pointed straight at one another.
27:17An American sentry's first question goes to the man behind the wheel.
27:21In a German team, that is the man who cannot answer it.
27:26Once counterintelligence had it, the instruction went out through the checkpoints.
27:30Talk to the driver.
27:32Ask him for his trip ticket.
27:34Ask him his serial number.
27:36Look at his dog tags.
27:37And the trip tickets came back blank.
27:39Or filled in wrong.
27:41Because a forger can reproduce the paper, but not the habit of a clerk who has filled out 400 of
27:46them.
27:47Then there was the arithmetic of the vehicle itself.
27:51American jeeps on those roads rarely carried more than two men, and regulations discouraged more than three.
27:57The German teams traveled four.
28:00Four men, every time.
28:03Four is a German number.
28:04It was the smallest group the German army moved and fought in.
28:08And when they organized an infiltration, they organized it in the unit they had always used.
28:12They put a squad in a jeep.
28:16And a jeep with four men in it, on a Belgian road that December, was a German sentence, written in
28:22American vocabulary, legible from 50 meters, before anybody opened his mouth.
28:28And then there is the one that no document states plainly, because nobody ever thought to write it down.
28:34Watch what happens when authority stops a vehicle.
28:36In the German army, the senior man answers, and the others hold still.
28:41You do not speak across your superior to an official.
28:45In an American jeep, everybody talks.
28:48The private answers for himself.
28:51Somebody says something he shouldn't.
28:53Somebody complains about the road.
28:54And the MP gives it straight back to him.
28:57You will not find that in a manual.
29:00But look at the procedure the Americans adopted, and it is sitting right there in plain sight.
29:06Question the driver.
29:08It works because an American driver answers for himself without glancing at anyone.
29:13And a man trained for years never to speak before his superior does the one thing that cannot be faked
29:19under pressure.
29:20He waits half a second for permission.
29:24Whatever else was in Manfred Pernas' head that night at I-Vila, we have one line of it.
29:30Under interrogation, he said,
29:32I could have avoided our capture by the MPs, but I wanted to sabotage our mission, because I want the
29:39Americans to conquer.
29:41Take that for what it is worth from a man in the position he was in, facing what he was
29:45facing.
29:46But notice what it concedes.
29:48He believed the outcome had been in his hands, and that it turned on what he did in the first
29:54few seconds at that roadblock.
29:56This is the answer coming into focus.
29:59And it is not about language.
30:01Germany could copy every visible object the American army owned.
30:05What it could not copy was that army's internal grammar.
30:10Who speaks?
30:11Who decides?
30:12Who is expected to answer for himself?
30:15And it could not copy it for a reason that ought to be obvious, and isn't.
30:21Nobody had written it down.
30:23The Americans hadn't written it down either.
30:25They had no idea it was there.
30:28It stayed invisible to them until a German got it wrong.
30:32Which brings us to the thing everyone remembers about that week.
30:35The trivia questions.
30:38Springfield.
30:38Betty Grable.
30:40Mickey Mouse.
30:40The strangest fact about that test is not the questions themselves.
30:45It is that no headquarters issued it.
30:47No manual contained it.
30:49And no officer signed it.
30:52It moved through the United States Army faster than any order in the entire campaign.
30:57And inside 48 hours, it had a lieutenant general standing in a road in Belgium, proving who he was.
31:04Somewhere on a Belgian road, in the third week of December, 1944, the second most important American soldier in Europe,
31:13was ordered out of his vehicle and told to prove who he was.
31:18Lieutenant General Omar Bradley was stopped three times.
31:22He wrote down what he was asked.
31:24The first time, by identifying Springfield as the capital of Illinois.
31:29The second time, by locating the guard between the center and the tackle on a line of scrimmage.
31:35The third time, by naming the current husband of a blonde named Betty Grable.
31:41He got all three right.
31:43And the first one nearly went badly.
31:46The soldier questioning him was not satisfied with Springfield.
31:50He had been holding out for Chicago.
31:53Think about what is happening in that exchange.
31:56The commanding general of an American army group is standing in the mud, being marked wrong by a private who
32:03does not know the capital of Illinois.
32:06And the general is the one who has to talk his way out of it.
32:10It went further than that.
32:12At St. Vite, a crossroads town the entire German timetable was hanging on,
32:17Brigadier General Bruce Clark was stopped by military police and asked which league the Chicago Cubs played in.
32:25He said the American League.
32:27The Cubs were a National League club.
32:43The man commanding the defense of St. Vite spent part of that crisis locked in a Belgian house by his
32:49own army, because he did not follow baseball.
32:53So why does that test work?
32:56Not because the answers are hard.
32:58Springfield is in any atlas.
33:01Any of Skorzenny's men could have memorized the capital of every state in a week, and some of them probably
33:06had.
33:07It works because it is not a knowledge test.
33:11It is a childhood test.
33:13The questions that caught people were the ones nobody studies.
33:16Who Mickey Mouse's girlfriend is.
33:18Who plays center field for the Yankees.
33:20Where the guard stands on a line of scrimmage.
33:23That is not information an adult acquires.
33:26It is sediment.
33:28It is what is left over from being nine years old in a particular country, and there is no six
33:33-week course that installs it.
33:34And it could not be prepared for, because there was no list.
33:39The questions were invented on the spot by whoever happened to be standing in the road, and they were different
33:44at the next checkpoint, and different again an hour later.
33:48Grafenwoe could teach American rank badges, because rank badges are finite.
33:53Nobody can teach an entire country's childhood, asked at random, by strangers, at gunpoint.
34:00But here is the part that matters most, and it is the answer this whole story has been walking toward.
34:06Nobody ordered it.
34:07There is no directive from 12th Army Group instructing sentries to ask about Betty Grable.
34:12No manual contains it.
34:14No officer put his signature on it.
34:17It was invented by enlisted men standing in the cold.
34:21It spread by word of mouth from post to post.
34:24And inside about 48 hours, it was running across an entire army group.
34:29A private first class with a carbine decided, on his own authority, to invent a security procedure, and then applied
34:37it to a lieutenant general.
34:39And the lieutenant general answered the questions.
34:42That is the whole thing in one image.
34:45Bradley did not have the man disciplined.
34:48Clark, afterwards, said the MP had been doing his job.
34:53Now put that against Operation Greif.
34:56The Germans were attempting to impersonate an army whose defining characteristic was that its lowest-ranking men acted without being
35:03told.
35:05You cannot rehearse that.
35:06You cannot copy it, because there is no document to copy.
35:10And the countermeasure that destroyed the operation was not really a countermeasure at all.
35:16It was that same characteristic switched on.
35:19The thing they could not imitate is the thing that caught them.
35:23And I am not going to pretend it came free, because it did not.
35:26The price was paid by Americans.
35:29Estimates of how many infiltrators were loose ran wildly past the truth.
35:33Perhaps 40-odd men were in the rear areas at any one time.
35:37The American rear believed in hundreds.
35:40Traffic stopped at every junction.
35:42On the 20th of December, a nervous military policeman shot and killed two American soldiers.
35:49On the 2nd of January, men of the 6th Armored Division fired on the 35th Infantry Division.
35:55Two Americans dead and more wounded.
35:58And then there was the rumor out of that sealed camp in Bavaria.
36:02Wilhelm Schmidt, under interrogation on the 19th of December, told his questioners that a unit of 200 men,
36:09no, he corrected himself, 300, was on its way to Paris to capture Eisenhower.
36:16No such order ever existed.
36:19Skorzeny denied it for the rest of his life, and no document has ever been found.
36:23It was barracks talk, repeated by a frightened 24-year-old with every reason to say something enormous.
36:30And it worked better than any Operation Skorzeny actually ran.
36:34The supreme commander of the Allied Expeditionary Force spent Christmas of 1944
36:39sealed inside his own headquarters under heavy guard, his movements restricted,
36:44while the battle he was responsible for was being fought 200 miles away.
36:49That was Operation Greif's real achievement.
36:52Not a bridge, not a road.
36:55A rumor from a barracks, repeated by a prisoner,
36:59that put the man in charge of the liberation of Europe under guard.
37:03Two days after Schmidt said it, he was standing in a room in Oipin,
37:07in front of an American military commission, with Billing and Pernas beside him.
37:11What those three men said in that room is the most direct answer to our question that anyone has ever
37:17given,
37:17and one of them put it into a single sentence.
37:20It is not a sentence about language.
37:22On the 21st of December, 1944, in the Belgian border town of Oipin,
37:27three men in American uniform stood in front of an American military commission.
37:32The proceedings were short.
37:34Crossing an enemy's lines in his uniform was not a gray area in 1944.
37:39It was among the oldest capital offenses in the laws of war,
37:42and every man in that room knew how it would end.
37:46What survives is what they said.
37:49Manfred Pernas, the driver, the poorest linguist of the three,
37:53the man in the seat where the questions start, said this,
37:57I could have avoided our capture by the MPs,
37:59but I wanted to sabotage our mission, because I want the Americans to conquer.
38:04Wilhelm Schmidt, who had spent three weeks in prisoner-of-war camps listening to Americans talk,
38:10and who had told his interrogators about 300 paratroopers bound for Paris, said,
38:14I admit that what I did was unfair.
38:17And Gunter Billing, 21 years old, the officer candidate out of the Naval Signal Service, said,
38:24I did not have another choice.
38:26I had to obey orders, or they would have shot me.
38:30These are the words of men who expected to be shot,
38:33and each of them was reaching for whatever might help.
38:37Pernas claiming that he sabotaged his own mission is not a statement you take at face value.
38:42But read Billing's sentence again, because it is not a defense a man invents on the spot.
38:49It is the defense that was lying ready to hand.
38:52In his army, it was the truest thing a soldier could say about himself.
38:57I had to obey orders, or they would have shot me.
39:02Now set that beside the private first class standing on a Belgian road who decided,
39:07entirely by himself,
39:09that a strange officer ought to be asked about Betty Grable,
39:13and then held the lieutenant general there until he answered.
39:17That is two armies in two sentences,
39:20and it is the answer to the question we started with.
39:23A man whose actions are produced by orders cannot impersonate a man whose actions are produced by his own judgment.
39:31He can wear the uniform.
39:32He can drive the jeep.
39:34He can get the vocabulary right,
39:36the insignia right,
39:37the paperwork nearly right.
39:40But the moment something unscripted happens,
39:43a hand goes up in the road,
39:45a question arrives that was in no curriculum,
39:48he does what his own army built into him.
39:51He waits to be told.
39:54And the man standing in front of him,
39:56who has never once in his life waited to be told,
40:00sees it happen.
40:02That is why half an hour was a normal lifespan for these teams.
40:06Not because the Americans were clever.
40:09Because the Germans were German,
40:11right down to the reflexes.
40:13And the reflexes were the one part of the disguise that nobody could issue them.
40:19The commissions that tried them were appointed by First Army,
40:23under authority running from Eisenhower through Bradley to Courtney Hodges.
40:27This was not a roadside shooting.
40:29It was a legal process,
40:31carried out in the middle of the worst week the American army had in Europe,
40:36by men who had every excuse to be careless with it,
40:39and were not.
40:41They were shot on the 23rd of December,
40:44behind the American barracks at Henri Chapelle,
40:47tied to posts.
40:49There is a photograph of it.
40:51By one account,
40:52Billing called out for Hitler at the end,
40:55and the other two said nothing at all.
40:58Pernas was 23.
41:00Schmidt was 24.
41:02Billing was 21.
41:04They were the first.
41:06Three more were shot at Henri Chapelle on the 26th of December.
41:11Seven more on the 30th.
41:13Three at Huy on the 13th of January.
41:17Lieutenant Gunther Schultz,
41:18the team leader taken at the Meuse Bridge,
41:21was not tried until May of 1945,
41:24and was executed that June,
41:27after the war in Europe had already been over for a month.
41:31And the brigade itself never went near a Meuse Bridge.
41:35The armored division it was supposed to follow
41:38never broke the road open,
41:39and by the 21st of December,
41:41Schultz's men were being spent as ordinary infantry.
41:45They attacked Malmedy that day,
41:47in their own uniforms now,
41:49with their own weapons,
41:50the disguise abandoned entirely,
41:52and American defenders threw them back.
41:55Schultz's men were being spent as ordinary infantry.
41:58The operation was finished.
42:01So let me total it honestly,
42:03because this audience deserves the arithmetic,
42:06rather than the legend.
42:07Roughly 44 men went through the American lines.
42:11They turned some signs.
42:13They cut a cable.
42:14They blew up a dump.
42:16They cost an American regiment an afternoon.
42:19Not one bridge was taken.
42:22And by the third day,
42:23the whole thing had stopped functioning,
42:25because the American rear had started asking a question
42:28that nobody in Bavaria could have prepared an answer for.
42:32Look at who did that.
42:33Not a special unit.
42:35Not a corps of professionals.
42:37Although the counterintelligence detachments
42:39did the analysis that mattered.
42:42The men who actually stopped those jeeps
42:44were military policemen at crossroads.
42:46Sentries on bridges.
42:48Clerks and drivers and riflemen
42:50standing out in the worst winter weather
42:52Belgium had seen in years.
42:54Each one deciding for himself
42:56what to ask the next vehicle that came up the road.
43:00That is not a trick the Germans failed to learn.
43:03It is something an army either is or is not.
43:07One question is left,
43:09and the ending is not the one you would expect.
43:13The man who designed all of this,
43:15who dressed 2,000 Germans as Americans,
43:18who had those uniforms pulled out of prisoner of war camps,
43:21and who sent Billing and Pernas and Schmidt
43:24to a post at Henri Chapelle,
43:26stood trial for it at Dachau in 1947.
43:31He walked out of that courtroom a free man.
43:34And the reason he walked out
43:36was handed to the court
43:37by a British officer
43:39who had spent his own war
43:40doing something remarkably similar.
43:43The trial opened at Dachau in the summer of 1947.
43:47Skoczeny and nine officers of Panzer Brigade 150
43:51faced charges of improper use of American uniforms,
43:55of entering combat disguised,
43:57of firing on Americans while wearing their clothes,
44:00and of taking those uniforms and Red Cross parcels
44:03out of a prisoner of war camp.
44:06The defense called a British officer.
44:09Wing Commander Forrest Yeo Thomas
44:11had run agents into occupied France
44:14for the special operations executive,
44:16had been captured, tortured,
44:18and had survived Buchenwald.
44:21He told the court that he and his own people
44:23had worn German uniforms behind German lines,
44:26and that everyone in that trade had done the same.
44:29The tribunal drew the line
44:31exactly where the German lawyers had drawn it
44:33two and a half years earlier.
44:35Wearing an enemy uniform to deceive
44:38was a ruse of war.
44:40Fighting in one was not.
44:42And the prosecution could not prove
44:44that any order had been issued
44:46to fight in American uniform.
44:47In September of 1947,
44:49Skoczeny and all nine of his officers were acquitted.
44:53He was interned afterwards,
44:55escaped in 1948,
44:56and spent the rest of his life abroad,
44:59largely in Madrid,
45:00where he died in 1975, in bed.
45:03So the men who obeyed the orders
45:05were shot at Henri Chapelle
45:08at 21, 23, and 24 years of age,
45:11and the man who issued them
45:13lived another 30 years.
45:16I will leave that where it lies.
45:18It is not the point of this story,
45:20but it is part of it.
45:23Eisenhower got out of his own headquarters in the end,
45:25and he got out because he finally lost his temper about it.
45:29He had been kept behind guards through Christmas
45:31on the strength of a rumor told by a frightened 24-year-old prisoner,
45:35and he said, in effect,
45:37that he would take his chances and go.
45:40The plot had never existed.
45:42The confinement was entirely real.
45:45As for the Americans in this,
45:47Bruce Clark,
45:48the general locked in a Belgian house
45:50over a baseball question,
45:52went back to Sainte-Vite
45:53and held that crossroads for six days
45:56against everything the Germans could throw at it,
45:59which wrecked their timetable in the northern sector.
46:02He finished his career a four-star general
46:05commanding the United States Army in Europe.
46:07Omar Bradley,
46:09who had to name Betty Grable's husband
46:10to get down his own road,
46:12took his army group to the Rhine and across it,
46:15and later wore five stars
46:16as the first chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff.
46:20Guy Stern, Gunter Stern of Hildesheim,
46:23who got out at 15 and came back in an American uniform,
46:27was decorated with the bronze star
46:29for his work with prisoners.
46:30He became a professor of German literature,
46:34spent decades telling this history
46:35to anyone who would listen,
46:37and died in Detroit in December of 2023,
46:41aged 101.
46:43The episode left marks.
46:45Passwords were changed more often.
46:48Identification was tightened.
46:49And for the rest of the war,
46:51and for a long time after it,
46:53American soldiers told each other
46:55about the week when you had to know your baseball
46:57to get down a road in Belgium.
46:59Panzer Brigade 150 was disbanded
47:02at the end of January 1945.
47:04It never once did the job it had been created for.
47:09One more thing about Henri Chapelle,
47:11and then we are finished.
47:12That village is not remembered for a firing squad.
47:16On the hillside outside it
47:18lies the Henri Chapelle American Cemetery,
47:20where nearly 8,000 American dead are buried,
47:23a great many of them from this campaign.
47:26The men who were fighting that winter
47:28while all of this was happening
47:29in the roads behind them.
47:32The three Germans were shot
47:34in the same small Belgian village
47:35where those graves were about to be dug,
47:38and the sentry at Évay.
47:41We do not know his name.
47:43No account records it.
47:45Some American soldier,
47:47on the evening of the 18th of December, 1944,
47:50stood in the cold
47:51at the end of a bridge over the Ambleve,
47:54watched a jeep come up the road
47:56with everything right about it,
47:57the paint,
47:58the star,
47:59the uniforms,
48:01the English,
48:02and asked for the password anyway.
48:04He was not a specialist.
48:06He had not been briefed on Operation Greif,
48:09because almost nobody had been.
48:11He had a word in his head,
48:13and a decision that was his alone to make,
48:16and he made it.
48:17And the most ambitious deception
48:19the German army attempted in the West
48:21came apart in his hands inside a minute.
48:25There were thousands of him that week,
48:27at bridges and crossroads and junctions
48:29all across that rear area,
48:31and between them,
48:33they shut the whole thing down.
48:35That is the answer.
48:37Germany could copy the uniform,
48:39the jeep,
48:40the papers,
48:41the insignia,
48:41and the accent.
48:43What Germany could not copy
48:45was an army in which the man at the bottom
48:47does not wait to be told.
48:49They could dress as American soldiers.
48:52They could not behave as American soldiers,
48:54because behaving like one
48:56meant acting on your own judgments,
48:58and that was the single thing
48:59their own army had spent years
49:01training out of them.
49:03Three men in a jeep,
49:0530 minutes,
49:06and one sentry
49:08who did not need anybody's permission
49:09to ask a question.
49:12Thank you for staying with this one
49:13all the way to the end.
49:15If it was worth your time,
49:16a like helps more than you would think.
49:19It is the signal
49:20that tells the platform
49:20to put this story
49:21in front of other people
49:22who care about what the G1s
49:24did in the Ardennes.
49:26Subscribe
49:26and turn on the bell
49:28and you will not miss the next one.
49:30I would like to know
49:31where you were watching from,
49:33so leave your town in the comments.
49:35And if your father,
49:36your grandfather,
49:37or your uncle
49:38served in the Second World War,
49:39tell me his name
49:41and his unit.
49:42They belong in the record
49:43as much as anything in this script.