Skip to playerSkip to main content
  • 37 minutes ago
WWE wrestlers, shocking deaths, and real-life tragedy collide in this dark true crime-style wrestling history story. From Chris Benoit and the murders in Fayetteville to the long-unsolved case around Jimmy Superfly Snuka, this narration traces some of the most disturbing incidents tied to pro wrestling names and backstage legends.

The story also covers Hijo del Perro Aguayo’s fatal in-ring collapse in Tijuana, Brian Ong’s death during training with the future Great Khali, the stabbing of Bruiser Brody in Puerto Rico, and the case involving Billy Jack Haynes in Portland. It closes with Verne Gagne and a fatal confrontation in a Minnesota memory care unit, showing how wrestling history can intersect with violence, legal battles, and unanswered questions.

Created for viewers and listeners who search for wrestling documentary storytelling, true crime wrestling history, pro wrestling scandals, and narrated sports history. It also fits searches for dark wrestling stories, WWE controversies, and long-form background listening with a serious, documentary-style tone.

Category

📚
Learning
Transcript
00:00The Lat Pull-Down Machine
00:01Over a three-day weekend, from June 22 through 24, 2007,
00:07Chris Benoit, a 40-year-old Canadian wrestling star
00:10and former WWE World Heavyweight Champion,
00:14was at his family home in Fayetteville, Georgia,
00:16while quietly missing the live events he was booked for in Texas.
00:20He texted colleagues his home address and the location of his dogs
00:24and gave WWE different excuses about family illness and flight trouble.
00:28By then, his wife Nancy and their seven-year-old son Daniel
00:32were already dead inside the house.
00:34Investigators concluded Benoit strangled Nancy on the night of June 22,
00:39bound her hands and feet, and placed a Bible by her body.
00:42The next morning, he sedated Daniel with Xanax
00:45and suffocated him in his bed, leaving a Bible there, too.
00:49On June 24, Benoit went to his home gym,
00:53looped the cable of his Lat Pull-Down Machine around his neck,
00:56and released the weight stack.
00:58WWE asked for a welfare check on June 25,
01:02and deputies found all three.
01:05Authorities in Fayette County determined the case to be a double murder,
01:08carried out by Benoit, who then died by his own hand.
01:12And later medical analysis found severe brain degeneration
01:15comparable to that of an elderly dementia patient.
01:19The Fall
01:20In May 1983, James Wiley Smith Jr.,
01:24the WWF high flyer known as Jimmy Superfly Snuka,
01:28was on the road with his girlfriend, 23-year-old Nancy Argentino,
01:33staying at a motor lodge in Whitehall Township, Pennsylvania,
01:36after an Allentown area event.
01:39Snuka called an ambulance to the room.
01:42His account was that Argentino had hit her head in a fall.
01:45The coroner found she died of cranio-cerebral injuries
01:49with multiple scalp, facial, and bodily bruises and abrasions,
01:53a pattern, the report said,
01:55wasn't consistent with a single, simple fall.
01:57Prosecutors believed she'd been beaten.
02:00Snuka maintained it was an accident.
02:02For decades, nothing happened.
02:05He wasn't charged in 1983.
02:07Then, a newspaper reopened the story.
02:09A grand jury took it up.
02:11And in 2015, more than 30 years later,
02:14Snuka was charged with third-degree murder
02:17and involuntary manslaughter.
02:19He never stood trial.
02:20In 2016, a judge ruled him not competent because of dementia.
02:24And on the 3rd of January 2017,
02:28the case was dismissed as he sat in hospice care in Florida.
02:31He died days later,
02:33and the death linked to him remained legally unresolved.
02:36The 619
02:37On the night of Friday, the 20th of March, 2015,
02:43Pedro Aguayo Ramirez,
02:45the 35-year-old Mexican star wrestling
02:47as Jijo del Perro Aguayo,
02:50son of a Lucha Libre legend,
02:52was in a tag match at a municipal auditorium in Tijuana
02:55against a team that included Rey Mysterio.
02:58It was a standard bout, not a stunt match.
03:02Aguayo ended up draped against the middle rope,
03:04the classic setup position for Mysterio's signature 619.
03:09Mysterio delivered a flying dropkick that struck him from behind
03:12and drove him forward into the ropes.
03:15Aguayo slumped over and stopped moving,
03:17hanging in that same position.
03:19For about two minutes,
03:20the other wrestlers and the referee kept working,
03:23not realizing he wasn't selling the spot.
03:25When they finally tended to him,
03:27he was rushed to a hospital one block away.
03:30He was pronounced dead around 1.30 a.m. on March 21.
03:34The Baja California Prosecutor's Office,
03:36citing the autopsy,
03:38gave the cause as trauma to the neck and a cervical fracture.
03:41They opened an investigation into possible manslaughter,
03:44but no charges were filed.
03:46The second knife,
03:48just after 8.30 p.m. on Wednesday,
03:50the 24th of July, 2013,
03:53deputies in Tampa, Florida,
03:55were called to the Grand Oaks Apartments on Del Lago Circle.
03:58Brian McGee,
03:59a 29-year-old former WWE developmental wrestler from the street.
04:04Louis Area,
04:04who'd worked the Florida system as the future,
04:07had gone to see his ex-girlfriend,
04:0925-year-old Bianca McGaughey.
04:11She was outside walking her dog.
04:14Prosecutors said McGee walked up
04:15and immediately attacked her with a knife.
04:17A witness saw what looked like a punch to the stomach.
04:20McGaughey fell screaming,
04:21and when the witness came back,
04:23a knife was sticking from her abdomen.
04:25During the attack,
04:26the blade broke,
04:27so McGee went back to his car for a second knife
04:30and kept stabbing.
04:31She died at the scene with multiple wounds.
04:34He fled in a Pontiac Grand Prix,
04:36posted a bloody image to Facebook,
04:38and confessed to his sister,
04:40his mother,
04:40and then a police officer over the phone.
04:43A chase ended when he crashed near Interstate 75
04:46and was taken down by a K-9.
04:49In 2016, he pleaded guilty,
04:51and the state dropped its death penalty bid
04:54in exchange for life without parole.
04:56The Spinebuster.
04:57On the 28th of May, 2001,
05:00at All Pro Wrestling's boot camp training school
05:03in Hayward, California,
05:04a 27-year-old trainee named Brian Ong
05:08was paired up to practice a move
05:10with a 28-year-old Indian powerhouse,
05:12a former Punjab police officer
05:15who hadn't yet become the great Kali.
05:17This wasn't a hardcore stunt.
05:19It was a basic drill,
05:21a spinebuster,
05:22run safely with other trainees that same day.
05:25But on the move,
05:26Ong grabbed Kali's shirt,
05:28which threw him out of position.
05:30His tailbone hit the mat first,
05:32then his head whipped back and slammed down.
05:35Ong had already taken a concussion
05:36in earlier training
05:37and been let back into the ring anyway.
05:40He was knocked unconscious
05:42and rushed to Street Rose Hospital,
05:44where he was pronounced dead.
05:45The Alameda County coroner listed the cause
05:48as acute subdural hemorrhage due to head trauma.
05:51Ong's family sued the school,
05:53and in July 2005,
05:55a jury found unanimously for them,
05:57awarding damages reported
05:59between $1.3 million
06:00and just over $2 million.
06:03The standoff.
06:05On the 8th of February, 2024,
06:07police in Portland, Oregon,
06:09were called to the home
06:10of 70-year-old William Albert Haynes III,
06:13the retired wrestler known to WWF fans
06:16as Billy Jack Haynes,
06:18who'd appeared at WrestleMania III
06:20back in the 1980s.
06:22The call was about a shooting
06:24involving an elderly woman.
06:26Inside was his wife,
06:2785-year-old Jeanette Becraft,
06:30who had dementia.
06:32Haynes didn't surrender.
06:33Reports describe a roughly two-hour standoff
06:36with a SWAT-style response
06:38before he was taken into custody
06:39and brought to a hospital.
06:41Becraft was found dead in the residence.
06:44Because the case went through
06:45a secret grand jury
06:46with no public probable cause affidavit,
06:49the exact sequence of the shooting
06:51isn't documented.
06:52What is on record,
06:53on February 28,
06:55he was charged with second-degree murder,
06:57domestic violence,
06:58and unlawful use of a weapon.
07:00In a jail interview,
07:01he called it way overcharged
07:03and said it didn't happen,
07:05insisting he loved her more than life.
07:07Talk business.
07:08On the evening of the 16th of July,
07:111988,
07:12Jose Huertas Gonzalez,
07:14the Puerto Rican wrestler
07:15and WWC booker
07:17known as Invader One,
07:19approached a top American brawler
07:21in the locker room
07:22at Juan Ramon Lubriel Stadium
07:24in Bayamon, Puerto Rico.
07:26Before a show,
07:27the brawler was 42-year-old Frank Goodish,
07:30the legendary bruiser Brody,
07:32booked that night against Dan Spivey.
07:35Gonzalez asked Brody
07:36to step into the shower area
07:38to talk business.
07:39Brody, unarmed,
07:40went with him.
07:41Inside,
07:42Gonzalez stabbed him.
07:44Tony Atlas,
07:45watching from outside,
07:46first thought it was a punch
07:47until he saw the wound.
07:49Brody staggered back out,
07:51gravely hurt,
07:52and other wrestlers carried him out
07:54as some initially told police
07:55a fan had done it.
07:57Police even wondered at first
07:59if it was a wrestling angle.
08:01Brody was rushed to surgery
08:03but died on July 17
08:04from the stab wounds.
08:06The knife was never recovered.
08:09Gonzalez claimed self-defense
08:10and didn't testify.
08:12Key witnesses like Atlas
08:13and Dutch Mantel
08:15never made it to the stand.
08:16Mantel's subpoena
08:17reportedly arrived
08:1810 days after the trial ended.
08:20In 1989,
08:22a jury acquitted Gonzalez
08:23and no one was ever convicted.
08:26The Body Slam
08:27On the 26th of January 2009,
08:31inside the memory care unit
08:32of a nursing home
08:33in Bloomington, Minnesota,
08:3583-year-old Vern Gagne,
08:37the American wrestling legend
08:39who founded and ran the AWA
08:41and held its world title 10 times,
08:44got into a physical confrontation
08:45with a fellow resident,
08:4797-year-old Helmut Gutmann,
08:50a retired physician
08:51and cancer researcher.
08:53Both men had Alzheimer's disease.
08:55According to police,
08:57Gagne threw or body-slammed Gutmann
08:59to the floor
08:59hard enough to break his hip.
09:01Investigators said
09:02they never learned
09:03what started it
09:04because neither man
09:05could remember.
09:06Gutmann was hospitalized,
09:08declined over the following weeks,
09:10and died on February 14, 2009.
09:13The Hennepin County
09:14medical examiner
09:15ruled it a homicide,
09:16death from complications
09:18of the broken hip,
09:19but no charges followed.
09:20Gagne's advanced dementia
09:22made him legally incompetent
09:23to prosecute,
09:24and Gutmann's daughter
09:25said she didn't want
09:26charges brought
09:27because Gagne
09:28couldn't be held responsible
09:30for what his disease had done.
09:31Gagne himself died in 2015 at 89,
09:35never tried,
09:36almost certainly
09:37never understanding
09:38what had happened.
09:39Thanks so much
09:40for rocking with the channel for real.
09:42Hit that subscribe
09:43and turn on the bell
09:44so you don't miss a single one.
09:46And got a topic
09:47you want me to dig into next?
09:48Drop it in the comments.
09:50before I get back.
09:50Thank you and I'll see you in a little bit s
Comments

Recommended