- 2 days ago
May 18th, 2004. A climber was begging the last two men remaining with him on Everest not to leave him behind. He was just smiling two hours earlier.
What happened in those two hours depends on who's telling it.
----------------------------------------------------------
Watch More:
The 2016 Everest Mission To Prove A Point: Maria Strydom’s Fatal Mistake
https://youtu.be/j6I7ZVUoINY?si=aHHk3MOgj37gg0su
From Hero to Fraud: The Man Who Faked His K2 Summit
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aYZYTJ2ju9U
----------------------------------------------------------
More eXtreme Stories - Subscribe: https://www.youtube.com/@TheExtreme-Edge
Every month there's a story that never goes on YouTube. You'll find it here: patreon.com/c/TheeXtreme
For business inquiries only - extremeedgeinfo@gmail.com
Voiceover: https://jessegvoiceactor.com/
What happened in those two hours depends on who's telling it.
----------------------------------------------------------
Watch More:
The 2016 Everest Mission To Prove A Point: Maria Strydom’s Fatal Mistake
https://youtu.be/j6I7ZVUoINY?si=aHHk3MOgj37gg0su
From Hero to Fraud: The Man Who Faked His K2 Summit
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aYZYTJ2ju9U
----------------------------------------------------------
More eXtreme Stories - Subscribe: https://www.youtube.com/@TheExtreme-Edge
Every month there's a story that never goes on YouTube. You'll find it here: patreon.com/c/TheeXtreme
For business inquiries only - extremeedgeinfo@gmail.com
Voiceover: https://jessegvoiceactor.com/
Category
🗞
NewsTranscript
00:00May 18th, 2004. A climber was begging the last two men remaining with him on Everest not to leave him
00:09behind. He was just smiling two hours earlier.
00:12What happened in those two hours depends on who's telling it.
00:17Welcome to the extreme edge, where the stakes are high, but nobody's just a headline.
00:23In late 2003, back in Washington, D.C., this man, Dr. Nils Antezana, offered his guide an all-expenses-paid
00:34trip up Mount Everest with flights, gear, and Sherpas covered, plus a $10,000 bonus if they both made it
00:43home alive.
00:44The guide was Gustavo Lisi. They had climbed together in the Andes, and Gustavo's website said he'd summited Everest in
00:532000.
00:54That was enough for Nils to bet his life on him.
00:57This was his last shot at summiting the highest mountain in the world.
01:02He had no way of knowing that guide would one day be the reason he never came home.
01:09By the spring of 2004, Nils and Gustavo went to Nepal, and climbers at base camp were watching this small,
01:18silver-haired man move slowly up and down Everest, acclimatizing.
01:23Plenty of them have wondered what he was even doing there.
01:27Some would have told you he had no business on that mountain at all.
01:31But then again, plenty of people had no business being on Everest that season anyway.
01:37By 2004, base camp had turned into something closer to a lawless frontier town than an expedition post.
01:47Climbers that season would carry loads up to the high camps, bury food and bottled oxygen inside a zip tent
01:55at 26,000 feet,
01:57only to return for the actual summit push and find their bottles and food stolen.
02:05On the other side of the mountain, one expedition leader beat his own wife unconscious in camp while his team
02:14watched and did nothing.
02:15There was no police, no rules that anyone had to answer to.
02:21Everest in 2004 was a place where the only thing protecting you was the character of the people you'd brought
02:28with you,
02:29which is why Nils brought three of the best guides money could hire.
02:33Two experienced Sherpas, Big Dorji and Mingma, both of whom had stood on the summit before,
02:40and he had Gustavo, his guide and friend, for support.
02:45By the middle of May, the forecasts showed the wind dying down up high and a rare summit window opening
02:52up.
02:53And so, on the night of May 17th, 2004, from the last camp at 26,000 feet,
03:01Nils Antizana switched on his headlamp and started climbing toward the top of the world.
03:06Summit night starts around 10 or 11 in the evening because the journey to the top from Camp 4 is
03:13a 12-hour climb.
03:15If things go well, you need to get there by mid-morning or early afternoon,
03:21and then come back down almost immediately because you need enough daylight and enough bottled oxygen left over for the
03:29way down.
03:30Every experienced climber in the Himalayas knows the summit is the halfway point.
03:35The finish line is the tent you left.
03:39Nils spent the whole night going up, very slowly, one boot, one breath, while faster teams passed him in the
03:48dark.
03:50Dawn came. The morning wore on.
03:52Teams that had started before him were out flanking him with terrifying speed.
03:57But he wasn't afraid.
04:00This was exactly what he planned for.
04:03And at around 10 a.m. on May 18th, 2004, Nils Antizana walked up the last few feet of snow
04:12and stood on the summit of Mount Everest.
04:15He had finally done it.
04:17He was now one of the oldest human beings ever to stand there.
04:23For a man who had reached the absolute pinnacle of his medical career and had just spent a fortune to
04:31bypass years of Himalayan training,
04:35standing on top of the world must have felt like the ultimate validation.
04:40He had bought his world record and he was going to savor it.
04:44But most climbers spend maybe 10 minutes up there to take a quick photo at the top of the world
04:51before coming back down
04:52because there is not enough oxygen up there to keep a person alive, no matter how prepared or motivated you
04:59are.
05:00Not Nils.
05:02Nils took photo after photo.
05:05He took in the view like a man on a hotel balcony.
05:09This 69-year-old man, who absolutely could not afford to have a single thing go wrong,
05:18stayed on the summit for 35 minutes, burning through his severely limited oxygen.
05:26And incredibly, the highly paid guide he brought along just stood there and let him do it.
05:32Finally, Nils signaled to Gustavo that it was time to head down.
05:37And at first, the descent looked exactly as you'd expect.
05:41Gustavo said he moved ahead, checking the fixed ropes before clipping himself in.
05:47Behind him came Nils, carefully lowering himself one step at a time.
05:53The two Sherpas stayed close and descended along with them in that same slow, measured pace.
06:00Up above, the summit disappeared behind them.
06:03And Camp 4 was just down there.
06:05Tents looked like yellow dots against an endless ocean of rock and snow.
06:11It looked close enough to reach maybe by lunchtime.
06:14But somewhere above a rock outcrop called the South Summit, less than an hour into the descent, it happened.
06:23Nils' right boot missed a step it was aimed at.
06:26Nobody said anything yet because there was still nothing to panic about.
06:30Maybe Nils was just tired.
06:32Of course he was.
06:34He'd just spent nearly 12 hours climbing to the highest point on Earth.
06:38But now, every few steps, he'd stop, lean on his poles, and take several deep breaths through his oxygen mask.
06:46And now, the pauses were becoming longer.
06:49Now, his weight started drifting sideways on the fixed rope, like a drunk man unable to tell which way is
06:56up.
06:57Big Dorji and Mingma closed in on either side of him.
07:01And a little further down, when one of them spoke to him, the answer that came back had the words
07:07slurred and mixed up.
07:08They knew what was happening.
07:11Inside Nils' skull, his brain was swelling and switching things off in a fixed order.
07:17Balance first.
07:18That was the boot.
07:20Speech second.
07:21And judgment third.
07:23And after judgment, everything else.
07:26Nils was a clinical pathologist.
07:28He had spent decades studying the human body.
07:32But as his brain swelled and stripped away his coordination, his only reaction was to lean heavier on his poles.
07:40He kept trying to walk as if his failing body was just a minor inconvenience.
07:45And then, he turned to the side to ask for Gustavo's advice,
07:49because this exact scenario was what carefully choosing a competent guide paying for their gear in the $10,000 bonus
07:58was for.
07:59So, a professional could be standing next to Nils at the moment his brain began to fail.
08:04But when he, Big Dorji, and Mingma looked around, Gustavo Lisi was nowhere to be found.
08:11So, the two Sherpas did the guide's job and put Nils between them.
08:16One man on either side and started bringing him down the mountain.
08:20These weren't inexperienced climbers trying their best.
08:23Big Dorji and Mingma had summited Everest before.
08:27They knew exactly what was happening to him was not yet fatal.
08:30But all three men had been climbing for nearly an entire day in the death zone.
08:36They were spent.
08:38And every minute spent helping Nils was another minute their own bodies were in danger of breaking down.
08:45But they kept going, slowly, painfully.
08:48And by dusk, they reached this wide spot the size of a small room at around 27,500 feet that
08:56climbers call the balcony.
08:58Despite their best efforts the entire afternoon, they had only been able to descend 1,000 vertical feet.
09:06Camp 4 was also more than 1,000 vertical feet below.
09:10And on that shelf, Nils stopped being able to stand on his own at all.
09:15Big Dorji and Mingma had to lower him down here because his legs had quit entirely.
09:21His body had simply reached the end of what it had after hours of brutal climbing.
09:26And the two Sherpas with him now faced a terrible decision.
09:29They could not carry Nils down the next stretch because below the balcony is a long, steep snow slope.
09:36And the two of them had been climbing for over 24 hours.
09:40They were already deeply, almost impossibly tired.
09:45Staying with Nils overnight in the open at 40 below also meant three bodies on that shelf instead of one.
09:53Those were the options.
09:55There was no third one.
09:57Because the man whose job it was to create a third option was nowhere to be found.
10:03So they did what they could do.
10:05They sat Nils upright in the snow, his back against the slope.
10:10They planted oxygen bottles in the ice beside him, close, or his hands could reach them.
10:15The hope was that the rest and oxygen might give him enough strength to stand one more time, grab the
10:23fixed rope, and make it down the mountain under his own power.
10:28Nils' brain was failing by then.
10:30The swelling would have stolen most of what remained of his judgment.
10:34But some things don't require perfect clarity.
10:37He understood what they were about to do.
10:40According to Big Dorji, Nils reached out and grabbed their legs.
10:45Then he said,
10:47The mountain is my home.
10:48Don't leave me.
10:49For a moment, nobody moved.
10:52Then Mingma gently stepped free,
10:54and the two Sherpas clipped themselves back onto the fixed rope and disappeared into the gathering darkness.
11:02Nils was just left there, alone, at 27,500 feet, to pay the price of his ambition.
11:10Somewhere within the hours of May 18, 2004, Nils Antizana died sitting upright in the snow.
11:19His body has never been found.
11:22And that's where this story should have ended, because Everest camp authorities don't really hold inquests.
11:28There's no police post at base camp.
11:31No court on earth up there.
11:33A climber dies up high, the season moves on, and the record books get one more line.
11:38Altitude, descent, and body not recovered.
11:42But in the days that followed, up and down the mountain, climbers kept circling back to one simple question.
11:49The same question you've probably been holding since the descent began.
11:54Where was Gustavo Lisi?
11:56Where was the man whose single job was to stick to his client?
12:00Could a rescue have been attempted?
12:02Could another guide have reached him before nightfall?
12:06The only way to answer this was to ask the man himself.
12:11And what he said was a master class in spin.
12:15Stories that would have made Don Draper proud.
12:19Quick detour.
12:20Every month, there's a story that never goes to YouTube.
12:24It's there if you want it.
12:26Patreon link below.
12:27Now, where were we?
12:29Gustavo Lisi was surprisingly willing to talk about what happened that afternoon.
12:34In fact, he talked about it a lot.
12:37The problem was that every time he told the story, he never said it the same way twice.
12:43In one interview, Gustavo remembered struggling behind the group, exhausted, barely able to keep up with the Sherbas as they
12:52tried to move Nils downhill.
12:54In another, he said he remembered being out in front, hurrying toward Camp 4 to prepare the way.
13:01Sometimes he seemed to lose his strength early.
13:05Sometimes much later.
13:06Even the point where he separated from Nils drifted from one telling to the next.
13:12None of those versions sounded impossible.
13:15On their own, every one of them was believable.
13:18It was only when climbers laid the story side by side that the gaps were revealed.
13:23But that's not automatically proof of anything, because everyone knows your memory above 27,000 feet is a terrible witness.
13:32Every man on that ridge had been awake for more than 24 hours, with every second of that breathing air
13:39with barely a third of the oxygen a brain normally gets.
13:43But there's always a way to test a shifting story, and the climbers who looked into this one used it.
13:51You find the account that doesn't move, and you measure everything against it.
13:56The account that doesn't move belongs to Big Dorji and Mingma.
14:00The two Sherpas told it plainly, and it never changed.
14:05Nils began failing within the first hour or two of the descent.
14:08They took him between them.
14:11They spent the entire afternoon bringing him down from somewhere above the south summit all the way down to the
14:17balcony.
14:18At no point in any telling is the guide helping his client.
14:23That account has everything Gustavo's stories did not.
14:27It was specific.
14:29It was consistent.
14:30It's backed by the plain arithmetic of the mountain of carrying a man a thousand vertical feet down the mountain.
14:37And it's confirmed by where everyone else ended up that night.
14:41But it just didn't make any sense.
14:44How does a professional guide make these mistakes?
14:48Not one mistake.
14:49A chain of them.
14:51Letting a 69-year-old stand on the summit for 35 minutes.
14:55No radio call when the client began to fail.
14:59No plan.
15:01No rescue.
15:02No message left with a single soul at Camp 4.
15:05These aren't lapses of strength.
15:08They're lapses of knowledge.
15:10The kind of things even average guys simply know.
15:14So, wait a minute.
15:16Who was Gustavo Lisi?
15:18It's the question nobody had thought to ask before the client.
15:22Well, because the man had a guiding company, a website full of Andean expeditions.
15:28And at the top of his resume was the credential that he summited Everest in the year 2000.
15:34But now people were asking.
15:37And thankfully, Everest is a remarkably difficult place to lie about because this is one of the most documented places
15:44on Earth.
15:44So, when climbers went looking for Gustavo Lisi in the records of the 2000 summit climbing season, they expected to
15:52see proof.
15:53They found nothing.
15:54But it gets even worse because the currency of an Everest summit is a photograph at the summit.
16:01It's the ultimate proof every client asks to see before they hire.
16:06And Gustavo had one too.
16:08He'd been showing this image of himself for years at the top of the world in 2000.
16:13But now, when climbers who had actually been on Everest in 2000 looked closely at that photograph, they noticed something
16:22that shouldn't have been there.
16:23Because it belongs to another climber who really did stand on top of the world in 2000, who came down
16:31with his summit pictures and whose photos had somehow ended up in Gustavo Lisi's hands, presented for four years as
16:40his own.
16:41So, the proof at the center of Gustavo's business, the image that closed the deal with every client who ever
16:48asked to see evidence, was stolen from a man who had actually done the thing Gustavo only claimed to.
16:56It turned out, Gustavo had never actually reached the top of Everest that 2000 season.
17:02He had instead come agonizingly close, around 650 feet before being forced to turn around.
17:11Turning around there is no disgrace.
17:13Honest ones report where they had to turn around, and it costs them nothing but pride and ego.
17:18That was the one price Gustavo Lisi couldn't pay.
17:23He came home from the only Everest expedition of his life, took another man's summit, put it on his website,
17:31and started charging clients to climb with the man in the photograph.
17:35So, the friend and professional who Nils thought had stood on the exact mountain Nils wanted and came home without
17:43incident had actually done neither.
17:46The experience gap Nils knew he had, the gap he spent all that money to fill, was being filled by
17:54a man who also had the very same gap.
17:57When Gustavo Lisi said yes to that deal, he was deliberately walking back into the death zone so a paying
18:05client would carry him back to the summit that had embarrassed him.
18:09And Nils had no idea.
18:11He thought he was buying experience that would compensate for his age.
18:16Instead, he unknowingly placed his life in the hands of someone who'd built that experience on a lie.
18:24Whether that affected the decisions he made up there that day, only Gustavo Lisi can truly answer.
18:31Can you imagine the ego it takes to do that?
18:34But almost unbelievably, almost impossibly, it gets worse.
18:40Because guess what Gustavo did after coming down from that mountain that night on May 18th, 2004,
18:46and reaching the tents at Camp 4 with his clients still sitting in the snow a thousand feet above him?
18:53He went to sleep.
18:55And to be fair to the man, Gustavo came down that mountain in genuinely bad shape.
19:01His own strength gave out somewhere on the way.
19:04And by his accounts, the exhaustion hit him so hard he could barely keep moving.
19:09He said he reached the tents at Camp 4 late that night, around 11pm, completely spent.
19:15And a man in that condition, on that night, can be forgiven for collapsing into a sleeping bag.
19:21The death zone empties everyone.
19:24Maybe there was truly nothing left in him.
19:27But sleep restores a man.
19:29But the information Gustavo had didn't wait for anyone to wake up.
19:33He was the only person at Camp 4 who knew his 69-year-old client was still up there, not
19:40yet out of danger.
19:41And all around him on the south call were the tents of other expeditions with full oxygen bottles.
19:48Telling any of them what happened cost nothing but words.
19:53He told no one.
19:54He didn't raise an alarm that night and not at sunrise on May 19th either.
19:59Not after rest, not after oxygen, not in the last morning hours when it was even conceivable that Nils' heart
20:06was still beating.
20:07Something did go out, though.
20:09Because the next day, Gustavo Lisi's website had an update.
20:13And what the world saw was good news from the Himalayas.
20:17A successful expedition.
20:19A summit of Mount Everest.
20:21If you were a past or better yet a future client reading that update, everything had gone exactly right.
20:28The guide had delivered again.
20:30The client whose money had paid for the expedition, still sitting a thousand feet above Camp 4, cold and helpless
20:37when that update went out, wasn't mentioned at all.
20:40It was as if he'd never existed.
20:43But he certainly existed to Gladys.
20:46Gladys Antezana had been married to Nils for 38 years.
20:51And in 38 years, through work and climbing every mountain that came before this one, they had a deal that
20:58he'd do the dangerous thing.
21:00And then, the moment he was safe, the phone would ring.
21:03He had never broken it.
21:05Not once in nearly four decades.
21:08That week, Gladys was in a hospital bed in Baltimore recovering from a minor surgery.
21:13So, on May 18th, she lay there working out the time difference in her head.
21:18If he summited in the morning over there, he'd be back in camp by evening.
21:22Which means he was supposed to call soon.
21:25Then, the 18th ended.
21:27And the 19th came and went.
21:30It finally rang two days after the summit.
21:32And the voice on the line wasn't her husband's.
21:35It was a strong, rough voice telling her that her husband had reached the top of the world.
21:42That he had been extremely happy up there.
21:45But something had gone wrong on the way down.
21:48And Nils didn't make it back to camp.
21:50The voice said he was gone.
21:53Then, in that same call, he asked,
21:56Where should he send her husband's things?
21:59That was all Gladys had.
22:02Nobody or explanation that made sense.
22:04Just a promise that had finally been broken.
22:08For most families, that's where it ends.
22:11Because what can you really do?
22:13There's no funeral without a body.
22:16No police report where no police exist.
22:19Everest hands you a closed door and the industry behind it shrugs.
22:23The mountain's dangerous.
22:25He knew the risks.
22:26And Gustavo would have gotten away with everything that happened up there.
22:31If not for Fabiola Antezana.
22:35Fabiola was Nils' daughter.
22:37And within days of that phone call, she was on a plane to Kathmandu.
22:42Because Fabiola hadn't been waiting at home in the dark for six weeks.
22:47She'd been hearing from her father throughout the expedition.
22:50And somewhere in those weeks, tucked in among the ordinary news of her day-to-day life and her father's
22:58last grand climbing adventure,
23:01something else had crept in.
23:03Things between Nils and Gustavo were not going the way they were supposed to go.
23:08And her father kept her informed.
23:10Now, on its own, that meant almost nothing.
23:14Clients and guides grind on each other during every long expedition.
23:17It wasn't the kind of thing you'd quit an expedition over.
23:21But it meant everything for what happened next.
23:23Because when that condolence call to Gladys finally came, everyone else on Earth heard a mountaineering tragedy.
23:33Fabiola was hearing something else.
23:36Especially when the guide her father had been having problems with was the same guide who came down without him,
23:44sat on the news for two days, and was now, strangely, in a hurry to mail his things.
23:50So she wasn't prepared to leave it there.
23:52She had to know what happened.
23:54Her first stop was the expedition's own paper trail.
23:58And it produced the first discovery that her father's death was already recorded as a routine altitude fatality.
24:07No inquiry opened.
24:08None planned.
24:09The government of Nepal was done with Nils Antizana before his daughter's plane landed.
24:15So she went to the people instead.
24:17She started tracking down anyone from the mountain that season.
24:21But the season was over, and witnesses were scattering to a dozen countries.
24:25And the ones she could reach had careers up there.
24:29Careers that don't survive testifying against guides.
24:33People were polite and very sorry for her loss, but they said very little,
24:37except the Sherpa's account and Gustavo's shifting stories.
24:41But even as Kathmandu ran dry, she took her questions to journalists and investigators in the climbing community.
24:48Message after message, to anyone with the means to look.
24:51And it worked.
24:52Climbers who'd been on the mountain began formally comparing notes about Gustavo.
24:57The community dug into his record.
25:00And everything you learned earlier in this video, the empty 2000 season, the stolen photograph,
25:06the business built on another man's summit, came out into the open, on the record, where no future client could
25:14miss it.
25:15A Washington Post reporter spent months reconstructing the expedition hour by hour.
25:21And Michael Kodas, a Pulitzer-winning journalist who'd been climbing Everest that very season,
25:26made the case a centerpiece of his book on what the mountain had become.
25:31The trail you've walked in this video, that's their work.
25:46So, for a case with such clear evidence, you'd think this is an open and shut case, right?
25:53Gustavo should have been arrested and charged with something.
25:56Negligence, abandonment, or fraud at the very least.
26:00Here's what actually happened.
26:02Nothing.
26:04Remember, Nepal's government had already recorded the death of Nils Antizana as a routine altitude fatality and declined to investigate.
26:12And no court anywhere else ever picked it up.
26:15Well, because no court anywhere else could.
26:18Follow the jurisdiction for a second.
26:20And you'll see the trap.
26:21The guide was Argentine.
26:24The client was American.
26:26The death happened in Nepal at 27,500 feet in a place where no investigator will ever stand,
26:33where the evidence is frozen into a ridge nobody can easily reach.
26:38Gustavo Lisi just walked away.
26:41And he went back to work.
26:43For years afterward, you could find Gustavo Lisi leading paying clients up mountains in South America.
26:49New clients who probably opened a website, read the resume, and trusted the man standing in front of them, just
26:56like Nils.
26:58Because the thing about a world with no courts is exposure is the only sentence available.
27:04In climbing circles, his name became shorthand for everything wrong with unregulated climbing.
27:10Climbers on forums openly asked how this man could still be working,
27:15how he could still hold membership and respect at alpine clubs.
27:18And the answer, every time, was the same one Nepal gave Fabiola.
27:24Nobody had the authority to stop him.
27:27The only background check and high-altitude guiding is the client's own.
27:31And clients don't read climbing forums.
27:34They read websites.
27:36The system that failed to punish Gustavo Lisi is the same system that let him guide in the first place.
27:42It never changed.
27:44And when the Antizana family confronted him directly, Gustavo Lisi said one of the most outrageous things about this entire
27:52disaster.
27:53He disputed that he was ever Nils' guide at all.
27:57The way Gustavo told it, he was simply a friend of Nils' who happened to be on the same expedition.
28:03The man Nils flew halfway across the world to trust with his life, later claimed he was never his guide
28:11at all.
28:12Just a friend who happened to be there.
28:15Nobody was ever charged for what happened to Nils' Antizana.
28:19Twelve years later, another climber walked into that same death zone chasing the same hunger to prove something to the
28:26world.
28:27Except this time, no guide would be there to take the blame.
28:31That story is next.
Comments