00:00.
00:00.
00:00.
00:00.
00:00.
00:00.
00:00.
00:00.
00:01.
00:06This is Mary Grace Piatos, the name of the Senate impeachment court in the office of the Vice President.
00:14She has been named in the acknowledgement receipts,
00:17such as a Piatos, the name of the Piatos, the name of the Apelido.
00:22Saksi, Joseph Moro.
00:27Umpong testigo para sa Day 11 ng impeachment trial si Roderick Wamil.
00:32Siya ang State Auditor ng Commission on Audit OCOA na nag-audit sa paggamit sa Confidential Fund
00:37ng tanggapan ni Vice President Sara Duterte at ang Department of Education nung ambisipaang kalihim.
00:43Ipinakita sa pagliliti sa mga acknowledgement receipts na ipinasan ng Office of the Vice President
00:48sa Commission on Audit, Intelligence and Confidential Fund Audit Unit.
00:52Isa sa mga ito nakapangalan sa isang Mary Grace Piatos.
00:56So, ina-acknowledge ng isang Mary Grace Piatos na tumanggap siya na magkano?
01:03Based from this acknowledgement receipt po,
01:05tumanggap po si Mary Grace Piatos ng P70,000 for the payment of rewards,
01:10close and open parenthesis medicines.
01:13Pero hindi lamang si Mary Grace ang may apelidong Piatos.
01:16Meron ding isang Renan Piatos na tumanggap ng ilampas P100,000
01:20dahil sa pagbibigay umano ng impormasyon.
01:23Pinirmahan niya ang acknowledgement receipt noong December 27, 2023
01:26na hindi pinayagan ng COA dahil ang pera ang sinabing ginamit para doon
01:31ay para sa December 2022.
01:33Bukod sa kanila ay may mga iprinisinta rin na iba pang tumanggap
01:37ng confidential funds tulad ng isang Mico P. Harina
01:40na nakatanggap ng P295,000 bilang bayad sa mga supplies.
01:45Meron ding Janice Marie Revilla, Pati Ting at Andy Lim.
01:50In the name of Odie or Andy C. Lim for P50,000.
01:59Andi, ah, Andi Lim.
02:04Kanya ko pala hindi mabasa, Andi Lim.
02:08Para kay Andi Lim, P50,000 ang date 12-21-2023.
02:18Yung date of payment po, December 27, 2023 is outside the coverage po
02:23nung kanilang period of disbursement.
02:25Kung merong Andi Lim, siguro dahil piquet.
02:28Objection, Your Honor.
02:29Ah, I'm sorry but, ah, I've been giving leeway to opposing counsel
02:33but I think she's been coloring, you know, the contents of the documents
02:37more than what is shown in the documents.
02:38Your Honor, I'm just reading. It says here.
02:40No, Your Honor.
02:41It says, Andi Lim. And the next one, maybe you will object again,
02:46it's Alejandro A. Piquet.
02:47I was gonna say, kanya siguro maduli, may pikit ang mata.
02:50Counsel, counsel for the panel of prosecutors,
02:53I think you know what the counsel for the respondent is talking about.
02:56Yes.
02:56Kindly proceed accordingly.
02:57Nang sumahin daw ito ni Wamin, lumabas ng halagang nakasaal sa acknowledgement receipts,
03:02sobra sa nakalagay sa accomplishment report ng OVP.
03:05Magkano ba ang binigay ng confidential funds?
03:09Based on the documents submitted to Iqbal, 125 million pesos po.
03:15May discrepancy?
03:17Hindi ito ba? 150,000 na butal?
03:20Based on the documents po, yes, may discrepancy po yung acknowledgement receipts
03:25and the accomplishment report.
03:26Ang mga acknowledgement receipts tulad halimbawa ng pinirmahan ng isang Mary Grace Piatos
03:31ay ebidensya ng prosekusyon sa Article 1
03:33o yung umarihindiwas ng paggamit ng lapas 600 million pesos na confidential funds
03:39ni Vice President Sara Duterte.
03:41Ang confidential fund ay pondong inilalaan para sa confidential expenses
03:45gaya ng surveillance activities, pagbili ng impormasyon,
03:49pagbibigay ng rewards sa impormante, pagbabayad sa safe houses at iba pa.
03:53Ayon kay Wamil, nakitaan niya ng mga paglilabag sa mga alinan-tunin ng COA
03:58ang dalawang tanggapan sa liquidation ng confidential fund.
04:01Gaya ng hindi pagbibigay ng specific o tiyak na confidential activity,
04:06hindi nagtutugbang petsa ng dokumento, kulang-kulang ng liquidation documents at iba pa.
04:11Pinakita sa iyo ang isang physical financial plan which you said is a faithful reproduction of the submissions.
04:20And this is now being shown on the screen.
04:22Ano, ano-ano ang observations mo?
04:25Dito sa physical and financial plan approved on December 13, 2022.
04:33Hindi po siya compliant to the Joint Circular dahil yung first column which is the programs, activities and projects,
04:41hindi po in-indicate ni OVP yung kanilang specific confidential activities na kanilang paggagamitan ng confidential fund
04:50as required under item 4.2 of the Joint Circular.
04:55Isa rin sa binanggit niya ang 125 million pesos ng Office of the Vice President para sa huling quarter ng
05:012022 na ginasos sa loob ng labing isang araw.
05:05Bakit mo napansin itong period na ito?
05:08Napansin ko lang naman po yun kasi yung kanilang cash advance based on the physical and financial plan po
05:14supposedly is for the whole fourth quarter of 2022.
05:18Pero based on this document po, na-disperse lang siya from December 21 to 31, 2022 or around 11 days.
05:27May mga dokumentong pirmado ng vice gaya ng physical and financial plan at accomplishment reports.
05:32Kaninong signature itong nakikita natin dito?
05:37Ito po ay signature ni Vice Presidente Sara Duterte.
05:40At anong ibig sabihin under your circular law ng attested?
05:49Ang ibig sabihin po ng attested ay kanyang kinoconfirm at biniverify na yung contents ng certification na ito ay totoo.
05:56Para sa prosecution, ebidensya ito laban sa vice-presidente.
06:00Under the direct supervision of the signatory, the signatory is the Vice President Duterte herself.
06:06It's clear that the Vice President had a direct hand on this.
06:11She signed it off, no?
06:13Not just the use, but the way that it was liquidated.
06:16Pero hindi sang-ayon dito ang depensa.
06:18Yung mga dokumento na yan ay kinilangan dumaan sa isang proseso, dumaan sa approval.
06:24As to the malfeasance, that's for them to prove, no?
06:27At sa atin, that's for us to also disprove.
06:29So, we will find out in the coming days.
06:32But again, as you, as, in fact, as the COA representative said earlier,
06:37their audits is limited to just compliance with the joint circular.
06:40Nothing further than that.
06:42Matapos makita mga paglabag,
06:44nagsumite na raw ang OVP ng revised accomplishment report.
06:47Pero may nakita pa rin ilang gastos na hindi pinahintulutan.
06:50I'm based on this document po, some of the line items as presented po na confidential expenses
06:57ay hindi among the allowable expenses under item 4.8 of the joint circular.
07:03Yung provision of medical input aid for the 440 million pesos
07:07at yung payment of incentives or traveling relative to confidential operations na 10 million pesos.
07:13Nakita rin ng COA na ginamit ang confidential fund pambili ng lamesa, upuan, computer,
07:19pero wala raw resibo kundi acknowledgement receipt lamang.
07:22May napansin din siya sa petsa ng ilan sa mga ito.
07:25Napansin ko na some of the payments were dated December 2023,
07:30which is beyond the scope po nung covered ng kanilang cash advances.
07:35And yun nga po, katulad nung nasabi ko kanina,
07:38may mga payment of rewards po sila,
07:40either in cash, in medicines, and in various goods,
07:43pero wala na po silang sinamit na any document na support or evidence,
07:49document evidencing the success of the information gathering activity
07:52on account of the information given by the informer.
07:56Ayon sa defense team ng BICE,
07:58walang pasabog ang prosecution sa impeachment trial kanina.
08:01Wala naman po, dahil sa aming pananaw,
08:04yan naman na ang lumabas sa COA findings,
08:08pina-identify lang naman sa COA kung ano yung kanilang naging findings.
08:12So kumbaga, nothing that we haven't read before,
08:15I think ang hindi lang nasasagot ng COA pa sa ngayon is
08:20ano yung nangyari after ng mga findings sila.
08:23Pero giit ng prosecution,
08:24malinaw nilang na ipakita na winaldas ng BICE
08:27ang confidential funds ng kanyang opisina.
08:30Dahil madali ang ginastos,
08:32hindi tugma-tugma yung dates
08:33at hindi tama yung kanilang binigay ng mga documentary evidence.
08:38Klaro, nung binigay po sa kanya itong pera na ito,
08:42pinagkatiwanan ng taong bayan,
08:43hindi po siya, hindi po niya ginamit ng gusto at maayos.
08:47Taong bayan ang bum na budol eh.
08:49Ako si Joseph Morong, ang inyong saksi.