- 4 months ago
Category
🥇
SportsTranscript
00:00Aaron Schatz with us on the Wester Hotline.
00:02I like that you were on with Steve Bennett the other day, Aaron, and his podcast.
00:07Steve is a local guy, Sportscasters, I believe is the name of it,
00:10and hopefully you had a good experience.
00:13Yeah, I do him every year, man.
00:15I've been doing with him since early in the book days, like 15 years ago or something.
00:19Awesome. Good. Very good.
00:21What's new and exciting about this year's edition other than all new information?
00:27Mostly the all new information.
00:28It's, you know, the usual chapters on every team, all kinds of advanced stats,
00:34all kinds of write-ups, analysis of what teams are going to do this year.
00:38The big change this year is we ranked nickelbacks separately from outside cornerbacks
00:43because there's all these players now who are called safeties,
00:47but they're really nickel corners, and then other guys are cornerbacks,
00:50but they're really different nickel corners.
00:52So we sort of combined all those guys into one category and looked at things that way,
00:57which we think is a more accurate way to look at it.
01:00The Bills had a good one for a long time in Taron Johnson,
01:03who has since been traded to the Raiders.
01:05I mean, maybe it was time.
01:08It's interesting about the Bills' defense,
01:10and we really haven't spent a ton of time on this because, you know,
01:13gone is gone, I guess maybe.
01:15But they have maybe a half-dozen defensive veterans who, like, just did not sign anywhere.
01:21Maybe it's not that many anymore.
01:23But Milano and Trey White and Bosa.
01:25And Taron Johnson was going to be released before they made a deal with the Raiders
01:29for, like, a seventh-round pick or something just after that.
01:32So, I mean, what about the Bills defensively for you, Aaron,
01:35as a, I guess, a team in transition?
01:39We like the Bills' defense to rebound a little bit this year.
01:42We think a couple of things.
01:44First of all, it's just general rebounding, right?
01:46They were a good defense until last year.
01:49They were really bad on third downs, really, really bad on third downs,
01:5430th in the league.
01:55So, it's much more likely that they play a lot closer to what they did on the first two downs,
02:00which is, like, 14th.
02:01And then they added some guys, right?
02:04Bradley Chubb, Gardner-Johnson, rookies like T.J. Parker.
02:09You know, it looks like they added some talent and didn't necessarily, like you said,
02:14the guys who are gone didn't really get signed by other teams.
02:18So, did they lose a lot?
02:20Not as much as we think that they added.
02:22So, we like the defense to rebound a bit.
02:24Yeah, you mentioned Chubb there, Aaron.
02:27When I get asked about this, you know, the new defense in general
02:31and maybe pass rush specifically is where I want to go here,
02:35I've thought that maybe the new scheme generates more pass rush overall for them,
02:40more aggressive, more blitzing, and maybe that gets them good results
02:44because I don't really think, even with Bradley Chubb here, that they have a guy.
02:51You know, like, the Bills have been searching for a guy since they signed Von Miller,
02:55or really even before that when they drafted Gregory Rousseau and Boogie Basham
02:59in the draft right after their first AFC title game lost to Kansas City
03:03and still haven't found it, but I wonder what you think of the idea
03:07that the scheme could just generate more pressure
03:09as opposed to just having some dude with his hair on fire.
03:12Here's the shock I'm going to give you.
03:14The Bills have been generating pressure for years.
03:18We have them fifth in pressure rate last year.
03:21Now, maybe they're doing it more through scheme, and now it's a different scheme,
03:25so maybe, you know, Leonard does it differently than McDermott did it,
03:30but, yeah, they have actually had reasonable pressure.
03:35They've been average on sacks and good on pressure rate
03:38despite the fact that they haven't had the guy.
03:43Is there a distinction between, for you, that's important for you,
03:47between pressures and sacks or hits, or, like, what's the most useful way of tracking this?
03:55Well, sacks are the best, right?
03:57I mean, you want to sack the quarterback, but in general,
04:00pressure will be more consistent from year to year than sacks will.
04:04You know, the times you almost get to the quarterback, don't quite get there.
04:08The next year, a couple of those will turn into sacks,
04:11or if you get the quarterback a lot more than you would think you would,
04:16then a couple of years, you know, the next year, a couple of them will just barely miss it.
04:20So pressure is usually a better way to predict the future than just raw sacks.
04:25Mm-hmm.
04:26Thirty-six sacks, I think it was, last year for the Bills' defense.
04:30I'm not sure where that would have ranked them,
04:31but maybe, like you're saying, it was better than we thought.
04:35Not middle of the pack.
04:36Middle of the pack, okay.
04:38While we're on defense, Aaron, how about the secondary?
04:43You mentioned, I don't know, did you mention Gardner-Johnson?
04:46You did.
04:46Yeah, you did.
04:47Okay, thank you.
04:47I just wanted to make sure I didn't, you know, have that wrong.
04:51Cole Bishop seemed to be coming last year.
04:54We'll see maybe as soon as this year what his ceiling is.
04:57But they're a long way from Micah Hyde and Jordan Poyer holding down the back end.
05:04But it feels like maybe with Gardner-Johnson here paired with, again,
05:08sort of maybe a breaking-through candidate in Cole Bishop,
05:11that they're back on track to having a safety tandem that can really be counted on.
05:17Yeah, I will say people in Cincinnati are not high on Geno Stone.
05:21They were happy to see him gone, so you probably don't want him to be playing a lot.
05:27But, you know, I mean, I'm still a big Benford fan.
05:31I still think he's one of the top corners in the league.
05:33Now, it's interesting, he's more of a zone corner,
05:36and I don't know if they want to play more man with Leonard as the defensive coordinator,
05:41so that might be interesting.
05:43But, you know, at safety, yeah, they need Bishop.
05:50You lose Aaron?
05:52Sounds like we did.
05:53Yeah.
05:53It happened just when I hit a button, and so it felt like maybe I did something.
05:58Yeah, it probably wasn't it, but I hate when that happens.
06:01Yeah, yeah.
06:02I guess, you know, something coincides with you having, you know, hit a button.
06:09Yeah.
06:10Aaron's back.
06:11All right, Aaron.
06:12Hi, I'm here.
06:12Hello.
06:13We lost you for a second there.
06:14You were talking about the safety tandem.
06:17Yeah, I was saying, you know, if Bishop can take a step forward
06:20and C.J. Gardner-Johnson doesn't tick off his teammates,
06:23then they'll be in reasonable shape.
06:25I have a question about defensive back play, but it isn't about the Bills.
06:29How statistically improbable is it to go an entire 17-game season
06:34without a single interception as a team like the Jets did?
06:37Absurd.
06:38Okay.
06:38Absurd.
06:39In general, 20% of your passes defensed will turn into interceptions.
06:46It's not completely random the way fumble recovery is, right?
06:50There is such a thing as ball skills.
06:52Some guys just, you know, do have ball skills, pick off more passes.
06:56But, in general, we would have expected the Jets last year to pick off
07:00between 10 and 12 passes, and instead they ended up with zero.
07:04It is ridiculously absurd.
07:07Well, what they need is a coach who played DB.
07:11That's what they need to figure out.
07:13Yeah.
07:13Get somebody who knows how to do this in there.
07:16If only they could find one of those.
07:18I know.
07:18Right.
07:19Aaron Glenn.
07:20All right.
07:20So, when you think about, from your analysis, Aaron, the Bills overall,
07:25is there anything – I mean, we've talked about a particular stat already
07:29in pressures, and maybe there was a misconception about that.
07:31What else, if there is anything else, might people, to your ears,
07:36tend to maybe get a little bit wrong about the Bills?
07:40I think people outside of Buffalo don't understand how good their offensive line
07:45has been and how good the running game has been
07:48and how important that's been to the offense.
07:49The people who are listening to my voice right now understand that,
07:53but the people who are not watching the Bills all the time,
07:57I think nationally that's not necessarily as well known.
08:00I don't think people realize how good Dawkins is, for example.
08:06Yeah, and they've also been very healthy.
08:09Right.
08:10Last year, I know, as we went to training camp,
08:12our Sal Capaccio would come on and point out that not only –
08:15not just healthy, but consistency over years.
08:19Not only do they have all their starters back, but they even have all their backups back
08:23going into last season.
08:25This year, they lost David Edwards and maybe a backup or two as well
08:28that I'm not thinking of right now.
08:30But they've – go ahead.
08:32We track this thing called adjusted games lost.
08:35The Bills have been a top three team in lowest adjusted games lost on offense
08:41for five straight years.
08:43Wow.
08:44But they were 29th on defense.
08:46So they lost a ton of games to injuries on defense last year, but like none on offense.
08:52And that showed.
08:53I mean –
08:54Yeah, for sure.
08:55It certainly was a talking point later on in the season that that happened.
08:59Would you anticipate, Aaron, that the offensive line continues to be a strength,
09:03even though there's going to be a new left guard?
09:05Mike mentions Edwards leaving, Alec Anderson, veteran Austin Corbett.
09:09These are people who are expected to compete for that job.
09:14But the rest is still all the same.
09:16Yeah, I don't think those guys are considered to be as good as Edwards.
09:22But in general, I think, you know, offensive line continuity is important.
09:26But changing one guy is not a huge big deal.
09:29What you don't want to do is change like four guys at a time.
09:31And nobody's worked together before.
09:34But like you said, the rest of them have worked together before,
09:37and I don't see any reason to see the rest of them decline, you know,
09:41based on – you know, compared to last year.
09:43Are you putting a win total on this team, Aaron, or all teams?
09:48We do a projected mean wins.
09:50You know, we project the season, whatever, 50,000 times.
09:54And the average number of wins that we come out with –
09:56because, you know, everything when you project the NFL,
09:58it's the hardest sport to predict.
10:00So it's always, you know, a range of possibilities.
10:03But we end up with the Bills at 10.0 wins, which is near the top of the league.
10:08I think it might be second in the AFC behind Houston.
10:12So we definitely like them this year.
10:14I mean, it helps that they're not going to be competing against a team
10:17with, like, the easiest schedule in 30 years.
10:22You know, that'll make things a little bit better for them.
10:26Interesting how, I think, the Bills and Patriots schedules broke down this year.
10:31I mean, the Bills' schedule looks pretty beastly.
10:34You have the Dolphins and the Jets.
10:36That's four-year games.
10:37They go to Vegas once.
10:38The other 12 are kind of all, like – I mean, what's the next softest game on their schedule?
10:43At Minnesota?
10:44Maybe some game like that on Monday night.
10:46But the Bills get Houston, Baltimore, and the Rams.
10:51And the Patriots get Jacksonville, Pittsburgh, and Seattle, which I'm not sure that's a lot different.
10:59I mean, Pittsburgh winning the AFC North there is, I guess, a break on paper, anyway, to the Patriots.
11:05That's their opener, I think.
11:06Or, no, Seattle's their opener.
11:08Seattle is their opener.
11:09That's right.
11:09Yeah, based on our projections, there's definitely a difference between Pittsburgh and Baltimore.
11:14But otherwise, there's not much of a difference between those schedules.
11:18And we end up with the Bills with the No. 11 projected schedule and the Patriots 14th.
11:24Yeah, the schedules aren't as hard as you think they are because they have all those games with the Jets
11:29and Dolphins on them.
11:3011th easiest or 11th hardest?
11:3311th hardest.
11:34Okay.
11:36So what do you see from New England here?
11:38We've talked about this with three of us maybe a couple of months ago.
11:41But consensus, whether that's by the betting numbers or just other conversations we've had, thinking of Sam Monson last week
11:49and other experts who come on, kind of give New England, like, you know, it's maybe not a coin flip,
11:54but like last year, for the most part, really close to the Bills.
11:59Yeah, we have them really close, too.
12:01We have the Bills at 10.0 and the Patriots at 9.6.
12:05So I think the Patriots are going to be a better team that looks worse because of the schedule change.
12:14On offense, they'll probably regress a little bit just because they were so good last year.
12:18Drake May was so good last year.
12:19But I think their defense will improve.
12:22There's reasons to believe, you know, that they've added some more defensive guys and that, you know, they should –
12:27the way that they were blitzing last year, it's the second year with the same defensive coordinator.
12:32Usually you take a little bit of a step forward your second year with the system.
12:36So we like their defense to be better and their offense a little worse.
12:40The whole team probably slightly better, but it'll look worse.
12:43And, yeah, those two teams are pretty neck and neck in a division that's really just two teams.
12:49How – sorry.
12:51You can see a, like, 1 in 200 chance where Geno Smith gets his groove back and the Jets have
12:58added a bunch of reasonable veterans on defense and suddenly they go, like, 9 in 8.
13:02But that's about the highest.
13:04It's like a 1 in 200 chance.
13:05And family members and I, a few weeks ago, got together and pooled some money and built 10, 8 division
13:14winner parlays, right?
13:16So you just have to – all 8.
13:18And I was with my nephew yesterday or Saturday and we were talking about this and ran through a few
13:24of them.
13:25And I remember the conversation because, you know, we did a few that were pretty chalky and then, you know,
13:31people are drinking and, hey, let's get the Titans in there.
13:34Let's get – and we had one where we wanted to decide the Jets or the Dolphins.
13:39And the group said the Dolphins.
13:41I have a tougher time, maybe a much tougher time seeing Miami.
13:44Me too.
13:44Shock the world, so to speak, than the Jets.
13:47It just feels like the Jets are trying more because they went out and signed all these reasonable veterans on
13:55defense and because there's no way they're going to have that few takeaways again.
14:00So their defense should be respectable.
14:04So, like, I mean, there is a chance that Geno Smith gets his groove back.
14:08It's just really unlikely because of his age.
14:11So, yeah, I would choose the Jets if I had to choose between those two.
14:15But it's fairly likely that those are two of the five or six worst teams in the league.
14:18Yeah.
14:19I want to skip right back to the Patriots just for a moment and just ask you about A.J.
14:23Brown and what kind of impact you anticipate him having with New England, Aaron.
14:29Yeah, he's really good still.
14:31I think everybody feels like he's really good still.
14:33But if his numbers dropped a little bit, it was because of the problems they had with the offense in
14:37Philadelphia.
14:38He still scores tremendously high in ESPN's receiver metrics that are based on the next-gen tracking.
14:45He gets open on all kinds of routes, inside, outside, deep, doesn't matter.
14:51He catches the ball well, yards after the kids.
14:54That's basically everything.
14:56I know there's a little bit of worry about his knee, but the team doesn't seem to be too worried
15:01about it.
15:01So it's a really – it's a great addition.
15:04Between that and Romeo Dobbs, fantastic additions to their offense.
15:08And then don't sleep on Elijah Vera Tucker, the new guard that they got from the Jets.
15:15He's fairly well-regarded, except he just can't stay healthy.
15:18But if he can stay healthy, that's a nice upgrade for their offensive line.
15:22Aaron, whether or not this is mostly a statistics-based answer or not,
15:27just curious for your perspective on the AFC quarterback landscape now,
15:34where we've, for a few years, had the relatively short conversation.
15:39Allen, Jackson, Mahomes, Burrow, all right.
15:41And now you have a landscape where there are at least that many names, you know,
15:46twice as many as guys like that, that you mentioned May already barely missed out on the MVP last year.
15:53How do you look at it?
15:54Allen is 30 now.
15:55They all have gotten a little bit older.
15:56Mahomes with the injury.
15:58Burrow's been hurt.
15:59Is it a turning point in this or not yet?
16:03We'll have to see what happens with Mahomes.
16:06You know, I have a feeling that he can't do some of the crazy Mahomes things,
16:09but I think he'll still play pretty well.
16:13You know, to me, it's only two guys in the AFC that are challenging those four.
16:18One is Herbert, and I'm not as down on Herbert as some of my writers are,
16:22but you do kind of want to see him finally do it.
16:25And I know people feel like with Mike McDaniel as his offensive coordinator,
16:29he's going to finally have a great season.
16:30But, like, let's see it before we crown the guy.
16:33And then with May, you know, it's going to be harder on him this year.
16:36There's no question about it.
16:37There'll be a little bit of regression otherwise.
16:40But, you know, if he has another year where he's a top six or seven quarterback,
16:44then he absolutely breaks into the discussion.
16:46Yeah.
16:47Speaking of quarterbacks who need to break through, I know,
16:50and you've already referenced Houston being, you know,
16:53having a higher total than the Bills.
16:55And I know from talking to you a few months ago that your numbers really like the Texans.
17:00How about Stroud within all of that?
17:03Because it seems like he took on a lot of water late last year.
17:07Yes, in the playoffs.
17:09But in the regular season, CJ Stroud was 11th in passing DPOA.
17:14I know that's crazy, right?
17:16It sounds nuts.
17:17The team staff got dragged down a little bit by the Davis Mills,
17:21even though Davis Mills won those games.
17:24But Stroud was actually reasonably good during the regular season
17:28and horrible, horrible in the playoffs.
17:31But, you know, I believe in general, professional athletes, psychology,
17:36these guys have a lot of confidence.
17:38And I just can't see Stroud going out there this year and going,
17:42well, I stuck in the playoffs, so my career's over.
17:44I guess I'm going to be terrible from now on.
17:46Like, he's going to go out there and be like, I was good in the regular season.
17:49I will now prove everybody wrong.
17:51And he's got a running game now and a little bit of a better offensive line.
17:56And I think that their offense is actually going to be above average this year.
18:00Looking or thinking about the betting markets,
18:03the Rams are like the clear-cut Super Bowl favorite now.
18:07Last I looked, it was plus 550,
18:09and then the Bills and another team or two were second, like plus 1,000.
18:13So a pretty good gap there for a team that did not even make the Super Bowl
18:17as good as they were last year.
18:19Do you think it's warranted, Aaron?
18:21Our numbers still have Seattle slightly ahead.
18:26I would put the Rams slightly ahead myself, but not that much ahead.
18:31I still think Seattle is going to be really good again.
18:34Now, if the Rams sign Aaron Donald again, you know, if he comes out of retirement,
18:39I mean, they are clear, super favorites.
18:43But, I mean, I agree with them being favorites,
18:46but I guess I would just put other teams, Seattle and Houston,
18:49I'd put a little closer to them.
18:51Who's your favorite long shot?
18:53Somebody in a division that is not being talked about.
18:58Golly.
18:59You know,
19:03I guess I feel like people don't realize how good Indianapolis was in the first
19:09half of the season,
19:09and I don't know what's going to happen with Daniel Jones and his ankle,
19:13and I don't know if their whole offense is going to fall apart.
19:16But they were fifth in DVOA for the whole season,
19:20even after losing Jones for four or five games.
19:23I don't remember exactly how many games it was.
19:25Like, they are a competitor.
19:29The problem with the AFC is that the bad teams are so bad
19:34that there's like 10 teams that are good enough to make the playoffs,
19:38and only seven of them make the playoffs.
19:41The thing about the NFL this year is there are like 20 above-average teams,
19:47not 16.
19:48It's just the bad teams are so bad that they drag the average down.
19:53Arizona's at the top of that list, right?
19:55I mean, they're an underdog in every game on the preseason lines.
19:58I think Arizona's a little bit better than people realize.
20:01I think they're more like the 28th best team in the league,
20:04not the 32nd best team.
20:05I realize that's damning with faint praise,
20:07but for people who like to put money on these things,
20:10some books have them on an over-under of 3.5 wins.
20:15I know they went 3-14 last year,
20:17but they were the most injured team in the league.
20:203.5 is really, really low.
20:23Really low.
20:25And even if they lose all their division games,
20:27all they have to do is win 4 out of 11 of their other games,
20:30and they beat that.
20:32I can't bring myself to draft the rookie, Love.
20:35Just thinking about, same with Achan, kind of.
20:38It's a little bit risky because they both might.
20:41I mean, Achan's been great.
20:42Yeah, I have Aston Janty on the phone,
20:44and he agrees with you about that.
20:46Right.
20:46Like, just if he's going to get hit behind the line of scrimmage
20:49on two out of three plays, what am I going to get out of Jeremiah Love?
20:53Yeah, I mean, I think that their offensive line is better than what Vegas
21:01had last year.
21:02But if you're the opponent, you're putting eight guys in the box,
21:06like constantly, not worried that Brissette is going to burn you,
21:10and it's going to be tough sledding for him.
21:13He'll put up the numbers just because he'll get up so many carries.
21:17But I think at the end of the year, we're going to say,
21:19oh, that was a disappointing season.
21:21Yeah.
21:21Aaron, before you go, I wanted to ask you about the Bengals
21:23because you've been on my mind when I make a certain point about them,
21:28how it's been very easy and correct to say that their defense
21:33is really holding them back.
21:34There's only so much Burrow, Chase, and Higgins in that offense can do.
21:39How do you feel about them going into the season on that side of the ball?
21:43I remember from maybe even the first conversations I recall ever having
21:47with you years ago about how volatile defense can be.
21:51More so, if you're excellent, it doesn't mean you're going to be excellent
21:54year over year.
21:55But wouldn't the same maybe apply to if it's been bad?
21:59How about the Bengals?
22:01Yeah, absolutely apply.
22:03If you look in the almanac, which is the book that we put out,
22:07the preseason book, which is out now, if you look at it,
22:10you'll notice that the range of possible defensive values is smaller
22:14than the range of possible offensive values because the average
22:19of the possibilities is going to be closer to average
22:22because it's harder to predict defense.
22:25And so, like, we don't think Cincinnati is going to have a good defense,
22:29but it's probable that they're going to have a better defense than they did
22:33certainly in the first half of last year.
22:36And their offense should be very, very good.
22:39They have Burrow for all 17 games, and they have the easiest projected
22:43schedule in the league right now.
22:46Yeah, favored in 15 out of 17, I think the number is.
22:49Aaron Schatz with us.
22:50FTN Fantasy, the almanac that you just mentioned again, is out.
22:54What's the best way for you to have our listeners buy it?
22:58Yeah, ftnfantasy.com slash almanac.
23:01And there is a sample chapter there, so if you want to see what the almanac
23:05is all about, you can read about the Indianapolis Colts
23:08and what we think about them.
23:10And, of course, there's also all the fantasy projections in there
23:13and the comments on all the skill position players.
23:16And you can also get it at Amazon.
23:18Just search for FTN Football Almanac 2026.
23:22Also, FTN Fantasy has a fun fantasy simulation game.
23:27Yes, we have the new fantasy simulator where you get to pick a fantasy team.
23:32It gives you teams to pick, and then you have to pick the players
23:35to try to have a perfect fantasy season.
23:37I went out in the first round of the playoffs.
23:40I got stuck with Travis Kelsey.
23:42That's why you play it 20 times.
23:45It could be worse.
23:50There are worse tight ends to own.
23:52Oh, yeah.
23:52No, but when you get down to that last slot, you've got to nail it, maybe.
23:56All right, congratulations on another year with the almanac, Aaron,
24:00and thanks, as always, for your time today.
24:02Hey, thanks for having me on, guys, and I hope people will check out the book.
24:05Very good.
24:06Aaron Schatz, A-Schatz, that's S-C-H-A-T-Z, NFL, on Twitter.
24:15Z, Zed, another way to say it, Zed.
24:17Sure.
24:19Sal, coming up at 5, the Bills' new alternate uniform and helmet.
24:23The big story today.
24:24Lines open for your reaction, 803-0550.