00:00Sa tatlong araw pa lang na itinatagal ng impeachment trial ni Vice President Sara Duterte,
00:05e marami-rami na ang katanungan ng mga Pinoy.
00:09Siguro dahil hindi pamilyar ang proseso sa pang-araw-araw na buhay ng ordinaryong mamamayan,
00:15maaring bago rin sa pandinig ang mga salitang objection o kaya naman ay sustained o kaya ay overruled
00:24para tulungan tayong maintindihan at masundan ang paglilitis.
00:28Kinuha namin ng tulong na isang eksperto at tinutukan yan, ni Mark Salazar.
00:38Ang daming tanong sa amin online tungkol sa impeachment trial.
00:42Halimbawa ito,
00:43Why is the Senate President not serving as the presiding officer during the impeachment trial?
00:49What is the role of the Senate President seated beside the presiding officer?
00:54Bakit nga ba dalawa silang nandun?
01:01Ito pa isang tanong ha, bakit daw pagkabagal-bagal ng proseso,
01:06nakaka-isang testigo pa lang ang korte hanggang ngayon?
01:19O,
01:21dinala ko na kayo mismo dito sa
01:22UP College of Law,
01:24UP Diliman,
01:26sa Malcolm Hall.
01:27Huwag kayong mag-alala,
01:29ipapalamanize natin sa mga eksperto yung mga tanong nyo.
01:38Prof,
01:39ang isa pong tanong nila,
01:41bakit ito pagkabagal-bagal,
01:42and one main reason is,
01:44object daw ng object,
01:46pareho naman yung prosecution at depensa.
01:49Objection, Your Honor.
01:50Wow.
01:51Objection.
01:52Objection.
01:52Objection.
01:53Objection.
01:53Objection.
01:56Yung proseso ng objection,
01:58or yung objection,
01:59ginagamit yan upang pigilin yung pagsagot
02:02ng isang tanong na lumalabag
02:04doon sa ating patakaran.
02:06Nagpapatagal talaga siya kahit pa paano sa proseso,
02:09pero dinidisenyohan kasi yun
02:11para maiwasan yung pagpasok ng mga problematic na sagot,
02:14o yung mga sagot na baka hindi nagpopromote
02:17ng katotohanan.
02:18Tapos, in between,
02:21magpapasok ang presiding officer
02:23sa sabihin niya,
02:25sustained,
02:26o overruled.
02:27Ano po yung dalawang yun?
02:29Overruled.
02:30Sustained.
02:31Overruled.
02:32Overruled.
02:33Yung sustained,
02:34ibig sabihin nun,
02:35pumapanig yung presiding officer sa objection.
02:37Pag overruled naman,
02:39ibig sabihin nun,
02:40hindi tama,
02:41or hindi wasto yung objection na nirace.
02:45Tapos, ano naman po itong
02:46direct examination,
02:48cross examination,
02:50muntik pong magkaroon ng redirect,
02:53at saka recross,
02:54o pakahaba daw,
02:56iisang testigo na pakadaming tanong.
02:58Hindi natin hinahayaan yung testigo
03:00na parang umupo na lang doon at magkwento,
03:02bako saan-saan pumuntay yung kwento,
03:04at hindi na titest yung katotohanan.
03:07So, yung direct examination,
03:09yun yung pagtatanong ng
03:10usually open-ended questions
03:12ng partido or panig
03:15na naghain ng witness.
03:17Pagdating naman sa
03:18cross examination,
03:20yung purpose nun ay
03:21para butasin
03:23yung kabilang panig,
03:24yung testimonya
03:25ng testigo.
03:27Susunod naman yung redirect.
03:29Para linisin yung ibang bagay
03:31na maharahil misleading
03:32galing doon sa cross examination.
03:35Tapos, mayroon na naman pagkakataon
03:37na butasin yung testimonya
03:38doon sa redirect,
03:40sa recross examination.
03:41At doon na nagtatapos yung
03:42pagtatanong ng mga abogado
03:44sa bawat testigo.
03:46Balikan natin ang tanong
03:47ng ilang netizens
03:48kung bakit dalawa silang
03:50nasa taas ng korte,
03:51si na-presiding officer
03:52Chief Escudero
03:53at Senate President
03:54Sherwin Gatchalian.
03:59Noong panahon ni President Estrada,
04:02nung siya yung ini-impeach,
04:03si Senator Aquilino Pimentel
04:05ay pangulo ng Senado
04:06at naroon din siya sa taas,
04:08kasama si Chief Justice
04:09Hilario Davide,
04:10na siya namang
04:11presiding officer
04:12noong trial.
04:13So, hindi ito makabago
04:13sa ating sistema.
04:15Pero, sino ang
04:16mas main character?
04:18Ang main character
04:19ay ang Senado mismo.
04:20So, yung pananatili
04:22ng presiding officer doon
04:23ay batay lamang
04:25sa rules ng Senado
04:26ngayon
04:26kung saan mayroon silang
04:28kapangyarihan
04:29na maghalal
04:29ng presiding officer.
04:30Ibig sabihin nun,
04:31pwede rin nila tanggalin
04:32yung presiding officer.
04:34Definition of terms
04:35naman tayo
04:36with Professor
04:37Paolo Tamase.
04:38Ano yung naririnig
04:39ho natin sa objection
04:40na leading question,
04:42Your Honors, please?
04:44Objection, leading.
04:45Yung leading questions
04:47ay mga tanong
04:48na parang
04:48sinasuggest na
04:50o minumungkahi na
04:51yung gusto marinig
04:52na sagot.
04:53Ano naman yung
04:54speculative,
04:55Your Honors, please?
04:57Speculative,
04:58ibig sabihin nun
04:59ay
05:00parang hypothetical
05:02yung sagot
05:03o parang
05:03masyadong madaming
05:04kuro-kuro
05:05yung sagot.
05:06Ito yung mga
05:06sagot na kailangan
05:07na parang humuhula
05:08lamang yung testigo.
05:11E yung
05:11argumentative,
05:13Your Honor.
05:14Yung argumentative
05:15naman na
05:15questioning,
05:16parang
05:16nahikipag-away na
05:18yung abogado
05:19sa testigo.
05:20Masyado niyang
05:20pinipilit yung testigo
05:22o naiipit yung testigo.
05:25Sa gitna rin
05:25ng trial,
05:26nagbiruan pa
05:27ang kapwa-abogadong
05:28sina Senator
05:29Judge Alan Cayetano
05:31at presiding officer
05:32Escudero
05:33tungkol sa marking
05:34of evidence
05:35na FFFF,
05:36GGGGG.
05:37Ano ba yun?
05:38F F F F F F F F F F F F
05:42dash G G G G G G G G G G G G
05:46That's F F F F F F F F F F
05:48to G G G G G G G G G G G G.
05:49Yes.
05:51Yung exhibit numbers
05:53kasi sa korte,
05:54kadalasan,
05:55kapag ikaw yung prosecution,
05:58yung exhibit numbers mo
06:00ay letra.
06:01na series.
06:02A, B, C, D, E.
06:03Pero syempre,
06:04pag naubos na yung 26 letters
06:06ng alphabet,
06:07dodoble yun.
06:08A, A, B, B, C, C.
06:10So, yung F F F F F F,
06:12yung siyam na F,
06:12ibig sabihin,
06:13nine times na naubos
06:14yung 26 na letra.
06:16Ganon kadami yung ebidensya.
06:18Mas madali sa depensa
06:19kasi sa depensa,
06:20ang normal na pagbibilang
06:22ay batay sa numero.
06:23So, exhibit 1, 2, 3, etc.
06:26So,
06:27kung ganyan pala
06:28ka voluminous
06:29ang evidence,
06:30voluminous,
06:32malaburaw ang 92 trial days
06:34sa kasong ito.
06:36Mark Salazar,
06:37nakatutok 24 oras.
06:41Naubos na B, C, D, E, T, E, T, E, T, E, T, E, T.
Comments