00:07Transcription by CastingWords
00:30May kinausap na ako na tao, sinabi ko sa kanya, kapag pinatay ako, patayin mo si BBM, si Lisa Araneta
00:39at si Martin Romales. No joke. No joke.
00:44Ang umanoy pagbabanta kay Pangulong Bongbong Marcos sa video ito, pinalabas sa ikalawang araw ng impeachment trial ni Vice President
00:52Sara Duterte.
00:53Nag-dealing na ako, ma'am. Pag namatay ako, sabi ko, huwag ka tumigila hanggang hindi mo magpatay sila. And
01:04then he said yes.
01:04Kuha yan sa online press conference ng Vice noong November 2024 at siyang ugat ng Article 4 sa Articles of
01:13Impeachment na Grave Threats and Destabilization.
01:15Pero bago maipalabas yan, ilang beses nagtalo ang prosecution at depensa nang maupo sa witness stand ang pinakaunang witness ng
01:26prosecution team, si John Mark Calilong, senior agent ng National Bureau of Investigation.
01:32Humiling ang depensa na i-exclude si Calilong bilang witness dahil wala raw siya sa mga impeachment complaint pa lang
01:39noon.
01:40Being not previously attached to the Ceballa and Cabrera complaints, as well as exclusion on the ground that he was
01:51not included in the articles of impeachment transmitted to the Senate Impeachment Court.
01:57Pero pinayagan ng impeachment court ang pagbibigay kastimonya ni Calilong.
02:02Ayon kay Calilong, siya ang kumuha ng kopya at nag-authenticate sa ipinalabas na video.
02:08Ang gusto ng prosecution, i-play ang maiksing bahagi lang ng mahigit dalawang oras na video.
02:14Pero tumutol ang depensa sabay-saming dapat ipalabas ang buong video para nasa tamang konteksto ito.
02:20Exactly, the video is 2 hours and 26 minutes and 10 seconds.
02:26We will not be showing the entire 2-hour video, Your Honor, please.
02:30We will be presenting the relevant portions of the video.
02:36It's 2 minutes and exactly 18 seconds, Your Honor, please.
02:40We object.
02:41We request that the entire video be played.
02:44It is for the prosecution to decide what to present, when to present, how to present, and whether to present
02:54at all.
02:55Maging si Sen. Judge Alan Peter Cayetano Tumayo para sabihin gusto niyang mapanood ang mahigit dalawang oras na video.
03:03Sandaling nag-suspend ang impeachment court.
03:06Pagbalik, nag-desisyon si presiding officer Sen. Cheese Escudero.
03:10The secretariat is instructed to play the USB given to the tech behind that was observed and witnessed by both
03:21councils for the party.
03:23Sorted.
03:23Kindly played o gano'n.
03:25Pinanood din ang ilan pang pahayag ng bise sa press conference naman noong October 2024.
03:31Gusto ko, ang dali niyo, ulo niya ba?
03:39Cutting his head.
03:45Pero isang beses sinabihan ko talaga si Sen. Aini.
03:49Sabi ko sa kanya, kung hindi kayo tumigil, huukayin ko yang tatay ninyo.
03:55Itatapon ko siya sa West Philippine Sea.
03:58Sa mahigit apat na oras na itinakbo ng paglilitis, panay ang pag-oobject ng depensa.
04:04In what particular portion of the subject video did the respondent utter
04:17that she already contracted a person to kill the President,
04:32the First Lady, and the former Speaker of the House of Representatives?
04:39Are you done?
04:41Objection?
04:41Objection, Your Honor.
04:42Wow.
04:43Ano ba, ano ba exactly yung sinabi ng Vice President nung araw na yan, November 23, 2024?
04:56Objection, Your Honor.
04:57I'm not yet done.
04:59Well, Your Honor, the pauses of the prosecution are very confusing.
05:04Kindly let the counsel for the prosecutors finish his question before you object.
05:08State it again, counsel for the prosecutors.
05:09Pumagit na na ang presiding officer.
05:11What particular statements of the Vice President on that day did you investigate?
05:16Objection, Your Honor.
05:18Vig.
05:20Aano, please.
05:23Council for Respondent, a bit of patience. Let the counsel finish.
05:27Sa isang punto, lalo pang uminit ang tensyon.
05:31Kinwestiyon ng Depensa kung paano na-identify ni Calino ang isang dokumentong ipinresentang ebidensya
05:37gayong wala naman siyang hawak na kopya.
05:40How can he be identifying the document when he does not have that copy?
05:45Are you following a script?
05:46Oh, my goodness.
05:48Your Honor, please.
05:48I move that that statement by the defense that the witness is following a script be stricken out of record.
05:54For the record, Your Honor, the witness was perusing the document before he handed that to the defense.
06:01The comments of both counsels are simply noted. Kindly, if you're done with the document, counsel, kindly give it to
06:06the witness.
06:06Pati, Senator Judges, nila nagkatensyon din.
06:10Counsel, none of these statements are proof that the Vice President actually contracted an assassin or hired one.
06:19Why are these acts impeachable?
06:22Ang tanong na yan ni Sen. Judge Riza Otiveros, pinalaga ni Sen. Judge Pia Kayetano.
06:28I don't think this is fair, Mr. President. Admonish us. Call us out if yung question natin is also not
06:36proper at the proper time.
06:39I don't want to see this happen again.
06:40Chair would like to remind my colleagues, the question posed by Senator Judge Riza pertains to the final question of
06:51this entire impeachment proceedings already.
06:53Reminded our colleagues with respect to similar questions to be asked in the future.
07:00I will submit to any ruling or statement of the presiding officer.
07:06But for clarity, Mr. Presiding Officer, my question po had to do with how the evidence is material to the
07:14allegations in the Articles of Impeachment.
07:17I wanted to appreciate the evidence before me in light of the Articles of Impeachment.
07:22Mula ang pisa, nakita kung gaano kahitpit ang pagbabantay ng prosecution at dipensa sa isa't isa.
07:29Sa pamamaril sa isang paaralan.
07:33Sorry, excuse me.
07:34Your Honor, may I be allowed to finish my manifestation?
07:36This is no disrespect.
07:38Council for respondents recognized.
07:40Thank you, Your Honor.
07:41Your Honor, this is improper.
07:42The improper for trial.
07:45Manifestation, this is not a manifestation proper for court procedure.
07:48This is instead them telling a story.
07:51This is a narration by the prosecution, which is not allowed.
07:55This is not allowed by any rule in any court.
07:57So, what is proper is that they present their first witnesses.
08:03Matapos magsalita ni Congressman Lawrence Defensor, humirit ang depensa.
08:08We move to strike that opening statement.
08:12Chair would like to inform and instruct the senator judges that the statement and manifestation made by the Honorable Defensor
08:19should not in any way be taken as evidentiary because it was merely a manifestation cum introduction.
08:26Motion is denied.
08:27Ito ang unang balita.
08:29Sandra Aguinaldo, GMA News.
Comments