• 5 months ago
There is a growing and controversial practice of introducing rap lyrics and other creative works as evidence in criminal trials across the United States. Panelists will explore how this trend disproportionately impacts Black and Brown artists and hip-hop performers. This dynamic raises urgent questions about racial bias in the justice system and the erosion of First Amendment protections for artistic expression. The discussion will also consider the opposing viewpoint that creative works may, under certain circumstances, constitute legitimate and relevant evidence in a court of law. Drawing on legal, cultural, and social perspectives, panelists will explore solutions that safeguard artistic creativity and free expression while upholding the integrity of the criminal justice system.
Transcript
00:01It is time to begin our final day of programming on the GBev stage.
00:06There is a growing and controversial practice of introducing rap lyrics and other creative works as evidence in criminal trials
00:15across the United States.
00:16Our panelists will explore how this trend disproportionately impacts black and brown artists and hip-hop performers.
00:25Joining us on the Global Black Economic Forum stage, nationally syndicated radio host heard on 90 stations across America and
00:36in New Orleans on KMEZ 102.9, Didi Maguire.
00:43Good morning, good morning, good morning, everyone.
00:45She is the CEO of Culture Holdings, Ty Basin, and music artist Bash for the World.
00:55Well, welcome, welcome, welcome, everybody.
00:57Let's talk about this.
00:58You know, when you think about it, throughout history, right, artists have used music to tell stories, express emotions, challenge
01:06power structures, and reflect the realities of their communities.
01:11Yet in recent years, think about this, courts across the United States have increasingly seen prosecutors introduce rap lyrics and
01:19other creative works as evidence in criminal trials, right?
01:22Critics argue that this practice disproportionately impacts black and brown artists, particularly hip-hop performers, and may undermine fundamental First
01:33Amendment protections.
01:35Supporters contend that creative works can sometimes be relevant evidence under certain circumstances.
01:40Today, we're going to explore all of that, the legal, cultural, and social implications of putting lyrics on trial.
01:47Here is one thing I need to ask the both of you.
01:50In one minute, in one minute, what concerns you most about the use of lyrics and criminal proceedings?
01:58Well, the first thing that comes to my mind is that rappers are treated as if they're not doing art
02:05versus an actor that's playing a killer or a country singer that's, you know, singing about abuse, right?
02:15Like, where rap, black, and brown artists are not treated as if their work is art.
02:21It's almost like it's a confession.
02:24Okay, I love that.
02:25What do you have to say?
02:25What do you think about that?
02:27I think at what point do we draw the line to what is creativity and what is basically fiction or
02:34nonfiction?
02:34At what point are you allowed to be an artist and at what point is the criminal system basically charging
02:42you at for what lyric that you're saying or whatever the case may be?
02:46So let me ask you this, Bash.
02:47When you're writing, how much are your lyrics a lived experience versus storytelling or a character?
02:56So I think it's a very broad way that I go about when I write my music.
03:02Obviously, I speak on what's going on in my environment, what's going on with me, what might be going on
03:08to some of my peers, what might be going on just from what I've seen or what I've done myself.
03:14I think it's just a healthy balance.
03:17What about you, Ty?
03:18When you think about hip-hop and rap lyrics, right, specifically getting pulled into courtrooms, right, what are you thinking
03:27about that in terms of the lyrics and the genre?
03:29How do you feel about it being pulled in the courtroom?
03:31I think that it being pulled in the courtroom is unfair because with hip-hop, there have always been journalists
03:43of the struggle of growing up in the United States of America, right?
03:49So when you think about a T.I. or you think about a Jay-Z or a Bun B, you
03:57don't think about crime, right?
03:59You're listening to hear what their experience was growing up in their environment, things of that nature.
04:08Right.
04:08Okay, but here's another question.
04:10How often are you seeing this happen now?
04:12Do you feel that you're seeing lyrics being used in the courtroom more often than before?
04:17Absolutely.
04:18I think social media kind of boosted that really, really, really heavily.
04:23When you have, I had a family member who violated, got his probation violated, he was reciting rap lyrics on
04:32Twitter, and they thought that it was him pleading guilty to a charge.
04:38But he was reciting T.I. rap lyrics, and they used it to kind of violate his probation.
04:43Do y'all hear this, right?
04:44This is why we have to pay attention.
04:46When you're thinking about a young artist like Bash, right, Bash, do you have the fear of being misread, right?
04:54Here you are being an artist and a storyteller.
04:58And are you ever nervous when you're writing that there's the possibility that your lyrics are going to be used
05:03against you?
05:04I think in this type of time that we're living in, you definitely have to be a little bit more
05:09cautious.
05:09At least I am.
05:10I feel like I definitely have a lot of real experiences that I pull from, a lot of things that
05:15I've dealt with, my own self, or somebody that may still be connected, one foot in, one foot out around
05:22me.
05:22So I'm definitely a lot more cautious of what it is that I'm saying.
05:26And I mean, I'm an artist, so I'm going to always speak my truth.
05:30But I definitely feel like in this type of day that we're in, we got to be a little bit
05:33more smarter with what we're saying.
05:35But does it hamper you when it comes to wanting to release music?
05:41You know, if you're concerned about your lyrics and how somebody's going to take it, now you're kind of going
05:45to be hiding your art, right?
05:47And so do you ever feel like, I don't want to release this for the fear of the backlash?
05:51I think that's the catch-22 in it because just me being so realistic in everything that I'm experiencing and
05:58going through.
06:00For me personally, to answer your question, I'm going to always tell my truth.
06:04I'm going to always, no matter what, I accept what comes with whatever that I'm doing or whatever.
06:10So I'm going to always speak my truth, but I definitely try to have some more caution with certain things
06:15that I may be saying.
06:17Okay.
06:18Now let's talk about this part, Ty.
06:20When you're thinking about audiences and you're thinking about the juries, do they hold black artists,
06:26think about it, especially in hip-hop, to a different standard?
06:31I think if hip-hop was founded by white people, they wouldn't.
06:36But being that it's black young kids, they're just naturally viewed.
06:42And the truth of the matter is hip-hop was a way to get out of hardship from a hood
06:47perspective, right?
06:48So the individuals that was able to break through during that time frame, it's not like that today, but it
06:55still carries that.
06:56So the level of racism and disparity that you speak about just from data is the reality of the world
07:04that rappers live in.
07:05It doesn't matter what they're rapping about, how they're rapping about it.
07:08Some of these things that there are rappers who have rapped about crimes that they've done.
07:13But that's very small compared to how many rappers it is in the United States of America.
07:19Okay, which brings me to, think about it, the YSL situation that we saw in Atlanta.
07:24Give me your thoughts on that because we saw in a situation there where the lyrics of an artist were
07:30being held against him.
07:31What are your thoughts?
07:32I think that when it came to the YSL, you know, turning a rap group into a criminal organization based
07:43on lyrics and using the lyrics outside of, like, real actions.
07:48I think that lyrics being put into cases like that distracts the jury from where really the truth is and
07:56where really the judge should be paying attention to.
07:59And I don't think lyrics, when it has that many people involved, because everybody wasn't rapping necessarily the same way
08:07that the next person was rapping.
08:08But the lyrics can be blanketed when an individual is looking at it.
08:12They might not like rappers.
08:14They might not even like rap music.
08:15So when you put rap music lyrics in the front of a jury, that can kind of blind them from
08:22what they really should be paying attention to.
08:24What are the evidence?
08:25What are the facts?
08:26You know, what are the circumstances?
08:29All of these different aspects.
08:30So what you're saying is that you're saying that if there are a hip-hop artist and you're going to
08:35trial and they're using the lyrics, there's going to already be a bias in your mind because of somebody's attitude
08:41towards hip-hop, right?
08:42Absolutely.
08:43And because of what we're seeing in the press and on the news and everything else, it gives it a
08:49bad name almost.
08:50And so you have jurors who may not feel it.
08:53So let's put it in perspective of business.
08:55Right now, today, in 2026, if you want to do a hip-hop concert, it's hard for you to get
09:00insurance.
09:02Because of the stigma of the idea.
09:051,000%.
09:05What comes with it, so they think, right?
09:08So Bash, as an artist, right, an up-and-coming artist for you, when you think about this, right, you
09:14ever think to yourself, I'm writing something, but I can potentially be framed based on what I've written.
09:20Does that make you nervous?
09:221,000%.
09:231,000%.
09:24I feel like we already at a disadvantage, so adding even more stress, more eyes that's unwanted is going to
09:33bring more, I guess, quote-unquote, heat to yourself or your situation.
09:37So I definitely do feel a little bit more, maybe not fearful, but a little more worrisome about what I'm
09:45saying.
10:14Okay, because here's the thing, right?
10:15It was based not necessarily on her life, and it wasn't based on an admission.
10:19This was based on her, a love of a movie.
10:23But if you were to take that into court, right, and you have jurors who don't know and can't separate.
10:28So that's what I'm thinking about with you, Bash, as an artist.
10:31You're not always writing about your life.
10:34You're writing about a character.
10:36But this can be, again, used.
10:38So I'm thinking to myself, what distinguishes, again, expression from factual when it comes to artists?
10:48It's not, right?
10:49It's hard to separate.
10:50I just think that when we talk about crime, just do the investigation on the crime, right?
10:55It's no, like, when Bash is writing about a song because of something he saw in the news and that
11:04inspired him to create art, it is what it is.
11:08It was an inspiration of something that he experienced by looking at it, not because he went and actually did
11:14a crime.
11:15So how do you defend that, though?
11:17You know what I mean?
11:17Like, is that hard to defend in a courtroom for an attorney if he's got a hip-hop artist and
11:23he's representing them?
11:24You know what I mean?
11:25Is it hard?
11:26You know what I'm saying?
11:26You're about to get Brian Steele.
11:29I mean, but, like, you get what I'm saying.
11:32It's difficult.
11:33It's different, and it's difficult.
11:35Do you do a lot of cases like that?
11:36Do you take those cases?
11:38If I'm a lawyer?
11:39Uh-huh, yeah.
11:40If you were a lawyer, would you take them, I'm saying?
11:41I mean, if I wanted to do good for the hood, I guess I wouldn't have no choice.
11:46I'm not a lawyer.
11:47I'm far from that.
11:47And I'm going to ask this to everybody who's watching, everybody in the audience right now.
11:52Do you, when you think about it, and you're listening to hip-hop artists, I'm curious about this.
11:57When you hear a song lyric about violence, do you automatically assume that the artist actually committed a crime, right?
12:06That's a question to ask yourself.
12:07Do you guys always automatically assume, do you guys, when you're listening to music, do you assume that they did
12:12everything that they're writing about?
12:14No.
12:15You think that it's what?
12:16It's just storytelling.
12:17Is it storytelling?
12:18Just like a movie.
12:20Yeah.
12:20Storytelling is a movie.
12:21Some people would say, but if you're storytelling and it talks about violence, right, is that a good thing to
12:28put out in the first place to the public?
12:29What are y'all's thoughts on that?
12:30That's subjective.
12:33I like that.
12:34Okay, Bash, what were you getting ready to say?
12:35Yeah, same thing, a song, a movie, a book, it's all a story to a certain extent.
12:41And it's just your writing and you're creating a character.
12:45Yeah, it's coming from just your creativity.
12:48Okay, so here's another question, guys, and I love this one, okay?
12:51Many legal scholars argue that using lyrics as evidence may create chilling effect on free expression.
12:59Why is this viewed as a First Amendment concern?
13:02What do you think?
13:05I mean, think about it.
13:06If you want to be a new artist and you're watching the Young Thug case, right, and you grew up,
13:13let's say, in the streets of Philadelphia, and you want to talk about the things that you grew up seeing,
13:19right?
13:19So, if you think that you can get penalized by freely speaking, then you're less likely to try to talk
13:29about those things, and it might hamper your storytelling.
13:33It might take you away from even wanting to be art, because the truth of the matter is everybody don't
13:39look at rappers as musicians, you know?
13:42Okay, let me ask this question, too, Bash.
13:46When we're thinking about this, because, again, the lyrics are always on trial, and we're seeing this with a lot
13:51of the cases, right?
13:52What responsibility do you think that managers and the labels and the industry, what do you think they have, their
14:00responsibility, in protecting artists from this?
14:07I would hope that they're doing a—I would hope that they're helping the artists understand what could potentially come to
14:16them if they still have one foot in, you know, quote-unquote, the streets.
14:20Me, I'm an independent artist, so I've always had to maneuver this on my own, and what I've done is—I
14:29mean, at the end of the day, I'm an artist.
14:31It's my creativity.
14:32Like we was talking about earlier, when do you blur the line?
14:34When is a lyric—a lyric is not an omission of guilt.
14:37A lyric is not something that should take me to jail or potentially ruin my career, but I just feel
14:45like, as a man, you need to be true with yourself and understand what you're dealing with.
14:49There's already a target on our backs coming from where we're coming from, being hip-hop artists, so I think
14:55we just need to do our own job as well and just be a little more cautious with certain things.
15:01So I want to just, you know, tell everybody who's walking, and I see some people walking, and some people
15:06may just be joining us, you know, on YouTube, our live stream.
15:09And let me tell you again, the objective of this panel is to examine the growing practice of using some
15:14lyrics, song lyrics, as evidence in criminal trials.
15:17This panel, again, is going to delve into the concerns regarding freedom of expression and racial bias.
15:22And I want to give you guys some background information real quick.
15:25As of 2026, more than 800 criminal cases in the United States have used lyrics as evidence, most commonly to
15:35establish character, intent, motive.
15:38And, of course, hip-hop lyrics have been used most frequently in the cases with Tay-K, Young Thug, and
15:45YNW Melly.
15:47So when you think about that, right, when you're thinking about what's going on right now, and you hear all
15:52these cases where they're using these lyrics, this is why this conversation is definitely needed and why we need to
15:57have this conversation.
15:58And we want to make sure that, again, this is being live streamed, YouTube, you get a chance to watch
16:03it, again, on GBF, everybody.
16:05So I just want to make sure I tell everybody that, is that these are the reasons why we're having
16:09this kind of conversations, because we're seeing this happen a lot in our society when it comes to hip-hop
16:14artists.
16:15One of the other things I'm really, really concerned about, though, is that when you're looking at your inspiration, right?
16:21Okay, let me ask you, Bash.
16:22You're looking at inspiration.
16:23You're looking at what?
16:24Tell me, what are the ingredients that goes into making a dope rap song for you, and where are the
16:30influences coming from?
16:33I mean, it's real broad as well, because it depends what type of record I'm making.
16:40I think hip-hop is such a huge genre.
16:43You got so many sub-genres within the genre.
16:46But for me, the best recipe I have for just making music is just pulling from real experience, whether it
16:53happened to me or somebody that's right next to me or something that I saw in my community or in
16:58my neighborhood.
16:59That's where I pull the most inspiration from.
17:02What would you say to young and upcoming artists who are worried about how their lyrics now might be perceived
17:07or used down the line?
17:10I would say the way that they're using these lyrics nowadays and the way that they already targeted us, I
17:17think you have to find a happy medium, and you have to be very careful with what it is that
17:22you're saying and what you're doing.
17:25Because hip-hop will catapult somebody from nothing to something, and they already have the eyes on them depending on
17:31where they're at in their neighborhood or whatever the case may be, really.
17:34So I think just having more caution is the name of the game in that.
17:38What do you think about this, Ty?
17:40I think that you should...
17:43What would you say?
17:43What would you actually say?
17:45I would say be an artist, you know.
17:47Just be an artist.
17:48Don't...
17:49If you are, you know, doing things that are illegal that can put you into a certain type of criminal
17:56activity, but then on top of it, you're rapping about it, that's just not being smart.
18:01So if you want to be a musician, if you want to be treated like a musician, be an artist.
18:06Because once you get out of being an artist, then you open yourself up for just self-indictment through the
18:15art that you're doing.
18:15So if you're really selling drugs, and you're rapping about selling drugs...
18:21That's just dumb.
18:22That's just dumb now.
18:23Now, at that point, yeah.
18:24Okay.
18:25Be an artist.
18:26Yeah.
18:26Now, at that point, we're going to take your lyrics and use them.
18:28I mean, come on.
18:29We're going to have to use these lyrics against you.
18:31But if you could change one thing about how the public, the industry, or the justice system treats creative work,
18:38if you could change one thing, what would it be?
18:40I think record labels specifically should spend more money lobbying to protect their clients.
18:49That's probably the biggest thing I would say, because they spend money lobbying for how much they want to pay,
18:55how much they don't want to pay.
18:56So I think they should do that same level of lobbying to protect their First Amendment and have freedom of
19:01speech.
19:01I love that.
19:02Protect that.
19:03What about you?
19:03What do you think, Bash?
19:04What can they do?
19:08You could change one thing about how the public, the industry, or the justice system treats creative work.
19:14What would it be?
19:17Don't judge it.
19:18I think art is art.
19:20Are they doing the same thing to a country singer?
19:23Are they doing the same thing to somebody like the likes of Eminem and the outlandish things that he'd be
19:30saying?
19:30I think art is art, and it needs to remain that.
19:34Okay.
19:35We're getting down to the last couple of questions, and I want to know this one here.
19:38Three states, I don't know if anyone has heard or you found out about this.
19:41Three states have passed laws limiting when lyrics can be used in court.
19:47There are other states with bills in progress but have not yet passed.
19:52What do you want artists and fans to know about those protections?
19:57What states say is you might want to relocate.
20:00Okay, right?
20:01Look, you all hear that.
20:03Depends on the state, huh?
20:04On the state, you might want to relocate if you want to double down on your protection.
20:09All right, I was getting ready, but clearly be careful in Atlanta because we saw what was going on with
20:13Young Thug, although he got off.
20:15Definitely be careful in Atlanta.
20:16But still, I mean, I'm just saying, what do you think about that?
20:18You're hearing what's going on, and they got a bill right now.
20:21Again, they got a bill right now that is in progress, but it hasn't passed yet, right?
20:26But they're talking about limiting when lyrics can be used in court.
20:29You guys, I mean, I think it's true.
20:31They should limit it, but what are your thoughts on this?
20:33What do you want artists and fans to know about these protections?
20:38I could just expand on what Ty said just as much the same way, I think.
20:43Move around.
20:45Wait, let me ask you a question.
20:46Bash, I think you're like, guess what?
20:48I'm going to take my chance.
20:49I'm going to come out here, and I'm going to do me.
20:51I'm going to write for me, and whatever happens, happens.
20:53Is that how you're looking at it?
20:55The way that I'm looking at it really is I'm a big believer in reality and the truth.
21:04I think you can't live in a space where music has come from so much reality and try to front
21:13it or try to fake it.
21:14You can't make food without the real ingredients.
21:18You get what I'm saying?
21:20It's not going to taste the same.
21:21It's not going to come out the same way.
21:22So it wouldn't even be so much about taking a chance.
21:26It's just I have to live my truth.
21:27I don't know what else to write about.
21:29I'm not a writer to write a fiction book about a fairy tale.
21:34I can only speak on what I've seen and I know my whole life.
21:38Okay.
21:38Here's our final question this morning.
21:41What policy changes, legal reforms, or industry actions could help address this issue?
21:48When we're talking about lyrics being used against artists in the courtroom,
21:53when we're thinking about what we've just talked about this morning,
21:55what policy changes, legal reforms, or industry actions could help address this issue?
22:01I don't think that it will be equally even when it talks about lyrics to address it and apply it
22:10to actors,
22:11to apply it to wrestlers, anything that's story-based, storytelling, or entertainment.
22:19So being that it can't be equally applied, it just needs to be eliminated in general.
22:25Right.
22:26That's what I think.
22:26So you don't believe that at all.
22:28What about you, Bash?
22:29What policy changes, legal reforms, or industry actions could help address this issue?
22:40Man.
22:48He's stuck on that one.
22:50Because at this point, we didn't see it.
22:51At this point, so I'm from Dallas, right?
22:54So the first time I seen this was the Tay-Kate case, right?
22:58And when I seen that, it kind of just, I mean, Texas is already Texas.
23:03But on top of that, I mean, it's a weird situation, but he was still a baby.
23:09He was 16.
23:11So I didn't dive into the case that much.
23:13I don't know.
23:14But what I do know is that they took from his music and his lyrics and his videos, and they
23:20used that in court.
23:21So, I mean, we're already at an unfair disadvantage.
23:25I feel like that was my first time seeing something like that.
23:31I was just, I don't, you know, it's creativity.
23:35So where, like I said, where is the line drawn?
23:37When does a lyric become a confession of guilt?
23:41This is crazy.
23:42Y'all hear this.
23:42It's so crazy.
23:43Well, listen, I want to thank you both for being, y'all clapping up for these two for being a
23:46part of our panel this morning.
23:48I'm going to tell y'all something right now.
23:50When you're thinking about it, music has always been more than entertainment.
23:54Now more than ever, we definitely need to value that music, it brings storytelling and cultural expression, and it brings
24:02protest.
24:03It brings healing and identity.
24:06As we continue to examine the intersection of artistic expression and criminal justice, you know what?
24:13The question before us is not only what role lyrics should play in the courtroom, but what kind of society
24:19we want to be in.
24:20One that encourages creative freedom, definitely, or one that risks criminalizing it.
24:25It's something for us to think about, right?
24:27Thank you again to our panelists.
24:28Thank you to our audience this morning for getting up early this morning, y'all.
24:32Clap it up for these folks right here, and clap it up for yourselves for being there with us this
24:36morning.
24:37I'm Dee Dee McGuire.
24:38I'll be talking to y'all in the morning on the radio.
24:41All right.
24:50Bye.
24:50Bye.
24:51Bye.
24:52Bye.
24:53Bye.
24:53Bye.
24:53Bye.
24:53Bye.

Recommended