- 2 days ago
What Froze German Patrols in Canadian Lines They Expected Empty
Category
đ
LearningTranscript
00:00November 14th, 1916. Somewhere east of Neuville-Saint-Vast, France.
00:06A German Unteroffizier and five men from the 6th Bavarian Reserve Division slip over their parapet and into no-man's
00:13land.
00:14Their orders are simple. Cross 400 meters of cratered ground, reach the Canadian forward trenches, and report what they find.
00:23German intelligence believes the sector is thinly held.
00:26Aerial photographs taken two days earlier showed almost no movement.
00:30No supply traffic, no trench repair. The line looks empty.
00:35The Unteroffizier has done this before. He has patrolled against the British, against the French.
00:40He knows how to read the dark. He knows the rhythm of star shells, knows to freeze when the magnesium
00:46flare catches the sky,
00:48knows to crawl again when the light dies. His men are steady. They have done this a dozen times.
00:54They cross the first hundred meters without incident, then the second. The shell craters are frozen at the edges.
01:01The mud has a skin of ice that cracks faintly under their knees. Ahead, nothing.
01:07No wire-mending parties. No clink of shovels. No coughing. The Canadian trenches are silent.
01:15Everything confirms what intelligence said. The sector is quiet. They keep crawling.
01:22300 meters now. Close enough to smell the parapet if anyone were cooking. Nothing.
01:28The Unteroffizier signals a halt. They wait. One minute. Two. The only sound is their own breathing.
01:37He signals again. Move forward. 50 more meters and they will be at the wire. They never reach it.
01:44That patrol was posted as missing the following morning. No shots were reported from any listening
01:49post on the German side. No flares went up. No grenades. No sound at all. Six men crawled into
01:57the dark toward a trench line that every piece of available intelligence said was empty.
02:01And they simply ceased to exist.
02:04If you find these stories worth telling, a like and a subscribe help them reach the people who grew
02:10up hearing their grandfathers talk about knights exactly like this one.
02:13Here is the part that German command could not reconcile. The Canadians opposite the 6th Bavarian
02:19Reserve were not hiding because they were weak. They were not quiet because they had withdrawn.
02:25The silence was not absence. It was presence. And the men lying motionless in that frozen mud
02:31between the trenches had been there for hours before the patrol even left its own parapet.
02:36What the Germans had walked into was not an ambush in any sense they understood. There was no tripwire.
02:42No machine gun pre-sighted on a gap in the wire. No flare triggered by a stumble. This was
02:48something else entirely. Something that had no equivalent on any other sector of the Western
02:53Front. Something that existed only where Canadian troops held the line. The British had a word for
02:58it. The French had heard rumors of it. The Germans who survived long enough to be captured and
03:03interrogated could barely describe it. But in the Canadian trenches, the men who crawled out every night
03:09and lay in the freezing dark with nothing but a trench knife and a pair of blackened hands
03:14had a name for what they did. They called it the Silent Death. And here is what makes this story
03:22worth 50 minutes of your time. The Silent Death was not a single act of bravery by a single soldier
03:28on a single night. It was a system, a doctrine, a deliberate, sustained and methodical campaign to make no man's
03:37land
03:38belong to Canada. It did not appear overnight and it did not appear by accident. It grew out of a
03:44specific set of
03:45circumstances that existed nowhere else in the British Expeditionary Force. And those circumstances began not with a
03:52tactic, not with an order from a general, but with the kind of men who volunteered to cross an ocean
03:58and fight a war
03:59that was not, strictly speaking, their own. To understand what froze those German patrols in ground they expected
04:06empty, you have to understand who was waiting for them. And that means going back 13 months before the
04:13Unto Officia vanished, to a rain-soaked Belgian farm on the Duve River, where a battalion commander from Vancouver was
04:20about to try something that no one in the British Army had attempted at that scale before. What happened at
04:26Petit Duve that
04:27night did not just kill Germans. It taught the Canadians something about themselves that would reshape the war in the
04:33dark.
04:35November 16th, 1915. The Duve River, near Messines, Belgium.
04:41Rain had been falling for three days straight, and the river that normally ran eight feet wide had swollen to
04:47three times that,
04:48ten feet deep in places, brown water rolling through a landscape that already looked like it belonged to no one.
04:54On the Canadian side of the line, Lieutenant Colonel Victor Odlem was watching the sky and making a decision.
05:01Odlem was not a career soldier. Before the war, he had been a newspaper editor in Vancouver.
05:06He was 40 years old, lean, sharp-faced, and possessed of a quality that would define Canadian operations for the
05:13next three years.
05:14He was impatient with passivity.
05:16The 7th Battalion had been sitting in these trenches for weeks. Morale was fraying.
05:23Men were dying to snipers and random shellfire without ever seeing the enemy.
05:28Odlem wanted to change that equation, and the method he chose was something the British High Command had never seen
05:34organized at this scale.
05:35He was going to send his men into the German trenches, not to hold them, not to break through, to
05:42hit, kill, grab prisoners, learn everything they could, and get out.
05:4820 minutes. No more.
05:50He had selected 85 volunteers from the 7th Battalion, plus a similar group from the 5th.
05:56For 10 days, these men had been excused from every other duty.
06:00They rehearsed on ground that had been dug to match the exact layout of the German position at Petit-Doux
06:06Farm,
06:06which sat inside a salient where the German line curved outward across the Messines-PlĂŒgstiert road.
06:12They practiced with portable bridging ladders.
06:15They learned to cross wire using specially built mats.
06:18They memorized the trench plan until they could walk it blindfolded.
06:22And they chose their weapons.
06:24Hold that detail. It matters later.
06:27The raid had already been postponed once because of the flooding.
06:31Now, on the night of the 16th, the water was still high, but Odlem decided they had waited long enough.
06:37At 9 that morning, Canadian 18-pounders began shelling the German wire.
06:42By afternoon, trench mortars joined in, hammering Petit-Doux Farm itself.
06:47That night, while covering parties crawled forward to watch the flanks, the assault group moved out.
06:53They crossed no man's land in darkness.
06:55The improvised bridges held.
06:58The wire cutters finished what the artillery had started.
07:01And just after midnight on November 17th, the Canadians emerged inside the German trench system with complete surprise.
07:08What followed took exactly 20 minutes.
07:12The raiders overran a rectangle of German trenches, killed the defenders who fought,
07:17seized 12 prisoners, and hustled them back across no man's land for interrogation.
07:22A survey party mapped everything they could see.
07:25Anything of military value that could be carried was taken.
07:28When the lieutenant's whistle blew, every man who could move was back across the wire before the Germans could organize
07:34a response.
07:35The high command loved it.
07:38Brigadiers who had been watching casualty lists grow from snipers and shellfire suddenly saw a model.
07:44Aggressive.
07:45Controlled.
07:47Productive.
07:47They demanded more.
07:50But here is what the official reports did not capture, and what matters for this story.
07:55The men who came back from Petite-Duve that night had learned something that no briefing could have taught them.
08:01They had learned that no man's land was not a barrier.
08:03It was a workspace.
08:05A place you could move through, hide in, and control, if you had the skills and the nerve.
08:11And the 7th Battalion happened to be full of men who already had both.
08:16Think about who volunteered for the Canadian Expeditionary Force in 1914 and 1915.
08:22Canada had no conscription.
08:24Every man who crossed the Atlantic chose to be there.
08:28And the battalions that shipped out in those first two years drew heavily from a country that was still, in
08:33large stretches, frontier.
08:36Lumber camps in northern Ontario.
08:38Trap lines in Manitoba.
08:40Cattle ranches in Alberta.
08:42Fishing stations on the Pacific coast.
08:44These were men who had spent their adult lives reading ground, moving quietly, and waiting in the cold for something
08:51that might or might not come.
08:53A deer.
08:54A lynx.
08:55A trap that needed checking at 3 in the morning in January.
08:59They did not know it yet, but the night at Petite-Duve had opened a door.
09:04In the months ahead, the raids would grow more frequent, more refined, and more feared.
09:10But the Canadians were about to discover that the most devastating thing you could do in no man's land was
09:16not to raid the enemy trench at all.
09:18It was to never reach it.
09:20To stop halfway.
09:22To lie down in the frozen mud, go silent, and wait.
09:26The men who figured that out did not learn it from a manual.
09:30They learned it from the dark.
09:32And the dark taught a lesson that the German army would spend two years trying to unlearn.
09:38By the spring of 1916, Canadian battalions were raiding German trenches two, three, sometimes four times a week along their
09:46sector.
09:47The high command kept demanding more, and the Canadians kept delivering.
09:51But somewhere in the rhythm of those raids, in the hours spent crawling back and forth across no man's land,
09:58certain men began to notice something.
10:01German patrols were coming out too.
10:03Every army on the western front sent patrols into no man's land after dark.
10:07It was the only way to know what was happening on the other side.
10:10Who was in the line, how strong the wire was, whether an attack was being prepared.
10:15The Germans were methodical about it.
10:17They sent small groups, four to six men, with orders to reach the enemy wire, observe, and return.
10:23And when they patrolled against the British or the French, they usually succeeded.
10:28The opposing side kept to its own trenches at night.
10:30No man's land was empty.
10:32But opposite the Canadians, it was not empty.
10:35And the Canadians who were already out there, lying in shell craters or pressed flat against frozen earth, began to
10:41realize they had a choice.
10:43They could keep crawling past the German patrols on their way to raid the trenches.
10:47Or they could stop where they were and deal with the patrols themselves.
10:51Remember the weapons the raiders chose at Petite Duve?
10:54That detail matters now.
10:56The men who volunteered for what became the Silent Death did not carry rifles.
11:01A rifle was useless for what they needed to do.
11:04And worse, a single shot would bring every machine gun and flare on the sector to life.
11:09They carried trench knives, short, double-edged blades designed for one thing.
11:15Some carried homemade clubs, weighted with lead or studded with nails.
11:19Some carried brass knuckle dusters or push daggers forged from barbed wire stakes.
11:25Every weapon was chosen for the same reason.
11:28It killed without sound.
11:31Before going out, they smeared their faces and hands with burnt cork until the skin was black.
11:36They removed anything that could rattle, clink, or reflect light.
11:40Identification tags came off.
11:42If they were captured, they wanted to give the Germans nothing.
11:46Then they climbed over their own parapet, crawled through their own wire, and moved out into the dark.
11:52And then they stopped.
11:55This is the part that most people, even people who know the First World War well, find hard to believe.
12:02These men did not advance to a position, set up, and wait for 30 minutes.
12:07They crawled to a spot in no man's land, sometimes 200 meters from their own trench,
12:12sometimes closer to the German wire than to their own, and they lay there.
12:17For hours.
12:18In rain, in frost, in mud that soaked through every layer of wool and cotton,
12:24until the cold was not something they felt on their skin, but something that lived in their bones.
12:30They did not move.
12:31They did not whisper.
12:33They breathed through their mouths to keep the sound of a stuffy nose from carrying in the stillness.
12:39And they waited.
12:41Picture a man who grew up running a trapline north of Lake Nipissing.
12:45He has lain in snow for three hours, waiting for a lynx to return to a kill site.
12:50His father taught him that the animal will come back, but only if nothing in the landscape has changed.
12:56Not a branch.
12:57Not a shadow.
12:58Not a scent.
13:00Patience is not something this man learned.
13:02It is something he is.
13:03Now put that man in a shell crater in Belgium, with a trench knife across his chest,
13:09and a German patrol walking toward him in the dark.
13:12Private Francis Pegamagabo, Ojibwe, from the Wassoxing First Nation near Parry Sound, Ontario,
13:18had been hunting since he could walk.
13:20He enlisted on August 13, 1914, one of the first indigenous volunteers in the entire Canadian Expeditionary Force.
13:28By 1916, he was already known in the 1st Battalion as a man who could cross no man's land like
13:34a ghost,
13:35spot a target in conditions where other men saw only blackness, and return without a sound.
13:40What he did out there at night would eventually make him the deadliest sniper of the entire war, on either
13:45side.
13:47378 confirmed kills.
13:49Over 300 prisoners captured.
13:51Three military medals.
13:53But in the spring of 1916, he was not yet a legend.
13:56He was one of dozens of Canadian soldiers, many of them hunters and trappers,
14:01who were discovering that the skills of the northern bush transferred to no man's land with terrifying precision.
14:07And the Germans opposite them were about to find out what that meant.
14:11Not through a report.
14:13Not through a briefing.
14:14Through the silence that followed when their patrol stopped coming home.
14:18Put yourself on the German side of the wire for a moment.
14:21You are a company commander in the 6th Bavarian Reserve Division,
14:24holding a sector near Neuville-Saint-Vas in the autumn of 1916.
14:28Your standing orders require you to send patrols into no man's land every night.
14:33The purpose is intelligence.
14:35You need to know if the enemy is reinforcing,
14:37digging new saps,
14:39cutting paths through his wire,
14:40preparing to attack.
14:41Every commander on the western front has the same requirement.
14:45It is routine.
14:46You select six men.
14:48Experienced.
14:49Steady.
14:50They blacken their faces and go out after dark.
14:54You wait.
14:54An hour.
14:56Two hours.
14:57The time window for their return passes.
14:59No shots were fired.
15:01No flares went up.
15:03No one on any listening post heard anything.
15:06You send a runner to the adjacent companies.
15:09Nothing.
15:10You wait until dawn.
15:12The patrol does not return.
15:14The following night,
15:15you send four men on a different route,
15:17200 meters south of where the first group crossed.
15:20They do not come back either.
15:22Now consider what this does to a company commander's ability to function.
15:26You have lost ten men in two nights without a single round being fired.
15:31You have no wounded to interrogate.
15:33You have no bodies to examine.
15:35You have absolutely no information about what happened.
15:39Your reports to battalion headquarters say the same thing every morning.
15:43Patrol dispatched.
15:45Patrol did not return.
15:46No enemy activity observed.
15:49That last line is the one that matters.
15:51No enemy activity observed.
15:53Because from the German parapet,
15:55there was nothing to observe.
15:57The Canadian trenches remained silent.
16:00No muzzle flashes.
16:01No grenade detonations.
16:02No shouting.
16:04The intelligence picture said the sector was quiet.
16:07Aerial photographs showed minimal movement.
16:09Every conventional indicator said the lines opposite were thinly held,
16:14possibly being rotated out.
16:16And yet men kept disappearing.
16:18This is where the silent death became something larger than a tactic.
16:22It became a psychological weapon.
16:24And its power lay precisely in the gap between what German intelligence could see
16:29and what was actually happening in the darkness between the trenches.
16:33A German patrol moving through no man's land against the British had a known set of risks.
16:38Trip a wire and a flare goes up.
16:40Get spotted and a machine gun opens.
16:42Stumble into a listening post and there is a short, violent firefight.
16:46All of these are dangerous, but they are comprehensible.
16:50A man can prepare for a risk he understands.
16:53He can watch for the flare, crawl below the machine gun's arc,
16:57avoid the listening post he has mapped on previous nights.
17:01Fear is manageable when it has a shape.
17:03Against the Canadians, the fear had no shape.
17:07There was no warning, no trigger, no moment where a man could say,
17:11this is the danger, and this is how I avoid it.
17:15German soldiers who rotated into sectors opposite the Canadian Corps
17:19began hearing stories from the men they replaced.
17:22Do not go out at night.
17:24No man's land is not empty.
17:27Something is out there.
17:28But nobody could say what, because nobody who had met it in the dark
17:33had come back to describe it.
17:35Here is a fact that deserves its full weight.
17:39Major Hesketh Pritchard, who ran the British Army's sniping and scouting school,
17:44wrote about the silent death in his book After the War.
17:47He described it plainly.
17:49Canadians crawled out every night, lay in the dark,
17:52waited for German patrols,
17:53and killed them with trench daggers as silently as possible.
17:56Then he wrote the sentence that tells you everything about what this tactic achieved.
18:01The Germans, he wrote, almost gave up patrolling in that sector.
18:06Think about what that means.
18:08On the Western Front, patrolling was not optional.
18:11It was the only way to gather intelligence about the enemy.
18:14An army that stops patrolling is an army that goes blind.
18:18It cannot see what is coming.
18:20It cannot prepare.
18:21It cannot adjust.
18:22The silent death did not just kill German soldiers.
18:25It took away Germany's eyes.
18:27And here is the part that Hesketh Pritchard added almost as an afterthought,
18:31but that carries the real weight of the story.
18:34One of his officers, he wrote, who used to command a silent death party,
18:38told him about the long and chilly waits in the frost or the rain,
18:42waiting for patrols that never came.
18:44The Germans had stopped sending them.
18:46The Canadians had won.
18:48And their enemy did not even understand the battle.
18:51But the German army was not built on passivity.
18:55Losing control of no man's land meant losing the ability to predict what the Canadians would do next.
19:01And by late 1916, German command decided that whatever was happening in the dark opposite the Canadian sector,
19:08they were going to answer it.
19:09The answer they chose would test the silent death in a way its inventors had not anticipated.
19:14The German answer came in stages.
19:17First, they increased the size of their patrols.
19:19If four men were vanishing, send 12.
19:22A larger group could defend itself.
19:24It could carry more firepower.
19:26It could sweep a wider area.
19:28The logic was sound against any conventional threat.
19:31It failed against the silent death for one reason.
19:34Twelve men moving through no man's land made three times the noise of four.
19:39The Canadians lying in the dark did not need to see the patrol.
19:42They heard it coming from 100 meters away.
19:45The soft crack of frozen mud.
19:47The scrape of a belt buckle against a crater's edge.
19:50A breath held too long and released too fast.
19:54Twelve men made it easier, not harder, for the waiting Canadians to position themselves.
19:59And twelve men in a confused, close-quarters fight in total darkness,
20:04unable to fire without hitting each other, died no better than four.
20:09Next, the Germans tried flooding no man's land with light.
20:12More star shells.
20:14More flares.
20:15Some sectors saw a flare going up every 45 seconds,
20:19turning the ground between the trenches into a stuttering black-and-white photograph.
20:23The idea was to catch the Canadians in the open.
20:26But a star shell only reveals what moves.
20:29The men lying in the mud had been trained, by years of hunting,
20:33to do one thing when light flooded the landscape.
20:36Freeze.
20:38Go completely still.
20:40Become part of the ground.
20:42A flare burns for roughly 60 seconds.
20:44A man who does not move for 60 seconds,
20:47whose face is blackened,
20:49whose clothing is caked in the same mud he is lying in,
20:52is invisible at 30 meters.
20:54The flares died,
20:56the darkness returned,
20:57and the Canadians were still there.
20:59Then the Germans tried their own version of the ambush.
21:03They sent parties out early,
21:04before full dark,
21:06to establish positions in no man's land
21:08and wait for the Canadians to come out.
21:10It was the closest anyone came to matching the silent death on its own terms.
21:15But it exposed a problem that no order from battalion headquarters could solve.
21:20The German soldiers who drew this duty were not hunters.
21:24They were conscripts,
21:25factory workers,
21:27clerks,
21:27farmers from the flatlands of Bavaria and Saxony.
21:31Brave men,
21:32disciplined men,
21:33but men who had never in their lives
21:35spent a night motionless in the wild,
21:38reading sounds,
21:39filtering the wind,
21:41trusting their instincts over their eyes.
21:43They shifted,
21:44they whispered,
21:45they checked their watches,
21:47and the Canadians heard every sound they made.
21:50Remember this,
21:51the advantage the Canadians held in no man's land
21:54was not technological.
21:55It was not numerical.
21:57It was biological.
21:59It lived in the nervous systems of men
22:01who had grown up in a landscape
22:03that demanded silence and patience
22:05as the price of survival.
22:06No training program could replicate it.
22:09No order could instill it.
22:11You either had 10,000 hours in the northern bush behind you,
22:14or you did not.
22:16And then the Canadians added a second layer
22:18that made the situation even worse.
22:20Lance Corporal Henry Norwest,
22:2250th Battalion,
22:23MĂ©tis of Cree and French ancestry,
22:26born in Fort Saskatchewan, Alberta.
22:28Before the war,
22:29he was a ranch hand and a rodeo rider.
22:31He had been hunting since boyhood,
22:33and what he could do with a rifle at distance
22:35was something his observers struggled to put into official language.
22:39Norwest's method was simple and merciless.
22:42He crawled into no man's land before dawn,
22:45found a position,
22:46camouflaged himself so completely
22:47that men standing 10 feet away could not see him,
22:50and waited,
22:51sometimes for hours.
22:53Sometimes for an entire day.
22:55When a German helmet appeared above a parapet,
22:57or a periscope glinted in a trench,
23:00he fired once and vanished.
23:02115 confirmed kills.
23:04Everyone observed and verified by a second man.
23:07The real number was almost certainly higher.
23:10Norwest was not alone.
23:12Pegamagaba was doing the same work
23:14in the 1st Battalion sector.
23:15Dozens of other Canadian snipers,
23:18many of them indigenous or from the northern frontier,
23:20were operating across the Corps.
23:22And what they created,
23:24combined with the silent death,
23:26was something no other allied force had achieved.
23:2924-hour dominance of no man's land.
23:32At night, the silent ambush teams owned the ground.
23:36By day, the snipers owned it.
23:38There was no window,
23:39no hour,
23:40no angle from which a German soldier
23:42could observe the Canadian lines
23:44without risking his life.
23:46The German army opposite the Canadian Corps
23:48was going blind in both eyes.
23:51And that blindness was about to cost them
23:53something far larger than patrols,
23:55because in the winter of 1916,
23:58the Canadians began moving into the sector
24:00below a long, high ridge
24:02that the French and the British
24:03had tried to take for two years
24:05at a cost of 150,000 men.
24:08The ridge was called Vimy.
24:10And the first thing the Canadians did
24:12when they arrived
24:13was send their silent death parties
24:15out into the dark
24:15to find out what the Germans were hiding up there.
24:18What they brought back
24:19would make the impossible possible.
24:22Late October, 1916.
24:24The Canadian Corps moved south from the Somme
24:27and took over the sector facing Vimy Ridge.
24:30The men who marched into those trenches
24:32looked up at a long escarpment
24:34that rose 60 meters above the surrounding plain
24:36and understood immediately
24:38why it still belonged to Germany.
24:40The ridge commanded everything.
24:42From its crest,
24:43German observers could see every road,
24:45every supply dump,
24:47every trench on the Allied side
24:48for kilometers.
24:50Nothing moved in daylight
24:51without being spotted.
24:52Nothing was built without being shelled.
24:55The French had thrown 150,000 men at Vimy
24:58in 1915 alone.
25:00The British had bled against it through 1916.
25:03The ridge held.
25:05Lieutenant General Julian Bing,
25:07commanding the Canadian Corps,
25:08and Major General Arthur Curry,
25:11commanding the 1st Division,
25:12looked at the same ground
25:14and asked a different question.
25:15Not, how do we break through the defenses?
25:18First, what are the defenses?
25:20Where exactly are the machine gun nests?
25:23Where are the tunnel entrances?
25:25Where are the artillery observation posts?
25:28How deep are the dugouts?
25:29Which units are holding which sections?
25:32What are their strengths?
25:33Their rotation schedules?
25:35Their morale?
25:36Every one of those questions had to be answered
25:38before a single plan could be drawn.
25:40And every one of those answers
25:42had to come from no man's land.
25:44This is where two years of silent death,
25:47of trench raiding,
25:48of absolute Canadian ownership
25:50of the ground between the trenches
25:51paid its strategic dividend.
25:54The Canadians did not need to guess
25:55what was on the ridge.
25:57They went out and looked.
25:59Through the winter of 1916 into 1917,
26:03Canadian raiding parties
26:04hit the German lines opposite Vimy
26:06with a frequency that no other sector
26:08of the Western Front had seen.
26:10These were not the silent ambush operations
26:13of the open ground.
26:14These were full-scale trench raids.
26:16Fifty men, eighty men, sometimes more,
26:19supported by artillery,
26:21planned to the minute,
26:22rehearsed on replica trenches
26:24behind the Canadian lines.
26:25Their purpose was not to kill,
26:27though they did.
26:28Their purpose was to take prisoners
26:30and bring them back alive for interrogation.
26:32And it worked because the Canadians
26:34controlled no man's land completely.
26:37The raiding parties could cross
26:38400 meters of open ground
26:40in the dark with confidence
26:41because they knew no German patrol
26:43would stumble into them on the way.
26:45The silent death teams
26:47had already cleared the route.
26:48The snipers had already suppressed
26:50every German observation post
26:52that might have spotted movement at dusk.
26:55The listening posts,
26:56pushed forward to within 25 meters
26:59of the German wire,
27:00had already mapped the sentry schedule.
27:02By the time the raiding party
27:04went over the top,
27:05they were walking through a corridor
27:07that Canadian dominance
27:08had made as safe
27:09as any piece of ground
27:11on the Western Front could be.
27:13The prisoners talked.
27:15German soldiers captured in trench raids
27:17were often terrified,
27:19sometimes relieved to be alive,
27:20and under skilled interrogation,
27:22they gave up details
27:23that no aerial photograph could provide.
27:26Tunnel locations,
27:27command post positions,
27:29relief schedules,
27:30unit identifications
27:32that told Canadian intelligence
27:33exactly which divisions
27:35were on the ridge
27:36and how strong they were.
27:38Curry took this information
27:40and did something
27:41that no British general
27:42had done before.
27:43He gave it to everyone.
27:45Not just to brigade commanders,
27:47not just to battalion officers,
27:49to every soldier.
27:5240,000 maps were printed
27:53and distributed
27:54down to the level
27:55of individual privates.
27:57Every man who would climb that ridge
27:59on the morning of the attack
28:00knew his precise objective,
28:02his route,
28:03his timing,
28:04and what he would find
28:05when he got there.
28:07And then,
28:08Curry built a replica of the ridge
28:09behind the Canadian lines
28:11and made his men rehearse the attack
28:13until they could do it
28:14in their sleep.
28:16April 9th, 1917,
28:18Easter Monday,
28:205.30 in the morning.
28:22All four Canadian divisions
28:23attacked together
28:24for the first time in the war.
28:27983 artillery pieces
28:29opened simultaneously.
28:31The barrage was so loud
28:33it was heard
28:33across the English Channel.
28:35And behind the wall
28:36of falling shells,
28:38the Canadians advanced up the ridge
28:40they already knew by heart.
28:42By nightfall,
28:43most of it was theirs.
28:45The French had spent two years
28:47and 150,000 casualties
28:49failing to take this ground.
28:51The Canadians took it
28:53in hours.
28:54And the knowledge
28:55that made that possible
28:56had been gathered by men
28:58lying in frozen mud
28:59with trench knives,
29:00one patrol at a time,
29:02over the five months
29:03before the attack.
29:05But Vimy Ridge
29:06was not the end of the story.
29:08It was the moment
29:09when the rest of the war
29:10noticed what the Canadians
29:12had become.
29:13And what the German
29:14high command noticed most
29:15was not the ridge
29:16they had lost.
29:17It was the fact
29:18that for months
29:19before losing it
29:20they had been blind.
29:21Their patrols had stopped.
29:23Their intelligence
29:24had dried up.
29:25They had not seen
29:26the blow coming
29:27because the men
29:28whose job it was to see
29:29had stopped coming back
29:30from the dark.
29:31That realization
29:32would follow the Canadian Corps
29:34for the rest of the war.
29:35And it would change
29:36the way Germany
29:37fought against them
29:38in ways that no one
29:39on either side expected.
29:41After Vimy,
29:42the Canadian Corps
29:43did not slow down.
29:45They became,
29:46in the vocabulary
29:47of the British Expeditionary Force,
29:49shock troops.
29:50The formation you sent
29:51where the line needed breaking.
29:53Hill 70
29:54in August of 1917.
29:57Passchendaele that autumn
29:58where Curry,
29:59now commanding the Corps,
30:01warned the high command
30:02that it would cost
30:0316,000 casualties
30:05and was told
30:06to do it anyway.
30:08He did it.
30:09It cost 15,654.
30:12He had been off
30:14by less than 400.
30:16But every battle,
30:17every raid,
30:18every night operation
30:19added another layer
30:21to a reputation
30:22that was becoming,
30:23in itself,
30:24a weapon.
30:25German intelligence officers
30:27tracked the Canadian Corps
30:28the way they tracked
30:29no other formation
30:30in the Allied line.
30:31They monitored
30:32its radio traffic.
30:33They watched
30:34for its shoulder patches
30:35on prisoners.
30:36They studied railway movements
30:38behind the front
30:39for signs that the Canadians
30:40were being transferred.
30:41and the reason
30:43was simple.
30:43Where the Canadians
30:44appeared,
30:45an attack was coming.
30:47They had never been used
30:48for a quiet sector.
30:50They had never been deployed
30:51to hold ground passively.
30:53When the Canadian Corps
30:54moved into your section
30:56of the front,
30:56it meant one thing.
30:58You were about to be hit.
31:00This was the strategic legacy
31:02of the silent death
31:03and it is worth pausing
31:04to trace the line
31:05from cause to effect.
31:07Canadian dominance
31:08of no man's land
31:09destroyed German patrol capability.
31:12Destroyed patrol capability
31:13meant destroyed intelligence.
31:15Destroyed intelligence
31:16meant the Germans
31:17could not predict
31:18Canadian operations.
31:20And that unpredictability
31:21made the Canadian Corps
31:23the most dangerous formation
31:24on the Western Front.
31:25Not just because
31:26of what it could do,
31:27but because the enemy
31:29could not see it doing it
31:30until it was too late.
31:32By the summer of 1918,
31:34this reputation
31:35had grown so large
31:36that it became a problem
31:37for Allied planners.
31:39Field Marshal Douglas Haig
31:41was preparing
31:41a massive offensive
31:42at Amiens for August.
31:44The Canadian Corps
31:45would spearhead the assault.
31:46But if the Germans
31:47detected Canadians
31:48moving into the Amiens sector,
31:50they would immediately reinforce.
31:52Surprise would be lost.
31:54The attack might fail.
31:56So the Allies
31:56did something extraordinary.
31:58They weaponized the fear.
32:00A detachment
32:01from the Canadian Corps,
32:02two infantry battalions,
32:04a wireless unit,
32:05and a casualty clearing station
32:07was sent north
32:08to the front near Ypres.
32:10They set up radio traffic.
32:11They made themselves visible.
32:13They behaved in every way
32:15as if the entire Canadian Corps
32:17was moving into Flanders.
32:19Orders distributed to the men
32:20included a single,
32:21blunt instruction.
32:22Keep your mouth shut.
32:25Meanwhile,
32:26the real Canadian Corps,
32:27100,000 men,
32:28marched south to Amiens
32:30in secrecy.
32:31They moved at night.
32:32They hid during the day.
32:34They were forbidden
32:35from wearing unit insignia
32:36or speaking to anyone
32:38outside their formation.
32:39The deception
32:40was built entirely
32:41on one assumption.
32:42The Germans feared
32:43the Canadians so deeply
32:45that the mere suggestion
32:46of their presence
32:47in a sector
32:47would fix German reserves
32:49in place
32:49hundreds of kilometers
32:51from the real attack.
32:52It worked.
32:53On August 8, 1918,
32:56the Canadian Corps
32:57attacked at Amiens
32:58alongside Australian
33:00and British divisions.
33:01The Germans had no warning.
33:03The Canadian infantry
33:05advanced 13 kilometers
33:06in a single day,
33:07the deepest penetration
33:09on the Western Front
33:10since trench warfare began.
33:12German General
33:13Erich Ludendorff
33:14called it
33:15the Black Day
33:16of the German Army.
33:17Not because of the ground lost,
33:19but because entire
33:20German divisions broke.
33:21soldiers surrendered
33:23to single platoons.
33:25Units that had fought
33:26for four years
33:27dissolved in hours.
33:29And in the hundred days
33:30that followed,
33:31from Amiens
33:32to the armistice,
33:33the four Canadian divisions,
33:35roughly 100,000 men,
33:37defeated or forced
33:38the retreat
33:39of 47 German divisions,
33:41one quarter
33:42of the entire German
33:43fighting force
33:44on the Western Front.
33:46British Prime Minister
33:47David Lloyd George,
33:48reflecting on the war,
33:49wrote a single sentence
33:51that carries the full weight
33:52of what the Canadians
33:53had achieved.
33:54Whenever the Germans
33:55found the Canadian Corps
33:57coming into the line,
33:58he wrote,
33:58they prepared for the worst.
34:00That sentence
34:01began in no man's land.
34:03It began with men
34:04lying in frozen mud
34:05with trench knives,
34:07making German patrols
34:08disappear without a sound.
34:10The silent death
34:11did not win the war
34:12by itself,
34:13but the fear it created
34:15became a reputation,
34:16and the reputation
34:17became a strategic instrument,
34:19and the strategic instrument
34:20helped break an army
34:22that had held
34:22the Western Front
34:23for four years.
34:25The war ended
34:26on the 11th hour
34:27of the 11th day
34:28of the 11th month
34:29of 1918.
34:31The last Canadian position
34:33captured was
34:33the Belgian city of Mons,
34:35where the British
34:36Expeditionary Force
34:37had fought its first battle
34:38in 1914.
34:40The circle closed.
34:42But there is one more
34:43part of this story
34:44that needs telling,
34:45and it is
34:46the quietest part.
34:47Henry Norwest
34:49did not see
34:49the end of the war.
34:51On August 18, 1918,
34:54three months before
34:55the armistice,
34:56the 50th Battalion
34:57was moving into position
34:58near Foucault
34:59during the advance
35:00from Amiens.
35:02Norwest and two other men
35:03were sent forward
35:04to locate a nest
35:05of German snipers
35:06that had been harassing
35:08the battalion's
35:08line of march.
35:09He found them.
35:10A German sniper
35:12found him at the same moment.
35:13The bullet killed him
35:14instantly.
35:15He was 37 years old.
35:17His battalion buried him
35:18where he fell.
35:20Victor Wheeler,
35:21who had served alongside him
35:22in the 50th,
35:23wrote about him
35:24after the war.
35:25Our famous sniper,
35:26he said,
35:27no doubt understood
35:28better than most of us
35:29the cost of life
35:30and the price of death.
35:32He went about his work
35:33with passionate dedication
35:34and showed complete detachment
35:36from everything
35:37while he was in the line.
35:38The men of the 50th
35:39erected a grave marker
35:41for him themselves,
35:42separate from the official one.
35:43They did not want
35:44the army's standard inscription.
35:46They wanted their own words
35:48for a man
35:48who had spent three years
35:50lying alone
35:51in the mud between the armies,
35:52doing the work
35:53that no one else could do.
35:56115 confirmed kills,
35:58a military medal,
36:00and bar.
36:01A MĂ©tis cowboy
36:02from Alberta
36:03who had been discharged
36:04once for misbehaviour,
36:05re-enlisted under
36:06a different name
36:07and became the most
36:08lethal sniper
36:09in the British
36:10expeditionary force.
36:12Francis Pegamagabo
36:13survived.
36:14He came home
36:15to the Wissoxing
36:16First Nation
36:16in 1919
36:17with three military medals,
36:20damaged lungs
36:20from the chlorine gas
36:21at Ypres,
36:22and a record
36:23that would not be matched
36:24by any sniper
36:25in any Allied army
36:27for the rest of the century.
36:31378 kills,
36:32over 300 captures,
36:35four years of crawling
36:36into no man's land
36:38and coming back alive.
36:40Canada did not
36:41treat him as a hero.
36:43The Indian Act
36:44still governed
36:45every aspect of his life.
36:47He could not vote,
36:48he could not leave
36:49the reserve
36:50without permission
36:50from an Indian agent.
36:52The skills that had made him
36:53the deadliest man
36:54on the Western Front
36:55were worth nothing
36:56in a country
36:57that classified him
36:58as a ward of the state.
36:59He spent the rest of his life
37:01fighting for indigenous rights,
37:03serving two terms
37:04as chief of his band,
37:05lobbying a government
37:06that had been happy
37:07to send him to war,
37:08but unwilling
37:09to grant him citizenship.
37:11He died of a heart attack
37:12on August 5, 1952.
37:15He was 63.
37:17Victor Odlum,
37:18the newspaper editor
37:19from Vancouver
37:20who had planned
37:21the first raid
37:22at Petite-Duve,
37:23survived both world wars.
37:25He commanded a division
37:26in the Second World War
37:27and later served
37:28as Canada's ambassador
37:30to Turkey
37:30and to China.
37:31He died in 1971
37:33at the age of 91.
37:35He never stopped talking
37:37about the men
37:37of the 7th Battalion.
37:39But most of the men
37:41who practiced the silent death
37:42left no names at all.
37:44They were not snipers
37:46with confirmed kills
37:47tallied in a logbook.
37:48They were not officers
37:50whose decisions
37:50were recorded
37:51in after-action reports.
37:53They were privates
37:54and corporals
37:55who crawled out
37:56into the dark
37:56with a knife
37:57and came back
37:58before dawn.
37:59And the only record
38:00of what they did
38:01is the absence
38:02in German patrol logs.
38:03Patrol dispatched.
38:05Patrol did not return.
38:07No enemy activity observed.
38:09That last line,
38:10written over and over
38:12in German company reports
38:13through 1916 and 1917,
38:16is the closest thing
38:17they have to a monument.
38:19It is a record of men
38:20who won by being invisible,
38:22by lying in the cold
38:23until their hands
38:24could barely grip,
38:25by breathing so quietly
38:26that a man six feet away
38:28could not hear them,
38:29by waiting,
38:30hour after hour,
38:32for a sound
38:32in the darkness
38:33that might or might not come.
38:35What froze German patrols
38:37and Canadian lines
38:38they expected empty
38:39was the simplest
38:40and oldest thing
38:41in warfare.
38:42Men who knew
38:43how to be still.
38:44Men whose patience
38:46was not trained
38:47but inherited
38:47from 10,000 nights
38:49in a country
38:50so vast
38:51and so quiet
38:51that silence
38:52was not a skill.
38:54It was a language.
38:55And the Canadians
38:56spoke it fluently.
38:58Thank you for spending
38:59this time
39:00with a story
39:00that most people
39:01have never heard.
39:02If it meant something to you,
39:04a like helps it reach
39:05the people
39:06who should hear it most,
39:07the families
39:08who lost someone
39:09between those trenches
39:10and never knew
39:11exactly what happened
39:12in the dark.
39:13If you are not subscribed,
39:15now is a good time.
39:16Hit the bell
39:17so you do not miss
39:18what is coming next.
39:19And I would love
39:20to hear from you.
39:21Where are you watching from?
39:22And if someone
39:24in your family
39:24served on the Allied side
39:26in the First
39:26or Second World War,
39:28tell us about them
39:29in the comments.
39:30Canadian,
39:30American,
39:31British,
39:32Australian,
39:33it does not matter.
39:34These stories
39:35belong to all of us.
39:37They deserve
39:37to be remembered.
Comments