00:01These scenes have shocked many across Turkey.
00:05Riot police seem forcing their way into the headquarters of the CHP, the country's largest opposition party.
00:12They use water cannons and tear gas against the party's resisting supporters.
00:17But apart from a few tweets and statements expressing concern, Europe's response has been remarkably restrained. Why?
00:24Nacho Sanchez-Amor is the European Parliament's lead expert on Turkey.
00:30He's been tracking the country's democratic record and its long-stalled bid to join the European Union.
00:36The silence is the result of a bad assessment of the whole relation with Turkey.
00:41The level of repression is so black until clear that is not a minor signal of going backwards. It's a
00:50trend.
00:51The confrontation did not come out of nowhere.
00:53Opposition parties in Turkey have faced years of mounting pressure.
00:57A controversial court ruling in May is merely the latest flashpoint.
01:01It removed CHP leader Özgür Özel and reinstated former chairman Kemal Kılıçdaroğlu, who lost the 2023 presidential election to Erdogan.
01:11Critics see the decision as part of a wider crackdown on the opposition.
01:15In the past two years, hundreds of CHP politicians and officials have been arrested over alleged corruption charges, among them
01:23Istanbul Mayor Ekrem İmamoğlu.
01:25He was widely regarded as President Recep Tayyip Erdogan's strongest challenger.
01:29But Turkey is still officially a candidate for EU membership.
01:34So what's driving Europe's silence?
01:36Part of the answer is geopolitics.
01:38Turkey has NATO's second largest military and controls access to the Black Sea, crucial in the EU's security calculations as
01:46Russia's war against Ukraine continues.
01:48Many European governments increasingly see Ankara as strategically indispensable.
01:54Turkey is a very important country for many aspects and many parts of our relations.
02:00And one of these parts is security and defence.
02:02A decade ago, European leadership was far more vocal about Turkey's democratic backsliding.
02:08But today, priorities have shifted.
02:10Energy security, migration, regional conflicts.
02:14These concerns now dominate the relationship between Brussels and Ankara.
02:18And that appears to give President Erdogan more room to manoeuvre.
02:22This is our blindness.
02:23Our blindness is requested by the Turkish.
02:26Please, let's talk about security and defence.
02:29Let's talk about pipelines.
02:30Let's talk about the cast of unions.
02:33But please, don't look to the prisons.
02:36Don't look to the civil society.
02:38Don't look to the journalists.
02:40Don't look to the LGBT people.
02:42Don't look to the universities.
02:43For many opposition supporters, the silence is felt on the ground.
02:49Europe needs to support the people in this country.
02:51We have members of parliament, mayors, students who were detained.
02:57They're throwing everyone who speaks out into jail.
03:03They are acting pragmatically, prioritising their own national interests.
03:07But we, as the Turkish people, feel like we've been left alone.
03:12President Erdogan portrays the CHP's crisis as an internal party conflict.
03:18His government rejects accusations.
03:20It is using the courts to target political opponents.
03:24And that it is moving away from democratic norms.
03:27Observers disagree.
03:29The European Union is still a club of democracies.
03:31And for that reason, we have to repeat to the Turkish authorities.
03:35If you want to really join the European Union, this is not about military power.
03:39This is not about geopolitics.
03:40This is not about trade.
03:41This is about democracy.
03:43For many here in Turkey, the concerns now go far beyond one opposition party.
03:48What will the next elections look like if the pressure continues?
03:52And will Europe find its voice again?
Comments