He Said 'She's With Me'- The Cold Ceo's Revenge Against My Toxic Ex

JournalismJourney

Transcript

00:00:00I had been in the ballroom for exactly 17 minutes when I saw her,

00:00:03and in those 17 minutes I had eaten one canapé,

00:00:06declined two drinks,

00:00:08and rehearsed approximately four versions of what I would say

00:00:11if I ran into anyone I knew.

00:00:12None of those rehearsals had accounted for Vivian Hart

00:00:15standing under a chandelier in a champagne-colored gown,

00:00:18laughing at something the woman beside her had said,

00:00:20looking exactly the way she had looked the night she told me

00:00:23she had been seeing someone else for six months.

00:00:25My champagne flute went cold against my fingers.

00:00:28Across the room,

00:00:30Celine Marchetti turned her head,

00:00:31found my face,

00:00:32and started walking toward me with the unhurried precision

00:00:35of a woman who had decided something.

00:00:37If you want to hear uncensored,

00:00:39too hot for YouTube stories,

00:00:40check out my Patreon in the description,

00:00:43tell us where you are watching from,

00:00:44and subscribe.

00:00:45I had not wanted to come to this gala.

00:00:47I had told my publisher exactly that.

00:00:49Three weeks ago.

00:00:50In the small, overheated office on the 14th floor

00:00:53where my publisher conducted all difficult conversations

00:00:55because the radiator made it uncomfortable enough

00:00:58that nobody wanted to extend them.

00:00:59I had said,

00:01:01with the calm of a woman who had spent six months

00:01:03rebuilding a sense of self after a long and public dismantling,

00:01:06that I did not have the energy for a black-tie literary fundraiser

00:01:10where every person in attendance would have read

00:01:12the New York Times piece about my novel,

00:01:14and approximately 40% of them would also have read the smaller,

00:01:18meaner piece in a publication I refused to name

00:01:21about the dissolution of my engagement.

00:01:23My publisher had looked at me over her reading glasses and said,

00:01:26with the same calm,

00:01:27that the gala was not optional,

00:01:29that my novel was up for an award,

00:01:31that my absence would be read as either weakness or arrogance,

00:01:34and neither was a brand we wanted to build right now.

00:01:37So I had bought the dress.

00:01:39Black, long-sleeved, high-necked,

00:01:41the kind of dress that read as armor to anyone paying attention

00:01:44and as elegance to anyone who was not.

00:01:46I had pinned my hair up the way I pinned it up for readings,

00:01:50which was the version of myself I trusted most in public.

00:01:53I had taken a car service to the venue alone

00:01:55because the alternative was asking someone to attend with me

00:01:58and I had not yet identified anyone in my life I could ask

00:02:01without feeling that I owed them something afterward.

00:02:03I had walked into the ballroom with a clean spine and a steady hand

00:02:06and I had eaten one canapé

00:02:08and I had declined two drinks and I had been doing fine.

00:02:12And then there was Vivian, under the chandelier, laughing.

00:02:15Vivian Hart had been my fiancée for two years and three months.

00:02:19She had ended our engagement on a Sunday in October

00:02:21by telling me, over coffee at the Kitchen Island

00:02:24in the apartment we had bought together,

00:02:26that she had been seeing the woman from her firm's London office for six months

00:02:30and was choosing to be honest about it now

00:02:32because she had decided to move there in the spring.

00:02:34The honesty had been, in Vivian's framing, a generosity.

00:02:38The six months had been, in Vivian's framing,

00:02:41a regrettable necessity she had needed to give herself permission to feel

00:02:45before she could communicate it.

00:02:47The woman from the London office had been with her at our engagement party in July.

00:02:51I had served her a slice of cake.

00:02:52It was a particular cruelty.

00:02:54The dress code of the gala?

00:02:56Because it ensured that Vivian would look the way she had looked

00:02:59at the engagement party composed and beautiful and unbothered,

00:03:02and it ensured that I would have to look at her looking that way

00:03:05without any visible armor of my continuators.

00:03:08I turned away from the chandelier with the kind of casual neck movement I had practiced.

00:03:13I located the nearest bar.

00:03:14I did not actually want a drink, but the bar was a destination,

00:03:18and a destination is what a woman who is being watched

00:03:20needs more than anything in a room she has not yet figured out how to exit.

00:03:23I had taken three steps when Celine Marchetti said my name.

00:03:27It was not loud.

00:03:28It was not theatrical.

00:03:29It was the way she said everything at exactly the volume the conversation required,

00:03:33no more, no less, calibrated for the specific acoustic of the room she was in.

00:03:39Saram, she said.

00:03:40I stopped.

00:03:42Celine was the CEO of the publishing house's parent company.

00:03:45I had met her exactly twice.

00:03:47The first time had been at the contract signing for my novel,

00:03:50in a glass-walled conference room on the 32nd floor,

00:03:53where she had sat across from me in a charcoal suit

00:03:56and had asked three questions about the book that had been more incisive

00:03:59than the questions any of the editors had asked

00:04:01over the course of the 18-month acquisition process.

00:04:04The second time had been at a quarterly author's luncheon,

00:04:07where she had stood at the back of the room

00:04:09and had not said a single word during the formal presentations

00:04:12and had then, in the brief mingling period afterward,

00:04:15walked directly to me and asked me how the second draft was going,

00:04:19in a tone that suggested she had read the first one carefully.

00:04:22She was 41 years old.

00:04:23She was, professionally speaking,

00:04:26the most powerful woman in the building I worked in,

00:04:28which was a building I worked in only contractually but still.

00:04:31She had a way of moving through rooms

00:04:33that made the rooms reorganize themselves around her

00:04:36without her appearing to ask them to.

00:04:38She wore tonight what she had worn both other times I had seen her,

00:04:41which was a tailored suit black tonight,

00:04:43with a silk blouse, the exact color of bone,

00:04:46and a watch on her right wrist

00:04:47that caught the chandelier light once when she lifted her hand.

00:04:50Her hair was pulled back.

00:04:52It was always pulled back.

00:04:53I had decided, sometime during the contract signing,

00:04:56that this was the most disciplined hairstyle I had ever seen

00:05:00on a woman who was not being televised.

00:05:02I turned and met her eyes.

00:05:04Selene? I said.

00:05:05She was three feet away, then two.

00:05:08Then she was beside me,

00:05:10close enough that I could smell her perfume,

00:05:12something quiet and expensive,

00:05:14cedar under citrus,

00:05:15the kind of scent that did not announce itself

00:05:17but stayed with you afterward in a way you could not quite identify.

00:05:20You look like you're heading somewhere, she said.

00:05:22The bar? I said.

00:05:24She glanced toward the bar, then back at me.

00:05:27Her eyes were a gray that read brown in some light

00:05:29and brown that read gray in others,

00:05:31and tonight, in the chandelier light,

00:05:33they were doing the gray version.

00:05:35I'll walk with you, she said.

00:05:37This was not a question.

00:05:38It was also not a command.

00:05:40It was the thing Selene Marchetti said that I had begun to recognize

00:05:43in our two prior encounters,

00:05:45as her particular grammatical construction,

00:05:48a statement of intent that allowed the person on the receiving end

00:05:51to refuse if they wanted to,

00:05:53while making clear that refusing would require an actual refusal,

00:05:56a sentence with a no in it,

00:05:58which was a sentence most people did not produce in time.

00:06:01I did not produce it in time.

00:06:02She fell into step beside me.

00:06:04The bar was about 30 feet away,

00:06:06on the far side of a small clutch of foundation board members in evening wear,

00:06:10who were laughing too loudly at something one of them had said.

00:06:13I navigated around them.

00:06:15Selene navigated around them in the half-step behind me

00:06:18that allowed me to set the pace without making either of us aware that she was doing it.

00:06:22I felt Vivian's attention before I saw it.

00:06:24There is a particular weight to being looked at by someone who used to know your body,

00:06:28and I felt it land between my shoulder blades approximately four feet before we reached the bar.

00:06:33I did not turn around.

00:06:34What are you drinking?

00:06:35Selene asked.

00:06:37Sparkling water, I said.

00:06:38She lifted one finger to the bartender,

00:06:40who appeared in front of her in the way bartenders appear

00:06:43when they have correctly identified the most important person at their bar.

00:06:46Selene ordered the sparkling water and a glass of wine for herself.

00:06:50Her ordering was efficient and uncomplicated,

00:06:53the way she did everything,

00:06:54and the bartender was gone again in eight seconds with a small nod.

00:06:58Selene turned and put her back to the bar.

00:07:00Her shoulder was not touching mine.

00:07:02She was simply standing beside me at a slight angle that made it clear,

00:07:05to anyone watching,

00:07:07that we were together,

00:07:08not in any romantic sense,

00:07:09just in the practical sense of two people

00:07:11who had arrived at the bar in the same conversation

00:07:14and had not yet ended it.

00:07:15She said quietly,

00:07:17You should look at me when she walks over here.

00:07:19I went still.

00:07:20I beg your pardon,

00:07:21I said.

00:07:23Selene did not look toward Vivian.

00:07:24Her eyes stayed on my face,

00:07:26the unhurried steadiness of a woman who had no doubt about what she had seen.

00:07:30She is looking at you,

00:07:31Selene said.

00:07:32She has been looking at you since you came in.

00:07:34She has spent the last 90 seconds talking to the woman beside her

00:07:38about something she is no longer interested in

00:07:40and in approximately two minutes,

00:07:42she will excuse herself and walk over here

00:07:44because she has decided she needs to know whether you came alone.

00:07:47I stared at her.

00:07:49How do you know that?

00:07:50I said.

00:07:50I have been watching the room,

00:07:52Selene said.

00:07:53It is what I do at these events.

00:07:55I have not seen you watching the room.

00:07:57That is also what I do.

00:07:58The bartender returned with our drinks.

00:08:01Selene took her wine and turned slightly

00:08:03so that her body angled toward mine,

00:08:04which had the effect, from across the room,

00:08:07of placing me at the center of her attention

00:08:09in a way that was visually unmistakable to a third party

00:08:12but did not actually involve any contact at all.

00:08:15I was very aware of how close she was standing.

00:08:18I said,

00:08:18Why are you doing this?

00:08:19She looked at me.

00:08:21The chandelier light on her face

00:08:22was doing something that made her look both younger and more deliberate,

00:08:25which was the kind of contradiction I had been trained,

00:08:28by my own writing practice,

00:08:30to notice.

00:08:31She said,

00:08:32Because six weeks ago I read a piece about you

00:08:34in a publication I will not name

00:08:36and I do not believe a person

00:08:38should have to walk into a room like this

00:08:39without someone beside them

00:08:41and I am not making any other claim about it than that.

00:08:43I absorbed this.

00:08:45I said,

00:08:46You read the piece.

00:08:47I read everything that touches the company,

00:08:49she said.

00:08:50That piece did not touch the company.

00:08:52It touched my author, she said.

00:08:54The word my did something specific in my chest.

00:08:57I cataloged it and refused to look at it directly.

00:08:59I said,

00:09:00That is more than I expected from a CEO.

00:09:02I am not a typical CEO,

00:09:05she said,

00:09:06and the corner of her mouth did something that might have been a smile if it had committed.

00:09:09I drank the sparkling water.

00:09:11The bubbles were doing their small, useful work against the back of my throat.

00:09:15Across the room,

00:09:16I could feel Vivian's attention shift

00:09:18and shift again

00:09:19and then I felt the specific moment where she made a decision

00:09:22because her conversation with the woman beside her

00:09:24ended visibly a polite touch on the woman's arm,

00:09:27a half step away,

00:09:29a full step.

00:09:30She is moving,

00:09:31I said quietly.

00:09:32I see her,

00:09:33Solene said.

00:09:34Solene shifted her weight.

00:09:36It was a small motion,

00:09:38the kind of weight redistribution that happens when a person is preparing to do something specific.

00:09:42Her right hand,

00:09:44the one with the watch,

00:09:45moved from the bar to a point just behind me not touching,

00:09:48just present,

00:09:49the way a hand is present when a hand is about to be involved in something.

00:09:53She said,

00:09:54very quietly,

00:09:55tell me now if this is not what you want.

00:09:57I looked at her.

00:09:58I had four seconds,

00:10:00maybe five.

00:10:01Vivian was crossing the floor with the long,

00:10:04even stride she used when she had decided she was going to do something graceful in front of an audience.

00:10:09The smile on her face was the public smile,

00:10:11the one she had used on partners and clients and judges,

00:10:14the one that meant I am about to be charming at you in a way you cannot decline without being

00:10:19the rude one.

00:10:19I said,

00:10:20this is what I want.

00:10:22Solene's hand moved.

00:10:23It went to my waist.

00:10:25Just my waist.

00:10:26Not a grab.

00:10:27Not a possession.

00:10:28Just the warm flat of her palm at the curve where my dress sat against my hip.

00:10:32The contact specific and steady and entirely unambiguous to anyone watching.

00:10:36Her thumb stayed still.

00:10:38Her fingers did not press.

00:10:40It was the gesture of a woman who had no need to perform her certainty because the certainty was already

00:10:45there.

00:10:45It was the most contact I had experienced from another person in six months.

00:10:50I forgot how to breathe correctly for approximately three seconds.

00:10:53Vivian arrived.

00:10:55Serum, she said.

00:10:56Her voice was bright and warm in the way she had perfected for difficult rooms.

00:11:00She was beautiful.

00:11:01I could acknowledge it without it costing me anything anymore,

00:11:04which was a piece of information I was going to need to sit with later.

00:11:07The champagne dress moved well.

00:11:09Her hair was different than it had been in October,

00:11:12shorter, more deliberate.

00:11:13London had been good to her in some surface ways,

00:11:16and I refused to begrudge her that.

00:11:18Vivian, I said.

00:11:19I had not prepared a tone for her name.

00:11:21The tone that came out was the one I used for distant colleagues,

00:11:25neutral and unweighted,

00:11:26and I was grateful to whatever part of myself had produced it without consultation.

00:11:30Vivian's eyes moved to Solene,

00:11:32the smile adjusted by some small percentage.

00:11:34I don't think we've met, she said.

00:11:37Solene, said Solene.

00:11:39Her voice was the one she used in the conference room.

00:11:41Surgical.

00:11:42No warmer or colder than was professionally appropriate.

00:11:46She did not extend her hand.

00:11:47The hand was occupied.

00:11:49Vivian's eyes flicked, with a precision I remembered,

00:11:53to the place where Solene's hand was sitting at my waist.

00:11:55She is with me, Solene said.

00:11:58The sentence was short and complete.

00:12:00It did not editorialize.

00:12:01It did not perform.

00:12:02It was offered the way Solene offered everything as information,

00:12:06accurate and uncluttered,

00:12:07with the implication that arguing with the information was a waste of the room's time.

00:12:12Vivian's smile held.

00:12:13I knew this smile.

00:12:14It was the smile she used when she had been told something she had not expected,

00:12:18and had decided to absorb it without flinching.

00:12:21It was, professionally speaking,

00:12:23an extremely effective smile,

00:12:25and it was one of the things I had loved about her once,

00:12:27because it had meant she could handle difficult news without making the room hold her.

00:12:31I had loved a number of things about Vivian.

00:12:34None of them had survived October.

00:12:36How nice, Vivian said.

00:12:38Her voice was perfectly calibrated.

00:12:40To meet someone Saram is seeing.

00:12:42Solene did not respond to this.

00:12:44She did not confirm the framing or correct it.

00:12:47She looked at Vivian with the unhurried attention she had brought to the bar

00:12:50and waited for whatever Vivian was going to do next.

00:12:53Vivian, to her credit, recovered quickly.

00:12:55She turned her attention back to me.

00:12:57You look well, she said.

00:12:59Thank you, I said.

00:13:01I read the Times piece.

00:13:03Congratulations on the book.

00:13:04Thank you, I said again.

00:13:05I had a sentence I had been working on for six months,

00:13:08in the small private editing room of my own head,

00:13:11for exactly this conversation.

00:13:13I had drafted and redrafted it.

00:13:15I had a version that was cutting,

00:13:17and a version that was civil,

00:13:18and a version that was forgiving in a way that would have cost me nothing

00:13:20because I had not actually forgiven anything.

00:13:23I had memorized all three.

00:13:25I did not use any of them.

00:13:26I said,

00:13:27Was there something you wanted, Vivian?

00:13:30It was not cruel.

00:13:31It was just direct.

00:13:32The tone was the one I had practiced in the mirror of my new apartment

00:13:35for approximately three weeks before I had given up practicing

00:13:38and decided I would simply produce whatever came out.

00:13:41Vivian's smile did the small adjustment again.

00:13:44I just wanted to say hello, she said.

00:13:46You said it, I said.

00:13:48A small silence.

00:13:49Celine did not move.

00:13:50Her hand stayed exactly where it was.

00:13:53She did not look at Vivian with any particular hostility.

00:13:55She looked at her with the steady, unaroused interest of a woman watching a scene she had

00:14:00correctly anticipated.

00:14:02Vivian said, with the brightness slightly tighter,

00:14:04It's good to see you doing well, Saram.

00:14:07I said,

00:14:08Thank you for coming over.

00:14:09She turned.

00:14:10She walked back across the ballroom with the same long, even stride.

00:14:14The champagne gown moved.

00:14:15The woman she had been talking to under the chandelier looked up,

00:14:18and her face did the small thing faces do when they have been waiting for information

00:14:22and have just received it.

00:14:24I exhaled.

00:14:25It came out shaky.

00:14:26Celine's hand stayed at my waist for one more beat.

00:14:29Then, with the same unhurried grace she had done everything else with all evening,

00:14:34it moved away.

00:14:35I said,

00:14:36I owe you a drink.

00:14:37She said,

00:14:38You owe me nothing.

00:14:39I said,

00:14:40I am buying you a drink anyway.

00:14:42She said,

00:14:42I will accept the drink,

00:14:44but you do not owe me anything.

00:14:45I want you to be clear about that.

00:14:47I looked at her.

00:14:48She was looking at me with the same steady attention she had brought to the entire encounter,

00:14:52and now that the encounter was over,

00:14:55the attention did not redirect.

00:14:56She did not check the room.

00:14:58She did not look toward the rest of the gala.

00:15:00She looked at me,

00:15:01and I had the disorienting sense,

00:15:03sitting at the bar of a room I had not wanted to enter,

00:15:06that I had become,

00:15:07for the duration of this conversation,

00:15:09the only thing she was actually here for.

00:15:11I said,

00:15:12Why did you do that?

00:15:14She said,

00:15:15I told you why.

00:15:16You told me partially.

00:15:18She conceded this with a small movement of her head.

00:15:20She said,

00:15:21I do not like watching people be ambushed in rooms they did not choose to be ambushed in,

00:15:26particularly people whose work I respect.

00:15:28Whose work you respect?

00:15:30I said.

00:15:31She said,

00:15:31Yes.

00:15:32There is more,

00:15:33I said.

00:15:34I was not asking.

00:15:35I was stating it.

00:15:37I was a writer.

00:15:38I knew the difference between a complete answer,

00:15:40and an answer with the corners trimmed off.

00:15:42She said,

00:15:44There is more.

00:15:45I am not going to tell you what the more is in the bar of a fundraiser.

00:15:48We have not earned that conversation yet.

00:15:51We,

00:15:51I said.

00:15:52She said,

00:15:53I am using the word loosely.

00:15:55I drank the sparkling water.

00:15:57My hand was steady on the glass.

00:15:59Across the room,

00:16:00Vivian had rejoined the woman in the champagne dress and was performing the recovery she had perfected,

00:16:05and I felt for the first time in six months that I had survived an encounter with her without losing

00:16:11anything.

00:16:12I said,

00:16:13What do I do now?

00:16:14Celine said,

00:16:15You stay.

00:16:16You eat dinner.

00:16:17You attend the awards portion.

00:16:19You leave when you are ready.

00:16:20I said,

00:16:21Will you stay?

00:16:22She said,

00:16:23I am already staying.

00:16:24I have a table.

00:16:26You may sit at it if you like,

00:16:27but you do not have to.

00:16:29Your publisher has placed you at table 14.

00:16:31I have asked.

00:16:32You can sit where you were assigned.

00:16:34Nothing about this evening requires you to do anything else.

00:16:37I looked at her.

00:16:38I said,

00:16:39I would like to sit at your table.

00:16:41A pause.

00:16:42She said,

00:16:43Good.

00:16:43She did not say anything else about it.

00:16:45She did not perform any reaction.

00:16:47She picked up her wine glass and took one careful sip and set it down again,

00:16:51and the simplicity of the gesture undid something in my chest that I had been carrying since the bar.

00:16:56We left the bar together.

00:16:58She did not put her hand back on my waist.

00:17:00She did not need to.

00:17:01The room had filed the information.

00:17:04Soline's table was at the front of the ballroom,

00:17:06near the small stage where the awards would be given out later.

00:17:09There were nine other people already seated when we arrived,

00:17:11and she introduced me to each of them by name and by a single descriptive sentence,

00:17:16the editor of a literary quarterly I admired,

00:17:18a board member of the foundation,

00:17:20a translator from the Spanish I had read twice.

00:17:23She did not introduce me as my author.

00:17:25She introduced me as Sarum Voss,

00:17:27whose novel was nominated tonight,

00:17:29and whose work she found exceptional.

00:17:31And then she sat down beside me without making any more of it.

00:17:34Dinner was served.

00:17:35The conversation around the table was the conversation that happened at literary tables discursive

00:17:40and a little arch and self-aware about its own architecture.

00:17:43Soline contributed exactly enough to be a present participant and not one syllable more.

00:17:47She did not perform.

00:17:49She listened.

00:17:50And when she spoke, she said something that moved the conversation forward by some small,

00:17:55useful increment, and then she was quiet again.

00:17:58Twice during the meal, her arm brushed mine on the table.

00:18:00Both times she did not move it away.

00:18:02Both times she did not look at me.

00:18:04The contact lasted only as long as the natural movement of her arm required,

00:18:08but I noticed it and I knew, without confirming, that she had noticed it too.

00:18:12I thought about the hand at my waist.

00:18:15I thought about it through the salad course and through the entree and through the speeches

00:18:18that preceded the awards.

00:18:20And by the time the foundation president stood at the podium and began the introduction for

00:18:24my category, I had thought about it enough that I had begun to understand certain things.

00:18:29I had begun to understand that Soline Marchetti had not happened to be at the bar when I was

00:18:33at the bar.

00:18:34I had begun to understand that her ordering had been unhurried in a way that suggested

00:18:38she had known what she was going to do before I asked her why she was doing it.

00:18:43I had begun to understand that the table I was now seated at had, in fact, had a vacant

00:18:47seat beside her when I arrived, even though there were ten places set, and that I was,

00:18:52mathematically, the eleventh person.

00:18:55I had begun to understand that the publishing house's CEO had read the smaller,

00:18:59meaner piece in the publication I refuse to name.

00:19:01That she had, by her own admission, read it six weeks ago.

00:19:05That this was, in practical terms, six weeks during which she had been in possession of

00:19:10information about me that no professional context required her to know, and she had

00:19:14not done anything with that information until tonight.

00:19:17I had begun to understand that what had happened at the bar had not been a rescue.

00:19:21It had been something else, something more deliberate, something with more architecture

00:19:25than I had at first assumed.

00:19:27I won the award.

00:19:28I had not expected to.

00:19:30I had told myself I had not expected to, partly because I had not, and partly because telling

00:19:35yourself you have not expected something is one of the most reliable ways of surviving

00:19:40the moment when you do not get it.

00:19:41I stood at the small podium with the trophy in my hand, and I gave the speech I had prepared

00:19:46in case, and I thanked my editor, and my agent, and my publisher, and I did not thank Vivian,

00:19:52and I did not thank Solene, and I sat back down.

00:19:55Solene beside me did not say anything immediately.

00:19:57She let me sit.

00:19:59She let the room return to its noise.

00:20:01She let my publisher come over from her own table to congratulate me, and she let my editor

00:20:06cry a little, and she stayed quiet while all of this happened.

00:20:09The way a person stays quiet who understands that the moment is not theirs.

00:20:13When my publisher and editor had returned to their seats, Solene leaned slightly toward

00:20:17me.

00:20:17She said very quietly,

00:20:19Your speech was good.

00:20:20I said thank you.

00:20:22She said,

00:20:23The line about finishing a thing without the person you started it with, that was a precise

00:20:28sentence.

00:20:28I had written that line at three in the morning approximately a month ago, and I had cut it

00:20:33from the prepared remarks twice and put it back three times, and I had read it tonight

00:20:37without certainty about whether I should have included it.

00:20:39I had decided to include it because I had decided I was going to be done apologizing for

00:20:43the existence of certain sentences in my own life.

00:20:46I said,

00:20:47Thank you for noticing it.

00:20:48She said,

00:20:49I noticed all of it.

00:20:50I looked at her.

00:20:51She looked back.

00:20:52She did not flinch from the look.

00:20:54She did not redirect it.

00:20:56She held my eyes the way she had held them at the bar, the way she had held them in

00:21:00the

00:21:00conference room six months ago and at the author's luncheon four months ago, and I

00:21:04understood, with the late and awful clarity that comes to writers eventually, that she

00:21:09had been holding my eyes that way every time.

00:21:11I said,

00:21:12Selene.

00:21:12She said,

00:21:13Yes.

00:21:14I said,

00:21:15Are you going to tell me what the more is?

00:21:17A pause.

00:21:18The room hummed around us.

00:21:19The awards were continuing on the stage,

00:21:21but the speeches had moved to categories that did not concern us, and the table was occupied

00:21:26with its own small conversations, and we had, for one specific window, a private conversation

00:21:32inside a public room.

00:21:33She said,

00:21:34Not here.

00:21:35I said,

00:21:36Where?

00:21:36She said,

00:21:38That depends on whether you want me to.

00:21:40I held my glass.

00:21:41The sparkling water was warm now, the bubbles long gone.

00:21:44I thought about the bar.

00:21:46I thought about the hand.

00:21:47I thought about six weeks of being carried, without knowing it, in the attention of a

00:21:51woman I had met twice in my professional life, and whom I had not previously understood

00:21:56to be carrying me in any way.

00:21:58I said,

00:21:59I want you to.

00:22:00She said,

00:22:01Then we will have the conversation.

00:22:03Not tonight.

00:22:04You have just won an award, and your ex-fiancee is across the room, and you are tired in ways

00:22:08you have not yet noticed.

00:22:10I am not going to ask you to hold a conversation of that weight at the end of a night

00:22:13like this

00:22:14one.

00:22:14I said,

00:22:15When?

00:22:16She said,

00:22:17I am going to send you my number tonight.

00:22:18You will message me when you are ready.

00:22:20It might be tomorrow.

00:22:22It might be next week.

00:22:23It might be next month.

00:22:24I have no schedule for it.

00:22:26I said,

00:22:27You have a schedule for everything.

00:22:29She said,

00:22:30I have a schedule for everything except this.

00:22:32The corner of her mouth did the thing again.

00:22:35The thing that might have been a smile if it committed.

00:22:37I said,

00:22:38That is a generous policy.

00:22:39She said,

00:22:40It is the only honest one.

00:22:42The awards ended.

00:22:43The applause moved through its final cycle.

00:22:46The room began the slow deconstruction that ballrooms perform at the end of long evenings.

00:22:50Chairs pushed back.

00:22:52Jackets retrieved.

00:22:53The polite scattering of people who had been politely contained for hours.

00:22:56I gathered my small purse.

00:22:58I gathered the trophy.

00:23:00Selene rose with me.

00:23:01I said,

00:23:02I am taking a car home.

00:23:04She said,

00:23:04I will walk you to the door.

00:23:06Not the car.

00:23:07The door.

00:23:08So that the room sees you are leaving with company.

00:23:11I said,

00:23:12You have thought about this in detail.

00:23:14She said,

00:23:15I have thought about a number of things in detail.

00:23:18We walked toward the exit.

00:23:19I felt the room organize itself around our movement the way it had organized itself around

00:23:24her arrival earlier in the evening.

00:23:26I felt Vivian see us.

00:23:27I did not turn to confirm it.

00:23:29I had stopped needing to confirm it.

00:23:31At the door of the ballroom,

00:23:33in the small marble vestibule between the room and the coat check,

00:23:36Selene stopped.

00:23:38She said,

00:23:38I am sending you my number now.

00:23:40She lifted her phone.

00:23:41I felt mine vibrate in my purse a moment later.

00:23:44The contact transfer was quick and uncomplicated.

00:23:47The way she did everything.

00:23:49She said,

00:23:50Saram.

00:23:50I said,

00:23:51Yes.

00:23:52She said,

00:23:53Whatever you decide about the conversation,

00:23:55you should know that the part at the bar was not about Vivian.

00:23:58I want you to be clear about that.

00:23:59I said,

00:24:00What was it about?

00:24:02She said,

00:24:03That is the conversation.

00:24:04I looked at her.

00:24:05I said,

00:24:06Good night, Selene.

00:24:06She said,

00:24:07Good night.

00:24:08I retrieved my coat.

00:24:10I walked through the lobby.

00:24:11I got into the car my publisher had ordered,

00:24:13and I rode home through the wet November streets with the trophy in my lap and the phone in my

00:24:17hand

00:24:18and the warmth of a stranger's palm still ghosting at my waist where no one had touched me for six

00:24:23months.

00:24:23I did not message Selene that night.

00:24:25I did not message her the next day.

00:24:27I did not message her on Sunday or Monday or Tuesday.

00:24:31I did not message her because I was a writer and I knew the value of a sentence said at

00:24:36the right time,

00:24:36and I did not yet know what the sentence was going to be.

00:24:39I messaged her on Wednesday evening at 6.14.

00:24:42I wrote,

00:24:44I would like to have the conversation.

00:24:46Three minutes passed.

00:24:47Then she wrote back,

00:24:48Friday.

00:24:497.

00:24:50There is a small place on 11th I will send you the address for.

00:24:53If you want a car, I will send one.

00:24:55If you want to come on your own, you may.

00:24:58I wrote,

00:24:59I will come on my own.

00:25:00Then she wrote,

00:25:01Good.

00:25:02She did not write anything else.

00:25:03The conversation closed cleanly.

00:25:05The way she closed all conversations.

00:25:07I put the phone face down on the kitchen counter of the small new apartment I had rented after October.

00:25:13The one I had chosen because it had a window that opened onto a courtyard with a single ginkgo tree.

00:25:18The one I had been calling,

00:25:19in the privacy of my own head,

00:25:21the apartment where I get to start over.

00:25:23I stood at the counter for a long moment.

00:25:26I thought about the hand at my waist.

00:25:27I thought about the line in my acceptance speech.

00:25:30I thought about a CEO who read everything that touched the company and who had read a piece six weeks

00:25:35ago that did not,

00:25:36professionally speaking, have any business landing on her desk,

00:25:40and who had carried me in the periphery of her attention for six weeks before producing one specific sentence in

00:25:45a ballroom about whose architecture she had clearly been thinking for some time.

00:25:49I thought about all of it.

00:25:51I went to bed early.

00:25:52I did not sleep well.

00:25:54I dreamed, more than once, of a champagne-colored gown and a black suit and the small surgical sentence she

00:25:59is with me,

00:26:00and I woke at five with the specific clarity of a writer who has been given material whether she wanted

00:26:05it or not.

00:26:06Friday came slowly.

00:26:07The small place on 11th turned out to be a restaurant with 12 tables and a bar in the back,

00:26:12the kind of place that did not advertise and did not need to,

00:26:15the kind of place a person took someone when they wanted the conversation to be private,

00:26:19and the privacy to be by virtue of the room rather than by any obvious effort.

00:26:23I arrived at 6.58.

00:26:25The host, a young woman with a clean face and quick hands,

00:26:28took my coat without my needing to give a name.

00:26:30She said,

00:26:31Miss Marchetti is at the back.

00:26:33She said you would be coming.

00:26:34I followed her through the small, crowded room.

00:26:37Solene was at a corner table by a window,

00:26:39the kind of corner that allowed her to see the entire room and the door and to be seen by

00:26:43both.

00:26:44She was in a black sweater tonight, soft-looking,

00:26:46the kind of person wears when she is not trying to communicate authority and dark trousers.

00:26:51Her hair was down.

00:26:52It was the first time I had ever seen her hair down.

00:26:55It changed her face by some amount I did not have language for yet.

00:26:58She rose when I came in.

00:27:00She did not extend a hand.

00:27:01She simply waited until I was at the table,

00:27:03and then she sat when I sat.

00:27:05The kind of small, old-fashioned courtesy that some women still performed and that I had,

00:27:10until that moment, found vaguely unnecessary.

00:27:12I did not find it vaguely unnecessary in this case.

00:27:16She said,

00:27:17Saram.

00:27:17I said,

00:27:18Solene.

00:27:19She said,

00:27:21Thank you for coming.

00:27:22I said,

00:27:23Thank you for not pressuring me.

00:27:24She said,

00:27:25I told you I had no schedule for this.

00:27:27I meant it.

00:27:28The host left a small carafe of water and two glasses and disappeared.

00:27:32The way the staff at restaurants of this kind disappeared efficient and discreet,

00:27:36the way I imagined the staff of Solene's life disappeared when she required it.

00:27:40I poured the water.

00:27:41My hands were steady.

00:27:42I had decided,

00:27:43on the walkover,

00:27:45that I was going to be a writer at this dinner and not a woman who had been left by

00:27:48her fiancé six months ago,

00:27:49and the two were not the same thing,

00:27:51and tonight I needed the writer.

00:27:53I said,

00:27:54Tell me what the more is.

00:27:56She said,

00:27:57Are you sure?

00:27:58I said,

00:27:59I have spent five days thinking about whether I am sure.

00:28:02I am sure.

00:28:03She looked at me.

00:28:04In the warmer light of this restaurant,

00:28:06with her hair down and the soft sweater and the unhurried directness she brought to every sentence,

00:28:11Solene Marchetti looked less like a CEO and more like a person,

00:28:15and the difference was the kind of difference that destabilizes a room if you are not braced for it.

00:28:20I was braced for it.

00:28:21I had spent five days bracing.

00:28:23She said,

00:28:24I read your novel two summers ago,

00:28:26in manuscript,

00:28:27before the acquisition.

00:28:29I said,

00:28:29I did not know that.

00:28:31She said,

00:28:32It is not unusual.

00:28:33I read the manuscripts of acquisitions over a certain advanced threshold.

00:28:37Yours was at that threshold.

00:28:38I said,

00:28:39All right.

00:28:40She said,

00:28:41I read your novel and I was not the same after I read it.

00:28:44I want you to understand the language I am using.

00:28:46I am not using the language of a person who appreciated a book.

00:28:49I am using the language of a person whose internal weather changed because of something she read,

00:28:54and who then sat with that change for two summers without any context for what to do with it.

00:28:59I said nothing.

00:29:00She said,

00:29:01I came to the contract signing because I wanted to see what the woman who wrote that book looked like

00:29:05when she was sitting across a table from me.

00:29:07I asked three questions about the book at the signing because I had read it three times by then

00:29:11and had three things I wanted to know.

00:29:12I came to the author's luncheon because I knew you would be there.

00:29:16I read the piece six weeks ago, the smaller, meaner piece,

00:29:19because someone in my office sent it to me unsolicited,

00:29:22and I read it once and then I did not read it again

00:29:24because reading it once was enough to know what I felt about it.

00:29:28I said,

00:29:28What did you feel about it?

00:29:30She said,

00:29:30I felt that someone had been cruel to you in print and that the cruelty had been the second cruelty

00:29:35and that I had been holding the awareness of you for two years already by then and the awareness sharpened.

00:29:41The room was very quiet.

00:29:43She said,

00:29:44I came to the gala because I knew you would be there.

00:29:46I requested the seating arrangement at the table.

00:29:49I did not arrange to encounter you at the bar that was a coincidence of timing,

00:29:52but when I saw you walk in, I was watching for you,

00:29:55and when I saw your ex-fiancee across the room, I made a decision.

00:29:59I said,

00:30:03You did not tell me any of this on the night.

00:30:10She said,

00:30:11I would not have told you any of this on the night even if you had asked.

00:30:14You had just won an award and survived an ambush,

00:30:16and you did not need me adding the weight of a two-year accounting on top of that.

00:30:20I was not going to be the third pressure of the evening.

00:30:23I drank the water.

00:30:24I said,

00:30:25You are the CEO of the company that publishes my novel.

00:30:28She said,

00:30:29I know.

00:30:30I said,

00:30:31This is, professionally speaking, a problem.

00:30:34She said,

00:30:35I know.

00:30:35I said,

00:30:36It is the same problem in every direction.

00:30:38If we have a personal relationship of any kind, it is a conflict of interest.

00:30:42If you make any decision related to me or my book or my contract,

00:30:46that decision is now contaminated.

00:30:48If you do not make any such decisions, you are not doing your job.

00:30:52If you recuse yourself from any such decisions,

00:30:54you are disclosing something I have not yet agreed to disclose.

00:30:58She said,

00:30:59I know all of this.

00:31:27I have thought about it at length.

00:31:30While standing across the room with the information I had been holding for two years,

00:31:35I said,

00:31:35That is a lot of architecture for a single gesture.

00:31:38She said,

00:31:39I know.

00:31:40I am giving you the architecture because you asked.

00:31:43I sat with this.

00:31:44I said,

00:31:45What do you want?

00:31:46She said,

00:31:47I want to be honest with you about what I have been holding.

00:31:50I want to give you the full information so that you can make any decision you want to make from

00:31:54a position of complete clarity.

00:31:56If you decide that the answer is that this conversation is the end of any extra professional contact between us,

00:32:02I will accept that completely.

00:32:04I will continue to be a competent CEO of the company that publishes your work,

00:32:08and I will not contact you again outside of professional necessity.

00:32:11If you decide differently, I have already begun the process of removing myself from any decision-making capacity that touches

00:32:18your contract or your imprint.

00:32:20I spoke to my chief operating officer on Monday.

00:32:23The recusal paperwork is drafted.

00:32:25I have not filed it because filing it requires a disclosure I have not yet earned the right to make,

00:32:30and I am not going to make a disclosure on your behalf without your consent.

00:32:33I said,

00:32:34You drafted recusal paperwork on Monday.

00:32:37She said,

00:32:38I drafted it on Saturday night.

00:32:40After I went home,

00:32:41I looked at her.

00:32:42She said,

00:32:43I was not going to do any of the things in this conversation

00:32:46if I had not already made it impossible for any of them to harm you institutionally.

00:32:50The paperwork was the prerequisite.

00:32:52I said,

00:32:53You did the difficult thing first.

00:32:55She said,

00:32:56I did the difficult thing first.

00:32:58The waiter came over.

00:32:59He set down small plates we had not ordered,

00:33:02a courtesy of the kitchen,

00:33:03and he poured the wine that had appeared without my noticing it being delivered,

00:33:07and he disappeared again.

00:33:08I said,

00:33:09Soleen.

00:33:10She said,

00:33:11Yes.

00:33:12I said,

00:33:12I am going to need a minute.

00:33:14She said,

00:33:15Take any number of minutes you need.

00:33:17I sat in the corner of a small restaurant on 11th Street,

00:33:20with a CEO across from me who had been carrying me in her attention for two summers without my knowing

00:33:25it,

00:33:25who had drafted paperwork on a Saturday night to make sure that the most honest version of her conversation with

00:33:30me

00:33:30would not damage my career,

00:33:32and I thought about Vivian under the chandelier,

00:33:35and I thought about the apartment with the ginkgo tree,

00:33:37and I thought about the line in my speech.

00:33:39I thought about all of it for a long time.

00:33:42She let me.

00:33:43She did not interrupt.

00:33:44She did not perform patience.

00:33:46She drank her wine slowly,

00:33:47the same controlled sip from the gala,

00:33:50and she watched the room without watching me,

00:33:52and the absence of pressure in her attention was its own form of attention.

00:33:56I said,

00:33:57After a long time,

00:33:58I have a question.

00:33:59She said,

00:34:00Ask.

00:34:01I said,

00:34:02If I had not asked you tonight,

00:34:03would you have ever told me any of this?

00:34:05She looked at me.

00:34:07She said,

00:34:08No.

00:34:08I said,

00:34:10Why not?

00:34:10She said,

00:34:11Because the version of this conversation in which you ask is the only one that does not make me a

00:34:16person who imposed something on you.

00:34:18I have been very careful about that.

00:34:20I am not going to be the third cruelty.

00:34:23I said,

00:34:23The third.

00:34:24She said,

00:34:25The first was your fiancé.

00:34:27The second was the piece.

00:34:28I will not be the third.

00:34:30I set the wine down.

00:34:31I said,

00:34:32That is the most decent sentence anyone has said to me in six months.

00:34:36She said,

00:34:37I would like to be a decent sentence in your life, Saram.

00:34:40I would like that very much.

00:34:41But I am not going to manufacture the conditions under which you give me the chance to be one.

00:34:46I looked at her.

00:34:47The hair down.

00:34:48The black sweater.

00:34:50The hands at rest on the table.

00:34:52A woman who had structured the entire architecture of an evening so that the question of whether she existed in

00:34:57my life at all would be entirely my decision.

00:34:59Made from complete information, without any pressure that she had not first removed.

00:35:04I said,

00:35:07I am not going to give you my answer tonight.

00:35:10She said,

00:35:11I would think less of you if you did.

00:35:13I said,

00:35:14But I want you to know that I am thinking about it seriously.

00:35:17She said,

00:35:17Thank you for telling me.

00:35:19I said,

00:35:20You are going to have to tell me a few more things.

00:35:22About yourself.

00:35:23Not all at once.

00:35:25Over time.

00:35:26Because right now I know quite a lot about how you have been thinking about me and almost nothing about

00:35:31who you actually are.

00:35:32And I cannot make a decision without the second.

00:35:34She said,

00:35:35I will tell you anything you ask.

00:35:37I said,

00:35:38Anything.

00:35:39She said,

00:35:40Anything.

00:35:40I will tell you the answer slowly, because that is how I tell things.

00:35:44But I will tell you anything.

00:35:46I said,

00:35:47Where did you grow up?

00:35:48She said,

00:35:49A small town in upstate New York.

00:35:51My mother taught piano.

00:35:53My father ran a hardware store.

00:35:54I was the only one of three siblings who left.

00:35:57I said,

00:35:58What was your favorite book at 12?

00:36:00She said,

00:36:01A little princess.

00:36:02I read it 11 times.

00:36:04I will not defend that choice and I will not apologize for it.

00:36:08I said,

00:36:08Why publishing?

00:36:10She said,

00:36:10Because I read your manuscript two summers ago and realized that the company I worked for was capable of making

00:36:16something that mattered to me at a level that nothing else in my professional life had ever reached,

00:36:20and I decided I wanted to be the person responsible for that being possible for other writers.

00:36:25I sat with this.

00:36:27I said,

00:36:28That answer was prepared.

00:36:29She said,

00:36:31That answer has been prepared for two years.

00:36:33I said,

00:36:34Solene.

00:36:34She said,

00:36:35Yes.

00:36:36I said,

00:36:37I am going to leave in a few minutes.

00:36:39Not because I am running.

00:36:40Because I have had enough information for one night and I want to walk home and think about all of

00:36:44it without your face across from me,

00:36:46because your face across from me makes it harder to think with the part of my brain I need to

00:36:50use.

00:36:51She said,

00:36:52Understood.

00:36:52I said,

00:36:53I will message you when I have thought about it.

00:36:55She said,

00:36:56I will be here.

00:36:57I stood.

00:36:59She rose.

00:37:00She paid for the dinner I had barely touched.

00:37:02She walked me to the door of the restaurant.

00:37:05On the sidewalk,

00:37:06she did not put her hand at my waist.

00:37:08She did not touch me at all.

00:37:09She said,

00:37:10Good night, Sarum.

00:37:11I said,

00:37:12Good night, Solene.

00:37:13I walked into the wet November street,

00:37:15and the cold air hit my face,

00:37:17and I started walking north,

00:37:19because north was the direction of my apartment,

00:37:21and also the direction my body had decided on without consulting me.

00:37:25Two blocks in,

00:37:26I stopped under a streetlight and stood for a long time with my hands in the pockets of my coat

00:37:30and the warmth of an evening and a sentence and a hand at my waist all sitting in my chest

00:37:34at once,

00:37:35and I understood,

00:37:36with the same late awful clarity,

00:37:38that I was already in trouble.

00:37:39I had not yet decided what to do about it,

00:37:42but I knew what the certainty writers sometimes have about the shapes of their own stories

00:37:46that I was going to.

00:37:48I walked the rest of the way home.

00:37:50Forty-one blocks.

00:37:51I did not take a car.

00:37:52I did not check my phone.

00:37:53I walked because the body knew things the head did not,

00:37:56and the body had decided it needed to put one foot down and then another foot down

00:38:00for a long enough stretch that the head would catch up,

00:38:02and I had learned,

00:38:03over the past six months,

00:38:05to listen to the body when it offered an instruction.

00:38:08The wet November streets were quiet at that hour.

00:38:11The restaurants were doing their last seatings.

00:38:13The bars on 8th had the soft yellow light that bars have on Fridays before midnight.

00:38:18I passed a flower shop that was already closed but had left its window display lit,

00:38:22and there were peonies in the window in a season that had no business holding peonies,

00:38:26and I stopped for a second and thought about how peonies in November cost something specific

00:38:31to the person who had ordered them,

00:38:32and then I kept walking.

00:38:34I thought,

00:38:35more or less,

00:38:36in straight lines.

00:38:37A woman who had read my novel two summers ago in manuscript and had not been the same after.

00:38:42A woman who had attended a contract signing because she wanted to see what I looked like

00:38:46across a table.

00:38:47A woman who had drafted recusal paperwork on a Saturday night before she was sure she was

00:38:51going to need it because she had decided that the most honest version of a future conversation

00:38:55with me would not be allowed to damage my career,

00:38:58and the paperwork was the prerequisite she was willing to pay before she would let herself

00:39:02do anything else.

00:39:03A woman who had told me, in a small restaurant on 11th, that she was not going to be the

00:39:08third

00:39:09cruelty.

00:39:09I did not know, walking home, whether I was thinking about Solene Marchetti or whether

00:39:14I was thinking about a character who had walked out of the kind of book I would have written

00:39:17if I had been a more generous writer.

00:39:20The line between the two was thinner than I was comfortable with, and I had spent enough

00:39:24years writing fiction to know that when a real person started to look like fiction,

00:39:27it usually meant the person was being more honest than the people around them, not less.

00:39:32I got to my apartment at 1240.

00:39:34I did not take off the coat for a long time.

00:39:36I sat at the kitchen counter under the small lamp I had bought specifically because it cast

00:39:41a warmer light than the overheads, and I looked at the ginkgo tree in the courtyard, and I thought,

00:39:46I did not message Solene that night.

00:39:48I did not message her on Saturday.

00:39:50I did not message her on Sunday, although on Sunday I picked up the phone seven times to

00:39:54draft messages I did not send.

00:39:56On Monday morning, I went to my desk and worked on the novel I had been not writing for six

00:40:01months.

00:40:01I wrote for two hours.

00:40:03The two hours were not particularly good, but they were two hours, and they were the

00:40:08first two hours of new work I had produced since October, and I understood, sitting at

00:40:13the desk with the cursor blinking and a paragraph that was already too long sitting on the screen,

00:40:18that something in me had stopped being held closed by the weight of a thing that had ended.

00:40:22I worked Monday and Tuesday and Wednesday.

00:40:24I produced something close to 4,000 words.

00:40:27They were not all keepers.

00:40:29Some of them would be cut, but they were words, and they were mine, and they had not

00:40:33been possible last week.

00:40:34On Wednesday evening, I messaged Solene.

00:40:37I wrote, I would like to see you on Saturday.

00:40:39There is a thing I would like to ask you in person.

00:40:42She wrote back more quickly than the previous message, which was the only piece of information

00:40:47I needed about how she had been spending her week.

00:40:49She wrote Saturday.

00:40:51Where?

00:40:51I wrote, the same place.

00:40:54She wrote, yes.

00:40:56She did not write anything else.

00:40:58The week between Wednesday and Saturday moved the way weeks move when you have given yourself

00:41:02a deadline.

00:41:03I worked at the desk in the morning.

00:41:04I walked in the afternoon.

00:41:06I did not see anyone I had to perform for.

00:41:09I did not check the literary gossip pages for any further versions of the smaller, meaner

00:41:13piece.

00:41:13On Friday afternoon, I bought a sweater I did not need.

00:41:16In a shade of dark green I had been thinking about for a while, and I told myself I was

00:41:21buying it for me, which was at least partially true.

00:41:24Saturday came.

00:41:25I wore the green sweater.

00:41:26I walked to 11th.

00:41:28Solene was at the same table.

00:41:30The same corner.

00:41:31The same soft sweater, although in a different color tonight.

00:41:34A deep gray, almost charcoal, the kind of gray that could pass for black at a distance, and

00:41:39revealed itself as gray only when you were close.

00:41:41Her hair was down again.

00:41:43The watch was still on the right wrist.

00:41:45She rose when I came in.

00:41:47She said, Saram.

00:41:48I said, Solene.

00:41:49She said, you look well.

00:41:51I said, I am well.

00:41:53We sat.

00:41:54The host poured the water.

00:41:56The waiter brought a wine list.

00:41:58Solene, with the same quiet courtesy as last time, deferred to me on whether to order.

00:42:02I said, I will have a glass of whatever you are having.

00:42:05She said, I am having the same wine I had last time.

00:42:08I find it difficult to be interesting about wine, and I have stopped pretending.

00:42:12I almost laughed.

00:42:14It was the closest I had come to laughing in front of her, and her eyes registered it,

00:42:18and the corner of her mouth did the thing that almost, but did not commit to a smile,

00:42:22and I felt the small, specific pleasure of having produced that response in her on purpose.

00:42:27The waiter took the order and disappeared.

00:42:30I said, I have my question.

00:42:31She said, I am ready.

00:42:33I said, I want to know what you would like, specifically, not in the abstract, not the

00:42:38careful version, the version where you tell me what you have been imagining for two years.

00:42:42She held my eyes.

00:42:44She said, you are asking me to say it out loud.

00:42:47I said, yes.

00:42:48She said, in a way that has not been edited for your comfort.

00:42:52I said, yes.

00:42:54She said, I want to take you to dinner regularly.

00:42:56I want to know the answers to the questions you ask me, and I want to ask you the questions

00:43:01I have been holding.

00:43:02I want to learn what you are like on a Tuesday morning when you have not slept, and what you

00:43:06are like at five in the afternoon when the work has gone well, and what you are like

00:43:10at the moment you decide a sentence is finished.

00:43:12I want to be allowed to bring you coffee in a way that is not a transaction, and a meal

00:43:16in a way that is not a meeting, and a book I have read in a way that is not

00:43:19a recommendation.

00:43:20I want to be permitted, eventually, to put my hand at your waist again in a context that

00:43:25has nothing to do with an ex-fiancé at a gala.

00:43:28I want to be the person you call when you have written something good, and the person

00:43:31you call when you have written something bad, and I want, more than anything else, to be

00:43:35the person who is paying close enough attention that you do not have to ask me twice for any

00:43:39of it.

00:43:40I sat with this.

00:43:41I said, that is a complete sentence.

00:43:44She said, I have been editing it for two years.

00:43:47I said, it shows.

00:43:49She said, thank you.

00:43:51The waiter brought the wine.

00:43:52He poured.

00:43:53He left.

00:43:54I said, I have an answer.

00:43:55She said, I am ready.

00:43:57I said, I want all of it, but I want it in stages.

00:44:01I want the first several months to be the version where we are getting to know each other and

00:44:04where I can change my mind without it costing either of us anything.

00:44:08I want you to file the recusal paperwork before we do anything else.

00:44:11I want there to be no professional contamination of any kind.

00:44:14I want, in general, to take this slowly enough that I will not look back in a year and feel

00:44:18that I was rebounding into the next thing because the previous thing had hurt me badly

00:44:22enough that I could not tell the difference.

00:44:24She said, all of that is reasonable.

00:44:27All of that is what I would have asked for if you had not.

00:44:30I said, and I want to tell you something.

00:44:32She said, tell me.

00:44:35I said, I do not entirely trust myself yet about who I am after October.

00:44:40I am going to need you to be patient with me while I find out.

00:44:43I am going to need you to not flinch when I am cold for reasons that have nothing to

00:44:47do with you, and I am going to need you to not interpret my carefulness as rejection.

00:44:51I am going to need you to keep saying the kinds of sentences you said tonight, even when

00:44:55the sentences are inconvenient, because the sentences are how I will know that you are

00:45:00still telling me the truth.

00:45:01She said, I can do all of that.

00:45:03I said, you are very confident about that.

00:45:06She said, I have been preparing for two years, Sarum.

00:45:09The waiting was not idle.

00:45:11I drank some of the wine.

00:45:12It was, in fact, a good wine.

00:45:15I had been wrong about wine being a thing I was indifferent to.

00:45:18I said, Solene.

00:45:19She said, yes.

00:45:21I said, you can put your hand on the table.

00:45:24She looked at me.

00:45:25I said, not on me.

00:45:27On the table.

00:45:28On the table where my hand is.

00:45:30She moved her hand.

00:45:31It came across the small space and settled near mine.

00:45:35Palm down.

00:45:36Fingers loose.

00:45:37The way a hand settles when it is offered rather than imposed.

00:45:40I moved my hand the small remaining distance and rested it against hers back of

00:45:44my hand against the back of hers, light, the kind of contact that in another life I would

00:45:49have called an accident.

00:45:50It was not an accident.

00:45:52She did not turn her hand.

00:45:54She did not lace her fingers with mine.

00:45:56She left the contact at exactly the level I had set, which was the cleanest thing she

00:46:00could have done.

00:46:00I said, this is the part where you are demonstrating your patience.

00:46:04She said, this is the part where I am happy.

00:46:07I sat with that.

00:46:08I said, we have a lot to do.

00:46:10She said, we have time.

00:46:12We did, in fact, have time.

00:46:14She filed the recusal paperwork the following Monday.

00:46:18The chief operating officer accepted it without comment.

00:46:21The paperwork was structured so that no decision touching me or my novel or my contract or my

00:46:26imprint would pass through Solene's office for the duration of any extra professional

00:46:30contact between us, with the disclosure logged to the company secretary and reviewable by the

00:46:36board if necessary.

00:46:37It was, by the standards of these things, an unusually clean filing.

00:46:42My agent, when she received the courtesy notification, called me on a Tuesday afternoon and asked,

00:46:48with the practice neutrality of a woman who had handled the careers of complicated authors

00:46:52for a long time, whether I was all right.

00:46:54I said, I am all right.

00:46:56She said, are you sure?

00:46:58I said, I am more sure than I expected to be.

00:47:01She said, all right.

00:47:02I will not ask again.

00:47:04If you ever need me to ask, you let me know, and I will ask.

00:47:08I said, I appreciate you.

00:47:09She said, I appreciate you back.

00:47:12The first months were what I had asked them to be.

00:47:14Solene was patient.

00:47:15She took me to dinner once a week, and then twice a week, and then we stopped counting.

00:47:20She brought me coffee on a Saturday morning in December, which I let her do because I had

00:47:25decided that morning that I was going to start letting people do things for me again,

00:47:28and her face, when I opened the door and let her in without saying anything, did the

00:47:33thing it did under the chandelier, the thing it did at the gala, when I said this is what

00:47:38I want, and I understood that the smallest gestures were going to cost her the most because

00:47:42she had been holding them the combination, longest.

00:47:46I learned things about her.

00:47:47I learned that she got up at 5.20 every morning and ran four miles regardless of weather, and

00:47:52that she had been doing this since she was 26 and had survived a year that she did not

00:47:56yet want to tell me about.

00:47:58I learned that she read fiction in the evenings and nonfiction in the mornings, and that she

00:48:03had three reading lights in her apartment at different intensities for different times

00:48:06of day.

00:48:07I learned that she could not sing and was unembarrassed about it, and that she could cook

00:48:11precisely four things and was unembarrassed about that too.

00:48:14I learned that she had a sister in Boston she called every Sunday, and a brother in

00:48:18Phoenix she called once a month, and that her parents were both still alive in upstate

00:48:22New York, and that she went home for one weekend every other month and helped her father with

00:48:27the inventory at the hardware store because the inventory was too much for him alone now,

00:48:31and he would not accept help from anyone who was not a...

00:48:34Marchetti.

00:48:35I learned that she was capable of being tired in a way I had not expected.

00:48:39The first time I saw it was in January, on a Wednesday evening, when she came over to

00:48:44my apartment after a long board meeting and sat on the couch and did not, for the first

00:48:48eight minutes, say anything at all.

00:48:50She just sat there with her shoulders slightly down, the composure not gone but resting, and

00:48:56I watched her and realized that the composure was a thing she put on every morning the same

00:49:00way she put on the suit, and that being allowed to take it off in front of someone was not

00:49:04a small thing for her.

00:49:05I made tea.

00:49:06I brought it to her without asking what she wanted, because I had learned what she wanted

00:49:10by then.

00:49:11She said,

00:49:13I said,

00:49:14You can stay here for as long as you want and not say anything, and I will not require

00:49:18you to perform.

00:49:19She looked at me over the cup of tea.

00:49:21She said,

00:49:22You are extremely good at this.

00:49:24I said,

00:49:25At what?

00:49:25She said,

00:49:27At noticing the things I have not asked for.

00:49:29I said,

00:49:30I am a writer.

00:49:32She said,

00:49:33You are also a person.

00:49:35I said,

00:49:36I am also a person.

00:49:37She drank the tea.

00:49:38She closed her eyes for 30 seconds.

00:49:40She opened them and was, more or less, the woman I had met at the gala composed, present,

00:49:46ready, and the difference between her at the moment of arrival and her now was the difference

00:49:50of a person who had been allowed to put down a thing for 30 seconds, and I understood

00:49:55with the small quiet ache of it that I had become, in the architecture,

00:49:59of her life, the place where she was permitted to put a thing down.

00:50:02It was a heavier responsibility than I had anticipated.

00:50:06It was also one I wanted.

00:50:07We did not, for a long time, do more than the hand at the table.

00:50:10This was a deliberate choice on my part and a respected choice on hers.

00:50:15I had told her I needed stages, and she had agreed to stages, and stages was what she gave

00:50:20me.

00:50:48We sat near each other on couches, and we walked close enough that our coats brushed

00:50:50the fact that it had been touched again had not yet caught up.

00:50:53The first kiss happened in February.

00:50:55It was not at the door.

00:50:57It was not in a restaurant.

00:50:58It was in the courtyard of my apartment, on a Sunday afternoon, in the cold, gray light

00:51:04of a winter that had been longer than usual, under the ginkgo tree that had no leaves but

00:51:08still looked like the tree that had made me sign the lease.

00:51:10I had been telling her about the tree, about why I had chosen the apartment.

00:51:14About the specific small pact I had made with myself in October that the tree was going

00:51:19to be the first decision of the next chapter and that everything else would follow from

00:51:23it.

00:51:23I told her this with my breath visible in the cold and my hands in the pockets of my

00:51:27coat, and she listened the way she listened to everything completely, with no agenda and

00:51:32no commentary.

00:51:33When I finished, she said,

00:51:34Saram.

00:51:35I said,

00:51:36Yes.

00:51:37She said,

00:51:38May I?

00:51:39I said,

00:51:40Yes.

00:51:40She put one hand at my jaw and one hand at the small of my back and she kissed me.

00:51:45It was patient.

00:51:46It was not frantic.

00:51:47It was the kind of kiss that a woman who had been editing a sentence for two years gave

00:51:51when she was finally allowed to say it.

00:51:53The cold air.

00:51:54The ginkgo tree.

00:51:56The fact that she did not lean any of her weight into me, did not press, did not take

00:52:00anything beyond what I had given.

00:52:02The fact that when she stepped back, she kept the hand at my jaw for a beat longer, and

00:52:07her thumb, just once, moved slowly across my cheekbone.

00:52:10And her eyes did not leave mine.

00:52:12I said,

00:52:13Soleen.

00:52:14She said,

00:52:15Yes.

00:52:15I said,

00:52:16Do that again.

00:52:17She did it again.

00:52:18The second one was less patient and more honest, and we stood in the courtyard for a

00:52:23long time, until the light shifted in a way that meant the afternoon was ending, and

00:52:27we went up to my apartment and made tea and sat on the couch and did not, that night,

00:52:31do anything beyond what I had agreed to in stages.

00:52:34But the stages had moved, and we both knew it, and neither of us pretended otherwise.

00:52:39She did not stay over that night.

00:52:41She did not stay over for a long time after that night.

00:52:44The not staying was, again, deliberate, a thing I had asked for and a thing she had

00:52:49given me.

00:52:50The first night she stayed, in late March, she stayed because I asked her to, and the

00:52:55asking was the part I had been waiting until I could do without flinching.

00:52:58And when I did it, she nodded once and said yes, the way she said yes to everything I had

00:53:02asked her for, which was to say, simply, without making a thing of it.

00:53:06In April, the publishing house's spring catalog launch happened.

00:53:10It was, by tradition, an industry event, the kind of thing where the entire literary apparatus

00:53:16of New York gathered in a hotel ballroom and ate small expensive food and pretended to be

00:53:20glad to see each other.

00:53:22I was, for the first time in my career, on the catalog as a major spring title, the paperback

00:53:27release of the novel, with a new afterword I had written over the winter, and a tour attached.

00:53:32Solene attended in her capacity as CEO.

00:53:35I attended in my capacity as author.

00:53:38The recusal paperwork had been on file for five months.

00:53:40It was visible on the internal record of any board member who chose to look at it.

00:53:45It was not, however, something either of us had publicized, because the publicity of these

00:53:50things is its own particular politics, and we had agreed, with the patient quietness we

00:53:55had agreed on most things, that we would let the disclosure speak for itself when it needed

00:53:59to.

00:54:00We arrived separately.

00:54:01She was already in the ballroom when I came in, standing near the front of the room with

00:54:05my publisher and the chair of the foundation board, and she did not, when I entered, walk

00:54:09over to me.

00:54:10She let me work the room the way authors work rooms at their own catalog events.

00:54:14She let me have the moment that was professionally mine.

00:54:17I worked the room.

00:54:18I shook the hands.

00:54:20I made the small, careful jokes that authors make at their catalog events.

00:54:23I did all of this with the steady spine that I had not had at the gala in November, and

00:54:28I did it with the small, quiet awareness, sitting underneath everything else, that there was

00:54:32a woman across the room whose hand I would be allowed to hold later, and the awareness

00:54:37was its own form of armor.

00:54:39Vivienne was not there.

00:54:40I had checked the guest list.

00:54:42She was not on it.

00:54:43She had moved to London in February, as planned, and she had stopped being a person whose schedule

00:54:48I tracked.

00:54:49What was there, however, was a woman I had not anticipated.

00:54:53I saw her at the bar.

00:54:54She was Solene's age, maybe a little older.

00:54:57She was tall, with her hair pulled back the way Solene used to pull her hair back before

00:55:01she had started leaving it down for me, and she was wearing a navy blue suit that was the

00:55:05kind of suit a person wore when they wanted to communicate professional gravity.

00:55:09I did not recognize her face.

00:55:11I recognized, however, the way she was looking at Solene from across the room.

00:55:15It was the way Solene used to look at me from across the rooms, in the months before the

00:55:20gala, when I had not yet known I was being looked at.

00:55:22I went to the bar.

00:55:24The woman saw me coming.

00:55:25Her eyes registered me with the small, specific recognition of a person who had been told,

00:55:30somewhere along the way, what I looked like.

00:55:32I said,

00:55:33I do not believe we have met.

00:55:35She said,

00:55:36We have not.

00:55:36I am Tess.

00:55:37She said this without a last name, the way some women say their first names when they

00:55:42are accustomed to being recognized without further information.

00:55:44And I noted this and filed it.

00:55:46I said,

00:55:47Saram.

00:55:48She said,

00:55:49I know.

00:55:49I said,

00:55:50How do you know?

00:55:51She said,

00:55:52Solene mentioned you.

00:55:53Some time ago.

00:55:54I said,

00:55:56How long ago?

00:55:57A pause.

00:55:58She looked at me.

00:55:59The look was not unfriendly.

00:56:01It was, in fact, the kind of look that women sometimes give each other when they have

00:56:05correctly identified that they are about to have a conversation neither of them was planning

00:56:09on having.

00:56:09She said,

00:56:1018 months ago, approximately.

00:56:12I said,

00:56:13And what were the circumstances under which she mentioned me?

00:56:16She said,

00:56:17We had been seeing each other for some months.

00:56:19She told me, on a Tuesday evening, that she had been carrying an awareness of someone

00:56:24whose work she had read, and that the awareness had reached a point where she was not able

00:56:28to be honest with me about the fact that the someone was not me.

00:56:31She ended things that night.

00:56:33She did not tell me your name.

00:56:35I learned your name on my own.

00:56:37Later, when your novel came out and the company began the marketing.

00:56:40I absorbed this.

00:56:42I said,

00:56:42Tess.

00:56:43She said,

00:56:44Yes.

00:56:45I said,

00:56:46Why are you telling me this?

00:56:47She said,

00:56:49Because I came tonight specifically to find out whether she was still carrying the awareness

00:56:53or whether she had moved past it.

00:56:55I have my answer.

00:56:56I have had my answer since the moment she walked in and looked at the door once, and then again,

00:57:01and then a third time, and her face did a thing it never did when she was looking at

00:57:05me.

00:57:06I am not going to do anything with the answer except what I am doing now, which is to tell

00:57:10you that she is, in my experience, the most honest person I have ever been involved with,

00:57:15and that she does not carry awarenesses lightly.

00:57:18I am telling you this because I think you should know, and because nobody else is going

00:57:22to tell you, and because I would have wanted to know if our positions had been reversed.

00:57:26I looked at her.

00:57:27I said,

00:57:28That is a generous thing to come here to do.

00:57:31She said,

00:57:32It is a generous thing on the surface.

00:57:34Underneath, it is also a thing I needed to do for me.

00:57:36I would like to be the kind of person who can stand at a bar and say accurate things

00:57:40to a stranger about a woman I used to be in love with, without the saying costing me

00:57:44anything I am not willing to pay.

00:57:46Tonight is the test of that.

00:57:48I appear to be passing.

00:57:49I said,

00:57:50You are passing.

00:57:52She said,

00:57:53I will leave you to your evening.

00:57:55It was very nice to meet you, Saram.

00:57:57I wish you a good catalog.

00:57:59She walked away.

00:58:00She did not look back.

00:58:02She crossed the room with the long, even stride of a woman who had decided something,

00:58:06and she left the ballroom approximately four minutes later, and I did not see her again.

00:58:10I stood at the bar for a long minute with the new information settling.

00:58:14Selene came over.

00:58:15She did not come over because she had seen Tess at the bar with me.

00:58:18She came over because she had been working the room in her capacity as CEO, and her capacity

00:58:23as CEO had brought her, on its natural circuit, to the bar where her author was standing.

00:58:29She arrived at the bar, ordered a sparkling water for me without asking, ordered a wine

00:58:33for herself, and turned with the same small angle of her body she had used at the gala,

00:58:38which had the effect of placing me at the center of her attention without any contact required.

00:58:43She said,

00:58:44You are quiet.

00:58:45I said,

00:58:46I just had a conversation with a woman named Tess.

00:58:48She did not flinch.

00:58:49Her face did one careful thing, a single small compression around the eyes,

00:58:54the kind of compression a person makes when they have correctly identified the conversation

00:58:58that has just been had and are now organizing themselves around it,

00:59:01and then her face was, again, the face she had brought to the room.

00:59:05She said,

00:59:06I see.

00:59:07I said,

00:59:08She told me that you ended things with her 18 months ago because of an awareness you had

00:59:12been carrying.

00:59:13She said,

00:59:14That is accurate.

00:59:15I said,

00:59:16You did not tell me that.

00:59:17She said,

00:59:18I did not tell you that because I did not think it was a story that belonged to me alone

00:59:23to tell.

00:59:24Tess is a private person.

00:59:26The version of that ending was hers as much as mine.

00:59:29I would not have told you about it without her permission,

00:59:31and I had not asked for her permission because I did not want to put her in a position of

00:59:35being

00:59:35asked for permission about something she had moved on from.

00:59:38I said,

00:59:39Soleen?

00:59:39She said,

00:59:40Yes.

00:59:41I said,

00:59:41That is one of those answers that is technically correct and emotionally unsatisfying.

00:59:46She said,

00:59:47I know.

00:59:47I said,

00:59:48Were you ever going to tell me?

00:59:50She said,

00:59:51Eventually.

00:59:52When the timing was right.

00:59:53When we had reached a stage at which the disclosure would not look like it had a strategic

00:59:57purpose.

00:59:57I have been thinking about how to tell you for several months.

01:00:01Tess told you tonight, which I did not anticipate, but which I respect, and which I am, in some

01:00:06way, grateful for.

01:00:08Because it means you have the information now without me having had to choose the moment.

01:00:12I looked at her.

01:00:13I said,

01:00:14Soleen.

01:00:15She said,

01:00:15Yes.

01:00:16I said,

01:00:17You ended a relationship 18 months ago because of me.

01:00:20She said,

01:00:22I ended a relationship 18 months ago because I had become a person who could not be honest

01:00:26with the person I was with.

01:00:28The reason I could not be honest was related to you.

01:00:31The decision to end the relationship was about my own honesty.

01:00:34I want you to hear the distinction.

01:00:36I said,

01:00:37I hear the distinction.

01:00:38She said,

01:00:39Good.

01:00:40I said,

01:00:41It is, however, a lot of information for a Wednesday night.

01:00:43She said,

01:00:44I know.

01:00:45I said,

01:00:46I would like to leave with you.

01:00:48She said,

01:00:48You have not done your full circuit of the room.

01:00:51I said,

01:00:52I have done enough of it.

01:00:53She said,

01:00:54Are you sure?

01:00:55I said,

01:00:56I am sure.

01:00:56She said,

01:00:58Then I will get our coats.

01:00:59We left a catalog event together.

01:01:01We had,

01:01:02By that point,

01:01:03Stopped pretending that there was a version of the evening at which we did not leave together,

01:01:07And the room had filed the information and had decided,

01:01:10As rooms decide these things,

01:01:12To be polite about it.

01:01:14My publisher had given me one specific look earlier in the evening,

01:01:17The small composed look that meant she had already known and had decided not to make me explain,

01:01:22And I was grateful to her,

01:01:24And I would tell her that later in a way that did not require either of us to make a

01:01:27thing of it.

01:01:28We walked to the corner.

01:01:30The car Solene had ordered was waiting.

01:01:32We got in.

01:01:33In the back of the car,

01:01:34She did not put her hand at my waist.

01:01:36She did not put her hand anywhere.

01:01:38She sat at her side of the seat with her hands in her lap,

01:01:41And she looked at me,

01:01:42And she waited.

01:01:43I said,

01:01:44You ended a relationship for me before I knew you existed.

01:01:47She said,

01:01:48I ended a relationship for the truth.

01:01:51You were,

01:01:52Separately,

01:01:53The truth.

01:01:54I said,

01:01:55That is the kind of sentence that should have been in the small restaurant

01:01:58On 11th.

01:01:59She said,

01:02:00You did not ask me at the small restaurant on 11th.

01:02:02I said,

01:02:03I should have asked more questions.

01:02:05She said,

01:02:06You asked the questions you needed to ask.

01:02:08You asked the questions a person asks when they are protecting themselves correctly.

01:02:13You did not ask the questions that came later because the later questions were not yet relevant to the decision

01:02:18you were making.

01:02:19I said,

01:02:19Selene?

01:02:20She said,

01:02:21Yes.

01:02:21I said,

01:02:23I am not angry.

01:02:24She said,

01:02:24I know.

01:02:25I said,

01:02:26I am,

01:02:26however,

01:02:27surprised.

01:02:28She said,

01:02:28I know that too.

01:02:29I said,

01:02:31And I am going to need you,

01:02:32going forward,

01:02:33to err on the side of telling me things sooner rather than later,

01:02:36even when the things are not strictly mine to know,

01:02:39even when the timing feels imperfect.

01:02:41Because the alternative,

01:02:42where Tess shows up at a catalog event and tells me the things you have been deciding the timing of,

01:02:47is a worse outcome than any version of you telling me yourself.

01:02:51She said,

01:02:52Understood.

01:02:53I said,

01:02:54Say it the way you mean it.

01:02:55She said,

01:02:56I will tell you things sooner rather than later.

01:02:58I will not edit my honesty for the timing.

01:03:00I will trust you to absorb difficult information without it costing us.

01:03:04Because you have,

01:03:05in fact,

01:03:06demonstrated that you can do that.

01:03:07I am sorry for the specific way you learned about Tess.

01:03:10I said,

01:03:11Apology accepted.

01:03:12She said,

01:03:14The car moved through the wet April streets.

01:03:16We did not say anything else for several minutes.

01:03:19At some point,

01:03:20my hand found her hand in the dark of the back seat,

01:03:22and her fingers,

01:03:23this time,

01:03:24laced with mine,

01:03:25and the two of us rode home that way without speaking,

01:03:28and the silence was the silence of a thing that had survived a small, specific test.

01:03:33She came up with me.

01:03:34She stayed.

01:03:35In May,

01:03:36I finished the new draft of the second novel.

01:03:38I had been working on it steadily since January.

01:03:41The novel was different from the one Solene had read in manuscript two summers ago.

01:03:45It was,

01:03:46in some ways,

01:03:47a more honest novel,

01:03:48because the woman writing it was a more honest woman.

01:03:51Solene did not read the draft.

01:03:52I had asked her not to,

01:03:54because the recusal paperwork covered any decisions related to my work,

01:03:58and any reading she did of the manuscript would have,

01:04:00in some technical sense,

01:04:02complicated the recusal architecture,

01:04:04and we had agreed that we were going to be religious about the architecture.

01:04:08She did, however,

01:04:09ask me one question on the night I finished it.

01:04:11She said,

01:04:12How does it feel?

01:04:13I said,

01:04:14It feels like a thing that is mine.

01:04:16She said,

01:04:17Good.

01:04:18She did not ask anything else.

01:04:20In June,

01:04:21on a Saturday morning,

01:04:22she made me coffee in the kitchen of my apartment,

01:04:24and brought it to me at the desk where I was reading proofs of someone else's book that I had

01:04:28agreed to blurb.

01:04:29She set the coffee down and did not interrupt.

01:04:32She kissed the top of my head.

01:04:33She went back to the kitchen.

01:04:35I sat with the proofs for another minute,

01:04:37and then I put them down,

01:04:39and I went into the kitchen,

01:04:40and I said,

01:04:41Solene.

01:04:42She said,

01:04:43Yes.

01:04:43I said,

01:04:44I love you.

01:04:45She did not flinch.

01:04:46She did not perform.

01:04:47She did not,

01:04:48in fact,

01:04:49do anything dramatic at all.

01:04:51She put down the dish towel she had been holding.

01:04:53She walked across the small kitchen to where I was standing in the doorway.

01:04:57She took my face in both of her hands,

01:04:58the way she had taken my face in the courtyard in February,

01:05:01and she said,

01:05:03very quietly,

01:05:04into the small space between us,

01:05:05I love you back.

01:05:07I have loved you back for two and a half years.

01:05:09I have loved you back since before I knew what you sounded like out loud.

01:05:13I love you back specifically and entirely.

01:05:15And I am very glad you said it first,

01:05:17because I had decided I would wait until you said it,

01:05:20and I had been wondering,

01:05:22for some time now,

01:05:23when that would be.

01:05:24I said,

01:05:25You were going to wait forever.

01:05:27She said,

01:05:28I was going to wait as long as it took.

01:05:30Forever was inside the range.

01:05:31I said,

01:05:33That is a very Solene answer.

01:05:34She said,

01:05:35I know.

01:05:36We stood in the kitchen for a long time.

01:05:38The coffee got cold.

01:05:39Neither of us cared.

01:05:40In September,

01:05:42almost a year after the gala,

01:05:43we attended the foundation's literary fundraiser again.

01:05:47It was the same ballroom.

01:05:48It was the same chandelier.

01:05:50It was the same approximate room,

01:05:51give or take some shuffling of the foundation's programming.

01:05:54I wore black again.

01:05:56Not the same black dress.

01:05:57A different black dress.

01:05:59This one with the back slightly lower

01:06:00and the sleeves three-quarter

01:06:01and a small piece of detailing at the shoulder

01:06:03that I had thought about for some time

01:06:05before deciding it was the right amount of attention

01:06:08to call to myself.

01:06:09I pinned my hair up.

01:06:11I took a car to the venue.

01:06:12I went with Solene.

01:06:14We arrived together.

01:06:15We walked into the ballroom together.

01:06:17We were placed,

01:06:18by the foundation,

01:06:19at the same table

01:06:20because there was no longer any pretense

01:06:22about how the seating should go.

01:06:24The publishing house had,

01:06:25at some point in the spring,

01:06:26made the disclosure formal.

01:06:28The board had,

01:06:29at some point in the spring,

01:06:30signed off.

01:06:31The recusal paperwork

01:06:32had been adjusted

01:06:33from temporary to permanent.

01:06:34The professional architecture

01:06:36had been the architecture all along

01:06:37and now,

01:06:38in September,

01:06:39it was simply the public version of itself.

01:06:42Vivian was not there.

01:06:43She had not,

01:06:44as it turned out,

01:06:45been invited back.

01:06:46The foundation had its own quiet politics

01:06:48about which prior attendees

01:06:49it required to attend in subsequent years

01:06:52and after some review

01:06:53of the prior gala's incidents,

01:06:55they had quietly chosen,

01:06:57for the comfort of the room,

01:06:58to leave certain names

01:06:59off the invitation list.

01:07:01The room saw us come in.

01:07:02The room had seen us come into many rooms by then.

01:07:05The room had filed all of the information.

01:07:08I worked the room in my capacity as a writer,

01:07:10with a book on the spring catalog

01:07:12and a paperback that had done well

01:07:14and a second novel

01:07:15that was about to be announced.

01:07:17Selene worked the room in her capacity

01:07:18as the CEO of the parent company,

01:07:20which had been her job all along,

01:07:22and which she did with the quiet efficiency

01:07:23she had always done it with.

01:07:25At one point,

01:07:26around halfway through the evening,

01:07:27I was at the bar with my publisher,

01:07:29and Selene was across the room

01:07:31with two foundation board members,

01:07:33and she looked over at me through the crowd,

01:07:34and her eyes found my eyes

01:07:36the way they always found my eyes now

01:07:38without searching,

01:07:39because the looking had become,

01:07:41by then,

01:07:41something her body did

01:07:43the way her body breathed.

01:07:44She lifted her glass

01:07:45approximately half an inch.

01:07:47It was not a toast.

01:07:48It was not a signal.

01:07:50It was simply the small private gesture

01:07:52of a woman acknowledging,

01:07:53in a public room,

01:07:54that she had located the person

01:07:56she was looking for.

01:07:57I lifted my glass back.

01:07:59My publisher,

01:08:00beside me,

01:08:00said,

01:08:01You look extremely well,

01:08:02Sarum.

01:08:03I said,

01:08:03I am extremely well.

01:08:05She said,

01:08:06I am very glad.

01:08:07I said,

01:08:08Me too.

01:08:09Later that evening,

01:08:10in the taxi on the way home,

01:08:12with the trophy I had,

01:08:13this time,

01:08:14not one,

01:08:15but had been a finalist for,

01:08:17and which therefore meant

01:08:18nothing concrete

01:08:19except that I had been seen

01:08:20as a serious enough person

01:08:21to be considered,

01:08:22I leaned my head

01:08:23against Selene's shoulder,

01:08:24and I said,

01:08:26very quietly,

01:08:27A year ago,

01:08:28you put your hand on my waist

01:08:29in this room.

01:08:30She said,

01:08:31I remember.

01:08:31I said,

01:08:32You did not have to.

01:08:34She said,

01:08:35I have not done one single thing

01:08:36in a year that I had to do,

01:08:38Sarum.

01:08:38Every part of it

01:08:39has been a thing I wanted.

01:08:41I said,

01:08:41I know.

01:08:42She said,

01:08:43Good.

01:08:44I said,

01:08:44I want you to know one thing.

01:08:46She said,

01:08:47What?

01:08:47I said,

01:08:48I am not the same woman

01:08:50you read in manuscript

01:08:51two and a half years ago.

01:08:52I am not the woman

01:08:53you carried in your awareness

01:08:54for 18 months.

01:08:55I am not even the woman

01:08:56who walked into the ballroom

01:08:58in November.

01:08:58I am someone newer than that.

01:09:00I am still becoming her.

01:09:02I want you to know

01:09:03that I plan to keep becoming her

01:09:04and that I plan to do it

01:09:06next to you

01:09:06if you are willing.

01:09:07She turned in the seat.

01:09:09She put her hand at my jaw,

01:09:11the way she had at the courtyard,

01:09:12the way she did now

01:09:13when she wanted me

01:09:14to listen to something specific.

01:09:16She said,

01:09:17Sarum.

01:09:17I said,

01:09:18Yes.

01:09:19She said,

01:09:19I would like to keep meeting

01:09:21all of the women you become.

01:09:22I have been excellent

01:09:23at it so far.

01:09:24I do not plan to stop.

01:09:26I said,

01:09:26That is, again,

01:09:27a complete sentence.

01:09:28She said,

01:09:29I have been editing it

01:09:30since June.

01:09:31I said,

01:09:32It shows.

01:09:33She said,

01:09:34She kissed me

01:09:35in the back of the taxi.

01:09:37The driver,

01:09:37who had seen many things

01:09:38in many years of driving,

01:09:40did not appear to notice.

01:09:41The wet September streets

01:09:43moved past the window.

01:09:44The chandelier of the ballroom

01:09:46was, by then,

01:09:47two avenues behind us,

01:09:49and the small private architecture

01:09:50of a life that had begun

01:09:51with one careful sentence

01:09:53in a public room was,

01:09:54by then,

01:09:55a year old,

01:09:56and stable,

01:09:57and,

01:09:58most importantly,

01:09:59ours.

01:10:00In November,

01:10:01two years after the night

01:10:02Vivienne had ended things

01:10:03at the kitchen island

01:10:04in the apartment

01:10:05we had bought together,

01:10:06I was at my desk

01:10:07in the small new apartment

01:10:08with the ginkgo tree,

01:10:09working on the third novel,

01:10:11when Solene let herself in

01:10:12with the key

01:10:13I had given her in July.

01:10:14She set down a paper bag

01:10:16from the place on 11th,

01:10:17which had become,

01:10:18over the course of the year,

01:10:20a place we did not have to discuss

01:10:21before going to.

01:10:23She said dinner.

01:10:24I said,

01:10:25five more minutes.

01:10:26She said,

01:10:27I will be in the kitchen.

01:10:28I finished the paragraph.

01:10:29I saved the draft.

01:10:31I went to the kitchen.

01:10:32She had taken off her coat.

01:10:34Her hair was down.

01:10:35She was unpacking

01:10:36the small containers

01:10:36from the paper bag

01:10:37in the unhurried way

01:10:38she did everything.

01:10:39She looked up

01:10:40when I came in.

01:10:41She smiled,

01:10:42the full version,

01:10:43the version that committed.

01:10:45She said,

01:10:45how was the work today?

01:10:46I said,

01:10:47the work was good.

01:10:48She said,

01:10:49tell me about it.

01:10:50I told her about it.

01:10:51She listened.

01:10:52She did not interrupt.

01:10:54She finished unpacking the food.

01:10:56We sat at the small table

01:10:57by the window

01:10:58that looked out

01:10:58onto the courtyard

01:10:59and the ginkgo tree,

01:11:01which had survived

01:11:02another November,

01:11:03was still there

01:11:03and we ate.

01:11:05After dinner,

01:11:06she did the dishes.

01:11:07She had decided,

01:11:08sometime in the spring,

01:11:10that doing the dishes

01:11:10was her contribution

01:11:11to evenings at my apartment

01:11:13and I had decided,

01:11:14at approximately the same time,

01:11:16to let her.

01:11:17She did them efficiently.

01:11:19She put everything

01:11:20where it belonged.

01:11:21She knew by then

01:11:22where everything belonged.

01:11:24She came back to the table.

01:11:26She said,

01:11:26Saram.

01:11:27I said,

01:11:28yes.

01:11:29She said,

01:11:30I have a question.

01:11:32I said,

01:11:32ask.

01:11:33She said,

01:11:34how would you feel

01:11:34about looking at apartments

01:11:35together in the spring?

01:11:36I sat with this.

01:11:38I said,

01:11:39Solene.

01:11:39She said,

01:11:40yes.

01:11:41I said,

01:11:42are you proposing

01:11:42that we live together?

01:11:44She said,

01:11:45I am asking how you would feel

01:11:46about looking at apartments.

01:11:48The looking is the question.

01:11:49The living is,

01:11:51separately,

01:11:51a question,

01:11:52which we can ask later

01:11:54if the looking goes well.

01:11:55I said,

01:11:56you have rehearsed this.

01:11:57She said,

01:11:58I have rehearsed this

01:11:59since August.

01:12:00I said,

01:12:00it shows.

01:12:01She said,

01:12:02thank you.

01:12:03I said,

01:12:03I would like to look at apartments

01:12:04with you in the spring.

01:12:05She said,

01:12:06good.

01:12:07She took my hand

01:12:08across the table.

01:12:09She did not lace her fingers

01:12:10with mine.

01:12:11She rested her palm

01:12:12against mine,

01:12:13the way she had

01:12:14at the small restaurant

01:12:15on 11th

01:12:16on the night

01:12:16I had given her the answer.

01:12:17She looked at me

01:12:18with the same steady attention

01:12:19she had brought to the bar

01:12:20at the gala

01:12:21on the night

01:12:22a hand at my waist

01:12:22had changed the architecture

01:12:24of two lives.

01:12:25I looked at her back.

01:12:26I thought,

01:12:27very briefly,

01:12:28about the woman

01:12:29who had stood at the bar

01:12:29a year ago

01:12:30with a champagne flute

01:12:31going cold

01:12:32against her fingers,

01:12:33watching her ex-fiancé

01:12:34under a chandelier,

01:12:35rehearsing four versions

01:12:37of a sentence

01:12:37none of which she had used.

01:12:39I thought about

01:12:40how much of a stranger

01:12:41that woman was to me now.

01:12:42I thought about

01:12:43how the strangeness

01:12:44was not a loss.

01:12:45I said,

01:12:46Solene.

01:12:47She said,

01:12:48yes.

01:12:48I said,

01:12:50this was the right answer.

01:12:51She said,

01:12:52I know.

01:12:53I said,

01:12:54I want you to know

01:12:55that I know.

01:12:56She said,

01:12:57thank you.

01:12:58We sat at the table

01:12:59by the window

01:12:59for a long time.

01:13:00The ginkgo tree

01:13:01was still there.

01:13:02The apartment

01:13:03was still mine.

01:13:04For now,

01:13:05the life I had

01:13:06was still being built,

01:13:07slowly,

01:13:08the way she had told me

01:13:09on a Tuesday evening

01:13:10in February

01:13:11that real things were built,

01:13:12which was the way

01:13:13she built everything.

01:13:14Outside,

01:13:15the city was wet again.

01:13:17November in this city was,

01:13:18I had come to understand,

01:13:20going to keep being wet

01:13:21for as long as I lived here.

01:13:23The wetness was no longer

01:13:24a thing I had to brace against.

01:13:26It was just the weather,

01:13:27and the weather was,

01:13:28this time,

01:13:29a thing I was inside of

01:13:31with someone else.

01:13:32And the someone else

01:13:33was the woman

01:13:34who had decided,

01:13:35two and a half years ago,

01:13:36in a quiet office

01:13:37on the 32nd floor

01:13:38of a building I worked in

01:13:39only contractually,

01:13:41that she was going to

01:13:42read a manuscript carefully,

01:13:43and then keep reading,

01:13:44and then keep paying attention,

01:13:46and then,

01:13:47when the time came,

01:13:48she was going to put her hand

01:13:49on the curve of my waist

01:13:50in a public room,

01:13:51and she was going to say

01:13:52a sentence of exactly

01:13:54four words,

01:13:55and the four words

01:13:55were going to be true.

01:13:57She is with me.

01:13:58She had said it

01:13:59before she had any right

01:14:00to say it.

01:14:01She had earned the right

01:14:02by saying it.

01:14:03She had spent a year,

01:14:04since,

01:14:05demonstrating that the sentence

01:14:06had been honest

01:14:07the whole time.

01:14:08I leaned across

01:14:09the small table.

01:14:10I kissed her.

01:14:11It was the kiss of a woman

01:14:12who had taken

01:14:12two and a half years

01:14:13of someone else's

01:14:14careful patience

01:14:15and had decided,

01:14:16finally,

01:14:17that she was going to

01:14:18start meeting it

01:14:19with her own.

01:14:19She kissed me back.

01:14:21In the courtyard,

01:14:22the ginkgo tree

01:14:22did the small movement

01:14:23it did in November wind.

01:14:25The light from the kitchen lamp

01:14:26fell across the table

01:14:27where our hands were resting.

01:14:29The new draft was saved

01:14:30on the desk

01:14:31in the next room.

01:14:32The recusal paperwork

01:14:33was filed and permanent.

01:14:35The apartments we would

01:14:36look at in the spring

01:14:37were,

01:14:37somewhere in the city

01:14:38already standing,

01:14:40waiting for two specific women

01:14:41to come in

01:14:42and walk through them

01:14:43and decide.

01:14:44I thought,

01:14:45with the late

01:14:45and grateful clarity

01:14:46that comes to writers

01:14:47eventually,

01:14:48this is the part

01:14:49of the story

01:14:49where the ending

01:14:50is also the beginning.

01:14:51I had not,

01:14:52until that moment,

01:14:53believed that such

01:14:53an ending existed.

01:14:55I believed it now.

01:14:56I kissed her again,

01:14:57just to make sure.

01:14:59She was still there.

01:15:00She is, in fact,

01:15:01still there.

01:15:02That is the truest sentence

01:15:03I know how to write.

Category

Transcript

Comments

Recommended