- 7 hours ago
She Cheated
Or Did She Teddy Tears Their Marriage Full Story
Or Did She Teddy Tears Their Marriage Full Story
Category
🎥
Short filmTranscript
00:00:06请原告辩护人进行案件陈述
00:00:07审判长 被告婚内出轨 我方申请被告人进身出户 并且赔偿我方精神损失
00:00:17韩旭 你混蛋 我没有婚内出轨
00:00:27审判长 我自结婚期就一直在家里面安分收集 结婚之后半年 我就怀孕了 之后就是十月怀胎 这两年 我的生活轨迹 所有人都可以为我证明
00:00:42是他 这一切都是他 是他将借着离婚的由头 分割我们叶家的财产 搞出来的阴谋
00:01:02审判长 我有证据 证明我的妻子出轨了
00:01:12出轨了一只 玩偶熊
00:01:16还有这种事情
00:01:28半年前 叶青柔有了这只玩偶熊之后 就把我改出了主网
00:01:33每天晚上宁愿抱着熊睡 也不让我进来
00:01:37老公
00:01:40老公
00:01:41你怎么在这儿啊
00:01:43今天是女儿的周翠燕 外面亲戚朋友都来了
00:01:46走 我们去招呼一下
00:01:48好 我们走
00:01:53老公
00:01:59同时 şey
00:02:00你好 小鸡
00:02:06你好 小鸡
00:02:06你看
00:02:07你女儿今天周翠燕 什么都不抓 就喜欢这个小熊
00:02:11你看
00:02:17Is it right?
00:02:19My daughter also likes to laugh at me.
00:02:23Right?
00:02:25Come here, come here.
00:02:27Come here, come here.
00:02:29Guys.
00:02:30Today, I have an important thing to announce.
00:02:34I want to marry my beloved wife,
00:02:38I want to marry my beloved wife.
00:02:40What?
00:02:41What?
00:02:45What?
00:02:46What are you saying?
00:02:48I said I want to marry you.
00:02:52What are you saying?
00:02:55Today is my daughter's birthday.
00:02:57You don't want to lie around here.
00:02:59You said you want to spend a lifetime with my beloved wife?
00:03:02I'd like you.
00:03:03What are you talking about?
00:03:04If you're the one, you're eating the same thing?
00:03:10When I'm pregnant, you're not mistaken.
00:03:12You're not supposed to be married.
00:03:14I don't want to marry you.
00:03:15The marriage is already put on the bed of the bed.
00:03:18Then I'll sign up in the morning.
00:03:21I'll call you.
00:03:24You're the one-time family.
00:03:24No, I'm not the one-time family.
00:03:24The only one-time family is a poor boy.
00:03:27I said, don't you remember?
00:03:32千柔当初给你生孩子的时候难产
00:03:33硬撑着没打麻药
00:03:35在医院里面昏迷了两天
00:03:37他为了怕吵着你
00:03:38自己带着孩子跟你分房睡
00:03:40他为了你做了这么多
00:03:42你怎么忍心跟他离婚
00:03:44是啊 小絮
00:03:45你怎么能离婚
00:03:49怎么能离婚
00:03:53他已经不值得我爱了
00:04:23韩旭
00:04:53韩旭
00:04:55明天是女儿的周孙彦
00:04:56就算我求你了
00:04:57不要胡闹了好不好
00:05:02是啊小旭
00:05:03为了一个玩具熊
00:05:05没必要闹到这一步
00:05:06对
00:05:07韩旭
00:05:08What are you going to tell me?
00:05:10I'll tell you.
00:05:11Don't.
00:05:15I'm going to leave you.
00:05:16You're going to leave a divorce.
00:05:21Is it because you have other people?
00:05:27You said before I told you that you were always with a woman in the same day.
00:05:33Is it because of her?
00:05:35So you think you're going to think that you're going to do it?
00:05:38If there's a woman, then there's a woman.
00:05:40What?
00:05:41There's a woman in the outside?
00:05:42You said that it's a good day.
00:05:44It's a good day.
00:05:45Yes.
00:05:46It's a good day.
00:05:51I don't care about you two.
00:05:53I'll take you three days.
00:05:55I'll take a good day.
00:05:58I'll take a good day.
00:05:59I'll take a good day.
00:05:59I'll take a good day.
00:06:00You don't forget.
00:06:02You have everything today.
00:06:04It's all for us.
00:06:19I'm ready.
00:06:21What do you think of your wife?
00:06:25I'll take you three days later.
00:06:27I'll talk to the White House.
00:06:30I'm still going to take your chair to issue your attorney.
00:06:32I'm going to take my wife's name.
00:06:33If you want me to take my wife's name, it's not possible.
00:06:41Of course.
00:06:42If you want me to do it, I will do it.
00:06:54Hello.
00:06:56Hello.
00:06:58You've heard of him.
00:06:59He divorced one of the female.
00:07:01He is married in a female.
00:07:03He doesn't like to sleep at him.
00:07:06This is awesome, I like him too.
00:07:08He was a kid so he took care of him.
00:07:12That's enough, I'm not saying.
00:07:13Who are you going to be split up?
00:07:16We took care of him.
00:07:20Well, this piece is too hard.
00:07:21Lulon is waiting for him.
00:07:28You're done.
00:07:30I'll buy you a card, let's take a look at it.
00:07:33The price of Filii is a product.
00:07:35You've spent a lot of time.
00:07:36If you like, I want to buy anything.
00:07:39Don't worry.
00:07:40I'm going to buy my own stuff today.
00:07:44I'll leave this card for you.
00:07:51Look at this.
00:07:57Honestly, I'm already back here.
00:08:06Mr. Sir, you've come back here.
00:08:08Mr. Sir, don't you let me tell your day out better?
00:08:09He may be faster than the last house.
00:08:10Mr. Sir, she's like a little girl.
00:08:13You'd love her to only be alone.
00:08:16Let me try.
00:08:18Mr. Sir, this is your girlfriend.
00:08:21You don't want to meet her?
00:08:24Let me go.
00:08:33This is my mom's memory.
00:08:36This house,
00:08:38except this one,
00:08:40doesn't matter what to love.
00:08:52I'm sorry.
00:08:53How are you?
00:08:54I just went home.
00:08:57I wanted to see her.
00:08:58But she didn't want to see me.
00:09:00She pushed me.
00:09:02I wanted to see her.
00:09:04But she didn't want to see me.
00:09:05She pushed me.
00:09:14You're so cold.
00:09:16This is your daughter.
00:09:18She's only a year old.
00:09:20I'm sorry.
00:09:21I'm sorry.
00:09:22I'm sorry.
00:09:24I'm sorry.
00:09:25This is your daughter.
00:09:26Even if she was dead,
00:09:27she didn't want to see me.
00:09:29I'm sorry.
00:09:30You're dead.
00:09:31You're dead.
00:09:32This is why?
00:09:34If you don't like that.
00:09:35If you don't like that.
00:09:36I'm just kidding.
00:09:37But why don't you do this?
00:09:40She's useless.
00:09:41I've already said it.
00:09:43I don't love you.
00:09:44I don't love you.
00:09:45I don't love you.
00:09:46If you don't love me.
00:09:47You don't love me.
00:09:48You're dead.
00:09:49You're dead.
00:09:51You're dead.
00:09:51You're dead.
00:09:52Don't let me get out of it.
00:09:53I'll tell you.
00:09:55Okay.
00:09:56You're so violent.
00:09:59You're dead.
00:10:02I'll go.
00:10:02You guys won't do it.
00:10:04You isn't going ao noch.
00:10:05You won't love me.
00:10:06You're not.法庭见.
00:10:14Good.法庭見?
00:10:20沈班长 我有证据 证明我的妻子出轨了 出轨了一只玩偶熊 如果仅以被告 与玩偶熊睡觉为由 本庭认为 并不能认定其存在过错
00:10:40不就是抱着玩偶熊睡觉吗 不至于破坏婚姻吧 是啊 对啊 这也太荒唐了吧 抱着玩偶熊睡觉有什么错 是啊 就是啊 没什么呀 韩旭 你听见了吗 你会败诉的 没有了叶家的庇护 你净身出户之后 没人会正眼看你的 韩旭 你不要再胡闹了 我可以再给你最后一次机会 你这机会我可不稀罕 夏旭
00:11:07我女儿愿意再给你一次机会
00:11:11你就这么不珍惜那个考虑清楚
00:11:12后果 拿柔柔抱着玩偶熊 这种可笑的理由分家产 你是赢不良的是吗 我可不这么认为审判长
00:11:23我方坚持认为 被告从再明显过错
00:11:27必须深究本庭已经解释过 如果原告方拿不出新的证据 上述指控无法成立
00:11:33我看啊 他明明自己出汇在前 所以已经是找出了个这么慌张的理由你说的没错
00:11:39这个韩旭 一看就不是什么好东西我早就听说
00:11:50他在外面够三大四的真是个东西韩旭
00:11:51你非要闹到底是吗
00:11:58好 既然如此 我也不会再跟你留情人沈班长
00:12:14这些照片是韩旭在婚姻期间发布在公开社交平台和其他异性的亲密照片
00:12:18我要控告含蓄 婚内出轨 和其他异性存在不正当关系真的假的
00:12:25真的假的 真的假的真厉害啊被告刚刚提交了你和其他异性的亲密照片本庭将依据现有的事实
00:12:42判定你为过错方你将净身出户原告是否能够自证清白
00:12:53既然不能证明 拿本庭现在宣布我有证据我有证据证明
00:12:55叶轻柔
00:13:01婚内出轨我有证据证明 叶轻柔
00:13:04婚内出轨韩旭 你有完没完这里是法庭你不要在这儿给我贼喊捉贼
00:13:11韩旭 我不许你这么不灭我女儿你真是胡说八道审判长
00:13:16我方申请播放视频
00:13:21同意请求请播放第一个视频
00:13:39这是什么屁号叶轻柔居然偷偷和玩偶熊干这种事
00:13:49他这是在和玩偶熊亲热这个太诡异了吧别放了韩旭
00:14:03你这算什么证据你知不知道偷拍别人是违法的你把这个视频拿到法庭上播放你这不是让轻柔难堪吗你用这种方式分财产你还算是个男人吗求女儿不哭
00:14:28有爸妈在一定给你撑腰别人都说一日夫妻百日你倒好要这样羞辱我女儿让她以后出去怎么见人你真是个混蛋真是瞎了眼了这些年养了你这么一个白眼狼你今天对我女儿的羞辱我一定要让你付出代价
00:14:57苏靖大家别着急啊这才是第一个视频沈班长请你打开第二个视频韩旭你再让她播放视频你信任我冻死你我苏靖请注意法庭秩序我播放视频证据你激动什么还是说你要为叶青柔隐瞒什么你这是违法偷拍的视频
00:15:24不能作为证据那刚刚叶青柔的表现你怎么解释韩旭青柔当初为你生孩子难产在医院里面疼婚了两天因为这个他患上了严重的抑郁症医生还为他开过证明他之所以这么做只是为了缓解自己的症状罢了如果是产后抑郁那也就说得通了毕竟抑郁患者做出什么奇奇怪的事情也是有可能的
00:15:38这话是什么当初我抑郁的时候天天抱着花盆哭呢哎呦喂哎呦这个男人到底做了什么把自己老婆逼成了这样太可恨了真是太恐怖了怎么会有这样的男人
00:16:07对什么的事韩旭你身为她的丈夫不仅没有体恤一个患有产后抑郁的老婆还用这种视频来羞辱她你到底有没有人性啊啊原来是产后抑郁啊什么人长大才这个白眼狼不仅会内出轨而且拍我女儿的隐私你一定要拍她有罪没错最好把这个偷拍者抓起来偷拍谁说我是偷拍
00:16:34这明明是叶轻柔自己装的摄像头什么女儿她说的是不是真的爸我这也是为了方便照顾女儿不管这个视频是不是偷拍的总之不管怎么样她都不能作为证据没错我女儿乖巧懂事她怎么会出轨我看分明是你血口喷人这样的人就该去坐牢坐牢坐牢坐牢
00:16:55坐牢就是跟她坐牢就是她必须让她能动就对她必须得坐牢坐牢坐牢快点那个熊洞亲爱的我去洗澡
00:17:23这个熊的动作也太像人了吧不会操人了吧难道含蓄说的是真的叶轻柔出轨了而且就是那个玩具熊大家快看呀不会吧真的假的呀
00:17:51柔柔这怎么回事啊你快实话告诉妈这玩偶熊里到底藏的是谁妈里面没人在场所有人都看到了这玩偶熊里面就是藏着人还请对方当事人如实回答问题我丫头有什么不实话实说你是不是有什么乃言之言没错轻荣向来清白她绝对不会做这种出格的事情
00:18:18她一定是有什么苦衷而且这是关于她的个人隐私我们还是不要再继续逼问她了苦衷这里是法庭法庭上是要讲证据的现在视频证据就在这摆着他出轨的事实已经毋庸置疑怎么难道你还要编一些什么谎话来欺骗大家吗我说的都是实话
00:18:33万物熊里面真的没有藏人没藏人那那一晚我看到的听到的又是什么韩伯取消了帮我听明天最早的韩伯好的韩总
00:18:55怎么把健身吃拿了降品快快快快小心快快快快快快快快快快
00:19:08My husband, did you get married?
00:19:12I signed up.
00:19:13Your husband, what kind of sound in your room?
00:19:18My husband, it's so late.
00:19:21I'm planning to sleep.
00:19:23What kind of sound?
00:19:27Maybe I didn't hear it.
00:19:31My husband, it's been a long time ago.
00:19:35My husband, you're going to have to go to bed tomorrow.
00:19:38Let's go to bed.
00:19:40And today, the kids are crazy.
00:19:43I'm tired.
00:19:44Okay.
00:19:50Is there anyone in your room?
00:19:56My husband, what are you talking about?
00:19:58This room is just two children.
00:20:01Right.
00:20:02There are others.
00:20:03Look, there are others.
00:20:05The child is just sleeping.
00:20:07You don't have to wake up.
00:20:10This monkey...
00:20:12What's the monkey?
00:20:13What's the monkey?
00:20:13He was just sleeping.
00:20:17My husband, you don't want to scare me.
00:20:20This is a toy.
00:20:22He might be able to sleep.
00:20:25Is it?
00:20:29What's the monkey?
00:20:30What's the monkey?
00:20:31What do you do?
00:20:32What do you do?
00:20:33What do you do?
00:20:34You're not that much.
00:20:35I'm not that much.
00:20:36I'm just looking for a look at the monkey.
00:20:37I don't want to scare the monkey.
00:20:39You go.
00:20:40I'm sorry.
00:20:41Go.
00:20:44Go.
00:20:47Go.
00:20:49At that time, I thought you were dead.
00:20:54I thought I was wrong with you.
00:20:56I thought you were wrong.
00:20:57I thought you were wrong with me.
00:20:57I was wrong with you.
00:20:58But now, I didn't see you.
00:21:00That monkey was just lying there.
00:21:04There was a monkey behind you.
00:21:05That was eight years ago.
00:21:06You were wrong with me.
00:21:08There are no monkey behind you.
00:21:10没藏人?
00:21:12那藏的是鬼吗?
00:21:16这也太邪性了
00:21:17我看叶清柔也不像是在说谎
00:21:20不会是闹鬼了吧
00:21:21有可能
00:21:25说不定之前叶清柔身上被什么脏东西缠上了
00:21:26所以行为才这么古怪
00:21:30法庭是神圣庄丽严的场合
00:21:31我们要尊重法律 尊重科学
00:21:34杜绝封建迷信
00:21:35叶清柔
00:21:37请你告知本庭
00:21:40那个玩偶熊里究竟藏着什么
00:21:42审判长 玩偶熊里面藏着什么并不重要
00:21:44您现在不要被韩旭带了节奏
00:21:46让他在这里胡言乱语 扰乱法庭的秩序
00:21:49女方家属
00:21:50我看扰乱法庭秩序的人是你吧
00:21:55审判长说什么你就回答什么
00:21:57你在这质疑审判长
00:21:58闭闪的嘴
00:21:59你这个狐狸精
00:22:02就是你跟韩旭串通一气
00:22:04在这里污蔑清柔
00:22:04肃静 这里是法庭
00:22:06被告家属 请注意你的言辞
00:22:10否则将以藐视法庭罪论处
00:22:12叶清柔 请你如实回答本庭的问题
00:22:16本庭需要了解
00:22:19玩偶熊里究竟是谁
00:22:21这对最后的判罚十分重要
00:22:23我
00:22:27沈班长
00:22:28请您相信我
00:22:31玩偶熊里面真的没有藏人
00:22:33看来叶太太还是不愿意躺
00:22:35不过没关系
00:22:37你的那只玩偶熊
00:22:39我已经带到法庭上了
00:22:40你说什么
00:22:44你去过我的房间
00:22:45什么时候
00:22:47就在开庭之前
00:22:51毕竟我还留着家里的钥匙
00:22:55审判长
00:22:58我方请求将玩偶熊作为证据呈上来
00:23:02同意请求
00:23:03韩旭
00:23:06为什么你一直揪着玩偶熊这个问题不放
00:23:09那就是一只普通的毛肉玩具
00:23:10里面根本就不可能藏人
00:23:12是吗
00:23:13你跟庆柔结婚这么多年
00:23:15他从来没有做过对不起你的事情
00:23:18你说熊里面藏人就藏人了
00:23:20你现在把那个熊带到法庭上
00:23:21又能证明得了什么呢
00:23:23这话你说的没错
00:23:25确实证明不了什么
00:23:28因为肩负不可能一直藏在玩偶熊里
00:23:31但是只要那只玩偶熊里面藏过人
00:23:32就一定会留下一些蛛丝马迹
00:23:35比如头发丝
00:23:36指甲蟹
00:23:38只要找到这些
00:23:39我们就能够通过DNA
00:23:41找到那个人
00:23:48待会等那只玩偶熊呈上来的时候
00:23:49一切就都真相大白了
00:23:54至于那只玩偶熊里面藏的人到底是谁
00:23:57想必大家应该也很想知道吧
00:23:58到底怎么会这样
00:24:01太去
00:24:02如果玩偶熊呈上来
00:24:04你找不到任何证据
00:24:06你今天对我女儿的污蔑
00:24:08我一定让你付出代价
00:24:09没错
00:24:10我女儿清清白白
00:24:13你这么污蔑她
00:24:14你是会后悔的
00:24:18请被告家属保持安静
00:24:19请将物证呈上
00:24:23审判长
00:24:25审判长
00:24:26这就是在叶清柔房间里发现的玩偶熊证物
00:24:28请开始检查物证
00:24:30等等
00:24:31审判长
00:24:36就算这个玩偶熊是从清柔房间里面找到的
00:24:39谁又能知道它有没有在里面动手脚
00:24:40万一被调包了怎么办
00:24:45毕竟玩偶熊是他们提供的
00:24:46谁知道路上有没有调包
00:24:48玩偶熊是我亲自过去拿的
00:24:50而且全程都在我的视线里
00:24:52不存在被调包的可能
00:24:53谁又知道呢
00:24:57这个白眼狼一直在污蔑我女儿
00:25:00说不定他早在谋划这件事情了
00:25:01对
00:25:03要是他提前把玩偶熊调包了
00:25:04还在里面放了陷害我女儿的证据
00:25:07那我女儿一辈子清白就毁了
00:25:11他房间的钥匙只有他自己有
00:25:15早在半年前我就再也没有进去过
00:25:16你没有钥匙
00:25:17那这熊是怎么拿到的
00:25:19砸门
00:25:20你怎么能砸门呢
00:25:22那是亲柔自己的房间
00:25:23我们还没有离婚
00:25:24那是我们的房间
00:25:26婚姻存续期间
00:25:30我有权进入夫妻共同住所
00:25:33并且法警同志在进入房间的时候
00:25:34全程录音录像
00:25:35我有没有调包
00:25:37录像里面一清二楚
00:25:38他说的没错
00:25:40录像就在我身上
00:25:42你们随时可以检查
00:25:47既然取证方式没有问题
00:25:48请继续检查
00:26:18继续检查
00:26:19继续检查
00:26:20里面居然有做电子仪器
00:26:21这怎么是机器
00:26:23不什么是电子熊
00:26:25他是个真凶
00:26:30难道这个玩偶熊是电动的
00:26:34审判长大人说的没错
00:26:38我的玩偶熊之所以能像人一样行走
00:26:38就是因为
00:26:40他是AI控制的
00:26:44什么是AI
00:26:46就是人工智能
00:26:47现在的高科技
00:26:49柔柔
00:26:50这件事情
00:26:52您为什么不能说明白
00:26:54没必要藏着掖着
00:26:56爸
00:26:58妈
00:27:00我之前因为难产差点丧命
00:27:01已经让你们为我操了太多的心
00:27:04后来我又得了抑郁症
00:27:07实在是不想因为这件事情
00:27:09再让你们为我担心了
00:27:15我从小就喜欢小熊
00:27:18所以就制定了这款玩偶熊
00:27:19他毛茸茸的
00:27:22好可爱
00:27:23还可以唱歌
00:27:25跳舞
00:27:27换我开心
00:27:28真的让我很有安全感
00:27:33我就是怕你们觉得我太奇怪了
00:27:34会怪我
00:27:36会担心我
00:27:37所以
00:27:38才一直都没有告诉你们真相
00:27:41没想到
00:27:42以前又这么孝顺
00:27:44你愿自己忍受抑郁症的痛苦
00:27:46都不愿意让父母担心
00:27:47真是个好女孩
00:27:49这么好的女孩
00:27:50怎么可能会出轨呢
00:27:52傻孩子
00:27:54你是我们的亲生女儿
00:27:56我们怎么会怪你呢
00:27:58柔柔
00:27:58以后遇到这样的事
00:28:00一定告诉爸妈
00:28:02我们一起分担
00:28:03啊
00:28:05韩旭
00:28:06现在证据已经摆在你眼前了
00:28:08你还有什么好说的
00:28:12现在证据已经摆在你眼前了
00:28:14你还有什么好说的
00:28:15审判长大人
00:28:18这个韩旭一直出息拘律地污蔑我女儿
00:28:21无非就是想托我们业家的财产
00:28:22像这样的恶毒
00:28:24必须严惩
00:28:26一定要这个白儿郎把老底做穿
00:28:29这韩旭背叛自己老婆不说
00:28:29还恶人牵口状
00:28:31非戳叶庆荣出轨
00:28:33这不是个东西
00:28:34就是
00:28:34叶庆荣这么好的姑娘
00:28:36碰上这个渣男
00:28:38一辈子都毁了
00:28:39才能不能放过她
00:28:43叶庆荣
00:28:45把自己说得这么可怜
00:28:47真是好一出苦肉计啊
00:28:52我刚才就觉得这个熊不对劲
00:28:55原来调包玩偶熊的人不是我
00:28:56而是你
00:28:58别在这里狡辩了
00:29:00没有用的
00:29:00我没狡辩
00:29:01我有证据
00:29:03审判长
00:29:05请将视频播放到一分零二秒
00:29:06同意
00:29:13各位请看
00:29:18视频中的这只玩偶熊和现场的这只有明显区别
00:29:19我方合理怀疑
00:29:21这是两只玩偶熊
00:29:24哪里不一样
00:29:26看的跟视频差不多
00:29:27是
00:29:29视频中的这只玩偶熊
00:29:31鼻子是黑色的
00:29:35而现场的这只鼻子是棕色的
00:29:36你别在这里胡扯
00:29:40你们一开始就造谣轻柔在玩偶熊里面藏人
00:29:41现在计划失败了
00:29:43又说这玩偶熊不是同一只是吧
00:29:47这玩偶熊是你自己从房间拿出来的
00:29:48现在又说不是同一只
00:29:50审判长
00:29:51我现在高度怀疑含蓄
00:29:53就精神分裂
00:29:55是不是同一只
00:29:58视频对比一下不就清楚了吗
00:30:09视频你们都看见了
00:30:10除了大致的轮廓
00:30:12鼻子的细节根本就看不清楚
00:30:15我不知道你们是怎么区分的
00:30:17还是说
00:30:19根本就是在胡说
00:30:26韩须
00:30:30我们在一起五年多了
00:30:34我今天才发现自己好像从来都不认识你
00:30:37你去告诉我吧
00:30:39你到底想要做的是什么
00:30:42她还能想要什么
00:30:43她就是想要你的钱
00:30:45审判长大人
00:30:46法庭的正义不容践踏
00:30:51她三番五次的用假证捂灭我女儿
00:30:52请您秉公之法
00:30:55尽快做出决定
00:30:58让这个畜生不要逍遥法外
00:30:59逍遥法外
00:31:00审判长大人
00:31:01我方申请将视频画面放大
00:31:03视频可以证明
00:31:05我方当事人说的都是事实
00:31:09视频中的这只玩偶熊和现场的这只
00:31:10根本不是同一只
00:31:14我反对
00:31:15审判长
00:31:16这个视频拍的这么模糊
00:31:18放大了也没有任何意义
00:31:19而且
00:31:20会对轻柔造成二次伤害
00:31:22审判长大人
00:31:25我们支持一致你去说话
00:31:27就算含蓄说的是真的
00:31:29就算是两个完全不同的玩具型
00:31:32这又能证明什么
00:31:33没有证据确凿的证据
00:31:35那就是浪费时间
00:31:38本庭理解被告的情绪
00:31:40就目前的视频证据而言
00:31:44的确无法证明叶秦柔有任何的不忠行为
00:31:45原告 如果接下来你不能提供有效的证据
00:31:50本庭将即刻做出宣判
00:31:52好 那我也不在这上面纠结了
00:31:55审判长 请打开下一个视频
00:31:58你还要放视频 你到底有完没完
00:32:01原告 如果这个视频依然不能提供任何有效的证据
00:32:09本庭将直接判处你在此次的离婚案中为过错方
00:32:13同时将追究你泄露他人隐私 诽谤侮辱他人等罪名
00:32:16好 我接受
00:32:19请播放下一个视频证据
00:32:22亲爱的 今天你还没有看女儿呢
00:32:45这熊真是高科技啊 竟然还能哄孩子睡觉 我就想买一个了
00:32:49要不是刚刚看到视频 真以为里面藏了个活人呢
00:32:54这熊真是高科技啊 竟然还能哄孩子睡觉 我就想买一个了
00:32:55这个玩意儿 他怎么可能做出视频里那么复杂的动作
00:33:01你一个三流野鸡大学的辍学生懂什么是AI嘛
00:33:02你有什么资格在这里质疑
00:33:07这个万欧熊是我在国外专门找人定制的高科技机器人
00:33:10采用的是最先进的AI技术
00:33:13所以他才能做出像人一样的动作
00:33:14你不知道其中的远离很正常
00:33:16是哪家公司啊 既然技术这么先进
00:33:21那这家公司的名声应该也很小吧
00:33:25这个公司的机器人还在研发阶段 是对外保密的
00:33:30所以我不能随便透露公司的信息
00:33:31既然不能透露公司的信息
00:33:34那你现场让他再跳一支舞也可以
00:33:39让我这个三流大学的辍学生开开眼
00:33:42他已经被你弄坏了 跳不了舞了
00:33:45只能先送去国外修理
00:33:48你还真是张口救了啊
00:33:52我看这只熊根本就不是什么AI机器人
00:33:55更不是在房间里跟你搂搂抱抱的那个
00:33:56不 这就是我房间里的玩偶熊
00:33:59他是我私人定制的高科技玩偶熊
00:34:02高科技玩偶熊
00:34:06竟然能高科技到自己办鬼脸了
00:34:07大家继续往后看
00:34:21真是闻所未闻
00:34:27他只是在模仿人的行为而已
00:34:28模仿人的行为
00:34:31还是说他本来就是个人
00:34:33你们看 他把头套摘下来了
00:34:39天哪
00:34:41你们看 是个人
00:34:42对啊
00:34:43看了叶星柔之前确实说谎了
00:34:45他真的出轨了
00:34:46柔柔
00:34:47这个人是谁
00:34:49我会真的像他们说的
00:34:51你出轨了
00:34:52妈
00:34:53我没有
00:34:54你不想说没关系
00:34:55我听你说
00:34:57大家仔细看
00:35:01虽然摄像头没有拍到这个人的脸
00:35:04但是他脖子上戴的项链却拍得一清二楚
00:35:06而且我知道
00:35:07今天在场的人当中
00:35:09就有一个人
00:35:10戴着一模一样的项链
00:35:12是谁
00:35:15是他
00:35:19就是他
00:35:26那就是他
00:35:27就是他
00:35:32兄弟
00:35:33这到底怎么回事
00:35:35我们叶家把你当亲人
00:35:37你就是这么回报我们的
00:35:39我也不知道
00:35:41总之这视频里的人不是我
00:35:44你这项链和视频上的一模一样
00:35:46你还要狡辩
00:35:47这枚项链
00:35:50是轻柔送给我的生日礼物
00:35:52这么些年来
00:35:53我一直把他当亲妹妹一样对待
00:35:56我怎么可能会跟他发生那种关系
00:35:58书语说的没有错
00:36:00视频里的人
00:36:02真的不是他
00:36:03不是他
00:36:04还能是谁
00:36:06你难道要说
00:36:07这只玩偶熊成精了吧
00:36:09是我
00:36:10亲爱的
00:36:12亲爱的
00:36:13我刚从国外飞回来
00:36:14还好赶上了
00:36:15我就说
00:36:16你那个老公是个渣男
00:36:21你是被告的人证
00:36:22是的
00:36:23审判长大人
00:36:24在这个玩偶熊里面的人
00:36:27是我
00:36:28不可能
00:36:29你在帮他做美证
00:36:31视频里的人明明是戴着项链的
00:36:33而你这什么都没有
00:36:35你说的不会是这条项链的
00:36:37你怎么也有
00:36:37这有什么大惊小怪的
00:36:41我和清柔从小就是最好的闺蜜
00:36:43这条项链是他送给我的
00:36:45象征着我们的友谊
00:36:47审判长
00:36:50清柔因为生完孩子得了抑郁症
00:36:52医生建议他需要情感陪伴
00:36:56所以我经常扮成玩偶熊陪着他
00:36:58只是为了让他安心露睡
00:37:02所以你说你藏在熊里就是为了陪他睡觉
00:37:04抑郁症患者的痛苦你永远不会懂
00:37:06清柔指望不上你
00:37:08我自然陪着他
00:37:11我刚刚提到项链
00:37:15你就恰好拿着一条一模一样的项链出现
00:37:16这未免也太巧了吧
00:37:19这张照片是我们三年前拍的
00:37:21项链就在我脖子上
00:37:22我还要解释更多吗
00:37:27要是知道你这么欺负他
00:37:28我早就回来了
00:37:29还让你这么欺负他吗
00:37:30被告证人
00:37:33近半年你有一半的时间是在国外
00:37:37你又怎么证明视频里穿玩偶服的人是你
00:37:39宣判长
00:37:42小晴和我从小一起长大
00:37:43他知道我喜欢玩偶熊
00:37:46所以每年我的生日
00:37:50他都会伴着玩偶熊陪着我
00:37:51对对对
00:37:52我不可以作证
00:37:53是的
00:37:53没错
00:37:55我女儿每年过生日
00:37:57小晴都会穿着玩偶服给她庆生
00:37:59十几年了
00:38:00年年如此
00:38:00庆若为了估计夫妻情分
00:38:03他不想公开
00:38:04但是为了自证清白
00:38:06他只能揭露真相
00:38:07证人要清楚
00:38:11法庭上做伪证将承担法律责任
00:38:12审判长
00:38:13我发誓
00:38:14我说的每一个字都是真的
00:38:17请看视频
00:38:23亲爱的
00:38:24亲爱的
00:38:25看 宝宝多可爱
00:38:30亲爱的
00:38:31把头头摘下来
00:38:32别把孩子吓着
00:38:33别把孩子吓着
00:38:47亲爱的
00:38:49你
00:38:51作为亲友的老公
00:38:53不但不关心你老婆的身体
00:38:55还整天疑神疑鬼的
00:38:56你还算是个男人吗
00:38:58韩旭
00:38:58你今天给我女儿离婚库
00:39:00一分下也不用拿到
00:39:01我要追究你的法律责任
00:39:03够你
00:39:04诽谤
00:39:05审判长
00:39:06现在证据确凿
00:39:07是韩旭出轨在先
00:39:09他为了取了离婚后的财产
00:39:11故意诬陷清柔
00:39:12您一定要秉公执法
00:39:14严惩这个人渣
00:39:18叶清柔啊叶清柔
00:39:21我没想到你提前准备了这么多
00:39:23我们只是把事实说出来了而已
00:39:26难道只允许你羞辱我
00:39:28还不允许我反击了吗
00:39:29韩旭
00:39:30你根本就没有实质性的证据
00:39:32而你
00:39:33跟你那个辩护律师
00:39:35那个狐狸精的照片
00:39:36拍的是清清楚楚
00:39:37你根本就无从狡辩
00:39:38我还有一个视频
00:39:40正在送过来的路上
00:39:41那个视频里
00:39:43清晰地拍下了藏在熊里的那个人
00:39:44我可以负责任地说
00:39:47那个人就是你
00:39:50原告
00:39:52你是否还有新的证据要提交
00:39:54是的 审判长
00:39:56因为就在开庭之前
00:39:57叶清柔销毁了他房间里所有的录像
00:40:00刚才的视频
00:40:02也是我方通过技术手段恢复的
00:40:03韩旭
00:40:04你就别再编故事了
00:40:06你所谓的清柔出轨
00:40:08就是你的污蔑
00:40:09是你的污蔑
00:40:10不
00:40:11是你的幻想
00:40:13幻想
00:40:14小晴
00:40:15你这话是什么意思
00:40:17因为
00:40:20他脑子有病
00:40:21反对
00:40:22对方证人
00:40:23公然侮辱我方当事人
00:40:25被告证人
00:40:26请注意你的言辞
00:40:28不
00:40:29这不是侮辱
00:40:30这是医学事实
00:40:31他患有精神分裂和被害妄想症
00:40:34他一直幻想清柔出轨
00:40:35你胡说报告
00:40:37我没有胡说
00:40:40各位请看
00:40:41我手上这份
00:40:43就是韩旭的诊断报告
00:40:46这里面有他近半年在精神科的诊断记录
00:40:48所以证明他的精神并不正常
00:40:50半年前
00:40:51韩旭因为车祸撞击头部
00:40:54导致精神受损
00:40:57至其他的精神一直都不正常
00:40:59半年前
00:41:01韩旭因为车祸撞击头部
00:41:04导致精神受损
00:41:05导致精神受损
00:41:06至此
00:41:06他的精神一直都不正常
00:41:08原来
00:41:09他就是个疯子
00:41:12看上这种人
00:41:14叶清荣就是倒了大霉了
00:41:25都够闭嘴
00:41:26再说一遍
00:41:28不是精神病
00:41:29康复后
00:41:31他就变得多疑
00:41:33偏执
00:41:34经常一身一归
00:41:36甚至半夜海
00:41:39尴得
00:41:45尴得
00:41:46沉船
00:41:48沉
00:41:49沉
00:41:51麻 他为什么
00:41:52我需要
00:41:52沉
00:41:53沉
00:41:59沉
00:41:59小 你
00:42:09What do you want to do next to me?
00:42:12My brother!
00:42:19What are you doing?
00:42:20What are you doing?
00:42:22Let me kill you.
00:42:24Let me kill you.
00:42:25I don't know what happened.
00:42:27I'm not sure what happened.
00:42:30I don't know what happened.
00:42:31What happened?
00:42:32What happened?
00:42:34What happened?
00:42:36I didn't want you to worry about me.
00:42:39I'm not going to be worried.
00:42:40You're a fool.
00:42:41I'm not going to be able to kill you.
00:42:45Please help me.
00:42:47Please help me.
00:42:48You're not going to lie.
00:42:49That night's not the case.
00:42:50It's not like you said that.
00:42:52I was never going to lie.
00:42:52This is the dream of you.
00:42:53It was that day you used to be a hammer.
00:42:55You were hammering out a hammer.
00:42:57You're not going to lie to her.
00:43:01You're not going to lie down the line.
00:43:02What happened?
00:43:07Don't lie down the line.
00:43:10You're going to hit me down the line.
00:43:15You didn't want to hurt me.
00:43:18It's all my fault. I'm not a good wife.
00:43:20So after that, she gave me a good wife.
00:43:24I don't have to be afraid of her.
00:43:26Look, we all have to be afraid of year秦柔.
00:43:28It's all this time.
00:43:29She's still trying to do it.
00:43:32She's a good wife.
00:43:32Yes, she's a good wife.
00:43:35I would say she should be able to marry her with her.
00:43:39She's going to be able to get married.秦柔,
00:43:42this is how can you怪 me? When you were pregnant,
00:43:44you were pregnant. Even if you were pregnant,
00:43:46you didn't even care about her.
00:43:47You were pregnant with her.
00:43:49And she?
00:43:50She's ruined you.
00:43:52You're pregnant.
00:43:53Even if we're pregnant, even if you're pregnant, I'll give you a piece of money.
00:43:58I'll give you a piece of money.
00:43:59You left the house after you left the house.
00:44:01You don't care about her.
00:44:03She's dead.
00:44:05You're dead.
00:44:06You're not going to die.
00:44:09Mom.
00:44:11I want to be able to do my love with her.
00:44:15I want to share my love with her.
00:44:16I want to share my love with you.
00:44:17Please shut up.
00:44:19I'm walking around.
00:44:20I'm not going to be able to kill my house.
00:44:22I can't read your mind.
00:44:25You're lying.
00:44:26You really don't care about me.
00:44:28I love to kill you, you're going to help me I'm not going to wear.
00:44:32You're not going to wear anything.
00:44:35I'm not gonna be able to do this.
00:44:37I'm not gonna be able to do this with our friend.
00:44:41He's all his friends.
00:44:42This boy is a dreamer to all of us.
00:44:44I'm not gonna be able to do this.
00:44:47He's gonna be able to do this.
00:44:49Stop!
00:44:50Say it again.
00:44:51It's not a bad thing.
00:44:52He's on the right hand.
00:44:54He's on the right hand.
00:44:55You're so dumb.
00:44:56You're so funny.
00:44:59You're not gonna be able to do this.
00:45:01You can't resist.
00:45:02A little bit more.
00:45:03I am ready for the bondage.
00:45:04I am beginning to get married after.
00:45:05I can't get much advice.
00:45:06And it is an endocrine.
00:45:07You don'tange that much.
00:45:09Yes.
00:45:09It is a question for you when you are asked.
00:45:11You are a kind of a consumerist.
00:45:11Your disorder is not a consumerist.
00:45:14You...
00:45:15You are...
00:45:16You are too lazy.
00:45:18You are a hesitant.
00:45:19You are as nice as you.
00:45:20You are almost a bear.
00:45:21You are so not an empty body.
00:45:22You are a cardiac cause of a person.
00:45:24You are a gratuitous person.
00:45:26You are a Christian.
00:45:31It is better.
00:45:31You are a regular person.
00:45:32Your culture is no longer a consumerist.
00:45:32I'm not sure what's wrong.
00:45:33But I have a proof.
00:45:35I'll show you this video.
00:45:36I'll show you that it is your home.
00:45:39You're not too late.
00:45:40You're not a fan of us.
00:45:42You put it in your videos.
00:45:44It's not a matter of fact.
00:45:46Is it a matter of fact?
00:45:46I'm not sure what else is.
00:45:49I'm going to send it to the point of the point.
00:45:52We don't want to send it.
00:45:53We don't want to send it.
00:45:53We don't want to send it.
00:45:54We don't want to send it.
00:45:57We don't want to send it.
00:45:58速静.监狱言告此前提交的证据可信度存疑
00:46:06.本庭将驳回此次申请.监盘长,我可以保证的
00:46:09!这语言的视频,清晰地拍下了藏在熊里的那个人
00:46:12!以前我都就是魂内出轨了
00:46:14!韩逊,你还要呼叫瞒缠到什么时候
00:46:24?请全体起立!本庭根据现有证据
00:46:27,现判决如下,
00:46:32原告韩逊,在婚内与他人保持不正当关系
00:46:35,破坏原有婚姻,属于明显的过错方。我不接受
00:46:40!监盘长,我的视频就在这儿
00:46:42!你看一眼就明白了!他们几个串通一气
00:46:45,做伪证
00:46:46,叶青柔他就是魂内出轨了
00:46:48!监盘长,你看一眼
00:46:49!你看一眼哪!监盘长!
00:46:51监盘长,你怎么了
00:46:53?监盘
00:47:01!快向救护区席
00:47:02!秦瑶,你在法庭上装得可太像,
00:47:06我以为你真的孕了
00:47:12幸福有法言快
00:47:15不然被审判长知道含蓄手机里面的视频
00:47:18那我之前所有的努力就都白费
00:47:22我就说你就该去当演员
00:47:24于正乖乖女 善良的妻子
00:47:28所有人都被你耍得团团转
00:47:33不过你教我说的话我在法庭上可都说了
00:47:34但是帮你做伪招
00:47:36我不是要坐牢的
00:47:39我的好情境你就放心好了
00:47:43等我和含蓄离了婚拿到了所有的钱
00:47:46之前答应给沈家的投资我一分都不会少的
00:47:48我相信你 沈家咱们是好闺蜜了
00:47:55不过我们之间的事你要永远都乱在肚子里
00:47:56放心 我们现在是一条生生的蚂蚱
00:48:01我不会说的
00:48:02不过我有点好奇 那个男人是谁啊
00:48:07什么男人啊
00:48:10当然是藏在玩偶熊里的那个人
00:48:14里面有人
00:48:17里面有人
00:48:19里面有人
00:48:19里面是谁
00:48:20他可是我的秘密 我不能告诉你
00:48:24凭怎么现在的关系
00:48:25连我也要隐瞒
00:48:27难不成你之前答应我的承诺
00:48:28都是骗我的
00:48:30既然你这么想知道
00:48:32那你可得为我
00:48:34保守秘密
00:48:46亲爱的
00:48:48把头头摘下来
00:48:49让我的好闺蜜看看你
00:48:57是你啊
00:48:59是你啊
00:49:08生气了
00:49:10在这喝梦酒
00:49:11摔杯子可没有用
00:49:13只有差一点
00:49:14要是那个视频能早点送过来
00:49:16这场官司我们早就赢了
00:49:18现在不也没输吗
00:49:20事情竟然已经发生了
00:49:21就没必要根根语坏了
00:49:23你现在
00:49:25应该在意一下社会舆论
00:49:27社会舆论对我们很不利
00:49:29我担心
00:49:30会影响后面的开庭
00:49:35我担心会影响后面的开庭
00:49:39有没有关注
00:49:40最近面试公司的提案案
00:49:42咱们自家被报仇
00:49:43幻影精神疾病
00:49:44管他去支付
00:49:45还去招呼招命责任
00:49:47现今儿一定有料
00:49:48和这位人家进行离婚
00:49:49以前还定是疏忽
00:49:51网络舆论上说
00:49:53你就是一个精神病患者
00:49:56还有英姆路说
00:49:57你不是神经病
00:49:58就是因为
00:49:59你想在外面花天酒地
00:50:01所以找了借口
00:50:05无聊
00:50:06随便他们怎么说
00:50:07舆论已经失控了
00:50:09三天后终审
00:50:11如果我们再拿不到实质性的证据
00:50:13你不仅会净身出户
00:50:17还有可能被以其他罪名起诉
00:50:19别担心
00:50:21别担心
00:50:23我已经找到了新的证据
00:50:24这份证据
00:50:26足够让叶家
00:50:30万劫不复
00:50:31不复
00:50:41韩旭
00:50:42我们今天请了高寒律师
00:50:45你输定了
00:50:46高寒?
00:50:48你们认识
00:50:50他是我们行业内知名的前辈
00:50:51专门打离婚案件
00:50:55在行业内创造了不少神话
00:50:58叶家能请他来打这个官司
00:50:59看来花了大价钱
00:51:02你可要小心一点
00:51:06叶清柔这次是要治你于死的
00:51:07巧了
00:51:10我也是
00:51:14韩旭与叶清柔离婚一案二审
00:51:15现在开庭
00:51:17审判长
00:51:18根据上次庭审结果
00:51:20韩旭已经被认定为过错方
00:51:22所以今日庭审
00:51:26审判长只需宣布财产分割事宜
00:51:27审判长
00:51:28我分认为
00:51:29韩先生跟叶太太的离婚案
00:51:32并不是本案的重点
00:51:33本案就是两个人的离婚案
00:51:35怎么就不是重点
00:51:38因为我的当事人要控告叶清柔
00:51:40涉嫌谋杀
00:51:46安律师
00:51:49我看你从事律师行业已经有几年了
00:51:50刑事案件事关重大
00:51:52需要确凿的证据才能立案
00:51:53不是靠你意想就能够成立的
00:51:56我当然知道
00:51:59不过叶清柔的确谋杀过韩旭
00:52:01只不过失败了
00:52:03说八道什么呢
00:52:05清柔他心地善良
00:52:07连只鸡都没有杀过
00:52:08怎么可能会谋杀
00:52:09安律师
00:52:11你上次就帮着韩旭造谣
00:52:13这次又要控告我谋杀
00:52:15我倒想问问你了
00:52:18我和韩旭在一起生活得好好的
00:52:20我为什么要谋杀他
00:52:22生活得好好的
00:52:23早在一年之前
00:52:24咱们就已经冒合审理了
00:52:26你甚至都不愿意让我碰你一下
00:52:28过去的一年里
00:52:30我把心思都花在了女儿身上
00:52:32后来我又得了抑郁症
00:52:34你又不是不知道
00:52:36对
00:52:37我承认
00:52:39过去的一年里我是冷落你了
00:52:41可是你也应该体谅我一下
00:52:43叶晴柔
00:52:44你这么好的演技
00:52:46不去当演员真是可惜了
00:52:48别以为我不知道
00:52:49你根本就没有抑郁症
00:52:53你一直都在
00:52:56对方导臣
00:52:57对方导臣
00:52:58你说的这些话有证据吗
00:53:00还是说
00:53:01你只是猜测
00:53:02我当然有证据
00:53:04不过在拿出证据之前
00:53:05我要先给大家讲一个故事
00:53:10半年前
00:53:12我跟叶晴柔的四周年结婚纪念日
00:53:14我跟叶晴柔的四周年结婚纪念日
00:53:26老公
00:53:27老公
00:53:29老公你看
00:53:29我今天打扮得漂亮吗
00:53:31漂亮
00:53:33纪念日当然要特别一些了
00:53:35晚上我在云丁酒店订了包间
00:53:37我们好好庆祝一下
00:53:39想到这么周到啊
00:53:40嗯
00:53:41对了老公
00:53:42你的车我拿去保养了
00:53:43今天开我的车去
00:53:44好
00:53:45那我先去公司
00:53:46晚上见
00:53:47嗯
00:53:47好
00:53:48老公
00:53:49路上注意安全
00:53:50嗯
00:54:06老公
00:54:07你等我一会儿
00:54:09我刚开了一个很重要的会
00:54:10马上就到几店了
00:54:11啊
00:54:13嗯
00:54:15嗯
00:54:24嗯
00:54:30啊
00:54:31啊
00:54:32啊
00:54:32啊
00:54:32啊
00:54:32啊
00:54:33先生
00:54:33你醒了
00:54:35我们已经通知了您的妻子
00:54:36我怎么会在这儿啊
00:54:38您昨天晚上发生了严重的车祸
00:54:41不过您放心
00:54:42我已经仔细的给您检查过了
00:54:45除了有一些轻微的脑震蛋外
00:54:47并没有大碍
00:54:48啊
00:54:48谢谢医生
00:54:53啊
00:54:57啊
00:54:58啊
00:54:59啊
00:55:00啊
00:55:01啊
00:55:02啊
00:55:03喂
00:55:04哈先生
00:55:05这只是微游场
00:55:05昨晚您
00:55:07您的车出车祸了
00:55:08啊
00:55:09啊
00:55:09啊
00:55:10啊
00:55:10啊
00:55:10啊
00:55:10啊
00:55:10啊
00:55:10啊
00:55:10啊
00:55:11啊
00:55:12啊
00:55:12啊
00:55:20啊
00:55:33那你的意思是说
00:55:34这次的车祸
00:55:35有人要害你
00:55:37我
00:55:38我们只是
00:55:39曾知道的情况
00:55:40若是告诉你
00:55:41嗯
00:55:44有人想要害我
00:55:46到底是谁
00:55:50老公
00:55:52啊
00:55:53啊
00:55:53啊
00:55:54啊
00:55:55啊
00:55:55啊
00:55:57你没事吧
00:55:58啊
00:55:59啊
00:55:59啊
00:55:59啊
00:56:00啊
00:56:00啊
00:56:01啊
00:56:01啊
00:56:01啊
00:56:01啊
00:56:03啊
00:56:04啊
00:56:06啊
00:56:07啊
00:56:08我要谋杀
00:56:09我要谋杀
00:56:09谋杀
00:56:09啊
00:56:10啊
00:56:10啊
00:56:10啊
00:56:11对方当事人
00:56:12你刚刚只是在抢故事
00:56:14并不能作为直接证据
00:56:16审判长
00:56:20若对方当事人继续以虚构的情结来污蔑我的当事人
00:56:23我方将立即提起刑事诉讼
00:56:24高丽事别着急
00:56:26这不是故事
00:56:27而是经过调查的事实
00:56:32审判长
00:56:33我发申请将证据提交
00:56:36请呈上证据
00:56:43根据我方的调查
00:56:46半年前也就是今年的三月十号
00:56:49秦淑宇曾去过一家名为微风的汽修店
00:56:53当时他开的那辆车就是我方当事人出车祸的力量
00:56:57结果在两天之后刹车就出了问题
00:56:58秦淑宇你怎么解释
00:57:03就算秦淑宇开车去过汽修店
00:57:04这和刹车系统出现故障
00:57:06没有直接联系
00:57:08所以 并不能作为直接证据
00:57:11你要证据
00:57:12好
00:57:14审判长
00:57:17我方申请传唤证人上场
00:57:18同意请求
00:57:23你是微风汽修店的老板王威
00:57:24是
00:57:25那你记不记得
00:57:27在三月十号那天
00:57:32有一辆车牌号为海A9D586的奔驰车
00:57:35我确实见过这辆车
00:57:37刘班长
00:57:38我怀疑正人在说谎
00:57:39三月十号已经是半年多前了
00:57:42如果没有提前准备
00:57:45普通人怎么可能记得那么清楚
00:57:47那天是我生日
00:57:48我想早点关门的
00:57:50他来个人开这辆车
00:57:52非让我帮他处理一下
00:57:53所以我印象深刻
00:57:54他是找你维修的
00:57:56我也以为他是来修车的
00:57:58但是
00:57:59他让我把刹车弄坏
00:58:04你帮他了
00:58:05我怕出事
00:58:07所以我一开始没答应他
00:58:09但是
00:58:10他给你钱了
00:58:12那笔钱够我修一年的车了
00:58:14加上当时店里生意不好
00:58:16我就答应了他
00:58:20我发誓
00:58:22当时我只动了穿车器
00:58:24我发誓
00:58:24没真的弄坏刹车
00:58:26你还记得那个人的长相吗
00:58:27时间太久了
00:58:29记得有点模糊了
00:58:31那你看一看
00:58:32那你看一看
00:58:33在法庭上有没有他
00:58:37那你看一看
00:58:39在法庭上有没有他
00:58:50那你看一看
00:58:51没有
00:58:52你再仔细地看一看
00:58:59好像是他
00:59:02对对对对
00:59:03是他
00:59:04那天来我店里的人就是他
00:59:07不是你在胡说八道什么呀
00:59:09我见都没见过你
00:59:10更没有去过你的店
00:59:11叶青柔的车除了我
00:59:13也就只有你有钥匙
00:59:14如果那天开车的人不是你
00:59:16你把车借给谁了
00:59:18我
00:59:20请问证人
00:59:21你的店里是否安装了摄像头
00:59:24我们的小破店装什么摄像头
00:59:26那就是没有证据了
00:59:28要知道空口无凭
00:59:31你们想通过这种方式定罪
00:59:33未免太儿戏了吧
00:59:34我说的是真的
00:59:36刚刚我有些犹豫
00:59:38但我仔细想了想
00:59:41那天开车来的人就是他
00:59:42肯定是他
00:59:43韩旭
00:59:45韩旭
00:59:45按你为了打赢官司
00:59:47随便找个人来诬告我
00:59:48我再次重申
00:59:50我没有见过他
00:59:51也没有到过他的店里
00:59:53而且3月10号那天
00:59:55我在国外出差
00:59:56你说什么
01:00:01审判长
01:00:02这是我那天的行程单
01:00:053月10号那天
01:00:06我在国外出差
01:00:09审判长
01:00:10三月10号我在海外出差
01:00:12根本就不在国内
01:00:14请呈上证据
01:00:16请呈上证据
01:00:30刚刚已经核实过了
01:00:32秦淑宇在今年3月10号
01:00:35确实由搭乘航班出境的记录
01:00:39秦淑宇在国外
01:00:40那去维修店的那个人
01:00:42难道是秦淑宇的分身不成
01:00:45难道真不是的
01:00:46审判长
01:00:48既然韩旭的证人
01:00:50无法证明车主身份
01:00:52那就说明他们的指控不成立
01:00:53请立刻宣判
01:00:54韩旭就是本离婚案中的过错方
01:00:56并且追究他
01:00:57诽谤我当事人及其佳人的刑事罪责
01:01:01审判长
01:01:03这些年来我为叶家付出了一切
01:01:05自从我跟叶青柔结婚以来
01:01:07我从来没有做过对不起他的事情
01:01:09背叛婚姻的人
01:01:10是他
01:01:11韩旭
01:01:12证据就摆在你面前
01:01:14你还在狡辩什么
01:01:15那我请问
01:01:16我出过题了
01:01:18明知故问
01:01:19那个人就是你的辩护律师
01:01:21是他
01:01:24陈班长
01:01:25这些照片足以证明
01:01:29韩旭与安瑶存在不正当的关系
01:01:30请呈上证据
01:01:40我跟他
01:01:41不过是走得近了一点
01:01:43就叫出轨了
01:01:44那现在你坐在叶青柔旁边
01:01:47是不是也叫出轨啊
01:01:48你这是在逞变
01:01:49叶青柔
01:01:50这上
01:01:51我是多么希望你没有做对不起我的事
01:01:53可没想到你居然
01:01:55叶青柔
01:01:56我还真是小看你了
01:01:58那我请问
01:02:01你还拍到我跟别的女人出轨的证据了吗
01:02:03韩旭
01:02:04你要不要脸
01:02:04一个还不够
01:02:06你还挺贪的嘛
01:02:07也就是除了我
01:02:09没有跟别的女人的照片
01:02:10对吧
01:02:12现在的小三
01:02:13当真是不要脸了
01:02:15不仅勾引人家的老公
01:02:17还想争夺原配的财产
01:02:18就是
01:02:20这样平行不端的人
01:02:21根本就不配当律师
01:02:22你笑什么
01:02:26自残行贿
01:02:27你是在掩盖你的心虚吗
01:02:30想到好笑的事了
01:02:32还不能笑笑
01:02:35我告诉你们
01:02:37韩旭跟谁出轨都行
01:02:39唯独跟我
01:02:40不可能
01:02:45根据大下法的规定
01:02:46夫妻关系中
01:02:49一方与婚外异性发生情感或者性关系时
01:02:52违背了夫妻忠实义务者为过头方
01:02:54在离婚时
01:02:56不具备分割夫妻共同财产的权利
01:02:58安理师
01:03:01现在证据已经交给审判长了
01:03:02你是逃不掉的
01:03:03像你这种
01:03:05明知道对方有家庭
01:03:07还不知廉耻的贴上去
01:03:09在古代是要被禁竹笼的
01:03:11我没有
01:03:12我不是
01:03:13你以为你傍上了金竹
01:03:16实际上他含蓄就是个吃软饭的
01:03:17没有了叶甲
01:03:19没有了轻柔
01:03:19他早回去喂猪去了
01:03:22他早回去喂猪去了
01:03:22他早回去喂猪去了
01:03:23呸
01:03:24不要脸的东西
01:03:25你们这么讨厌小三
01:03:29我和我哥四五年没见了
01:03:31亲兄妹拥抱一下怎么了
01:03:33犯法了吗
01:03:34犯法了吗
01:03:36犯法了吗
01:03:37犯法了
01:03:38犯法了
01:03:39犯法了
01:03:41犯法了
01:03:42犯法了
01:03:44犯法了
01:03:45犯法了
01:03:46犯法了
01:03:48犯法了
01:03:48犯法了
01:03:53我跟韩旭是如假包换的亲兄妹
01:03:55同父同母的那种
01:03:58所以你说我跟他有不正当关系
01:04:00不就是很好笑吗
01:04:01你在说话
01:04:03我调查过你的背景
01:04:05你不可能是他亲妹妹
01:04:07你怎么那么酱呢
01:04:10我爸妈在我们很小的时候就离婚了
01:04:12我五岁就跟我妈去了国外
01:04:14我跟我妈醒
01:04:16你查不到 很正常
01:04:18不可能
01:04:19绝对不可能
01:04:20不好意思 叶晴柔
01:04:22让你失望
01:04:28审判长
01:04:29这是我和韩旭的出身证明
01:04:31还有我们的DNA检测报告
01:04:34我们的关系
01:04:35无需止
01:04:37请乘上资料
01:04:50没错
01:04:52没错
01:04:53安瑶和韩旭
01:04:54确实属于亲兄妹
01:04:55所以沈班长
01:04:57他们对我出轨的指控
01:04:59是不是也不能成立了
01:05:00本庭认为
01:05:04韩旭和安瑶兄妹关系事实清楚
01:05:07韩旭并不存在婚内出轨的行为
01:05:07高律师
01:05:10高律师
01:05:11高律师
01:05:11你别看着他们
01:05:12你找去个反驳他们
01:05:13对方证据冲锁
01:05:15我没办法反驳
01:05:19叶晴柔
01:05:22看来我们又回到同一情况线了
01:05:23不对
01:05:24我的复仇
01:05:26现在才开始
01:05:33请证人刘梅出庭
01:05:35柔柔
01:05:37柔柔
01:05:38这不是你家保姆刘梅吗
01:05:38她怎么给韩旭做证理呢
01:05:41是啊
01:05:42你不是给她开工资吗
01:05:43这不是吃里扒外
01:05:45她半年前就回老家了
01:05:47我也很久没见过她了
01:05:51你竟然把她给找过来了
01:05:55沈晴
01:05:57沈晴
01:05:57帮我调查一下
01:05:58我家之前的保姆
01:05:59刘梅
01:06:00我叫刘梅
01:06:06之前是在韩先生和叶太太别墅里做保姆
01:06:10今天我是来为韩先生做证人的
01:06:12刘阿姨
01:06:13我记得你离开庆柔家的时候
01:06:15庆柔给了你一大笔钱了
01:06:17你今天却要给这个人渣做人证
01:06:19韩先生他是个好人
01:06:21太太和他没法比
01:06:24韩旭究竟给了你多少钱
01:06:26你要这么说
01:06:27尊敬的审判长
01:06:30韩先生和太太刚结婚
01:06:34我就一直在他家照顾他们的起居
01:06:38我能证明有婚外情的人是叶太太
01:06:42请问证人
01:06:44你如何确定是叶轻柔出轨了呢
01:06:47那还要怎么证明
01:06:50我是亲眼看到的
01:06:51你看到了什么
01:06:52我看到了
01:06:57一个玩偶熊
01:07:00不可能
01:07:02这话一定是韩旭教他说的
01:07:04你又知道了
01:07:05我没有说谎
01:07:10我确实在太太房间里看到了一个玩偶熊
01:07:12对方证人
01:07:16有没有可能你看到的这只玩偶熊
01:07:17是个机器人
01:07:20或者她是我当事人的闺蜜
01:07:21沈青奖办的呢
01:07:23不
01:07:23我很确定
01:07:27那个玩偶熊里藏着的是一个男人
01:07:32那一天下午
01:07:34太太想吃绿豆糕
01:07:36等我买回来后
01:07:38太太
01:07:39你要的绿豆糕我买回来了
01:07:42我把绿豆糕
01:07:53老公
01:07:55你去洗澡吧
01:08:00刘阿姨
01:08:01你有什么事吗
01:08:06你要吃的绿豆糕我给你买回来了
01:08:09我刚不知道韩先生在家里
01:08:10不好意思打扰你了
01:08:13没事
01:08:14你出去吧
01:08:16对了
01:08:18今天的事怪尴尬的
01:08:21所以你看到的不要出去乱说
01:08:23你放心
01:08:25太太
01:08:26我不会乱说的
01:08:31我一直以为
01:08:35那天我看到的那个男人是韩先生
01:08:36最后我才知道
01:08:38韩先生
01:08:40那几天出差就没在家
01:08:43所以你并没有看清楚那个人的长相
01:08:45没有
01:08:47那你怎么证明你刚刚说的就是真的
01:08:49是我亲眼看到的
01:08:52我看到那个男人
01:08:55胸口还有一道伤疤
01:08:59陈班长
01:09:01我认为对方证人刚刚说的只是一面之词
01:09:03更有可能他是受人指控
01:09:05在这里污蔑我的当事人
01:09:09没有
01:09:10我没有
01:09:11没有
01:09:16陈班长
01:09:17这是我们刚刚调查到的信息
01:09:22证人刘梅她的个人账户上个月多了两笔巨额转账
01:09:24贡系十二版
01:09:25而给她转账的人就是韩旭
01:09:30所以我方怀疑刘梅收受了韩旭的钱财
01:09:34作为回报她在当庭替韩旭作证
01:09:35不
01:09:36不是的
01:09:37行了吧
01:09:38我看你就是和韩旭穿通一气
01:09:40刘阿姨
01:09:41你是不是忘了
01:09:43清柔给你开的工资是市场价了三倍
01:09:45你这是忘恩负义啊
01:09:47你根本什么都不知道
01:09:51韩先生说我工作认真
01:09:54所以就让我到别墅里做毛母去了
01:09:59五年来给我开工资的一直是韩先生
01:10:00女儿 是这样吗
01:10:02女儿 是这样吗
01:10:05你感觉我既然在别墅里干得好好的
01:10:07工资还是市场价的三倍
01:10:09那我为什么要走了
01:10:11是啊 刘阿姨
01:10:12我也想问为什么
01:10:14都是因为她逼得我
01:10:17她逼得我
01:10:19韩先生
01:10:22从小和母亲分开的早
01:10:24她说我长得很像她母亲
01:10:28所以她对我一直很照顾
01:10:32确实很像
01:10:34虽然韩先生很照顾我
01:10:36但是太太处处刁难我
01:10:39甚至有许多小事情
01:10:41还打我
01:10:43我没有
01:10:44你说什么呢 刘阿姨
01:10:46你在我们家五年了
01:10:48她当我对你不够好吗
01:10:50你一个乡下保姆
01:10:51一定是胡说八道
01:10:53我女儿从小乖巧
01:10:54怎么会打你
01:10:55没错
01:10:56我女儿是大家闺秀
01:11:00怎么会干出这种臭恶的事
01:11:01我早就说过了
01:11:03叶清柔很会演戏
01:11:04你们都不信
01:11:06你少在那虎唱交友了 韩旭
01:11:08其实我早就想走了
01:11:10但一方面
01:11:12韩先生对我很照顾
01:11:14另一方面
01:11:16我确实需要这份工作
01:11:18我就忍下来了
01:11:20这一忍就是五年
01:11:22对啊 刘阿姨
01:11:24之前叶清柔打你
01:11:26你都忍了下来
01:11:27怎么治回忽然回了乡下
01:11:29据我所知
01:11:30你的丈夫得了肾病
01:11:32每个月需要几万块来做透析
01:11:35你累值了她的病怎么办
01:11:37我也没办法
01:11:41因为我戳破了太太的秘密
01:11:42我不得不走
01:11:44什么秘密
01:11:45他是想害韩先生
01:11:50谁说没有证据
01:11:52证据就等了
01:11:53你的证据
01:11:54上次大家都看到了
01:11:56你还有什么好说
01:11:57这是我修复过后的证据
01:11:59里面清楚地拍到了
01:12:00藏在熊里的那
01:12:02视频里不是审情吗
01:12:04我们大家都看到了
01:12:06审判长
01:12:07他们的视频是伪造的
01:12:11真相就在这儿
01:12:12审判长
01:12:13我方申请提交新的证据
01:12:17我不同意
01:12:18审判长
01:12:19这不合规矩
01:12:22既然原告有新的证据提交
01:12:23请呈上证据
01:12:30请播放
01:12:31请播放
01:12:34审判长
01:12:36我请求
01:12:37立即停止播放
01:12:41韩旭
01:12:43你到底还想要干什么
01:12:44干什么
01:12:45真相马上就要大白了
01:12:52这 这怎么可能
01:12:56这不就是情书语吗
01:12:57真的是他
01:12:58之前都是贼喊捉贼
01:13:00他们竟然真的是剑锋淫妇
01:13:02何管起来批评我们
01:13:03藏在网络熊里偷刑
01:13:05这还是人干的事吧
01:13:07太贱了
01:13:08那个人不是我
01:13:09就是他
01:13:09他俩就相信他们了
01:13:11金融
01:13:11那个人不是我
01:13:14白坏家风
01:13:16叶家的脸都让你不尽了
01:13:16秦柔
01:13:18你平时那么乖巧
01:13:20怎么变在现在这个样子
01:13:21出轨偷情
01:13:23你对得起小训
01:13:24对得起我们吗
01:13:26被告
01:13:27你还有什么想说的
01:13:28审判长
01:13:29这些都是假的
01:13:31这个视频是伪造的
01:13:35一个礼拜之后
01:13:37我从老家回来
01:13:38才知道
01:13:40韩先生确实出了车祸
01:13:42没过多久
01:13:43太太就找了个理由
01:13:45把我辞退了
01:13:46我想
01:13:47太太是怀疑
01:13:51那天我在外面偷听到了吧
01:13:52不是这样的
01:13:53明明是你自己干过偷懒
01:13:56我才把你辞退的
01:13:57而且你刚刚说的
01:13:59完全就是自虚无有
01:14:01行了
01:14:01你们都别再演了
01:14:03一定是你
01:14:04和韩旭串通一切
01:14:05你们的转账记录就是证据
01:14:08不是的
01:14:08不是的
01:14:09我老公得了重病
01:14:11欠了一屁股再
01:14:13我女儿又上大学
01:14:15韩先生
01:14:16他是看我可怜
01:14:18才借给我监的
01:14:19如果要是没有韩先生
01:14:22我老公就活不了了
01:14:23赶先生
01:14:24他是个好人
01:14:26原本
01:14:26他是不让我写戒条的
01:14:29这戒条
01:14:31是我一直坚持要写的
01:14:33看
01:14:39这些都是从你们嘴巴里说出来的
01:14:40想通过这些
01:14:43来指控我的当事人谋杀
01:14:44依旧无评
01:14:45谁说没有证据
01:14:47证据就在这
01:14:51谁说没有证据
01:14:53证据就在这
01:14:54你的证据
01:14:55上次大家都看到了
01:14:56你还有什么好说
01:14:57这是我修复过后的证据
01:15:00里面清楚地拍到了藏在熊里的那
01:15:02视频里不是审情吗
01:15:04我们大家都看到了呀
01:15:07审判长
01:15:08他们的视频是伪造的
01:15:10真相就在这
01:15:12审判长
01:15:14我方申请提交新的证据
01:15:18我不同意
01:15:19审判长
01:15:20这不合规矩
01:15:23既然原告有新的证据提交
01:15:24请呈上证据
01:15:25请承上证据
01:15:30请播放
01:15:35审判长
01:15:36审判长
01:15:37我请求
01:15:37立即停止播放
01:15:41韩旭
01:15:43你到底还想要干什么
01:15:45干什么
01:15:46真相马上就要大白了
01:15:54这
01:15:55这怎么可能
01:15:56这不就是情书语吗
01:15:58真的是他
01:15:59之前都是贼喊捉贼
01:16:00他们是贼喊捉贼
01:16:01他们竟然真的是贱贼贼
01:16:02他们竟然真的是贱贼贼
01:16:02何关起来批评我们
01:16:04藏在王傲熊里偷情
01:16:06这还是人干个事
01:16:08太贱了
01:16:08那个人不是我
01:16:10就是他
01:16:11他人就相信他们了
01:16:11秦柔
01:16:13那个人不是我
01:16:13败坏贼贼贼贼
01:16:16叶家的脸都让你不进了
01:16:18秦柔
01:16:19你平时那么乖巧
01:16:20怎么变才现在这个样子
01:16:22出轨偷情
01:16:23你对得起小讯
01:16:25对得起我们吗
01:16:26被告
01:16:27你还有什么想说的
01:16:29审判长
01:16:30这些都是假的
01:16:32这个视频是伪造的
01:16:36现在科技这么发达
01:16:37这个视频一干就是后期做了
01:16:41What do you think of this?
01:16:44Father, Mom, I trust you.
01:16:47This video is made of. I really didn't get out of the way.
01:16:50This is all I need to do with.
01:16:52I knew you were going to delay.
01:16:53So I had to look for a specific company for the video.
01:16:59This is the legal agency for the video.
01:17:02You can confirm that the video is not going through any later.
01:17:05Let me show you the evidence.
01:17:15I don't know.
01:17:40I will follow you, you will kill me.
01:17:43I will kill you.
01:17:46Put the Philharmon in the air.
01:17:49Let me check the Philharmon in the air.
01:17:51You are going to kill me in the jail.
01:17:54I will kill you!
01:17:56You are crazy!
01:17:59You don't want me to do that.
01:18:00You are the only one!
01:18:01You are a fool!
01:18:04Let's do the Philharmon in the air!
01:18:05Let the Philharmon in the air!
01:18:08Please don't let me!
01:18:09Li***gue, I'm not in prison!
01:18:12Li***gue...
01:18:13I'm wrong. I'm really счастful!
01:18:16Please, you can leave me this time.
01:18:19Li***gue, you're not sure you cheat.
01:18:21You're not sure you cheat.
01:18:21You are sure you're in prison.
01:18:23No.
01:18:24Li***gue...
01:18:25Li***gue, I love you.
01:18:26You believe you may always love me, right?
01:18:29If only you leave me this time, I will be like a wrong one.
01:18:34Je***gue you.
01:18:35Li***gue, you heard your father's message.
01:18:37Do you believe me?
01:18:40You hate me.
01:18:41I can understand.
01:18:42But you don't forget.
01:18:43We have a girl that's so cute.
01:18:46She's a young girl.
01:18:48She can't be a mother.
01:18:49So I can't be a mother.
01:18:50So I can't be a mother.
01:18:51So I can't be a mother.
01:18:53So I can't be a mother.
01:18:56Yes.
01:18:56She's done wrong.
01:18:58She's still not.
01:19:00Yes.
01:19:01Yes.
01:19:01You look at the child's face.
01:19:03Let's do it.
01:19:04Okay?
01:19:05The child is a father.
01:19:07But what do you have to do with me?
01:19:09You can hate me.
01:19:11But you can't say my daughter.
01:19:13She's your son.
01:19:14I think you don't know anything.
01:19:17Do you really think I don't know anything?
01:19:19What do you mean?
01:19:21What do you mean?
01:19:23I wanted to give you a little face.
01:19:25If you don't, then I'd like you.
01:19:28It's not that I'm not human.
01:19:29It's the child.
01:19:31It's not me.
01:19:33What?
01:19:33How can this happen?
01:19:35What?
01:19:35What did you mean?
01:19:36The child is your son.
01:19:38The woman who did not report the report.
01:19:40According to DNA,
01:19:42the woman who is the mother of the DNA
01:19:44has no relationship with the mother of the mother.
01:19:46What?
01:19:47Why?
01:19:54老公 我承认孩子的事情是我错了 但它是个意外 我不是故意要骗你的 老公 别说了 要不是我故意留了个心眼假装神经病 估计现在我的尸体都没有瘦 你现在变得太陌生了 早就不是我以前认识的那个叶青龙了 高律师
01:20:18我给了你那么多律师费 你当时把我想想办法呀 审判长 现有的证据只能证明我的当事人存在出轨行为 至于所谓的谋杀 对方没有拿出实质性的证据 现在激压我的当事人 不符合法理 你说的没错 我确实拿不出他杀人的证据
01:20:46不过这些年叶青龙偷税漏税 还将公司的资产转移到海外的私人账户上 都在我手上 有了这些证据 同样足以让他坐牢
01:20:55不可能 这些都是我们演示集团的机密 你是怎么拿到的我是怎么拿到的这些年集团都是我一个人在忙活
01:21:07我忙上忙下
01:21:08拿到这些证据很难吗
01:21:14你们总是对外说 说我含蓄潘高枝 靠着你们叶家才有了今天但是事实呢
01:21:21如果没有我 你们叶家早就破产了五年前 叶氏集团负债三亿
01:21:27银行拒绝续带是我 是我用自己公司的全部利润替你们叶家续命
01:21:34也是我 在这五年期间 苦心经营 帮助你们叶家重回往日的荣光可是你们呢
01:21:44你们有考虑过我的感受吗你们嘴上说着
01:21:48我是一个好女婿 实际上却处处嫌弃我嫌我出身低贱
01:21:51配不上叶庆柔现在想想 还真是讽刺不是
01:21:56小薰好了 别说了是时候该拿回属于我的一切了
01:22:08叶氢柔挪用转移公司资产属于严重违法行为经过叶家集团董事长一致决定交由韩旭
01:22:09担任新任董事长你 你说什么叶氏集团
01:22:18性寒了老头子 老头子老公 鸡头我不要了财产我不要了我就求你鲜亮简术原谅我好不好我真的不想做了
01:22:29我求你
01:22:56结婚纪念日那个你想要杀我的早上我们之间的情分就已经断了现在开始宣判请全体体力韩旭与叶清柔离婚一案叶清柔婚内出轨谋杀未遂
01:23:00证据确击叹其净身出户韩旭胜诉
01:23:11不嗯不
01:23:42I'll see you next time.
01:23:43I'll see you next time.
01:24:15I'll see you next time.
01:24:39I'll see you next time.
01:24:44I'll see you next time.
01:25:42I'll see you next time.
01:25:50I'll see you next time.
01:25:51I'll see you next time.
01:26:00I'll see you next time.
01:26:36I'll see you next time.
Comments