00:02How did that?
00:04Sure you want to do this?
00:06I have to.
00:08You can wait.
00:11I've waited 20 years.
00:13Two families are desperate for answers
00:15after their teenage sons disappeared without a trace.
00:19The 17-year-old boys Matthew Nichols and Jordan Reimer
00:22were last seen on the evening of October 31st
00:24in Port Rupert on the northern edge of the island.
00:27Their families are holding out hope
00:29they'll be found safe.
00:31They'll be found safe.
00:33That's why I'm making this documentary
00:35because I want a better answer
00:37to the question of what happened to them
00:40than the one I have right now.
00:43My son didn't come home last night
00:45and he's not at school today,
00:46so I wanted to report back to police.
00:49Was it this? Was it that?
00:50Was there a cult?
00:53Listen to me. I'm telling you,
00:55Pam or somebody withheld something.
00:58So why isn't there another tape?
01:00Clerical error? Okay.
01:03What is she doing?
01:05Hey, Tara?
01:07Stop recording.
01:09Don't talk to me about these. You have no idea.
01:12At that point, the case went cold.
01:14Manny!
01:15This, this is the one thing that gets missed.
01:18They're not doing anything like that.
01:19Stop that!
01:20Stop speaking to me like that.
01:22You're in my home.
01:23There's things that we shouldn't speak about.
01:25What we do,
01:27gives them power.
01:29Makes them real.
01:32I, I, I'm sorry if I frightened you.
01:35Showtime.
01:36You have no idea!
01:37I know less about my brother now
01:39than when we even started the same thing!
01:44And so whatever I find, I'm okay with
01:46because I'll have gotten to know my brother better.
Comments