- 7 weeks ago
This video is presented for educational, documentary, and informational purposes.
Unreal True Crime creates original narratives based on extensive research using publicly available sources such as news reports, court documents, interviews, and archival material. While we strive to investigate each case as thoroughly and accurately as possible, some details may be incomplete or subject to interpretation, and unintentional errors may occur.
This content is published in accordance with Fair Use principles under Section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Act, allowing the use of limited portions of copyrighted material for purposes such as commentary, criticism, education, and analysis.
For narration, this channel may use AI-generated voice technology as a production tool to deliver the script clearly and consistently. All scripts are originally written and structured by our team, and the use of AI voice does not replace human research, writing, or editorial judgment.
Unreal True Crime does not seek to glorify violence or exploit tragedy. Our goal is to inform, analyze, and encourage critical thinking about real criminal cases.
Unreal True Crime creates original narratives based on extensive research using publicly available sources such as news reports, court documents, interviews, and archival material. While we strive to investigate each case as thoroughly and accurately as possible, some details may be incomplete or subject to interpretation, and unintentional errors may occur.
This content is published in accordance with Fair Use principles under Section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Act, allowing the use of limited portions of copyrighted material for purposes such as commentary, criticism, education, and analysis.
For narration, this channel may use AI-generated voice technology as a production tool to deliver the script clearly and consistently. All scripts are originally written and structured by our team, and the use of AI voice does not replace human research, writing, or editorial judgment.
Unreal True Crime does not seek to glorify violence or exploit tragedy. Our goal is to inform, analyze, and encourage critical thinking about real criminal cases.
Category
📚
LearningTranscript
00:00On a quiet summer night in July 2007, the peaceful town of Cheshire, Connecticut became the scene
00:22of one of the most horrific crimes in American history. What began as a chance encounter
00:28at a supermarket would escalate into a seven-hour nightmare that claimed three innocent lives
00:34and exposed devastating failures in the criminal justice system.
00:39This is the story of the Petit family, a story of unimaginable terror, survival, and a community
00:47forever changed. But it's also a story that forces us to confront difficult questions about repeat
00:54offenders, parole systems, and whether justice was truly served.
00:59Are you ready for the darkest stories Britain has to offer? Introducing our new book, Unreal
01:25True Crime, British Edition, 35 shocking true murder cases that will keep you on the edge
01:32of your seat. Available now on Amazon in paperback and Kindle, or grab your instant PDF download
01:40from our website. Links are in the description below. Don't miss out. Get your copy today.
01:47And now, let's continue with today's case.
02:07The Petit family represented the American dream. Dr. William Petit Jr. was a respected endocrinologist
02:14who had practiced in Plainville, Connecticut since 1989. Born on September 24, 1956, in Southington,
02:23Connecticut, William grew up in a family deeply involved in their community. His father ran a
02:29general store and served on the school board and town council. After graduating from Dartmouth College,
02:37William attended the University of Pittsburgh School of Medicine, where his life would change forever.
02:44In 1985, while working as a third-year medical student at Children's Hospital of Pittsburgh,
02:50he met Jennifer Hawke, a new oncology nurse at the same hospital. Their connection was immediate,
02:56and they married on April 13, 1985, in Meadville, Pennsylvania.
03:03Jennifer, born September 26, 1958, in Morristown, New Jersey, brought warmth and dedication to
03:11everything she did. She became the co-director of the health center at Cheshire Academy,
03:17a private boarding school where she was beloved by students and staff.
03:21Despite being diagnosed with multiple sclerosis, Jennifer never let her condition define her.
03:28Instead, she turned it into a cause that would inspire her entire family.
03:34The Petits had two daughters who were the pride of their lives. Haley Elizabeth, born October 15,
03:411989, was 17 years old in the summer of 2007. She had just graduated from the prestigious
03:49Miss Porter School in Farmington, where she excelled in everything she touched.
03:55Haley ran varsity cross country, played basketball and crew, maintained a spot on the high honor role,
04:02and was elected Athletic Association Head, a senior leadership position. She had been accepted to
04:09Dartmouth College, her father's alma mater, where she planned to study medicine and continue the family
04:15legacy of service. But Haley's greatest passion was fighting multiple sclerosis in honor of her mother.
04:24She captained a Walk MS team called Haley's Hope and won a school award for exceptional community service.
04:32Her dedication to this cause would become part of her lasting legacy.
04:3611-year-old Michaela Rose Petit, born November 17, 1995, was the family's creative spirit.
04:45She attended Chase Collegiate School in Waterbury and loved cooking, often preparing elaborate meals for
04:52her family. On July 22, 2007, she went shopping with her mother to buy ingredients for a special dinner
05:00she planned to cook that evening. Michaela had already decided that when Haley left for college,
05:06she would take over the MS fundraising team and rename it Michaela's Miracle.
05:13The Petits were deeply embedded in their community. Their home on Sorghum Mill Road in Cheshire was a
05:19place of warmth, achievement, and hope. They had built a life that many would envy, successful careers,
05:27bright children, and a strong commitment to making the world better. But unknown to them,
05:33they had been noticed by two men who would destroy everything they had built.
05:40Joshua Komisarzewski was 26 years old in 2007 with a history of burglary convictions and drug abuse.
05:49Born on August 10, 1980, he had been adopted by Ben and Jude Komisarzewski
05:56into a family with deep ties to the arts. His grandfather was the renowned theater director
06:02Theodore Komisarzewski. But Joshua's life had taken a dark turn. He had spent years in and out of
06:10the criminal justice system, and by July 2007, he was on parole. Stephen Hayes, 44 years old, had an
06:20even longer criminal record dating back to a burglary conviction in 1981 when he was still a teenager.
06:28Born on May 30, 1963, Hayes had spent much of his adult life cycling through the prison system.
06:36Court documents would later reveal a disturbing pattern of cruelty that began in childhood,
06:41including severe abuse toward his younger brother.
06:45The two men had met through a halfway house drug treatment program.
06:49Both were supposed to be under supervision, monitored by the parole system designed to
06:54protect the public. But on July 22, 2007, they were free to walk the streets of Cheshire,
07:01planning their next crime.
07:06Sunday evening, July 22, 2007, seemed like any other summer day.
07:12Jennifer Petit took 11-year-old Michaela to a local supermarket. Michaela was excited about
07:18the special dinner she planned to cook for her family. As they shopped for ingredients,
07:24they had no idea they were being watched. Joshua Komisarzewski spotted them in the store. Later
07:31testimony and trial evidence would reveal that he followed Jennifer and Michaela from the supermarket
07:37back to their home on Sorghum Mill Road. He observed the family, their routine, their beautiful home.
07:44He saw opportunity. He saw targets.
07:47That evening, Komisarzewski contacted Stephen Hayes. At 7.45 p.m., Hayes sent a chilling text message.
07:58I'm chomping at the bit to get started. Need a margarita soon.
08:02Over the next hour and a half, between 8.45 p.m. and 9.20 p.m.,
08:08the two men exchanged texts that prosecutors would later use as evidence of premeditation.
08:13They were joking, planning, anticipating what they were about to do.
08:19Police later reported that the pair may have even gone shopping for implements,
08:23an air rifle and rope, after seeing the girls at the supermarket. They were methodically preparing
08:30for a home invasion. The Petit family went to sleep that night with no idea that two violent
08:37criminals had marked them for destruction. The exact timing of the initial entry remains somewhat
08:46disputed in official records. A Connecticut Supreme Court summary places the entry at around 2 a.m.
08:54on Monday, July 23. Other police reports and contemporaneous news coverage describe the break-in
09:01as occurring shortly after 3 a.m. What is clear is that Hayes and Komisarzewski entered the Petit home
09:10in the early morning darkness. Dr. William Petit was sleeping on a couch on the first floor,
09:17having dozed off after watching television. He was suddenly awakened by a devastating blow to his head
09:24with a baseball bat they had found in the home. The attack was brutal and immediate. William was dragged
09:31to the basement, disoriented and bleeding. The intruders bound him with rope and pillowcases,
09:38ensuring he couldn't escape or call for help. They beat him repeatedly. Later medical evidence would
09:44document severe injuries, head trauma, facial fractures, and extensive bruising. But somehow,
09:52William remained conscious, trapped in his own basement while the nightmare unfolded upstairs.
09:59Jennifer and the two girls were herded into their bedrooms and tied to their beds. The intruders
10:05told them this was just a robbery, that if everyone cooperated, no one would be hurt. It was a lie that
10:12would be repeated throughout the ordeal, a cruel psychological tactic to maintain control while they
10:18methodically planned something far more sinister. For approximately six to seven hours, the Petit family
10:26endured unimaginable terror. The intruders ransacked the house, searching for valuables, credit cards,
10:34bank information. They demanded to know where money was kept, what accounts the family had access to.
10:40All the while, they kept the family separated, bound, and terrified.
10:47At some point during this period, Stephen Hayes left the house and went to a nearby gas station.
10:54Surveillance video captured him purchasing $10 worth of gasoline in containers taken from the Petit
11:00Garage. This wasn't for a getaway vehicle. It was for something far more horrific.
11:06As morning broke on July 23rd, the situation escalated into its most critical phase.
11:14The intruders had decided to force Jennifer to go to the bank and withdraw money. It was around 9am
11:21when Stephen Hayes drove Jennifer to the Bank of America on Maplecroft Plaza in Cheshire,
11:27holding her hostage in her own vehicle. Jennifer knew she was in grave danger. She knew her family was
11:33being held in the home, but she also saw an opportunity to get help. When she entered the bank,
11:40she managed to communicate to bank personnel that something was desperately wrong. The bank manager
11:46immediately recognized the danger Jennifer was in. At 9.21am, while Jennifer was still at or near the
11:54teller window, the bank manager called 911. He tracked Jennifer's movements in real time, updating the
12:01dispatcher as she completed the forced withdrawal. At 9.25am, the dispatcher relayed critical details to
12:09a supervising officer. One minute later, at 9.26am, a broadcast went out to all Cheshire Police units
12:17with vehicle information and the license plate number. The wheels of law enforcement were now in motion.
12:25Police were dispatched toward both the bank area and the Petit residence. But for the family trapped
12:32inside the house, time was running out. When Hayes returned to the house with Jennifer and the
12:39withdrawn money, the situation inside had already deteriorated beyond imagination. While Hayes had been at
12:47the bank, Komiser Jevsky had assaulted Michaela. He had taken explicit photographs with his cell phone,
12:54evidence that would later be crucial in proving the depraved nature of these crimes.
13:00Jennifer was also assaulted. The medical examiner would later confirm that both mother and youngest
13:06daughter had been victimized in the most horrific ways possible. The intruders had never intended to
13:13simply rob the family and leave. They had planned something far more permanent.
13:20The men knew police were likely coming. The bank manager's call had started a countdown.
13:25They couldn't stop. Rather than flee and abandon their victims alive, Hayes and Komiser Jevsky
13:32made a decision that would seal their fate as two of the most hated criminals in Connecticut history.
13:38They doused the house with the gasoline Hayes had purchased. They poured it around the beds where
13:45Hayley and Michaela lay tied and helpless. Then they set the house on fire. Jennifer Hawk Petit, 48 years
13:54old, didn't die in the flames. She was strangled to death, a final act of violence before the fire could
14:02consume her. Her daughters, 17-year-old Hayley and 11-year-old Michaela, died from smoke inhalation as
14:10the flames spread rapidly through the home. They were conscious when the fire started. They knew they
14:16were going to die. In the basement, Dr. William Petit was still bound but conscious. The smell of smoke
14:25filtered down to him. He could hear the sounds above. Summoning strength he didn't know he had,
14:32despite his severe injuries, William managed to free himself from his restraints. He crawled to a
14:38basement window, kicked it open, and escaped to a neighbor's yard. He collapsed on their porch,
14:45bloody and barely conscious, but alive.
14:48Cheshire police arrived at the Petit residence to a scene of chaos. The house was visibly burning.
14:57Just as they arrived, they saw two men exit the house and get into a vehicle in the driveway.
15:03These were Hayes and Commissar Jeffsky, attempting to flee the scene of their crimes.
15:10What happened next unfolded in seconds. The suspects started the vehicle and began to back out.
15:16Police moved to block their exit. Rather than surrender, the suspects rammed their vehicle
15:22into multiple police cruisers, trying desperately to escape. But the collisions disabled their vehicle.
15:29They were trapped. At gunpoint, both Stephen Hayes and Joshua Commissar Jeffsky were taken into custody.
15:37They were arrested at the scene while firefighters rushed to battle the blaze, consuming the Petit home.
15:44When firefighters finally suppressed the fire and could safely enter, they discovered what everyone
15:50had feared. Three bodies were found inside. Jennifer, Haley, and Michaela had all perished.
15:58The only survivor was Dr. William Petit, who had been transported to the hospital with life-threatening
16:04injuries. Multiple scenes had to be secured. The bank where Jennifer had made her desperate,
16:14silent plea for help. The burning home where three women had died. And the collision site where
16:20the suspects had been arrested. The Cheshire Police Department, Connecticut State Police Central
16:26District Major Crime Squad, and the State Fire Marshal's Office all responded to what had become
16:33one of the most heinous crimes in Connecticut history. The investigation that followed built an
16:39overwhelming case against both perpetrators. Text messages between Hayes and Commissar Jeffsky from the
16:46night before the crime showed clear premeditation. Their joking anticipatory messages about getting
16:53started demolished any defense that this had been a burglary that spontaneously escalated.
17:01The cell phone belonging to Joshua Commissar Jeffsky contained photographs that were
17:06almost too disturbing to describe. Digital images showed the victims bound and included explicit photos
17:14of the assault of Michaela. Technology expert John Farnham testified about these images at trial,
17:21and they became crucial evidence linking Commissar Jeffsky directly to the assault charges.
17:27Bank surveillance video showed Hayes with Jennifer during the forced withdrawal.
17:32Gas station surveillance showed Hayes purchasing the gasoline shortly before the arson. The timeline
17:39was airtight. Medical examiner Wayne Carver provided testimony about the causes of death.
17:46Jennifer had been strangled. Haley and Michaela had died from smoke inhalation, their bodies found in
17:53their burned beds where they had been tied. The physical evidence from the fire scene showed ropes,
17:59restraints, and the accelerant patterns that proved arson. Perhaps most damning laboratory officials
18:07testified that blood samples showed neither Hayes nor Commissar Jeffsky had alcohol or illegal drugs in
18:14their systems. There was no intoxication defense. They had been completely aware of their actions.
18:20On Tuesday, July 24, 2007, just one day after the murders, both suspects were arraigned in
18:29Meriden Superior Court. The state announced charges including kidnapping, burglary, arson, robbery, larceny,
18:38and assault. Each was held on $15 million bond. By Thursday, July 26, 2007, prosecutors announced they
18:49would seek the death penalty. Both men were formally charged with six capital felony counts, charges that
18:56made them eligible for execution under Connecticut law at the time.
19:02Stephen Hayes went to trial first. His trial began on September 13, 2010, more than three years after the
19:10crime. On October 5, 2010, the jury found him guilty on all counts. On November 8, 2010, the jury
19:21recommended the death penalty. On December 2, 2010, Judge John Blue formally sentenced Hayes to death.
19:29Joshua Commissar Jeffsky's trial began on September 19, 2011. On September 22, jurors heard his recorded
19:41confession. On September 28, they saw the text messages and heard medical examiner testimony about
19:48evidence of Michaela's assault. His defense team presented evidence of the abuse Commissar Jeffsky had
19:54suffered, hoping for mitigation in sentencing. The jury was unmoved.
20:01Commissar Jeffsky was also found guilty and sentenced to death. Both men would sit on Connecticut's death
20:08row, their appeals dragging through the courts while Dr. William Petit tried to rebuild a shattered life.
20:15The Petit murders became a watershed moment for Connecticut. On July 28, 2007, just five days after
20:27the murders, thousands attended a memorial service where Dr. William Petit eulogized his family. A
20:34community gathered at Central Connecticut State University to mourn three lives taken too soon. In the
20:41months that followed, the outpouring of support was extraordinary. On January 6, 2008, the Cheshire
20:50Lights of Hope event saw more than 130,000 luminaria candles lit in memory of Jennifer, Haley, and Michaela.
20:59The Petit Family Foundation was established to continue the charitable work, especially the MS advocacy
21:06that had meant so much to the family. Then came an unexpected turn. On April 25, 2012, Connecticut
21:17enacted legislation that prospectively repealed the death penalty for crimes committed on or after that
21:23date. The new law didn't affect Hayes and Commissar Jeffsky, whose crimes had occurred in 2007. They
21:31remained on death row. But in 2015, the Connecticut Supreme Court issued a landmark ruling in a case
21:40called State v. Santiago. The court held that executing prisoners for crimes committed before
21:46the 2012 repeal would constitute cruel and unusual punishment under the Connecticut State Constitution.
21:55All death sentences were to be converted to life imprisonment without the possibility of release.
22:01In June 2016, Stephen Hayes was resentenced by Judge John Blue to six consecutive life terms
22:11without the possibility of release, plus an additional 106 years on related charges.
22:19Judge Blue's words at resentencing were final and absolute. With the gravity of these crimes
22:26and the depravity of your character, nothing more needs to be said.
22:31On July 26, 2016, Joshua Komisar Jeffsky received the same sentence, six consecutive life terms
22:40without the possibility of release. Both men will die in prison. There will be no parole hearings,
22:47no chances for release, no possibility of freedom. The Cheshire home invasion stands as one of the
22:54most brutal crimes in American history. It exposed failures in the parole system, sparked debates about
23:00the death penalty, and left a community forever scarred. But perhaps more importantly, it showed us the
23:07preciousness of life and the devastating consequences when evil goes unchecked.
23:15Dr. William Petit survived physically, but he lost everything that mattered most.
23:21In the years following the tragedy, he has shown remarkable resilience. He has since remarried and had
23:28children, working tirelessly to honor his first family's memory through continued charitable work.
23:34Dr. William Petit Family Foundation continues to support causes that were dear to Jennifer,
23:41Haley, and Michaela, particularly in the areas of education and multiple sclerosis research.
23:48William has become a powerful advocate for victims' rights and criminal justice reform. He has testified
23:56before legislative committees, spoken at conferences, and worked with lawmakers to strengthen parole
24:02supervision and improve the criminal justice system's ability to protect the public. His advocacy helped
24:09shape Connecticut's response to violent crime, including stricter parole guidelines and enhanced monitoring
24:16of repeat offenders. The parole board faced intense scrutiny. Questions arose about risk assessment,
24:24supervision protocols, and whether warning signs had been missed or ignored.
24:29The case became a catalyst for reform, with new legislation passed to tighten parole requirements,
24:37increase supervision of high-risk offenders, and provide better training for parole officers in
24:42identifying dangerous behavior patterns. The death penalty debate that followed the
24:48Connecticut Supreme Court's 2015 ruling was equally contentious. Many victims' rights advocates, including Dr.
24:57Petit himself, believed that Hayes and Komisarzewski deserved execution. They argued that the brutality
25:04of the crimes warranted the ultimate punishment, and that converting their death sentences to life
25:10imprisonment represented a failure of justice. Others saw the Connecticut Supreme Court's decision as a
25:19principled stand against capital punishment regardless of the heinousness of the crime.
25:24The court reasoned that once Connecticut had decided the death penalty was wrong going forward,
25:30it would be inconsistent and cruel to continue executing prisoners for older crimes.
25:36The debate continues to this day, with the Petit case serving as the primary example used by both sides.
25:43Jennifer, Haley, and Michaela Petit were extraordinary people whose lives were stolen by two men who chose
25:53violence, cruelty, and murder. Jennifer was more than a nurse and a mother. She was a caregiver who touched
26:01countless lives at Cheshire Academy. Students remembered her kindness, her dedication,
26:07and her ability to make everyone feel cared for even as she battled her own illness.
26:14Haley was on the cusp of greatness. Her acceptance to Dartmouth, her athletic achievements, her leadership
26:21roles, all pointed to a young woman who would have made significant contributions to society.
26:27Her dedication to MS fundraising showed a maturity and compassion beyond her years.
26:33The world lost not just a bright student, but a future leader in medicine and advocacy.
26:40Michaela, at just 11 years old, had already shown the creativity and warmth that would have defined her life.
26:48Her love of cooking, her eagerness to take over her sister's fundraising work, her excitement about
26:55starting middle school, these were the dreams of a child whose future was limitless.
27:00That future was stolen in the most horrific way imaginable.
27:05They deserved to grow old, to achieve their dreams, to make their mark on the world.
27:11Instead, they became symbols, reminders that evil exists, that vigilance matters, and that justice,
27:19though sometimes imperfect, must always strive to protect the innocent.
27:36For more, these families who cares to help us then change speeds
27:42to secure that Möglichkeit...
27:49...
27:52...
27:54...
Comments