Skip to player
Skip to main content
Search
Connect
Watch fullscreen
Like
Bookmark
Share
More
Add to Playlist
Report
'SIR সংবিধান বিরোধী!' সংসদে বিরাট হুঙ্কার সাংসদ কল্যাণের, ঠিক কী বললেন?
Asianet News Bangla
Follow
1 day ago
'SIR সংবিধান বিরোধী!' সংসদে বিরাট হুঙ্কার সাংসদ কল্যাণের, ঠিক কী বললেন?
Category
🗞
News
Transcript
Display full video transcript
00:00
Where is the foreigners?
00:11
You have failed to discharge your duties.
00:14
Whether your father-in-law's, mother-in-law's, mother-in-law's father had spared.
00:21
Uncle his name is there or not.
00:23
Put the name.
00:25
If the election commission doesn't do it,
00:27
I will see up to Supreme Court what is the power of the Supreme Court election commission.
00:32
Nobody is above the law!
00:34
Shri Kalyan Banar Ji,
00:38
Aaj Kalyan Banar Ji suited me, tie-ae bhi laga rakhir.
00:44
Thank you, the honourable speaker, sir.
00:47
And I am obliged...
00:48
I am obliged that you are holding the chair.
00:55
Sir, after the commencement of the SIR, Special Intensive Revision,
01:04
huge work pressure, inhuman work pressures, were given to the BLO.
01:12
As a result thereof, in West Bengal, twenty persons have committed suicide.
01:22
And suicide notes are there.
01:25
Five persons became ill.
01:28
Nineteen persons expired.
01:31
And three persons attempted to commit suicide.
01:36
Who will be responsible, sir, for this?
01:40
Election commission.
01:44
And it has been pointed out that because of the pressure, we are committing suicide.
01:50
All right.
01:51
This is not the lone picture of the West Bengal, sir.
01:56
In Uttar Pradesh, Akhilesji Abhiabhi bola, ten persons, BJP state.
02:05
Madhya Pradesh, nine persons, BJP state.
02:12
Gujarat, six persons, BJP state.
02:17
Rajasthan, your state, sir.
02:20
BJP state, three persons.
02:24
How many people have gone?
02:25
How many people have gone?
02:26
How many people have gone?
02:27
How many people have gone?
02:28
How many people have gone?
02:29
Why?
02:30
We have gone.
02:31
Kerala, CPM.
02:32
One person.
02:33
Tamil Nadu, two.
02:34
DMK.
02:35
Three are non-BJP.
02:36
And five are the BJP states.
02:39
Sir, let me talk about some constitutional provisions and law.
02:55
Sir, article 324 of the constitution of India has given the power to the election commission,
03:08
for superintendents, direction, and control of election to be vested in an election commission,
03:16
including the electoral rule.
03:19
And article 327 of the constitution of India empowers the parliament to enact law for the
03:30
purpose of the election.
03:32
The elections to the house of the people, the subject to the provisions of this parliament
03:37
from time to time, by law, make provision with respect to all matters relating to or in
03:42
connection with elections to either the house of the parliament or to the house of the other
03:47
legislatures.
03:48
Therefore, by reason of this power, under article 327, this parliament engrafted law represents
03:58
the people's act 1950 and 1951.
04:03
1950 is a subject matter today because it deals with the electoral rule.
04:10
Sir, this election commission is saying all the time, I have a superintendents power, I can't do anything.
04:20
But with respect I am saying, power of superintendents cannot override the power enacted by this parliament
04:31
under any act under article 327.
04:33
How this power comes, and power and how to, electoral role would be prepared, that has been engrafted
04:45
by this parliament under the representation of the people's act 1950 and rules framed there under,
04:56
that is the representation of the people's act 1960.
04:59
Sir, section 21 of the act itself speaks about the preparation and revision of the electoral
05:07
rules.
05:08
21, 22.
05:11
But 21 subsection 3 speaks about that, notwithstanding anything contained in subsection 2, the election
05:21
may at any time, for reasons to be recorded, direct a special revision of the electoral rule
05:26
for any constituency or part of a constituency in such manner as it may think fit.
05:31
If a constituency is there, we can't read here constituencies.
05:36
We cannot read this state, how invoking the power under article 21, subarticle 3, entire country,
05:46
this is, this is, SIR is going on?
05:49
No, no, probation is different.
05:51
This, this cannot be done.
05:53
There is an existence of the electoral role is there.
05:57
And existence of the, so long existence of the electoral role is there, any election is
06:03
done, it has to be done on the basis of the existing electoral role.
06:07
Sir, very interesting.
06:08
Sir, aap chala jate hain, sir.
06:09
Chaliyye.
06:10
Aar kya karega mein?
06:11
Sir, aare aap aa gay hai?
06:12
Haan.
06:13
Khi cha mat.
06:14
Allow karna bolna ke liya.
06:15
Sir, this is the rule, represents of the election rules 1960, this rule, rule 5 to rule
06:34
22 speaks about the registration of the electors, how to be done, electoral rule.
06:45
Sir, here, more importantly is the rule 24.
06:50
Rule 24 speaks about, one, if any constituency is delimited, a new in accordance with law,
07:02
and it is necessary urgently to prepare the role for such, the Electoral Election Commission
07:07
may direct that it shall be prepared by putting together all the roles of such existing constituency
07:12
or parts thereof by making appropriate alterations.
07:16
Therefore, the moment delimitation has been taken place, electoral role has come into force.
07:22
Under the operation of these rules, only that is the role will remain, how the 2022 electoral
07:31
role exists.
07:33
Delimitation was effected in 2009, electoral role was prepared in 2009, all of us, many
07:42
of us have elected and came to the house on the basis of that electoral role.
07:48
If these two electoral roles come, sir, the 2002 electoral role has gone, doesn't exist
07:58
at all.
07:59
The whole SIR is contrary to rule 24 and also contrary to the constitutional provisions and
08:06
the act, and that's absolutely unconstitutional.
08:10
Absolutely unconstitutional.
08:11
You can't do it.
08:12
It is not the whims of choice of the election commission or caprice.
08:18
Election commission has to go by each and every word of the act and the rules.
08:24
Each and every act of the rules cannot do it in delimitation in this fashion.
08:31
However, have you seen the enumeration list?
08:36
In the enumeration list it is literally written names of the relatives.
08:45
Relatives have not been defined under the act.
08:48
Relatives have not been defined under rule.
08:53
My brother is also my relative.
08:56
My wife is also my relative.
08:59
My uncle is also my relative.
09:02
My father-in-law is also relative.
09:05
But the form app has been made in such a way, unless the parents' names are not there, they
09:12
would not be treated as relatives.
09:15
App will not entertain.
09:19
It will reject.
09:20
Sir, the question more is, whether an app will decide who will be my relative?
09:29
My brother is not my relative.
09:33
My wife is not my relative.
09:37
How it can be?
09:39
If my wife's name is there in 2002, if my name is not there in 2002, then let's assume
09:47
my parents died, then I will not be included.
09:53
What is the ambition?
09:55
What is the object?
09:57
Object is the inclusion.
10:00
Here, that object is being defeated.
10:04
SIR is only to delete the electors.
10:08
Only to delete the electors.
10:10
How to delete?
10:12
How it has been?
10:15
New voters will come.
10:17
Nobody has think or thought about the process of SIR.
10:20
What the election commission is doing, saying, no, no, let us do, allow us to do this SIR.
10:26
Thereafter, we will take SSI's of the enrollment of the new elector.
10:32
Is it not country to the Act and Rules?
10:35
Is it not country to the Constitution?
10:38
Why an, why an elector whose name was there in 2024 can be said he is not for the time
10:50
being an elector since his name is not there in 2002?
10:54
You are taking away the right?
10:57
Election commission will take away my right to be rude to remain as elector?
11:02
Even for one day, SIR, constitutional right cannot be stayed.
11:10
If right under the Constitution is there, SIR, one thing is said, voters' right, only
11:19
in that case, you have a right to election.
11:22
If you don't vote for the election, why do you vote for the election?
11:28
If you don't vote for the election, then what will the election be?
11:32
It was before it.
11:34
It was before it.
11:36
It was now.
11:38
Elector will decide the government.
11:40
Who will be my government?
11:43
Modi ji decides government through the election commission.
11:46
If you want to vote for the election commission, then you decide.
11:53
Why?
11:54
It is a constitutional body.
11:55
I think, SIR, yes, yes, yes.
11:57
Election commission.
11:58
So many persons have said nobody raised objection.
12:01
You are raising an objection.
12:03
Don't say a little harm, don't say objection.
12:06
Let's listen.
12:07
Let's listen.
12:08
Let's listen.
12:09
Let's listen.
12:10
Let's listen.
12:11
Let's listen.
12:12
Let's listen.
12:13
Election commissioner.
12:14
Let's listen.
12:15
Let's listen.
12:16
Election commission.
12:17
Let's listen.
12:18
Let's listen.
12:19
Sir, relatives will be deprived.
12:21
Sir, I am telling you one incident.
12:24
One lady came to my constituency and said, sir, we haven't got difficult.
12:28
What has happened?
12:31
My father-in-law and mother-in-law, they are named since 1995 in the electoral room.
12:38
And they were working in the Delhi Department at Kharagpur.
12:43
In 2001, at the end, they were transferred.
12:48
Now, 2002, when the SIR was made, just they had gone, their names were not included.
12:57
Thereafter, again, names have been included now.
13:02
My mother-in-law cannot enroll since my father-in-law's name was not there.
13:13
What an unfortunate incident is going on in the country itself.
13:18
A voter by reason of the transfer has been transferred.
13:21
Now, 2002, there is no rule.
13:23
Name was not there.
13:25
I have said to her, whether your father-in-law's mother-in-law's mother-in-law's father had expired,
13:35
uncle's name is there or not, put the name.
13:38
If the election commission doesn't do it, I will see up to the Supreme Court what is the power of the Supreme Court election commission.
13:46
Nobody is above the law.
13:49
No one is above the law.
13:51
And final things will be said by the Supreme Court of India.
13:55
Other card was not mentioned in the first enumeration list.
14:00
In Bihar matters, Supreme Court has included the other card.
14:05
Supreme Court has included the other card which has resolved so many problems.
14:11
Now, sir, the deletion part.
14:23
Now, sir, the point is that very crucial question is whether the names of the voter would be deleted with that object.
14:36
That cannot be, that cannot be purpose.
14:39
But election commission is saying that votes, 3 lakhs votes have been deleted, 5 lakhs have been deleted, 7 lakhs have been deleted,
14:48
and BJP people out there are dancing their Englishmen.
14:51
Ah, ah, ah, one card, one card, one card, one card, one card, one card, one card, one card, one card.
14:57
How can this happen?
14:59
Now, sir, you see what the election commission is doing?
15:03
To find out whether the elector is a citizen of India or not?
15:08
Under the Repentant People's Act, the rules, ordinary resident has been said, not the citizen of India has been said.
15:17
Ordinary resident, not the citizen of India.
15:22
Who will decide?
15:24
Election commission will decide that he is a citizen or not a citizen.
15:29
It will be, sir,
15:32
The citizenship, who will decide it will be a citizen?
15:50
Under the authority under the Citizenship Act, not by the election commission of India.
15:55
said if even the election if they if any foreigner is there who can have the who can
16:05
arrest them who can election commission certainly not there is a law there is a law foreign
16:15
investors law just that they will decide the whom it has been given the power power has been
16:25
given to the police there were election commission is not the authority to decide who is citizen and
16:31
who is not citizen
16:32
to say good patient good patient good patient gp tube patient to the house and
16:42
who has done it again
16:43
where is the foreigners you have failed to discharge your duties if the foreigners have
17:13
come override come where they have come BSF could not detect it CISF could not detect it that's a fault
17:25
on the part of the Home Minister and the Honorable Prime Minister that is not the fault of anyone
17:31
they have given the power has been given Home Department name Mizoram go government
17:48
what is the reason is the Mizoram state is a favorite child of the Narantham Odiya
18:06
and Bengali if someone speaks Bengali in Delhi at Delhi you see she or he would be arrested
18:16
and you have seen that Supreme Court order
18:21
has been compelled to Sonali Bibi ko leya na pada has been compelled to Sonali Bibi ko leya na pada
18:32
I know I understand understand the problem these BJP is basically is a Bengali hitter
19:00
Bengali hitter that is the reason that is the reason that is the reason that is the reason
19:07
statue is broken that is the reason Ramon Raya has been seriously criticized and that is the reason
19:17
our honorable prime minister speaks
19:22
when he was born
19:24
when he was born
19:26
the 3rd generation of Modi ji ka
19:28
Pahe leo ka pahle unko bhi dadha bol de te hai
19:31
sir da da da bol de te hai
19:33
kavi koi guzati ko to nehi bol ta da da balok bhai patel daa bolte hai
19:37
kavi bolan
19:38
Bengali ko serve
19:40
to hate Bengal
19:42
hate Bengalis
19:44
this is your work to be done
19:47
done. Sir, I will be very quick in saying three or four points. 15 na? No, no, just
20:00
give me five minutes. It is stated that the process has caused mass, but don't cut it
20:06
from Satavdi. Mass, high strain, suicide attempt due to SIR panic. Mother attempted suicide
20:14
along with the child, other documentation fear. Hunger strike by Motua community. This
20:21
Motua community. Sir, do you know what is happening? One BJP MOS sitting in West Bengal is giving
20:30
the citizens a certificate. Can you imagine? Motua. But the central government is not arresting
20:40
that minister. This certificate will be given under the Citizenship Act, not by any otherwise.
20:48
Sir, in my area, in my constituency, Motua never cast more to me. I am telling you, this time
20:56
when SIR is going on, in my one of the area, Domjur Jagadishpur, huge Motua came to me and
21:03
said that we have, we will be, our names would not be there. Anna, don't worry. I am here.
21:08
Mamuta Banerjee is here. We'll see you in political fight and also in the Supreme Court. Sir, BLO linked
21:16
with the SIR. BLO. Wi-Fi is not available in the village, remote village. And you are saying
21:22
that you have to have to work. Even in the Ponchait office, the election commission is
21:27
not allowing the BLO to function from there where the Wi-Fi is available. Sir, BSF exercises
21:33
quasi-judicial authority who will be the citizen of this country. Sir, lack of proper adjudicating
21:41
procedure. Residents of the border districts experience constant fear of non-citizens.
21:47
But see, I have spoken about only the BLOs. I have not spoken about the voters. Illegal
21:54
pushback practice. When the SIR has started, has comments, all of a sudden they are rising
22:02
to push back the foreigners. Sir, thank you. At least you have tolerated me this time.
22:10
I am grateful to you. Thank you, Sir. Thank you.
Be the first to comment
Add your comment
Recommended
6:25
|
Up next
লোকসভায় দাঁড়িয়ে কমিশনের কাছে কেন্দ্রীয় বাহিনীর আর্জি অভিজিৎ গাঙ্গুলির
Asianet News Bangla
2 hours ago
5:46
শেখ শাহজাহানকে অন্য রাজ্যে নিয়ে যাওয়ার আর্জি শুভেন্দুর
Asianet News Bangla
3 hours ago
8:05
ওয়াকফ ইস্যুতে মমতাকে একহাত নিলেন শুভেন্দু! সব প্রমাণ ফাঁস করলেন আজ
Asianet News Bangla
5 hours ago
3:48
খড়দহে BLO-র বাড়িতে হামলা, সরাসরি তৃণমূলকে দায়ী অর্জুনের
Asianet News Bangla
6 hours ago
5:14
টার্গেট সাক্ষী? ড্রাইভার কে? নেপথ্যে সবিতা ও মোসলেম! নয়া মোড় শুভেন্দুর মন্তব্যে
Asianet News Bangla
6 hours ago
6:56
'বাবাকে ফলো করছিল লরিটা' লরির চালক শাহজাহানের কে হয়? বলেদিলেন ভোলা ঘোষের ছেলে!
Asianet News Bangla
7 hours ago
6:29
এক ভোটার কার্ডে একাধিক মানুষ! ফর্ম জমা করতেই ফাঁস ভয়াবহ গরমিল
Asianet News Bangla
8 hours ago
5:37
খড়দহে রাতের অন্ধকারে BLO-র বাড়িতে দুষ্কৃতীদের হামলা, আতঙ্কে BLO সহ তাঁর পরিবার
Asianet News Bangla
8 hours ago
8:00
টার্গেট কী ভোলা ঘোষ? আদালতে যাওয়ার পথেই শেষ! শাহজাহানের বিরুদ্ধে সাক্ষ্য দিতে যেতেই এমন ঘটনা!
Asianet News Bangla
9 hours ago
8:21
গীতাপাঠের অনুষ্ঠানে চিকেন প্য়াটিস বিক্রেতাকে মারধর! কী প্রতিক্রিয়া অধীরের
Asianet News Bangla
10 hours ago
5:06
SIR-এর আবহে ভয়ংকর ছবি! আবর্জনার বস্তা খুলতেই বেরোল একরাশ ভোটার কার্ড
Asianet News Bangla
11 hours ago
4:36
'গীতাপাঠ হয়েছে, এবার কোরান পাঠ করাব' ফের হুঁশিয়ারি দিলেন হুমায়ুন কবীর
Asianet News Bangla
11 hours ago
3:42
সংসদে ‘বঙ্কিমদা’ বলায় মোদীকে কটাক্ষ তৃণমূলের! কী প্রতিক্রিয়া দিলেন দিলীপ?
Asianet News Bangla
13 hours ago
3:51
'কারও নাম বাদ গেলে BJP-কে বুথে ঢুকতে দেব না!' হুমকি TMC নেতার, পাল্টা বিজেপি
Asianet News Bangla
13 hours ago
5:22
'চাই না বলিনি, পাই না বলেছি' মুসলিম ভোট নিয়ে ফের অবস্থান স্পষ্ট করলেন শুভেন্দু
Asianet News Bangla
14 hours ago
4:51
কাগজ ছিঁড়ে প্রতিবাদ মমতার, পাল্টা আক্রমণে বিজেপির ভাবনা বোহরা
Asianet News Bangla
16 hours ago
7:12
‘তৃণমূল বিজেপির কাছে মাথা নত করে না!’ কোচবিহারে রণহুংকার মমতার
Asianet News Bangla
1 day ago
3:59
নিউটাউনে তৃণমূলের বাড়ল অস্বস্তি! গেরুয়া শিবিরে দুই নেতা-কর্মীর যোগদান
Asianet News Bangla
1 day ago
4:50
সংসদে ‘বঙ্কিমদা’ বলায় মোদীকে কটাক্ষ তৃণমূলের! পাল্টা আক্রমণ সুকান্তর
Asianet News Bangla
1 day ago
4:52
‘বিজেপির সঙ্গে সংঘাতে যেতে চান না মমতা!’ শাসকের আসল উদ্দেশ্য ফাঁস করলেন অধীর
Asianet News Bangla
1 day ago
4:47
নন্দীগ্রামে SIR-এর কাজে কি সন্তুষ্ট কমিশন? খতিয়ে দেখলেন পর্যবেক্ষক নীলম মিনা
Asianet News Bangla
1 day ago
9:35
এক ঘণ্টায় বিজেপিকে ‘সাফ’ করার হুমকি তৃণমূল নেতার! পাল্টা দিয়ে চরম কটাক্ষ বিজেপির
Asianet News Bangla
1 day ago
6:39
'এখন সুতো গোটাচ্ছে, যতদিন যাবে যন্ত্রণা বাড়বে' কাদেরকে ঠুকলেন শুভেন্দু?
Asianet News Bangla
1 day ago
9:06
ওয়াকফ বিল নিয়ে মমতাকে বিস্ফোরক আক্রমণ শুভেন্দুর! দেখুন কী বলছেন তিনি
Asianet News Bangla
1 day ago
10:55
'এবার থেকে যেখানে যাবেন বন্দে মাতরম বাজান হবে' মমতাকে চরম বার্তা শুভেন্দুর
Asianet News Bangla
2 days ago
Be the first to comment