Skip to playerSkip to main content
  • 1 day ago
Transcript
00:00Simple question for you to start, Rich. What happens next?
00:04You know, it is really anyone's guess.
00:07You know, you've now got this hostile offer, tender offer from the Ellisons and from Paramount.
00:14Obviously, shareholders are going to have to, you know, really look at this.
00:17I mean, you've got, you know, the offers are very different, right?
00:21Because one is for just the streaming and studios, and you're going to end up with a resulting stub equity that is the cable network piece.
00:29And, you know, depending on how that's valued, it could be anywhere from, you know, a buck and a half to four or five dollars like a share.
00:36And so it all depends on sort of how that trades ultimately.
00:40And do investors want to sort of bet on the value of that entity, own some Netflix equity, as well as get 20, you know, plus dollars, $23 of cash?
00:51So this is not a simple equation.
00:53Obviously, we know from Warner Brothers that they believe that the Netflix offer was superior.
01:00They think it was $31 or $32 a share in effective value.
01:04Will some investors want to take 30 in cash?
01:07There may be, and I think that's going to be the question.
01:09But can they get enough of the shares to actually block the transaction?
01:13I think that's what essentially Paramount would now be hoping for,
01:16is that enough people tender their shares that they can stop Netflix and force them to abandon the offer.
01:23If I may, to recap, the Netflix offer was $27.75, but only for the streaming and studios bit, right?
01:30The Paramount Skydance $30 bid was for the entirety of it.
01:34If we put the deal making and the arbitrage to one side,
01:37which makes most sense based on the current state of the media and entertainment landscape?
01:44Look, we're at a point now in the entertainment landscape where the industry is going through seismic change.
01:52You know, movie theater attendance is down 50% from before COVID.
01:58You know, forget about box office, but actually, you know, sort of people attending movies in the U.S.,
02:03you're down nearly 50%.
02:05You know, you're seeing most of the major streaming companies out there really scale back their ambitions,
02:11and that's Warner Brothers.
02:13That's, you know, if you look at what's happened with Peacock, none of them are as aggressive.
02:17Disney and Hulu have certainly reduced their overall aggressiveness in how much content they're making.
02:23Like, everyone is realizing how streaming is so hard.
02:27And so the reality is consolidation is certainly necessary,
02:31and I don't think this is the last transaction we're going to see.
02:34I think you're going to actually see this set off.
02:36You know, there's going to be knock-on effects from whoever ends up buying this.
02:40You're going to see other things happen.
02:43You know, is there a story to tell for both companies?
02:46Absolutely.
02:47I mean, there's no doubt in my mind that if you, you know, put Warner Brothers into Netflix,
02:52the ability to do far more with that library than has ever been done before,
02:57looking at that global platform and how they've been able to sort of surface content.
03:02I mean, all of this content's been sitting on HBO Max, and no one really watches it.
03:07That's what Netflix does really well is they get people to watch things throughout the library in a way that others cannot.
03:14Right.
03:15That algorithm is so powerful.
03:17Paramount buying it?
03:18Look, Paramount needs more scale.
03:20If Paramount doesn't buy this, my guess is they're going to go after something else in the space,
03:24whether that's NBCUniversal, whether that's Sony.
03:28Like, I don't think Paramount is going to sit still.
03:30They want to get bigger.
03:32Look, they may just spend a lot of money.
03:34I mean, Ellison Family has a tremendous amount of capital.
03:37Will they just use that to fund far greater investment than they were previously in Paramount?
03:43That might be another angle here.
03:44I mean, we've always said Paramount doesn't have to have that
03:47because they have one of the wealthiest families in the world backing them.
03:51They've got more than the wealthiest family in the world.
03:54They've got Middle Eastern money helping them with this.
03:56It would transpire.
03:57Does that change the storytelling, Rich?
04:00Well, I think what's interesting is there is this perception on Wall Street
04:04that this was just Larry Ellison, you know, writing a check to buy all of this.
04:08And what it actually turns out is that Larry's only writing a $12 billion check.
04:13He's backstopping a larger portion.
04:15But the actual check he's writing is $12 billion.
04:18And three Middle East entities are actually investing $24 billion.
04:23I don't know if that played into him.
04:25And they say there's no CFIUS concerns.
04:27But you do wonder whether the largest sort of, you know, as a group,
04:31the Middle East being the single largest sort of equity contributor to this deal,
04:36I wonder if that played a role in concern around this transaction.
04:41You know, we'll see.
04:42It's funny how there's been so much sort of industry uproar around Netflix buying Warner Brothers.
04:52I wonder, as people start to understand more of what's inside the Paramount bid,
04:57as you just said, Carolyn, will we see more pushback on the Paramount bid?
05:01I don't know.
05:02I mean, I think, you know, all of these bids have – there certainly are issues.
05:06And look, from a – you know, if you think about sort of from an antitrust standpoint,
05:10Disney bought Fox.
05:12That seemed – you know, Disney was at the pinnacle height of the industry when they bought Fox.
05:16And that was approved during Trump 1.
05:18You know, it's hard to believe that this transaction ultimately gets blocked.
05:23Either one of them gets blocked.
05:24Right.
05:24I think, obviously, the Netflix will probably take longer than the Paramount one,
05:28but I don't think there's any quick approval.
05:30A lot of states are going to be frustrated by, you know, both of these bids.
05:33Foreign countries are going to be frustrated.
05:35So I think there's a long regulatory review process, meaning over 12 months,
05:39maybe even 18 months, for both of these companies.
05:42And YouTube gets brought into that, Rich, more.
05:44Will we understand what a competitive threat that is?
05:48Look, there's three layers to this.
05:50Is streaming a distinct market?
05:52Is streaming in linear TV?
05:54Like, there are people watching us right now, Carolyn,
05:57who, you know, are watching linear TV and have Bloomberg TV and have CNBC
06:02and all of these channels.
06:04Like, you know, it's hard to sort of believe that, you know, FX and, you know,
06:09ABC and CBS don't really compete with Netflix.
06:12And then you've obviously got the larger thread of, like, well, you know,
06:15YouTube has Sunday Ticket.
06:17Like, where do you watch Sunday Ticket?
06:18Now you watch it on YouTube.
06:20Can you really say that YouTube is not a competitor to Netflix?
06:23And so it gets very challenging to define what the market is.
06:28And I think you're going to see a real difficulty in the government, you know,
06:32trying to not just say what the market is, but actually back that up in court.
06:37I look forward to seeing how they actually try to prevent either of these two transactions.
06:42So.
06:42So.
06:42So.
06:42So.
06:43So.
Be the first to comment
Add your comment

Recommended