• 1 year ago
Scott Trench, host of the BiggerPockets Money Podcast, explores how recent rate cuts, high borrowing costs, and mortgage rates are reshaping U.S. real estate.

Category

📺
TV
Transcript
00:00As interest rates shift and economic uncertainty continues to linger, investors across the
00:05country are looking for strategic guidance now more than ever about how to navigate what
00:10comes next, or at least what may come next.
00:12Join us now to break it all down and talk about the current market landscape is Scott
00:16Trench.
00:16Scott is host of the BiggerPockets Money Podcast.
00:19Scott, welcome to the show.
00:20Good to have you.
00:21Thanks for having me on.
00:22Great to be here.
00:23Let's start first and foremost with a bit of an introduction to BiggerPockets and your
00:27mission specifically in the all-important world of personal finance.
00:32Yeah.
00:32So our goal is to help people retire early.
00:35We want them to achieve financial independence early in life and pursue their dreams.
00:39Real estate is a really powerful way to do that.
00:41And the goal has been, we actually recently achieved it, is to help a million people produce
00:46a million dollars in personal net worth in part through real estate.
00:51Tell me about what that process has looked like for you, connecting with viewers, connecting
00:55with listeners, and ultimately, we always say through the lens of the market, it's about
01:00being a more informed investor.
01:02And I'd imagine you got years of feedback in real time about how you've been able to
01:06help people.
01:07Absolutely.
01:08Yeah.
01:08We've, you know, the, when you want to invest in real estate, it's a immersion journey.
01:14Your journey begins with this immersion concept where people will spend literally hundreds
01:18of hours learning about, you know, all the ins and outs of how to select good tenants,
01:23avoid problems with properties, get financing, all those kinds of things, estimate cash flow
01:28appropriately.
01:28And so what BiggerPockets does is we just provide a up-to-date real-time learning for
01:35that experience one by one with investor interviews.
01:38Every single day, there's a podcast coming out or a YouTube video or a blog post or a forum
01:43post talking about a investor who is buying a property, the good, the bad, and the ugly
01:47that go along with that.
01:49And throughout all the challenges, all the mistakes, all the horror stories, which are
01:52very real in real estate investing, wealth is created as loans are paid down, as properties
01:57appreciate, as rents grow, and as people get better and better at adding value and taking
02:02properties to their highest and best use.
02:03And so that's the core value proposition of BiggerPockets.
02:08And of course, there's plenty of subscription tools and connections to be made with agents and
02:11lenders and contractors and all that kind of good stuff on the platform as well.
02:16Let's take a bit of a step back and kind of look at the markets more through the macro
02:20lens, the big pictures.
02:22What would you say right now are some of the top trends or the narratives that most stand
02:26out to you, specifically any of those that overlap with housing, interest rates, and
02:32kind of your sweet spot for your audience?
02:34Yeah, you know, I think that in some ways you can zoom out and the same questions that have
02:38been really paralyzing investors for the last two or three years are still in play, right?
02:43Everything is so expensive from an asset perspective, right?
02:47Stocks are trading at very high price to earnings multiples, almost historically high.
02:51In some cases, if you look at the Shiller price to earnings index, for example, interest
02:55rates are too low to offer a compelling yield in bond investments for most investors, especially
03:02those who are younger and looking to build long term wealth.
03:04Real estate is tough right now in most markets in the country because the cap rate, the cash
03:10flow produced by a rental property, an approximation of cash flow produced by a rental property is
03:16lower than interest rates that you'd borrow, right?
03:18If you borrow at a six or seven percent mortgage and your cash flow is five or six percent, that's
03:22a tough proposition for a lot of real estate investors.
03:25Gold is at all time highs.
03:27Bitcoin is just slightly off of its all time high.
03:30And it brings the question, where do you put your money?
03:33If you put it all in cash at the beginning of the year, well, guess what?
03:35The dollar lost 10 percent of its value relative to other currencies, right, over the course
03:39of this year.
03:40So it's a really challenging time for investors, I think, from that standpoint overall.
03:44And then, of course, you zoom in and you say, what's going to happen with interest rate
03:48policy coming?
03:49And we know that the Fed lowered rates last week, of course.
03:51And of course, mortgage rates promptly went up a little bit because that's what happens
03:54there.
03:54It's not a one to one relationship between the federal funds rate, the short term, the overnight
03:58rate that the Fed controls and long term borrowing rates like 10 or 30 year treasuries.
04:04And then, of course, mortgages, which are highly correlated, but not directly linked to
04:08those longer term, longer duration treasuries.
04:10So I think it's a really challenging time for investors.
04:13And for me, you know, I've been playing defense all year and probably lost out a little bit
04:17on that on my portfolio.
04:19I decided to pay off my mortgage.
04:22I've been very cautiously buying real estate with no debt where I can much less aggressively
04:27than I otherwise could.
04:28And I'm just I'm just kind of being very tentative and cautious personally in this in this market,
04:32in these market conditions.
04:33And I know some other folks have made very bold bets and ridden the roller coaster of
04:372025 and done very well.
04:39I think it's a really tough time for investors that want to make any hardcore predictions,
04:43though, about what's what's coming next.
04:45I'm glad you mentioned the Fed lowering interest rates, because it was fascinating to be here at
04:48the New York Stock Exchange, look up and say, well, there's the 10 year it's creeping
04:53up for basis points.
04:54What's the 30 year doing?
04:55It's also creeping up.
04:57A few basis points.
04:58What do you say to people that, you know, understandably may hear the headlines, may
05:03see the action from the Federal Open Markets Committee, say, oh, interest rates are coming
05:07down.
05:07Oh, great.
05:08What does that mean now for that stubborn long end of the yield curve?
05:12What does that mean to ease some of the borrowing costs for would be homebuyers?
05:16How do you position people mentally to look at the headlines on the one hand and then maybe
05:20see a bit of a different reality on the long end of the curve?
05:23Yeah, I mean, if your investment strategy is dependent on the near term movement of long
05:30term U.S. treasuries or long term debt yields, you're playing the game wrong.
05:34You got to have you got to have a strategy that's more sustainable.
05:37You know, all but a select few will fail and really have a miserable time.
05:41They have a horrible journey.
05:42If you're if you're near term strategy is dependent on what's going to happen next with, you know,
05:47medium duration or long term treasury yields or long term debt.
05:50So I think that, you know, zooming in on that, however, say that aside, what do we think is
05:57going to happen with treasury yield debt?
05:59You know, what ought to be the case?
06:01The core problem over the last two or three years has been the flattened or inverted yield
06:07curve, right?
06:08So short term treasuries are trading at or even in some cases higher than long duration
06:14treasuries.
06:15That says that the market expects the Fed to lower rates a bunch of times.
06:21The 10 year treasury, which is a really core number that is talked about a lot in financial
06:25circles, but is really critical in the real estate investing space is is supposed to be,
06:30you know, is usually about 100 to 125 basis points above the you know, the yield is higher
06:35than the overnight federal funds rate.
06:37And so I think personally, you know, I don't I don't have any of my strategy predicated on
06:43this.
06:43But, you know, if you ask me what what I think should happen, I think the federal funds rate
06:48is too high.
06:49I think the Fed will lower rates two or three more times, but I think the 10 year is too
06:53low and I think it will actually come up.
06:55And I think that's going to leave mortgage rates, you know, volatile.
06:58They're going to go bumping up and down.
07:00And what you're going to see, but but over over the next year or two, I think you're going
07:03to see them largely stay where they're at or even rise up a little bit, those 30 year
07:07mortgage rates.
07:08But that volatility is going to create some weirdness in the housing market, because when
07:12mortgage rates drop all of a sudden, you're going to see people flooding in to refinance
07:18or consider purchasing or locking in those rates at that time.
07:21You're going to see strong pulses of demand in various markets, which will lag that.
07:25So that makes it really hard to get a grip on predicting the near term, you know, happenings
07:31in the housing market nationwide.
07:34And then, of course, there's all these local and more regional things that are more predicated
07:37on the traditional balances of supply and demand, who's building what and who's moving
07:40where.
07:42When you talk about some of those key markets where you talk about those pockets where
07:45despite the volatility, you may start to see some easing.
07:49Is there maybe it's a geographics question?
07:52Is there any bellwether?
07:53Is there any kind of canary in the coal mine?
07:56I'm just using an example.
07:57But like historically, like do you look at Buffalo, New York?
07:59And you're like, all right, once we usually see that's the type of demographic shifting
08:03populations in and out that that can kind of maybe give you an earlier sense that maybe
08:10we have an alleviation of some of the pain points in housing.
08:14Well, you know, like if you're going to say, where should I invest and am I going to win?
08:18There are kind of three you need three answers to three questions in order to really succeed.
08:22Right.
08:22One is what's going to happen with interest rates?
08:24Nobody knows.
08:25Right.
08:25But you have to have an opinion.
08:26And I think the only rational opinion is a conservative one that assumes that interest
08:30rates are going to stay high or even go a little higher.
08:32I think, you know, you can't go all in, but that's that's a gamble.
08:35And I don't think you can really say at the end of the day, you know what you're doing.
08:37You know, you do anything other than getting lucky if interest rates go down and bail out
08:41a real estate investment.
08:43The second key component is going to be supply.
08:45So the amount of supply is defined by new construction.
08:49New construction is not the real estate investor's friend.
08:52Many real estate investors are big proponents of new construction, yet it also inhibits
08:56returns.
08:56A great example of this is if you look at Austin, Texas, Austin, Texas added over 10 percent
09:02to its existing multifamily housing stock last year in 2024, and rents went down 15 percent
09:10year over year.
09:11It's incredible.
09:12And, you know, there's a lot of optimism about Austin a few years ago from a real estate
09:16investing perspective.
09:17And there ought to be over 30 years.
09:19But no major metro grows at 10 percent in a year from a population perspective or wage
09:26perspective or anything else that can drive that.
09:28And so, you know, rents are coming down if the numbers get that extreme.
09:32Right.
09:32And what you're seeing here in 2025 is the end of that housing boom.
09:38We've built so much record new construction, especially in multifamily over the last couple
09:42of years.
09:43And, you know, we built so much, you know, it didn't lead to rent growth because the rent
09:46is too dang high.
09:47People stopped taking over the Internet.
09:50They'll be back in a few years because what's happened is that new construction and new deliveries
09:55have slowed.
09:56You will see historically low new completions in multifamily housing over the next three
10:03years in most major metros.
10:05Some will lag, right?
10:06Like Denver's boom, where I live, is largely over right now.
10:11Phoenix will have another six to 12 months with the still high new delivery volume.
10:16That's my favorite one to really key in on of those three variables, interest rates, supply
10:22and demand.
10:23I love supply because you don't have to be very smart to nail it, right?
10:28All the new construction in this country is permitted.
10:31Essentially, every time someone starts a new construction project, they finish it because
10:35they've got very expensive debt and developers do not like going bankrupt on there.
10:39They like to complete those projects and finish them.
10:41So you kind of know what's going to happen.
10:43It's all there for the next year, two or three.
10:46Demand is the last one.
10:47And that's in between.
10:48It's a little easier to forecast, especially in these larger metro areas.
10:52Then interest rates, for example, but a little harder and you can get yourself embarrassed
10:56every once every 10 years with the way things move in some of those metros.
11:01And I think the best thing you can do there is look up these reports for these major metros
11:05and just take the average of what's going to happen.
11:07And where you see the largest imbalance between relative new supply being constructed and population
11:13growth, that's going to be a really good catalyst for opportunity.
11:17And this plays out in real time.
11:19You can go back a couple of years and you look at like, hey, everyone was poo-pooing
11:21Chicago as this terrible place to invest in real estate.
11:24It's not landlord friendly, you know, yada, yada, yada.
11:27But Chicago has been great.
11:28The rents have grown the last couple of years.
11:31There hasn't been a lot of construction.
11:32The investors who have been in Chicago have been doing just fine.
11:35Same with things like New York City and same thing with San Francisco over the last
11:39couple of years.
11:39Meanwhile, the markets in the South that had all these, you know, that had all this swan
11:43song about them, they've been getting decimated as from a real estate investor's perspective
11:47from a renter or housing perspective.
11:49It's actually been great because housing prices and rents have been going down substantially
11:53in many of those markets.
11:54But that's, I think, the thing to look out for if you're a real estate investor and trying
11:57to choose where to where to invest.
11:59I think supply is one of those key variables that people so obvious, but people just miss or
12:04don't don't do the research on.
12:07Let him look.
12:08I just learned a ton and I wish I can continue the conversation for much longer.
12:13I'll have to have you back for a part two very soon.
12:16Really grateful for the context because I think you helped demystify a lot of information
12:21and narrative surrounding housing market and expectations or maybe lack thereof of alleviation.
12:27Scott Trench, host of the BiggerPockets Money Podcast.
12:30Scott, thanks a lot for being here.
12:31Great to have you.
12:32Thank you, JD.
12:32Great to be here.

Recommended