Skip to playerSkip to main content
  • 1 year ago
During a Senate Aging Committee hearing on Wednesday, Sen. Kirsten Gillibrand (D-NY) questioned broadcast journalist Gretchen Carlson about public support for forced arbitration.

Category

🗞
News
Transcript
00:00You noted in your testimony, the Protecting Older Americans Act has bipartisan support.
00:06The bipartisan support of this bill reflects the coalition that you have been working on
00:10and building to give workers a choice in how they address their discrimination claims.
00:15Your organization, Lift Our Voices, includes both Democrats and Republicans as supporters
00:19of its goal.
00:21What are some of the reasons your allies in the movement, whether Democrat or Republican
00:25or Independent, have given their support to oppose forced arbitration?
00:30And anecdotally, what have you seen in terms of momentum for why we should pass this bill
00:34now?
00:36Thank you so much, Senator.
00:37I think it's a variety of different things.
00:39I always describe this movement as a perfect storm.
00:42When I came forward, luckily because my lawyers found a way to make my case public even with
00:47my forced arbitration clause or we wouldn't even be having this discussion, that happened
00:53and then a tidal wave of other women came forward.
00:56But really what was also essential was that the media started covering these stories.
01:00And I can say this as a member of media, that had it been pitched before 2016 as an idea,
01:05it probably would not have been covered.
01:08So the media became interested in covering these stories.
01:12Social media actually helped because it allowed people to come forward either anonymously or with
01:16their face on their story in droves.
01:20And suddenly it became a worldwide issue.
01:23But the third thing that really helped this perfect storm happen where people became more
01:27educated on these issues is that the American public got mad.
01:32Because they thought we had come a lot further along in this process of protecting people
01:37at work, whether it's age discrimination, sexual harassment, or any other kind of discrimination.
01:42Why did they think that?
01:44Because they didn't hear about these stories.
01:46And why were they not hearing about these stories?
01:49Because they were all going to the secrecy of forced arbitration.
01:52There's been an explosion of the use of forced arbitration.
01:541991, 2% of all employees were under it.
01:58This year, more than 80% will be under it.
02:02It's been an explosion.
02:04So the American public got mad and they were like, wait a minute, I thought we were more
02:07equal and fair to all of our workers across this country.
02:11And so I think that the education behind this has been crucial where more people are understanding,
02:17starting to understand what forced arbitration is.
02:20And actually, when they find out what it is, they don't like it.
02:24Last year, Lift Our Voices commissioned a study with the morning consult.
02:28And more than 70% of all Americans, when they understand what forced arbitration is and it takes away their choice
02:36and their Seventh Amendment right, they're against it.
02:39And what the study actually found was that the percentages are higher in southern states
02:45and higher amongst the most conservative of those surveyed when they understand what it is.
02:51Right.
02:52Because you're taking away someone's constitutional right to a jury trial, a jury of their peers
02:56to judge an issue and not be shuttered behind closed doors.
03:00And as you know well, Gretchen, a lot of these forced arbitration clauses are paired with non-disclosure
03:06agreements.
03:07And so you're forced into silence regardless.
03:10Mrs. MacLeod, Mrs. Lamond, in your testimony, you cite an AARP report that found age discrimination
03:18draining $850 billion from the U.S. economy every year.
03:23This is a shockingly high number.
03:25You also cited an Urban Institute study that found 50% of workers in their early 50s experiencing
03:31involuntary job loss.
03:33Can you please go into more detail on the emotional and economic impacts that age discrimination
03:38has on the older workforce?
03:40And what is the workforce losing due to age discrimination?
03:44Well, Senator, both you and the chairman spoke a little bit about it in your opening remarks.
03:51This is devastating for individuals and also can be overall for the workforce if we lose
03:56this valuable resource that I think everybody on the panel has spoken about.
04:01And when you talk about individuals and their families, it has tremendous, tremendous impact.
04:08Rachel mentioned volunteers and no organization is prouder of their volunteers than AARP, many
04:14of whom are here today.
04:16And when I met with them in the cafeteria at the office before walking over, one of them
04:19said to me, thank you for testifying this.
04:22I have my own story.
04:24And that's what I hear everywhere.
04:26And I'm sure you do as well.
04:28The emotional toll of losing your job, so much of it is your identity.
04:33So much of it is your social group.
04:36And so much of it obviously is your income.
04:39The ability to be able to have health insurance and protect your family.
04:44It's all woven and there are stories everywhere.
04:48And what we hope and are encouraged by sessions like this is that we can look at all we can
04:54do to help the individual workers and also to help businesses in the country.
04:59Mr. Chairman.
05:00Thanks.
05:04See you too.
05:05It is.
05:08Yeah.
05:09Yeah.
05:15Yeah.
05:16Yeah.
05:17And, so on.
05:24Yeah.
05:25Yeah.

Recommended