00:00Let's talk to Sean Bell, the retired Air Vice-Marshal and Military Analyst.
00:04Sean, welcome back.
00:05What has Israel actually achieved militarily overnight in Gaza?
00:12Yeah, good afternoon to you, Jamie.
00:15The trouble is I'm a grey-haired, seasoned sort of military warrior,
00:19and I speak to a number of my IDF colleagues in Israel,
00:23and I think, frankly, there is no military solution now
00:27to the challenge that Prime Minister Netanyahu appears to be presenting,
00:32which is to somehow destroy all of Hamas.
00:35You saw that letter from, I think, 600 different Israeli former retired senior military and politicians
00:43who basically said, you know, there is no real prospect of any achievement militarily by continuing,
00:51and all you do is risk, A, the lives of the hostages,
00:54but also the lives of IDF soldiers.
00:57It is worth pointing out that we focus a lot on the over 62,000 now Palestinian people
01:02that, according to the Hamas-controlled Gaza Health Authority, have died,
01:07that actually the Israeli Defense Forces said last month that over 450 of their soldiers have died,
01:12and 200,800 have injured.
01:14So the fact that Israelis now are not only seeing a potential military action
01:19that will unlikely enable the release of the hostages,
01:24it's also going to put a lot more of their soldiers in harm's way,
01:27and it's not just the 60,000 that have been mobilized,
01:30it's also 20,000 that were mobilized have had their mobilization extended.
01:35That will be a grave worry to many of the Israeli citizens.
01:38We've, as you say, seen this call for further Israeli military mobilization.
01:44We're told the IDF is short of thousands of troops and may even be recruiting from abroad.
01:50I mean, depending on how long this goes on for,
01:52how well is Israel prepared for what comes next?
01:56Well, the slight challenge here is working out,
02:02I think you and I have talked about before, Jamie,
02:04that the military can't achieve an end in itself.
02:07The politicians have to define the end state,
02:09and the military try to work out how to achieve that.
02:13And if the end state is actually a two-state solution,
02:17this isn't their route to doing it.
02:18If the end state is to release the hostages,
02:21then most of the hostages to date have only been released through negotiation
02:25and some sort of ceasefire.
02:27So it's very difficult to see what the political objectives are here.
02:31If you stand back a few paces from this conflict
02:34and look at what Israel is doing in the West Bank at the moment,
02:37and also the nature of how it seems to be trying to make life intolerable
02:41for Palestinians in the Gaza,
02:43you could be forgiven for thinking that actually
02:45this is a pursuit of a single-state solution,
02:48and that Prime Minister Netanyahu has therefore got his sights set on that.
02:52Now, he's not declaring that publicly.
02:54He doesn't appear to be declaring that to his military,
02:57and therefore you've got this slightly difficult task
02:59that the military are being asked to perform
03:01with no real prospect of knowing how or when,
03:05how successful it will be, or when it will be achieved.
03:08Sean, good to see you.
03:09Thanks so much for coming back on the programme.
03:10Sean Bell, the retired Air Vice Marshal and Military Analyst.