• 1 year ago
Hi everybody, and welcome back to Borderline! Today, we're diving deep into the controversial claim that Prime Minister Keir Starmer has "sold out" British fishermen during recent renegotiations with the EU. Is it really that simple, though?
Fishing in the UK has been declining for decades — and living on the South Coast, I’ve seen this firsthand. In this video, we look at:
The actual state of the UK fishing industry
What fish are being caught vs. what’s being sold in UK supermarkets
Why most British-caught fish are exported abroad
Whether Starmer's decision was betrayal — or just cold, hard economics
Love him or hate him, the issue is more complex than it seems. So let’s discuss:
👉 Was it betrayal, pragmatism, or just reality?
👉 What should a British PM do in this situation?

Category

🗞
News
Transcript
00:00hi everybody and welcome back to borderline so recently a lot of people went on the bandwagon
00:08saying that our wonderful prime minister mr keir starmer or sir keir whatever you want to call him
00:16there's a few other names you could personally call him but when he was renegotiating the so-called
00:23deal with the eu that he right royally sold out the fishermen and i thought did he did he really
00:34because the problem is in the uk fishing's been on the decline and you could probably go all the way
00:44back to the 1950s if you look at the statistics it's just a nosedive like that the british fisherman
00:50fleet now i live in a place called leon sun which is right on the south coast and we have a fishing
00:58fleet down in portsmouth it's next to nothing i live about you know the seat is about five minutes
01:08walk that way five to ten minutes walk i can walk it in and i may occasionally see one out you know
01:17there's norm you know about a week about a week ago i saw one which was out
01:22probably about 100 meters out you know dropping pots down probably for crabs or lobsters or whatever
01:33i don't know okay i rarely see them you know the charter boats see them on a regular basis
01:41but i don't see trawlers out now
01:46my argument is
01:50and there's been a long term argument saying yeah but the problem is for the trawler the fishermen
01:58that they're not being bought in the uk they're having to export them abroad anywhere and a lot of
02:04people could say and they would be absolutely right with saying it but that's not the point that's
02:10business for fishermen in the uk even if they're sending it over to france or spain or italy or
02:17wherever that's potential business and they're correct with that i can't argue with that argument
02:24so i thought let's have a look what are the 10 most common fish that are caught in british waters
02:34the british fishermen are catching okay and are these fish that are being sold in our supermarkets
02:44now i can answer this because i do this shop my wife doesn't do the shop she does the clothes shopping
02:51and she does the toy shopping and all that kind of rubbish but balls the hell out of me but i then
02:56generally do the food shopping okay so i thought let's go and have a look at this and i thought
03:03how many people can say in the last six months if not the last 12 months they've bought any of these
03:10fish on this list okay or even know what one of them looks like
03:15okay because realistically the most common fish that i would say that people are going to buy
03:25and they're going to get from the fish and chip shop okay it's going to be cod haddock
03:31and place
03:34okay so and only one of those you can actually catch around here you can get place but they're a rarity
03:46you can catch cod around here okay so number one is mackerel mackerel is a fish i can catch around here
03:55during the um summer months you can catch them in quite close actually um but they come in number one
04:03as my father-in-law would say the only thing a mackerel is good for is pike fishing okay but mackerel
04:11comes in number one number two is heron okay number three is blue whiting who here knows what a blue
04:23whiting looks like i bet not many people do now number four and five i would expect
04:29most people to have bought this year okay if you eat fish you'd probably eat in one one of these two
04:41and i'm actually surprised in which order it is okay haddock's number four cod's number five okay i
04:49actually thought cod would be much higher on the list but you know i can be surprised now and again
04:54okay next is monkfish okay a lot of people don't aren't going to know what a monkfish looks like
05:03let alone how to skin it i personally do because i was um trained in fishmongery because i was trained
05:10chef and i had to learn how to one of the first fish i ever learned how to actually skin was a monkfish
05:17the next one is a i'm probably going to pronounce this wrong is a save i don't even know what it looks
05:23like and i've fished virtually all my life okay since the age of eight so i've been fishing what
05:3036 nearly 37 years i don't even know what save looks like it's about s-a-i-t-h-e okay maybe you can
05:40somebody can drop one in the um comments down below and let me know what it looks like
05:44next at number eight we've got whiting catch them around here nine is hake
05:53and the last on the list is horse mackerel now out of all of that list okay mackerel and hair mackerel
06:06and herring you'll sometimes get on the fish counters in supermarkets you will get them in the
06:12tins blue whiting never seen them in the supermarket monkfish you'll get them on the um on ice at the
06:22actual fishmongers bloody expensive save never seen one whiting you'll get them in the fishmongers
06:31okay hey i can't actually honestly remember actually ever seeing one and horse mackerel never
06:39seen one in a supermarket ever and this is the problem
06:44not all of these fish are sold and these are the top 10 fish that are being sold and this is the
06:52problem that if our fleet can't sell them to people in this country they ain't got a business
07:01they've got to rely on on france so as much as i'm going to get hate for it i also understand why
07:10he's done it
07:11we've got a shrinking fleet
07:14and all the fish is being sold abroad anyway
07:20so and i know this is an awful i feel awful for saying this to a degree i understand why he's done it
07:27so let us know in the comments down below what you think he should have done
07:33you know honestly from a business point of view okay not just because it's
07:43british waters and going down the stupid nigel farage idiotic um route a realistic
07:51response what should he have done to protect fish because remember you're going to need a bigger fleet
07:58and you're going to need to sell to the british public who aren't buying fish so you let me know
08:05what he should have done okay but for now thanks for watching and i'll speak to you all again a bit later

Recommended