• 1 year ago
Prison staff sceptical renting cells abroad will solve France's overcrowding crisis

With prisons overflowing, France is considering renting cells abroad. But will this solve the problem or just shift it to other countries?

READ MORE : http://www.euronews.com/2025/05/22/prison-staff-sceptical-renting-cells-abroad-will-solve-frances-overcrowding-crisis

Subscribe to our channel. Euronews is available on Dailymotion in 12 languages

Category

🗞
News
Transcript
00:00France is considering a radical response to its prison crisis,
00:06renting cell space in other European countries.
00:10But is it a realistic fix or just political buzz?
00:15With more than 82,900 inmates and just 62,000 prison cells,
00:20France is running out of space.
00:23Last week, French President Emmanuel Macron
00:26said he is open to renting foreign prison places.
00:30France wouldn't be the first.
00:32Belgium rented more than 650 cells in the Netherlands between 2010 and 2016.
00:40In 2021, Denmark struck a 210 million euro deal to lease 300 places in Kosovo.
00:49Estonia soon wants to monetize its half-empty prison cells.
00:54But the Belgium case raised major ethical concerns.
01:00La Hollande louait ses places à la Belgique avec son propre personnel,
01:05mais sous l'empire de la loi belge.
01:07Donc il a fallu faire suivre des formations hollandais
01:10pour qu'ils apprennent comment ça se passait dans les prisons en Belgique.
01:13Et de deux, les visites des familles et des proches étaient extrêmement compliquées.
01:17Les visas, les trucs, tout ça, bon.
01:19La Belgique a abandonné.
01:20Donc je ne vois pas pourquoi renouveler l'exploit.
01:26Critics say this idea also comes with steep logistical costs.
01:30France spends between 100 and 250 euros per prisoner per day.
01:36Meanwhile, Denmark's Kosovo deal works out to nearly 200 euros per day.
01:42Belgium's Dutch experiment cost 400 million euros per year.
01:47Il y a des éléments très concrets qui, à mon sens,
01:51rendent plutôt très, très, très difficile la mise en œuvre d'une idée pareille.
01:56Alors pourquoi ?
01:57D'abord, budgétairement.
02:00Aller à l'étranger, ne serait-ce que pour louer des locaux, ça a un coût.
02:04Et aujourd'hui, les finances publiques françaises sont telles qu'il faut économiser partout.
02:08Je ne vois pas comment ça pourrait être rentable d'aller envoyer des personnes condamnées
02:15dans un autre établissement hors nos frontières.
02:17While France ranks third worst in Europe for prison overcrowding,
02:21according to the Council of Europe, behind Cyprus and Romania,
02:26some warn that rushing to deport prisoners may create more problems than it actually solves.

Recommended