• 1 year ago
During remarks on the Senate floor Tuesday, Sen. Peter Welch (D-VT) introduced a resolution to demand Israel cease its blockade of humanitarian aid into Gaza that was blocked by Sen. James Risch (R-ID).

Category

🗞
News
Transcript
00:00from Vermont. Mr. President, all of us are extremely concerned, and I mean all of us,
00:06Senator Risch and all the Republican colleagues and me and all of the Democratic colleagues
00:12about the suffering and famine that's upon the folks in Gaza. And today I'm here to offer
00:19a resolution for consideration on which 46 senators on our side agree. And although
00:30not had signatories on the Republican side, I know that my colleagues on the Republican
00:36side are very concerned about the devastating absence of food and medicine, baby formula
00:45for 2 million Palestinians that are living in Gaza. It's been 74 days, Mr. President,
00:54since aid trucks were allowed to transit into Gaza. That's a decision that the Israeli government
01:03has made under Prime Minister Netanyahu. And what does alarm me is that it's very clear
01:11under international law, it's very clear on prior actions that this United States Senate
01:18has taken, that in a conflict, as a tactic of war, starving the civilian population is illegal,
01:28impermissible, and just wrong, absolutely wrong. And it's an indication of the suffering. This
01:37is a young child who died in her parents' arms, Janine Ishkafi. And that was due to no food,
01:49no baby formula to feed this young person. And the UN has released a report that indicates if food is not
02:02brought into Gaza. Within the next 48 hours, 14,000 more infants will die. And they will die in the arms
02:12of their mother or father. So this question of should aid get in, obviously it should. It's not right for aid
02:23to be withheld as an instrument of war. And regrettably, that appears to have been a decision that has been
02:34made by the Israeli government. It's not right, it's not necessary, it's not helpful, and it is
02:42extraordinarily harmful to innocent children, to innocent mothers. So my hope is that this Senate
02:52would pass a resolution making very clear about our concern about the well-being of innocent
03:00Palestinians in Gaza. And that food that those Palestinians in Gaza need is right on the other
03:08side of the border. It's there. All it needs is to be transported from where it is into Gaza and then
03:19distribute it. You know, I want to just quote a Palestinian about how dire that situation is.
03:32The words of a Palestinian, let me quote, believe it or not, and this is, by the way, in a moment when
03:41bombs are still dropping, where people who've been relocated a dozen times are having to relocate again.
03:48Where the two remaining hospitals and Han Yunus have been bombed, where there's no security
03:56whatsoever. This is what the Palestinians said that sums it up. Believe it or not, people no longer care
04:02about bombs, rockets, or even death. What consumes them now is food, how to find it, how to feed their
04:11children. It is impossible to describe how hard life has become. People walk around in a daze, dizzy from
04:20malnutrition and despair. People are confused, anxious, and exhausted. They are literally dying of hunger.
04:29At this point, they would accept anything just to survive. People are fainting in the streets.
04:36They look like skin and bones, pale and dizzy. If you saw them, you would break down and cry.
04:43That's the word of a Palestinian in Gaza. Mr. President,
04:47we've got to feed those people. The food is there. We all want those innocent people to survive
04:58and avoid famine. Let us do every single thing we can to persuade the Israeli Netanyahu government to get
05:08that food in to people who desperately need it. Mr. President, at this point, I want to yield to my
05:14colleague, Senator Van Holland from Maryland.
05:17Mr. President.
05:19Senator Van Holland from Maryland.
05:20Thank you, Mr. President. First, I want to thank my friend and colleague, Senator from Vermont,
05:26Mr. Welch, for offering this resolution. And I just want to focus on the resolution itself
05:32for a moment, because you would think this is something that we could all agree on.
05:38I'm just reading the Resolved Clause here.
05:40Resolved that the Senate, Part One, is gravely concerned with A, the humanitarian crisis and
05:48acute suffering of the Palestinian civilians in Gaza, and B, the suffering of the hostages
05:56and hostage families. So that's Section One of the Resolved Clause. As Senator Welch has said,
06:06I think we all acknowledge the terrible humanitarian disaster that Palestinians civilians are suffering
06:14under right now. President Trump just acknowledged it the other day. He said a lot of people
06:19are starving. Cindy McCain said, and I quote, families in Gaza are starving while the food they need
06:27is sitting at the border. 57 children have already died from malnutrition, and the reports are that
06:3614,000 Palestinian children in Gaza are at imminent risk of death if they don't get more food.
06:44Now, just yesterday, after 78 days of a total siege and blockade on any food coming in to Gaza,
06:54a trickle of food began to get in, primarily because European countries began to say very loudly
07:02that what was happening that what was happening was unacceptable, that it was a violation of
07:06international law. We're also hearing from the hostage families the urgency of putting an end to
07:15this conflict and resolving this to make sure their loved ones can come home. I was very glad to see Steve
07:22Witkoff be able to bring home Edan Alexander. Now we have to bring back the rest of the hostages,
07:30and the hostage families overwhelmingly have been calling on Prime Minister Netanyahu and his government
07:36to end the conflict, end the suffering on all sides, and bring their loved ones home.
07:45Now I want to just read the second part of this resolution, because it does what I understand so many of the
07:53hostages' families have been saying that we should do it. It calls on the White House, the Department of State,
07:59and other relevant United States government agencies to urgently use all available diplomatic tools
08:06to bring about the release of the hostages, an immediate cessation of the blockade on food and humanitarian aid
08:12for Palestinian civilians, and a durable end to the conflict in Gaza. That's part one and part two of the
08:20resolve clause that I just read. And I want to thank Senator Welch, because he has written this in a way
08:26that you would think not a single senator could object to the words in this resolution. And so I do urge my
08:34colleagues to support it. Let's put an end to the suffering and starvation of Palestinian civilians in Gaza.
08:41Let's get the hostages home. And let's work to end this conflict in a way that ensures no more October 7th
08:49and ensures security and dignity for both Israelis and Palestinians alike. I yield back to the senator from Vermont.
08:56Thank you, Senator Van Hollen. Senator from Vermont. Thank you, Mr. President. Thank you again, Senator from Maryland.
09:05Mr. President, notwithstanding Rule 22, I ask unanimous consent that the Committee on Foreign Relations be discharged
09:12from further consideration, and the Senate now proceed to Senate Res. 224. Further, that the resolution be agreed to,
09:22the preamble be agreed to, and that the motions to reconsider be considered made and laid upon the table.
09:28Mr. President. Senator from Idaho. Mr. President, reserving the right to object. Look, first of all, we have no disagreement
09:49with the suffering that's going on in Gaza. The problem we have here is, as we heard from both of these speakers,
09:58not one word was said as to whose fault this is. This is the fault of a group of people. And that group of people is Hamas.
10:10I heard them mention Israel several times. This is not Israel's fault. I heard them mention us, the United States. This is not our fault.
10:22I couldn't agree more with Senator Wealth when he talks about the fact that we want an immediate ceasefire and for people to be fed there
10:32and things to get better there. It is so simple. It is so easy. It is totally in the hands of Hamas. If they release the hostages,
10:42they lay down their arms, and they surrender, not one more bullet will be fired, and there will be scads of trucks come into Gaza.
10:51That's how this ends. But can we end it? No. If we send trucks in, Senator, you know, you've seen the intelligence on this.
10:59When we send trucks of food in there, who eats? The soldiers eat. The Hamas soldiers eat. They starve the women and they starve the children.
11:09Not only do they starve them, they use them as human shields. And they set up their facilities, their military facilities,
11:18in hospitals, in schools, in mosques, in all kinds of places that they then wring their hands and say,
11:25oh my gosh, we've been attacked. Look, this is despicable. This is horrible. This is criminal. It's beyond human understanding,
11:36how human beings could treat other human beings the same way, especially when you're related to them as they are in Palestine.
11:44So I agree that this needs to stop. But the first thing that needs to be said is that this is the fault of Hamas, and it is not our fault.
11:54And it doesn't matter if we roll trucks in there tomorrow, that food would be taken, it would be stolen,
12:00it would be distributed by Hamas to their fighting soldiers, and the dying and the suffering of the women and children would continue.
12:09This thing is badly aimed. It does not in any way lay the fault where it belongs, and that is at the feet of Hamas.
12:19So based on all that, I share your objective. This gets us nowhere. And worse than that, it doesn't point out where the problem is.
12:29Madam President, I object.
12:32Objections heard. Madam President.
12:36Senator from Vermont.
12:38I want the Senator from Idaho, the esteemed chairman of the Foreign Relations Committee, to know that when it comes to condemning Hamas for what it did on October 7th,
12:50for what it's done to the Palestinians in Gaza on an ongoing basis, I join you in condemning Hamas.
12:58And this resolution, Madam President, does not get into the question of fault.
13:05It gets into the question of suffering.
13:08It gets into the question of suffering of innocent people who at times have been victimized by Hamas,
13:17but whose families are hungry, who are starving.
13:21And the point of this resolution is to say, let's help them avoid starvation by supporting the delivery of the food and the medicine and the baby formula that they need.
13:38This in no way is going to solve the conflict.
13:41That's a point the Senator made, and he's got a point to be made.
13:47But if we do all we can to facilitate the delivery of aid, it means that we're doing all we can to ease the suffering of innocent families who have been victimized.
14:03My view, Madam President, is that we should do all we can to alleviate the suffering, especially for these infants, these children, these women, and peace-loving Palestinians who want nothing more than to live in peace in their neighborhood.
14:22I yield back.
14:24Senator Prater.
14:25Senator M. Prompidaho.
14:26Senator M. Prompidaho—
14:28Mr. President, I want to respond to that.
14:29First of all, I commend the Senator for his appreciation for the suffering that's going on.
14:35It's horrible.
14:36It's despicable.
14:37You've seen the photos.
14:38You've seen the video.
14:39It's a horrible, horrible situation.
14:44One of the difficulties I have with this is—he is correct—this resolution does not assign fault, nor does it talk about fault.
14:53And that's one of the biggest problems I have with this.
14:56If this is going to be resolved, fault must be identified, the conditions on the ground
15:02has to be identified, and how this is going to be resolved has to be identified, none
15:07of which is considered in here.
15:09It is simply a suggestion that simply taking food there is going to resolve this problem.
15:15And we have done that.
15:16We have food there.
15:17It's ready to go in.
15:18As I said, three things need to happen, and it's in the hands solely of Hamas.
15:24Not in Israel, not in Netanyahu, not in our president, not in the people of the United
15:28States' hands, it's in the hands of Hamas.
15:32And that is if they simply release the hostages, lay down their arms and surrender, it's over.
15:37The food flows in, there's not another bullet fired.
15:40That's all that has to happen.
15:42But what has to be recognized in this is how this is going to end.
15:47There's only one way this can end, and that is with the complete and total destruction
15:52of Hamas.
15:53This is very similar to what the United States of America and its allies did in the late 1930s.
15:58We decided that the Nazis were so bad, they could not exist as a military force, as a
16:04political force, or as a cultural force, and we decided they needed to be eliminated.
16:10That's what Israel has decided it has to do to protect itself.
16:14That's what it's doing.
16:15But Hamas can stop this, and they can stop it in a minute.
16:19And they're not showing any signs of that.
16:22So what's going to happen is, this thing's going to fight, this fight is going to go on,
16:27until the last Hamas falls.

Recommended