00:00Schmidt. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Mr. Altman, I'll start with you. I really enjoyed and was inspired
00:05by your story with the light on and the home you grew up in in St. Louis and you talked about the
00:12spirit of innovation. That is the spirit of St. Louis as a fellow St. Louis native. That's a good
00:17story to hear. And we just look forward to more investment in St. Louis from your company. That'd
00:22be great too. So I'll put a plug in for that. But I do want to ask you, specifically, there's
00:30a lot made of sort of the comparison between the United States and the regulatory environment
00:35and what exists in Europe. What specifically, and I'll open this up to you, what specifically
00:40has gone wrong in Europe that we can draw some conclusions from? First of all, we'd love
00:48to figure out how to invest more in St. Louis. I'd love an excuse to get to go home more often.
00:52I'll point out one example that I think is just very painful to users. When we launch
01:01a new feature or a major new model, we have what is now considered a little bit of like
01:07an in-joke where we say we have this great new thing not available in the EU and a handful
01:14of other countries because they have this long process before a model can go out. And there
01:21will be, I believe, great models and services that are quite safe and robust that we will
01:25be unable to offer in other regulatory regimes. And if you are trying to be competitive in
01:31this new world, and if you are consistently some number of months behind what other people
01:37in other countries get access to, that's an example that's extremely painful to users.
01:42And you mentioned sort of your observation that the AI stack may get more vertically integrated.
01:50So how does that work then? Because right now, the best estimates, I suppose, right, is that,
01:57I don't know, China's two months to six months behind, maybe on large language models. Hopefully,
02:03some of the advances we're seeing in the US, maybe there's a degree of separation. It's hard to know
02:07exactly right with DeepSeq. But then you get down to the chips and that advantage is more like a couple
02:12of years, probably something like that. So if that's where we're headed, does that increase
02:18the US's advantage in your view? Or does that sort of allow China to catch up quicker as we get more
02:24vertically integrated? I think there's a lot of things that can increase US leadership, but we
02:33touched on this earlier, I think it's so important. There will be great chips made around the world,
02:37there will be great models trained around the world. If the United States companies can win on
02:41products, and the sort of all of the positive feedback loops that come from how you can improve
02:47this once, you know, real users are using your products in their daily lives for their hardest
02:51tasks, that is something special that is not so easy to catch up with just by doing good chips and
02:57good models. So making sure that the US can win at the product level here, obviously, I'm like talking
03:03my book a little bit, but I really do believe it is quite important. And that's in addition to all of
03:09the chips algorithm, or the infrastructure algorithms and data. I think this is a new area
03:14where the US is really winning, and has a very strong compounding effect. Thanks, Mr. Entredemer,
03:19did I pronounce that correctly, by the way? Yep. Okay, thank you. I want to turn a little bit,
03:24sort of staying on this this regulatory environment. One of the things I think that's most concerning,
03:30that's coming out of Europe is this sort of censorship regime, that exists, not just online,
03:37but in real life. But certainly it's happening online. I mean, people are being arrested for
03:42things that they say online. And one of the concerns I have with AI, I suppose, is that if,
03:52if we end up with a place where it's somehow policing, quote unquote, misinformation, and you know,
04:00I think even in NIST's most recent voluntary standards, one of the risks to be on the lookout
04:09for was the spread of misinformation. So the point of the question is, how do we make sure
04:18that I think part of what's going wrong in Europe is it's sort of a funneling information. And in my
04:25view, whether I agree with the point of view or not, it ought to be out there, people can make their own
04:29decisions, you combat speech you don't agree with, not by censoring it, but by with more speech.
04:35What are some lessons to be learned there and make sure that does not happen here?
04:41So Europe is moving forward with its regulatory regime in a European way. And from from our seat,
04:51where we have to make these enormous capital investments, one of the things about the approach
04:58that Europe is taking that we are deeply concerned about every day is the
05:06balkanization to use to use
05:12of how they go about
05:15allowing information to flow and how they go about regulating and how they go about
05:21with each component of their union having its own set of rules, which will be tremendously challenging
05:30in Europe as time goes on, because it is really hard to make the magnitude of investments that we were
05:40doing. Beyond that though, jurisdictionally, I'm talking about content now.
05:43Yeah, so we're not, the role of our company is really kind of below that, you know, and
05:51and, you know, Sam and, you know, Microsoft, you're going to get a lot more attention paid
06:01to the content level because of the role that they play in the stack. It's not really where we
06:06are primarily focused, we're really focused on the investment side of it.
06:09Yeah. If any of you would like to, Sam, if you are Mr. Altman, if you would like to respond to that,
06:15I'd like to get some answer.
06:18I
06:23I think, well, first of all, I strongly agree that people getting, you know, like put in jail for
06:29stuff they say online is very not American, not what we should be doing. The AI is quite different
06:36than social media, at least in its current evolution. People are using these tools in a
06:41sort of one-on-one way instead of this massive thing online. So I think it's easy to make too
06:48many analogies, but it's a little bit dangerous to try to talk about AI and the things we're going to
06:54face here in the same way that we did for social media. But our stance is that we need to give
07:01adult users a lot of freedom to use AI in the way that they want to use it and to trust them to be
07:08responsible with the tool. And I know there's increasing pressure in other places around the
07:13world and some in the US to not do that. But I think this is like, this is a tool and we need to
07:21make it a powerful and capable tool. We will, of course, put some guardrails in very wide bounds, but
07:25I think we need to give a lot of freedom. Yeah, I'm out of time, but there's a lot more questions
07:29there that we'll follow up with. Thank you, Madam Chair.