- 08/05/2025
Diagnosis Murder Season 8 Episode 19 No Good Deed
Category
📺
TVTranscript
00:00D?
00:00Yeah, Roger Callender.
00:02Roger Callender, the defense attorney?
00:05I hear a lot of cops will be celebrating at night.
00:08His BP's dropping, systolic is down to 90.
00:11We need more volume.
00:12You're not gonna make it, am I?
00:14You're doing great.
00:16I've been cutting the gut.
00:18Sir, just let us do our job.
00:20I have to tell you something before you lose me.
00:23You're not gonna lose ya.
00:24You have to tell people proud of me.
00:26I can't take this to the grave.
00:28How much more do you think he needs?
00:30I called it.
00:31I told him to let us go as soon as we're ready.
00:33Just give him as much as we can until then.
00:35Anybody specifically I should notify, Mr. Kelly?
00:38The press.
00:39His lines aren't any great, but his pulse is really dreading.
00:42I killed a man.
00:44You hear me?
00:45I killed a man.
00:47I want everybody to know.
00:49I killed him.
00:51He's coding!
00:52Hi!
00:55Where?
00:58I killed him!
00:59I killed him!
01:00I killed him!
01:03No!
01:06Ah!
01:11I killed him!
01:15You see them?
01:17You took him a共우�орт.
01:18I killed him!
01:20I killed him!
01:21I killed him!
01:22Mr. Kellner, Dr. Sloan.
01:53Where are your minions?
01:54Excuse me?
01:55Don't you see your doctors, trail students, wherever you go?
01:58No, I'm not making rounds.
02:00I wanted to ask you a question about something that bothered me three days ago in ER.
02:05Yeah?
02:05That wound there on your forearm.
02:09You mean this?
02:10Yeah, that is a nasty bite.
02:13A nasty beast.
02:14Now, this happened before the stabbing, didn't it?
02:17About a week ago.
02:19Were you able to identify the animal?
02:21Never saw it before, nor after.
02:24Clearly a canine, a large mouth.
02:28Coyote, maybe.
02:29Dog.
02:30Did you provoke him in any way?
02:32Absolutely not.
02:34You'd have been better if you had.
02:36Sometimes an unprovoked animal attack can really be trouble.
02:39I was out driving.
02:41No, just driving.
02:42Dog left out right in front of me.
02:45Had to break so hard, I nearly wrecked the car.
02:47When I got out to see if the damn beast was okay, he did this to me.
02:51Ouch.
02:52Yeah, back to life.
02:53No good deed goes unpunished.
02:57You really believe that?
02:59Absolutely.
03:01I see here that you had started a series of rabies shots already.
03:05The day I was bitten.
03:06Believe me, doctor.
03:07I don't leave loose ends unattended.
03:09It's funny you should say that.
03:12I have a question about a loose end concerning your case.
03:16Am I going to need more surgery?
03:18Oh, no.
03:18No, you're recovering remarkably.
03:21We're still a little worried about infection.
03:22That's why we have all the equipment.
03:25So what's the problem then?
03:27Something you said when you were rushed in here, and you were very insistent about it.
03:32I wonder if you remember what it was.
03:35No.
03:35You said you killed a man.
03:41Was I on drugs at the time?
03:43Pink?
03:43I was, you know.
03:44I've had many such confessions thrown out of court.
03:47It's amazing that fantasies and drugs can induce.
03:51So you didn't kill anybody?
03:53No, that's not exactly true.
03:55I've killed.
03:56Who?
03:57In Vietnam, DACA.
03:59I was Special Forces.
04:03He was a lerp.
04:04Huh?
04:05Long-range reconnaissance patrol.
04:08In fact, he got a silver medal.
04:10This might be like you said.
04:12Some kind of a flashback?
04:14You know, people on the edge of death have been known to snap back to their most stressful situation.
04:19Well, Roger Callender wasn't just confessing, but he sounded almost proud of it.
04:24Not my favorite kind of soldier, but I have known men who knots their guns.
04:29What do you know about this guy?
04:31Well, there are those who say he's the best defense attorney in the city.
04:35What do you think?
04:37I'm not particularly fond of lawyers who rip cops apart on the stand.
04:41Oh, Specialist.
04:42Look, Dad, a lot of guys have gotten away with murder because of Roger Callender, but that doesn't make him a killer.
04:47What I heard was a dying declaration.
04:51He was telling the truth.
04:52Maybe, but without a victim, I wouldn't even know where to look.
04:56How about going through the open cases?
04:58Well, that's a great idea.
04:59There's only about 1,600 of them.
05:02If I get started right away, I might finish by summer.
05:051,600?
05:05Yeah, give or take.
05:07How many years do you want to go back?
05:09Well, you're right, anyway.
05:11This could have been last week or ten years ago.
05:13See what I mean?
05:15What about the guy who stabbed Roger?
05:18Well, that would be Kayla McCabe.
05:19No mystery there.
05:20My only regret is that I didn't kill the son of a bitch.
05:24Why?
05:25My sister was Lori Wilkins.
05:27Has it gotten Lori Wilkins?
05:29Oh, you're in a horrible case.
05:32I'm so sorry, losing your sister and her children.
05:36I didn't lose them.
05:38They were taken from me by Scott Wilkins,
05:41and only 12 people in the world don't believe it to be true.
05:44The jury?
05:45Because of that great defense attorney, Roger Callender.
05:48Scott didn't kill his family.
05:50Some intruder did.
05:51The one our man did it.
05:53Roger must have been very persuasive.
05:54You know, if someone did that to my sister,
05:56I'd go after the man that killed her.
05:58Now, his attorney.
05:59Believe me, if I could have killed Scott,
06:00I would have done it in an instant.
06:02What stopped him?
06:03He ran away to Costa Rica.
06:06Man can't show his face in America.
06:09That's some comfort.
06:12Small comfort.
06:19We've got one man bragging about a stabbing,
06:22and his victim throwing about killing somebody else.
06:25It's kind of sad when you think about it.
06:27If Roger Callender dies,
06:29Caleb McCaig is going to spend the rest of his life in jail.
06:32And we're not one step closer to knowing who Roger killed.
06:36I want you to report any discomfort,
06:38any pain, no matter how small.
06:41I'm a tough guy.
06:43Yeah, that's what I'm afraid of.
06:45Look, in your case,
06:46even a minor infection can turn into peritonitis.
06:49So, first sign of trouble,
06:52you get someone in here.
06:54Anything else?
06:57I wasn't going to bring this up.
07:01What?
07:02A so-called confession?
07:03No, actually, um...
07:07You don't remember me,
07:09but we've met before.
07:11Where?
07:12In court.
07:13I was eight years old.
07:15You defended my father on a murder charge.
07:18Hmm.
07:19How did I do?
07:21Pretty well,
07:22considering you had a guilty man for a client.
07:25You pled the case down to manslaughter.
07:28Sometimes that's the best you can manage.
07:30Because of you, my father got a second chance.
07:34You made him promise to do something
07:36to pay back society when he got out.
07:39This must have been back in my idealistic days
07:42when I was still with the public defender's office.
07:45It worked, Mr. Callender.
07:47My father counsels released felons.
07:49He credits you with everything.
07:51Well, even in my salad days,
07:53I was a damn good lawyer.
07:58And you haven't even asked his name.
08:00Mr. Callender?
08:15Yes?
08:16Dr. Mark Sloan,
08:17I was on duty when your husband
08:19was brought into emergency.
08:21And they say doctors don't make house calls.
08:23Actually, I was surprised not to meet you
08:25at the hospital.
08:26Not as surprised as I was
08:28when Roger announced he wanted a divorce.
08:31Oh, I see.
08:33I didn't.
08:34See it coming.
08:36Not for a minute.
08:38Two weeks ago,
08:38Roger took off for the weekend
08:40and when he came home,
08:41he announced that he wanted to change his life.
08:45Translation for Lamelle,
08:47change his wife.
08:48Gardena?
08:53Why, thank you.
08:56Had he done that kind of thing before?
08:59Get a divorce?
09:00No, taking the weekend for himself.
09:03Two, three times a year.
09:05Oh, it's not what you're thinking.
09:08No, I didn't mean to apply.
09:10Well, it's a common assumption.
09:12A man takes off by himself,
09:14everyone assumes a mistress.
09:16Well, I try never to assume anything.
09:19Good, because Roger was never that predictable.
09:22He'd really like a change of scene
09:24when he had a difficult case to ponder.
09:26So few people appreciate solitude these days.
09:29And solitude is exactly what he was after.
09:34Years ago,
09:35I made the mistake
09:36of tagging along on one of those thinking trips.
09:40I never did that again.
09:42So it didn't bother you
09:45two weekends ago
09:46when he took off?
09:50That's what makes it so hard.
09:56Mrs. Callender,
09:59forgive me for asking this,
10:00but once Roger came home
10:02from that weekend,
10:02did he show any signs
10:03of having been in a struggle?
10:07Yes, he had gotten bitten by a dog.
10:09Yeah, well, I saw the bite on his arm.
10:12I was thinking in terms
10:13of other signs of a struggle.
10:16Why?
10:17Well, when he came into surgery,
10:19he claimed
10:21that he killed a man.
10:24Then after he came out of surgery,
10:26he denied it.
10:28You know which is true?
10:29Well, Roger
10:39plays his cards
10:41close to the desk.
10:43So I gather.
10:45But I can tell you this much.
10:48If there's something
10:49Roger doesn't want you to know,
10:51you're never going to find out.
10:54May I?
10:55Sure.
10:56Sure.
10:56Yeah, it's nice.
11:01Why do people do that anymore?
11:02I know.
11:25I always loved those flowers
11:33I know
11:35Not that I ever told you
11:37I know Roger
11:40I know
11:43What happened that weekend
11:46You went away
11:47I know who you killed
11:51Oh I get it
11:56Dr. Sloan came to see you
11:58He hasn't a clue
11:59But I do
12:01All of a sudden it made sense
12:05Speculation
12:06Don't talk to me like a lawyer
12:08I am a lawyer
12:08Not that weekend you weren't
12:10Is this some form of marital blackmail?
12:14Do you really think that little of me?
12:18What do you want?
12:21To stay married
12:23I'm sorry I can't do that
12:27It's really the best thing to do
12:29Look I have no desire for a nasty divorce
12:34I intend to be scrupulously fair
12:36When it comes to that we'll talk
12:38But right now it's important we stay married
12:43For your sake Roger
12:45Think about it
12:48You want to preserve the spouse of privilege
12:53I'm surprised you hadn't thought of that yourself
12:56Well I didn't think it would do me any good
12:58A wife can't be forced to testify
13:00But a willing wife can say anything she chooses
13:04And I choose not to be forced
13:07I can't believe you'd be willing to protect me after what I've done
13:13I'm furious you left me Roger
13:15I really am
13:16But after I realize who you killed
13:20I'd protect you the way a lioness does her cubs
13:23Hello?
13:52Hello?
13:52Hello?
13:52Hello?
13:52Hello?
13:52Dr. Sloan
13:55I hope you'll forgive the intrusion
13:58I was so inspired by your gardenias yesterday
14:02I bought this for myself
14:04Then I got it home and I realized I'm no good with plants
14:08They die on me
14:09I thought maybe you could find a proper home for it
14:12I'm impressed
14:13Most men barely notice flowers much less know their names
14:16Well you told me yesterday
14:18Then I noticed you brought Roger's son to the hospital
14:21Well, that explains the gift
14:21Well, that explains the gift
14:23Well, you inspired me
14:25The way the Athenians inspired the Trojans and gave them a horse
14:30Well, there's no warriors in there, I promise you
14:32Except for you
14:34Well, I never really thought of myself as a warrior
14:38Don't sell yourself short
14:39Don't sell yourself short
14:39You're every bit of a warrior that my husband is
14:41You just use different techniques
14:44Is that a compliment or a criticism?
14:47The way I'm feeling these days
14:49A little of both
14:51Confused?
14:54Very
14:54Yeah, me too
14:56I keep thinking about that dog bite
15:00What about it?
15:03Well, this sounds a little strange, I know
15:05But do you think it could have any connection with Roger's decision to change his life?
15:10The house on the left
15:15A new trophy wife
15:17On the right, I just don't love you anymore
15:19Across the street, I discovered I'm gay
15:21But a dog bite
15:22Yeah, I know
15:24It doesn't make any sense
15:25I just have this feeling about it
15:29Well, I have a feeling too
15:31Tell me
15:33You're trying to get me to say something that's going to harm my husband
15:37Well, I just want the truth
15:39Dr. Sloan
15:41Roger and I may be estranged
15:44But we're still married
15:45And I'm not going to say anything
15:48That will hurt him
15:49You know, I hope this doesn't sound too forward
15:53But
15:54I don't think Roger realizes the remarkable woman he married
15:58Why do you say that?
16:00Because if he did, he would have never left
16:07I've been Roger Callender's doctor for the last, oh, I don't know, 20 years
16:13And never, not once, ever did I realize he had his capacity for pain
16:18You mean when he came and bought the dog bite, he wasn't complaining?
16:22The man is a walking contradiction
16:24Now, um, I am an American, Chicago-born
16:30I don't, what does that have to do with it?
16:33It's a quote
16:33Saul Bellow
16:34The Adventures of Augie March
16:36It's a great novel
16:37Is there a dog in it?
16:38No, there's cold in it
16:40Bone-chilling Chicago cold
16:42I'm sorry I don't get the connection
16:45Roger is a local boy
16:48Now, I know that you California folks have a whole different meaning for the word chill
16:53Yeah, I suppose we do
16:55I've never in my 20 years have I seen a man walking around Beverly Hills with two layers of silk underwear on
17:02Now, what does that tell you?
17:04Well, you're his doctor, what's your opinion?
17:06Roger is hypersensitive to cold
17:08I'm telling you, doctor, that dog bit through two layers of fabric
17:13I had to remove silk strands from the wound
17:17That sounds pretty nasty
17:19Yeah, that's my point
17:20I don't have to tell you that if you leave a wound unattended for several hours
17:26It begins to exhibit arrhythmia outside the area of the laceration
17:30Roger did exhibit redness
17:33He must have been walking around like that for hours
17:35I'm telling you, if I had a dog bite that bad
17:40I would get myself to the nearest emergency room
17:44Like a hellhound on my trail
17:47Robert Johnson
17:48Oh, the blues singer, yeah
17:51If I remember the song right, though, the dog never did catch up with him, did he?
17:56If you believe the legend, the devil did
17:58Oh, that's right
18:00On a lonely crossroad in the middle of nowhere
18:04Yeah
18:05I wonder where Roger got bit
18:08On the left forearm
18:09Well, I was thinking more in terms of a location where it's cold
18:13Oh, you mean Chicago or Aspen or Montevideo
18:18Yeah, that would explain the winter underwear, anyway
18:20You know, one thing that all those places have in common
18:23An emergency room
18:25Why didn't you just go to the nearest one?
18:28Yeah, now that's a $64,000 question
18:30American television, the 50s
18:33Price was going up since then
18:36Already checked with the airlines
18:40No record of his taking a flight
18:42No record with Amtrak, either
18:45Well, you don't need an anti-ID to take a train
18:47You just need a reservation for long-distance travel
18:51No record there, either
18:52Which, uh, leaves his car
18:56Brand new
18:57Looks like Roger didn't think small
19:01You know, I just read the New York Times
19:03That you're three times as likely to kill somebody in one of these
19:06In a regular car
19:07If you're thinking hit and run
19:09Well, you shouldn't dismiss the possibility
19:12I went and checked
19:13There are no outstanding unintended car accidents in L.A. County
19:16You know, he left on Friday and came back on Sunday
19:20We shouldn't limit ourselves to the county, either
19:23I wanted to check the outside for damage
19:25And I'll search inside
19:26Good idea
19:27I don't know if I could just find a map
19:35Or a hotel bill
19:38Gas receipt
19:40You know, I just bet he went to the mountains
19:45But where?
19:49Someplace with some serious snow
19:51Oh, come on, Dad, you can't know that
19:54Any snow that caught up in the real world would have long melted by now
19:58Dad, what are you looking at?
20:04Fresh dense
20:05The kind made by snow chains
20:08So if we check the weather reports from the weekend
20:12And then see whether there was significant snowfall within driving distance of L.A.
20:17We'll have a pretty good idea of where Roger spent his lost weekend
20:20I'm hard-pressed to believe that a small-town banker can be of much help to the L.A. community
20:26Well, this is a long shot, but Big Bear is the only place to get snow this weekend
20:31And you figure the man you're looking for stopped at an ATM for cash?
20:35Well, certainly a possibility
20:37I'm glad to keep your ATM surveillance photos
20:40We want automated banking to be a safe and secure experience
20:44I pulled the mails for the dates you requested
20:46Thank you
20:47Well, would you look at this?
20:57Scott Wilkins?
20:59You're looking for Scott Wilkins?
21:00I am now
21:01Tell me some good news
21:03Tell me you're going to try him again
21:04I can't
21:06Jury verdict is final
21:07Scott Wilkins is an innocent
21:10Sure he is, and I'll give you a line of unsecured credit
21:13Pretty dog
21:15Can be mean, though
21:17You know him?
21:18Mr. Wilkins is a customer
21:20He has a cabin up here
21:21Not that anybody here likes to serve him
21:23Especially since he got Wolfie
21:25Wolfie's the dog
21:26Mr. Wilkins obviously knows how the people around here feel about him
21:31Get too close to Wilkins
21:33Wolfie gets an attitude
21:34You hear that Scott Wilkins is back in the country?
21:39Of course
21:39Scott called me from Costa Rica
21:41About some business we had to discuss
21:43He told me he was driving up to Big Bear to check on his house
21:46Really?
21:48You didn't buy any chance to go up there and see him, did you?
21:51No, I didn't see him at all
21:52How come?
21:54He's a client, not a friend
21:55There's no reason for me to see him
21:58What kind of a business did you two have to discuss?
22:02This bill
22:02Oh, I thought this guy got the insurance from his wife's death
22:07Oh, that didn't begin to cover my fees
22:09Oh, yeah, that's right
22:11You pointed that out to the jury
22:12Lack of motive
22:13Well, it's quite a story
22:15An innocent man comes home to find his entire family slaughtered
22:20In the depth of his grief
22:22He's reviled before the entire world
22:24Put on trial
22:26But in the end, justice triumphs
22:30Sounds like a good movie
22:32Book first
22:33Movie later
22:33Are you negotiating the rights?
22:36If I had represented Sam Shepard
22:38He would have gotten the cut of that series
22:40Sam Shepard was convicted
22:41He didn't have me as his attorney
22:43This is the last time you saw Scott
22:47Did he have the dog with him?
22:49Scott wanted to get a dog to keep the world at bay
22:51He got one
22:52Oh, boy, is he kind of a Malamute wolf mixed with you?
22:55I'm not a dog person
22:56The dog that bit you
22:58Didn't have to look anything like a wolf, did he?
23:03Dr. All I saw was a large mouth
23:05A strong jaw
23:07And sharp teeth
23:08Must have hurt my cow, buddy, bitch
23:11That's about worse
23:13That's right
23:15That's right, yeah
23:16Well, I don't know how it works in the big city
23:23But up here, folks come and go as you please
23:26But no one actually saw Wilkins leave, Big Bear?
23:29Mr. Wilkins doesn't exactly advertise his coming and going
23:32I take it he's not your most popular citizen
23:35Yeah, no offense, detective
23:37But most folks in my jurisdiction don't understand how you fail to get a conviction
23:42Uh, your folks and everybody else
23:45You work that case?
23:47Thank heaven for small favors
23:48How come the sudden interest?
23:50I, uh, caught the guy that stabbed Wilkins' lawyer
23:53Oh, yeah, the brother-in-law
23:55Caleb McCabe
23:56Oh, there's the man folks up here admire
23:59Well, you can take a look around
24:04My boys have been through and through it
24:06No sign of a struggle
24:07Any sign of a dog?
24:11Wolfie?
24:12I assume he's with Scott
24:13Dog usually goes with his master
24:15No
24:16That is, uh, Scott's car out there, isn't it?
24:20Well, that vehicle is the reason we're having this conversation
24:23I know for a fact Mr. Wilkins drove himself up here
24:27Had that car serviced locally
24:30Same day as he made that withdrawal
24:33He checked the odometer
24:35Well, dang, now why didn't I think of that?
24:39Well, if I had checked that odometer
24:41I might have found that Mr. Scott Wilkins only drove himself eight miles after service
24:46I might have thought of that
24:48I might have known it was only two miles from the service station to the cabin
24:53That leaves six miles unaccounted for
24:57Sorry
24:58Of course, he might not have been the one doing that six-mile drive
25:02Three miles up
25:04Three miles back
25:07That leaves a three-mile radius in which to search
25:14They teach math real good up here
25:18I really am sorry
25:20I know you are
25:21I just can't help myself at times
25:24Bad habit
25:26Kind of like leaving dirty laundry lying around
25:33Do you ever go hunting with bloodhounds?
25:53Scott Wilkins, I presume
25:55Yeah, bloodhounds do love dirty laundry
25:57The repair shop said Scott Wilkins picked up his car Friday afternoon
26:22Was the local coroner able to establish the time of death?
26:26Well, they believe he was killed on Saturday
26:28But because of the cold weather, there's some possibility Scott was killed a Friday night
26:32What about the cabin?
26:35Really recent fingerprints from Scott
26:37Did you ever find Scott's dog?
26:40Well, vanished
26:40You might ask Sheriff for half of us
26:43Not too much trouble to dig around that grave a little bit
26:45The man is very thorough
26:47Already did that, huh?
26:49Wolfie was not buried next to his master
26:51What about footprints around the cabin
26:55Dog or human?
26:57Well, the weekend of the murder
26:58They were covered with snow
26:59Which has since melted
27:00I've taken the evidence with it
27:02And you said you didn't find any evidence of blood around Scott's car?
27:06His neck was snapped
27:08The killer was clean, efficient
27:10And more likely trained in hand-to-hand combat
27:12Just like Roger Callender
27:15Oh, there you are
27:18Hey
27:19Uh, Sheriff Buck O'Hara
27:21My father, Dr. Mark Sloan
27:23Oh, this is an honor
27:24Oh, I'm not that special
27:26Yeah, the government's never toot their own horns
27:28Of course, up where I live
27:31I don't get as much practice in homicide as you two fellas
27:35But when I found out that Caleb McKay had been in my jurisdiction
27:39On the last day that Scott Wilkins was seen alive
27:43Well, I took two and I added two
27:46And I came up with a burning desire to ask Mr. McKay some questions
27:50Caleb McKay was in Big Bear
27:53He was asking directions to Wilkins' cabin
27:56You think Caleb killed Scott?
27:58Barely had means, motive, opportunity
28:01And no scruples about murder
28:03If you put it that way, I've got a few questions myself
28:07My name is Jamie Barkin
28:09I'm with the Public Defender's Office
28:11I'm here to represent Mr. Caleb McKay
28:14McKay
28:15There's no R, it's Scott's
28:17I'll do the talking, please
28:20You can whisper any corrections to me
28:22I'm here to represent Mr. Caleb McKay
28:24Capital M, lowercase C
28:27Is this your first murder case?
28:29No
28:29I mean outside a moot court
28:32But we'd just like to clear up a few details
28:38My client has a constitutional right for him
28:40We know he was in Big Bear the weekend of the murder
28:42Not the weekend
28:43I drove back to L.A. Friday night
28:46Not a word
28:47Counselor, that answer would tend to exonerate your client
28:50I'll determine that
28:52Now, uh, when did this alleged murder take place?
28:56Sometime between 10 p.m. on Friday and 6 p.m. on Saturday
29:01The last weekend of last month
29:03Uh, that settles it
29:05Please
29:06I was at the USC-UCLA game on Saturday
29:0930 people saw me, you want a list?
29:11Yes
29:12Of that list will be made available to me
29:15As will the results of any interviews
29:17Between my client and between the
29:19Uh
29:20Between my client and the
29:22What are you doing?
29:26Just checking
29:27I thought so
29:29I am not wet behind the ears
29:33When was the last time you checked?
29:35Sheriff, if you are trying to undermine confidence
29:37Between attorney and client
29:39Then I suggest
29:39You, uh, practice up my way, Counselor?
29:42I'm with the Los Angeles County Public Defender's Office
29:45So, you represent Mr. McCaig here
29:48In the attempted murder of Mr. Roger Callum
29:51And I am fully prepared to challenge
29:53Any incriminating statements for my client
29:55Counselor, I'm on a petition to court
29:56To have your client remove the Big Bear
29:59In connection with the murder of Scott Wilkins
30:02Now, I don't have your vast legal experience
30:06But up country way
30:08The murder charge trumps an attempted murder
30:11Any day of the week
30:12You know, it doesn't make sense
30:17Well, actually, it makes perfect sense
30:20Caleb McKay thought that Scott Wilkins killed his sister
30:23But if Caleb killed Scott, why would he stab me?
30:27Well, rid the world of two evils, maybe?
30:30Well, I'm trying to get inside his brain
30:32Well, let's do exactly that
30:33Let's get inside Caleb's brain
30:35Now, he stabbed me in broad daylight
30:38He confessed
30:39If he killed Scott, he'd be shot in from the rooftops
30:41Yeah, he'd want the world to know
30:43Absolutely
30:43Well, when you confessed to murder
30:46You wouldn't even bring him to the press
30:47You don't believe Caleb killed Scott any more than I do
30:51Honestly?
30:52I think there's a real possibility Caleb's going to pay for your crime
30:57No, no jury would ever convince him
30:59Well, I wouldn't be too sure of that
31:01You know, especially if the real killer isn't apprehended
31:04But they never found the intruder who killed Roy Wilkins
31:07Because there wasn't one
31:09Still voted not guilty
31:12Well, Caleb won't have you as his lawyer
31:16He should
31:19You know, if he did
31:21His lawyer would not be able to call the one person who could prove his innocence
31:26You?
31:27Now, what possible motive would I have for killing Scott Wilkins?
31:30That's what I can't figure out
31:32In fact, I had a good reason not to kill him
31:34What's that?
31:35His death would be against my financial interest
31:38My client dead
31:39There's no book deal
31:40Well, money's not the only motive for murder
31:43As I understand it, you don't need a motive to prove murder
31:46Well, it just means an opportunity
31:48Can you place me at Big Bear Dr. Sloan?
31:51Not yet
31:52But you had means for the murder
31:55That's something Caleb didn't have
31:56Explain
31:58Well, Scott Wilkins was afraid that somebody was going to kill him
32:02That's why it got Wolfie
32:03Now, to snap his neck, the killer would have to get past the dog
32:07Oh, I doubt Caleb could do that
32:09But you thought you were his lawyer
32:12There's no reason to put the dog between you and him
32:15Doctor, doctor, doctor
32:17I used to be getting the physiology
32:19It's hard work to snap a man's neck
32:22What was the name of that unit you were with, Long Range?
32:25Lerp
32:25Assassins
32:27Soldiers
32:28Train in exactly the technique that you used on Scott Wilkins
32:32I got a medal for my service
32:35You're not likely to get one on this one
32:38Not even posthumously
32:39Of course, I guess it's what you want to go in
32:42A posthumous medal
32:44I'll have that waiver now
32:58I need you to get Dr. Sloan up here right away
33:03You should be in bed
33:11I've had it with this hospital and its staff
33:14I'm pretty sure you're still in danger of infection and bleeding
33:18If you're like another doctor, it can be arranged
33:20I have my own physician, thank you
33:22I want you to understand that this is against medical advice
33:26I consider this to be life-threatening
33:28And I want you to understand that I've signed all necessary legal waivers
33:32The hospital's off the hook
33:34Thanks for coming in
33:44Oh, I love it
33:45I'm not only a veterinarian, now I'm a police consultant
33:47What do you got?
33:49Can you identify a dog by its bite?
33:52Absolutely
33:52Hey, you bring me a dog
33:53I'll take an imprint of the teeth and just match it to the bite
33:56Just like humans
33:57No two bites exactly the same
33:59But we haven't got the dog
34:00That makes things much more difficult
34:02Could this be the dog?
34:06Oh, yeah
34:07He could do this, part Malamute, part wolf
34:09A dog like this is very unpredictable
34:12I'll tell you one thing for certain
34:14This dog's bite is much worse than his bark
34:44What do you think we're a dog?
34:45Good to see you
34:47What do you think, man?
34:49For example, one thing for certain
34:51A dog was to be a dog
34:53That's the dog
34:53He could be aã…Ž
34:55Okay, and that's part of the dog
34:56If we are can, a dog
34:57That's right
34:57how next to our dog
34:59We are not gonna be out
35:00In the 21st pessoas
36:52Betsy, I need help.
36:57Bad, isn't it?
36:58Someone should never have left the hospital.
37:01What?
37:02Jimmy James.
37:04Your father, Jimmy James.
37:06How did you know that?
37:08I'll never forget it.
37:10Defend him.
37:13He's hemorrhaging.
37:14He's going to need emergency surgery.
37:15Again.
37:18Hold it right away.
37:25That's the second time I've brought you back from the dead.
37:28Don't count on happening again.
37:30Well, I've only got one question that I can test this time to.
37:37I have a hard question to ask.
37:58Yes.
38:00You don't know what the question is.
38:03Counselor, don't you always say you never ask a question to which you don't know the answer?
38:09Yes.
38:10And that's your answer.
38:12Yes.
38:14What's my question?
38:15Can you move back in?
38:21Come home, Roger.
38:23It's what we both want.
38:25It's what we both want.
38:48It's what we both want.
38:49Hey! Hey, come here!
39:01Sheriff's deputy did another search on Scott Wilkins' cabin today and discovered this receipt from Nora's coffee house.
39:23Now, the receipt is dated 12.33 p.m. Saturday. That indicates that Mr. Wilkins was still alive when witnesses placed Mr. McCaig in Los Angeles.
39:35As a result, we are releasing Mr. McCaig from custody and dropping all charges. This time, I'd like to introduce his attorney, Cedric Watersmith.
39:48Cedric Watersmith, didn't you co-counsel with him on that Maxwell case?
39:54C.W.'s almost as good as my husband.
39:57This spot is expensive, too. I wonder who's gonna pick up the tab on that one.
40:02I am.
40:03Well, that's very generous of you. Well, it would be a tragedy if Caleb got any significant jail time.
40:10I don't think I've ever heard a crime victim say that before. Well, if C.W. calls me, I'll be saying it from the stand.
40:17My husband's a changed man, Dr. Sloan.
40:22St. Thomas Aquinas. Good?
40:26A gift from my wife. Fascinating reading.
40:30Yeah. Interesting bookmark, too.
40:33A laundry receipt. I found that in my wallet.
40:36Yeah, I do the same thing. You look around for a bookmark.
40:40Exactly. Seems that's what Scott Wilkins did, too.
40:45You said it yourself, Dr. Sloan. Everyone does it.
40:49Hmm. It's convenient, though, if the Sheriff O'Hara just happened to have found a dated receipt.
40:56Caleb McKay would have never been exonerated without it.
41:00Doctor, would you feel comfortable if an innocent man were punished?
41:05No. No, I wouldn't. But then I wouldn't feel comfortable if a guilty man went free either.
41:11You couldn't bear the thought of an innocent man being convicted for his crime.
41:18Well, it's the first time I heard of someone planning evidence to make someone else look not guilty.
41:23Where did you get that receipt?
41:26Uh, Nora's coffee house. It's on the way to Big Bear.
41:30You know, Roger must have stopped there himself.
41:33Oh, there's a way to commit the murder.
41:36You know, if we could find one person who saw him, one single witness,
41:41sounds like I'd better take a little trip up to the mountains.
41:50I like a man who likes plain coffee.
41:54Oh, I sell plenty of that fancy stuff here.
41:57You can't get away with not these days.
42:00But me?
42:02I like coffee.
42:04Plain black coffee.
42:08What about this man? What is he like?
42:11Oh!
42:12That's that attorney.
42:14What's his name?
42:16October and September.
42:18It's a calendar!
42:19Do you remember him coming in here?
42:21I've seen him on television.
42:23Have you seen him in here?
42:25Oh, I'd remember him.
42:30George Clooney came in here once.
42:34Oh, he's every bit as handsome in person as he is on screen.
42:40Maybe one of your customers noticed him?
42:43Mr. Clooney?
42:44Mr. Callender.
42:46Oh, no one said a word to me.
42:52They all noticed Mr. Clooney.
42:54Yeah.
42:55Yes, boy.
43:05You wanna eat?
43:08You know you do!
43:09Come on!
43:10Eat.
43:11Eat, you know you do.
43:16Come on, eat.
43:32Good boy.
43:34Good boy, yeah, yes.
43:39Hey there.
43:40Hey there, you pretty thing.
43:47Come on, come on.
43:49Oh, good boy.
43:51What a good boy.
43:53Yes, you do.
43:54There you go.
43:56That's it.
43:57Yeah.
43:57Oh, good boy.
44:12Why do you have to be so cute?
44:32I could hold myself, but my mother would kill me.
44:39You're not going to kill anything more than a lot of people.
44:42Dr. Huck's going to give you a shot, and then you're going to go to sleep.
44:47So you've got to be brave, okay?
44:50You've got to be brave for me.
44:58I've never seen that man.
45:00It's like I never see him.
45:03Have I done something to upset you, Penelope?
45:05That's what you haven't done.
45:08And what's that?
45:09I called his office five times, five times.
45:15About that dog?
45:18What dog?
45:19The one that's been scaring my kids.
45:22I've been calling and calling and calling.
45:25I'm truly sorry, Penelope.
45:27My deputies are getting fearful about this.
45:29Ma'am, can you describe this dog?
45:31Well, of course I can describe the dog.
45:33He was in my car.
45:35I'm the one who drove him to the pound.
45:38They say he's hurt so bad they've got no choice but to destroy him.
45:43You know, that dog's not as bad as people think he is
45:46just because he's belonging to Scott Wilkins.
45:49Scott Wilkins?
45:49Yeah, I feel bad.
45:53I love animals.
45:54I don't know if I can work here.
46:00No, but you just have to do things that make you feel sad.
46:04What time are they putting the dogs down?
46:07Not while they're talking on the phone, Penelope.
46:10That's too beautiful.
46:13Are you crazy, Tim?
46:15You're handsome.
46:16I'm talking to the dog.
46:26All right, Timmy, I gotta hang up.
46:28This beast, he's really hurt bad.
46:31We have to put him to sleep.
46:36Tim, that's the stupidest thing I've ever heard.
46:46They have worse wolfies.
47:11They have worse wolfies.
47:16Give me them out, you.
47:18Please tell me you haven't put them down.
47:19We have a witness.
47:37A dog.
47:38Who's already got an impression of the teeth marks.
47:41If it matches your bite, exactly.
47:43Your Honor,
47:52I have defended many guilty men.
47:55When I defended Scott Wilkins,
47:57I truly believed that he was innocent.
48:00I asked myself the same question that I asked the jury.
48:03What kind of man would slaughter his own children just to create a cover story?
48:09Only a monster would do such a thing.
48:12A monster.
48:14I did my job.
48:15I got him off.
48:18And then I did what was right.
48:21Some have called me a hero.
48:23That is not how I see myself.
48:24Others believe that I myself have become a monster.
48:28That's their privilege.
48:30I regard myself only as a man.
48:34It is your unenviable task
48:36to judge the appropriate punishment
48:39of my actions.
48:43I beg neither mercy nor forgiveness.
48:46I take full responsibility for what I have done.
48:49And I accept whatever punishment you deem just.
48:54You know,
49:05if Caleb McKaig
49:06had taken the law into his own hands,
49:09we would have never known who Roger killed.
49:12He would have gotten away with murder.
49:14A murder that Caleb himself wouldn't be committed.
49:16But he did take the law into his own hands.
49:18Yep.
49:19And now they're both in jail.
49:22Yep.
49:22Well, because a guilty man went free.
49:26Well, somebody killed your sister.
49:28Could you accept a not guilty verdict?
49:31I know I'm supposed to,
49:32but I really couldn't say for certain.
49:36I don't think any of us can.
49:37Follow the evidence on CSI.
49:56Coming up next,
49:58Julie Andrews on performing on Golden Pond Live.
50:01Live television is much more daunting than live theatre.
50:05In a theatre,
50:05if you get 2,000 people watching,
50:07that's one thing,
50:08but this could be 40 million.
50:10It is a flattering to the audience at home
50:13to feel that this is being done.
50:16Thank you so much.
50:18I hope you enjoyed any of us.
50:23God bless you.
50:27You're welcome.
Recommended
49:19
|
Up next
45:32
45:32
47:38
48:30
49:08
0:46
2:11
2:55
11:13