Diagnosis Murder Season 7 Episode 17 Teachers Pet
Category
📺
TVTranscript
00:00Hey, Winter, what are you, uh, still doing here? I thought you'd be at the beach by now, aren't you?
00:03House-sitting for Dr. Sloan?
00:05Yeah, I promised Dr. Sloan I'd check on Mrs. Winter before I go, so...
00:09I'll see her.
00:10But I said I would.
00:11Ah, it's okay, get out of here. Hang out with Jill at the beach all afternoon.
00:15Don't think about medical school. Don't think, period.
00:18Yeah, thanks, Jill.
00:20I'll speak of the devil.
00:21Um, excuse me?
00:24Hey, Jill!
00:26Hey.
00:27Thanks, man.
00:28Jill!
00:29Oh, yeah.
00:30Jill!
00:31Excuse me, guys.
00:35Hey, darling.
00:37Donald, I had to see you.
00:40I miss you so much this week.
00:43I love you.
00:55Mickey?
00:57Honey?
00:57I got some Chinese food.
01:01Mickey.
01:03Hi.
01:05We haven't gotten to our first anniversary, and you're already making me to someone else.
01:10What are you talking about?
01:12How could you do this?
01:14Mickey, you gotta stop this jealousy thing.
01:17I heard you!
01:21I was outside of Donald Ward's office.
01:23I was outside of Donald Ward's office.
01:30So, is he going to Brazil with you?
01:32Is this what your research project is for, so you and your lover can be together?
01:37Well, at least the boat didn't sink.
01:52Well, at least the boat didn't sink.
01:56You know, between the boat rental, the rods, the reels, the cabin overnight, these fish come
02:03to about 500 bucks a piece.
02:05Good thing we didn't catch more of them.
02:08You know, that's another thing.
02:09Why is it that you always catch the most fish?
02:12Psychology.
02:13I think like a fish.
02:18Steve.
02:21That, you better wait here.
02:39Jill?
02:41Mickey?
02:43Anybody here?
03:04Jill?
03:06Oh, my God.
03:08Jill, what happened?
03:11Where's Mickey?
03:13He's dead.
03:38He's dead.
03:39He's dead.
05:12There's a bad cut on the side of your head there.
05:15This may hurt a little.
05:16I tried to help Mickey.
05:22And we were kicking him and hitting him.
05:27And when I went to help, this guy in a Halloween mask started beating me up.
05:32And he was laughing like it was fun.
05:38And when Mickey tried to defend me, he hit him over the head.
05:43He just kept hitting him and hitting him.
05:46I'm sorry.
05:53Mickey was so looking forward to this weekend.
05:58And we had a horrible night from the moment I got here.
06:07You came in on the robbery?
06:10No.
06:12Mickey was angry with me.
06:15Mickey?
06:15He had this whole romantic night planned, and when something came up at the hospital,
06:25he thought, well, it doesn't matter what he thought.
06:30He finally calmed down, and we went to bed.
06:38It was still dark.
06:40We woke.
06:43Heard the glass breaking.
06:44Dad?
06:51Try to keep a little pressure.
06:52I'll be ruined.
07:04The phone lines were cut.
07:07But all I found missing so far was a camera, your laptop, and some of your jewelry.
07:12Well, it's not much of a robbery.
07:16That's one interpretation.
07:18What's the other one?
07:22No, you can't mean that.
07:25Dad, in 16 years, on the job, I have never seen a robber kill one person and leave another alive.
07:32Maybe they just left her for dead.
07:34They would have known if she was dead.
07:42Jill, you're going to have to try and answer a few questions for me.
07:55Can you tell me what these robbers looked like?
07:58I don't know.
08:00They were wearing masks, like for Halloween.
08:02Did you see their hands?
08:07No.
08:08They were wearing gloves.
08:11Were they short?
08:12Tall?
08:14I don't know.
08:16I was so scared.
08:17It was so crazy.
08:20Can you tell me anything about their appearance?
08:23I feel like you're interrogating me.
08:26Steve, maybe this isn't the time.
08:29Just trying to figure out what happened.
08:31I told you what happened.
08:36They killed my husband and not me unconscious.
08:40That's what happened.
08:42I told you what happened.
09:01Jesse.
09:02They're, uh, going to take you down to x-ray in a couple of minutes.
09:07No, I don't have a skull fracture.
09:09Mark just wants to make sure.
09:13Jill, I don't know what to say.
09:15I'm just, you know, I'm just so sorry that this happened to you.
09:18You know what the irony is?
09:23Things are really getting better.
09:25I really thought that Mickey and I were going to make it.
09:29Well, Lena, we couldn't wait to get to the beach to be with you.
09:33No, I saw him about an hour ago.
09:50He was doing rounds.
09:51Okay.
09:52Oh, I'll find him.
09:52Never mind.
09:53It's okay.
09:53You can cage him.
09:54Yeah, I can do that.
09:55Donald, Donald.
09:56I'm glad I ran into you.
09:57I'm thinking about canceling your classes today.
10:01Why?
10:01Because of the boy?
10:03Well, yeah, I think the kids are upset.
10:05Well, they want to be doctors.
10:06They should get over it.
10:07I'm doing Mickey's autopsy tonight.
10:09Hmm.
10:10Excuse me.
10:13Oh, Dr. Ward.
10:13Yeah.
10:14I can't help but notice something's different about you,
10:17and I can't quite put my finger on it.
10:19Is the haircut?
10:22Open glass.
10:22I've never seen you in glasses.
10:24Lost one of my contacts.
10:25And they become you.
10:27Yeah.
10:29Yeah, you're welcome.
10:30Here.
10:32These are for you.
10:34I think you two should have this moment alone.
10:37I'll see you later.
10:38See ya.
10:40Medical school applications.
10:43You promised to read them by Friday.
10:46Then it was Monday.
10:48The admissions committee meets tomorrow, Mark, at 5.
10:54Sure, you're fine.
10:55I'll do them.
10:56I've got patients to see this afternoon,
10:57but I'll take them back to my office at night.
10:59We'll do them.
10:59This is, yeah.
11:03Well, one who?
11:13You know, I read this article on a magazine
11:15that said that women think it's sexy when men do the dishes.
11:19I don't see any women.
11:20Well, what would be the matter with a little practice?
11:25Nah.
11:29Let me put it this way.
11:30You get over here and dry these dishes, my friend,
11:34or you're going to be living in a cardboard box over in the park.
11:37Why didn't you say that in the first place?
11:39Now, don't move.
11:54Ah, oh, boy.
12:01Next time you dry, put some peroxide on there.
12:09You're telling me, see, if that's not from the kitchen,
12:11this glass is etched.
12:12Look at that.
12:14Like from the front door?
12:15Well, how could glass from the front door get in their towel?
12:20You're not going to like my answer to that.
12:22Can I just say this?
12:30Jill is a very good friend of mine.
12:32I understand that, Jess.
12:33But forensics went through that house.
12:35They collected every fiber, every fingerprint, even every partial.
12:39They didn't come up with a trace of any unaccounted-for stranger.
12:43All that means is that they were very careful.
12:45No, what it means is the best explanation
12:47for how that glass got in the towel
12:49was that someone inside the house
12:51wrapped the towel around her hand,
12:53then went outside and broke the glass in her front door.
12:56And that has to be Jill?
12:58Well, I don't think it's Mickey.
12:59Steve, Jill and Mickey
13:01might have had problems
13:03like any other married couple,
13:05but I don't think that she's capable of something like this.
13:09Eight zip.
13:10What I don't believe is that
13:12real robbers would leave a stereo,
13:14three TVs, and a DVD player.
13:17Nine zip.
13:19Look, Steve,
13:20I don't think that you're being completely objective about this.
13:23Now, why wouldn't I be objective?
13:25I don't know.
13:26Jill doesn't think you like her.
13:29Now, that's ridiculous.
13:30I mean, I hardly even know her.
13:32Oh, I think long I get winners.
13:35Oh, great.
13:36Here, it's not me.
13:37Is that the autopsy report?
13:39Yeah, Mickey was killed
13:41due to multiple blows to the head.
13:42As expected.
13:43Yeah, but what's odd about this
13:45is that two to three blows to the head
13:46should have rendered him unconscious,
13:48that he was hit five more times
13:50before he was killed.
13:51Sounds like an angry, personal murder to me.
13:54It's not what robbers usually do,
13:56especially when they leave a victim alive.
13:59Why do I get the feeling
14:00I'm the only one on Jill's side?
14:02I gotta call the D-8.
14:05Thanks.
14:05See ya.
14:08Okay, righty,
14:09I spot you three points.
14:11Lefty, we play even up.
14:17I think you've got a little too much game in you.
14:20Oh, coward.
14:21All right, so tomorrow's readings
14:27will be on antiarrhythmic drugs
14:29and cardiac rescue,
14:31specifically the efficacy of lidocaine
14:33and procainamide
14:34in terminating ventricular tachycardia.
14:37All right.
14:38That's it, folks.
14:39Dr. Ward?
14:50Yep.
14:50I've missed a couple of classes.
14:51I have some questions on the readings.
14:56All right.
15:06Wait, wait, wait.
15:07Wait a second, John.
15:08Just hold on a second.
15:09What? What's the matter?
15:10What's been going on with you and Jesse Travis?
15:13He was all over you the other day.
15:14Donald, he's my friend.
15:16He was comforting me.
15:17Really?
15:18Really.
15:25Really?
15:26Mm-hmm.
15:26Mm-hmm.
15:26Steve, Steve, what can I do for you?
15:42Actually, I was looking for her.
15:45Joe Hobbing, I'm placing you under arrest
15:47for the murder of your husband, Mickey.
15:49Boy, that's a little excessive, don't you think?
15:51You have the right to remain silent.
15:52If you say can't, and we'll be used against the order of law.
16:11Well, well, well, when did you break out?
16:13My dad could have failed.
16:16I'm glad.
16:17Hey, um, can I talk to you for a second?
16:22You know, I wanted to talk to you today.
16:24Is something wrong?
16:29Look, you know, I don't know how to say this exactly,
16:32so I'm just going to say it straight out.
16:35I've known for a while that you and Donald Ward
16:38have been having an affair.
16:41Why are you telling me this?
16:43Because I should have said something before.
16:44Now I think that I have to.
16:46Jesse, please don't do this.
16:47Look, I think that it's relevant to the case.
16:49No, it isn't.
16:51Donald has nothing to do with the case.
16:53Jill...
16:53He has nothing to do with the fact
16:55that I have been charged for murder.
16:57If you do this,
16:59if our affair becomes public,
17:01he'll lose his job.
17:03And for what?
17:04For nothing.
17:07I don't know.
17:08Jesse, please.
17:10I am begging you.
17:12Things are bad enough.
17:14All right, we've got six applicants left
17:21and one acceptance to fill.
17:24I'd like to recommend that we put
17:27Gilder, Richardson, and Weber
17:29in the waiting list pile.
17:31Anyone else?
17:33Yes, I think we should give the last spot
17:35to Jordan Alsop.
17:36Well, wait a second.
17:39What about Lorna Gillespie?
17:42She's 43 years old.
17:44She hasn't been in school
17:46for at least 20 years.
17:48Is that something against age?
17:50In this particular instance,
17:51yes.
17:52She won't start practicing
17:53until she's 50.
17:55And she'll be lucky
17:56if she has a career
17:57that lasts 20 years.
17:58And what a career.
17:59The most dedicated,
18:01hard-working doctor I ever knew
18:03was Elliot Crane.
18:04And he didn't start medical school
18:06until he was in his 40s.
18:08This boy will practice
18:09twice as long as Mrs. Gillespie.
18:13He's only got a 3.1 grade average.
18:16I suppose the fact that his father
18:18is worth millions of money and dollars
18:19is scary.
18:20It's getting late, folks.
18:22Let's finish tomorrow.
18:24It's 5 okay.
18:25Wait a minute.
18:25I had a better idea.
18:26Why don't we have this young man come in
18:27and we'll have a look at him?
18:29Okay with you?
18:32Fine.
18:33Camera, laptop, jewelry.
19:02Yesterday, a fisherman
19:04pulled a garbage bag
19:05out of the ocean
19:06about 100 yards down the beach
19:07from our house.
19:09All the things we thought
19:10were stolen were in that bag.
19:12There were no robbers.
19:14You killed your husband
19:15and threw that stuff in the ocean.
19:17That's a lie.
19:18Young lady,
19:19I've prosecuted
19:20hundreds of cases.
19:22Trust me when I say
19:23this is shaping up
19:24as one of my favorites.
19:25Then I ask myself,
19:27self,
19:29why has this
19:31assistant district attorney
19:33asked to meet with us?
19:35For the record,
19:36I'd love to go to trial.
19:38But the DA
19:39thinks it's such a slam dunk
19:41that it's a waste
19:42of everybody's time
19:42and money.
19:43So he has authorized me.
19:46No.
19:48He has ordered me
19:49to make a one-day,
19:51one-time only offer.
19:53Anytime in the next 24 hours,
19:54your client complete
19:55demands fault or two.
19:57After that,
19:58we go to trial
19:59on the original charge.
20:02Murder one.
20:03You can take your offering.
20:05Jill.
20:05No, forget it.
20:06I'm not taking a deal.
20:0724 hours.
20:09I'm not taking a deal.
20:39I'm running to Prince.
20:55Yeah?
20:57You have any idea
20:57what they took?
20:59Steve.
20:59It's a morgue.
21:01Would they take a body?
21:03No, they didn't take a body,
21:05but it looks like
21:05all they did was break
21:06into Mickey Huffing's
21:08property bed.
21:08What's strange is that
21:09they didn't take anything?
21:11Isn't the chain
21:12of evidence broken?
21:13I mean, that could be
21:13a problem at the trial.
21:15That's no big deal.
21:16We've got so much evidence
21:17it doesn't matter.
21:18Look, guys,
21:19I love you,
21:20but if you're not
21:21going to help me file,
21:22beat it.
21:27So you think
21:27it was Jill
21:28that broke in here?
21:29Jill was with
21:30her lawyer last night.
21:32You already checked?
21:33First thing.
21:33Well, if it wasn't her,
21:36doesn't that suggest
21:37that something in
21:37Mickey's stuff
21:38points the finger
21:39at somebody else?
21:40Well, yeah,
21:41that's possible.
21:44You all right, Jess?
21:45Something wrong?
21:46No, no, I'm fine.
21:47I thought that you should
21:54hear this from me
21:55personally, Mark.
21:58This afternoon,
21:59I plan to resign
22:00from the community
22:01general.
22:01You're not retiring,
22:04are you?
22:04Pardon me.
22:05I'm leaving
22:06because
22:09for the last nine months
22:12I've been
22:13having an affair
22:14with one of my students.
22:20Jill Hubbard.
22:31I'll miss
22:33working with you,
22:34Donald.
22:35As I will with you.
22:38You're a good doctor,
22:39Donald.
22:39I'll give that up.
22:43Before I go,
22:44there's something
22:44I might ask you,
22:45Mark.
22:47You're working
22:48with your son
22:48on Jill's case.
22:49Yes, I am.
22:51She didn't do this,
22:52Mark.
22:54Evidence is
22:54awful convincing.
22:56Reexamine
22:56evidence.
22:58Please,
22:59I beg you,
23:00she needs
23:01what you're asking.
23:05Well,
23:07that's
23:08all I can say.
23:10Donald,
23:11somebody tried
23:15to help Jill
23:16last night
23:17by tampering
23:18with the evidence
23:18in the morgue.
23:20Wait,
23:20you're not suggesting
23:21that.
23:23No, no, Mark.
23:24No, I know
23:25this young woman.
23:26She is no more
23:27capable of something
23:27like this
23:28than you or I.
23:29Don, I'm sorry.
23:32I think she's
23:32guilty.
23:33And I'm afraid
23:34you just provided
23:35the one thing
23:36that was missing
23:37her motive
23:38for killing
23:39Nikki.
23:40It was you.
23:41This is Huffington
23:50will tell you
23:51a harrowing tale.
23:55The story
23:56of two medical
23:57students,
23:58a happily married
24:00young couple
24:00house-sitting
24:01for a friend.
24:02story of
24:05robbers
24:06breaking in
24:07late at night
24:08and brutally
24:10beating her husband
24:12Nikki to death.
24:14It's a frightening,
24:16horrific tale
24:17that preys
24:18on all of our fears.
24:21But just to reassure you,
24:22in this case,
24:24it's a total lie.
24:26not a word
24:28of it
24:29is true.
24:33Mrs.
24:34Huffing
24:34says the robbers
24:36broke in the front door.
24:39The police
24:40went through the house
24:40from top to bottom,
24:42couldn't find a single sign
24:44of an intruder.
24:46Mrs.
24:47Huffing
24:47says
24:48the robbers
24:49killed her husband
24:50and knocked her
24:51unconscious.
24:52And yet,
24:55having all the time
24:56in the world,
24:58all they stole
24:59was a camera,
25:00a laptop,
25:01computer,
25:02and jewelry.
25:05Not much of a haul,
25:06would you say?
25:09Then you know
25:10what these robbers did?
25:12Mrs.
25:13Huffing
25:13would have us believe
25:14they put this
25:16poultry heist
25:18into a garbage bag
25:20and threw it
25:21into the ocean.
25:25And why
25:26would they do that?
25:30The answer is simple.
25:35They didn't.
25:38There was no robbery
25:39and there were no robbers.
25:43Mrs. Huffing
25:43killed her husband
25:45and wanted it
25:46to look like
25:47somebody else
25:48had done it.
25:49The defendant
25:50would also like you
25:51to believe
25:52that she loved
25:52her husband
25:53and wanted
25:54her marriage
25:54to work.
25:56And yet,
25:57less than two months
25:58after Jill
25:58married Mickey,
26:00she began
26:01a torrid affair
26:02and that affair
26:03continues to
26:04this very day.
26:05Don't let that
26:10sweet young face
26:11confuse you.
26:13You're looking
26:14at a cold-blooded
26:15killer.
26:18Court is adjourned
26:19until nine
26:20tomorrow.
26:20Come on.
26:30Jason.
26:30Jason.
26:30Jason.
26:30Jason.
26:30Jason.
26:30Jason.
26:30Jason.
26:30Jason.
26:32Jason.
26:35So what did
26:36you say to her?
26:37Well,
26:38I try to be supportive.
26:40She's a friend.
26:41You're supposed
26:42to be loyal
26:43to friends.
26:44What happens
26:44when another friend
26:45is the arresting officer?
26:46How's that work?
26:47Not too well.
26:49Excuse me a minute.
26:50I'll be right back.
26:55But you're still
26:56mad at me
26:56because of Jill.
26:58I just don't like
26:58the way you treated her.
26:59I treated her
27:00like any suspect.
27:01You took her
27:02out of there
27:02in handcuffs.
27:03Just like I would
27:04any other suspect.
27:05Just as procedure.
27:06That's all.
27:08You sure?
27:09Well,
27:10I told you that
27:10before and I meant it.
27:14Okay.
27:16Okay.
27:17You guys are such guys.
27:19Steve, come here
27:28a minute.
27:30All of you.
27:40Look,
27:41my toothbrush
27:42is out of the holder
27:43and I put it back in.
27:44It wouldn't take a charge.
27:46Maybe we should
27:46launch an investigation.
27:47There was a contact lens
27:50in the bottom.
27:50That's why
27:51it wouldn't charge.
27:52And that would be
27:52important because
27:54no one in this house
27:55wears contacts.
27:56So how did the lens
27:57get there
27:57and does it have
27:58anything to do
27:58with Mickey
27:59Hubbing's death?
28:00Thank you, Steve.
28:01You know,
28:01I know someone
28:02who lost a contact lens
28:03the other day
28:04right around the time
28:04that Mickey died.
28:05Who would that be?
28:06Dr. Donald Ward.
28:08Oh, no,
28:19let me do that.
28:21You know,
28:22I so appreciate
28:23you suggesting
28:24that we see
28:25this young man.
28:26Well,
28:27I shouldn't have said
28:28it was about the money.
28:29I'm sorry.
28:31Send him in.
28:32Hi.
28:37Dr. Wesley.
28:38Yes, hi.
28:39Pleasure to meet you.
28:40Dr. Sloan.
28:41Jordan, sit down,
28:42will you?
28:48Jordan,
28:48you went over
28:49your application
28:50and we just thought
28:51we'd like to know
28:51a little more about you.
28:52Have you given
28:53any thought to the future,
28:55considered a specialty,
28:56or decided where
28:58you'd like to practice?
28:59Well,
29:00I've been thinking
29:00I'd like to practice
29:01out of the country.
29:03Hmm,
29:03interesting.
29:04Any particular reason?
29:07Well,
29:07we've made so many
29:08advances in this country,
29:10I think we should share them
29:11with the rest of the world.
29:12There are so many people
29:13who could benefit from them.
29:15You know,
29:16when I was your age,
29:17I used to dream
29:18about traveling
29:19around the world
29:20and curing exotic diseases.
29:23Have you considered
29:24any particular specialty,
29:26like epidemiology,
29:27or anything?
29:28For cardiac surgery,
29:29our techniques have surpassed
29:31the rest of the world.
29:32Well,
29:32actually,
29:33I was thinking
29:34of cosmetic surgery.
29:36Possibly,
29:36you're not aware
29:37of how many people
29:38leave Europe
29:38to get work done
29:39on their faces,
29:41their breasts,
29:43hips.
29:43Well,
29:44I've looked into it.
29:45They go to New York,
29:47L.A.,
29:47and, of course,
29:49Brazil.
29:50I figure they need
29:51an American-type practice
29:52in Europe.
29:53Maybe in Switzerland,
29:55it's centrally located.
29:56I think Switzerland
29:57would be great.
29:58Don't you?
30:09Dad?
30:15There was a print.
30:17You would be
30:17if there wasn't a print.
30:18There was one
30:19unmistakable print
30:20on that lens,
30:21and it belongs
30:22to Dr. Donald Ward.
30:24So he must have been
30:25in the house that night
30:26and Mickey was killed.
30:27Maybe.
30:28Ah,
30:29we've got to get
30:29a search warrant.
30:30Just what we need.
30:32Another suspect.
30:34What we need
30:35is the truth.
30:38Dr. Ward,
30:39this warrant
30:39authorizes a complete
30:40search of your home
30:41and your office.
30:43I'm going to call
30:44one where?
30:47I'll leave
30:47the computer on,
30:48please.
30:54We've already
30:54searched your home.
30:55Please step aside
30:56so we can search
30:57your office.
31:00Let me tell you
31:01something.
31:04I'm going to have
31:04your badge.
31:05I know your dad
31:12sometimes has
31:13good hunches,
31:14but this
31:14is a waste of time.
31:16We just want to
31:17cover all the bases.
31:19Well,
31:19we didn't find
31:19anything at the house,
31:20and we're not
31:21going to find
31:22anything here.
31:24He'd have to be
31:24an idiot
31:25to leave some...
31:26What is it?
31:34I don't know.
31:35I'll leave it.
31:40Dr. Ward,
31:42I hand you
31:44these printouts
31:45of some letters
31:47that were found
31:48by the police
31:48in an email file
31:50in your office
31:51computer.
31:52The top letter
31:53is dated
31:55February 9th.
31:57It was sent
31:59to Mickey Hobbing
32:02four days
32:03before his death
32:04I'd like to
32:07read a few
32:08relevant lines.
32:10It says,
32:12and I quote,
32:14I know what you
32:15did last night.
32:17You hit Jill
32:18and abused her.
32:20If you ever
32:21lay a hand
32:21on her again,
32:23I'll kill you.
32:24end quote.
32:28Did you write
32:29this letter?
32:34Sir?
32:36Your name's
32:40on the bottom.
32:42I wrote it.
32:43when you wrote it,
32:47you were having
32:48an affair
32:48with Mrs.
32:50Hobbing.
32:51And in fact,
32:52you still are.
32:55That is correct.
32:56It must have been
32:57painful
32:58loving this woman
32:59knowing that her
33:00husband was
33:01beating her up.
33:02I'd like to
33:04quote from
33:05another letter
33:06to Mr.
33:06Hobbing
33:07dated
33:07February 4th.
33:10You are a
33:12coward and
33:12a bully.
33:13Every fiber
33:14of my body
33:15cries out to
33:16beat you
33:17within an inch
33:17of your life.
33:19Mr.
33:19McNamara,
33:20you've more
33:21than made
33:21your point.
33:23Sorry,
33:23Your Honor.
33:24Dr.
33:32Ward,
33:33isn't it
33:34true that
33:34you lost
33:35a contact
33:36lens right
33:37about the
33:38time of this
33:38murder?
33:39Yes,
33:40I lost
33:40a contact
33:41lens.
33:41I'm not
33:41sure when.
33:43Would it
33:44refresh your
33:45memory if I
33:46told you that
33:46you were seen
33:47wearing glasses
33:48at the hospital
33:49the morning
33:51that Mickey
33:51Hobbing's body
33:52was found?
33:53That's right.
33:54That's exactly
33:55right.
33:56I lost my
33:56contact right
33:57around then.
33:59I'd like to
34:00enter this
34:01contact lens
34:02as defense
34:03exhibit K.
34:06Sir,
34:06this lens
34:07was found
34:08at the scene
34:08of the crime
34:09several days
34:11after the
34:11murder.
34:12Do you
34:13recognize it?
34:15That would
34:16be impossible.
34:18Yes,
34:18I suppose
34:19it would.
34:22Except
34:23your fingerprint
34:24was found
34:25smack dab
34:26in the middle
34:26of it.
34:28Possibly
34:28you can
34:29explain
34:30how you
34:30lost it
34:31at the scene
34:31of the crime.
34:33I don't
34:34recall.
34:35Let me
34:35help.
34:37Were you
34:38at Mark
34:39Sloan's
34:40house on
34:40the night
34:41of the murder?
34:44I refuse
34:45to answer
34:45on the grounds
34:46that might
34:46incriminate
34:47me.
34:49Well,
34:49let me
34:50put it
34:51differently,
34:52sir.
34:53Did you
34:54see the
34:54victim,
34:56Mickey
34:56humming,
34:57on the
34:57night he
34:57died?
34:58I refuse
34:59to answer
35:00on the
35:00grounds
35:00it might
35:01incriminate
35:01me.
35:02Why is he
35:03taking the
35:03fit?
35:03It makes
35:04him look
35:04guilty.
35:05Did you
35:05see Jill
35:06humming
35:07on the
35:07night her
35:08husband died?
35:10I refuse
35:11to answer
35:12on the
35:12grounds
35:13it might
35:13incriminate
35:14me.
35:14I don't
35:16understand
35:16why he's
35:17doing
35:17this.
35:18Possibly
35:19you can
35:19answer
35:19this
35:19question.
35:20It's
35:21simple
35:22enough.
35:24Where
35:24were you
35:25on the
35:26night
35:26Mickey
35:26Hoffing
35:27died?
35:28I
35:28refuse
35:29to answer
35:30on the
35:31grounds
35:31it might
35:32incriminate
35:32me.
35:37Thank
35:37you,
35:38Dr.
35:38Ward.
35:39No more
35:39questions.
35:41Apparently
35:42he doesn't
35:42care if
35:43he looks
35:43guilty.
35:44he probably
35:45figures that
35:46once Jill
35:47is tried
35:48for Mickey's
35:49murder it
35:50would be
35:51nearly impossible
35:51to convict
35:52anyone else
35:53of the same
35:53crime.
35:54Yeah, but the
35:55least he
35:55could do
35:56is lie
35:56and make
35:56himself look
35:57better.
35:58Well, he
35:58has to make
35:58sure he
35:59doesn't perjure
36:00himself.
36:01That's an
36:01incredibly
36:02dangerous game
36:02he's playing.
36:04I call
36:05Jill
36:06Hobbing to
36:06the stand.
36:11Mrs.
36:11Hobbing,
36:12please tell
36:15the court
36:15what happened
36:16the night
36:17your husband
36:17died.
36:19First, I
36:20would like
36:21to apologize
36:22to you
36:24and the
36:24court.
36:27I lied.
36:29I've caused
36:30a lot of
36:30trouble and
36:31confusion,
36:32and for that
36:33I'm sorry.
36:34I'm sorry.
36:34Please, tell
36:39us the
36:40truth.
36:42When I
36:43got to
36:43Dr. Sloan's
36:44that night,
36:46Mickey was
36:46in a rage.
36:48I'd never
36:48seen him
36:49like that.
36:50He was
36:51so angry
36:51he could
36:52barely speak.
36:53Why was
36:54he so
36:54angry?
36:56He had
36:57discovered
36:57that Donald
36:59Ward and I
37:00were having
37:01an affair.
37:02And what
37:03did he do?
37:04he hit
37:06me and
37:07kicked me.
37:09And when I
37:09tried to
37:10run away,
37:10he dragged
37:11me back
37:11and he
37:12beat me
37:12some more.
37:14So,
37:15you're saying
37:16your cuts
37:17and bruises
37:18were caused
37:18by your
37:19husband beating
37:20you?
37:21Yes,
37:21that's right.
37:23What happened
37:24then?
37:24I ran away
37:26and he
37:31went to the
37:32bedroom and
37:33I slipped
37:33out the
37:34deck door
37:34and ran
37:36down the
37:36beach.
37:38I didn't
37:39know where
37:39else to go
37:40so I went
37:42to Donald's.
37:44I was
37:45frantic and
37:46scared and
37:47he lived
37:48pretty close.
37:49I shouldn't
37:51have gone
37:51there,
37:51I know.
37:54Maybe I
37:55even knew
37:55what would
37:55happen.
37:58Maybe I
37:58wanted it
37:59to happen.
38:02He went
38:02nuts the
38:04moment he
38:04saw me.
38:06He told me
38:06to stay at
38:07his place
38:07while he
38:08went to
38:09see Mickey
38:09and I
38:10tried to
38:11stop him.
38:11I begged
38:12him not
38:12to go
38:12but he
38:15wouldn't
38:15listen.
38:16I waited.
38:21I waited
38:22and waited.
38:24Must have
38:25been a
38:25couple of
38:26hours and
38:26he still
38:26didn't come
38:27back.
38:31And I
38:32was scared
38:33to go back
38:34to Dr.
38:35Sloan's
38:35house because
38:37I knew.
38:38I knew
38:39what had
38:40happened.
38:42Donald had
38:42said it so
38:43many times
38:44so when I
38:46went back
38:47and he
38:47was dead
38:48I knew
38:55that Donald
38:55had killed
38:56him and
38:59he did
38:59it for
39:00me so I
39:03had to
39:03protect him.
39:05So I
39:06broke the
39:07front door
39:08and I
39:08made it
39:08look like
39:09the house
39:09had been
39:09robbed.
39:14I know
39:15I know
39:17what I
39:17did was
39:18wrong
39:18but I
39:21did it
39:22because
39:22I
39:25left
39:25Donald
39:26and I
39:29didn't know
39:29what else
39:30to do.
39:34I'm
39:35sorry.
39:41I'm
39:42sorry
39:42Donald.
39:42I
40:01don't
40:01believe
40:01it.
40:02I
40:03would
40:03have
40:03bet
40:03the
40:03house
40:03still
40:04killed
40:04their
40:04husband.
40:05Excuse
40:05me,
40:06it's not
40:06your house
40:06to bet.
40:07It's a
40:08good thing.
40:10The
40:10problem
40:10is we're
40:10going to
40:11have to
40:11have an
40:11ironclad
40:12case
40:12against
40:13Donald.
40:14The
40:14DA says
40:14he's
40:15not
40:15going to
40:15charge
40:15Donald
40:16for it.
40:16Evidence
40:17is too
40:17thin.
40:17He doesn't
40:18think he
40:18can get
40:18a
40:18conviction.
40:19You
40:19done?
40:20Yeah.
40:21You
40:21don't
40:21eat
40:21that?
40:22No.
40:24Can't
40:25let him
40:25get away
40:25with murder.
40:28Listen,
40:28you think
40:29we could
40:29dig up
40:29the name
40:30of
40:30Donald's
40:30optometrist?
40:33It
40:33should
40:34be here
40:34in the
40:35recycle bin.
40:36Bob!
40:36Let's
40:38try
40:39looking
40:39on the
40:39hard
40:39drive.
40:41Yeah,
40:41I can
40:42go to
40:42DOS.
40:42Look,
40:43you don't
40:43have to
40:44do that.
40:44Just let
40:45me try.
40:46Son,
40:47sit over
40:48there.
40:51I'm
40:51sorry to
40:52bring in
40:52on a
40:52Saturday,
40:53but I
40:53had to
40:53see if
40:53there was
40:54any more
40:54letters
40:54and what
40:55the
40:55dates
40:55were.
40:56Could
40:56be
40:57there.
40:59Look,
40:59just find
41:00the utility
41:00that he's
41:01using.
41:02Type in
41:02undelete.
41:03Replace
41:04the question
41:04mark with
41:04the first
41:05letter of
41:05the file
41:05you're
41:06looking
41:06for?
41:08You're
41:08bothering
41:09me.
41:09Look,
41:10we're
41:11supposed to
41:11be going
41:11to the
41:12Kings game
41:12this
41:12afternoon.
41:14There's
41:14only one
41:14way we're
41:15going to
41:15get there.
41:16You guys
41:16have to
41:17let me
41:17do this.
41:18All
41:19right.
41:20Go
41:20ahead.
41:26Sloan
41:26here.
41:27I'm a
41:28Donald
41:28Ward's
41:28optometrist
41:29office.
41:30Do you
41:30find anything
41:30interesting?
41:31More
41:32than I
41:32ever
41:32hoped
41:32for.
41:35You're
41:35quite
41:35an
41:36actress.
41:37I
41:37apologized
41:38for lying
41:39about the
41:40robbery.
41:40No,
41:41that's not
41:41what I
41:41meant.
41:42I was
41:42talking about
41:43your performance
41:43in court.
41:44No,
41:45now,
41:45wait a minute.
41:46She made a fool
41:47out of you
41:47just like she
41:48did the rest
41:48of us.
41:49Donald
41:50Ward
41:50didn't kill
41:51Mickey.
41:52You and
41:52Donald set
41:53that up
41:53to keep
41:54you from
41:54being
41:54convicted.
41:55Wait
41:56a minute.
41:57You guys
41:57found the
41:58evidence
41:58against
41:59Donald
41:59Ward.
42:00Yeah,
42:00let's
42:00take a look
42:01at that.
42:01The
42:02contact
42:02lens we
42:03found was
42:04the wrong
42:04lens.
42:05It was
42:05the left
42:06one.
42:07Donald
42:07lost the
42:08right one
42:08at the
42:08time of
42:09the murder.
42:10He must
42:10have planted
42:11the left
42:11one when
42:11he visited
42:12our house
42:13a couple
42:13of days
42:13ago.
42:16So,
42:17now you're
42:18saying that
42:19he deliberately
42:20made himself
42:21look like a
42:22suspect?
42:22Then there's
42:23the email.
42:25All the
42:25letters were
42:26dated before
42:26the murder.
42:28It's easy
42:28to do
42:28on a
42:29computer.
42:30But then
42:31a 14
42:32year old
42:32boy told
42:33me to
42:33go back
42:33to the
42:34central
42:35email
42:36server.
42:37See,
42:38there you
42:38can't
42:38change
42:38the dates.
42:40It turns
42:40out that
42:41the letters
42:41were actually
42:41sent after
42:42Mickey was
42:43already
42:43dead.
42:45You and
42:45Donald
42:45made it
42:46look like
42:46he killed
42:47Mickey to
42:47create
42:48reasonable
42:48doubt.
42:49Brilliant.
42:51And arrogant
42:51beyond belief.
42:54Doesn't
42:55this fall
42:55under the
42:56category of
42:57too little,
42:57too late?
42:58You killed
43:00Mickey.
43:01Prove it.
43:03It's over,
43:03Dr. Sun.
43:04Get over it.
43:05Donald's
43:05testified.
43:06He's told
43:07his side of
43:07the story.
43:08He's not
43:08going to
43:09change it.
43:10How are
43:10you going
43:11to convict
43:11me?
43:13Tell me.
43:14How?
43:17I hate
43:18to tell you
43:18this, but
43:19she's probably
43:20right.
43:21Look at it
43:21this way.
43:22In a couple
43:23of weeks,
43:23I'll be in
43:24Rio, and
43:25you'll never
43:25have to think
43:26about me
43:26again.
43:28Well,
43:35that went
43:35nowhere.
43:38You know,
43:38this is an old
43:38fisherman's saying,
43:39different lures
43:40for different
43:40fish.
43:42I got a couple
43:43of good ones
43:43left on my
43:44tackle box.
43:46That's good,
43:47Dad.
43:47That's, uh,
43:48really good.
43:49you set us
43:55up with the
43:55lens in the
43:56email.
43:57Want to make
43:58sure Jill
43:58wasn't
43:59convicted.
44:00You cop to
44:01it now,
44:01maybe we
44:01can get you
44:02a deal.
44:02Cop to
44:03what?
44:03If I committed
44:04a crime?
44:04You're an
44:05accessory after
44:05the fact.
44:07Accessory to
44:07whom?
44:08How can I be
44:08an accessory to
44:09murder if
44:09Jill is found
44:09innocent?
44:10And if the
44:11district attorney
44:11calls you as a
44:12rebuttal witness?
44:13I stick with my
44:14story.
44:15No matter what?
44:16No matter what.
44:18Why would you take a
44:19risk like that for
44:20girl like Jill?
44:21I love her.
44:23Oh, Donald,
44:24she's 25 years
44:26old.
44:26What exactly is the
44:27point here?
44:28Well, I just
44:28wonder what a girl
44:29like that's doing
44:30with someone like
44:30you.
44:31She loves me.
44:32Did that ever
44:32occur to you?
44:33Oh, yeah.
44:34Yeah, it did.
44:35So, uh, why
44:36aren't you going
44:37to Rio with her?
44:39I have a practice
44:40here.
44:40I have to be here.
44:42The only reason,
44:43huh?
44:43Yes, of course.
44:46Donald, I'm
44:46sorry.
44:46That's not what I
44:47heard.
44:48I heard that she
44:49was going to Rio
44:49with Jesse
44:50Travis.
44:53Mark, this is
44:55beneath you.
44:57No, really, he's
44:57a friend of mine.
44:58You told me it was
44:59going to take a
44:59couple of weeks
45:00off from the
45:01hospital and then
45:01we're going to
45:02leave right after
45:02the trial.
45:04Let me rephrase
45:05this.
45:06It's pathetic.
45:08You don't believe
45:09me?
45:09No, I don't.
45:11Look, the phone's
45:11right there.
45:12Why don't you
45:12call up the
45:13travel agent and
45:13see if there's a
45:14ticket in Jesse's
45:15name?
45:15Well, I'm sure
45:16that you arranged
45:16that, too.
45:17You know, let me
45:17tell you something,
45:18guys.
45:20I don't
45:21appreciate you
45:21setting me up
45:22like this.
45:24This conversation
45:25is over.
45:26Jill, it's
45:41Donald.
45:44Jill?
45:44What do you want
45:46me to do?
45:49Jill?
45:49Uh, just a
45:51minute.
45:52He'll freak if
45:53he's easy.
45:58Jill?
45:59Coming.
46:02Sorry, I was
46:03getting dressed.
46:06You didn't call.
46:09Yeah, well, I
46:10heard this ridiculous
46:11story today about
46:13you and Jesse
46:14going to Rio.
46:16Donald, I told
46:17you there's nothing
46:18going on between
46:19Jesse and me.
46:20We're just
46:20friends.
46:21That's all.
46:21I swear.
46:24Oh, you're
46:25upset.
46:26That's why he
46:27came over.
46:29Yeah, well, you
46:30know, the idea
46:32that you were
46:34somebody else is
46:35a little difficult.
46:37Who told you?
46:39Mark Sloan.
46:41And you
46:42believed him?
46:43It's a lie.
46:45A set-up.
46:46He's trying to
46:47split us apart.
46:52I love you.
46:54And I'd like to
46:55spend the next
46:56couple of hours
46:56with you, but
46:57I have to be with
46:58my lawyers in
46:5820 minutes.
47:03So, let him
47:06wait.
47:07what is this?
47:18Oh, I, uh, I
47:20hit my head.
47:22You are
47:22beneath
47:23contempt.
47:24Look, I can
47:24explain.
47:25Let go of me!
47:26Stop!
47:27Don't you see
47:27that?
47:28They wanted you
47:28to find Jesse
47:29here.
47:30Look, you can't
47:31go.
47:31You gotta believe
47:32me.
47:32Why should I
47:32believe you?
47:33You cheated on
47:34your husband.
47:34You cheated on
47:35me.
47:36This is
47:37who you are,
47:38Jill.
47:38You cheated on
47:40me.
47:40You cheated on
47:41me.
47:41You cheated on
47:42me.
47:42You cheated on
47:43me.
47:43You cheated on
47:43me.
47:43You cheated on
47:44me.
47:44You cheated on
47:45me.
47:45You cheated on
47:46me.
47:46You cheated on
47:47me.
47:47You cheated on
47:48me.
47:48You cheated on
47:49me.
47:49You cheated on
47:50me.
47:50You cheated on
47:51me.
47:51You cheated on
47:52me.
47:52You cheated on
47:53me.
47:53You cheated on
47:54me.
47:55You cheated on
47:56me.
47:57You cheated on
47:57me.
47:57You cheated on
47:58me.
47:59You cheated on
48:00Don has been granted immunity.
48:14He's going to testify as a rebuttal witness, so you might think about changing your plea.
48:30Mr. Lane, you may call your rebuttal witness, Your Honor.
48:39Your Honor, at this time, my client would like to change your plea.
48:46Let the record show the defendant is changing your plea.
48:50What was that thing you said?
48:53If you want to catch a fish, you have to think like a fish.
49:00Don't gloat.
49:08Well, what?
49:09Well, you're going to gloat when I tell you this.
49:12No, I won't. I won't gloat a promise. What is it?
49:16Well, you know that student position we had to fill in?
49:20Yeah.
49:21Well, our first choice, Mrs. Gillespie, turned us down.
49:25She decided to go to Harvard.
49:26You see? You're gloating.
49:31No, I'm not. I'm not gloating.
49:33No, I'm not.
49:33Where?
49:34Where's the gloat?
49:35Where's the gloat here?
49:40Oh, excuse me.
49:41A minute, will you?
49:42A minute, will you go to Harvard, Harvard, Harvard, Harvard, Harvard, Harvard, Harvard, Harvard, Harvard, Harvard, Harvard, Harvard, Harvard, Harvard, Harvard, Harvard, Harvard, Harvard, Harvard, Harvard, Harvard, Harvard, Harvard, Harvard, Harvard, Harvard, Harvard, Harvard, Harvard, Harvard, Harvard, Harvard, Harvard, Harvard, Harvard, Harvard, Harvard, Harvard, Harvard, Harvard, Harvard, Harvard, Harvard, Harvard, Harvard, Harvard, Harvard, Harvard, Harvard, Harvard, Harvard, Harvard, Harvard, Harvard, Harvard, Harvard, Harvard, Harvard, Harvard, Harvard, Harvard, Harvard, Harvard, Harvard, Harvard, Harvard, Harvard, Harvard, Harvard, Harvard, Harvard, Harvard, Harvard, Harvard, Harvard, Harvard, Harvard, Harvard, Harvard, Harvard, Harvard, Harvard, Harvard, Harvard, Harvard, Harvard, Harvard, Harvard, Harvard, Harvard, Harvard, Harvard, Harvard, Harvard, Harvard, Harvard, Harvard, Harvard, Harvard, Harvard, Harvard, Harvard, Harvard, Harvard, Harvard, Harvard, Harvard,