During Tuesday's House Ways and Means Committee hearing, Rep. Darin LaHood (R-IL) asked witnesses about strategies for mitigating TANF fraud.
Fuel your success with Forbes. Gain unlimited access to premium journalism, including breaking news, groundbreaking in-depth reported stories, daily digests and more. Plus, members get a front-row seat at members-only events with leading thinkers and doers, access to premium video that can help you get ahead, an ad-light experience, early access to select products including NFT drops and more:
Stay Connected Forbes on Facebook: http://fb.com/forbes Forbes Video on Twitter: http://www.twitter.com/forbes Forbes Video on Instagram: http://instagram.com/forbes More From Forbes: http://forbes.com
00:00Thank you, Ms. Summerlott. I want to thank all of our witnesses today for your valuable testimony on this important hearing.
00:07I especially want to thank GAO for their thorough work to dig into some of the concerns raised by the subcommittee.
00:13And now we'll proceed to question and answer session by the members of the subcommittee.
00:18And I'll begin by recognizing myself.
00:20Mr. Arkin, you mentioned in your testimony that GAO found that states are not reporting complete information about TANF expenditures.
00:30And most states lacked transparent reporting on subgrantees.
00:34For example, in your testimony, you said seven out of 31 states did not provide or had incomplete narrative explanations of non-assisted spending for FY 2022.
00:44This is extremely concerning because otherwise it's like a black box that we don't know how much behind what categories a state spends in.
00:54So my question is, your report provides recommendations for HHS, but are there any legislative recommendations you would make to improve transparency of state non-assistance spending so we can know the impact of the dollars and where they're actually being spent at?
01:14Thank you for the question, Mr. Chairman.
01:17Short answer, yes, we do.
01:19And the issue is most of the reporting requirements in the law apply to assistance spending and actually prohibit HHS from collecting information on non-assistance spending because it's not a specific statutory authority provided in the law.
01:33So we think information that allows HHS to ask states to discuss what are they planning to do in the non-assistance area and to whom are they going to provide the funds?
01:45You mentioned the subrecipient issue.
01:48That's something that would help not just with oversight of spending, but also potentially help HHS provide an estimate of improper payments.
01:57It's really key information for them to be able to do that.
02:00Thank you for that, Mr. Arkin.
02:01I'll next turn to Ms. Lahren.
02:03Our subcommittee has spent a significant amount of time looking at federal child welfare spending.
02:08Last year, Ranking Member Davis and I worked to pass a bill to reauthorize the Title 4B Child Welfare Program.
02:14One of the things we focused on was having in place the right data and performance reporting so we can see the quality of services and impact on families.
02:25According to GAO's recent report, TANF now constitutes approximately one-fourth of total federal child welfare spending, eclipsing state funding through the Title 4B program.
02:36To you, Ms. Lahren, do you have data about the specific demographics of the children in foster care funded by TANF as we do in the Title 4B program?
02:50You know, states are collecting data on the demographics of all the children they serve in their child welfare programs.
02:57So, at the state level, that data does exist.
03:01But going back to one of the main findings of our report, data on non-assistance TANF funding, there are no federal reporting requirements.
03:10So, even if that information is available at the state level, it's not being reported either to the state TANF agency or to HHS.
03:19So, no, the answer is, you know, at the state level, they may be able to disaggregate which children are being served by TANF versus 4E or 4B.
03:31But that information is not reported up in a way that makes it easily accessible.
03:36And do you have a recommendation on either a statutory change on fixing that reporting requirement?
03:42Yeah, this really goes back to the recommendation that we made to Congress to give HHS more oversight authority, which would include more robust reporting requirements for non-assistance spending.
03:57Thank you for that.
03:58Mr. Dalkin, I'll turn to you.
03:59In your testimony, you said GAO found nearly one-third of TANF-ODA findings were characterized as material weaknesses.
04:07The most severe category of findings that was made.
04:11As you know, one of the longstanding recommendations made by GAO is to measure and report improper payments in the TANF program.
04:19Would applying improper payments reporting to TANF help address or minimize these repeated audit findings?
04:26And how are these two related?
04:32Thank you for your question.
04:33I believe it would be a little of each because a material weakness could have a financial implication or it could be related to controls.
04:43Improper payments relate more to the dollars.
04:47And so for the portion of the TANF issues that are material weaknesses related to dollars, that could be subject to the improper payments analysis.
04:58For the other portion that relate to the lack of internal controls, it wouldn't fall under the improper payments.
05:07Mr. Bagdoyan, in your testimony, you stated that HHS's fraud risk assessment portal does not have the functionality to assess and determine the magnitude of each fraud risk facing TANF.
05:19From your perspective, what are the key components to efficient fraud risk management, particularly as it relates to putting in place the right processes and technology?
05:28Okay.
05:29Thank you for your question, Mr. Chairman.
05:32The fundamentals are captured in this document, which is GAO's fraud risk framework.
05:37It's been around for 10 years or so.
05:39So, this is what we benchmark, fraud risk management at agencies, and it includes fraud risk assessments, defining the likelihood and the impact of these risks.
05:52So, it begins with an entity that takes the lead in conducting fraud risk management, doing fraud risk assessments, crafting a strategy and implementing that,
06:05and then measuring back to see how effective that strategy has been and making adjustments.
06:12But a fraud risk assessment that gets at what you mentioned is at the core, and technology, such as deep data analytics, can help get an agency to that point.
Be the first to comment