What is going on in the Supreme Court? - Court Reporter Hasnaat Malik Reveals Insiders - video Dailymotion

ARY NEWS

Watch What is going on in the Supreme Court? - Court Reporter Hasnaat Malik Reveals Insiders - ARY NEWS on Dailymotion

Transcript

00:00Muneer Malik sahib, you are seeing letters and letters, judges are writing letters against each other.

00:06We are sitting outside and watching what is happening in the Supreme Court.

00:10One judge writes a letter and says, the first senior judge, why don't you talk about legality?

00:16The second judge writes an answer, there is no question of legality in that,

00:21but the opposing judge says that they are lazy, they don't come, they finish at 11 o'clock, they go on leave.

00:27What is happening, sir?

00:30This is unfortunate, but if a judge recuses himself from a bench, then there is nothing wrong with that.

00:43Sir, but he didn't recuse himself technically.

00:46You tell me, what is the irony position of this?

00:50Look, if we go back in time, do you remember the murder trial of Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto in the past?

00:58Yes, yes.

01:00In that, Justice Waheeduddin sahib wrote a letter to the Supreme Court,

01:06that I am ill, for a while, this case should be postponed.

01:16Okay.

01:17That case was not postponed.

01:20Okay.

01:22The Supreme Court went on.

01:25Okay.

01:26Sir, but on the intention of each other…

01:29Just tell me a little about your viewpoint.

01:33Yes, sir.

01:36That case went on.

01:38Okay.

01:39And a decision came in it.

01:43That was during the middle of the hearing.

01:49So, that is not the viewpoint of the new case.

01:55Okay?

01:56Okay, sir.

01:57At this time, Respected Justice Muneeb Akhtar did not even recuse himself,

02:08and is also a part of the bench.

02:15He is so learned that he will be able to state this contradiction himself.

02:24A small legislator like me cannot state this.

02:32Sir, we are waiting for him.

02:33But my question, sir, is a big one.

02:35But there cannot be a single paralysis of the Supreme Court.

02:40There cannot be a paralysis.

02:41The Supreme Court cannot stop working.

02:43What I have read, he says,

02:45the Supreme Court shall consist of the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court,

02:53and such other judges as may be appointed under law.

03:00This is my understanding, right?

03:03Absolutely, sir.

03:04But listen to my question, sir.

03:06It also says that the committee has been formed for nine months.

03:09The CRP, which you suddenly had to put on the committee agenda in the 17th meeting,

03:16the 18th, 7th, and 24th,

03:19you put this on the committee agenda for the first time.

03:23And when there was no bench, you said that the senior judge will lead it.

03:28Now, you have assumed the command of this case.

03:32This is a case of 63A, which will have a big impact in the coming politics,

03:37for reasons that are unknown.

03:39Now, there are not direct accusations against each other, but indirectly.

03:45You realize that?

04:10That is also a political act.

04:13Okay?

04:14Okay?

04:45Now, this is another thing, right?

04:47Which breakfast tastes better?

04:53There are two kinds of views in that.

04:56One is this view, which people say,

05:00that what is written on the breakfast menu,

05:05it says, dal, chana, and chaar.

05:09Okay?

05:10Okay, sir.

05:12One will say, dal and chana should be there.

05:16The other person will say,

05:19onions are also there with chana.

05:23This is another point of view.

05:26Okay?

05:27Okay.

05:28So, this is a legal debate.

05:33Sir, this is a legal debate, but it has become a personal debate.

05:37At the end of the day,

05:41the decision of the Supreme Court,

05:44I am always very fond of Justice Jackson.

05:48Okay.

05:49It is not that we are right because we are final.

05:58It is because we are final, that's why we are right.

06:01We are final.

06:03Look, there is no such decision, Mr. Abbasi.

06:10You are so senior.

06:12Sir, there is no such thing as a decision.

06:14The real problem in this is that

06:15these people are beating each other up in politics.

06:17One says, you don't come on time, you take leave.

06:19The other says, you…

06:21Who says that?

06:22You don't remember the 9th,

06:23now suddenly you remember that you have to make a bench.

06:25Who says that?

06:26Who says that?

06:27Who can say that

06:31that a judicial decision does not have political undertones?

06:38This is something that lives in the imaginary world.

06:42Sir, you are saying that there are political undertones.

06:44Sir, thank you very much.

06:45Actually, this is what I wanted to ask.

06:47He is saying that there are political undertones.

06:49Hasnath is present with me.

06:50Hasnath, what is happening in your Supreme Court?

06:54Look, Mr. Raghupat Hassan is also ready

06:56to tell Hasnath the inside story.

06:58Yes, of course, of course.

07:02The news is coming out.

07:05And you have seen the situation.

07:08And at the moment, it is very clear

07:11that there is a difference between the Supreme Court

07:15and the other side.

07:17And today, if you look at it,

07:19the question that Justice Muneeb Akhtar raised,

07:23the question that Justice Mansoor Ali Shah raised in the letter

07:27that the Supreme Court is being held through Alimax,

07:29you did not answer it.

07:31Secondly, on July 18,

07:34which was proposed by the bank after the decision of the special parties,

07:38that was different.

07:40And now that you have changed it,

07:42and you are representing the bank yourself,

07:43tell us the reason.

07:44You changed the bank without reason.

07:46So these were the things that needed to be told.

07:50And secondly, we will request Justice Muneeb Akhtar again.

07:53It has become very unusual that if a judge is not available,

07:56then the charge is that he was in the bank and the seat was vacant.

08:00And he, I did not think that he would be able to...

08:04But Hasnath, has the fight intensified?

08:08Yes, of course.

08:09Has it become more heated,

08:10as Mr. Chand says, has it become heated, Mukhtariya?

08:14The point is that Justice Muneeb Akhtar has written another letter

08:18in which he has raised further questions.

08:21But now these things are not going to stop at the letter.

08:24Chief Justice Rani Faisal,

08:26it is evident that he has only one claim,

08:28that it seems that the judicial package somehow reached the completion,

08:32and there is no movement from the Supreme Court.

08:34If he has five seats in the Supreme Court,

08:37and it seems that the Supreme Court has 144 seats.

What is going on in the Supreme Court? - Court Reporter Hasnaat Malik Reveals Insiders

Category

Transcript

Be the first to comment

Recommended