Skip to playerSkip to main contentSkip to footer
  • 8/26/2024
How can many stupid things combine to form smart things? How can proteins become living cells? How become lots of ants a colony? What is emergence?
Transcript
00:00An ant is pretty stupid. It doesn't have much of a brain, no will, no plan.
00:06And yet, many ants together are smart.
00:10An ant colony can construct complex structures.
00:14Some colonies keep farms of fungi, others take care of cattle.
00:19They can wage war or defend themselves.
00:22How is this possible? How can a bunch of stupid things do smart things together?
00:28This phenomenon is called emergence, and it's one of the most fascinating and mysterious features of our universe.
00:36In a nutshell, it describes small things forming bigger things that have different properties than the sum of their parts.
00:44Emergence is complexity arising from simplicity.
00:48And emergence is everywhere.
00:51Water has vastly different properties to the molecules that make it up, like the concept of wetness.
00:57Take wet fabric. If you zoom in far enough, there is no wetness.
01:02There are just molecules sitting in the spaces between the atoms of the cloth.
01:06Wetness is an emerging property of water.
01:09Something new, only created by a lot of individual interactions between water molecules.
01:15And this is sort of it.
01:17Many things interact under a certain set of rules, creating something above and beyond themselves.
01:23It turns out that more is different.
01:26This different property is itself a new thing, and that new thing can couple with other new things to repeat the process.
01:34You can imagine this as layers stacked upon each other, every layer made from more complex parts.
01:40Atoms form molecules.
01:42Molecules form proteins.
01:44Proteins make up cells.
01:46Cells make up organs.
01:48Organs form individuals.
01:50Individuals form societies.
01:53But how can something be more than the sum of its parts?
01:56How do ants form the sort of cloudy entity that is a colony?
02:00By following a rule set that produces order through chaos.
02:04For example, let's look at how an ant colony distributes jobs.
02:08Let's assume that a colony should have 25% workers, 25% caretakers, 25% soldiers, and 25% gatherers.
02:17Ants communicate their current job via chemicals.
02:20For example, a worker ant constantly secretes chemicals that say,
02:24I'm a worker.
02:26When ants meet other ants, they smell each other to gather information, telling each other their job and what they're doing.
02:32Both keep track of who they met in the past.
02:35Now, imagine an anteater kills most of the gatherers.
02:39If this isn't fixed quickly, the colony will starve.
02:43Many worker ants need to switch jobs, but how do you tell this to thousands of them?
02:48Simple. You don't.
02:51Our worker ant will still meet and smell other ants, but it will encounter almost no gatherers at all.
02:57It counts too few gatherers until it reaches a critical point, and then it changes its job.
03:04The worker becomes a gatherer.
03:06Other ants will do the same until, after a while, there are enough gatherers again.
03:11The balance is restored all by itself.
03:14The actions and interactions of an individual are random.
03:18You can't plan which ant will encounter which other ant,
03:21but the simple set of rules is so elegant that a colony's many operations emerge as a consequence.
03:28On an even more fundamental level,
03:30hundreds of millions of complicated molecules interact to maintain a robust and amazing structure,
03:36a being with vastly different properties than the sum of its dead parts emerges.
03:41The smallest unit of life, a cell.
03:44We still don't have a clear definition of what living things are,
03:47we just know they emerge from things that are not alive.
03:51Cells combine and cooperate, they specialize and respond to one another,
03:56and over time, we develop into complex organisms with remarkable capacities.
04:01Your arms and legs and heart are an incredibly complex and complicated system
04:07made of trillions of individual stupid things.
04:10And yet we breathe, digest, and watch YouTube videos.
04:15How do your cells know what to do?
04:18Think of the pacemaker cells in your heart.
04:21Billions of them need to send out an impulse just at the right moment to collectively create a heartbeat.
04:28Our cells exchange chemical information with their neighbor cells
04:31to see what they're up to and then decide what to do.
04:35If it's among a lot of cells that are working on the same task,
04:38it will start working on that task as well and sync up with them.
04:42There is no mastermind giving commands,
04:45just single units communicating with their neighbors and acting according to the feedback they get.
04:51What about our most important part?
04:53What is the thing that asks these kinds of questions?
04:58Is our consciousness then an emergent property of the cells in our brain?
05:03This question is too big and important.
05:06It deserves a video of its own.
05:09Some things that emerge are hard to define.
05:12You can't touch an ant colony, only its parts.
05:15It has neither brain nor face nor body.
05:19And yet the colony interacts with the world.
05:22Just like colonies emerge from ants, things emerge from humans like nations.
05:29What actually is a nation?
05:31Is it its population? Is it its institutions?
05:34Its symbols like its flag, colors or anthems?
05:38The physical things it makes like cities?
05:41The territory it occupies?
05:43All of these things are fluid.
05:46Populations change and are replaced.
05:48Institutions come and go.
05:50Cities can be constructed and abandoned.
05:53Borders have changed all the time for most of history.
05:56And symbols get replaced by new symbols.
06:00A nation has no face, no brain, no body.
06:05Are nations not real then?
06:07Of course they are.
06:08Just like ant colonies, nations interact with the world.
06:12They can change landscapes, wage wars, grow or decline, and they can stop existing.
06:18But they only exist because of a lot of humans interacting with each other.
06:23But not just nations.
06:25All the complex structures that surround us emerge from us.
06:29Even if we don't intend to, we are constantly creating.
06:33Communities.
06:34Companies.
06:36Cities.
06:37Societies.
06:38All of these things are entities that have fundamentally different properties and abilities than the pretty stupid apes they emerged from.
06:46We don't know why any of this happens.
06:49We just observe it and it seems to be a fundamental property of our universe.
06:54It may be the most beautiful and wondrous property of our universe.

Recommended