00:00 Hello and welcome to NDTV Profit.
00:04 The interim budget has set a vision to become India to become a developed country.
00:11 Now staying on this path is going to be critical as we get along the most important question
00:17 that keeps coming for a country like India which is resilient in terms of its economy,
00:23 there is political stability and the fastest growing economy.
00:26 The question that arises is will international rating, global rating agencies upgrade India's
00:34 rating.
00:35 Now that's the big question we are asking today evening after the interim budget has
00:40 set a very clear path of fiscal consolidation.
00:43 Now who better to answer this than Christian de Guzman, Senior Vice President Sovereign
00:50 Risk Group at Moody's Investor Services.
00:54 Thanks for joining us Christian, welcome to NDTV Profit.
00:57 Thanks for having me Murali.
00:59 So my first question is loaded in my intro itself, when will India get its upgrade?
01:07 Well I think I'd like to answer that question by referring to our published downward triggers.
01:12 So we do have ratings, we do express to the market what it would take for us to upgrade
01:18 or change the outlook to positive or to downgrade or change the outlook to negative.
01:23 So in that context we have publicly said that it would take very material debt reduction
01:32 on the back of material deficit consolidation and continued high growth and accompanying
01:39 that would be an improvement in what we call debt affordability.
01:43 So in essence what we are looking for is an improvement in the weak points of India's
01:49 sovereign credit profile.
01:50 You've already mentioned some of the strong points such as the very strong economic growth
01:55 for even a country this large.
01:57 We also have a few strengths that we haven't mentioned.
02:00 I think we do have a nice track record of macroeconomic stability and overall institutional
02:06 strength.
02:07 We have political stability as you mentioned.
02:10 That doesn't mean everything is well with political risk but we can get into that.
02:14 We also have a stable banking system, a recently more stable banking system.
02:19 So there's a lot of strengths but there are also weaknesses that need to be addressed
02:22 before we can consider upgrading India.
02:25 Right.
02:26 Okay.
02:27 So that's a very interesting observation.
02:29 There are many tick boxes that we can tick from the checklist.
02:34 Before I come to the most important question of the overall debt, I would like to have
02:41 your reaction on today's budget.
02:42 We have very clearly set a fiscal prudence and management path.
02:48 What is your reaction?
02:49 Well, my reaction is that in many ways this was really more of a political statement in
02:57 terms of what the budget speech represented rather than really a very detailed plan, fiscal
03:04 or economic in terms of going forward.
03:06 Indeed, one of the highlights of the budget speech is the announcement of a white paper
03:11 in essence doing a report to the populace, to the voting population of the good things
03:17 that have been done over the past 10 years.
03:21 So having said that, we do acknowledge that there is a very firm communication of that
03:28 commitment to fiscal deficit consolidation.
03:32 We do have the government basically committing again and again towards that 4.5% of GDP deficit
03:39 by 2025-2026.
03:43 In the details, I think what we have found is that that deficit consolidation is being
03:49 driven by lower spending as a share of GDP rather than increasing revenue.
03:56 So perhaps there is some risk here as shocks propagating from the challenging global environment
04:02 or maybe even climate related shocks.
04:04 I think El Nino is still a risk for the region, for example.
04:08 This could perhaps push up expenditures more than what we currently envision or what the
04:14 budget envisions.
04:17 And then perhaps on the revenue side, I mentioned debt affordability earlier.
04:22 Debt affordability, we can measure that by interest payments to revenue.
04:25 We are in a currently high interest rate environment.
04:29 And so what is perhaps needed to improve debt affordability is to increase revenue.
04:34 And we didn't quite see any significant revenue or tax measures in this interim budget.
04:39 Yeah.
04:40 So as the finance minister suggested, there are no tax measures because it's an interim
04:45 budget.
04:46 More importantly, she has set the path for a developed economy and they are going to
04:51 come out with a very clear roadmap to achieve the stage of developed economy over a period
04:58 of whatever, 10 years or so.
05:01 My next question is on the issue of risk arising from interest rates.
05:06 Now that risk is awaiting if you see, we have reached a pivot globally.
05:10 In India, inflation is also coming under control.
05:13 The RBI governor has said that in another one or one and a half years, we will be able
05:18 to achieve that inflation target.
05:20 So the interest rate risk is also waning as far as the country is concerned.
05:23 How would you look at that?
05:25 Well, it is indeed true that interest rates are waning, but they are currently high and
05:30 they have been high for the past year or so.
05:32 So which means that the debts that were incurred over the past year carry these higher interest
05:37 rates.
05:38 And, you know, we don't expect interest rates for the Fed to be cutting rates over the next
05:44 quarter at least, or, you know, we're only looking at the Fed cutting rates in the middle
05:48 of the year, for example, which means that the debts that are going to be incurred over
05:52 the next few months are also going to carry these high interest rates, including the debts
05:58 that were incurred, some of the debts that were incurred during the pandemic at very
06:03 low rates.
06:04 So you can see how those refinancing pressures at these currently high interest rates are
06:08 going to continue to apply pressure on what we call debt affordability.
06:13 But yes, I would agree over the medium term, interest rates will come down and it will
06:18 alleviate some pressure, but the pressure is still not, has not yet abated.
06:23 Okay.
06:24 So let me come back to the critical question.
06:26 You know, so we have a situation where we need to push growth.
06:31 If we push growth, expenditure has to be pushed, capex expenditure has to be pushed.
06:36 The states also are also being empowered through a scheme where the center will give them a
06:41 loan, 50 year interest free loan of 75,000 crores to be given to the state to help reach
06:50 the developed economy goal.
06:53 Now, see, this is also going to be a very important development in so far as, so that
06:59 will also help the state governments, right?
07:01 So from that perspective, how do you see our debt to GDP ratio, the combined one from the
07:07 centers and the states?
07:08 Sure.
07:09 It's a good, it's a good that you sort of bring that up because our sovereign credit
07:14 rating actually looks at not just the union budget, but what we call the general government
07:20 balance.
07:22 So that includes the union budget plus the states.
07:27 And here, I think there is perhaps less evidence of more significant fiscal consolidation,
07:33 given that the states themselves have not exhibited the same kind of fiscal discipline
07:39 that the union government has over the past couple of years.
07:43 Yes, there has been progress, but it's still a weak point relative to where we see the
07:48 union government in terms of their progress.
07:51 Now, with perhaps the other part of your question is, is it going to help?
07:56 Now here, perhaps it's not just about funding growth or funding development.
08:03 India has always had very good access to funding, whether it's tapping the deep domestic capital
08:09 markets or tapping multilateral development bank debt, you know, debt from the World Bank
08:16 or the ADB, which then comes with technical assistance to facilitate that development.
08:21 So financing is not the issue.
08:23 It's what will these states do with that funding?
08:27 Is there enough absorption capacity at the local levels to really maximize the development
08:32 impact of these funding avenues that have been made available by the union government?
08:38 Right.
08:39 So from the checklist that you mentioned, the only area where we cannot clearly take
08:47 is the combined debt of both the state and the center.
08:51 The data that I just looked at shows that the ratio has come down sharply from 88% in
09:00 2022 to about 81% in 2022-23.
09:06 Now where should that go down for India to qualify for a rating?
09:11 Does it have to go down by another 10 or 20% lower?
09:17 So let me maybe perhaps take a step back.
09:21 The weak point in our sovereign credit rating assessment of India is fiscal strength.
09:28 And fiscal strength is broadly can be encapsulated into two things, which I mentioned and which
09:35 we have been talking about.
09:36 The first, of course, is that and that is very high.
09:39 And yes, it has come down.
09:40 But I think a lot of the analysis that we do is comparative in nature.
09:46 While it has come down, it's still over 80% of GDP.
09:51 The general government debt levels are still over 80% of GDP, which is still higher than
09:56 all other BAA-rated emerging market economies.
10:00 [MUSIC PLAYING]
10:04 [MUSIC PLAYING]
10:07 (dramatic music)
10:10 [BLANK_AUDIO]