• 25 minutes ago
A heated debate occurred between BJP and Congress spokespersons over Modi's appeal to curb non-essential gold imports and its economic impact.

Category

🗞
News
Transcript
00:00So joining me this evening is National BJP Spokesperson Sanju Verma and National
00:06Congress Spokesperson Bridges Kalapa. Very good evening to both of you. I'll
00:10begin by opening the floor to this question that I have right at the
00:14beginning. Can curbing gold purchases really be placed alongside skipping a
00:20meal or does the comparison simply glide the politics of austerity? How are you
00:25looking at it? Miss Burma? Miss Burma, can you hear me? I think there's a slight
00:38glitch. I'll repeat my question for you. No problem. My question is, can curbing
00:46gold purchases really be placed alongside skipping a meal or does that
00:51comparison simply gill the politics of austerity? Okay. Am I audible to you?
00:58Yes, you're absolutely audible. Please proceed. Okay. So, Shreya, thank you for
01:03having me over. First and foremost, let's get one thing. Very clear that, you know,
01:08the Congress has the habit of engaging in halal blue and brouhaha for no given
01:13reason. I will come to the comparison with, you know, what Lal Bahadur Shastri
01:17said way back in 1965 about skipping a meal. But be that as it may, let's not
01:22forget, everybody knows that gold prices are a function of, you know, international,
01:26you know, dollar movement, rupee dollar movement, how internationally commodity
01:33prices move, and then how local prices move. It's a function of various demand and
01:38supply conditions. But, but, but, the fact of the matter is that in and around the
01:4510th of May in Sikandrabad, when Prime Minister Narendra Modi said that, please
01:49restrain and curtail gold purchases, he was not saying that blanketly stop buying
01:54gold, because, you know, gold is something which is not just buying a precious metal
01:59for many housewives, homemakers. It's an emotional connect. They think, this is a
02:07safety for the future. He said, please restrain, please curtail, please curb non-essential gold
02:16buying. And he said this at the height of the West Asia crisis, because don't forget that
02:23our annual imports are to the tune of $979 billion, out of which gold imports alone on an average
02:32are to the tune of $72 billion, which means 7.3% of our import bill is accounted for by
02:41gold imports
02:42alone. So, if the Prime Minister asks the citizenry to curb non-essential purchases, I don't understand
02:50what's the big deal, point number one. And point number two, don't forget that, you know, under the
02:57Congress. If you remember way back in 1990, 1991, when we had that huge crisis, when India was on the
03:04throes of bankruptcy, the Manmohan Singh, you know, dispensation, he was then, of course, not the
03:12Prime Minister, he was the Finance Minister. India mortgaged 47 tons of gold with the Bank of England
03:20and Bank of Japan to simply raise a measly $405 million. So, if Manmohan Singh as Finance Minister
03:30could mortgage gold, and we applauded him saying, wow, wow, you know, that austerity measure was the
03:37need of the hour in 1990, 1991. I fail to understand at the height of a black swan event, like
03:43the West
03:44Asia crisis, when supply chains were broken, when even inflation in countries like US, UK, Thailand,
03:51Malaysia, UAE, was anywhere between 27 to 39 to 64 percent. If Prime Minister Narendra Modi said,
03:58curving non-essential gold imports will help save forex reserves, will help lower the trade deficit,
04:05will help lower the current account deficit, will help lower the import bill. Why is the Congress
04:10needled? Why is the Congress instigated? Why is the Congress provoked? And I want to end by just
04:16saying one last thing. The Congress made a huge hue and cry when the rupee was depreciating.
04:23Just 27 hours back, the rupee hit a seven-month high, moving towards 92. And as you and me speak,
04:31if the current trend continues, we could go down to 88, 89. And the fact that, Sriya, between April and
04:40October, gold imports are down how much? They are down 43 percent. And in October alone,
04:47gold imports are down 67 percent. So, I think we should applaud Prime Minister Modi rather than
04:52witch hunting.
04:53Point, point, point taken. Point taken, Ms. Verma. Let me take this to Bridges Kalapa.
04:57Bridges Kalapa, please. Firstly, Mr. Kalapa, do respond to what Sanju Verma has said.
05:02And also, I'll add on this, that one thing is clear. Every time we do see an economic,
05:10you know, win for India of sorts, the Congress comes out to question it. That's fine. The opposition's
05:16duty is to question. But then, why continuously question it without evidence? I mean, gold rates
05:22have been going down in the last couple of months. And earlier, it was called a death warrant by the
05:28Congress when the Prime Minister had made this appeal. So, why consistently politicize it
05:34when, you know, perhaps the call for restraint was ultimately for the good of the country in
05:40a way that, yes, if we restrain it now, maybe later the prices come down. That's just a call
05:45that had been made by the Prime Minister. Why oppose that call? And now when the numbers are
05:50coming in, why oppose that as well? See, Shreha, see, since most of the media has become
05:59cheerleaders, it's only the opposition which can ask questions. No, sir, we have not become
06:04cheerleaders. I'm sorry, I will have to interrupt that. But we have not become cheerleaders. We
06:08are coming. I have also here, I'm just giving out facts. So, please answer the question.
06:13No, no. Let me at least start by what I want to say. Unless, if you want me to say
06:18a certain
06:18thing, you can send me a message. Not at all. Sir, please continue. Please continue. Please
06:22respond to what Sanju Verma has said and the question here. Without mentioning you, I have
06:27no problem with that. No, no. Please continue. Please continue. The point is this, that since
06:30the media have become cheerleaders, it's the Congress party alone and only the Congress party
06:35which can ask questions. Because it's the job of the Congress party which is in the opposition
06:40to ask questions. And, you know, you can't give the government a free run like the media
06:45presently is. Right? So, therefore, it is our duty, it's our onerous
06:49duty to ask questions. Now, in regard to what the BJP spokesperson just
06:54mentioned. First, she said that, you look, you know, gold prices are a direct result of
07:02international conditionalities. Right? So, obviously, Mr. Modi had nothing with bringing
07:07the prices down because the rates are fixed by the World Gold Council and that's based in
07:12London. And, you know, various international factors contribute to making the gold prices
07:19either go up or go down. It had gone to a high of 190, 1,90,000 rupees. At that
07:25time,
07:25Mr. Modi, if he had the power, like he had the power to stop the war between Ukraine and
07:31Russia to facilitate the easy movement of students, then he could have at that time itself ensured
07:38that gold prices did not go beyond 1,25,000 rupees a kilo. Sorry, 1,25,000 a kilo. Now,
07:47the point is this, that, you know, the worst thing that you can do is score a self-goal.
07:54Like my colleague from the Congress Party had earlier said, a person who changes clothes four
07:59to five times a day cannot compare himself to Lalbadur Shastri. Lalbadur Shastri was the
08:05epitome of austerity. He didn't create oligarchs. He didn't create, you know, rich men out of
08:13nothing. And then say that, look, a person who was way down the line before Modi became the chief
08:22minister then reached the 600th position in the world once Modi became the prime minister. And now
08:29that he has become the prime minister, he has become the one or second richest man in the world.
08:34So you're comparing Lalbadur Shastri, the epitome of austerity to himself. So I think this is something
08:42which is a self-goal. I think this is something which is going to hurt Modi himself in the long
08:47run
08:47as it is his popularity is declining and declining, you know, by a great deal. So therefore, I don't think
08:54he should make these, you know, very, rather ridiculous comparisons. More importantly, I think
09:01more than gold, I think there are several issues which Modi must involve himself and try to relieve
09:09people of the burden of. Why doesn't he do something with petrol and diesel? Why doesn't he do something
09:15with mustard oil, milk, rice, flour, toordal, urad dal, moong dal, masoor dal, sugar, peanut
09:22oil, soya oil, pameleen, jaggery, rajma, kabuli chana, basin, tea, and these are the essential
09:30things that will touch the, you know, lady of the house. Because all these prices have more than doubled,
09:40point noted, you have made a point and you've asked a question. Let, let, let Ms. Barma come
09:46in and respond to that. Yes, Ms. Barma, continue. You know, the discussion today is on gold and the
09:53Congress spokesperson, you know, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, I mean, this is what happens
09:58when you come on national television without doing homework on the topic of the discussion. Now,
10:04let me say one thing. He kept referring to, you know, one or two industrialists have become suddenly
10:09rich. Excuse me, I will name these industrialists. At the height of the Hindenburg, at the height of
10:14the Hindenburg controversy, I remember Rahul Gandhi saying, Hindenburg has come out with a report.
10:21State Bank of India will go bankrupt. LIC will go bankrupt. And do you know something,
10:26Sriya, your audience needs to listen to this. State Bank of India last year posted record net profit of
10:3381,000 crore, more than the entire profit posted by State Bank of India in the previous 20 years.
10:42And LIC posted a net profit of 57,000 crore. So Rahul Gandhi's narrative are,
10:49LIC banh ho jayega, FBI banh ho jayega. Rahul Gandhi has a big fat omelette on his face because he
10:54blabbers
10:55without facts. He only engages in baseless allegations and reckless rhetoric. But let me come to the mood
11:01point. The mood point is simply this. And I want your audience to listen to this because I come with
11:06prepared homework rather than just dishing out rhetoric. You will be surprised to know that
11:12an annual gold import bill is in the region of six and a half to seven and a half lakh
11:19crore,
11:19which is more than the combined GSDP, the combined GDP of these states. I have the numbers here.
11:29Sikkim, where the GSDP is around 57,000 crore, Manipur around 55,000 crore, Arunachal
11:36Pradesh around 49,000 crores, Nagaland around 45,000 crores, Mizoram around 39,000 crores,
11:42Goa around 1.39 lakh crores, Tripura around 87,000 crores, and Naghalia around 66,000 crores.
11:50I'm amazed that if we have been able to save, you know, from a pending disaster and reigning the
11:59import bill of gold, which is more than the GSDP of many smaller Indian states, why is the Congress
12:07Party so rattled? And my second point is this. Oh, blah, blah, blah. Toor dal, chana dal, rajma.
12:13Excuse me. What is the value added tax today on fuel in Karnataka? It is 39.7 percent.
12:21Why has the Congress government in Karnataka not reduced back on petrol and diesel? The spokesperson
12:27sit on national TV and give Bhashar one minute. What is the impact on fuel in Telangana? It is 38
12:34.2
12:34percent. And do you know something? Telangana today has a debt of 8.5 lakh crore,
12:41of which 3.25 lakh crore was added to the debt numbers only in the last two years under an
12:47incompetent Congress government. So Raghur Gandhi's khatta khatta model has failed completely.
12:54And the spokespersons, rather than talking about Karnataka, Telangana, chana dal, toor dal...
12:59Let me bring in Mr. Kalapa here. Mr. Kalapa, I have one question to you as well.
13:03Why is it that encouraging citizens... Why don't you have questions for the BJP spokesperson,
13:07Treyya? No, no. Why don't you have questions for the BJP spokesperson?
13:10No, no. Of course I do. Of course I do have questions. I just asked her. I just asked her
13:15about the entire point of the reference that Prime Minister Modi has made. And she herself
13:20has spoken about the fact that gold prices are... No, it seems like you are giving a free run.
13:23That's the reason I asked you. Mr. Kalapa, okay. And let me, let me finish my question to you.
13:27And then I will bring my question to Sanju Verma as well. My question to you, sir, is why is
13:33it that
13:34encouraging citizens to save money or reduce unnecessary imports are objectionable to the
13:40Congress at this point? Because... In the first place, Treyya, you see, when you claim that the
13:46economy is doing phenomenally well, and I'm not one of those braggarts, like the BJP spokesperson who likes
13:53to pat myself on the back, saying I've come prepared, and so-and-so hasn't come prepared.
13:58I think she is, you know, freshly on television, from the BJP. Earlier, she used to be in the
14:03half. So I think she has to, you know, prove her credentials to her party. I don't have to.
14:07Oh my God.
14:08Now, the point is this. One minute, madam. Don't get so excited. The point is this.
14:13Arrah, you are nobody to lecture me.
14:14Please, madam, I told you not to get excited. You are nobody to lecture me.
14:16Why do you have this habit of getting so excited?
14:19You are nobody to lecture me. Please, take it easy. You can respond to what I have said.
14:22Why does it matter? The point is this, that as far as Mr. Modi is concerned, he on November 13,
14:302016,
14:31he said, even after having announced demonetization, he said, give me 50 days, right? So this is one of
14:41those major gaffes that he has done, and he has still not been held responsible. Nobody still knows
14:47who is responsible for demonetization, who advised it, which expert in economics advised demonetization.
14:55And today, the same gentleman is trying to claim credit for an international event over
14:59which he has absolutely no control. How did he deal with COVID? What was the lockdown issue?
15:05Did he not, you know, send so many people packing across the country? Who was responsible for that? I think
15:11there has to be some occasion where he takes his huge responsibility and doesn't say that, look,
15:16success always has many fathers. Failure is an orphan. But these are failures of Modiji and he has to
15:22We are now, we are now diverting from the topic at hand, which is the gold prices right now.
15:27One minute question. Mr. Kalappa, I'll come back to you for closing comments.
15:30Mr. Kalappa, I'll come back to you for closing comments because we're completely short on time right now.
15:34So, Ms. Varma, I'll come to you for your closing comments right now as a response to what Mr. Kalappa
15:39has said.
15:40And also one thing, yes, that gold prices, you yourself started the argument with gold prices,
15:46have several factors. In fact, mostly international factors that continue to determine gold prices.
15:52International prices have come down. Indian prices have come down. On that very note,
15:57the Prime Minister coming out to make a reference to former Prime Minister Lalbhadur Shastri,
16:02as well as saying that because India has shown restraint in buying gold, that's exactly where
16:07we see the prices getting affected. That might seem a little misdirected. And that's why the entire
16:13debate, please respond to that and Mr. Kalappa, and we will go to Mr. Kalappa next. Mr. Varma, yes.
16:19First and foremost, Mr. Kalappa needs to be educated. I did not make this personal. I was in
16:26our party from January 2014 to March 2014. Barely for three months, I was not even a full-fledged
16:34primary member. For the longest time, I have only been with BJP because prior to that I was an
16:40investment banker. So, I know my math, I know my data, I know my logic. Unlike other Congress
16:46spokespersons who are laughed at within the legal fraternity because they do not even know GDP from
16:52GMP and Aadhaar card from Pankak. Ms. Varma, I only have a minute for you. Please, please,
16:56please do wrap up. Yes, please go ahead. I am not the one who made it personal by calling you,
17:02you
17:02know, you are not answering questions. Let's stick to the topic. Let's stick to the topic. Yes.
17:08So, let the illiterate Congress spokesperson listen to this. Why I said that Modi-nomics needs a pat on
17:14the back. This is not Sanju Varma saying it. IMF, World Bank, Goldman Sachs, JP Morgan,
17:19Morgan Stanley, ADB, OECD, S&P, Moody's. They were all saying India will not grow at more than 6%
17:26or 6.5%. Now, they are saying 7%. Goldman Sachs says India will grow at 7.9% in FY27.
17:34GDP growth last quarter, 7.8%. Rupee at seven-month high. Record exports of $863 billion last year.
17:41We added 72 lakh draw to market capitalization in the month of November alone. Stock markets went up by
17:4712% in the month of November alone. November has not yet ended by the way. Forex reserves $720
17:55billion, almost at a record high. GST revenue last month at 2.31 lakh crore, again at almost a new
18:02high. UPI trades at a new record of 31.53 lakh crore in October and car sales of 5 lakh
18:10plus units in
18:12October. They sold 26 lakh two-wheelers in October. So, if somebody sitting here does not acknowledge
18:18these numbers, all I can say is that in Hindi it is a claim that some of the people are
18:23going to be a
18:23good man. Right, Ms. Badma?
18:26Ms. Badma, I'll have to bring in Mr. Kalappa here for closing comments. I'll have to bring him here for
18:31closing comments. Mr. Kalappa, your closing comments, please. Proceed.
18:34Yeah, Shreya, so the point is this, that you know, these are all peripheral issues. The price of gold,
18:39not every Indian can afford to buy gold. Right? So, these are all peripheral issues. Now, if you're going
18:44to concentrate if the Prime Minister is going to speak about, you know, buying and selling gold, I think
18:49it's an absurdity. Because we are all said and done a poor country. I think he has to do something
18:54with the fact that Price, and I don't know why this lady does this. You know, she brings the video
19:00No, no, Mr. Kalappa, you continue. You continue. You continue to speak. I don't know why she does this.
19:03Ms. Badma, I've given you your time. Let Mr. Kalappa speak. Mr. Kalappa, please continue.
19:08I must tell you something. I don't want to make it personal. I must tell you something. See, as far
19:13as, as far as the
19:14BJP is concerned, every time she comes on television, the BJP loses votes with this kind
19:19of absurdities. So, please, I would request her to kindly stop this. Now, there is a rising
19:25unemployment problem, and this is causing a huge number of students to come to the streets.
19:30So, your point is basically that the BJP has to focus on other issues as well. Yes, Mr. Kalappa,
19:35thank you for making your point. We're completely out of time. So, I'll have to thank you both there.
19:39All right. Those are your closing comments. Thank you, viewers.

Recommended