• 11 minutes ago
Three presidents dominated the headlines at APEC. The bigger story may be the simmering battle over chips, data centers and AI supply chains.

Category

🗞
News
Transcript
00:00Trump, Xi and Putin walk into a conference room and no, that's not the start of a bad joke,
00:05but actually a historic meeting that just a few years ago seemed impossible. This is all happening
00:11at the APEC summit in Shenzhen, China, where 21 member countries met to discuss trade,
00:16investment and overall economic cooperation. But let's be honest, that's not what's grabbing
00:21headlines. The real story is the meetings between the presidents of China, the US and Russia. These
00:27are three leaders who are simultaneously competing, cooperating and trying to reshape the whole
00:33global economy. And now they're all sitting down at the same table. And while the images
00:38are definitely historic, will these meetings actually lead to any historic changes? Can these
00:44three men make progress on the wars, economic pressures and technological rivalries that are
00:49reshaping the world? Or is this really just a carefully staged show of strength aimed at audiences
00:57back home? Welcome to The Dip, your podcast for money, power and consequences. I'm Cassandra.
01:04To help us read between the lines and figure out what this summit and side meetings were all about,
01:09I have conveyed my own trilateral meeting today. Up first is Deborah Elms. She's the head of trade
01:15policy at the Henrik Foundation. She joins us from Singapore today. Deborah, thanks for making the time.
01:21And on the line as well, we have Zhang Yuen, Zoe Liu. She's a senior fellow for China Studies at
01:25the
01:26Council on Foreign Relations. She joins us from Colombia today. Zoe, thank you for making the
01:30time.
01:30Thank you for having me, Cassandra.
01:32You're in Colombia today, but you are actually just in Shenzhen, where the APEC Summit is taking
01:37place. What was it like?
01:38It was quite vibrant, I'd say. And just being able to see so many people gathering at China's vibrant
01:47city and the window of China's reform and open up and high tech, I'd say the summit is really a
01:52big win
01:53for China. Debra, we here in Berlin are seeing these headlines about the presidents of the U.S.,
02:00China and Russia meeting. That's really what's grabbing headlines here. You've been covering
02:03trade for a long time. How big of a deal is it that these three are meeting now?
02:07Well, I don't think it's a particularly big deal for trade because there's very little trade,
02:12particularly between Russia and most of the APEC economies. But certainly on a security front and
02:18on the larger political discussions, the trilateral is extremely important. But for trade and economic
02:25reasons, it's less relevant. So it's a bit of an interesting mix. I mean, all three are members
02:30of APEC, the Asia Pacific Economic Cooperation, but they're not always together in this way. And
02:36they're not always together for the purpose of just talking about trade.
02:38What's the significance, Debra, of China hosting this summit right now?
02:43Well, China, the APEC summit always rotates. So every year we have a new host. This year happened
02:49to be China's year. I think it was always going to be interesting. But you can imagine that in the
02:53middle of this incredible disruption that we've seen, in the middle of what Mark Carney from Canada
02:59did call this rupture in January, this became an even more fraught and complicated time for China to
03:05host the overall APEC meetings all year long. And then when you get to the summit, after you've also had
03:12conflict in Russia, Ukraine conflict in Iran, you hit the summit at the end of this year and all
03:18sorts of geopolitics, which is often outside or at least alongside APEC suddenly becomes front and
03:25center in what is generally a discussion about economics and trade policy.
03:29And this summit, this gathering of the 21 member countries leaders, it took place in Shenzhen. It's a
03:36tech hub. It's the home of a lot of Chinese industrial darlings, also known, I've learned this week,
03:40as the miracle city. Zoe, tell us more. What else is China showing off with putting this summit in
03:47Shenzhen? I'd say a big theme or a big show off would be Shenzhen's being China's high tech hub.
03:54And in particular, since October this year, China and the city of Shenzhen have been very actively
04:03pushing out this idea of the so-called Shenzhen cycle. The idea that Shenzhen is making China's
04:10future over a day. The idea that you have an idea in the morning, get a prototype in the afternoon,
04:17and get your product tomorrow. And within a week, your product can go from less than a meter counter to
04:24the rest of the world. People are really pushing this idea. And on top of that,
04:29I have seen people visiting and delegations visiting Shenzhen's so-called Huaqiangbei. This is
04:38the China's most dense or perhaps the world's densest electronic supply chain area. You have
04:44thousands of suppliers of every little ingredient, electronic input that you can imagine of. So I'd say
04:53here, the APEC not just showing Shenzhen being China's vibrant city, it also shows the power of
05:02Chinese manufacturing, not just in making toys, but also in the entire electronic supply chain for the
05:10rest of the world.
05:10Debra, you mentioned, for example, the comments from the Canadian Prime Minister, Mark Carney.
05:15Trump has met on the sidelines with the Canadian Prime Minister and also the Mexican President,
05:20Claudia Scheinbaum. Why and what are we seeing from these smaller meetings that aren't grabbing
05:26the headlines?
05:27Well, I think that's actually the power of APEC. So every year, we've had this grouping that comes
05:32together. And what it does more than anything else is it puts a deadline in everyone's calendar.
05:36And it provides a meeting place for leaders and then also senior officials in various work streams
05:43to meet across the year. And at the end of the year is when the prime ministers and presidents all
05:47come
05:48together. That is absolutely vital. Because if you didn't have that in the calendar, it might be very
05:52challenging to get these 21 members together in any other forum. And it provides, again, that opportunity
05:58for not just collective groupings, but various kinds of bilaterals, trilaterals, smaller arrangements
06:05to also piggyback on the APEC setting. And I think it doesn't make a particularly sexy headline
06:12always for APEC to say, we held meetings. But actually, especially now, that is the most vital
06:18part of what APEC does.
06:20We talked a little bit, you mentioned the calendar there. Something else that's very top of mind for
06:25any people around the world when it comes to the calendars, the fact that the US election,
06:28midterm elections just passed. What is the signal to other countries about how they can work with the
06:34United States in the coming two years? Or is that not really what APEC's about? It's about what's
06:38already been worked on in the calendar year? Well, I think this is the first opportunity that the APEC
06:44other leaders have had to see Trump in this after the midterm moment and to try to understand from him
06:51and from the officials who are traveling with him, how much policy might change? What is their what is
06:58their posture, literally posture? What is the interaction like? Does it suggest that there are new
07:05openings that might be available next year, which have been challenging for this year? And so I think
07:10this APEC, again, a lot of more focus on it, because of the disruption that we've had, coupled with the
07:18just off these incredible midterms that really may have diminished Trump's overall power, but leaves him
07:25unfettered in the international system, particularly on trade issues. So I think everyone is carefully
07:31gauging what how is Trump himself acting similarly or differently? How are the people around him
07:37positioning themselves? And what opportunities do we see going forward for better cooperation,
07:42or perhaps less cooperation in the next two years of the Trump presidency?
07:48Yeah, let's get into some of these details. Zoe, just before the APEC summit, we saw Trump in the
07:53Philippines, where he was seeking to strengthen a China free AI supply chain called Pax Silica. Is that
08:00a bit awkward? Because now here he is at the bottom of the of the little stairs they put on
08:05the
08:05airplanes giving President Xi a big old hug? I'd say no, it's not necessarily awkward or out of place. Part
08:12of the
08:13reason is because in the overall context of the indefinite strategic competition between the United States,
08:21of which technology and artificial intelligence is right at the frontier of the competition, it doesn't matter
08:28how President Xi Jinping or how President Trump interact with each other through a ceremonial way, that would matter
08:36less than the structural forces beneath or underneath the ceremonies. And I'd say, especially in the context of after
08:47the stories of Nvidia, basically, domestically speaking in the United States, strengthening export control, closing some of the
08:59loopholes that allowed advanced chip sales to China, that is already set in motion. So from that perspective, I'd say,
09:08no, President Trump's
09:10idea of strengthening Pax Silica is now not out of place. And in fact, in China, Chinese policymakers and entrepreneurs,
09:18they are also full speed, gaining momentum on achieving technology self reliance as well.
09:25Deborah, are we seeing any tension around AI playing out at AIPAC? At the time of recording, I wasn't seeing
09:32that as part of any of the readouts, any
09:35cooperation or tension. But what's your read on the situation when it comes to how all these countries are playing
09:40together or against each other when it comes to artificial intelligence?
09:43Well, I think one of the big questions for AIPAC, it wasn't necessarily on the agenda, but I guarantee that
09:48it was a topic of conversation at lunches and tea
09:52breaks was what is happening with the artificial intelligence build out in the United States? Is this boom going to
09:58continue? Or is it going to diminish in some way? Because most of the
10:03APEC economies and certainly the APEC economies in Asia have their own domestic level economic growth and jobs tied very
10:11closely, actually, to what happens with this AI build out in the US. If it slows in the United States,
10:17it means that there are fewer exports coming out of Korea, Japan, Southeast Asia, etc. That makes a big difference
10:24for APEC economies. So even if it wasn't on the agenda as such, at least at the at the leaders
10:30level, it was certainly a topic of conversation all year long at the officials level. But when you get to
10:35the leaders level, it was less of a topic of conversation on the formal agenda. But it was definitely discussed,
10:41you know, again, dinner, lunch, etc.
10:43All of these bilateral meetings and sideline meetings, I'm certain that it came up for an awful lot of the
10:49officials of the prime ministers and presidents who were who were present in in China.
10:54And I should say that APEC shorthand for Asia Pacific economic cooperation. So a lot of countries that have the
11:01Pacific Ocean on their coast. So that's why we were mentioning Mexico and Canada earlier as well, just to keep
11:07listeners with us here.
11:09But I want to bring up, you know, how are the rest of these APEC members working with China or
11:17the US or both in this supply chain? Zoe, how do you see it?
11:20I'd say countries or economies relationship with China or the US in the context of artificial intelligence or semiconductors are
11:33very different. If you think about countries like Japan or Korea, for example, in Northeast Asia, South Korea is more
11:42of a complementarity position with China, less so for Japan.
11:47And certainly when you try to bring the conversation about Taiwan, that matters to a significantly different degree, because not
11:58just about Taiwan's overall position in semiconductor supply chain, but also in the complex relationship between Taiwan and the mainland.
12:08But here, I'd say overall countries in Asia Pacific region, a lot of these do not necessarily view them as
12:18significant players in the AI race, especially not necessarily in the AI advanced and large language model.
12:28However, several countries do view themselves have a lot to play in the context of critical minerals.
12:35And this matters for Japan. This matters for Korea. This also matters for countries like Chile, Mexico or Indonesia.
12:44Tariffs used to be a word that I feel like would be the first thing on my mind covering business
12:48news when I woke up in the morning.
12:49But it doesn't really seem to be the same kind of trigger word anymore.
12:53We're not seeing the same level of tariff announcements coming out of the US lately.
12:58Knock on wood, I guess. Deborah, have leaders in APEC been able to massage away some of these threats from
13:05the United States?
13:06I do expect that we will have more tariff announcements coming out of the United States.
13:10This is not we're not done with tariffs and we're not done with the conversations at the bilateral level.
13:16In fact, when Trump was in Southeast Asia, where he was at the tail end of the meetings in Southeast
13:23Asia, he tried to argue that the deals with both Philippines and Thailand are nearly signed.
13:29And that he discussed in great detail, actually, what he expected on the tariff front with both the Philippines and
13:36with Thailand.
13:36So he is obsessed with tariffs. And I think we will continue to have this conversation around tariffs for as
13:43long as he remains in the White House.
13:45I want to come back to a topic that I feel like was probably also a point of conversation over
13:50tea or lunches in Shenzhen,
13:52which is this NVIDIA and mega speed news that has been kind of breaking in waves over the last week.
13:58The long story short version of this is that there's been a lot of chips making their way into China
14:05that through Singapore, from what I understand.
14:08Are we expecting any changes to this relationship between the U.S. and China?
14:14The U.S. previously saying that they weren't allowing some of the most high tech chips into China through various
14:20rules?
14:21Or could we be facing the music, so to say, in the next few months with the Trump administration and
14:26really just having the rules look a little bit more like the reality,
14:30which is a lot of chips do seem to be making their way into China as of now?
14:33I would say, Cassandra, export controls are always leaky, period.
14:38And yes, previously there have been several loopholes that allowed not just chips to be informally flowing into China,
14:48but also Chinese companies have been able to rent computing powers in countries like Philippines,
14:57sorry, Malaysia, for example, that were constructed using advanced chips, essentially a resource from America.
15:04And here we have already seen in the U.S., policymakers have been tightening export controls that are specifically targeting
15:13previous loopholes.
15:16So I'd say going forward, we probably will see further tightening of export controls.
15:21But the NVIDIA story has not necessarily been finished.
15:26And I wouldn't put too much weight on how a individual story would change the overall course of export controls
15:36and retaliation in the overall context of U.S.-China strategic competition,
15:42because both sides would have the incentive to not letting the other side leading in this race.
15:49And here, what really matters is that the Chinese large language models, they are good enough, but significantly cheaper.
15:58And this is going to be perhaps China's continued advantage over a lot of American advanced large language models.
16:08Unbreak this a little bit for me.
16:10When we're talking about chips making their way into China versus rented chip capacity in another country like Malaysia,
16:16I would imagine that maybe the difference isn't always clear.
16:19It's not really that clear to me, to be honest.
16:21Why is this a problem, so to say, from a China hawk perspective for someone in the U.S.?
16:28A U.S. politician might not like that idea.
16:31Why?
16:32They're not owning the chips.
16:33The chips aren't within Chinese borders.
16:35Why is this a problem from that perspective?
16:37One-third of China's compute spending has been to rent these chips in data centers, mostly in Southeast Asia.
16:46And so that is the challenge, is that if you're not going to export directly to China, which is not
16:51meant to be legal,
16:52then if you can rent them, then that allows you access to the chips while still supposedly complying with the
16:59rules.
17:00But the rules, as noted, just got tightened literally this week.
17:03So on the same day that the United States announced its Paxilica, it also targeted four members of Southeast Asia
17:10with Brazil
17:10and said these five countries now have to have new rules and new approvals for the importation of high-end
17:18chips,
17:19and they are going to be inspected for their rental, whether they're renting them out to Chinese companies.
17:25And so I think this is going to create real problems in Southeast Asia,
17:28where the data center build-out in this region has actually been quite strong as well.
17:33It matters for U.S. policymakers because they do not want you to have access to this kind of technology.
17:39And they thought that they had solved that, don't send chips to China.
17:42And they've discovered that, in fact, chips are both being exported to China, but also rented and used as if
17:49they were in China.
17:50And I think that is a real problem for China hawks in Washington.
17:53So basically, you don't need to have a home gym in your house.
17:56If you can send your large language model to the rented gym to get stronger, to finesse it, that's going
18:03to basically do the job.
18:04Right, Debra?
18:04Yes.
18:05Just very quickly on that, Cassandra, I'd say I agree with everything Debra mentioned.
18:10Just a very quick footnote there.
18:13If we evaluate U.S.-China AI race, China does have comparative advantage in data.
18:20And China also has a great amount of advantage in engineering talent, and increasingly so.
18:27China also has advantage in relatively cheap electricity prices.
18:32And more on top of that, they are also building a lot of renewal capacity to generate electricity.
18:38What China historically has been lagging behind would be an algorithm, but they have been catching up there.
18:43So one critical element in a lot of ways is going to determine who is going to be a more
18:53powerful player is going to be in the compute power.
18:57So this is why I'd say for Washington, China hawks, they are increasingly laser focused on chips.
19:05And more importantly, chips is good.
19:08Chips defining the computing power is exactly why, you know, this whole compute power matters.
19:16Because this is an area where they see the potential to further constrain China's ability to catch up.
19:24Again, because historically, more computing power, better computing power, more potent computing power tends to generate better AI capacity.
19:33Another topic that has become a big part of the conversation around this APEC summit.
19:37AI is something that is a very big contention between the U.S. and China.
19:43But something that affects all three of these countries that are in the headlines right now is energy.
19:47Energy prices have been skyrocketing this year.
19:50A very large part of that being the U.S. war in Iran.
19:54And there was a joint declaration after the trilateral meeting on Thursday, which discussed a plan to increase production and
20:00supply of refined petroleum products.
20:02So this trilateral meeting, the three-way meeting between Presidents Xi, Putin and Trump.
20:07So what can we understand about the future of energy from this kind of brief statement, Debra?
20:13Well, I think you can see that Trump is not that fond of green climate-friendly energy in general.
20:21And he has managed to say that this should be not the future.
20:25The future should remain oil-based, petroleum-based.
20:28And I think that might suit the needs of Russia.
20:31And it might in some ways be helpful for China, who could then buy Russian oil perhaps without sanctions.
20:37But it isn't probably the future.
20:39The future is likely to be green.
20:40And that is an area that China dominates.
20:42So I'm sure that China looked at this summit declaration and said, fantastic, you people, you go off and you
20:50invest in last year's technology.
20:52We will continue to invest in next year's technology.
20:54And let's see which of us is doing better 10 years from now.
20:58Zoe, do we expect any kind of declaration like this to actually lower prices at the pump for folks in
21:05the United States or even here in Europe anytime soon?
21:07I'd say oil market is actually more resilient than people have often times imagined.
21:13So the track record of the relatively resilient oil price have actually been demonstrated throughout the course of the straightforward
21:23moves.
21:24And I do not anticipate such declaration going to effectively lower U.S. energy price or gasoline price at the
21:33pump anytime soon.
21:35But I do think this is the oil price, given that oil price has already been coming down since this
21:44past week.
21:45I'd say it really depends what is going to matter for gasoline prices going forward is going to be dependent
21:53on two major factors.
21:55One is how much and how sustainable oil is going to continue to flow out of the straightforward moves.
22:03And secondly, to what extent major global energy players from state-owned oil and gas companies to independent refiners and
22:14major refiners,
22:15how fast they are returning to global market to stockpile.
22:19Because if they return to market too fast, they might risk jacking up the price.
22:26Debra, something that kind of surprised me as well is, was President Putin kind of musing out loud that he
22:32might attend the G20 meeting in the U.S. city of Miami this year?
22:38What can we make of that?
22:39I know this isn't necessarily your area of expertise, but the G20 being the top 20 economies in the world,
22:45how should we look at this?
22:46As an example of the unusual approach to foreign policy that the Trump administration and particularly Trump takes,
22:53you know, you have a leader who has been under sanctions for quite some time.
22:58There are many people, particularly in the incoming Democratic Congress,
23:02who will be outraged at the idea that you would allow President Putin to arrive on U.S. soil for
23:10a meeting hosted by the U.S. president.
23:12We'll see how that one plays out.
23:14Of course, that meeting will take place ahead of the seating of this new Congress.
23:18But the mood in the U.S. is not overall enthusiastic about President Putin becoming closer or more closely aligned
23:26with President Trump.
23:27So we'll see whether this actually turns out to be true.
23:30But the fact that they had the trilateral and the fact that this was even put out in public
23:35reminds you again of how unusual Trump is relative to any other U.S. leader in the past.
23:42Zoe, I'm wondering, you know, this conversation, I'm guilty of it as a member of the media.
23:48I've focused a lot on the presidents of China, the United States and Russia here.
23:54But I'm wondering, you know, from your vantage point, what are we missing so much by focusing on these three?
23:59Are there other alliances or cooperations forming at APEC that we should be potentially paying attention to?
24:05And that's a great point.
24:07I do not necessarily see new alliance or new partners being necessarily forming.
24:14But I do think the lack of or the lukewarm reception that Chinese officials put out for Japanese Prime Minister
24:26Takeuchi is relatively revealing.
24:29It goes to show that China-Japan relationship is still in a relatively cold point and there is no major
24:39sign of improvement anytime soon.
24:42And I think this detail matters not just because of China-Japan relationship, but also because of Japan's position to
24:53Taiwan and Japan's relationship with the United States.
24:56It's not just bilateral, but also U.S.-Japan-Korea partnership in semiconductors in trade and also in the context of
25:06Japan and Korea's committed investment in the United States and how that is supposed to change global supply chain, bring
25:14jobs back to America, bring supply chains back to America.
25:18So I'd say that little detail is very revealing and it also goes to show China-U.S. relationship is
25:25not necessarily going to be bilateral.
25:27It actually matters for a lot of third countries because I can imagine Japanese Prime Minister Takaichi and his domestic
25:36constituencies are going to have a very different interpretation for the three big powers summit.
25:45Debra, same to you. What are we missing from your perspective if the only thing that we remember from this
25:51summit is these three presidents sitting at a very big, very round table?
25:54Well, that could be all that you remember, but I would say it depends on different markets, right?
25:59So one other sort of counterpoint to the frosty reception to Japan was the warmer reception that Canada received.
26:07And so Canada and China managed to help tone down some of the disagreements that those two parties have had.
26:14And again, to me, it shows what's interesting around APEC is not so much a deliverable at APEC as much
26:21as it is the ability of leaders to be able to connect and sign off on things that are running
26:26in parallel with APEC,
26:27like a thawing of relations or at least a lessening of the freeze between China and Canada.
26:34And I think if we were to dig down deeper, we might find at the end of this this week
26:40that there were other similar kinds of arrangements that were were signed on or at least were agreed to between
26:47other APEC economies that we will hear about in the next coming days,
26:51or perhaps not at all because they don't seem that important unless you happen to to be resident in one
26:55of those APEC economies.
26:57Debra Elms from the Heinrich Foundation. Thank you so much for making the time.
27:01And Zhang Yuan, Zoe Liu, thanks so much for making some time as well.
27:04Thank you for having me.
27:07Thank you so much for watching The Dip.
27:09Of course, if you have any questions or comments, go ahead and leave them wherever you're watching or listening right
27:14now.
27:15Any feedback is, of course, always welcome.
27:18And if you're not subscribed in the podcast app of your choice, go ahead and do so.
27:22You can find us by searching The Dip.
27:23Then go ahead and slam that follow or subscribe button.
27:27But until next time, thank you so much for watching The Dip.
27:31Bye.
27:31Until next time.

Recommended