• 1 day ago
Investing News related information In 1897, a hunting party in northern New Brunswick counted 147 caribou in three days. By the late 1920s, there were none.

T.N.T. (True North Tactics) tells a real story from Canadian history and turns it into one trading lesson. Episode 2: the woodland caribou of New Brunswick, the warnings that came early, the brochure that said "increasing", and why "it will always be there" is the most expensive belief in trading.

Includes the recovery math every trader should know: lose 10% and you need 11% to get back, lose 50% and you need 100%, lose 90% and you need 900%.

Chapters
0:00 Lessons from the New Brunswick caribou
0:06 147 caribou in three days
0:31 New Brunswick in the 1800s
1:00 The warning, 1873
1:40 "Not yet"
1:59 The south goes quiet, 1894
2:16 The brochure, 1898
2:54 Two stories at once
3:15 The half-measure
3:47 The last years
4:16 Why they couldn't come back
4:55 The last herd: Gaspésie
5:20 "It will always be there"
5:40 The warning is early, and quiet
6:18 The math of a loss that doesn't revert
7:14 Half-measures vs real decisions
7:50 The map: caribou to market
8:13 Three lessons

Three lessons
1. Read the survey, not the brochure.
2. Decide your exit before you need it.
3. Act on the warning while you still have something to protect.

Sources
A. L. Adams, Field and Forest Rambles (1873)
Crown Land Department of New Brunswick, Big Game in New Brunswick (1898)
Hinterland Who's Who, Caribou
Environment and Climate Change Canada, Atlantic-Gaspésie caribou recovery strategy (2020)
Quebec MELCCFP Gaspésie caribou surveys (2021–2023)
A. MacKay, The Last Woodland Caribou
Saltscapes, The legend lives on (2025)

Charts in the trading half are illustrations, not real market data. Maps are schematic.

Educational only. Not financial advice.
Learn more at https://samxon.ca

Category

📚
Learning
Transcript
00:00Lessons from the Caribou of New Brunswick and what they can teach traders.
00:07In 1897, a hunting party in northern New Brunswick counted 147 caribou in three days.
00:14Thirty years later, there were none. Not fewer. None.
00:19And for most of those thirty years, the people in charge said the same thing.
00:23There are plenty. They will always be there.
00:32This is New Brunswick in the 1800s.
00:35Forest from the Bay of Fundy to the Restagouche, with open barrens and bogs in between.
00:41Woodland caribou lived across this country.
00:44They are animals of old forest and open bog, and they feed on lichen that grows slowly and takes years
00:50to come back.
00:51They were here long before the province had a name.
00:54They were also a source of food, of hides, and more and more, of money.
01:02In 1873, a British army surgeon and naturalist named Andrew Leif Adams published a book about the wildlife of eastern
01:09Canada.
01:10He had spent years in these woods.
01:12He wrote that the caribou was steadily decreasing in the New Brunswick forests.
01:16Not mainly because of the numbers shot, he said, but because of the intrusion of man on its haunts.
01:22He watched open barrens empty out once tree fellings started nearby.
01:26And he warned that these animals would vanish at the same pace as their forest.
01:30But in the same book he also wrote a reassuring line.
01:33The big animals of the forest were greatly reduced, yes, but they were not yet on the verge of extinction.
01:40Not yet.
01:42Those two words are the whole story.
01:44The warning was there, in print, from someone who knew the animal.
01:49The decline was already visible.
01:51But the conclusion was, that there was still time.
01:54And when there is still time, nobody has to do anything today.
01:5921 years later, in 1894, a biological survey found that the caribou had vanished from the southern half of the
02:07province.
02:08Half the range, gone.
02:10That is not a warning anymore.
02:12That is damage, already done.
02:16Four years after that, in 1898, the province's own Crown Land Department published a guide for sport hunters.
02:24It was called Big Game in New Brunswick.
02:26It invited hunters from outside the province to come, hire a guide, and take a moose or a caribou.
02:33And it said that Big Game had increased, in a still greater degree, for the caribou, than for the moose.
02:39It listed the guides and their daily wages.
02:41It described caribou plains and a herd of 80 to 100 animals.
02:46And it told the story of that party in the north that counted 147 caribou, in three days.
02:56So in the same decade, there are two stories.
02:59One says half the range is empty.
03:02The other says there are more caribou than ever.
03:05Both are written down.
03:07Only one of them is selling something.
03:09And the one that is selling something, is the one that gets printed, advertised, and believed.
03:16Officials did act.
03:18A little.
03:19In Albert County, the guide notes, moose, caribou, and deer were not found in large numbers.
03:26So to preserve them, a close season was set there, to last until 1903.
03:31One county.
03:33For a few years.
03:34While the rest of the province was being advertised to hunters.
03:37That is not a decision.
03:39That is a half measure.
03:41It feels like action.
03:42And it lets everyone keep doing what they were already doing.
03:48By the 19-teams, the caribou were holding on in the north of the province.
03:53One local history records 231 caribou killed in 1914.
03:58Eight taken by legal hunters in 1917.
04:01And in 1918, none.
04:03A few herds were still reported in northern counties into the 1920s.
04:08Then, the reports stop.
04:10By the late 1920s, the woodland caribou was gone from New Brunswick.
04:17It was not one cause.
04:19Hunting took animals quickly.
04:21Settlement and logging opened the forest, and cleared the old growth the caribou needed.
04:26And into those open woods, came white-tailed deer.
04:29Carrying a parasite called brain worm.
04:32The deer live with it.
04:33It kills caribou.
04:35So even once the shooting stopped, the country the caribou needed was no longer there.
04:40People have tried to bring them back to the Maritimes.
04:43Eight were released in Nova Scotia in 1939.
04:4759 more were brought to Cape Breton in the late 1960s.
04:51By 1972, those were gone too.
04:56Their relatives still live just across the border, in the mountains of the Gaspé, in Quebec.
05:02In the 1950s, there were around 700 of them.
05:06In the 1970s, about 150.
05:09In 2023, Quebec's own survey estimated at least 23.
05:14The same story, still running, a few hours' drive from Bathurst.
05:20Now, think about the most expensive sentence in trading.
05:23It will always be there.
05:25The stock will come back.
05:27The setup that worked for years will keep working.
05:30The money in the account will still be there next month.
05:33Every trader who has blown up an account, believed some version of that sentence.
05:37Right up to the end.
05:40The warning almost always comes early.
05:43And it almost always comes in the form of, not yet.
05:47Look at this chart.
05:48The trend is still up.
05:50But each new high is a little weaker.
05:52Momentum is fading underneath it, the same way the caribou were decreasing while the woods still looked full.
05:59Then comes the first real damage.
06:02A lower high.
06:03A lower low.
06:05Half the range is gone.
06:06And this is the moment most traders read the brochure, instead of the survey.
06:11They listen to the story that says it will bounce.
06:14Because that story asks nothing of them.
06:18Now here is the math nobody wants to look at.
06:21Take $100,000.
06:23Lose 10%.
06:24And you have $90,000.
06:26To get back, you need about 11%.
06:29Annoying.
06:30Fixable.
06:31Lose 50%.
06:32Now you have $50,000.
06:34And to get back you need to double it.
06:36100%.
06:37100%.
06:37Just to be where you started.
06:40Lose 90%.
06:41$10,000 left.
06:43To get back, you need 900%.
06:46900.
06:47That is not a recovery.
06:49That is a miracle.
06:50And you will be asking for it, with a tenth of the money you had.
06:53The way down is a straight line.
06:55The way back up gets steeper with every dollar you lose.
06:59That is why the loss you cut at 10% is a lesson.
07:02And the loss you ride to 90% is an ending.
07:05The Caribou did not lose 90%.
07:07They lost all of it.
07:08And no amount of reintroduction brought them back.
07:14The Albert County close season has a trading version too.
07:19You move your stop a little lower.
07:21You sell a quarter of the position.
07:23You promise yourself you will cut it if it breaks the next level.
07:26It feels like action.
07:28It protects nothing.
07:30The real decision is made before the trade in numbers.
07:33Where you are wrong.
07:35How much you can lose on one idea.
07:37How deep a drawdown you'll accept on the whole account before you stop and step back.
07:42Then, when the warning comes, you don't debate it.
07:45You act on it, while you still have something to protect.
07:51So, here is the whole map.
07:53The naturalist's warning is the first divergence.
07:56The empty south is the first lower low.
07:59The brochure is the crowd telling you it will bounce.
08:01The close season in one county is the stop you keep moving.
08:06And the late 1920s is the loss that does not come back.
08:10Different worlds.
08:11Same logic.
08:14Read the survey.
08:15Not the brochure.
08:17Decide your exit before you need it.
08:19And act on the warning, while you still have something to protect.
08:23This has been TNT.
08:25Educational only.
08:26Not financial advice.
08:28Learn more at samson.ca.
08:32Oh, my God.'relish
08:32on theói is the stop. I don't
08:32know what you're saying. I couldn't
08:34believe it. But if you're
08:34at this. I'll see it.