00:00You, Zafferino S. Rodolfo, do swear that the evidence you shall give in the case now pending between the Philippines
00:07and Vice President Cyrus Zimmerman Duterte shall be the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth. So I
00:13help you God.
00:14I do.
00:15Calia 88 Foods Corporation is a duly registered export enterprise with a board of investments and is engaged in the
00:24lawful and legitimate business of producing and exporting bananas.
00:30I would like to comment regarding these statements that the Vice President of the Vice President, Attorney Panelo, is that
00:51right?
00:52I mean, I believe there is a problem here.
00:57I will therefore file a motion to issue a show cause order for the spokesperson of the Vice President.
01:12Upon motion, there will be no objection.
01:18Chair, the motion is hereby approved.
01:21Clerk of court is directed to issue a show cause order to Attorney Paolo Panelo in regard to his remarks
01:33made yesterday afternoon, if I'm not mistaken.
01:36Yes, Mr. President, thank you.
01:39Sir, if I may interrupt.
01:42I just noticed that the witness is reading from notes which are handwritten.
01:47Maybe we just know what the document is.
01:51Ito po yung nilista lang po namin kung ano yung mga document requirements for...
01:58Allowed po ba ako, sir?
01:59Dr. Perry, kayo po nagprepara ng notes na yan?
02:02Sinulat po namin kanina bago po pumasok dito.
02:05When you say namin, kayo nga po nagprepara?
02:07Apo, nakita. Kasama po ako sa nagprepara.
02:10Okay. So these are your notes?
02:12Apo.
02:13Okay. Thank you, Your Honor.
02:15Thank you, Your Honor.
02:17And according to this report made by Kale 88 Foods Corporation,
02:21what is the volume of export sales in the year 2023 of banana chips, sir?
02:28216,000 kilograms po.
02:30Now, below that number is value.
02:34What is that number?
02:36What does that number pertain to, sir?
02:38Yun pong revenue niya dahil naibenta niya po sa labas dahil export po ito yung 216,000 kilograms na yan.
02:47Okay.
02:48Sir, nanonood naman po kayo ng impeachment proceedings?
02:52Hindi po masyado talaga po eh.
02:55Napanood niyo po ba yung interjection dati ni Senator Judge Joel Villanueva tungkol sa zero rank and file employees na
03:04nakareport sa GIS for the years 2022, 23, and 24?
03:08And dahil dito humingi siya ng alpha list of employees from the BIR witness.
03:13Alam niyo po ba na hindi nagsasubmit ng alpha list of employees itong Kale 88 sa BIR based po sa
03:21certification?
03:21Same objection, Your Honor.
03:22The witness would be incompetent.
03:24He is from the Board of Investments.
03:27They had their time to present that witness.
03:29They failed to do so.
03:31Sir, alam niyo po ba na mahiling magtanim ng mga puno si Vice President Sara Duterte?
03:37Objection, Your Honor. What's the relevance?
03:39Andito po yung pitch up.
03:40Hindi ko po.
03:41I have a point, Your Honor. I promise.
03:44Tama po ba na itong pagtatanim ng mga puno ni Vice President Sara Duterte ay connected sa pag-comply ng
03:51Kale 88 Foods sa three planting activities na requirement ng Board of Investment?
03:56In fact, ang requirement po ng Board of Investments ay magtanim dapat ang mga enterprises ng at least 100 forest
04:04trees. May ganong requirement? Tama po ba?
04:06Objection, Your Honor. Misleading.
04:07There is no prior testimony coming from the witness wherein he testified that the Vice President participated in the compliance
04:14requirement of tree planting.
04:16The insinuation being made by the prosecution that the pictures being shown or that was displayed of the Vice President
04:23planting trees had any relation to the Kale 88 Foods Corporation's registration is misleading, malicious, and callous, Your Honor.
04:32Ma'am Merlin, naunawaan niyo po ba yung inyong pinanumpaan kaugnay sa pagbibigay niyo na inyong testimonya sa hapong ito?
04:39Opo. Your Honor was based on the subpoena that I received. I will have to testify.
04:45Doon po sa product registration documents that were submitted by the Kale 8 Food Corporation to FDA.
04:54That is correct, ma'am.
04:55And the certificate of product registration issued under the company, the Kale...
05:01Based on the subpoena, ma'am. Let the lawyers take care of that.
05:04Now, you said earlier that this is in response to the earlier denial.
05:09How is the submission of these photos of packagings a response to the earlier denyan?
05:15Para po sa amin na hindi pamilyar sa mga requirements sa FDA.
05:18Sir, indeed to...
05:20These are the documents, as part of the documents that was submitted in the earlier application,
05:27na it was denied because the FDA evaluator finds the non-compliant to the labeling regulations of FDA.
05:37So, as declared in the denial letter, so non-declaration of the complete nutrition facts,
05:48and then there is the claims initially regarding the banana because this is considered as nutrient content claims
06:01or health claims or health claims, because Cardava is the highest content of nutrients because it is the deepest roots
06:08among other banana plants.
06:09Okay.
06:21You