• 13 minutes ago
Some sports biopics stick close to the playbook, and others take some creative liberties. Join us as we break down the biggest facts “Madden” got right and the moments it bent the truth, from John Madden’s flight anxiety and broadcast rise to the origins of the iconic video game and the characters Hollywood added for drama.
Transcript
00:00Welcome to WatchMojo, and today we're counting down our picks for the things David O. Russell's
00:04John Madden biopic got right, and the things that changed, invented, or passed to the wrong person.
00:09Oh, now look at these seagulls. Big, big circles over the seagulls, and I like that. I like seagulls.
00:17Number 10. John Madden was grounded for good. Right.
00:21John's fear of flying all stems from when we lost the San Luis Obispo team,
00:26when they all went down on that plane. The entire football team. And John very well
00:33could have been on that plane. That's something he's never recovered from.
00:37Covering football across the country is a demanding job when getting on a plane is off the table.
00:41The film correctly makes Madden's aversion to flying part of his story. After a panic attack
00:45aboard a plane in Tampa in 1979, he stopped flying altogether. Madden described the problem as
00:50claustrophobia, rather than simply a fear of turbulence or heights. He traveled by train
00:54before Greyhound supplied a customized bus in 1987, creating the famous Madden Cruiser. That
01:00enormous vehicle became an unmistakable extension of his public identity. The travel arrangements
01:05might look like a celebrity eccentricity on screen, but they helped him keep doing a job
01:09that required crossing the country. You know, he looked a little apprehensive. And I said,
01:14I'll think about the airplane now. And he said he was not thinking about it. He was thinking
01:20about a whip route where two receivers make the defenders collide.
01:24Number 9. The neighbor Hollywood moved in. Wrong.
01:27I'm Vince McGarry. I work at educational games for now. I got married because of John. He inspires
01:33me. He's my neighbor. Well, he was my neighbor.
01:35With so many recognizable names wandering through this movie, you might assume Shane Gillis is playing
01:40another person for Madden's life. His man-child neighbor Vince McGarry certainly seems positioned
01:45that way. Someone outside the football business who can drop into the story and provide comic relief.
01:50My own neighbor, Vince, was giving me talismans and good luck charms.
01:54Check this out. Coyote jawbone. Foot of a duck. This is for you, coach.
02:00There's one problem with treating those encounters as reality. Vince is entirely fictional. He's a
02:05character created for the movie, so his interactions with Madden aren't evidence of an actual friendship.
02:10Invented supporting characters can help the film move along, but viewers deserve to know where the
02:14invention begins. In this case, it begins right next door.
02:17You gotta find a place to talk football. You got more to say about it, John. I'll be here with
02:21the
02:21clubs and the cigarettes and the beer whenever you need it. I'm just doing what I can to help this
02:26country. Number 8. Football's Secrets Handed Over. Right.
02:30On the cover of Madden, John is a coach. John is a coach. It is all bullshit anyway. You got
02:37nothing
02:37without the league. You gotta get real teams, real uniforms, real players. Without that, nothing's
02:44real. I'm gonna get the respect of the league because John is gonna give me his playbook.
02:49Before the game could teach millions of people how football worked, somebody had to teach its
02:53developers. The movie gives that process a tangible centerpiece when Madden hands his playbook over to
02:58Trip Hawkins. That part has a real foundation. He supplied Electronic Arts with the 1980 Raiders
03:03playbook, giving the team actual football strategy to draw on. His knowledge helped turn an ambitious
03:11computer project into something that reflected the decisions made on a football field. The film
03:16surrounds the handover with a heated confrontation involving Al Davis, which shouldn't be treated as a
03:21verified account. But the book itself belongs in the story. Madden was sharing the substance behind
03:26the name on the box.
03:26It's my bible. Every play I ever coached, every play I ever drew, every argument I ever had with
03:34Al, every matchup, every player rate, and every offense for every defense, every defense for every
03:38offense. That's the entirety of my life experience. It's what I love. Prove me wrong, kid.
03:46Number 7. Putting words in Pat Summerall's mouth. Wrong.
04:06A legendary partnership apparently needs a little backstage hostility first. The movie shows
04:11broadcaster Pat Summerall criticizing Madden to Howard Cosell inside the CBS broadcast booth.
04:16According to Madden and Summerall author Rich Podolsky, that encounter never happened.
04:21He's surprised by light. What is he, a Neanderthal?
04:24Throw that headset on.
04:25We never used these on the sidelines. I never did. I have everything in my head. We didn't have this
04:30either. It's all up. Al Davis and I always had it in our heads. Sort of Kenny Stabler.
04:34There you go. That's wonderful. Yeah.
04:35So what?
04:36Go ahead and throw that. There you go.
04:38We never had paper on the sidelines.
04:41Summerall did have reservations about losing his longtime partner, Tom Brookshire, but Podolsky,
04:46citing CBS executive producer Terry O'Neill, points to a newspaper interview in which Summerall
04:51said he'd miss Brookshire without attacking Madden. Cosell's presence in the booth is another
04:55invention. Podolsky specifically disputes. There's a meaningful difference between being
04:59reluctant to lose a friend and openly disparaging the replacement.
05:02I'm sorry about that, John. And that is not my style. I was out of line. I apologize. I'm sincerely
05:10sorry about that. Well, and I am sorry too because I overstepped. It was TV. It was new. I was
05:16excited.
05:17And I want you to know that I'll make sure to give you the appropriate space so you can get
05:23the plays
05:23out. Biopics give us plenty to argue about. Join the conversation on WatchMojo's pop culture live
05:28streams, where we talk about movies, TV, and the stories behind them. Scan the QR code on screen
05:33to check them out.
05:37Walking away at 42. Right.
05:39John's throwing up. Yeah. It's become a thing of this. I'm worried about your coach. Oh, you guys are
05:48getting injured. My injury's on the inside. Mine's on the inside. You can't see it.
05:53For a coach who lived for football, leaving the sidelines at 42 sounds almost impossible. But that's
05:58exactly what John Madden did. The film makes his bleeding ulcer and the pressure on his home life
06:03central to the decision, reflecting the real toll of the job. He announced his retirement on January
06:274th, 1979 after 10 seasons leading the Raiders. He'd won a Super Bowl and never finished a season
06:32with a losing record. Yet success had only made the workload less sustainable. We can't know what
06:37Madden said to his family in private moments, but it's hard to argue that he walked away while he
06:41still had plenty of coaching ability left.
06:43I started out as an Oakland Raider. I will retire as an Oakland Raider. I will always be an Oakland
06:51Raider.
06:52Number 5. Al Davis gets the agent's job. Wrong.
06:55So listen, CBS, they want you as a broadcaster.
06:59A haircut? No, those guys are nothing but haircuts, Al.
07:03Christian Bale's Al Davis gets to launch Madden's broadcasting career too. In the film, he brings
07:08news of CBS's interest and encourages the reluctant former coach to give television a chance.
07:12According to Rich Badalski, that conversation actually belonged to Madden's agent, Barry Frank.
07:17When Madden suggested waiting a few years, Frank warned that the network might no longer be
07:21interested by them.
07:22So what about CBS?
07:24Now, let me think about it. Maybe in a couple of years, I'll think about it.
07:27A couple of years, they might not be interested in you. Remember when you used to say to the
07:31players quitting training camp, this might be the last chance you get to play professional
07:36football? Well, this might be the last chance that you get to announce professional football.
07:41CBS's initial offer was $12,000 for four games in 1979, giving Madden a chance to try broadcasting
07:48without committing indefinitely. He also insisted on a practice broadcast, working a preseason
07:52game between the Rams and 49ers alongside a young Bob Costas. By 1981, Madden had joined
07:58Pat Summerall on CBS's lead NFL announcing team.
08:01It's a heck of a first half. The Packers really did dominate there.
08:04Well, that's absolutely right, Pat. It reminds me of a play that Vince Lombardi spent eight
08:10hours teaching to me in class. Eight hours. The power sweep.
08:13I'm going to demonstrate it for you. I'll use it on my new telestrator.
08:17What is that? Where do you get that?
08:20Number four, 11 players or no deal. Right.
08:23This is the future. Take a look.
08:25There's one number Nicolas Cage's John Madden won't negotiate. When John Mulaney's Trip Hawkins
08:30proposed video game offers seven players per team, Cage Madden's coach refuses to put his name behind
08:36it. The real Madden took essentially the same position.
08:38What is this? Blocky, globular s**t. No one has a face. And wait a minute. You only have seven men
08:46on a team. This whole thing is antithetical to my identity. And you know what that means.
08:52It is embarrassing. And I'm out. I'm out.
08:56Early plans called for smaller teams because contemporary computers struggled with the demands
09:00of a full football simulation. Madden insisted on 11 players on each side. As a former offensive
09:06lineman, he understood that removing players meant losing essential parts of the sport.
09:11His stubbornness made development harder, but it also helped define what the game would become.
09:15The first version finally arrived in 1988. The movie gets this crucial point right.
09:20If developers wanted Madden's endorsement, they had to meet his standards.
09:24Willie, let's go home. Dinner with Virginia and the Davises.
09:29Coach!
09:29Coach!
09:30Coach!
09:30Why can't it look like football? Is that too much to ask?
09:34Number three, seven years too early. Wrong.
09:36The Raiders have won the Super Bowl. The celebration is underway and Trip Hawkins arrives with a proposal
09:41for Madden's future.
09:42Hey, Coach Madden. Hey, Coach.
09:44Trip Hawkins. Do you remember me? I saw you at the Tasty Burger.
09:48Yeah, but Trip isn't in a good football name. Maybe whip or rip or zip.
09:52I don't understand what a computer game is.
09:55It's going to be a football game for the computer. Just like...
09:59Have you been to an arcade with the kids?
10:01It's a tidy way to connect the coach to the video game.
10:04It's also years ahead of schedule.
10:06The film places that approach at the 1977 victory party, but Hawkins approached Madden in 1984.
10:11What are you talking about?
10:13This game is your legacy. Madden football.
10:16There's no John Madden football. There's no Al Davis football. There's just Raiders football.
10:21Electronic Arts itself wasn't founded until 1982.
10:25By then, Madden was already a successful broadcaster, while Hawkins had unsuccessfully pursued Joe Montana.
10:30The eventual collaboration included a two-day Amtrak journey with Madden, Hawkins, and producer Joe Ibarra.
10:36Madden saw the proposed game as a teaching tool, something that could let people explore the decisions behind the plays.
10:42One day, Coach Madden football. This is my f***ing dream.
10:46Number 2. Madden showed up when it mattered. Right.
10:49I'm going to the f***ing hospital.
10:51John, he's not our player. Hey, we take care of ours, they take care of theirs, okay?
10:56Yeah, no, the Patriots left for the airport without him, and the guy can't move.
11:05One of the film's most moving moments has a stronger factual basis than you might expect.
11:09In August 1978, Patriots receiver Daryl Stingley suffered a devastating spinal injury after a collision with Raiders defender Jack Tatum.
11:17Madden visited him in the hospital, beginning a friendship that extended far beyond that night.
11:22Something's different. What the f***?
11:25The machine stopped.
11:27We need help! Something happened in here! The brain, the machine stopped! We need help!
11:32The movie also shows him alerting nurses when Stingley's medical equipment malfunctions.
11:36That wasn't simply a dramatic invention. Former Raiders player Pat Toomey later recounted how Madden noticed Stingley's ventilator malfunctioning and
11:44summoned a nurse.
11:45Stingley later said he might have choked to death without him.
11:48Somehow, the man on the opposing sideline became someone Stingley could count on.
11:51Yeah, hi, this is John Madden.
11:54Where are you?
11:57Well, I don't care that you left the gate.
12:00You need to turn your airplane around.
12:04Because someone needs to come and be here with this young man from your team.
12:09Number one. The deal Al Davis didn't make. Wrong.
12:12The NFL is now part of the John Madden video game.
12:16Stop it!
12:17We got the league.
12:19We're gonna have all the teams. We're gonna have all the colors.
12:21We're gonna have all the uniforms.
12:23And we haven't got the Players Association. Doesn't matter.
12:24We got the lead for the John Madden video game.
12:28And it is mostly due to this man.
12:32Al Davis.
12:33The film has Al Davis help secure the NFL license for Madden's video game, giving their friendship a satisfying payoff.
12:39But Trip Hawkins told Time Magazine that Davis had nothing to do with that.
12:43EA already had a hit without official NFL branding.
12:46The 1990 Genesis version sold roughly 400,000 copies against expectations of 75,000.
12:58Released in 1993, Madden NFL 94 finally introduced authentic team names, logos, and uniforms.
13:04Named players required a separate NFL Players Association agreement, which arrived with the Genesis version of Madden NFL 95.
13:11The movie gives Davis a heartwarming role in that success.
13:14Hawkins remembers getting there without his help.
13:24Which surprised you more?
13:25What Madden made up or what actually happened?
13:28Be sure to tell us which scene caught you off guard in the comments.

Recommended