• 11 minutes ago
Cargo Bay 101

Category

📺
TV
Transcript
00:00I am John Billingsley and you are watching Trek Culture.
00:16Hello my friends and welcome to Cargo Bay 101, which by the way we borrowed from George Orwell's 1984, not
00:24the popular television show on BBC, just to be very clear about that for legal reasons.
00:27And this week we are inviting our wonderful guest, Eddie, to take something from all of Star Trek, put it
00:35in the Cargo Bay and then convince us to push the big red button that I have on my tricorder.
00:41Eddie, what do you have for us?
00:45I'm putting in short, expensive, 10 episode a year seasons of Star Trek.
00:54That's what I'm putting in.
00:55Okay, okay, I am very interested to hear what you have to say.
01:00Okay, lay it out for us.
01:02This is something that I think that quite a lot of people are mad about with Star Trek, especially when
01:09it's good and they like it.
01:12Where is it? Where's more of it?
01:16I've got to wait a full year for an additional 10 episodes.
01:22And it's like, when they explain why, it's like, well, it's really cinematic, there's so many great, expensive effects.
01:28And you're watching the episodes, like, Strange New Worlds.
01:31A lot of those, like, really cool, intricate cinematic effects are done over captain's logs and stuff.
01:38And it's like, like, how many, like, scenes of actors just sitting in a room, like, given with great dialogue
01:47and, like, tension and just scenes we could have had instead of all of that.
01:52I'm just, I'm really, really jealous of all that stuff.
01:54When have I got?
01:55Eddie, I could kiss you right now.
02:01I completely agree.
02:03I don't care how much money you've spent on it.
02:05Is the show good or not?
02:06There's been this weird shift.
02:08I think once, like, CGI and, you know, the boom of CGI and also film cameras became so good.
02:17But we're digital film cameras became so good and crisp that we started, you know, using them more and more.
02:24And it was easier to use them in every kind of TV show and film.
02:27Number one, I don't think that's a good idea.
02:29I like film.
02:30I'm not saying that everything should be on film.
02:32But I think the more crisp kind of cameras we've been getting and using makes everything feel a bit kind
02:40of strange.
02:42Like, just because something looks real doesn't mean it looks good, basically.
02:47And we've been going this projection with all those things that I think we are focusing, we're putting money in
02:55the wrong place, basically.
02:57And it's, you know, it's the other thing of, like, there's a saying within the arts, which I've now completely
03:03forgotten.
03:03But it's basically, you know, restraint is good if you have only a certain amount of budget, only a certain
03:11amount of money.
03:11You can only do so many things.
03:13That makes you have to be creative.
03:15So having money to splash on these, like you said, these sweeping shots over Captain's log, or how many times
03:23can we see a black hole in Strange New Worlds?
03:26Many times.
03:28Yes, it looks nice.
03:29I want to see something else.
03:31Like, we're focusing on things.
03:33Oh, the sets are really big.
03:34This is the biggest set ever.
03:36Make it smaller.
03:37How about make it smaller, though?
03:38What have you thought about that?
03:42It's just, it's, yeah, like you said, I'm going to keep saying it, but it is focusing on the wrong
03:47things.
03:48We're blessed to live in an age where we get to see Star Trek in such a different kind of
03:52way.
03:53But it's just, I think the focus is off, really.
03:58Well, I mean, if you've, like, who fans will know, like, there's been, like, that whole Disney thing.
04:05That was an insane cash injection where the episodes got really cinematic and there's, like, a big hangover from it
04:12now.
04:12So, where people are kind of nostalgic for the washing up liquid villains and stuff.
04:18They're just the really shoddy, yeah, plank in a fashion style.
04:24Like, I mean, there's definitely, there's a period of Doctor Who's history where every episode was dubbed by Neil Buchanan
04:29on Art Attack.
04:30Do you know what I mean?
04:30Like, that's just what the effects were.
04:32And it was fine because there is a suspension of disbelief that we bring into sci-fi.
04:38We know the Daleks aren't coming to get us.
04:42Do you know what I mean?
04:43We, you know, it's, it's a big pepper pot.
04:45We know that.
04:46But we, we invest it.
04:49Similarly, you know, look at the, the M113 Salt Vampire from, you know, from the Mantrap, which is an iconic
04:56design.
04:57And it's, you know, not to take away from the design, but, like, it's some fur, you know, with, you
05:03know, with the mask that was probably thrown together with, you know, a bit of paper mache.
05:07Again, I'm not talking down the design of it.
05:10What I'm saying is that you had the tools available to you at the day.
05:15And you said, Eddie, as well, which I completely agree with, is that Star Trek has so many scenes of
05:20people sitting in rooms talking.
05:23That's where Trek is, I think, at its strongest.
05:27And that's true of the films as it is of the TV series.
05:31And I think when we, because television has changed, I mean, like, you know, it, you watched it through the
05:36years of Game of Thrones, but it was changing before that already.
05:39The HBOing of television, because there is so much, you know, increase in budgets, effects are so much, you know,
05:49I won't say better than they were before.
05:51It's very different.
05:51You know what I mean?
05:52We are capable of doing more with effects now.
05:56But I think sometimes, and maybe Strange New Worlds is particularly guilty, for want of a better word of this.
06:05But it's like, we're going to spend X amount on the effects this week to have 10 new shots of
06:12the Enterprise and these spacefaring things and the battle and everything.
06:16And then I think of Encounter at Farpoint, where ILM came in and filmed that model of the Enterprise, and
06:23for pretty much two seasons, they reused footage.
06:27And it works.
06:29Honestly, it works.
06:31Maybe they would have done it differently if there was, again, if the cash was there, if it was being
06:35filmed in ILM's headquarters.
06:37You know, maybe they would have done it differently.
06:39But I don't think, certainly, those first two seasons, I don't think we lose anything from not having big, mad
06:49spacefaring things or, you know, like, okay, Q-Who looked amazing.
06:56Some of that was reused footage of the ship, you know, obviously they filmed, you know, they filmed the cube
07:01and stuff like that.
07:01But, so, that's something, it sounds like I'm arguing for Star Trek to get lazy, but I'm not saying that,
07:08but, like, you don't have to create 27 new shots of the ship in every single episode.
07:14And, you know, Salat Who Ate Its Own Tale?
07:17Hmm.
07:18Like, there's some really expensive shots that I wish weren't in it and stuff, like the TARDIS is in it,
07:24for example.
07:24But, the really cool, like, HBO-style shots that are in it, or, um, of Kirk, when he's sort of,
07:31with this new crew, he's like, oh my god, they're not listening.
07:34And he's just totally in himself.
07:36And then looking at him, like, oh, they're kicking him, like, oh, is he going to work?
07:39We've got a dud captain.
07:41And, like, those shots, those are creative and those are, like, more advanced than your basic coverage.
07:46But they're of characters, like, it's explaining a dynamic with it.
07:51It's doing something cool.
07:53Like, I'm fine with those, but it's, like, we need more of those.
07:59Yeah.
07:59I mean, I've also, with what you guys have been saying, Eddie would probably maybe understand this as well, which
08:06is, I feel like I can go to an old episode of Star Trek and very easily, or an old
08:13season, very easily find shots of ships that I'm looking for.
08:17And with new seasons of Star Trek, like the Strangely Worlds, you might get a couple of quick shots of
08:23the ship, but it's not all the time.
08:26And it's not the same kind of shot that you're looking for.
08:29It's, like, blurred frames.
08:30Yeah.
08:31It's blurry.
08:31It's weird.
08:32It's like, I'm trying to, I just want a clear shot of it moving left to right.
08:35And it's like, I actually can't find that in the episode.
08:38There's a weird, again, they've changed their focus on what they actually want to show.
08:43And there's also a big discussion about practical and visual effects, right?
08:49And, you know, practical effects, you could go into a studio and film a model of a ship every which
08:54way possible.
08:55And then you've got it banked for however long you want to use it.
08:58I might be wrong, but I'm assuming it's more difficult now to be like, hey, we need this shot.
09:04Do we have that that we can just copy and paste from a previous episode?
09:08If not, we need to recreate the entire, you know, whatever.
09:14So, and if you think about Strangely Worlds, what are the effects that people always talk about in Strangely Worlds
09:19at the moment?
09:20It's the practical effects of the Gorn.
09:21That's the one that everyone loves.
09:24I don't know enough.
09:25I've always kind of assumed that practical is cheaper than special effects.
09:31But from what I hear about from the industry, that we use visual effects because it is cheaper.
09:36Not just because making it is cheaper, but it means you can more quickly do things that you need to
09:41change.
09:42Yeah.
09:43I don't know how true that is.
09:44My gut says it's not true or it's not worth it.
09:48I always want to smack producers around the head and go, just use practical effects because everyone actually likes it.
09:52But I don't know how true that actually is.
09:57But that's what's popular.
09:59And like with what you were saying, Eddie, as well, which is like, you know, the more interesting shots that
10:03we had with Kirk and all that.
10:05If you go back and think of a simple episode of TNG, you might have a static shot and you've
10:13got a two shot and it doesn't change for ages.
10:15And you've got people walking to and from the camera and someone might sit down and get back up again.
10:20And by the time you've cut into a different shot, sometimes it could be like three minutes long.
10:27And I've said to you guys, when I'm my edit brain kind of kicks in when I'm watching these kind
10:33of shows, because I like to look at a simple setup of two people talking in a room and they
10:39will cut between five different shots of the same thing over and over again.
10:42And your brain can't even keep track of what's going on or where.
10:46And you're like, they're trying to make it exciting.
10:48The camera is always moving that in their heads.
10:52They're going, well, this has to be exciting.
10:54Something I learned very early on in editing when I was at film school is to show off.
11:00I went to film school.
11:01No, to if you're having to cut away all the time for something, it's because what you're shooting isn't interesting
11:08enough.
11:08Now, that doesn't mean it's true for everything, but for a simple thing like that, if you think that these
11:15people talking in the room isn't interesting enough, that you're going to have to cut around a million different shots
11:19of the same thing, you've got to rewrite it.
11:21You've got to rethink it.
11:23And I think that's the basis of what you're saying of like, hey, I'm glad we've got these very expensive
11:29episodes, but they're not doing the job that a cheaper show could be doing.
11:34Yeah, when you've got like those like ready room scenes, like all you really need to do if the scene
11:40and the discussion is good is just have the camera be like a table level.
11:45So people feel like they're in the meeting and then just present the information to the characters and just do
11:51some really simple back and forth shots.
11:53And that's it.
11:55That's all you'd need to do.
11:56So I think it's just a case of they're willing to painstakingly go for like really nice imagery.
12:03And when it comes to like the scenes in the scripts, they're like, yeah, that'll do.
12:08Whereas before the, yeah, that'll do would be for reusing footage.
12:13So I think that, yeah, their energies are being diverted.
12:16That's really interesting.
12:17Actually, that's a really interesting take because, you know, it's the kind of, what is it?
12:26Um, it's from Star Trek six, the president going just because one can do a thing, it does not necessarily
12:32follow that one must do that thing.
12:34Yeah.
12:35Um, and I think that's really, I think it's what Tom, what you were saying about, like, you know, holding
12:39on, um, you know, a scene and, and, and cutting away and having five or six different shots of two
12:46people sitting in a chair, as opposed to just leaving the camera run.
12:49Imagine chain of command where you had Picard and gold Madrid sitting there.
12:54And part of the power is it doesn't pull away.
12:58You know, it doesn't give you that breath to change your angle, to change everything.
13:03It's like, this is uncomfortable and it's meant to be uncomfortable.
13:07Yeah.
13:07And so we're not going to pull away.
13:09The reveals, like it uses the staticness of the shot to do like reveals in that where it cuts from
13:15like tender moments with like a grandfather and his granddaughter being like lovely.
13:20And then the camera will just like subtly move because one of the characters moved in.
13:24There's a tortured man in a spotlight.
13:27Yeah.
13:27Yeah.
13:28There's a pacing within the editing of itself.
13:30You know, you're supposed to sit and watch how this happens.
13:34You know, if you think, say for example, in a horror film, a lot of times you have that static
13:40shot that zooms in or slowly focus on this like dark spot.
13:44And it's building up this tension and you're wondering what's going to happen.
13:47Imagine if they filmed that spot with five different cameras and constantly cut and you'd be like, wait, wait, I'm
13:54not scared anymore.
13:54I don't know really what's going on.
13:56It's that same thing.
13:57It's the famous one of, in one of the Taken films where Liam Neeson jumps over a fence and they
14:02shot it with like, I think there's like 14 cuts or something.
14:05It's just him jumping over a fence.
14:07It's like you've, you've taken away what could have been a cool moment by, by cutting so many times.
14:12There's a great, I want to just recommend this quickly to people who are interested in editing within films.
14:18There's a great channel.
14:20I haven't checked it out for a moment.
14:21They, they, they've, they've got some new things.
14:24Uh, every frame a painting.
14:26Um, and they have a bunch of videos talking about editing and film, et cetera.
14:34Um, and there's one on Hong Kong movies, specifically Jackie Chan, like Hong Kong action films.
14:41And it's called how to do action comedy.
14:44And it talks about how they edit the actual action.
14:48And that's a really good way to know, like when to cut, when not to cut.
14:52And it also, you know, again, you, you can, you can think of those moments where Jackie Chan jumps up
14:58a wall and you're like, how did he do that?
15:01Imagine if they cut in a million times, seeing every foot, every detail, it doesn't matter anymore.
15:06You've lost the momentum that you could have from that single shot.
15:09So I feel like we've gone like deep into the weeds of this, but I do think it's an issue,
15:14not just with Star Trek, but just with where at the moment with our media and how it's being filmed
15:20and produced.
15:21There was a thing the other day, again, I don't know how true this is, but it was, I want
15:26to say Jamila Jamil.
15:28I'm glad you brought this up.
15:29I know exactly what you're talking about.
15:32So for the audience, um, it was something along the lines of producers are now telling writers of shows to
15:39write in a way that if people are on their phone, not paying attention to the show, they can understand
15:43what's going on.
15:44So that's why everything is really obvious in the writing anymore.
15:48And I heard that, and I wanted to say that can't be true, but I wouldn't be surprised.
15:55That had a scene in the inside baseball of wrestling of, um, everyone is short attention span theater now.
16:02And that presided over like a really bad creative period in wrestling.
16:06So that's a really cynical viewpoint that I think hurts work product that people are trying to entertain people with.
16:12Yeah, that, I can't even imagine how that could be a thing in wrestling.
16:16Like, how could you add that into wrestling thinking people aren't interested in what's going on?
16:20It's, the whole short attention span thing is stupid on its face.
16:24It's like people, they tune into stuff, they access media and entertainment, they're like, cause the thing that it's about
16:31interested them.
16:32Yeah.
16:33I've always said, is it quick?
16:35They didn't do it, oh, is it about space?
16:37Is it about dinosaurs?
16:38I'm in.
16:39Yeah, yeah.
16:40It's, it's something that is always said, like how media is being made at the moment.
16:43But I think it's, it comes from the top people, you know, the producers of these shows who assume something
16:51about how the world is at the moment and uses that to create the media.
16:55And I always think.
16:56The world they don't live in.
16:57No, no, human beings don't actually act this way.
17:00Like you don't have to do this thing.
17:01You've just decided that's what we have to do now.
17:04Oh.
17:06We really went in the weeds in this one.
17:07So I think safe to say, yep, we're in agreement.
17:11I think that one topic is about 27 little different topics as well.
17:15But I do think it does go back into the, it's the shorter seasons, you know, where there's more to
17:22do with less time to do it.
17:24Which has, you know, has kind of fed into much more scenes, much more shots.
17:30The sort of, we've covered it.
17:33Yes, I think we're with you on that one.
17:35Because as well, I think, I think in general, the idea of shorter seasons, we've sort of, we kind of
17:40have airlocked that one.
17:41But I think we've gone through a bit more specific reasons with this one.
17:45So everything we just covered is going out the airlock.
17:49I've decided I have my tricorder with my red button, which you can just about see.
17:54And I am going to push that.
17:57Here we go.
18:17Hi, I'm Duncan Relic, no relation, and I collect relics from before the burn.
18:24Thanks to a temporal wormhole, I now have an unlimited supply of Trek culture t-shirts.
18:30And I'm selling them to you.
18:35You could be wearing this stylish down and up t-shirt.
18:39Or, how about this fish watching design?
18:42Bright yellow on black.
18:44The colours I'd use in thumbnails, I tell you that for nothing.
18:47I plan to take these designs and transfer them via quantum duplication onto hats, mugs, and posters.
18:56So look out for those.
18:58Back!
19:01Treat this unlimited supply as a limited time deal.
19:06Get your t-shirt quick.
19:07Who's your daddy?
19:30Thank you so much for watching along.
19:32Did you know that you can also listen in and catch every episode of our podcast
19:37just by following the link in the description below this video.
19:40Please make sure that you're subscribed to the channel
19:42and please make sure you're following us on the various socials.
19:44Till I see you again, look after yourselves.
19:47Make sure that you live long and prosper.

Recommended