• 52 minutes ago
The report analyses winter air pollution in North India caused by stubble burning, comparing higher fires in Punjab with Haryana's effective control using protection forces and incentives.

Category

🗞
News
Transcript
00:00And sticking with, you know, air pollution, let's shift our focus to one of the reasons why North India turns
00:05toxic every winter.
00:07And one of the reasons that everybody loves to blame is double burning.
00:11Two neighbouring states for Delhi, but two different realities.
00:15We're talking about Punjab and Haryana.
00:17And let's compare now Punjab's double burning problem with that of Haryana,
00:22which has, you know, in a sense, gotten rid of its menace.
00:26That's at least the analysis that India today has done that really shows.
00:30Up to November 17th this year, Punjab had reported over 6,516 farm fires.
00:35In Haryana, the number is 256.
00:39But before we compare the two states, there's something important to remember.
00:42Punjab has actually made significant progress over the last few years as well.
00:45In 2020, the state recorded more than 80,000 farm fires.
00:49The numbers came down around 70,000 in 21, came down to 48,000 over there almost in 22,
00:552, then came down to 33 in 23 and just over 8,000 in 24.
01:00So they have made progress, but not as fast as Haryana.
01:06There has been a massive reduction.
01:08But this year, the numbers have started rising again, for Punjab at least.
01:13This year, we've seen numbers go from 5,000, which was in 2025, to about 6,500 recorded.
01:20And this is just November 17th that we're looking at.
01:23Punjab has crossed this entire 2025 tally.
01:26The latest figure is also 27% higher than the same period last year.
01:31So, why is Punjab still struggling?
01:34And what is Haryana doing differently?
01:37First, let's understand why farmers burn stubble in the first place.
01:41After paddy is harvested, a large amount of the straw is left behind the fields.
01:46Farmers have only about 15-20 days to clear and prepare the land for the next wheat crop.
01:51And burning the straw is quick, it's cheap, it's done.
01:53Clearing it without burning takes much more time, machinery and also money.
01:58Farmers also need someone who can buy or use those leftover straws as well.
02:02And Punjab has a much bigger challenge here because the area under the paddy cultivation in Punjab is almost twice
02:08that of Haryana.
02:09So, factor that.
02:11In 2025, Punjab produced around 19.3 million tons of paddy straw.
02:16Haryana has about 8.55 million.
02:19Right?
02:20More than double.
02:22So, what is Haryana doing differently?
02:24The state is combining financial help with stricter checks.
02:28This year, Haryana announced an incentive of 1,200 rupees per acre for farmers who are using the machines to
02:37manage the leftover straw.
02:39It has also appointed more than 8,000 officers to keep a check on the villages.
02:43A special team called the Parali Protection Force has been set up to stop farm fires.
02:48The state has also announced drone surveillance and late-night patrols.
02:51And there are penalties.
02:53The verified cases of stubble burning, farmers can face an FIR and a fine and a red entry in their
03:00land records.
03:02But does that mean Punjab has done nothing?
03:04Not at all.
03:05Punjab has around 1.79 lakh machines to help farmers manage the leftover straw.
03:10It also has more than 26,000 centres where farmers, you know, rent these machines.
03:14The state is offering subsidies to encourage farmers to use them as well.
03:18But there is a difference in how the two states are using the leftover straw.
03:26Haryana uses a much larger share of its paddy straw as animal fodder.
03:31In 2025, it used around 2.2 million tonnes of this, you know, of the paddy straw.
03:36Punjab has used about 0.86 million tonnes over there.
03:40And then there is a political dimension as is always the case in India.
03:45Punjab has had a non-NDA government since 2017.
03:49The Congress was in power from 2017 to 2022, followed by Amati Party.
03:53Haryana, meanwhile, has had BGB government since 2014.
03:56Farmers need affordable machines, access to them.
03:58There is a consistency in the kind of policy that has been rolled out for them as well.
04:02Punjab has shown that farm fires can be brought down sharply.
04:06But the rise in case this year is a reminder that the problem is far from over.
04:12And unless the alternatives become easier, more affordable for farmers,
04:17stubble burning will remain a challenge.
04:20We are not saying it's the reason behind Delhi's air going bad,
04:23but clearly the reason behind the spike that we see in the winter,
04:28where we are already trapped in a bowl.
04:30To be continued...
04:32...

Recommended