00:00European Commissioner for the Economy, Valdis Tombrowski.
00:02It's really good to have you with us.
00:04So first, as Maria said, some positive news there in terms of the growth,
00:08but isn't this inevitably being overshadowed by the increasing public debt
00:15that we're seeing in many countries and also inflationary pressure which continues?
00:19Well, first of all, it's clear that the EU economy is again proving resilient
00:26to the consecutive external shocks we are facing.
00:29So this is a case also now with this energy supply and price shock we're experiencing right now.
00:35So we have upgraded up the EU's growth forecast to 1.4% growth both this year and next.
00:43And for the euro area, as you mentioned, 1.2% growth for this year and next.
00:48At the same time, indeed, if you look at the energy prices,
00:52this energy price shock has turned out more persistent than initially for a scene.
00:59So we now expect higher for longer energy prices.
01:03And that's obviously affecting our inflation outlook,
01:07where we expect inflation to stay elevated about 3% also next year
01:12before moving back to the ECB target of around 2% in 2028.
01:18We're also, as I said, seeing debt levels climbing in many countries,
01:22France and Belgium, as you mentioned this afternoon, causing the most concern at the moment.
01:27And the figures for France are quite, you know, extraordinary.
01:30123% of GDP in terms of public debt by 2028.
01:35Is this now a risk to financial stability in the broader European Union?
01:39Well, first of all, it's worth noting that there are several other EU member states
01:44which have a deficit above 5% of GDP.
01:48But in any case, it's clear, seeing also the interest rate developments globally,
01:56not only in the EU, seeing that markets are increasingly differentiating
02:01across EU member states, so the spreads are also increasing.
02:06It's important that member states pursue responsible fiscal policies,
02:12follow the fiscal trajectories agreed in the medium-term fiscal structural plans,
02:18and make sure that they are in line with the EU fiscal rules.
02:23But how much do you worry, Commissioner, about the situation in France?
02:27Because that is where the market attention is focused on.
02:30You're seeing a campaign, a lot of political volatility.
02:33You called clearly for fiscal responsibility.
02:35You need to make tough decisions.
02:37That means in some way you either grow your economy,
02:39but you cut the forecast for the French economy,
02:42or you make difficult cuts in public spending.
02:45I don't see anyone on the campaign trail advocating for those difficult decisions.
02:49Do you rule out a sovereign debt crisis triggered by that sort of politics?
02:53Well, first of all, if we discuss interest rate developments,
02:56it's part of the broader trend.
02:59If, for example, the French 10-year interest rates have reached 5.5%,
03:05that's also U.S. 10-year interest rates.
03:10So those are broader developments which we are facing.
03:14We do not see any, so to say, immediate market risks.
03:18So the demand for the French government won't remain strong.
03:22But obviously it's important to send the right signal.
03:26And from that point of view, it's important to have an agreement on next year's budget,
03:32which would be in line with fiscal rules.
03:35So the French government had put forward an ambitious draft budgetary plan for 2027,
03:40which would bring France in line with its medium-term fiscal structural plan.
03:47But now it's important that it's agreed and implemented.
03:50But there is a question around the interest rates and how you place that debt.
03:54The head of the French central bank, Emmanuel Moulin,
03:57he said we cannot become strangled by interest rates.
04:00So is it your message, as Emmanuel Macron prepares to depart,
04:04that whoever takes over that French government,
04:06and the pen seems to be heading into a full-on clash with the European Commission,
04:10that this is a risky move.
04:12You really need to make these decisions.
04:14It's inevitable.
04:15You have to make tough fiscal decisions.
04:17Well, as regards fiscal discipline,
04:21indeed it's an important message in the current market environment,
04:25in the current interest rate environment.
04:28It's clear that that message will be also very much emphasising
04:33when we'll be presenting the European semester autumn cycle next week.
04:38And, Commissioner, we must also ask you this evening, of course,
04:42tomorrow we're expecting the Commission to table a proposal
04:44on how it's going to raise €45 billion in aid to Ukraine
04:50in joint borrowing against the EU budget.
04:52What can we expect tomorrow?
04:54Well, indeed.
04:56So what we see is that due to the fact that Russia has intensified
05:02its war against Ukraine,
05:03intensified attacks against critical infrastructure in Ukraine,
05:08pursuing Black Sea ports, blockage, and so on,
05:13the financing needs of Ukraine has increased,
05:16both in terms of military needs and in terms of also budget support.
05:20So we estimate its funding gap of around €70 billion for next year.
05:26And we would aim to cover some two-thirds of this.
05:31So, yes, €45 billion to be more specific.
05:37And so we're going to outline our proposal for this tomorrow.
05:41But as you said, Russia keeps escalating its attacks
05:44despite the diplomatic push to accelerate peace negotiations.
05:47There is no sign at the moment this war is ending.
05:50For how long can Europe really sustain this,
05:54continuing to fund Ukraine at this rate by borrowing,
05:58especially given that the cost of borrowing is skyrocketing?
06:02Well, obviously, it's important to continue both to support Ukraine,
06:08but also to put a pressure on aggressor Russia to stop its aggression.
06:13And there, Russia only understands position of strengths.
06:18So in a sense, the stronger pressure we put against Russia as an aggressor state,
06:22the faster we can arrive at real peace process.
06:26Because currently, as you rightly noted, Russia shows no interest in any serious engagement in the peace process.
06:33But in terms of the borrowing and the joint borrowing,
06:35for how long do you think the political appetite will stay there?
06:40You know, are you going to have to resort in the end to reviving the conversation,
06:44for example, around the frozen assets?
06:45Well, on this, first of all, it's worth noting that already in our existing Ukraine support regulation,
06:52we have explicitly foreseen that what we provide to Ukraine is a non-recourse loan.
06:59So Ukraine...
07:00But they will not pay it back, Commissioner.
07:01You know it.
07:02They cannot repay this loan.
07:03No, that's what I'm saying.
07:04Ukraine only would need to pay it back when Russia pays reparations,
07:09which obviously invites a question, what happens if Russia does not pay reparations?
07:13And on this, we have explicitly foreseen in regulations that in this case,
07:18the Union reserves the rights to use immobilized Russian sovereign assets.
07:24Okay, Commissioner Dombrovskis, thank you so much for your time and for joining us on Europe tonight.