Skip to playerSkip to main content
  • 16 minutes ago
Deputy leader of Medway Council Teresa Murray and business strategist Dr Tim Aker join Rob Bailey.

Category

📺
TV
Transcript
00:22Welcome to the Kent Politics Show on KMTV. I'm Rob Bailey.
00:25Many Kent families will get a £100 winter fuel payment from the government this winter to help with the cost
00:31of living.
00:31The first budget since Andy Burnham became Prime Minister also included a freeze on fuel duty, help for first-time
00:38buyers and some tax relief for pensioners.
00:40But we'll start with struggling high streets.
00:43Chancellor John Healy raised the business rates threshold and said many small businesses will not pay rates at all.
00:49But he also raised the minimum wage by 3.9%.
00:52Reporter Maisie Walker talked to Kent businesses about what this really means for them.
00:58And for 2.3 million of our lowest paid workers, I'm increasing both the national minimum wage and the national
01:04living wage by 3.9%.
01:08Well, there you have it. This year's autumn budget has just been announced and many business owners are not happy.
01:14While they understand the need for minimum and living wage increases, owners across Kent are concerned about keeping their businesses
01:21afloat.
01:22Despite the business rates threshold rising to £18,000, meaning an extra 70,000 businesses will be exempt.
01:31I want to pay my carers more, so the rise of the national minimum wage is great, but there was
01:37nothing for small providers' relief.
01:40Like for us as care providers, we run on a very, very low margin, but there was no budget for
01:45social care at all.
01:47I don't know. I don't have words for it, like, you know, like how to describe my dissatisfaction with this
01:52budget.
01:53Do you almost, as a small business owner, feel dismissed or forgotten about it?
01:58Yeah, completely, completely dismissed, completely forgotten.
02:01We saw the national minimum wage be increased and it's just putting up the cost of employing people.
02:07And if the government was serious about supporting young people back into work, it would create more incentives for businesses
02:13to actually go out there and employ young people.
02:15Building up to it, it was all about small businesses and so the word was used a lot, but I
02:21couldn't see any policy or measures that actually specifically supported small business owners.
02:27For businesses across Kent, this year's autumn budget has left many feeling unsupported as they question how they'll keep going
02:35this time.
02:36Maisie Walker for KMTV in Ebb Street.
02:40And here with me is Theresa Murray, Labour's Deputy Leader of Medway Council and Business Strategist and former UKIP MEP,
02:47Dr Tim Aker.
02:48Thank you very much for joining me.
02:49Tim, I think it would be fair to say that John Healy wanted this budget to be one that unleashed
02:55businesses.
02:56It gave them the confidence to create jobs, to create growth.
03:01Do you think he succeeded?
03:03Well, it was going into a budget that was meant to unleash an election.
03:08And instead, it was one that was a damp squib, as you've heard from the businesses there.
03:12The business rates thing is great, but the detail means not as many are going to be benefited from.
03:18For instance, if a business has many properties and many business outlets, they're not covered with the business rate relief.
03:26The £100 for homeowners, yeah, that's grand.
03:29But the cost of petrol and diesel going up, that's one tank.
03:33Right, so these are sticking plaster policies for an arterial bleed.
03:37It's not really enough.
03:38And when you've got the minimum wage going up and no relief on employers' national insurance, that's another burden on
03:44businesses.
03:44We've got nearly a million young people out of work.
03:48Surely they want to incentivise businesses to get these young people into work, and you don't do that by increasing
03:53the cost of employment.
03:54When I was listening to the budget on Wednesday, Teresa, I was thinking a lot about Chatham and Gillingham, because
03:59we are very close to both of those high streets here in the studio.
04:03And they seem to be the perfect case study, really.
04:05High streets which are struggling, where there's a lot of small independent businesses, the kind of businesses that I think
04:10were being targeted in that budget.
04:12Do you think that they will feel better today than they did at the start of the week?
04:16As much as I appreciate everything that Tim does for the small business community, and it's really interesting to hear
04:22what people had to say, I don't agree with the idea that it was a sticking plaster budget.
04:27And as far as young people are concerned, before I come to your question on the high streets, I don't
04:33think there would be another council that has taken that as seriously as we have.
04:37We've just opened the youth hub in partnership with the DWP at Mid-Kent College so that young people can
04:44come along and get help for jobs.
04:46We have made young people a priority as a Marmot place, tackling health inequality and making sure that those families
04:53who've got young people feel supported.
04:56There's been a change to universal credit so that somebody who gets an apprenticeship won't impact the rest of the
05:03family income.
05:04And yes, I understand that businesses would like more and we would do more.
05:09I don't know where this idea comes from, that it was a budget to unleash an election.
05:14Andy Burnham has been 100% clear that that wasn't the case.
05:17It was a budget for small bits of breathing space while we work on the wider issues that the government
05:24have got to tackle.
05:25And I understand the cost of fuel. It's changing everything.
05:30We had all Kent businesses at the university just a few weeks ago and heard from the Bank of England
05:36about the underlying strength of the economy.
05:38But every economist is absolutely clear.
05:40This terrible war in the Middle East is impacting the price of fuel.
05:44And I'm afraid locally there's nothing we can do about it except acknowledge it, keep the fuel duty down and
05:51try to take other measures.
05:54You know, that is something that is a global problem.
05:56So the government are facing various headwinds, aren't they?
06:00A global headwind with the war in the Middle East, making fuel across the world, including in America.
06:07We'll see what the electorate think of that next week.
06:10Making fuel across the world, very expensive.
06:13And as soon as fuel goes up, everything else goes up.
06:16And I know how tough that is for businesses.
06:18But we've got to work together.
06:20We've got to provide opportunities for young people.
06:23And I'm very pleased that lots of Medway businesses do do that already.
06:27Some of the bigger people, like Barclays, like Sainsbury's, have come in and said that they will offer large opportunities
06:34for young people to do apprenticeships and get work experience.
06:38And we've got to have a positive narrative.
06:39That's Barclays who have just cut 5,000 jobs because of AI across their entire business.
06:46I mean, that's got to be taking with one hand, giving with another again, hasn't it?
06:49Well, they have.
06:50But they were there at the opening of the youth hub promising to offer young people opportunities.
06:55You know, they've got to run their business according to technological changes like everyone else.
07:00But it doesn't mean that forever they'll never employ anybody else because their workforce will get older and all the
07:06rest of it.
07:07What we've got to stop is this depressing narrative for young people that there's no hope, that there's nothing for
07:13them.
07:13There absolutely is if we work together and make that happen.
07:16You've increased the cost of employing people.
07:18So how can there be hope when employers, the economy is 98% of small businesses.
07:24The majority of people who are employed under the minimum wage work for small businesses.
07:30And the government has just said, right, we're making it more difficult for you to employ people.
07:33We just heard Shweta say that she appreciates the need to pay people a decent wage.
07:38Yeah, and she also said that she can't afford to pay them more.
07:40Less than £14 is at least a wage that people can cope on.
07:47Well, hang on, hang on.
07:48We've got to subsidise everybody.
07:49Do you run a business?
07:50I don't run a business.
07:51Well, how can you understand the pressure that small businesses have?
07:54I do understand, Tim.
07:55Because you're not running the same race that they're running.
07:57As you know, Tim.
07:58They're employing people.
07:59They're looking after their family.
08:00They're looking after the families of their workers.
08:02They're dealing with the same pressures.
08:04And there was no relief whatsoever.
08:05They said it was a small business budget, as you've seen from the businesses themselves with skin in the game.
08:11There was very, very little there for small businesses.
08:13As you know, Tim, we pay attention to small businesses.
08:15We listen to you.
08:17I don't have to run a business to understand what is happening.
08:20There has been some rate relief for the very smaller businesses who will benefit from that.
08:25There has been a freeze on fuel duty.
08:27We are doing as much as we can for young people.
08:29The price of fuel is over half the price of fuel is taxed.
08:32There is a £3,000 bonus for people who take on a young person, available now and has been for
08:38some months.
08:39And I'm afraid I can't and the government can't stop the war in the Middle East at a stroke and
08:45prevent the terrible rise in fuel.
08:48But the government had other options, didn't it?
08:50I mean, some businesses might say that the national insurance rise that came under the previous Labour government, if you
08:56like, before Andy Burnham took over.
08:58That could have been undone, couldn't it?
09:00And that would help small businesses a lot more.
09:02We've got to make sure that we use all the resources available to the government to pay for all of
09:07the services that we need.
09:08That's why the banks have been taxed by an additional 3%.
09:1120 years ago, the British people had to help the banks get out of the crash.
09:17Now we're asking them to pay more to help us do some of these things.
09:21And we will do more.
09:22What John Healy isn't going to do is rush at the gate, making measures that he can't secure for the
09:27longer term.
09:28And I support that.
09:28And we're not going to do that either.
09:30But we can work together locally to think about how we approach our local landscape.
09:36We've got new businesses opening up here in Medway.
09:39And I'm sure that's true of Kent as well.
09:42We're making our high streets a different place in Chatham, obviously now in the Pentagon.
09:48We've got a community supermarket.
09:50We've got a health centre.
09:52Soon we'll have other council services in the Pentagon.
09:55We're making it a different place.
09:57There is more accommodation there.
09:585,000 people will help businesses as they get invested.
10:02The changing shape of the high streets is an interesting thing here.
10:04And obviously that's something that's been acknowledged in the budget.
10:06They're taxing the banks partly to help pay for some of the things that they're doing.
10:10But also vape shops and gambling shops, which with a cynical hat on, you'd say the two growth businesses on
10:16the high street these days.
10:16What did you make of that in terms of a revenue-raising scheme from Labour?
10:21We're at the position now where revenue raising, again, is just a sticking plaster.
10:26The government takes less in tax than it pays out in benefits, in income tax.
10:31That is completely unsustainable.
10:35The budget deficit is growing and growing.
10:37We're in £3 trillion of debt.
10:39And taxing a few vape shops and gambling shops, as welcome as that may be, is not going to fix
10:45it.
10:45There was no long-term vision.
10:47And what we would have liked to have seen, or what I would have liked to have seen from the
10:51Chancellor, is an escalator.
10:54They all talk about fiscal rules, right?
10:56So minimum wage goes up.
10:58Very difficult to argue against that, right?
11:00But if you're small businesses, the pressure now is unavoidable.
11:03Why not an escalator so when the minimum wage goes up, employers' national insurance goes down?
11:08You say to the business community, yes, we appreciate the pressures you're under.
11:12Here's some relief so you can pay people more.
11:14I don't know a single small business that doesn't want to pay their staff more.
11:18Because it's easier to keep someone than it is to find someone new.
11:22You want to keep people in.
11:23It's institutional knowledge.
11:25They know how to work the business.
11:27They know the clients, the customers.
11:28They're a part of the family, so keep them there.
11:31But there was nothing.
11:32There was no vision whatsoever.
11:33In fact, I think John Healy and Andy Burnham should come and see Medway, how you've done it with your
11:39business support program.
11:40Because there's tangible support there at the grassroots level.
11:43But we're not seeing any vision.
11:45That's all we've got time for in this hub.
11:47We'll be back after a short break.
11:49We'll have more on the budget when we come back.
11:52Stay with us.
12:15Stay with us.
12:15Stay with us.
21:23but it's about them rather than being about the whole of the population the
21:28biggest proportion of welfare Tim as you know and everybody knows the top 1% of
21:31taxpayers pay over a third of all I'm talking about welfare now the biggest
21:36proportion of well who pays for it the biggest proportion of welfare is
21:40pensioners we've got about aging that pension is a benefit no actual welfare
21:45benefits well pension is a welfare benefit that everybody gets we've got
21:51an aging population and more older people if Tim and other people think the
21:56older people don't deserve to have a pension when did I say that when did I
22:00say it but people are well then why do you create that ad hominem attack two
22:04urgent two urban myths one rich people running out of the country to Pippen
22:10Universal Credit is killing the welfare state we have to pay for our pensioners
22:15they must be our first priority looking after people who've worked into old age
22:22the productive sector of the economy pays the taxes you can't tax a pro you can't
22:26tax a loss you can only tax a profit right you need more people making profit in
22:31this country to get the taxes to pay for all of those benefits and including the
22:35pensions and if you keep squeezing the productive sector of the economy you will
22:39have to borrow money which means you'll need to repay it at a high rate which is
22:43why the debt interest the debt interest is over a hundred billion are you happy with
22:48that this kind of kind of faux anger about paying tax I'm afraid doesn't
22:53what again you don't really have to run a business we have got to run a business
22:58let me speak we have got to pay tax I'm happy that my taxes go to help you Tim when
23:03you need a service my taxes will help you get that service that's the essence of a
23:09benevolent welfare social society so I haven't got any problems in the structure
23:15of it I haven't got any problems with the productive sector of the economy a
23:20healthy private sector pays for these things and at the minute the budget and
23:24our business people who were questioned about it said that there's nothing for
23:29the healthy private sector is not the only people that pay tax people who work in
23:32the public sector pay tax when you drive up public services paid by the state you get
23:38tax revenue you get tax revenue from the people who earn that money and they do
23:43that as much as anybody in the private but where does the state get its money
23:46this is everybody paying to sources borrows it or it taxes the private sector
23:50you're putting this fantasy idea the private sector is the only people who pay
23:55tax people who work in the public sector pay tax but they're paid by the state
23:59and they use they use your businesses private sector there were no people paid by the
24:05state tim to the state you come and pays public sector workers paid by the state to come and use
24:10your business you wouldn't have a business if there was no private sector you have a public sector
24:14I'd like to cut just for a second because there's one thing I'd like to ask you about
24:16before we before we end the show which is about local government reorganisation and that
24:20feeds very much into this question about welfare we learn just after the budget that Kent is going to
24:26remain in limbo until next year that the government is still committed to LGR but we don't know what shape
24:30it will take
24:31you're in the middle of a budget setting process which has profound implications for
24:35welfare spending in Medway what does that how does that leave Medway in terms of your
24:40ability to plan for next year and beyond it leaves us doing what we're doing now
24:43business as usual planning for Medway there'll be in there was an announcement of
24:48five mayoral authorities there will be more by the end of the year and the final group
24:54early next year which I think is actually a sensible way of running out the way that devolution should go
25:01it is disappointing there's a human cost to this in terms of all of the workforce who've been
25:06working towards it that work is not wasted our workforce understand that I'm sure the workforce in Kent
25:12who've been doing the same understand that too we want to be a mayoral authority we want to have those
25:17devolved powers we want that the mayor to be able to work with business that isn't coming yet but it
25:23isn't
25:23a stasis of what's happening in the council what's happening in the council is going on business as usual
25:29working with businesses improving public services getting to grips with the demand for social care
25:35making sure that we've got the best education we can possibly offer making sure we've got parks and
25:41leisure facilities that help people have a good quality of life nothing has changed so in terms
25:46of budget planning we are planning for the nearly 300,000 people in Medway to need our services
25:52do you think it's business as usual where we're not sure what local government will look like in
25:56the future it's a farce isn't it it was a policy that rushed out at Christmas time a few years
26:02ago
26:03they spent god knows how much money on these consultations and to be told yes it's paused and
26:08it's restarted it's the okie-cokie it's it's it's farcical farcical another packed way of describing a
26:17government legislative process about which there have been legal challenges which have to be worked out
26:22and that was part of the government's manifesto devolution is important the prime minister is
26:27an absolute fan of devolution so we it will come when it comes Tim knows that we haven't stopped
26:33doing our business services or stop doing a healthy workplace sorry that is all we've got time for
26:38today thank you to both my guests for joining us Kent tonight's coming up with all the news from
26:42around the county and we'll be back next week with more debate and Kent politics we'll see you then
26:53you

Recommended