• 3 months ago
On NewsTrack, Marya Shakil spoke to Stimson Center Senior Fellow Austin Lord and HiMAP Senior Researcher Alton C. Byers about the growing disaster risks across the Himalayas. They discussed the Nepal floods, extreme rainfall, fragile terrain, the China factor, the need for greater information sharing and whether Switzerland-style 3D landslide simulation models could be adapted to the Himalayan region.

Category

🗞
News
Transcript
00:01Good evening, you're watching NewsTrack with me, Maria Shakeel.
00:04At least 1,000 people have lost their lives in the Nepal flash floods and the death toll is only
00:11expected to rise.
00:12But the question on everyone's mind is what triggered this devastating flood?
00:17Scientists say it was not a glacial lake outburst flood.
00:23Instead, the evidence points to a massive ice and rock avalanche high in the Himalayas.
00:31Around 5,200 metres up in the Langtang-Lirung region, a huge chunk of glacier broke away from the mountain.
00:40Tons of ice, rock and debris came crashing down into the Lende River.
00:46The falling ice and rock triggered a massive landslide, creating a temporary glacial lake in its path.
00:56Look at that map there.
00:58And as more ice, rock and debris came crashing down, another lake formed further along the mountain slope.
01:08The sudden surge then entered the Lende River and flowed into the Bhote-Koshi River system, racing downstream at staggering
01:17speed.
01:19Around 22 kilometres were covered in just over seven seconds.
01:25In fact, seven minutes.
01:2722 kilometres covered in just over seven minutes.
01:32The flood also devastated key infrastructure along its path.
01:36The debris-filled torrent swept through settlements, destroying homes, roads and bridges along the flood path.
01:43And the flood also affected the Gairong border.
01:48That was the crossing, a border crossing and a key crossing that is there between Nepal and Tibet.
01:54Scientists say further field investigations are now needed to establish the precise mechanism that is behind this collapse.
02:03But the disaster has once again put the spotlight on the fragile Himalayan region and the challenges that India, Nepal
02:10and China must confront together.
02:13Before I bring in the guests, here's a report.
02:23Death, devastation, destruction and despair.
02:30Year after year, nation after nation.
02:34And one mountain range, the Himalayas.
02:42The Himalayas are the youngest major mountain system on earth, formed 50 to 70 million years ago.
02:50Home to some of the highest peaks and also the source of some of Asia's greatest rivers.
02:57But of late, they have become a disaster zone.
03:03And the question now is, why are the Himalayas becoming such a great challenge, making way for catastrophes, often with
03:13little or no warnings?
03:16What happened in Nepal came with no warning.
03:20And it is certainly not the first time we have seen something like this.
03:30Uttarakhand floods in 2013 and 2021.
03:37In 2023, it was Sikkim.
03:39A glacial lake outburst triggered massive flooding.
03:45In 2024, Nepal was battered by floods.
03:52And now flash floods near the Nepal-Tibet border.
03:56Different countries, different rivers, different triggers, but the same mountains.
04:06The reasons lie in the Himalayas themselves.
04:10One, that they are still rising.
04:12Because they are relatively young mountains.
04:16The tectonic plates are still pushing against each other.
04:21The rocks are fractured.
04:22The slopes are unstable, making the entire mountain system naturally vulnerable.
04:30The terrain is also a problem.
04:32It adds to the risk.
04:34The Himalayas also hold vast amounts of ice.
04:38But climate change is adding another layer of danger.
04:46Glaciers are retreating.
04:48Snow is melting.
04:49New glacial lakes are forming.
04:53And when these lakes fill up behind unstable walls of rock and ice,
04:57a sudden breach can unleash enormous volumes of water and debris downhill.
05:06And then comes the human pressure.
05:08We want towns, roads, dams, hydropower projects, hotels, and most importantly, tourism.
05:20Development is essential for people living in the mountains.
05:24But building on an already fragile landscape can make the consequences of a natural event far more devastating.
05:36And the warning signs are increasingly difficult to ignore.
05:41And this is not a crisis any one country can tackle alone.
05:45The Himalayan ecosystem stretches across India, Nepal, and China.
05:53Its rivers cross borders.
05:55Its glaciers and mountain systems are interconnected.
05:59But geopolitical tensions can make cooperation difficult.
06:04The question is, can the countries sharing the Himalayas put their differences aside before the next disaster strikes?
06:13So what can be done?
06:16First, close monitoring.
06:20Glaciers and glacier lakes need round-the-clock monitoring using satellites, sensors, and ground-based systems.
06:28Second, early warning.
06:31Warning systems must detect sudden glacier collapses, avalanches, and rapid changes in glacial lakes, giving communities enough time to evacuate.
06:43Third, build responsibly.
06:46Roads, dams, and tourism infrastructure can't be planned as if the Himalayas were ordinary terrain.
06:54Environmental assessments must consider the cumulative impact of multiple projects on already unstable slopes.
07:04Fourth, share data.
07:07India, Nepal, and China need stronger mechanisms to share information on glaciers, rivers, rainfall, and potential hazards.
07:19And that's what voices from India and Nepal are saying too.
07:24It's important that relief, yes, must happen immediately.
07:31And it's important that a calamity of this nature and volume should not be left just to the Nepali government.
07:39It's important the world bodies participate in this because it's beyond any single government to handle this kind of situations.
07:47Great neighbors, China, India, Nepal, somehow join hands in this and do something collectively.
08:08Because the Himalayan disaster does not stop at a national border.
08:13Rivers don't do borders.
08:15They just flow.
08:17And the data should do.
08:19Lives are precious.
08:21The Himalayas are telling us something.
08:24The SOS is loud and clear.
08:27And we must pay heed.
08:31Bureau Report, India Today.
08:36And joining me now is Dr. Austin Lord.
08:38He is a senior fellow at the Stimson Center in Washington, D.C.
08:42And an anthropologist who has been working in exactly this region of Nepal for 14 years.
08:48Austin, appreciate your time.
08:49The Bote-Kochi disaster began in Tibet and hit Nepal within hours.
08:55A reminder that Himalayan rivers don't stop at borders.
09:00But China doesn't share real-time hydrological data with downstream countries the way established international water treaties would require.
09:09Is this silence on data sharing now a security risk, not just an environmental one?
09:18Well, first I would say thank you for the question.
09:21I would start with two things.
09:22One, this event did originate in Nepal.
09:28The initial source area of this disaster was actually on the Nepal side, on the backside of the Langtang Range,
09:35near to the China border.
09:37But the initial bedrock and glacial collapse that started this whole cascading flood event, it began in Nepal.
09:45And then it flowed north into the river on the border of Nepal and China.
09:50The second thing I'd clarify really quickly is just that the event actually, the latest scientific estimates, they calculated that
10:01the front of the flood surge actually reached the Nepal-China border within 10 minutes,
10:10it's an estimated eight minutes, perhaps, from the initial fracture in the mountains.
10:15So this came extremely fast.
10:19I've said in other interviews, and I'm sure everyone has also heard, this is not the type of disaster.
10:26There are kinds of transboundary disasters and floods where monitoring and information sharing improvements in those fields could be useful.
10:35This type of disaster at the moment, with these massive glacial collapses, unless there's a sense of where to look
10:43and where to monitor,
10:44it's very difficult to collect real-time information to share because it's, to use a simple metaphor,
10:50it's like looking for needles in haystacks across the Himalayan Range, whether it's Nepal or China.
10:56The last thing I would say in answer to your question is that information sharing has been improving since the
11:04time of the event.
11:05I think it's actually somewhat encouraging, the state of communication.
11:10And there's been several, I can go into more detail, but there's been several follow-on risks or new risks
11:17emerging after the disaster
11:19that China actually has been communicating quite clearly with the proper Nepalese alerting authorities on.
11:26Since you're speaking about new risks, Austin, will the frequency of such catastrophic events increase?
11:38It's difficult to say with precision, but I'm comfortable saying that the frequency of these events is increasing.
11:45In the last 10 to 15 years, we've seen multiple events.
11:49I know viewers in India are familiar with the Chamali disaster that struck Uttarakhand in 2021,
11:57the South Lonak Glaf that struck Sikkim in 2023, just to name two.
12:03Nepal itself has experienced, not at this scale, but it has experienced both other kinds of extreme collapse events,
12:11extreme flow events, and it has experienced trans-boundary floods, several in recent years.
12:17So I think it is absolutely apparent to both the scientific community and to governments in the region, India included,
12:27that the intensity, the frequency is certainly increasing, and it seems as if the intensity is also increasing,
12:34in part because you have these coupled risks or these confluent risks coming together from seismic risk,
12:42monsoon risk, and different sorts of climate risks related to the destabilization of the mountain environment,
12:50what we could call the cryosphere or the frozen mountain world.
12:53So then are we supposed to be living with it?
13:00That is the important question.
13:03Folks, I will say folks in the Himalayan region have been living with similar risks for centuries
13:08and have been adapting, living with mountain hazards as part of life in the Himalayas.
13:15I say that as an environmental anthropologist who spent a lot of time.
13:19I'm also a survivor of a Himalayan disaster.
13:23In 2015, the earthquake, the Gorkha earthquake in Nepal triggered a massive avalanche
13:29just on the other side of this mountain, Langtang-Lirung, and I was there,
13:33and I've talked to people in that community who have been living with these type of disasters
13:36and these risks for a long time.
13:38The sense is that the scale and the error bars are changing.
13:42There's sort of two things to point out.
13:45One, as we said, the severity and the increasing, the severity is increasing,
13:49or the frequency is increasing, so people have to be on alert or living with these risks,
13:55and more often perhaps or more consistently.
13:58The seasonality of some of these risks is also different, right?
14:01Sometimes a late-season snowstorm can do a lot of damage.
14:04Sometimes extreme warming trends or an El Nino year, for example, could lead to more events.
14:09So there is the climate-related impacts that are forcing people to live with these events,
14:15but then undoubtedly there's also people, the other aspect of disaster, right?
14:21It's not just hazard, it's exposure and vulnerability.
14:23So you have people, for a variety of reasons, making the decision to live with,
14:30or they don't all have an equal say in making the decision,
14:33but living in places that are exposed and moving into floodplains.
14:39Urbanization of floodplains is something that a lot of people in Nepal have been talking about.
14:42It's a natural instinct, right, to want economic development
14:47and to want to move where you have opportunities for business and for your family.
14:52But in this case, you know, the Rasuwa Corridor on the Nepal side,
14:56that district is called Rasuwa, of this disaster area.
15:01That has become a major trade corridor since 2015.
15:06After the earthquake in 2015 closed effectively another corridor,
15:11this one became the major corridor, and that has also led to an influx of population.
15:17There's a lot of people there working on hydropower projects.
15:19That's something I've been studying for actually 12 years in the same corridor,
15:24these same communities.
15:24I've even been in some of these tunnels where people have been trapped.
15:29It's extremely tragic.
15:30People come from all around Nepal to work and have opportunities in hydropower projects.
15:34It's just a labor job in most cases.
15:37Sometimes it's technical.
15:38But you have people moving into these areas for a variety of reasons,
15:42and that's why collectively a new multi-hazard risk assessment needs to be done
15:49with this new lens, right?
15:51Thinking about the frequency of these disasters, thinking about how it could be a combination of
15:57different factors that could increase both exposure and vulnerability of infrastructure,
16:01for example.
16:02It needs to be done collectively at a watershed scale.
16:06It doesn't matter whether it's the Nepal-China border or it's another trans-boundary border.
16:10Coordination is critical to understand how the risks throughout the entire watershed could converge
16:16in an event like this.
16:17Sadhguru has spoken about the need for five-nation Himalayan board,
16:22which should have India, China, Pakistan, Nepal, Bhutan, one table,
16:26and they should come up with a plan because, you know,
16:29there's a need to deal with disasters in this fragile mountain region.
16:34But let's be honest, China and India don't even agree on where the border is.
16:38So is this a good idea?
16:39But perhaps people will not have appetite for it.
16:43But because of the nature of challenges, and it's so huge, Himalayan challenges,
16:48one would say, there is and there has to be an engagement now.
16:56I would say first, I agree with the last part of what you said.
16:59There has to be engagement because of the nature of the challenges we face.
17:03And also, I would say I greatly appreciate that proposal from Sadhguru.
17:08And I hope that more people come to the table to discuss the possibility.
17:13Again, I think, so this is sort of a divergent, well, I'll end there.
17:17But I think, again, I've been encouraged by the level of activity
17:21and information sharing since the event.
17:23I have looked at other transboundary events in recent years.
17:27There was even one in 2025 in the same river.
17:31It was a different type of flow event.
17:34It was a super glacial lake flood.
17:37So it was a lake on top of a glacier that drained quickly
17:40and sent a flood pulse through the same area.
17:43It damaged the same Nepal-China bridge.
17:46It was a smaller scale.
17:47So there's been these other wake-up call events.
17:50And, again, it doesn't matter if it's the Nepal-China border or another.
17:53There have been wake-up call events.
17:55And I would just say that in the wake of this particular large-scale,
17:59extremely tragic event, it seems like something is being catalyzed.
18:03And if you have actors, right, or people in the mix like Sadhguru
18:09who are calling for this, I think that's positive momentum.
18:13I think from the China side, obviously I can't speak on behalf of anyone there,
18:17but it seems as if there is a greater interest.
18:20And there are more different types of stakeholders who seem legitimately interested
18:25in creating a new model or a new paradigm.
18:28I think they're just trying to figure out the right –
18:31they recognize both the need to get the approach right
18:34and to go through the formal channels.
18:36So it's not something that can be rushed, but a catalyzing event like this
18:41might make something that has historically not been very likely or possible
18:46and politically difficult.
18:47It might make it space to increase the quality of the conversation.
18:52Okay.
18:53So let me ask my last and final question here, Austin.
18:55The SOS has clearly been sounded.
18:58Glacial lakes bursting, landslides multiplying,
19:02the earthquake threat never going away.
19:05So my question is simple and direct.
19:06Have we already crossed the point of no return,
19:08or is there still time to act?
19:15I think there is still time to act.
19:19When it comes to setting up early warning systems,
19:22when it comes to multi-hazard risk assessment,
19:23when it comes to better planning and information sharing,
19:28and basically just all kinds of dialogue at a basin scale,
19:32there is time.
19:34And, again, there's sort of two kinds of time, right?
19:38There's sort of planning time, which takes years,
19:41which takes thoughtful engagement,
19:43which takes working with the private sector as well and governments.
19:47That must be done.
19:48It will not happen overnight.
19:50It's slower.
19:51And then in addition to that,
19:53there's the time, the immediate urgent time of disaster response.
19:58There's the need to do anything that can increase the quantity
20:04and of lead time that you receive via an alert
20:08when there's an event like this,
20:10and the quality of the information you may receive.
20:13So it's a difficult moment to say that we're,
20:20of course, we are struggling with climate risks
20:23that many people thought would be far in the future,
20:25and many people don't even want to talk about.
20:27So it is in part true that time is catching up with us.
20:33But I would like to think that there is still hope.
20:37And then every year in the future as we go forward,
20:41if we can make improvements now,
20:43we will save lives in the years to come
20:46because these risks are not going away.
20:48I think that is the right note to end this conversation.
20:51Austin Lord, I appreciate your time.
20:53Joining me now is Alton Byers.
20:55He is the Senior Research Associate,
20:58Co-Manager, High Mountains Adaptation Partnership,
21:02and Senior Fellow at the Mountain Institute.
21:05Mr. Byers, every time a Himalayan disaster strikes,
21:08there is post-mortem that is done.
21:11And scientists say that the warning signs were there.
21:14So let me ask you a plain and direct question.
21:17Is Nepal's flood an unpredictable act of nature?
21:21Or the price, one would say, of ignoring signs we already had?
21:29I think that is true to a certain extent
21:32that some of the indicators of a potential catastrophic event
21:38are always there.
21:40But to predict with precision when something of this magnitude will happen
21:45is very, very difficult.
21:48However, at the same time,
21:49I do think that we are about to enter an era
21:52where scientists will start looking much more seriously
21:56at ways that we can,
21:58through remote sensing and drone imagery
22:00and hopefully more ground field work,
22:03get a better idea on how we can flag the areas of highest concern,
22:08areas with overhanging ice,
22:10areas with villages,
22:13urban areas down lower in the watershed.
22:16I think that we can not predict with precision,
22:19but we can do a much better job than we have so far.
22:22Okay.
22:23Roads, that is, hydropower projects,
22:26tourism infrastructure,
22:27all expanding rapidly across the Himalayan valleys,
22:30even as the region turns more fragile by the year.
22:35So, Mr. Byers,
22:36as someone who has been working
22:38on high mountain adaptation for decades,
22:41is this development sustainable
22:42or are we building our vulnerabilities on borrowed time?
22:51Well, like it or not,
22:53it has happened.
22:54You're completely right.
22:57There's been a phenomenal urbanization of watersheds,
23:02especially in high-risk zone,
23:05in floodplains in the last 20, 30 years
23:08in Nepal, India, and elsewhere.
23:11So, it's going to happen again and again.
23:16So, the main questions on my mind is,
23:19how can we do a better job of predicting?
23:21How can we do a better job
23:24of developing early warning systems
23:26that are truly effective?
23:27And how can we reduce the level of damage
23:31for urban areas that already exist?
23:34You can't pick up these urban areas
23:37and move them to higher ground.
23:39They're there,
23:40and they're always going to be there.
23:42And if this were 1985,
23:44we wouldn't be having this discussion
23:46because there were no urban areas
23:48in these floodplains.
23:50All the villages were up high.
23:52Only the agricultural fields were down low.
23:55So, I think that we're shifting more and more,
24:00certainly what I'm seeing from the media
24:01and my colleagues in Nepal.
24:03We're looking at these three fundamental questions
24:05in terms of a future direction.
24:08So, let's try and find answers
24:10to the three fundamental questions
24:12that you're speaking about.
24:13Can technology then actually keep pace
24:15with how fast these events unfold?
24:18Or are we always going to be
24:20one step behind the mountain?
24:25I think we're always going to be
24:28at the mercy of the mountains.
24:29These events started some time ago, long ago,
24:33and they're increasing in frequency
24:35and magnitude now.
24:37On the other hand,
24:39I have confidence in science
24:42to increase our ability
24:44to predict dangerous areas anyway,
24:49to develop early warning systems
24:52that are truly effective,
24:53that have had a pretty dismal record
24:55until now, up till now.
24:58And, of course,
24:59how to mitigate future damage
25:03to areas that already exist.
25:07Yes.
25:07Mr. Baas, since you're speaking
25:08about early warning systems,
25:11India is actually accelerating
25:12early warning systems.
25:13Nepal and China share some glacial data.
25:16But the Bote Koshy's own warning system
25:19was designed to track
25:21gradual glacier movement,
25:23not the sudden surge
25:25that hit last week.
25:30Yeah.
25:31And that's what I think
25:32we need to be prepared for,
25:34an order of magnitude
25:35of catastrophic event
25:37way beyond what we've been
25:39preparing for in the past.
25:41I think we need to look at
25:42new types of early warning systems as well.
25:44Somebody made the point
25:46that even if there had been
25:48a system measuring water level
25:52on bridges above the Tresoli
25:55and Shabrubesi
25:57and other villages
25:57that were impacted,
25:59those bridges were destroyed.
26:01So we need something more,
26:05something higher up
26:06beaming a laser down on the river
26:08to give us an indication
26:10of an abrupt change in water level.
26:13Now, in the times
26:15that between the onset
26:17of the catastrophic event
26:18and arrival at an urban area
26:20are going to vary,
26:22but hopefully with a combination
26:23of early warning systems,
26:26it could be cell phone based,
26:28it could be old fashioned sirens,
26:30that'll be accompanied also
26:31by an evacuation plan
26:33so that when people hear the sirens,
26:36they'll know this time
26:37not to run downstream,
26:38but to run uphill.
26:40And there are models,
26:42there are models that we can look at.
26:45For example, in Hokkaido,
26:46in Japan,
26:48there are this very sophisticated system
26:50of early warning systems for tsunami.
26:53So if people hear the sirens,
26:54they know exactly where to drive uphill,
26:57where to run uphill.
26:59You know, after Blatton was destroyed
27:01by a glacier collapse in 2025,
27:04Switzerland's advanced monitoring
27:06and evacuation systems
27:07helped limit casualties.
27:10But the Himalayan geology
27:12is vastly different.
27:13And here, disasters
27:14like the Bote-Kochi flood
27:16cross straight from Tibet
27:18into Nepal,
27:19with impact reaching India too.
27:22So, Mr. Byers,
27:23is a Switzerland-style model
27:25even transferable here?
27:29I think that remains to be seen,
27:31but I think that the model
27:32developed in Blatton
27:33that proved to be very effective
27:36shows promise.
27:37And I would urge scientists
27:41and natural hazard specialists
27:43to look very seriously at that.
27:45Yes, the Himalayas are different.
27:47Yes, the magnitude of the events
27:49tend to be much larger.
27:51But, yes, I think there is a lot of promise
27:56in that model
27:57and other models as well.
27:58And, you know,
27:59people aren't sitting still.
28:01I'm seeing and hearing
28:03from my colleagues in Nepal
28:04that there are already serious discussions
28:07in China, in Nepal,
28:10in India, elsewhere,
28:12about how do we refine,
28:14how do we improve
28:16a Himalayan-specific model
28:18of early warning systems
28:20or models, plural,
28:22of early warning systems?
28:23All right, Alton Byers,
28:25I appreciate your time.
28:26Thank you for joining us.
28:27We are putting out
28:28those two interviews
28:28on our website
28:29and also on the YouTube channel.
28:31That's all from me.
28:32Thanks so much for watching.

Recommended