Skip to playerSkip to main content
  • 2 months ago
The debate surrounding whether FIFA favored Lionel Messi at the World Cup has become one of the most discussed topics in modern football.

Supporters of Cristiano Ronaldo often interpret Argentina’s path to the trophy through a lens of controversy, tactical advantage, and perceived institutional preference.

At the same time, Messi’s supporters argue that his success was the natural result of elite performance, leadership, and years of international persistence.

This article explores the claims, the evidence, the context, and the broader football landscape that shaped the conversation.

It also examines how media narratives, officiating decisions, tournament structure, and player legacy all influence the perception that FIFA favored Messi at the World Cup.
Transcript
00:00A single social media like from Cristiano Ronaldo has football fans talking again.
00:05He appeared to endorse a post-accusing FIFA of favoring Lionel Messi and Argentina at the World
00:10Cup. But once you see exactly what was written, you'll understand why this has exploded.
00:14The like that said everything. There was no press conference, no statement through a
00:19representative, no interview granted to a friendly outlet. There was only a small red
00:23heart appearing under a video on Instagram, and the name attached to that heart belonged
00:28to the most followed athlete on the planet. By around July 20, 2026, the screenshots were
00:33everywhere. Facebook, Instagram, TikTok, X, Reddit, group chats, and a dozen languages.
00:38They all showed the same thing. A reel posted by the Spanish television program Espigio
00:42Público, sitting on somewhere between 150,000 and 188,000 likes, and in the list of accounts
00:47that had engaged with it, the verified handle, Cristiano. In some versions of the screenshot,
00:52it was rendered in French. Aim par Cristiano.
00:55So Cristiano Ronaldo has just liked a post that is accusing FIFA and Argentina of corruption.
01:00That clip is not even from this tournament. That is a creator reacting to an earlier,
01:04near-identical incident involving Argentina's 2022 title, which tells you the habit has a track record.
01:10But the 2026 version landed differently because of what was actually being said in the video he endorsed.
01:16And the reel's Spanish journalist Pilar Rodriguez Losantos was not offering measured analysis.
01:21She described FIFA as un organismo mafios oi vergonzos, a mafia-like and shameful organization,
01:27and called it one of the most corrupt institutions on the planet. She claimed Argentina should have
01:31been eliminated at least five matches earlier and had only survived because FIFA wanted them alive.
01:35Then came the line that got subtitled and reposted several million times.
01:40Poor lo tanto amino mi de ningun mido Argentina, mi de mucho mido Infantino. I am not afraid of
01:45Argentina at all. I am afraid of Infantino. She went further, arguing that whoever met Argentina
01:50in the final would not be facing 11 Argentinians, but all of FIFA, an organization she said wanted to
01:56hand the World Cup to Lionel Messi. And here is the part that actually matters. Ronaldo did not invent
02:01that theory. He did not seed it, fund it, or caption it. He walked into a fire that had already
02:06been
02:06burning for three weeks and quietly added his name to the guest list. Because by mid-July 2026,
02:14this was not a fringe opinion held by bitter supporters in the replies. It was arguably the
02:19biggest story of the entire World Cup, and it had its own vocabulary. VA Argentina, Argent FIFA,
02:24FIFA's princess. Every one of those nicknames existed before Ronaldo tapped anything.
02:29There are many people who feel like Argentina and Lionel Messi are the darlings of FIFA.
02:35The accusation had two halves, and the first half was about the road itself. The claim was that
02:40Argentina had been handed a soft path to the final, while genuine contenders were stacked
02:45into the opposite side of the bracket, and that the draw had been engineered rather than earned.
02:49And Infantino does everything in his power to make sure that they have both an easy path.
02:54The second half was about the whistle, and this is where it got genuinely ugly.
02:58Match after match, millions of fans accused FIFA of keeping Argentina alive through refereeing
03:03decisions, pointing to a run in which they led the tournament in fouls committed while,
03:07by contemporaneous reporting, no VAR decision went against them until the very late stages.
03:12We will go through those decisions one by one, because several of them are far more
03:16defensible than the internet insisted, and at least two of them are far less.
03:20What Ronaldo's fanbase argued, loudly and constantly, boiled down to three positions.
03:25That Messi received protection no other player on earth receives, that Argentina were permitted
03:30a level of physicality that would have been punished in anybody else, and that the entire
03:34tournament was a coronation with a predetermined ending.
03:42The hostility did not stay theoretical either. A petition demanding Argentina be removed from the
03:48World Cup reportedly passed 20 million signatures. Neutrals who had spent their entire lives disliking England,
03:54found themselves supporting England in the semi-final purely to stop Argentina reaching the final.
03:59FIFA opened an investigation into racist conduct by Argentine supporters.
04:03Argentine players unfurled a Las Malvinas banner after eliminating England, in apparent conflict with
04:08FIFA's own prohibition on political messaging, and no immediate punishment followed, which every
04:13skeptic filed as further proof of a double standard. Reports emerged that the FBI was examining the
04:18Argentine Football Association over financial operations in the United States, involving allegations of
04:24money laundering and fraud. No charges were filed. Nothing connected it to a single player on the pitch.
04:29It got welded onto the conspiracy anyway. And running underneath all of it was the president himself.
04:34Gianni Infantino has cultivated a long, warm, heavily photographed relationship with Lionel Messi,
04:40that predates 2026 and intensified after Argentina's 2022 triumph. During this tournament, he publicly
04:46congratulated Messi after the semi-final win over England. Clips circulated of him looking visibly anxious
04:51and emotionally invested, while Argentina were losing. AI-generated memes casting Messi as FIFA's princess,
04:58alongside Infantino, pulled hundreds of thousands of interactions. None of that is evidence of corruption.
05:03All of it is spectacular optics for people who already believed. So when the most-followed footballer
05:09alive pressed a button on a video calling FIFA Mafia, he was not starting an argument. He was ratifying
05:14one. He handed 100 million people the endorsement they had been demanding for three weeks, and he did
05:19it without typing a single word that could be quoted back at him. The case he was endorsing.
05:25Here is what makes the like genuinely interesting rather than merely petty. Ronaldo did not invent this
05:30accusation. He did not seed it, fund it, or amplify it with a caption. He simply signed his name to
05:35something millions of people were already screaming about, and to be fair to those millions, the
05:40tournament had handed them a remarkable amount of raw material. The nickname arrived early and stuck
05:45like tar. VA Argentina. The case against, built decision by decision, went something like this.
05:57It started in the group stage against Algeria. Lionel Messi appeared to make studs up contact
06:01from behind on the calf and Achilles area of Algeria captain Aissa Mandi. Mandi went down
06:06in visible pain. No yellow card was shown. No red card was shown. The AR did not intervene at all.
06:11Messi then went on to score a hat trick in a 3-0 win, and Algeria later filed a formal
06:16complaint
06:16with FIFA about the officiating. Under the laws of the game, studs up contact from behind on the lower
06:21leg is frequently punished as serious foul play. The absence of any card, followed by a hat
06:26trick from the man who made the contact, was the first brick in the wall. The second brick,
06:31and the heaviest one, was Egypt. Round of 16 July 7 in Atlanta. Around the 58th minute,
06:37Mostafa Zico put the ball in the net to make it 2-0. After a lengthy VAR review, the goal
06:42was
06:42disallowed for a foul by Marouin Atiyah on Lissandro Martinez in the build-up, an incident that occurred
06:46roughly 100 yards from goal and amounted to a tangle of legs and a foot being stood on. Egypt scored
06:52anyway to lead 2-0. And then Argentina scored three times in roughly 13 minutes, the winner
06:57arriving through Enzo Fernandes in stoppage time, to steal a 3-2 result. Egypt's coach Hassam Hassan
07:03did not do diplomacy afterwards. He said there were factors influencing it, not external, but internal
07:09on the pitch, and external before the match. He said there seemed to have been pressure on the
07:13Argentinian side on the referee that brought about this outcome. He said flatly that the cup is
07:18directed towards Argentina. He asked whether they wanted the world champions kept in the competition,
07:23whether they wanted Messi to stay in the running, and added that it is all about money. He said life
07:27is unfair and the world is unfair, but asked why there is no fairness in the sport. He vowed that
07:31once he was home he would never watch the World Cup again, because there is no justice in this
07:35competition. He was booked during the match for making FIFA's own anti-racism gesture in protest.
07:40Goalscorer Mostafa Zico backed him. The Egyptian Football Association issued a formal statement,
07:45saying it could not remain silent. The awkward detail for FIFA is that Hassan was not alone in
07:51his reading. Former referees writing for major outlets argued the VAR intervention had violated
07:56the clear and obvious error threshold, describing it as re-refereeing rather than correcting a mistake.
08:02Football fans became convinced that Argentina weren't simply getting lucky, they were getting help.
08:07Four days later, the quarter-final against Switzerland delivered brick number three. At 1-1,
08:11Lindro Pairds was initially booked for a challenge on Breland below. VAR reviewed it under the
08:15tournament's newly introduced mistaken identity protocol, concluded Mbelo had gone down before
08:20meaningful contact, overturned the foul entirely, and gave Mbelo a second yellow and a red card.
08:25Switzerland played a long stretch and the whole of extra time with 10 men, and lost 3-1.
08:30Coach Murat Yakin called the decision unacceptable and incomprehensible, and said it destroyed the
08:35game. Mbelo was in tears. The protocol was technically correctly applied. That was never really
08:40the argument. The argument was that a rule almost nobody had heard of, used only once previously in
08:46the entire tournament, had materialized at the exact instant Switzerland found their footing.
08:50Then came England in the semi-final, and this is where the pattern stopped being about single
08:55decisions and started being about tolerance levels. The specific incident that pundits kept
09:04circling back to happened in the opening minutes. The challenge on Elliott Anderson involved contact
09:12toward the head and back area, and it produced no card at all. Not a red, not even a yellow.
09:22Argentina won 2-1. Referee Ismail Elfath was heavily criticized for losing control of the match,
09:27and the wider statistical framing did the rest of the work for the conspiracy. Across the tournament,
09:32Argentina led in fouls committed while, by contemporaneous reporting, no VAR decision
09:37went against them until the very late stages. Then there were the optics, and the optics were
09:42arguably worse than any single call. Gianni Infantino has cultivated a long, warm, extremely
09:48photographed relationship with Messi, going back well before 2026 and intensifying after Argentina's
09:532022 title. During this tournament, he publicly congratulated Messi after the semi-final win over
09:58England. Clips circulated of him looking visibly anxious and emotionally invested, while Argentina
10:03were losing, particularly around the Egypt match. AI-generated memes portraying Messi as FIFA's
10:09princess alongside Infantino, racked up hundreds of thousands of interactions, and the hashtags wrote
10:14themselves, Argent FIFA of Argentina. And around it, the noise thickened. The mayor of New York City said
10:20Egypt had been robbed. Argentine players unfurled a Las Malvinas banner after beating England,
10:24in apparent conflict with FIFA's prohibition on political messaging, and no immediate punishment
10:29followed. FIFA opened an investigation into racist conduct by Argentine supporters.
10:34Reports emerged that the FBI was investigating the Argentine Football Association over financial
10:40operations in the United States, with no charges filed, and no link whatsoever to anything on the
10:45pitch, which did not stop anyone from connecting it anyway. A petition to remove Argentina from the
10:50World Cup reportedly passed 20 million signatures. FIFA's refereeing chief Pierluigi Kalina repeatedly
10:56rejected the bias claims and defended the independence of match officials. He did it after
11:01Egypt. He did it again as the accusations mounted. By that stage, nobody arguing on the internet was
11:07listening, because the story had stopped being about refereeing and had become something far more
11:11useful. It had become a scoreboard in a 20-year war, and every new decision was simply another
11:16round of ammunition handed to whichever side wanted it. That is the environment Ronaldo's like dropped
11:21into. Not a calm debate about VAR thresholds. A bonfire that had already been burning for three weeks,
11:27with two of the largest fan communities on the planet standing around it holding petrol.
11:32The Script That Failed
11:34Now for the other side, because the other side is considerably stronger than the screenshots suggest.
11:39The first problem with the FIFA favors Messi theory is that a lot of serious football people
11:44looked at exactly the same evidence and found it embarrassing. This tournament has a lot of
11:50people feeling like it's scripted. The bracket argument was the loudest one,
11:53and it collapses quickest under examination. I didn't actually was supposed to play either Spain
11:58or Uruguay in the next round. The tournament is seated so that the biggest teams meet late.
12:04That is the design. It only breaks when the biggest teams fail to do their jobs in the group stage,
12:09and in 2026 they failed spectacularly. Uruguay were knocked out. Cape Verde finished second in a group
12:22where they held Spain to a scoreless draw and came through with a goal difference of zero. Portugal
12:27drew with Dr. Congo and drew with Colombia. Every one of those results shoved somebody into a bracket
12:32they were never meant to occupy. And then the counter-argument goes somewhere genuinely uncomfortable
12:44for the man who pressed like. FIFA favors Ronaldo. It sounds crazy, but FIFA...
12:49The example offered was a disciplinary matter from Portugal's own qualifying campaign, in which Ronaldo
12:55was sent off and faced an automatic three-match ban heading into the World Cup.
12:59What did Infantino do? Infantino went like, we can't miss Ronaldo for the World Cup.
13:03He served one match, the other two were suspended, a mechanism the panel described as effectively
13:08unprecedented in the sport. And then a second example, reaching back more than a decade to a
13:13Ballon d'Or race. The Ballon d'Or voting was supposed to be closed November 15th.
13:17Ronaldo scored a hat-trick against Sweden on November 19th of that year, four days after voting was
13:23supposed to have shut. FIFA extends the Ballon d'Or for the first and last time to November 29th.
13:29There's been a pattern upon pattern of FIFA favoring Ronaldo.
13:32There's been a pattern upon pattern of FIFA favoring Ronaldo. Whether you accept that framing
13:37or not, it establishes the essential shape of this argument. Both fan bases have a folder of grievances,
13:43both folders are thick, and both are curated with total ruthlessness.
13:47I'm sure you've seen that there's a huge beef on the internet right now between Messi fans and
13:51Ronaldo fans. They argue that Messi gets favorable calls. They argue that Argentina's a dirtier team.
13:57Inside professional punditry, the pushback was blunter. On the rest is football. Previewing the
14:01semi-final, Joe Cole said the whole world wanted Messi in the final, while explicitly clarifying he was
14:06not alleging any skullduggery from FIFA and was talking about vibes rather than corruption.
14:10That clarification did not survive the clipping process. His co-panelist John Mikkel Obi rejected
14:15the conspiracy outright, insisting Argentina had earned their root by winning their games.
14:20Nigerian outlets including Punch, Vanguard and Daily Post reported the exchange around July 14 and 15.
14:26Obi later expanded on the same theme. Then there is the football itself, which is the part the
14:45screenshots never included. Messi finished the campaign with 8 goals and 4 assists, 12 goal
14:50contributions out of the 19 goals Argentina scored across the tournament. He scored a hat-trick against
14:54Algeria at 38, the oldest player ever to do so at a World Cup, a brace against Austria,
14:59a goal against Jordan, a goal against Cape Verde, and a goal plus an assist during the Egypt comeback.
15:04He led or ranked near the top in chances created, dribbles and progressive actions. Referees do not
15:10create that. But the single most devastating rebuttal to the entire conspiracy was
15:24delivered on July 19, 2026, at MetLife Stadium, and it was delivered by Spain.
15:30Spain beat Argentina 1-0 after extra time, Ferran Tours scoring in the 106th minute. The performance
15:36was not close. Spain had around 65% possession, 20 shots with 12 on target, and 31 touches in the
15:43penalty area. Argentina managed 2 shots, none on target, 1 corner and 8 touches in the box. They went into
15:49half-time with zero shots and zero corners. Emiliano Martinez made a record 11 saves in a World Cup
15:54final, and it still was not enough. And in the 90-plus third minute, Enzo Fernandez was shown a second
16:08yellow and sent off, leaving Argentina to play the entire extra time period with 10 men. He became the
16:14immediate scapegoat in a tournament that had been defined by officiating controversy, and then ended
16:19with Argentina seeing red. Think about that for one second. If an all-powerful organization had spent
16:24six matches steering a trophy toward Lionel Messi, it chose the final itself to send off Argentina's
16:29midfield engine and let Spain, the same team that had eliminated Ronaldo's Portugal,
16:34walk away with the trophy. The alleged script did not merely fail. It failed on the biggest stage
16:38available in front of the largest audience in sport. Then came the ugly part. But the bad and
16:44the ugly certainly came at the end of the game, Shaq. I couldn't believe what I was seeing.
16:48Scuffles broke out after the whistle. Pairds and Molina were central. Spain,
16:52by nearly every account, kept their composure throughout and looked like the cleaner side in
16:57every sense of the word. I don't think the image of the game will be hurt at all because of
17:01the result.
17:02Messi finished as a peripheral figure, described in reports as a ghost chasing Spanish players and
17:07rarely touching the ball anywhere dangerous. And yet even the harshest analysts refused to let that
17:12define him. But if we're talking about football, there's no one like Messi in the history of the
17:19of the game. So where does that leave the like? The evidence supports a perception problem, not a
17:24conspiracy. No credible documentation has ever shown Infantino or FIFA directing match officials or
17:30altering VAR protocols to favor Argentina. Several decisions were genuinely poor. Several were
17:35defensible. Almost all were subjective, which is what modern refereeing is made of. What made them
17:40explosive was not their merit. It was that two of the largest fan communities on earth were already
17:45loaded and waiting. And Spain's victory allowed one side to declare the script broken, while the other
17:50pointed at a team that finished with 10 men and no shots on target. Ronaldo did not write the theory.
17:55He did not narrate it, fund it, or say a word about it out loud. He simply pressed a button
18:00that told
18:00several hundred million people exactly where he stood, and then said nothing at all, which is a
18:05communication strategy he has been refining since 2008. Portugal went home on July 6. Messi played a
18:11World Cup final on July 19. The like sits somewhere between those two dates, and it is the loudest thing
18:17Cristiano Ronaldo never said. Thank you for watching. If you enjoyed watching this video,
18:22click on one of the boxes playing on your screen to watch more similar content.

Recommended