Skip to playerSkip to main content
  • 4 months ago
The Daleks, Cybermen, and The Master come back time and time again, but what about the other brilliant monsters? Join us as we count down 10 Doctor Who villains who surprisingly only ever had one television appearance.
Transcript
00:00The Doctor has faced a great deal of terrifying foes throughout their travels.
00:04Given the vast expanse of all of time and space, it's incredibly surprising when the Doctor bumps
00:09into those foes again. Looking through the prism of a long-running television drama that has to
00:14attract audiences, it becomes a lot clearer as to why big hitters like the Daleks, Cybermen,
00:19and the Master all regularly return to ruin the Doctor's day. The Daleks practically secured
00:24Doctor Who's longevity the minute they waved a sucker arm in Barbara's face way back in 1963,
00:30and writers and showrunners repeatedly return to the Daleks nearly six decades later.
00:36Some monsters and villains don't get as lucky as the Daleks and the Master, however.
00:41It's not for lack of trying. The Sea Devils, for example, were a huge part of the cultural memory
00:46of 1970s Doctor Who. The Zygons from 1975's Tom Baker serial captured the imagination of a young
00:53David Tennant, but they didn't return to the series until 2013. And then there are monsters
00:58even unluckier than that, those who are clearly brilliant, but have, to date, never returned
01:04to the TV series. So with that in mind then, I'm Ellie with Who Culture, here with 10 Doctor Who
01:10villains you're surprised only appeared once.
01:1310. Fenric
01:15Fenric and the Doctor have a long history with each other. First appearing in the seventh Doctor
01:19classic The Curse of Fenric, he was the original evil from the dawn of time. An earlier incarnation
01:25of the Doctor and Fenric first met in 3rd century Constantinople, where the Doctor defeated the
01:30intelligence in a game of chess and imprisoned him in a flask. From his prison, Fenric manipulated
01:36the seventh Doctor's timeline in order to free himself from his prison. The Doctor and Ace
01:40eventually defeated Fenric once more, but the old evil played a big role in the seventh Doctor's
01:45Big Finish series of audios. Fenric was intrinsically linked to the legendary Cartmall Master plan that
01:51would suggest the Doctor was more than a Time Lord. With that in mind, it wouldn't be beyond the realms
01:56of possibility for Fenric to have been defeated by Joe Martin's Fugitive Doctor in the employ of
02:01Division, or by another of the Timeless Doctors. Whichever Doctor defeated him first, it's surely
02:06time for another rematch. If only so the Doctor's last important chess game wasn't that awful one from
02:12Nightmare in Silver. 9. Eternals
02:15Enlightenment is one of the best Peter Davison serials. Taking place during an intergalactic
02:20yacht race, it introduces the Eternals as godlike beings that play games with dispensable human
02:25pawns for prizes. The Doctor is rightly horrified, and his confrontation with Stryker gives Davison
02:32some of his best material in the role. The Eternals have been mentioned in passing throughout the
02:37new series, but haven't yet made a return. Or at least not explicitly. In the 13th Doctor adventure
02:42Can You Hear Me?, the TARDIS team come up against Zelin, who can manifest people's fears and do weird
02:48things with his fingers. He tricks the Doctor into freeing his lover Rakaia, but is of course
02:52eventually defeated.
02:54While not explicitly referenced as Eternals on screen, a tie-in story entitled The Guide to the Dark Times was
03:01published in the official Doctor Who Annual 2021. Written by River Song, it outlines the history of
03:07the mythical Dark Times and suggests that Zelin and Rakaia were Eternals. Regardless of whether this was
03:13the intention of the original script, a Doctor Who story that tackles gods who treat human beings as
03:17toys would be fantastic. I mean, it's a regular fallback plot across the Star Trek series, so isn't it about
03:23time that the Doctor had their own queue?
03:26Number 8. Scarison
03:27The Zygons finally returned to Doctor Who in the 2010s, but when they did, their pet Scarison was
03:34nowhere to be found. In their original story, Terror of the Zygons, this terrifying creature was key to
03:40the story. The Scarison was revealed to be the actual Loch Ness Monster, and the Zygons themselves survived
03:46on the creature's milk. Loch Ness Monster Milk, a product that even the Scottish Tourist Board wouldn't
03:51even consider marketing. The realisation of the Scarison on screen was one of those notoriously
03:57ropey Doctor Who monsters, so it's perhaps unsurprising that the Scarison hasn't yet made
04:02an appearance in the new series. After all, it hardly fits with the Zygon invasion in Virgin's
04:07political allegory of terrorism and immigration. However, if Legend of the Sea Devils can reinvent
04:13the Mirka as a terrifying sea creature, then they can do the same for the Scarison. Perhaps a period
04:18adventure set around the time of the first Nessie sighting, where curious scientists accidentally
04:23awaken the Zygons under the loch a few decades early. Scotland is all too rarely visited in Doctor
04:29Who, so it is about time that it paid Nessie the Scarison a visit.
04:33Number 7. The Axons
04:35The John Pertwee serial The Claws of Axos is a bit of an underrated classic. It's the first story by
04:40Bob
04:41Baker and Dave Martin, who would go on to co-create K9 and tackle some very timely concerns around energy.
04:47With the world facing an energy crisis, alien visitors land in the English home counties
04:52to offer clean, renewable energy to humanity. Of course, their gift comes at a price, and soon
04:58the Doctor has to team up with the Master to avert their dastardly plans, trapping them inside a time
05:03loop. The Axons are still stuck in that time loop on screen, though they've occasionally escaped to
05:08wreak havoc in two big Finnish audios, the second of which is to be released later this year.
05:13As humanity continues to discuss the financial and environmental costs of fuel,
05:18surely the Axons are primed for a comeback. It would surely be a foolish endeavour for the
05:22Axons to try the same grift twice, but humanity's never been great at learning from their history.
05:28It would take the Doctor to pop in and save us from our own errors once more.
05:31They're an incredibly striking looking creation, though, sort of psychedelic golden gods. Their true
05:36form, all orange tendrils, would later be repainted to become crinoids, but more on those later.
05:426. Gods of Ragnarok
05:45In the greatest show in the galaxy, the Doctor and Ace visit the psychic circus,
05:50which has been taken over by the ancient gods of Ragnarok. These ancient beings crave entertainment
05:55and wear those in their employ down, demanding endless entertainment and new and more exciting
06:01and thrilling acts each time. The gods were clearly a metaphor for those higher up in the BBC at the
06:06time,
06:06when Doctor Who was on the way out. However, from a contemporary perspective,
06:10aren't they also a metaphor for the endless stream of TV talent shows? It's so crazy that during Russell
06:15T Davies' first era, when Doctor Who was regularly pitted against shows like Britain's Got Talent
06:20and The X Factor, that he never considered writing a satire of those shows. Given how willing everyone
06:26was to play along with the reality show satire in Doctor Who's very first season, it's strange that
06:31they never attempted it. But then maybe that's why, the worry that to have a greatest show in the galaxy
06:36sequel would be too similar to Bad Wolf. So it's a good job RTD's coming back then.
06:415. Rootans
06:43The Sontarans' mortal enemies may look like balls of snot, but they're deadly shapeshifters with
06:49plenty of unrealised potential. While they've been name-checked in the new series, they've never
06:54actually appeared in an episode. However, they have appeared in multiple comic strips, novels,
06:59fan films, and even video games. It's perhaps the Rootans' jellyfish-like appearance that has barred
07:04them from returning to the series after the horror of Fang Rock. How to effectively realise their
07:10appearance without being totally embarrassing probably makes Doctor Who's practical and visual
07:14effects team wake up in a cold sweat. However, the Rootans are shapeshifters. The horror of Fang
07:19Rock is essentially John Carpenter's The Thing in a lighthouse. No one's sure who's who as this deadly
07:25alien works their murderous way through the inhabitants of the lighthouse as they assess
07:29the strategic importance of planet Earth. While the Zygon invasion-slash-inversion has already done
07:35the shapeshifting political thriller, there's surely plenty of scope for another shapeshifter
07:39story in modern Doctor Who. Or perhaps given Flux's epic space battles, the time is right to finally
07:45see what a Sontaran and Rootan war actually looks like.
07:494. The Wirren
07:51Stephen Moffat and Russell T. Davies have both sang the praises of The Ark in Space
07:55over the years, so it's odd that there's never been a sequel. Perhaps they felt the pressure
07:59of following a story that has such a lauded position in the canon. It's a shame because
08:03the Wirren are suitably horrifying creations that could be realised to great effect with modern
08:08visual effects. The Wirren are human-sized insect creatures that breed by using cattle species to
08:14grow their eggs. In The Ark in Space, this is the crew of the Nerva Beacon and is portrayed to
08:19horrifying effect with some of the most creative use of green bubble wrap that you'll ever see.
08:24It's so effective that a recent Bruce Willis film called Breach has practically the same plot,
08:29but couldn't come close to matching the horror, despite the slightly more advanced effects work
08:33and a higher age rating. Maybe this is key to why the Wirren haven't yet returned to the series,
08:39as any Doctor Who production team is wary of recreating the alchemy of those early Tom Baker
08:43stories. Regardless, these creepy-crawlies are long overdue a return.
08:483. Sutek Everyone forgets that the fourth episode is actually a bit rubbish,
08:53but Pyramids of Mars is a stone-cold Doctor Who classic. It pits the Doctor against an Egyptian god
08:59imprisoned on Mars and introduces the Assyrians, god-like aliens in the Doctor Who universe.
09:05There had been demonic aliens introduced in the Third Doctor era, but here was the show
09:09tackling the gods themselves. Sutek has never returned to the TV series, but one of his relations
09:15travelled with the Tenth Doctor in the comics. Gabriel Wolf, who played Sutek in Pyramids of
09:20Mars, has returned to the series, playing the voice of the Beast in the Impossible Planet
09:24slash the Satan Pit. To date, however, no Sutek. Having the Doctor take on an Egyptian god would be an
09:30epic season finale, so it's strange that it's not happened yet. Now that the MCU is making Egyptology
09:37cool again with their Moon Knight series, maybe the Fourteenth Doctor will be taking on the Assyrians
09:42in a future episode. It would certainly push the show in a much-needed new direction, away from the
09:47alien invasion plots that have become overly familiar. 2. The Dream Lord
09:53Arguably, the Dream Lord is the Valiard, the embodiment of the Doctor's worst impulses. However,
09:59his genesis is different, the product of spores that find their way into the TARDIS systems.
10:04The Dark Doctor is an incredibly compelling concept, so much so that the Matt Smith era tried it again
10:09with much less success in Neil Gaiman's difficult second story, Nightmare in Silver. It's odd that
10:15the Dream Lord hasn't returned in the series. There certainly appeared to be unfinished business
10:19at the end of Amy's Choice. The availability of Toby Jones needn't be a problem either,
10:24as you could have a different Dream Lord for each Doctor actor. We've had opportunities for the Doctor
10:29actors to play darker versions of themselves over the years since Amy's Choice, but nothing that's
10:34captured the Doctor's self-loathing and anxiety. It's strange that a story like Can You Hear Me,
10:39which was all about mental health, didn't reintroduce the Dream Lord as the embodiment
10:43of the Doctor's own anxieties and mental health concerns. Perhaps the introduction of the Fugitive
10:48Doctor put Paige to that idea, so for now, the Dream Lord is still out there, waiting.
10:541. The Crinoid The Seeds of Doom is an absolute cracker of a Tom Baker story.
10:59It begins by riffing on The Thing From Another World, long before John Carpenter and Kurt Russell
11:04did to great acclaim in 1982. After the Doctor and Sarah's Antarctic sojourn, they return to the UK
11:11to stop unhinged millionaire Harrison Chase from playing in his green cathedral and unleashing the
11:17terrifying Crinoid upon the world. The Crinoid are a great creation by Zygon creator Robert Banks
11:23Stewart, carnivorous plant life that consume animal life. Their pods can transform other
11:28beings into plant life too, prompting the Doctor to recall that on planets where the Crinoid take
11:32root, all animal life cease to exist. The Crinoid have dug their tendrils into various bits of Doctor
11:38Who spin-off media, but haven't yet returned to the series. As plant-based diets have become
11:43increasingly popular in recent years, and with the return of Russell T Davies to the show,
11:48the time is surely right for a Crinoid return. It's in RTD's wheelhouse to use an old Doctor Who
11:54monster to comment on our contemporary society, and a story about plants that eat humans feels
11:59relevant at a time where we're all questioning our impact on nature.
12:03And that concludes our list. If you have any other suggestions, then do let us know in the
12:07comments below, and while you're there don't forget to like and subscribe and tap that notification bell.
12:12Also head over to Twitter and follow us there, at WhoCulture, and I can be found across various social
12:17medias just by searching Ellie Littlechild. I've been Ellie with WhoCulture, and in the words of
12:22River Song herself, goodbye, sweeties.

Recommended