• 6 months ago
WWE and AEW both struggle in 2025 as creative dips result in multiple low ebbs for the majors...
Transcript
00:00From failed comebacks to unbridled backstage chaos, literal Molotov cocktails in AEW and
00:05supernatural zombie crews in WWE, 2025 has been another wild, wild year in the wild,
00:11wild world of pro wrestling. It would probably be over the top to call it bad on the balance of
00:16things, but boy does it feel a little weirder than it did a couple of years ago. In AEW,
00:21the on-screen vibes are good, certainly far higher than they were in 2023 or 2024,
00:26but this has not translated into better business. Far from it, in fact. WWE, meanwhile,
00:33conspired to mess up the most eagerly anticipated heel turn of all time. That was far from the
00:38company's only shortcoming in a year that suggested that the Paul Levesque honeymoon period is long
00:43gone. There are always highs and lows in wrestling. These companies produce a mind-boggling amount of
00:49content each year, so naturally, some of it is going to suck. Today, we take a look at what sucked
00:55the most in 2025, from the perversely entertaining to the stuff that had you questioning your entire
01:01fandom and everything in between. So grab your popcorn, pop open a crisp bottle of haterade,
01:06and enjoy the ride. I'm Andy from WhatCulture, and these are the 25 worst wrestling moments of 2025.
01:13Number 25, Triple H has bad news for New Orleans. Perhaps this is conspiratorial, but after nearly
01:20three decades of sniping between The Rock and Triple H, it's hard not to look upon every big swing they
01:25take as being intended for the other's face. When Dwayne Johnson announced that WrestleMania 42 was
01:31going to take place in New Orleans back in February, he couldn't have known that everything was going
01:35to change. WWE ended up moving the event to Las Vegas, which also ruled out any possibility of
01:40WrestleMania 43 going to New Orleans as well, when that show is now booked for Saudi Arabia.
01:45It makes the bombastic announcement from The Rock all the more cringeworthy, particularly in contrast
01:50to Triple H's apologetic, corporate-speak walkback on the May 23rd Smackdown. There, he repeated a
01:57change that had controversially been made public 24 hours earlier, before offering Money in the Bank
02:022026 as a tame replacement for the city losing Mania. The difference in tone and presentation between
02:08these two talks couldn't have been starker. And although surely not by design, Johnson looked like
02:13something of a snake oil salesman compared to the suited, booted and nuanced Levesque.
02:18Regardless of who won that particular optics war, WWE lost yet another one with their fanbase.
02:23Vegas was and will be again an incredible host city for Mania, but the unprecedented venue shift
02:29in the chase of dollars was yet another example of WWE shamelessly alienating the emotions and
02:35wallets of its core audience.
02:37Number 24, Eddie Kingston's AEW return. I cannot believe I am saying this, but as I record this,
02:43AEW has somehow conspired to fumble an Eddie Kingston comeback of all the things in the world
02:48they could possibly fumble. At All Out 2025, Kingston returned to the ring after a whopping 17 months
02:53away in a wonky match with Big Bill. The build had already been criticised for how frustratingly low-key
02:59the whole thing was. It was as if AEW simply didn't understand how much the Mad King means to their
03:04fanbase,
03:05how much he was missed, and how valuable he was to a weekly world that was notably lacking
03:09several of its top stars. Within weeks of the whiffed Hurricane that scored him the win over Bill,
03:15Kingston was stuck in the mire of tag matches with Hook, who I like, but come on.
03:19The race to put Hook under yet another wing was annoying, as was the choice to so quickly maroon
03:25Kingston on the B-Show collision without so much as one lengthy promo on Dynamite to show just how back
03:30he was. The normalisation of a top star is indicative of wider problems as much as anything else,
03:36and Kingston's return should have been a home run. Instead, it started not with a roar, but with a whimper.
03:41Number 23, the worst botch of the year. There are botches and flubs, and then there are botches
03:47and flubs that result in even more botches and flubs, talent getting hurt, and live televised main events
03:51collapsing so badly that the audience turns on everyone involved. This was the case on the September 26th
03:57episode of SmackDown when, during a WWE women's title triple threat between champion Tiffany Stratton,
04:03Nia Jax and Jake Cargill, an accidental injury resulted in a chain of events that made a laughing
04:09stock of all three and referee Daphne LaShawn. A solid match completely fell apart at the finish,
04:15when Stratton was late to a kick-out save while Cargill had pinned Jax. Jax had no choice but to
04:20kick
04:21out, otherwise she would look like a buffoon, but then Stratton attacked anyway, rolling onto Jax for yet
04:26another pin attempt even though the irresistible force had already recovered. LaShawn realised that
04:31she was counting and held her free before her hand could hit the mat, presumably in some telepathic
04:37hope that Nia would roll her shoulder again. She did, but not for what felt like an ice age on
04:42television and presumably in the building. Of note, all of this took place minutes after Jade Cargill
04:48had been bloodied hard way. She was launched into the steel steps by Jax, and based on the size of
04:53the
04:53gash that opened up on her head, was lucky to escape the ordeal without a more serious injury.
04:58Number 22. The End of the Hurt Syndicate and MJF Story
05:02Low-key controversy has followed the Hurt Syndicate around AEW since they got there,
05:06and it has opened up an interesting debate between fans about the way they would like to see talent
05:10conduct their backstage business. There is more than a dash of old-school mentality in the manner
05:15MVP Bobby Lashley and Shelton Benjamin have politically protected themselves. But when months of build
05:21between the group and MJF was flushed down the toilet in one segment in August, it felt as if
05:26the contentiousness was now coming at the cost of good creative. To recap, MJF wanted in the Hurt
05:31Syndicate, the three members teased a thumbs up, thumbs down bit that got over massively in the
05:36building, MJF was allowed in and all seemed rosy in the garden, then MJF scored a world title shot while
05:42Bobby and Shelton were tag team champions, then out of nowhere the original trio all got completely sick
05:47of MJF and booted him out. And that was it. No follow-up, nothing. Barring an unrealistic and now
05:53unwanted long game, the whole thing is something that everybody's got to pretend just never happened.
05:58Number 21. Hurt Syndicate don't lose at Forbidden Door
06:02Bobby Lashley and Shelton Benjamin's run as AEW tag team champions flattered to deceive.
06:07Initially cast as a new age version of the Road Warriors thanks to their massive size advantage over
06:12pretty much everyone else in the company, their squashes were too competitive and too long to properly do
06:17the job. Then came countless stories of the Syndicate's apparent unwillingness to do jobs,
06:21which hurt suspension of disbelief and any reason to invest in the fiction without thinking about
06:26the facts. Forbidden Door 2025 was a confluence of all three issues. A well-booked tournament to
06:32determine the number one contenders brought FTR and Brodido together for an epic finale that ended
06:37in a draw. This put both teams into the final for a freeway dance against Lashley and Benjamin at
06:43Forbidden Door and fans cynically assumed that this was political protection to save the title
06:48holders from doing a job. But if it were only that simple. Brought into a feud with Ricochet and The
06:53Demand, the Hurt Syndicate were dragged into a brawl mid-match meaning that they weren't even on
06:58screen for the deciding fall. A fall which was unfortunately badly botched when Cash Wheeler was
07:03late for a save ahead of the actual recount. Brodido became champions and are, in truth,
07:08one of AEW's biggest success stories this year. It's just unfortunate then that the moment that
07:13made it so was so awkwardly done. 20. Swing and a miss for Funda Rosa,
07:18Megan Bain and Penelope Ford There has never been quite
07:21enough focus on the AEW women's division since the company launched, and while 2025 brought yet
07:26more enormous strides in the right direction, a lack of organisation brought disastrous consequences
07:32for Funda Rosa, Megan Bain, Penelope Ford and Chris Statlander in February. The spot was
07:37seemingly simple enough and maybe that's why it stuck out as such an embarrassment. The heels were
07:42laying a beating on Statlander, prompting Funda Rosa to arrive on the scene with a chair and chase
07:46them all off. Only they didn't run away, they didn't powder, and this forced the former women's
07:52champion to simply hold the chair and wobble it around a little bit in their direction until they
07:56calmly left the ring. Ford was so unbuttered that she appeared to wrestle the chair away from
08:01Rosa who couldn't let go lest she look weaker still. The subsequent tug of war was absolutely
08:07excruciating. It looked as though they'd successfully called the babyface's bluff and as with all flubs
08:11in wrestling, it happened while everyone was standing completely still. Per all reliable reports
08:15on the matter, it was completely by accident rather than a case of a work becoming a shoot or an
08:20attempt
08:20to bury anybody, but the talent were left paying the price for multiple damaging miscommunications.
08:2619. The Bayley Nervous Breakdown Character In one of the stupider WWE plot developments since
08:32Vince McMahon buggered off in 2022, Bayley's failure to help Lyra Valkyria win back the
08:36Intercontinental Championship from Becky Lynch coinciding with a personal losing streak resulted
08:41in the role model experiencing a serious and visible case of split personality disorder. This
08:47was communicated by a video package in which we could all hear the voices in her head, but the rest
08:52of
08:52the roster, including her concerned friend Valkyria, could not. When Bayley's scattershot behaviour made
08:58it to the arenas, Lyra was at least the one who flagged it with Adam Pearce. But he didn't care
09:03really, as he tends not to when females on the roster are booked to express their concerns.
09:07Meanwhile, the former Intercontinental Champion found herself on the wrong end of the role model's
09:12acid tongue just to be embraced minutes later by the hugger. Everybody could see what was happening
09:17now. So the script flipped and Valkyria herself was the one who was randomly confused again. Breaking
09:23fourth walls and rules alike, the story was a reminder of the quality bar gradually rising
09:27over the years. Even in the cartoon world of WWE, these felt like two animated characters just
09:33waiting for a weekly reset. It was the kind of stuff that Vince came up with, and boy,
09:38do we not need any more of that ever again.
09:4118. Kyle Lore
09:42The 7th October episode of Dynamite featured a match between Kyle Fletcher and Kyle O'Reilly.
09:48Fletcher's TNT title was on the line, it followed the standard AEW formula as well of a good TV
09:53match and there was the added bonus, sort of, of Don Callis family lore. The two Kyles had wrestled
10:00once before and they were greeted with KYLE chants in the arena, so O'Reilly decided to contribute
10:06something to social media that took a largely satisfied audience and split it in half. Revealing
10:12some preposterous Kyle lore hours before the bell, O'Reilly's post got so deep into magical,
10:17mystical bollocks that it inadvertently got sections of the audience asking far bigger questions than
10:23who would win the title match. Here, I'll read some of it to you.
10:27Once upon a time, there was an ancient kingdom known as Kyletron, named after the original Kyle,
10:32who was a mighty and just warrior renowned by his people for outlawing the abuse of baby oil in
10:37wrestling. Oh, okay, okay, I think that's quite enough, thank you. The rambling Instagram post
10:43continued with talk of an evil dark mage brother named Lyle and other such nonsense that probably
10:48should have been left in the drafts folder. To top it off, plenty of fans speculated that the entire
10:53thing may have been generated by AI, just in case it wasn't already unbearable enough. The whole thing
10:59was played for geeky laughs and it sucked any juice out of the TNT title fight. Humor is extremely subjective,
11:06perhaps the most subjective thing in the world. And if you were on the negative end of this subjectivity,
11:11this shit was unbearable and cringe. 17. Kit Wilson's Toxic Masculinity Persona
11:17At the start of the year, Pretty Deadly were a useful unit for WWE, serving as an overact that
11:23other tag teams could beat en route to winning the titles. Lots of people won the gold,
11:27lots of people thus needed to score a win over Pretty Deadly, and as warm comedic foils,
11:32the British duo stayed over enough to keep the machine rolling. With a loss to Fraxium in May,
11:37it came to a screeching halt, and Kit Wilson's rubbish comeback on Smackdown was disappointing
11:42and retrograde as an outcome. On the off chance that WWE Unreal didn't highlight the lack of
11:47diversity at the company's writing table enough, just listen to the words coming out of Kit Wilson's
11:51mouth before he's thrown through the walls or wheeled down some stairs. Basically, it's a bunch
11:56of creative team fossils misplacing terms they've read on social media to take pops at younger or
12:01different portions of the fanbase who perhaps didn't like everything that was being served to them by the
12:06market leader. Customers, mind you. Customers who are consuming at a stronger rate than ever
12:11and being charged the most in history for the privilege. History always repeats. When wrestling
12:16companies cool off, they always take shots at the audience. Potshots at the fans aren't exactly top of
12:21the priority list after all when the customers are satisfied, and this is the kind of rubbish that
12:26should really be set on fire somewhere. Speaking of which, number 16, MJF threatens to set Mark Briscoe on
12:33fire. More than just the millionth case of unreported attempted murder in pro wrestling,
12:37this particular near-fatal incident was more egregious because of its bizarre placement as
12:41the emotional climax of an otherwise very good program between Hangman Page and MJF. The salt of
12:47the earth had been needling Page, going back to before he even regained the belt, in a cute callback to
12:52their original exchanges back in 2019. After Hangman beat Moxley on the same night that MJF earned a contract,
12:59the two came together, but Page, the smart babyface, convinced Max to use his shot at an upcoming
13:05forbidden door pay-per-view rather than saving it for a more opportune cowardly time. MJF said yes
13:10and the match was made. Then, just a week later and in a preposterous development, by threatening to
13:16burn Mark Briscoe alive, MJF got his shot back, went back on his original deal and forced the champion
13:22to comply within his own weighted stipulations. The nature of the threat was dumb, but the damage it did
13:27to the audience's trust in AEW's creative process was even worse. Bad booking at the top of the cards
13:33in an era where AEW could still do with convincing audience that this sort of thing was long gone.
13:3915. The Charlotte Flair- Tiffany Stratton promo
13:42For some, a glimpse into the chaotic version of WWE they'd rather watch, and for others, a dim and
13:47distant reminder of Catastrophe's past. The verbal sparring session between Charlotte Flair and
13:51Tiffany Stratton on the 4th April episode of Smackdown was a chilling recollection of why,
13:56sometimes, scripts aren't so bad. Some typical turn taking very quickly got nasty. Both dove deep
14:02into the other's personal lives, with Stratton referencing Flair's divorces before bailing,
14:07resulting in Charlotte making a crack about the champion's partner, Ludwig Kaiser, being in her DMs.
14:13The Barb's felt over the line, and the report soon emerged that very little of this segment played
14:18out as was planned. Stratton later noted that she believed Charlotte didn't expect just how rough
14:24things were going to get. It was, however, totally telegraphed. A satellite back and forth
14:29two weeks prior had been completely derailed by Flair. A week after that, it was tiffy time by
14:35necessity. She kept receipts and ultimately left Charlotte looking like quite the fool.
14:40The jagged build had a mixed impact on the feud. Some people thought the match stood the chance of
14:45breaking out into a shoot while others noted that the lack of trust hadn't exactly been good for
14:49match quality in the past. The gritty but at times sloppy WrestleMania match was a compromise of
14:54outcomes but never had it looked more in doubt than doing this Smackdown verbal duel.
15:0014. MJF and Jeff Jarrett start and end a feud
15:04A program that made sense on paper, the planned storyline between MJF and Jeff Jarrett vanished off
15:09the face of AEW's earth after a terrible promo segment between the two that did just as much damage to
15:15Jarrett's planned retirement run as it did the storyline. It started well enough. In the shadow
15:20of Sting's amazing farewell the previous year and with a John Cena retirement tour also kicking off
15:25in the other company, Double J teased his own extended exit before revealing that he'd signed one last
15:30contract as a talent on January 1st. In doing so, he confirmed that he wanted AEW gold and doubled down
15:37on the ambition by saying that he was going after the World Heavyweight Championship. MJF took an interest in
15:43this and a week later he offered The Last Outlaw a deal. Join up with me to get the title
15:47back and
15:48I will give you the first shot. Now a babyface, Double J said no. A week after that they engaged
15:54in a promo exchange so outdated and overthought that the entire program was binned. In a sad tribute to
16:00MJF's classic sparring sessions with CM Punk, Jeff responded to various barbs by calling the former
16:06champion's fiancé, a Canadian call girl and much worse to make his point, before closing out by
16:12saying that MJF was drowning in his own shit. MJF replied with references to Owen Hart before Karen
16:18Jarrett found herself in the middle and then on the deck. Jeff wrestled only one more match for AEW
16:24in the aftermath, losing to Claudio Castagnoli on the 29th of January, while neither wrestler ever brought
16:30up their feud again. It was damning. Tony Khan drops very few programs cold, but he dropped this.
16:37Number 13. Jon Moxley kidnaps the Rock and Roll Express
16:40It took a long time for the Deathriders storyline to mature into something effective and debate will
16:45continue to rage thanks to the brilliance that was Hangman Page's crowning as AEW World Champion at All
16:51in Texas. But was it really worth all of this? In his bids to rebuild AEW in his own image,
16:56Jon Moxley
16:57set about unleashing acts of aggression upon all the people he deemed responsible for the company's
17:02decline. Using the organisation as a babyface institution was as flawed as many of Moxley's
17:07own methods, but never did the concept feel as dead as it did when the world champion kidnapped the
17:12Rock and Roll Express to anger-rated FTR. I mean, what even was Jon Moxley at this point? Was he
17:17the
17:18ass-kicking hard lad that the likes of Marina Shafir and Wheeler Yuta would follow into war? Was he the
17:22biggest stooge of them all, masking his insecurity with authoritarian leadership? Or was he,
17:27based on this and other incidents like it, a curious little petty criminal with actions that fell
17:32apart underneath any level of scrutiny? The lack of reaction to Ricky Morton and Robert Gibson's plight
17:37was unsurprising but damning, as was the match that this nonsense was supposed to be selling.
17:4212. Mox and Cope at Revolution
17:44It's to AEW's credit that very few matches from the company's year could make any kind of worst of list.
17:50More on that in a few days. Matches are what the companies do best, better than their opposition,
17:55in fact. The effort to maintain where the best wrestle as a legitimate catchphrase is constant
18:00and obvious. And even when the storylines might not create the most anticipation for the matches,
18:06they are, at the very least, good enough to ensure that the business end of the business
18:09is taken care of. Jon Moxley's Revolution title defence against Adam Copeland was a bleak,
18:15rule-proving exception that signified everything so annoyingly flawed about the divisive Death Riders.
18:20The pair worked a slow and drab match with an interference heavy layout and did so in the
18:25main event of a Revolution pay-per-view with at least two matches that many would have on their
18:30match of the year list. It felt completely incongruous, which in turn made Moxley's mission look like
18:35it would destroy AEW's credibility as a shoot before anything could be rebuilt as a work.
18:40It was topped off by Christian Cage's failed late stage execution of his title shot contract,
18:45a cash-in so alienating in how close it was to WWE that Tony Khan eventually changed the rules.
18:51Moxley ended up beating Cage to win the match, meaning, yay, you got to see Cope vs Mox again.
18:58Goodie.
18:59Number 11. Ron Killings returns, and so does our truth.
19:02Fans care when wrestlers get released, and this is nice. Since the heartless pandemic cuts of 2020's
19:08Black Wednesday, the sentiment towards performers losing their jobs at any time is a strong one,
19:13and never was this more prevalent in recent times than when R-Truth's contract wasn't renewed by
19:18WWE in June. The remarkable outpouring of support resulted in protests against WWE that hadn't
19:24really been seen since The Rock took Cody Rhodes' WrestleMania spot in 2024. That move felt like
19:30a political one that creative head Triple H was only too happy to reverse. This time, however,
19:35he didn't look quite as keen. According to reports, Nick Khan himself reversed the decision,
19:40and this was revealed when Truth made a shocking return to the company, doing a tag match pitting
19:45John Cena and Logan Paul against Cody Rhodes and Jey Uso at Money in the Bank.
19:49On the Raw after the PLE, Truth, now going by this and his real name, Ron Killings, cut a serious
19:55promo
19:55and his hair, but just as people had fantasy booked his insertion into the SummerSlam main event,
20:00he was shunted right back down the card where he remains to this day. John Cena's babyface turn ended up
20:06being a complete reversion for R-Truth as well. It was if they had both agreed at the same time
20:11to retcon just about everything that had happened to them in the three months prior.
20:1510. The Post-All-In Texas AEW Cooldown
20:19The run-up to All-In Texas was excellent for AEW and bordered on exceptional when it came to the
20:24most creative task of the year. Hangman Page rescuing the AEW World Championship from Jon Moxley almost
20:29justified the strangleholds that the Deathriders story had on the promotion and the match was absolutely
20:34tremendous. But Tony Khan's historic problem with following up once again reared its ugly head.
20:39From the heat of the Summer, Autumn and Winter brought a notable and frustrating cooldown on
20:44Dynamite and Collision. The pressure of monthly pay-per-views resulted in a page title reign once
20:49again feeling nowhere near as good as it should have been, injuries and absences to the likes of
20:53Will Ospreay and Swerve Strickland left massive holes and every development passing through the show
20:57felt like a purposeless breeze rather than the narrative earthquake the company needed. Eddie Kingston,
21:03Pac and Orange Cassidy were three major names that could have addressed this but a distinct lack
21:08of promotional spark behind their returns reflected badly of the booking. There are in-ring highs
21:15but Khan increasingly feels stubborn. He likes what he likes, we know what he likes,
21:21and if history repeats itself as much as it usually does, we might just have to get used to it.
21:259. The TNA vs NXT Storyline The problems with the TNA
21:30Invasion of NXT were many and they existed long before the two sides went to a tepid war on a
21:36showdown special that fell short of even modest expectations. A working relationship had already
21:41existed between TNA and WWE for years so it was never going to scan as a believable war but both
21:47sides gave up literally trying seven days before showdown when GM personas Ava and Centino Marella were
21:53booked as best friends ostensibly just messing with the lives of the wrestlers on either side. The muddled
21:59state of TNA's various title pictures meant that NXT wrestlers holding TNA gold were on different
22:04teams pending their storylines, to the point where plot holes opened up in the booking and multiple
22:09performers looked as if they'd forgotten how to wrestle in a bunch of botch-laden cross-brand
22:13matches. In the aftermath, which by the way ended in a draw, the two sides went back to just working
22:18alongside one another anyway. Nothing was solved, with the net positives being entirely to do with TNA's
22:24alleged business growth rather than anything that could simply be enjoyed or engaged with by the
22:28viewing audience. WWE trying to elevate TNA to a point where it stifles AEW is a strategy in keeping
22:35with their usual corporate chicanery but it has hurt the already dubious quality of NXT to a very large
22:41degree. 8. Cody Rhodes vs John Cena
22:45There was the temptation to blame two of the biggest stars in all of wrestling wetting the bed at
22:49WrestleMania on the rapper doing a slow motion run in at the end, but that would be letting WWE off
22:55the hook. Travis Scott, despite his original enthusiasm, was not cut out for wrestling, but the
23:00people making the decisions within WWE were stupid enough to place so many eggs in his basket in the
23:06first place. His lame interference only buried the lead. Cody Rhodes and newly-heeled John Cena
23:11wrestled a chronically boring match that temporarily damaged the reputations of both men and did more
23:17harm in the audience trust in the creative process than anything else that had happened in WWE up to
23:22that point. Ponderously slow and without a narrative thread beyond Cena's punches and kicks somehow
23:27being enough to keep the prime American nightmare down, this was a flashback to darker days where the
23:32fiction was impossible to invest in. The reality of the situation got worse, too. The furnace atmosphere
23:38at the start of the match had completely gone away by the end and the looping rendition of Scott's
23:43Fiend was more Fever Dream than Dream Match and Lord knows I never want to hear that piece of crap
23:47song ever again. The five years it took Scott to get to the ring didn't help either, but the match
23:52was
23:52already garbage before he showed up. A quality rematch at Summerslam helped a lot, but the WrestleMania
23:57encounter was an unquestionable artistic low in the careers of both. It's the biggest match of the
24:03year, the WrestleMania Night 2 main event, and they pissed themselves.
24:077. John Cena vs CM Punk The long-awaited final showdown between
24:12John Cena and CM Punk was theoretically a generational dream rematch and, at very least,
24:18a promotional highlight for WWE. A nostalgic callback for long-time fans and a fresh spectacle,
24:23this was an open goal that was somehow fired wide. Running the match in Saudi Arabia guaranteed
24:28controversy, especially considering Punk's past criticisms of working there. Any story they tried
24:33to tell was doomed to be overshadowed by the perception that Punk was being forced to swallow
24:38his words, not least when Cena alluded to it, going as close to the line as he possibly could,
24:43without threatening the business relationship. Even without the geographic complications,
24:47the creative direction was, in keeping with Cena's heel run in general, a mess. Punk seemed begrudgingly
24:53at peace with his lot, as if chasing Cena was worth more than the various principles he once condemned.
24:59In response, Cena's exhausted and insincere recreation of Punk's iconic pipe bomb promo suffered from
25:05naff delivery and the preposterous sight of Punk selling a Slim Jim table bump for about 5 minutes.
25:11The Punk life response from the voice of the voiceless a week later was pathetically lame,
25:16and spoke to a man who could neither check out nor lock in. The match itself was alright,
25:21it was something of an over-delivery, but it shouldn't have been given such a low bar to clear in
25:25the
25:25first place. 6. Brock Lesnar's Return
25:28Like everything in the Vince McMahon slash WWE sex trafficking lawsuit, the reality of everything
25:34going on behind the scenes where Brock Lesnar's return is far worse than anything as trivial as
25:39some bad wrestling or a bit of nonsensical booking. So, in the interest of keeping this video strictly
25:44about things that happened on screen, let's focus on how Lesnar has looked since his bewildering return
25:49at Summerslam. Surprises draw pops, especially ones as unexpected as Brock's comeback with the
25:55lawsuit still ongoing, so the noise greeting his return was less shocking than many might have
26:00considered. The true extent of how phoned in it all was was revealed, however, doing an abysmal
26:05face-to-face with Cena's new old best friend R-Truth on the September 12th edition of SmackDown.
26:10Forgetting and fluffing their lines, the two attempted some bad WWE comedy. Lesnar then battered
26:16Truth, split his trousers and laughed off the whole mess. It sucked. Both performers looked terrible.
26:21Cena's inconsistency didn't inspire confidence, but a total lack of stakes and effort from all
26:27involved was foreboding to the extreme. This, effectively, was the only in-arena sales pitch
26:33for the Cena-Lesnar match that was due to happen at Wrestlepalooza. What could possibly go wrong there,
26:38right? 5. Wrestlepalooza
26:40A stinker of a show that stood as a monument to the wider creative problems with WWE in 2025,
26:46Wrestlepalooza was a spiritual sequel to Raw is Netflix in that it toasted a bold new
26:51relationship with a streaming provider in just about the worst way possible.
26:55Everything had problems. The latest Triple H narrated video package about the history of
27:00the company was very well produced, but it contradicted half of the Netflix one they'd produced
27:04in January. AJ Lee and CM Punk's mixed tag team match with Becky Lynch and Seth Rollins was red-hot,
27:10but it went way, way too long. Stephanie Vaquer and EOSky's workmanlike effort could hardly be
27:15heralded as match of the night when so much of it played out to complete silence. Cody Rhodes
27:20doesn't really have bad matches, unless he's wrestling John Cena at Wrestlemania, but this
27:24title defense against Drew McIntyre was the weakest outside of that Cena disaster. And speaking of
27:29disasters, the Usos looked like they'd never met during their botch-laden mess with Braun Breaker and
27:35Bronson Reed. Tellingly, there was near-universal agreement about Wrestlepalooza's lack of quality.
27:40In tribal times defined by daily culture wars, most of WWE's base came together to acknowledge
27:45that the show simply wasn't good enough. The next few years of television will determine
27:50if this was just a blip or the true moment of no return, the creative boom.
27:554. The Rock on Raw is Netflix
27:57There's an awful lot of Dwayne Johnson on this year's worst of list, much like there should have
28:02been of him at Wrestlemania 41. Ahead of pausing wrestling to promote an Oscar-baiting performance
28:07in the Smashing Machine, Dwayne Johnson had a near-devastating impact on two separate
28:11Wrestlemania money matches when he strolled to the ring to kick off WWE's brand new year on a
28:16brand new platform. The Raw is Netflix debut edition of the flagship on January 6 was its own kind of
28:22nightmare for reasons also explained elsewhere, but Johnson got it off to a rather fitting start
28:27by spouting a load of nonsense and burning his lingering tensions with Cody Rhodes and Roman Reigns
28:33to the ground. The American Nightmare got a little hair ruffle ahead of a shared drink backstage,
28:38confusing fans who had waited for months to see how the white-hot tension established in 2024
28:43was going to be followed up on. The answer was not at all. The Rock pinned Cody Rhodes at
28:48Wrestlemania 40. 24 hours after, Cody finished the story at Roman's expense. What would come of this
28:54was potentially captivating until the Great One bizarrely capsized the boat, attaboying the Tribal
29:00Chief following his win over Solo Sekoua. Two money programs that had asked for your time and
29:05feelings were suddenly put out to pasture because it felt like a past-it icon had forgotten what he
29:10was actually there for. 3. The Rock on NXT
29:13Fresh off blowing up Wrestlemania on the Netflix debut, The Rock had apparently spent his time
29:19online reading feedback when he appeared on the developmental brand for the very first time,
29:24the very next night. The New Year's Evil show appearance was an earthquake of sorts for Shawn Michaels,
29:29but rather than the ground opening up and swallowing HBK as he may have wished,
29:34Rock simply opened fire on his haters and swallowed up the time from the advertised matches instead.
29:39It was admittedly quite fascinating to see a star of this magnitude in a relatively small wrestling
29:44setting, but the longer Rock he wore on and on and on, the more the novelty wore off. Swearing up
29:50a
29:50storm and Stumbo bumbling his way through some absolute nonsense about the final boss being 20 steps
29:56ahead in response to the criticism of his Netflix performance, The Rock attempted to tether himself
30:01to an NXT concept he'd never had anything to do with, recapped his nicknames and continued to
30:06reference how little time he had to speak despite taking ages to say absolutely nothing. It was a
30:12terrible promo in which Rock, who should probably be the most secure person in the world, came off like
30:17an insecure little boy. 48 hours that ultimately ended up defining a year.
30:222. WWE's Creative Decline
30:25It seems counter-intuitive, but compiling a list of approximately 25 moments for a worst list is
30:31actually easy, even in wrestling's good years. Companies on hot streaks are not immune to duds,
30:36and in something as notoriously difficult as episodic weekly television, keeping the garbage confined to
30:41double figures is very impressive. But it is the context, the nature and the scale of the clangers
30:47that shoot and do raise concern if you're a WWE hardcore. Let's run through some of it. How about we
30:52begin with making a mess of the WrestleMania main event and in fact blowing so much of the build to
30:57the biggest show of the year that the multi-person match is made up for the single slogs. There's
31:02becoming obsessed with reality show angles and worked shoot bobbins so much that it derails your
31:07programs and breakdowns audience trust. There's disappointing up the arseholes of sponsors,
31:12executives, comedians and anybody else who wants face time at the expense of a real fan that wants
31:17to enjoy the show. And there's continuing to price those fans out with brutal price gouging around
31:22every corner. Then there's the return of every bad habit, from non-finishes to 50-50 feuds and dropped
31:29threads, followed by press conference bollockings that are way more defensive than the booking practices
31:34themselves. These things are a trend, we don't just judge individual moments and declare decline.
31:40The fact is that over the past year, WWE's moments of true greatness have become fewer and farther
31:46between. And then there's the final thing on this list.
31:50Number 1. John Cena's Heel Run
31:52Was this even supposed to happen? WWE Unreal told us so as part of an Ocean's Eleven-style plot between
31:58all
31:59the key players and Travis Scott, but the reality of the situation was reflected by how terribly
32:04it was handled in the aftermath. According to multiple outlets, The Rock decided in early
32:092025 that he wanted Cody Rhodes to turn heel and for The Rock to be the reason. Fortunately,
32:14enough people, including Cody himself, pushed back on this terrible idea and John Cena fulfilled
32:19the spot as a perennial good soldier. The Rock subsequently never appeared on television again
32:25in the aftermath, nor was he even referenced by Cena in multiple different You People speeches
32:30that he gave before winning the WWE Championship at WrestleMania 41. Multiple You People speeches,
32:36because none of them worked. John tried some nonsense about an abusive relationship with the
32:41audience that was stuck in 2014 while still receiving the odd boos. He then acted his WWE
32:47shop socks off, trying to be a violent psychopath in the build to the Cody match, but dropped it when
32:53the
32:53bell rang. He then became a coward, a cheat, an enemy of our truth, a friend of Logan Paul, and
32:59was every
32:59kind of villain to the sound of every kind of sigh. It was terribly inconsistent. Grand design for Cena's
33:06last year or not, the whole thing was abruptly dropped on the Summerslam Go Home edition of Smackdown,
33:11in a move that was so relieving and so many people were so thankful was over that they just stopped
33:16complaining. In 2025, WWE somehow botched a John Cena heel turn, something you'd have been probably
33:22locked up for suggesting a few years prior. How could anything else be number one?

Recommended