Skip to playerSkip to main content
  • 1 day ago
Seth and Sean discuss if the Texans should consider trading for Giants DT Dexter Lawrence, and why it doesn't make much sense despite the Texans having the 2nd highest odds of being his next team.
Transcript
00:00Yesterday, Seth, Dexter Lawrence, we know earlier this week he requested a trade.
00:06So as of right now, there's an open trade request from Dexter Lawrence from his team or to his team,
00:12the New York Giants.
00:14So we'll see if he gets traded.
00:15John Harbaugh has spoken on it now, and he said, we want Dexter Lawrence on this team.
00:19Everybody's saying all the right things on the Giants side of things.
00:21Dexter Lawrence agitates for a new contract every single year.
00:24I'm already annoyed by his agitating for a new contract even before the Texans have even just taken any kind
00:30of a look at him.
00:31So you and I workshopped this yesterday on the show, not once but twice.
00:35You workshopped it on your YouTube channel.
00:37What would a Dexter Lawrence trade to the Texans look like?
00:40In every permutation that we came up with, the end result was I don't want to do this.
00:46There's too much money involved.
00:47I don't want to give up draft.
00:49Giving up draft capital for the right to potentially overpay somebody is a fool's game.
00:54And also just the vibe of this is a guy who wants a new contract all the time.
00:58You and I both arrived at no is the answer to would we do this, right?
01:02Yeah, prudence led us there.
01:03That's right.
01:04That's right.
01:04Including the fact that he had that elbow dislocation a couple years ago, and he just wasn't as impressive last
01:11year.
01:11It's tricky with nose tackles to try to use statistics because he's getting double teamed a lot.
01:16But there is that as well.
01:18So it just, it doesn't make sense right now to spend that many resources on the side of the ball
01:24that is already awesome.
01:25Agreed.
01:26We're in lockstep on that.
01:26You and I are simpatico on that.
01:28And I'm curious, you know, maybe I'll pull this thing later today.
01:31I am curious what the, you know, text in, base power text line, 7135724610.
01:36Do you have the appetite for a Dexter Lawrence trade?
01:39How then do we explain the odds makers yesterday putting out odds on Trevor Lawrence, Trevor Lawrence, Dexter Lawrence's next
01:47team, if he gets traded?
01:49How do we explain the Texans being number two on the odds board behind only the Chargers of Los Angeles?
01:57I think because it does make a lot of sense.
02:00I mean, for the same reason that when I first saw that Dexter Lawrence was available, I thought, oh, man,
02:06let's do this, D'Amico.
02:07Come on.
02:10And we know that D'Amico loves his defensive lineman.
02:13I think largely a lot of it, though, is that a lot of it can boil down to disrespect for
02:19Tommy Togiai.
02:20I think a lot of people around the league look at the Texans' depth chart, and they see Sheldon Rankins,
02:24and they see this guy Tommy Togiai,
02:26and the Texans signed Logan Hall, who's going to be in the rotation as well.
02:30And they think, wow, this is a really good defense.
02:32They always want really good defensive linemen.
02:34And there's a perception that the defensive tackles were worse than they were last year.
02:39Partly, I think, really because – and this goes for Texans fans, too.
02:44People after the Bucs game last year were really upset with the defensive tackles.
02:49I was, too, but I was also upset with the defensive ends and the linebackers.
02:53Yeah, they could tackle.
02:54That was a committee affair.
02:55That was a bad tackling game for them.
02:56Yeah, well, and it was a bad – the defensive linemen were, including the defensive ends, were really falling prey
03:03to a lot of misdirection and things.
03:05And they buttoned it up, and they ended up being one of the best run defenses in the league, even
03:10though a lot of people never felt like it.
03:12I kept getting questions all through the end of the season of, why are they so bad against the run?
03:16They're like a top-five team against the run.
03:18I don't know what you want from them.
03:21So, I think that – it's that.
03:23I think there's not a lot of name-brand appeal on the interior of the defensive line in the eyes
03:28of the public, despite the fact that they're still a very, very good defense.
03:31I'll give you – I'll give you another reason why I think they're this high on the odds board, and
03:35it's Nick Casario.
03:36Nick Casario has a pretty – first of all, nobody's more active as a GM making deals, whether it's free
03:43agency, trade.
03:44Like, he does a lot of things.
03:46Like, the Texans seem to be in the transaction section of the – you know, of a website more often
03:52than most teams in the NFL.
03:54I would add to that that Nick Casario has a fairly high ratio among GMs of making trades that have
04:00some sizzle to it.
04:01He – the Deshaun Watson trade was the sizzliest trade of arguably the last five years.
04:06Now, he was kind of forced into that because of Deshaun not wanting to be here and then his legal
04:10situation.
04:10But I would say, you know, the trade for Stefan Diggs, the trade up to get Will Anderson in the
04:16draft.
04:18Nick Casario is not afraid to make big moves.
04:22This would be a huge move if they were to trade for Dexter Lawrence.
04:25So, I think, you know, look, these betting odds are driven by the public, by and large.
04:30And I think the public probably views the Texans – one, they view the Texans as a good defense, and
04:35this could be viewed –
04:37in Houston, we already know what you said yesterday, which is, look,
04:40you only have so many resources, probably don't need Dexter Lawrence on this defense.
04:44It's already a great defense.
04:45People outside of Houston that might be driving this betting line,
04:49they're driving activity on the Texans at 7-1 to get Dexter Lawrence,
04:53they might look at – they might look at and go,
04:55this is the finishing touches on a potentially historic defense kind of thing.
05:00The one that doesn't make sense on here either is the Titans are the third favorite,
05:04tied for third favorite to land Dexter Lawrence,
05:06which I think if you're a Texans fan, you think about what those Titans defensive tackles have done
05:12to the Texans interior offensive line, that might make you a little bit nervous.
05:15You should still be nervous until the Texans interior offensive line really proves that they can operate
05:20because they do have Jeffrey Simmons and they do – they have John Franklin Myers,
05:25who they just gave a big free agency contact to.
05:28Yeah, and they spent heavily on defense in free agency, so I think via trade and free agency.
05:34So I think that that's probably part of it is the perception that, okay,
05:39the Titans are going to really try to stock up on defense.
05:41It wouldn't make a whole lot of sense that they would pay three guys at defensive tackles the way they
05:47would have to.
05:47They have 70 million bucks allocated to defensive tackle.
05:50It would be crazy.
05:51It would be crazy.
05:52How about this stat set that I saw yesterday?
05:54I mean, if you're Dexter Lawrence's side of things here, if you're his representation,
05:59you take this Warren Sharpe tweet that he put – and I'm assuming Warren Sharpe is accurate on this.
06:04I mean, this is what he does.
06:05He puts out numbers.
06:07So pressures went aligned at nose tackle since 2022, okay?
06:12So these are players aligned at nose tackle for the last four seasons.
06:16And he does that thing where he's got Dexter Lawrence with 108.
06:19Then he takes every integer after that and just lists it vertically on the tweet.
06:25And there's no name – so Dexter Lawrence has 108, and then you go down hundreds in the 90s and
06:32the 80s,
06:33and nobody's even in the 70s, 60s.
06:34The next closest nose tackle in QB pressures since 2022 is Vita Vea of the Buccaneers with 32.
06:44The next closest guy is 70 pressures behind him.
06:49Yeah, so that's when you're aligned up over the center as a nose tackle.
06:52And the reason is part of it is usually, you know, if Dexter Lawrence was on a lesser defensive line,
07:00like he's athletic enough that I think they would line him up even more at three technique between the guard
07:05and the tackle
07:05than they do because he can go out there and he can play all over the line and everything.
07:09But he's just kind of a freakish guy in terms of his ability to play the run as a nose
07:14tackle
07:14and soak up a lot of double teams but also rush the passer.
07:18And it's hard to do when you're at nose tackle because you end up getting more double teams.
07:22You end up getting more assistance from guards.
07:24It's really, really impressive.
07:25He's an awesome football player.
07:27He really, really is.
07:29And if the Texans hadn't already committed so much money on the defensive line,
07:34and I'm saying that including Will Anderson in it because Will Anderson is about to get a huge deal.
07:40Daniil Hunter is about to get a huge deal.
07:41You've got to just look at it and say responsibly, where do we need to spend more money on this
07:47football team?
07:48We just can't keep doubling and tripling and down on something that's already really good.
07:53Well, we still need to – and not to mention the draft capital because you might have to give up
07:58a first-rounder
07:59or a couple of second-rounders to get Dexter Lawrence on resources that could be spent either bolstering depth
08:05or helping out the offense or whatever.
08:07If you're starting edge rushers on this team, if Daniil Hunter were still a Viking
08:11and you're starting edge rushers were Will Anderson Jr. and, say, Derek Barnett.
08:15I'll just use Derek Barnett as an example.
08:17Like journeyman vet who's making a few million bucks, then go for it on this Dexter Lawrence thing.
08:22You know, you attack things a different way.
08:25I've never seen one of these Warren Sharp tweets where he does the vertical listing of numbers
08:29with a bigger gap between one and two than this one.
08:33This is a – it's a sight to behold, man.
08:37Part of that is true.
08:38I think somebody else had done it.
08:39If you do it, if you go back – like Jordan Davis, if you do it over the last two
08:42seasons,
08:43is a lot closer to Dexter Lawrence.
08:45So there's the whole – every time you go back – it's impressive.
08:50I don't want to take anything away from it.
08:51Oh, yeah, no, two names that are interesting on here.
08:53Vita Veya was second at 32.
08:55Tied for third is DJ Reader, former Texan.
08:58How about Roy Lopez, eighth?
09:01Or I think – no, ninth?
09:02No, seventh.
09:03Seventh.
09:04Seventh, 22 – he's seventh on this list.
09:06Oh, Roy Lopez, who was – he was a big face of the team back in the Lovie Smith-David
09:12Culley days.
09:13He was at the draft party signing autographs.
09:15He was.
09:15He was.
09:16Yeah, good for Roy Lopez.
09:17Found a home.
09:18I like it.
09:18I like it.
Comments

Recommended