- 8 months ago
creator connect video:egkowmf
Category
🗞
NewsTranscript
00:00Like Mana Mitra, technology, when combined with strong government intent, thoughtful design, and inclusive accessibility, can fundamentally transform the way
00:11citizens interact with government systems.
00:14Now, to continue this momentum, I request Srinara Lokeshji and Ms. Sandhya Devanathan to please join us again on stage
00:20as we move to a very special segment of the evening,
00:24an exclusive fireside chat that brings together leadership from government and technology on stage, offering valuable perspectives on the evolving
00:32role of technology and innovation in strengthening citizen engagement.
00:36It's an honor to present a conversation between Srinara Lokeshji, Honorable Minister of IT and Minister of HRD Government of
00:44Andhra Pradesh, and Ms. Sandhya Devanathan, Vice President of India and Southeast Asia Meta.
00:48Please join me in welcoming the conversation on stage.
01:10Hi, everyone. It's such a privilege to have all of you in the room today, and such a privilege to
01:15have you, sir, in the room as well.
01:17Thank you so much, Nara Lokeshji, for taking the time to be here with us today.
01:21And we have a really exciting discussion because you, I remember this, you know, when we first met, and I
01:28remember your vision for Andhra, for Manamitra that we talked about for the state of Andhra.
01:33And what you had talked at that time was one single WhatsApp number for all citizen services.
01:40And it was, and your goal was really simple, which was to simplify governance and enhance, you know, citizen service
01:47accessibility.
01:48So could you talk about how you came up with this idea to begin with?
01:53Because this was quite transformative, because we were having some pilots, but this was the next leap.
02:02Thank you, Sandeer, for hosting me.
02:05You know, the idea came about when I did my Padhyatra, where citizens would ask me that I would push
02:11a button and I get groceries to home, or I get a taxi, or I can watch a movie.
02:16So why is government not proactive in delivering services?
02:21So it was actually an electoral promise that I made during my Padhyatra that we'll bring all the citizen services
02:28onto a single platform, a number, and deliver on the promise of ease of living.
02:34So that's where this idea came about.
02:36So it was inspired by the experience that people of Andhra Pradesh were actually having across various other technology platforms.
02:43And then I realized that everyone loves WhatsApp in India, and that's when we reached out to Meta, and then
02:49we started the discussion.
02:50And I remember the aggressive timeline you put as well for us.
02:54Do you want to talk about that a bit?
02:58I'm sure my chief minister will be watching this, and I'll get into a lot of trouble.
03:02We agreed to do this project in 60 days.
03:04It took us 90 days to launch.
03:06So if all of you have followed, Andhra is known for speed of doing business.
03:10But, yes, I think we've started in the right direction, and I think we've really solved the basic problems that
03:16our citizens today face.
03:18And I think just in terms of from the genesis of an idea to actual implementation, and trust me, 90
03:25days is very fast, but Manamatra scaled rapidly.
03:29We started with 160 services in Feb last year.
03:33And now it's almost 900 citizen services, and, you know, increasing every day.
03:39A significant expansion, if I may say that, across multiple departments, all in a very short period of time.
03:45So would love to hear your, you know, insights into the journey, because it's very rapid growth.
03:50A little about, as you think about bringing all of these services online, and your vision for this one number
03:57citizen services, a bit about the internal processes, the technologies, and collaboration that would have had to be enabled.
04:04You know, because I think we are a platform which enables it, but actually the real work gets done in
04:09the back end in terms of processes.
04:11And what mindset shifts were necessary, because there was that as well, right?
04:16Because multiple different government teams, stakeholders, to transition from a very traditional service delivery to a citizen-centric digital, you
04:25know, approach.
04:26And I think we'd love to hear from you on key learnings, key challenges, and how you approach this, because
04:32at the heart of it, it's still a simple solution to use.
04:35I think the biggest challenge is internal politics.
04:40You know, every department would like to control the experience, control data.
04:46But what makes things unique in Andhra Pradesh is we have something called real-time governance.
04:50It's actually a ministry.
04:52And I happen to be the minister of it.
04:54This is something our Chief Minister, Mr. Nigel, envisaged way back in 2016-17.
05:00And ever since, it's taken different forms.
05:02But now we've come out with a new avatar.
05:05But the biggest challenge was to bring everyone to come, sit, discuss, and then open up their AIs.
05:12So technology is merely an enabler of change, but real change should actually happen culturally.
05:17The cultural shift is important.
05:19So that's where I had to sit with the various ministers, ministries, secretaries, to have a very open conversation that
05:26this is going to be a politically important subject for us.
05:29This is the mandate of our Honourable Chief Minister and we need to get it done.
05:34Then we had to work department by department.
05:36We said, first let's get the high sort of traffic services going.
05:42And then work backwards to the more niche services which are used occasionally, but are important for that few citizens
05:48who want to use it.
05:49So it was building that consensus and, of course, when we launched, the success that we've sort of delivered on
05:56the first 100 odd services, that really enabled us.
05:59It was a catalyst for every department to say, aha, this works and this can transform.
06:05And then this was part of our discussion in every cabinet meeting where the Chief Minister would also say that,
06:10okay, you're launching this service, make it WhatsApp first.
06:14So that's the approach that we've taken as a state.
06:17And I believe this is just the beginning.
06:19You know, before I came for the session, we were talking about how can we now go from menu-based
06:24to more AI-driven.
06:26How can you use, you know, conversational AI?
06:29How can we use, of course, your call center, Agentic AI, and deliver these services and build trust on the
06:34platform further?
06:35So, I mean, in that sense, I think the most important thing for all the secretaries here to the policymakers
06:41here is that that political will is going to be very, very important to deliver this.
06:46In fact, I remember one meeting where we had come down to Amravati as well.
06:49And I think the mandate was very clear from the Honorable Chief Minister and from you, sir, around how we
06:55make this across all departments, not make it small in scope, but over a period of time, really add more
07:00and more services.
07:01And you're right.
07:02I think that kind of, you know, will across multiple departments with your leadership was really helpful.
07:08No, I think if I can add, you know, this is a question that I keep asking my team.
07:13So, I'm also the HRD minister.
07:15I keep telling them, you know, keep the child as center of our universe and then look at it from
07:20a policy.
07:22It puts things in perspective.
07:23Similarly, in RTG, I said, let's put the citizen as center of our universe, not the chief minister.
07:28General tendency is, you know, what is the reports he needs or what do we need to do?
07:31I said, flip it.
07:32Let's keep the citizen as center of our universe.
07:35And then as departments, we're here to serve the citizen.
07:38And that sort of changed our entire thought process.
07:41And the team really came together.
07:42And they all came together.
07:43And of course, we continue to fight.
07:45Some of them resist change.
07:47A few of the temples are not yet on the platform.
07:50So, it's a constant struggle that we have.
07:52But, you know, greater part of the services have now come on board.
07:56Awesome.
07:56And over the past months, since we launched Manumitra,
08:00what kind of feedback have you directly received from citizens and district officers on the ground?
08:06I know your WhatsApp keeps blowing up with feedback and messages.
08:10Are there any memorable examples or stories where a citizen reached out to you directly
08:15and shared about how their life was significantly transformed by accessing public services?
08:20I think, you know, hall tickets.
08:24I happen to be the HRD minister.
08:26So, hall tickets, I didn't know, were so cumbersome.
08:29So, this idea came from my citizen saying that, you know,
08:32why don't you make it WhatsApp enabled from day one?
08:35And that simple transformation made it so much more easy for our kids to access hall tickets.
08:41And they didn't have to go to any other center or take printouts.
08:43It was so seamless.
08:45And I could see a flurry of messages that came after we launched.
08:48They said, thank you so much.
08:49It saved time.
08:50It saved energy.
08:52In this kind of summer, we don't need to go out.
08:56So, it really helped in that sense.
08:58The other areas, you know, paying utility bills was really transformative.
09:05And I continued to get feedback across board.
09:07Where citizens, you know, they get to know my number.
09:10They share their feedback.
09:12And, you know, they're very appreciative of our services.
09:14But what's even more exciting is, once the citizen avails the service,
09:19we have a mechanism where we collect feedback from the citizen.
09:23So, and departments are ranked based on this feedback.
09:27My Honorable Chief Minister actually reviews this on a weekly basis.
09:32So, there's an RTG meeting where he actually reviews this.
09:35And he gives this feedback to the ministers and the secretary saying,
09:38okay, you've did or you've improved.
09:40This is how we can do better.
09:42And that has sort of enabled us to refine, fine-tune our services.
09:46That's why I was sharing, you know, when we met, I was sharing that on a scale 1 to 10,
09:51where am I?
09:51I'm at 3.
09:53I need to now, you know, really improve to the next level.
09:56Though my citizens have rated us at 8.5, 9.
09:59But as a minister, I believe that we can do better.
10:01We can really, you know, unlock the potential of AI in that sense.
10:06In fact, that's, you're absolutely right in terms of just the vision and the ambition that you can have.
10:13I think AI enables a lot more of what you have planned in terms of citizen services at citizens' fingertips.
10:20And that's actually my next question, right?
10:21I think, one, you've become recently the first state government that formally incorporated WhatsApp governance in a state budget.
10:30And we saw that, you know, come through this year.
10:33We already have conversations with your team.
10:35We're also in conversations with your team on how we can leverage AI for better experience for the citizens.
10:40And you just talked about that.
10:42So what new features or integration do you think, and you touched a little bit, maybe if you can elaborate,
10:47that can make Manamitra even more impactful for citizens?
10:50What's your vision there?
10:52And can you share with us how the state plans to integrate more advanced features, such as AI-powered, personal
10:58assistant, predictive alerts, secured digital certificates on QR codes?
11:02There's a whole bunch of things technology now makes possible.
11:05So, and I know you're a technologist.
11:08So, how do you think about that?
11:10And as a sharing, every industrial revolution has created more jobs than it has replaced.
11:15But it has created these jobs in geographies where they were ready for that industrial revolution.
11:23So, it's imperative that India embraces AI and we actually lead the conversation.
11:29And that's where Andhra Pradesh is playing a significant role, starting from data centers to all the way to actually
11:34empowering citizens.
11:36Saying that I believe that AI is here.
11:39And the entire Data Lake project is that where we are ensuring that the data gets tightly integrated.
11:45And keeping, again, a citizen at the center of our universe in terms of delivering services.
11:50That's where now AI is playing a much larger role.
11:53So, once we issue a birth certificate, automatically a lot of things can sort of get integrated.
11:59That tracking, that ability to use the basic rule engine and actually deliver it and have the documents ready,
12:06though the citizen might ask for it or might not ask for it.
12:10But when they want it, it's there.
12:12And that's where I believe that AI is going to play a very, very powerful role.
12:16And that's what I believe is the next wave in terms of what we are going to do in Andhra
12:20Pradesh.
12:21Saying that, you know, what excites me is the conversational AI bit.
12:24You know, our ability to empower citizens and not go through.
12:28You know, we've done the menu bit, which I call version 1.0.
12:31And now we need to do the 2.0 in the next 90 days.
12:34And, you know, using AI just to make...
12:36You have a new target.
12:37I think my team is here already, so they're writing the minutes down.
12:40But 90 days, I think we can do the AI bit where it becomes a lot more easy.
12:44You know, the experience can become a lot more easy.
12:46The third part and the most important part is when there's a financial transaction.
12:51How do you give that sense of confidence and trust to the citizen?
12:56That yes, you know, you're paying to the government, it is secure.
13:00And that is going to require a lot more sort of collaborative workshops, engaging citizens, giving them that comfort.
13:09So people are going to know how much they're due in terms of power bill or property taxes.
13:15But then some of them still are like, okay, you know, I'd rather pay manually.
13:20Because we have to build a trust factor as we go.
13:22So I think that's the next focus area for us in terms of taking Manamitra 2.0.
13:282.0.
13:29So we are at about 30% of us households using Manamitra.
13:34And we want to take this to now 100%.
13:37So that's why we're going to back it with a sort of a door-to-door campaign to explain this
13:42to our citizens.
13:43And anyone who has a doubt, we can actually sort of give them an idea of how to use it
13:47if required.
13:48You know, do some use cases then and there.
13:50That's awesome.
13:51But I want to go back to what you've said across multiple questions now, which is you keep the citizen
13:56at the center of it and then build for the, you know, based on what the citizen wants.
14:01So AI, the same way, is an enabler for what the citizen, how easily the citizen could access services or,
14:08you know, go about his day-to-day life, his or her day-to-day life.
14:11And I think that's also something that we think about a lot, which is how can we make WhatsApp more
14:15powerful for users and how can we make it simpler to use as well.
14:19And that's why AI voice, you know, conversations on WhatsApp make it very easy versus, you know, like you said,
14:26menu-based.
14:27So we love the idea as well of taking this to WhatsApp 2.0.
14:33I want to go to my next question, and you sort of alluded to it, which is 30% of
14:37households are already using Manamitra today.
14:40I think since the bot launched, more than 50 lakh people have used it in Andhra.
14:47And I think that as you think about Manamitra in terms of simplifying citizen services to government services, how do
14:55you, you know, how does citizen access to government services, how do you think this has worked particularly for rural
15:00households, for women, and for low literacy populations?
15:05Do you see a difference there?
15:07No, definitely.
15:08I think, you know, their willingness to sort of adapt to technology is always going to be at a different
15:14level.
15:14Urban will be ahead of the curve, rural will be the next one.
15:18But then sort of educating and giving this idea that, yes, you know, government services are available on the phone.
15:24So power of using Manamitra for farmers to understand, you know, what are the government services that are eligible.
15:31Or the second is when we actually do a scheme disbursement, sort of proactively reaching out to saying, you know,
15:37this is what has happened.
15:38You know, this is the money we've deposited.
15:41You know, are you satisfied?
15:42Is there anything else that we can do?
15:43Or someone who didn't get benefit from that scheme can sort of raise a workflow and say that, you know,
15:50I believe that I am eligible and I didn't get it.
15:53And all through their mobile device.
15:56So they don't need to go to an office or go to the, you know, local government's center or the
16:01Miseva Center in that sense.
16:03So they can do it from their phone.
16:04And that has really transformed, you know, the entire workflow.
16:09And it has enabled us to look at, okay, this is the grievance that's raised.
16:13And then how many of them got solved?
16:14At what point did they get solved?
16:16Because earlier they would still say, I want to verify you.
16:19So you come to my office.
16:21So we said, no, you can't do that.
16:22It has to be all online.
16:24Because it's all done through Aadhaar.
16:26There's a certain amount of safety, security that's actually in place.
16:29And that's what we have built out.
16:31And I think there, the bit that you talked about, which is also the trust factor and awareness.
16:38I think as time goes by, people will get a lot more comfortable as well.
16:41And with voice integrated, I think it also makes it a lot easier for people to access.
16:46But that's, yeah, it's pretty awesome.
16:50You know, moving, sticking to the theme of services, what services have you seen have the highest uptake on Manamitra?
16:57We saw the video.
16:58There's everything from temple booking to getting certificates to getting hall tickets.
17:03And what measurable improvements have you actually seen?
17:06So in terms of either fewer office visits, faster turnaround time, something took five months, now you get it instantly.
17:13Citizen satisfaction, you measure that with feedback.
17:15What are some hard metrics that you've actually seen move?
17:20And what do people use the most?
17:23Utility payments is one service that is used widely.
17:27Second is the service around hall tickets, getting to know about your examination results.
17:33That's something that's really widely used by citizens at large.
17:37So, I mean, for us, every service is important, whether it's high velocity or low velocity.
17:42Because if, again, keeping the citizen as center of the universe, if they have a problem, we are here to
17:48solve that.
17:48Or if they need a solution, we need to go find that.
17:51And we've seen that gradually our scores improving.
17:55So, citizen satisfaction improving while they've used the services.
18:00And wherever we've been sort of rated low, we've used a mechanism to reach out to them and understand what's,
18:07why have you rated as low?
18:08So, how can we do this better?
18:10So, that sort of iterative process and closing the loop has really helped us sort of improve services as we
18:17go.
18:18But then, with all fairness, all this works, if you have a very integrated and a tight data lake, as
18:24we call it in Andhra, the data lake is going to be very critical.
18:28If your data sets are disjoint, this project is not going to be successful at all.
18:34So, that's going to be very, very critical for states that are looking at scaling it up beyond the first
18:40100, 150 services.
18:42So, if you want to get to the 900, then it really becomes important.
18:45And I guess that's a parallel sort of track where you're continuing to invest in fidelity of that data lake
18:50and what's in it.
18:51Absolutely. So, data lake is going to be very, very critical.
18:55Two, I think this provides an opportunity even for policy makers and the bureaucrats in the room is to question
19:02every process.
19:03So, that's the approach that we started to take.
19:05We said, okay, one, we brought everything online, great.
19:08But did we bring a broken system and made it online?
19:12How far is it truly delivering real time?
19:17That's why we said, no, let's do process re-engineering.
19:20So, if X takes 10 steps, what are the four steps that I can throw out of the window?
19:25How can we make this a lot more proactive rather than reactive?
19:30You know, there's some certificates which we say that you apply and then we deliver.
19:35So, my challenge to the team is why should they even apply?
19:37It should be there.
19:39With the power of AI, it actually can be done.
19:41And the rule engine is quite straightforward in that sense.
19:44So, that's where we have sort of re-looked at the entire process.
19:48So, a great example of this is CAST certificate.
19:50It's a weird thing that you need to apply periodically for a CAST certificate.
19:54I said, no, we should not do that.
19:55There should be a framework where once delivered, it's done.
19:58Put it on a QR code where track and trace exists.
20:02Blockchain.
20:02So, we know who issued the certificate.
20:04When did they issue the certificate.
20:06So, if there's any legal recourse also, it's clear.
20:09So, that's where we've done all this.
20:10And then, of course, we need to ensure that the entire regulatory framework is also in place.
20:15That gives it a bit more, which is more binding in nature.
20:19In fact, I was just sharing with Lokeshji that I was talking to somebody at Meta who's a very senior
20:24person in the company.
20:27And they wanted it for their country.
20:29So, we're like, how do we not have it in our own country in Europe?
20:33This is someone in Europe.
20:34And they were like, this is awesome.
20:36But back to what you just said, I think that's been our experiences across all states, which is the process
20:41re-engineering, putting what takes 10 steps, can we do it in six?
20:46And then using WhatsApp as a forcing function to deliver that.
20:49So, like I said, we're just a platform where you can deliver this.
20:52But using this opportunity also to re-engineer some old processes.
20:57I think that's very, very important.
20:59And as India goes about this journey of digitization, it's very important that we re-look at everything.
21:06Because honestly, in certain areas, we've done digitization, but I think we've ruined certain systems.
21:12So, there are enough examples of where we've got…
21:15I feel that, yes, we've digitized it, but we seem to have gone backwards.
21:18We made citizens' lives a lot more difficult.
21:21So, it's very important that now we start…
21:23Every one of us sort of question, why is this taking so many steps?
21:27Why should it take so much time?
21:29So, Jogmi, you tell my secretary, my IT secretary, that, you know, the day we make a politician
21:33and a bureaucrat irrelevant in day-to-day lives of a citizen, then we have succeeded.
21:38That's my simple thumb rule.
21:40I said, that's when we've succeeded, we've done something right, and we've done sort of
21:44service to our great nation.
21:46So, it's really inspiring to see all the work we're doing with states in the country.
21:50And like I said, I think we're the first to do it in India globally.
21:54So, that gives us also a lot of satisfaction.
21:58At least, I believe.
21:59I don't know if I'm right on that, but I think we have the best.
22:02I think you touched upon a little bit on the lessons that you've learned.
22:08If, for this audience, what do you think, from your experience, you know, can help, you know,
22:14everyone in this room inform similar rollouts in other states or even nationally?
22:19And if you had to prioritize and pick two or three things, what would they be that we need
22:24to address first?
22:25I think you talked about process simplification, a few more.
22:27But if you had to pick three things and give that as advice to this group, what would that be?
22:33Honestly, in India, every state has its own unique challenges.
22:37So, I think it will be unfair for me to sort of tell what other states should do.
22:42But as far as Andhra is concerned, why are we, why were we able to achieve what we've achieved?
22:48One, we have a robust data leak that has enabled us to sort of onboard all the services.
22:57The second is the political will, where from our chief minister all the way down,
23:03believes in this project, it becomes a strategically important project.
23:07And for us, it was an electoral promise.
23:09For me personally, it was my promise during my Padihatra, my walkathon.
23:13So, there's a lot of emotion value that we've invested into this project and to see it succeed.
23:20And then time and again, it's very important to go back and reiterate the importance of this.
23:24Because then there's always a fatigue that sort of creeps in and departments have different priorities.
23:29But it's important that political leadership also ensures that this is on top of the priority
23:34of every department and they understand its importance.
23:39And that's where I think Andhra has managed to get both of it relatively right.
23:43I wouldn't say we're perfect, but I believe that we are in the right trajectory.
23:48And I think a year from now, we would have a model that I believe is close to perfection.
23:53That's awesome.
23:54This was such an inspiring, just sitting and listening to how you've,
23:57I know we've partnered very closely on this, but even listening to how you sort of made this a reality
24:02and now it's 900 services and counting and it's in your state budget and how you're thinking
24:07about rolling it out with a citizen at the center of it and deploying AI.
24:11I think it's really inspiring to hear.
24:13We have many more examples here in the room also.
24:16We're doing incredible work.
24:17You saw some of it in the presentation.
24:19But it's something that delights us as well, that WhatsApp can play a role in helping you reach your citizens.
24:27So, thank you so much, sir.
24:28Really appreciate this.
24:30And thank you so much for your time and your sponsorship.
24:33Thanks for having me.
24:34Appreciate it, Sande.