ಭಾರತ-ಚೀನಾ ಗಡಿ ಸಂಘರ್ಷದ ವಿಚಾರವಾಗಿ ಲೋಕಸಭೆಯಲ್ಲಿ ಆಡಳಿತ ಮತ್ತು ವಿಪಕ್ಷಗಳ ನಡುವೆ ತೀವ್ರ ವಾಕ್ಸಮರ ನಡೆದಿದೆ. ನಿವೃತ್ತ ಸೇನಾ ಮುಖ್ಯಸ್ಥ ಎಂ.ಎಂ. ನರವಾಣೆ ಅವರ ಇನ್ನೂ ಪ್ರಕಟವಾಗದ 'ಫೋರ್ ಸ್ಟಾರ್ಸ್ ಆಫ್ ಡೆಸ್ಟಿನಿ' ಪುಸ್ತಕವನ್ನು ಉಲ್ಲೇಖಿಸಿ, 2020ರ ಗಡಿ ಸಂಘರ್ಷದ ವೇಳೆ ಪ್ರಧಾನಿ ಮೋದಿ ಕರ್ತವ್ಯ ಲೋಪ ಎಸಗಿದ್ದಾರೆ ಎಂದು ರಾಹುಲ್ ಗಾಂಧಿ ಗಂಭೀರ ಆರೋಪ ಮಾಡಿದರು. "ಚೀನಾ ಟ್ಯಾಂಕರ್ಗಳು ನುಗ್ಗಿದಾಗ ಮೋದಿ ಸೇನೆಯ ಬೆನ್ನಿಗೆ ನಿಲ್ಲಲಿಲ್ಲ" ಎಂದು ರಾಹುಲ್ ವಾಗ್ದಾಳಿ ನಡೆಸಿದರು. ಇದಕ್ಕೆ ಆಕ್ಷೇಪ ವ್ಯಕ್ತಪಡಿಸಿದ ಗೃಹ ಸಚಿವ ಅಮಿತ್ ಶಾ, ಪ್ರಕಟವಾಗದ ಪುಸ್ತಕದ ಬಗ್ಗೆ ಚರ್ಚಿಸುವುದು ನಿಯಮಬಾಹಿರ ಎಂದು ತಿರುಗೇಟು ನೀಡಿದರು. ಈ ಗದ್ದಲದ ನಡುವೆಯೇ ವಿಪಕ್ಷಗಳು ಮೋದಿಗೆ ಮುತ್ತಿಗೆ ಹಾಕಲು ಯತ್ನಿಸಿದ ಪ್ರಸಂಗವೂ ನಡೆಯಿತು.
ಸುವರ್ಣ ನ್ಯೂಸ್ನ ಜನಪ್ರಿಯ ಚರ್ಚಾ ಕಾರ್ಯಕ್ರಮ 'ಲೆಫ್ಟ್ ರೈಟ್ & ಸೆಂಟರ್', ವಿಷಯ ತಜ್ಞರ ನೇರಾನೇರ ಹಣಾಹಣಿ. ಅಜಿತ್ ಹನುಮಕ್ಕನವರ್ ನಡೆಸಿಕೊಡುವ 'ಲೆಫ್ಟ್ ರೈಟ್ & ಸೆಂಟರ್' ಚರ್ಚಾ ಕಣದಲ್ಲಿ ಇಂದಿನ ವಿಷಯದ ಆಳವಾದ ಅವಲೋಕನ.
Suvarna News | Kannada News | Asianet Suvarna News | Latest Kannada News | Suvarna News 24x7 | ಕನ್ನಡ ಲೈವ್ ನ್ಯೂಸ್ | ಏಷ್ಯಾನೆಟ್ ಸುವರ್ಣ ನ್ಯೂಸ್
Suvarna News Kannada Debate | Suvarna News Discussion | Ajit Hanamakkanavar | Left Right And Centre
#ParliamentSession #RahulGandhi #PMModi #ChinaBorder #MMNaravane #LokSabha #LeftRightAndCentre #SuvarnaNewsDebate #SuvarnaNewsDiscussion #KannadaNews #AjitHanamakkanavar #DKShivakumar #SuvarnaNews #KannadaNews #AsianetSuvarnaNews #KarnatakaPolitics #politics #karnataka #news
Suvarna News Live: https://youtube.com/live/KeAuH_bcbwU
Download the Asianet News App now! Available on Android & iOS
👉 Android:
https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.vserv.asianet&hl=en_IN
👉 iOS:
https://apps.apple.com/in/app/asianet-news-official/id1093450032
Like and Subscribe:
WhatsApp ► https://whatsapp.com/channel/0029Va9CL2hGE56uFHsT3J2s
YouTube ► https://www.youtube.com/@AsianetSuvarnaNews
Website ► https://kannada.asianetnews.com/
Facebook ► https://www.facebook.com/SuvarnaNews
Twitter ► https://twitter.com/AsianetNewsSN
Instagram ► https://www.instagram.com/asianetsuvarnanews/
ಸುವರ್ಣ ನ್ಯೂಸ್ನ ಜನಪ್ರಿಯ ಚರ್ಚಾ ಕಾರ್ಯಕ್ರಮ 'ಲೆಫ್ಟ್ ರೈಟ್ & ಸೆಂಟರ್', ವಿಷಯ ತಜ್ಞರ ನೇರಾನೇರ ಹಣಾಹಣಿ. ಅಜಿತ್ ಹನುಮಕ್ಕನವರ್ ನಡೆಸಿಕೊಡುವ 'ಲೆಫ್ಟ್ ರೈಟ್ & ಸೆಂಟರ್' ಚರ್ಚಾ ಕಣದಲ್ಲಿ ಇಂದಿನ ವಿಷಯದ ಆಳವಾದ ಅವಲೋಕನ.
Suvarna News | Kannada News | Asianet Suvarna News | Latest Kannada News | Suvarna News 24x7 | ಕನ್ನಡ ಲೈವ್ ನ್ಯೂಸ್ | ಏಷ್ಯಾನೆಟ್ ಸುವರ್ಣ ನ್ಯೂಸ್
Suvarna News Kannada Debate | Suvarna News Discussion | Ajit Hanamakkanavar | Left Right And Centre
#ParliamentSession #RahulGandhi #PMModi #ChinaBorder #MMNaravane #LokSabha #LeftRightAndCentre #SuvarnaNewsDebate #SuvarnaNewsDiscussion #KannadaNews #AjitHanamakkanavar #DKShivakumar #SuvarnaNews #KannadaNews #AsianetSuvarnaNews #KarnatakaPolitics #politics #karnataka #news
Suvarna News Live: https://youtube.com/live/KeAuH_bcbwU
Download the Asianet News App now! Available on Android & iOS
👉 Android:
https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.vserv.asianet&hl=en_IN
👉 iOS:
https://apps.apple.com/in/app/asianet-news-official/id1093450032
Like and Subscribe:
WhatsApp ► https://whatsapp.com/channel/0029Va9CL2hGE56uFHsT3J2s
YouTube ► https://www.youtube.com/@AsianetSuvarnaNews
Website ► https://kannada.asianetnews.com/
Facebook ► https://www.facebook.com/SuvarnaNews
Twitter ► https://twitter.com/AsianetNewsSN
Instagram ► https://www.instagram.com/asianetsuvarnanews/
Category
🗞
NewsTranscript
00:00Hello, my name is Aseanet Suvarnan News.
00:04Left, right and center, I am Raksht Shetty.
00:08This is the question of the people and the people who are ruling the government.
00:16This is the question of the government.
00:22The government have a good job,
00:25the government have a good job,
00:26the government have a good job,
02:28This is from the memoir of Army Chief Narawane.
02:34And I'd like you to listen nicely.
02:39You will understand exactly who is patriotic, who is not.
02:47It'll take a little while, so this is about when four Chinese tanks were entering Indian
02:59territory.
02:59They were taking a ridge in Doklam and the army chief writes, and I quote from an article
03:10that is quoting his book, the tanks were within a few hundred meters of Indian positions on
03:17the Kailash Range.
03:18No, sir.
03:19No, sir.
03:20No, sir.
03:22No, no.
03:24He's not yielding.
03:26He's not yielding.
03:28He's on the foot.
03:30He's not yielding.
03:31He's not yielding.
03:32I'm not yielding.
03:34He was not yielding.
03:37So, this is 100% authentic, 100% authentic.
03:58Sir, Rajnath Singh is getting exercise because his name is going to be spoken.
04:07So, these are the memoirs of General Narawani, in which he said that he has not done it.
04:37So, this is the memoirs of General Narawani.
04:44So, this is the memoirs of General Narawani.
04:49So, this is the memoirs of General Narawani.
04:56So, this is the memoirs of General Narawani.
05:03He can write.
05:04Speaker Sir, this is guaranteed and authentic.
05:08Narawani has said that his memoirs are not published to him.
05:10The memoirs of General Narawani.
05:11He said that these books are not published to him.
05:13It's all wrote.
05:14I don't know why I'm not publishing them.
05:17I'm just saying I'm only trying to make a line
05:20which means...
05:24I'm not going to tell you.
05:33That's not what I want to do.
05:37You want to tell me that...
05:40I don't know.
06:10This is the case of Congress.
06:40the government has said this book does not exist
06:52Rajnath Singh Ji has said this book does not exist
06:55every youngster in India should see that this book exists
06:57this is Mr. Naravane's book
07:00Naravane Ji's book
07:01Chief of Army Staff
07:03General Naravane
07:05Rajnath Singh Ji's phone
07:07and said that the Chinese tanks are in our territory
07:11what do we have to do?
07:17first Rajnath Singh Ji has replied
07:19standing order was top
07:21that if the Chinese forces are in our territory
07:24then we have to fire without our question
07:25we have to do not do it
07:26Naravane Ji and our army
07:29who wanted to fire them
07:30because those tanks were in our territory
07:33we have to do it
07:35Naravane Ji Ji has a message
07:37that if you understand what you are in our territory
07:40you will do it
07:41you will do it
13:20Yes.
13:52Yes.
17:22In Pakistan, in 2016, we had a surgical strike, in 2019, we had a URI strike, and in 2025, we had a buildup along the L.A.C.
17:35This is how we build up the L.A.C.
17:39Purposely, we don't build infrastructure along the L.A.C.
17:42It helps the Chinese on the floor of the house.
17:46Post-2014, 2015, 2016, 2017, we had a skirmish and stand-offs, we had a build infrastructure, shelters, roads, bridges.
17:59This has been the Chinese.
18:02This is the pain point.
18:04Let's say, from Dubrook to DBO, almost about 250-odd kilometers along the Sherlock River,
18:15we had a build, we had a deployment, we had a fast deployment, we had a fast movement, we had a fast movement,
18:23we had a lot of problems.
18:24In 2008, we had a decision for Congress and government.
18:27But, we had no idea.
18:29Actually, on the ground, we had no idea.
18:31So, this has hit the Chinese.
18:33So, that is how various stand-offs have taken place.
18:352013, 2017, 2017, 2017, 2017, 2017, 2017, 2017, 2017, 2017, 2017.
18:42But 2020 run throughかな socialisties isdeant.
18:44how does the Chinese fight go up?
18:46These are my opening comments, I think.
18:48Yes! Yes!
18:49Joshi sir!
18:50thousands, thousands of people have passed.
18:51I must ask that.
18:52But one important fact is that you will not open fire unless cleared at the topmost level.
19:22So at that point, General Narwani had to escalate the problem to the level of Rajnath Singh, Defense Minister, Ajit Dhowal, NSA and Jay Shankar, our external affairs minister. And he kept asking them one question. What are my orders?
19:40So because there is an existing protocol, there is a question.
19:47Yes.
19:48There is an existing protocol.
19:51There is no protocol on Pakistan.
19:55There is no protocol on Pakistan.
19:57There is no protocol on the local commander.
19:58There is no suitable reply to the local commander.
20:03There is no one in the field.
20:05But in China, modernly, the situation is very different.
20:09The orders are very different.
20:11So that is why General Narwani had to escalate the matter to the highest level in Delhi.
20:19In Delhi.
20:20So he said that Rajnath Singh said that he did what he did.
20:26So the Prime Minister has decided to hand over his responsibility to the local, I mean army chief and to the local commanders.
20:39He said that there was an extreme possibility of this escalating into a major war between India and China.
20:51Because the tanks were coming almost 200-300 meters away from our tanks.
20:58Finally, you know, at about soon after Rajnath Singh says this,
21:04Chinese PLA commander has a message.
21:09He said that let us cool the situation.
21:13Let us have a meeting tomorrow morning at 9.30.
21:16And then we will consider the matter.
21:19Then General Narwani tells General Joshi,
21:23You just do not open fire, but take your tanks as far as possible and put them in a position of offence.
21:31But put your cannon down.
21:35You know, right up to the eyeball to eyeball level.
21:38So this is what exactly happens on that day.
21:45On the night of 29.30 August 2020.
21:50So this is where the dangerous situation is going to be overt.
21:56But the matter was almost getting into a trigger point.
22:02The trigger point is that someone is firing.
22:07So the causes belly comes to India.
22:10India will be blamed as an aggressor.
22:12So that's why we shouldn't have to do that.
22:13So when we discuss that,
22:16General Narwani is on the lower level,
22:19the mayor level, the mayor level,
22:21the president knows that.
22:23Sir, he knows that the president is right.
22:25So I think General Narwani was right.
22:26Sir, that's why he knows that the top leadership is the end of your team.
22:31He knows that the president is the end of your team.
22:32He knows that the Rekshan Satchivaru and PM is the end of the team.
22:34I will take up the matter at the political level.
23:03You do not escalate the matter and wait for a few more hours because there is always a hotline connection between the DGMOs from Delhi and also with Beijing.
23:19I have asked the DGMO in Beijing, in the PLA Headquarters, if you are a local tactical commander,
23:35I have asked the DGMOs to approve the DGMOs.
23:47Now it is all, you know, it is all wisdom and hindsight. That is useless.
23:52But I think the Prime Minister should have been more decisive because the Chief of AVI Staff is asking for a clear direction.
24:07Yes, Joshi Sarhaagiri, Joshi Sarhaagiri, Chandrasekharo.
24:12Here is the Indo-Pakistan border room and the Indo-China border room.
24:18They are in the same direction as a leader.
24:39the government has been using the government's laws.
24:41The government has no idea,
24:43it has been reported as well
24:45it is written as well
24:47and it continues to be written for us
24:49it has got a lot of information
24:51but, the government had not been read
24:53the government's books
24:55even though the government ended up
24:57being published
24:59it has been published
25:01still with the defences ministry
25:03because the Governor's conservative
25:05and the government from the press
25:07I don't know if you're confused about Rahul Gandhi.
25:12Rahul Gandhi's thoughts are very important.
25:17Even in the magazine, there's an article.
25:23There's an article in the moment of truth.
25:26There's an article in the 90th page.
25:28There's a lot of people who have a lot of people.
25:31There's a lot of people who have a lot of people.
25:33There's a lot of people who have a lot of people.
25:36At the same time, there's a lot of people who have a lot of people.
25:40There's a lot of people who have a lot of people.
25:43Other media is biter and Modi.
25:45I was just missing, there was an article in India.
25:49They think they're going to be published.
25:52They are going to join events and look at them.
25:54It's all about you.
25:56Let me share with you with yourself.
25:58Joshi, does look at the court,
26:00the court at the same time in the Indo-China border,
26:03there are still many protocols.
26:05That's why Narvani is here.
26:08That's why Narvani is here.
26:12How do you do this?
26:13No, let me explain.
26:15When Narvani is here,
26:19he is here and he is here.
26:22He is here and he is here.
26:25He is here and he is here.
26:29He is here and he is here.
26:32Why do you say that,
26:34the first question is that,
26:37about this firing will be there.
26:41If we are saying,
26:42we will do that in China.
26:43And this is a treaty,
26:45for the лож조 and tranquility agreement,
26:47in 1996,
26:48we don't speak 없.
26:50How do we get off the phone?
26:52When it comes to the military,
26:54whether there are any other issues
26:56between the Chancellor's nine-year-old
26:58Because in the 1980s, the major general Lulin was calling to the Indian Army chief.
27:06I was not a brother, but you were also a brother.
27:10He was calling to the United States to the United States.
27:13He was calling to the government.
27:16He was calling to the other side and he was calling to the other side.
27:21He was calling to the defense minister as well.
27:25When you talk about the Prime Minister, you will not have to deal with the ground.
27:30You will not have to deal with the ground.
27:34There is a difference between LOC and LES.
27:37There is a line of control between Pakistan and Bhartik.
27:42There is a line of control.
27:47There is a line of actual control.
27:50There is a line of control.
27:54There is a line of control.
27:59There are a line of control.
28:04The Prime Minister and CCD are the line of control.
28:10The government is the line of control.
28:15What are the lines of control?
28:17The government is correct.
28:20Yes, the government didn't have to deal with this.
28:23You have to deal with these two lines.
28:27Yes, the government is correct.
28:28What are the lines of control?
28:29What else are the lines of control?
28:30That's what the line is.
28:31It was a moment of profound isolation.
28:39So Narvane, on the map of JNK and Ladakh on the wall, he could visualize the location
28:49of each and every unit and formation in quotes.
28:53Even on the unmarked maps, a hundred different thoughts flashed across his mind.
28:58Economy was reeling under Covid, economy was faltering, global supply chains had fractured.
29:05Would we be able to endure a steady supply of spares, etc., under these conditions?
29:14In case of a long drawn out action, who were our supporters in the global arena and what
29:20about the collusive threat from China and Pakistan?
29:23We are ready in all respects, but I did not really want to start the war.
29:32The chief of army staff had the power of the army, so they were not able to do it.
29:39Sir, with due respect…
29:40One second…
29:41There is no peace.
30:06So this is a serious issue.
30:34So this is something which General Narvani has said.
30:43He is a serious issue.
30:45Who is this issue?
30:47Who is this issue?
30:49Who is this issue?
30:51Who is this issue?
30:53Who is this issue?
30:55Who is this issue?
30:58Who is this issue?
31:08Who is this issue?
31:09Who is this issue?
31:10Who is this issue?
31:14So these are all very serious matters.
31:17Why are you talking about this issue?
31:20You can't speak about this issue.
31:22You can't speak about the country.
31:24Congress is speaking about it.
31:27You can speak about it.
31:28You can speak about it.
31:30You can speak about the country.
31:32It is not published in India because Ministry of Defense has not given permission.
31:39It is not the right word.
31:40It is not the right word.
31:42They have to speak.
31:44The interpretation is understood.
31:45If you have permission for this issue, I said to you.
31:48I said to you never give.
31:49I said to you never give.
31:50I said to you never give.
31:51I said to him never give.
31:52I said to him never give.
31:54I don't have to say anything about it.
31:57So, this is a very serious issue.
32:00It's a matter of national security.
32:03In this case,
32:06in June,
32:09in Galvan,
32:10we have to say that
32:12we have to say that
32:14we have to say that
32:16so this is a very serious situation.
32:18We have to say that
32:23I have to say that
32:25the Prime Minister has to say that
32:26the Prime Minister is going to give a phone
32:28and not to be able to do.
32:30Note that
32:32the Chief of Army Staff
32:34the Chief of Army Staff
32:36is Nalak General Jothimahat
32:37Doval
32:39General Bipin Rawat
32:43Jay Shankar
32:46of Rajnath Singh.
32:47Why do they talk about the first ministers?
32:50The first ministers who have elected the president and the president will be elected to the president.
32:59But this is why they are elected to the president.
33:02We are going to call them the British government.
33:04I will quote each other.
33:06In this case, everyone is going to sign a national movement.
33:11Indian army get some poor na swathantra vanna kottre a psycho thing
33:16I don't know I don't know I don't know what I'm going to work and never be a
33:29purely military decision it is taken by a democratically elected political
33:35leadership during the 1999 conflict and atal bihari watch by every action was
33:41debated and approved in meetings of the cabinet committee on security India's
33:47final decision making body on national security chaired by the prime minister
33:52memoirs from that period show CCS being able to own its decisions and issue
33:59clear directives to military commanders the same was true of Indira Gandhi
34:04Indira Gandhi during the 1971 war that led to the liberation of Bangladesh we are a
34:10democratically elected country number this is a republic but Italy we only that
34:16only the democratically elected prime minister can take a decision with regard
34:21to war that I don't know you're give a bit put in theory political leadership has
34:25to take the strategy political annango see wait a little one Indira Gandhi
34:29prathahn mantri I'll small question Indira Gandhi Prathahn mantri
34:33I guarantee you 100% defeat.
34:45No, no.
34:46If he is a defeat, he is a defeat.
34:50He is a defeat.
34:52He is a defeat.
34:57In China, there are skirmishes in the Middle East.
35:02I have a question about Ravijoshyav's interpretation and Mudri Sahib's interpretation.
35:10How do you interpret it?
35:13See, I have a question for you.
35:17I have a question for you.
35:19I have a question for you.
35:21I have a question for three years.
35:23I have a question for you.
35:25You can't have the cake and eat it too.
35:35Either you allow the publication.
35:38I don't agree with this.
35:48He is in a sensitive post.
35:50We are all bound by the Official Secret Act of 1923.
35:54We are all bound by the chain of command and communication.
36:01Build up to the decision.
36:02We are all bound by the decision.
36:03We are all bound by the decision.
36:04We are all bound by the decision.
36:06So, there are sensitive matters which you can't quote.
36:08The public cannot come to know about all this.
36:10The Official Secret Act of 1923 is in direct conflict with RTA of 2005.
36:16We are all bound by the debate.
36:17We are all bound by the debate.
36:18We are all bound by the debate.
36:19We are all bound by the constitutional head.
36:20You can't write everything for the public domain.
36:23And everybody can't take.
36:24We are all bound by the decision.
36:25You can't argue and not have any awareness.
36:27It is where the interpretation is.
36:29This is not an event of left.
36:31This is not an event of yesterday.
36:38This is not an event of yesterday.
36:41This is history.
36:431962.
36:46All of the BJP people have become independent.
36:52We have become independent.
36:55We have become independent.
37:00We have become independent.
37:02We have become independent.
37:04We have become independent.
37:06We have become independent.
37:08What time Maxim wrote in 1962?
37:10After the battle of R2 complex.
37:12It is not a complex complex.
37:14It is a complex complex.
37:16In that battle, 121 people were there.
37:18Company commander.
37:20And along with all soldiers.
37:24114 people were killed by China.
37:26It is not in Rasanglan.
37:28These people were captured PWs.
37:30One chap returned from that battle to tell the whole story how this battle was fought.
37:34You know what he writes?
37:38He says, everybody had a bullet on their chest or not on their back.
37:42You know what Time magazine wrote after 1962 operations?
37:46Indian soldier needs everything except courage.
37:48Courage is one thing that he has in abundance.
37:52Everything else was lacking.
37:54Equipment was not there.
37:56Arms were not there.
37:58Ammunition was not there.
37:59Everything was not there.
38:00Decisiveness is not there.
38:02Decisiveness is not about
38:04Oh, I have given you free hand.
38:06No, that is not decisiveness.
38:08Building up to that fight.
38:10Six years, seven years, ten years, eleven years.
38:12You have to equip your army.
38:14You have to train your army.
38:16You have to strengthen your army.
38:17That is decisiveness.
38:18Contrary, Prime Minister.
38:19What did you say?
38:21You said that.
38:22Political leadership is not a decision.
38:24General Naravani is not a decision.
38:25General Naravani is not a decision.
38:27I am not a decision.
38:28I am not a decision.
38:29I am not a decision.
38:30I am not a decision.
38:31What are you doing, Prime Minister?
38:33No, no.
38:34See, first is,
38:35he should have spoken to General Naravani himself.
38:37He should have spoken to General Naravani himself.
38:38He is not a decision.
38:40He is after all speaking to the Chief of Army Staff.
38:43And he is working for him.
38:45He was his choice.
38:46Actually, General Naravani is not a decision.
38:48He should have spoken to General Naravani.
38:49He should have spoken to General Naravani.
38:50I don't know.
38:51I have forgotten the name.
38:52No, no.
38:53No, there was another person who was in line.
38:54There was no other person.
38:55I will give you the history behind this.
38:56That's okay.
38:57But you are not a decision.
38:59That's okay.
39:00The first thing is,
39:01Prime Minister should have come online.
39:03First,
39:04he should have spoken to General Naravani.
39:05Given direction,
39:07find out what the ground realities are.
39:11Then say,
39:12see, these are my...
39:14You've decided this,
39:15that's why we are not here.
39:17You've given him the field manual.
39:18I said,
39:19that's how the field marshal used to leave Manik Shah and Indra Gandhi.
39:21They work in church.
39:22You work in church.
39:23And they have to say to them,
39:24they say to them,
39:25they have just killed each other.
39:26You are...
39:27like,
39:28that's right.
39:29You are saying that...
39:30That's right.
39:31That's right.
39:32That's right.
39:33That's right.
39:34You're saying this...
39:35see this we see ultimately you must understand one thing this is a very
39:40serious situation extremely serious situation or sata to a hathra never
39:45tether one kilometer door I do I'm I don't meet in hathra in a birthday the
39:50tanks birthday there I thought you're ready to go we have no it's not through
39:55BJP or oh oh really the guy like you know don't do mathuk at the middle but
40:00thanks birthday there they are still moving progressing forward yes I thought
40:03our own the critical period early prime minister should show leadership
40:09but the other thing is tanks do not move like that it's not a terrain for tanks to
40:18move tanks will only stand and fire I can't on railway where tanks move they're in
40:22deserts actually tanks are meant for desert II high altitude regional and act
40:26to go to the direct firing role only of the health package in thanks now
40:29position mani the way it is a deterrent it's a deterrent that you just can't
40:33move because there are peaks there there is limited line of communication and
40:37movement asten there is no line of coming
40:38there is no line of coming up and there is no line of coming up and there is no line of
40:43operational details system gothithi dhe anntak e othini
40:47prime minister illa ni fire maadu onth a hellba kitta
40:50illa illa I don't agree with that
40:52that is what I am he doesn't know
40:54tactical battle area
40:56tactical battle area nalil yeh nakhtna idhe anna otho
40:57avari gothithi lale
40:58yes joshi sir maat naad isthi nini manna naga
41:01break na samayya chandra shaker imi go time kuru tini
41:03joshi sir illi maat naad taayitha aag
41:05ond vichara pundhu
41:06a sandar padalli yaudu sultana odunna
41:09madi anna odunna heelodunna haru thup padisii
41:12beri yen heelodun ksadhyayitu
41:14action na vichara anta bandhaga
41:16pradani aasuchna yana kododun ksadhyayana
41:24how do pradani kododunna niyaar kododunna you know
41:28the decision to go to war must be taken by political leadership not by the army
41:36the army cannot push the country into war that will be extremely reckless on the part of the army to do that
41:41the army to do that
41:43and maad baad vaakal saa
41:45adukos kara army generals hu
41:47matter na raiz maat thara political level ali
41:49adukos kara army generals hu
41:51matter na raiz maat thara political level ali
41:53cabinet committee on security is hei
41:55amele china study group is hei
41:57china study group is informal body
41:59but cabinet committee on security is a formal body
42:01that is presided by the prime minister
42:03that is the defence minister is hei
42:05NSA is hei
42:07external affairs minister is hei
42:09we are
42:11we are
42:13one
42:15we are
42:17one
42:19of the economic fallout the political fallout the diplomatic fallout
42:23and whether we will get the support of russia or u.s. in the context
42:27in the context.
42:28That way, I would like to consider that the war will be the decision.
42:34Raviy Joshi, sir, the president of the Raviy Joshi, sir, is coming in a tank.
42:41I said, absolutely.
42:42When the president of the Raviy Joshi is coming in a tank, the president of the Raviy Joshi is coming in a tank,
42:48or when he talks about political leadership, he says,
42:54What do you want to talk about now?
42:59This is the first attack.
43:02This is the first attack.
43:04This is the first attack.
43:09This is the first attack.
43:13Actually, our tanks were medium batted tanks.
43:16Our tanks were far superior to the Chinese tanks.
43:19General Joshi could have easily taken up on those tanks.
43:22They were destroyed.
43:24But you have a direct press.
43:27The question is,
43:32there is a protocol there on the China border
43:36that generals cannot fire.
43:38In July, there is a fist fight.
43:45They are fighting with clubs.
43:48And they all have weapons.
43:50But they are not using the weapons.
43:52Because of this rule.
43:53That you cannot fire.
43:55So, that rule is held sacrosanct.
44:00So, that rule is violated.
44:01So, that rule is violated.
44:02So, that rule is violated.
44:03So, General Narvani is clear.
44:07Yes.
44:08Yes.
44:09Yes.
44:10Yes.
44:11Yes.
44:12Yes.
44:13Yes.
44:14Yes.
44:15Yes.
44:16Yes.
44:17Yes.
44:18Yes.
44:19Yes.
44:20Yes.
44:21Yes.
44:22Yes.
44:23Yes.
44:24Yes.
44:25Yes.
44:26Yes.
44:27Yes.
44:28Yes.
44:29Yes.
44:30Yes.
44:31Yes.
44:32Yes.
44:33Yes.
44:34Yes.
44:35NARVANI IS NOT RELEASED?
44:37Yes, it's not true.
44:39There are no words in the magazine.
44:43In terms of the defense and security,
44:46you can get permission to assess.
44:50If you get a letter,
44:52you don't have permission to get a letter.
44:56Why don't you get it?
44:58You and us.
45:00Look, this is the same way.
45:04No, no, no.
45:05Just escalation.
45:06It's an escalation.
45:07Escalation on the Sandharapdalli.
45:08Munchenand kuda local alane dishyent to go back.
45:11Army dishyent to go back.
45:12So, 2-3 years ago, General Sahgat Singh on the land.
45:16Naturalamil itharihti chines attack adaga.
45:18Mailㄱ sarkarayalto restrain, don't fire on the land.
45:20But you dishyent to go on the we will fire on the land.
45:23Absolutely correct.
45:24Exactly.
45:25So, alline local commander Jeevwa hsenevru.
45:27Jeevwa hsenevru asami division.
45:29Aawunay dishyent to go on the land.
45:33just one person.
45:34Yes.
45:35Allukuda adaga,
45:36one of the,
45:37the assayami regiment,
45:38he took the mission to fire.
45:40Sir, the last comment,
45:41Sir, last comment,
45:42Muddiri sir,
45:43Muddiri sir,
45:44Pustak yak release,
45:45that's not a confusion.
45:47That's not a confusion.
45:48But you must see the background,
45:49Narwaniya,
45:502021,
45:51Yaavaga retired,
45:52April,
45:532020,
45:55Rawat avaro,
45:56accident alli,
45:57100 janus tha tha tha tha,
45:58helicopter crash alli.
45:59You know,
46:00that means,
46:01he was not a pliable,
46:02loyal,
46:03one question.
46:04Dispensation heeng beekko,
46:05hangge ichchi illa,
46:06otherwise,
46:07Narwaniya would have become the CDS.
46:09Actually,
46:10he was the most eligible person to become CDS,
46:12after Rawat.
46:13For nine months,
46:14CDS posed to,
46:15Idhinya agir illa,
46:16Philadelphia.
46:17So,
46:18you must see the background,
46:19Narwaniya avaro,
46:2020,
46:2122,
46:2221,
46:23post to,
46:24Idhinya agir illa,
46:25Phillip agir illa.
46:26In the month of June,
46:27July,
46:28Government tweaked,
46:29the criteria,
46:30eligibility criteria,
46:31for CDS.
46:32That's why,
46:33three-star general,
46:34Anil Chavanan,
46:35the other,
46:36retirement in the,
46:37Karkon Bandhu,
46:38CDS,
46:39otherwise,
46:40Narwaniya,
46:41did not find a favour,
46:42with the government,
46:43even,
46:44even while in service.
46:45So,
46:46some publication houses,
46:47do not release,
46:48controversy,
46:49Penguin House,
46:50why is it not written to,
46:51MOD to release the book?
46:52They want to raise all such things,
46:57so that book sells well,
46:58also.
46:59Last comment.
47:00Yes,
47:01last comment.
47:14I am going to turn on the left-right center.
47:18I am going to turn on the left-right center.
47:21I am going to turn on the left-right center.
Comments