00:00Joshi sari li maatnaar thai thaga ond vichara banttu
00:02A sandar badalli yaudu sultana odunna madi annoodunna heildodunna haruttu padisii
00:09Biri yen heildodukk sathya aittu
00:10Action na vichara anthabandhaaga pradani yaasuchanayenna kododukk sathya na
00:15How do? Pradani kodudu ilin dren yair kodudu bhekku
00:24You know the decision to go to war must be taken by political leadership not by the army
00:33The army cannot push the country into war that will be extremely reckless on the part of the army to do that
00:38Aur maadbhaar dha akal saa adukos kara army generals hu matter na raiz maatthara political level ali
00:46There is a cabinet committee on security, China study group, China study group is informal body but cabinet committee on security is a formal body
00:57That is presided by the prime minister, defence ministers, NSA, external affairs ministers
01:04So aur maadbhaar dha akal kodudu the economic fallout, the political fallout, the diplomatic fallout
01:18And whether we will get the support of Russia or U.S. in the context
01:24So you should note that the war could be taken by the end of the war
01:30So it is a decision to be taken by the Pazar mantri
01:34Raviyoshi sir, nak tank kodudu
01:37Nak tank kodudu
01:38Nak tank kodudu bertha kanta sandharabdalli
01:41Pradani mantri or illa full fledg wadhari
01:45What do you think about political leadership?
01:49What do you think about political leadership?
01:51Who is talking about this?
01:56If you have attacked by the first time,
01:59you will have to take these Nalk tank.
02:06Yeah, Nalk tank,
02:08our tanks, actually our tanks were medium batted tanks.
02:12Our tanks were far superior to the Chinese tanks.
02:15And General Joshi could have easily taken up on those tanks.
02:18They would have destroyed the tanks.
02:20Okay, but you have to take a direct question.
02:24Now, Nalk tank, Aida tank,
02:27the question is,
02:29there is a protocol there on the China border
02:32that generals cannot fire.
02:34If you look at the Galvan clash,
02:39there is a fist fight.
02:42They are fighting with clubs.
02:45And they all have weapons.
02:47But they are not using the weapons.
02:48Because of this rule that you cannot fire.
02:51So that rule is held sacrosanct.
02:57So that rule is violated,
02:59and General Narvani is clear.
03:04Yes, yes.
03:06Yes.
03:07H.N. Chandrasekhar,
03:08you are going to talk about your speech.
03:10Yes.
03:11You are going to talk about your speech.
03:13You are going to talk about the rules.
03:14And you have to talk about the rules.
03:15So you are going to talk about the rules.
03:16Very beautiful question, sir.
03:17One thing, sir.
03:18One thing, sir.
03:19One thing, sir.
03:20Is the President's government
03:22the school is going to talk about the rules.
03:24You are going to talk about Narvani's words.
03:27They are going to talk about Narvani's words.
03:34That's what it means.
03:36So, there are no words in the magazine.
03:39In the defense and security,
03:43you can get the permission to assess.
03:47If you get a letter,
03:49you don't have permission to get the address.
03:53Why don't you get the address?
03:54You and us.
03:56Look, this is how you get the war.
04:00Just escalation.
04:03As a result of the escalation, there is also a situation in the local army.
04:08So, in the 1980s, the general Sahagat Singh said that the Chinese attacked the Nathulam,
04:13the government will restrain, don't fire.
04:17But if you have a situation, we will fire.
04:19Absolutely correct.
04:20Exactly. So, the local commander of the Assammy Division,
04:26they have a situation in that situation.
04:27So, if you have a situation, just one person.
04:31He took the ditcher to fire.
04:37Last comment.
04:39Now last comment, Mudri Sir.
04:41Pustak yak release.
04:43Confusion 3.
04:45Yak release,
04:47Optional Secret Act violation.
04:49Sensitive details.
04:51But you must see the background.
04:53Narwani,
04:552021,
04:57in April,
04:592020,
05:01Ravath accidentally,
05:03helicopter crash.
05:05That means he was not a pliable, loyal
05:07one question.
05:09Otherwise, Narwani would have become the CDS.
05:13Actually, he was the most eligible person to become CDS after Ravath.
05:17For 9 months,
05:19CDS posed to Philip.
05:21In the month of June, July,
05:23Government tweaked the criteria,
05:25Eligibility criteria for CDS.
05:27He was the three-star general.
05:29He was the three-star general,
05:31Anil Chavan,
05:33He was the one who did retirement.
05:35Otherwise, Narwani did not find favour with the Government,
05:39even while in service.
05:41So, some publication houses do not release.
05:43Why is it controversial?
05:45Penguin House, why is it not written to M.O.D.
05:47to release the book?
05:49They want to raise the...
05:51They want to raise all such things,
05:53so that book sells well, also.
05:55Last comment.
05:57I have written quotes,
05:59I have written quotes,
06:01and I have written a general Narwani.
06:03I have written a B.J.P.C.
06:05I have written a clarification.
06:07Yes, thank you.
Comments