- 10 months ago
A selection of fascinating details from the final days of the Ponds.
Category
📺
TVTranscript
00:00The thing that people tend to forget about Doctor Who is its absolute ability to give pain.
00:05Just pain. With some slight trepidation, I'm Sean Farrick for Who Culture, and here are
00:1020 Things You Didn't Know About The Angels Take Manhattan.
00:14Number 20. The Ponds Wanted a Permanent Goodbye. Aside from that Statue of Liberty reveal,
00:19The Angels Take Manhattan is most famous for being the last regular appearance of Amy and
00:24Rory Pond. The 11th Doctor's first friends were snatched from the jaws of safety by a rogue angel
00:28and cast backwards in time forevermore, writing them out of the show in a tragic and permanent
00:33fashion, which is exactly what the actors wanted. Karen Gillan and Arthur Darville requested that
00:38Amy and Rory be removed for good, as they didn't want their demise to be undercut by recurring
00:42cameos like certain other companions. Oh, gross. Gillan did go back on her word when she appeared
00:48briefly at the end of Matt Smith's final episode, but that cameo was both incredibly short and
00:53entirely fitting, considering Amy's connection to the Raggedy Man. Darville, meanwhile, hasn't
00:57been seen in an episode of Doctor Who since departing.
01:00Number 19. It was originally the Daleks. It's difficult to imagine it being any other way,
01:04but the Weeping Angels were not the original villains of this story. Initially, it was going
01:08to be the Daleks. Writer and showrunner Stephen Moffat felt that such a devastating blow to the
01:13Doctor should be dealt by his oldest enemies, adding more heat to their Ian's long feud. However,
01:18he was cautious about returning the Daleks to New York, as this had already been done,
01:22relatively recently, in Daleks in Manhattan Evolution of the Daleks, feeling that the Angels were
01:27a better fit for this sombre noir setting. They were drafted in instead, and the Sons of Scarrow
01:33were moved to the series premiere, Asylum of the Daleks. The Daleks would probably have made for a
01:37much more predictable ending for the Ponds, so we're glad it wasn't them. Number 18. Middle Name Mayhem.
01:43Whovians must have been delighted when they finally learned Rory's middle name in the Angels Take
01:47Manhattan, were it not for the small fact that he had to die for them to do so. On Rory's tombstone at the
01:52end of the episode, the text reads, in loving memory, Rory Arthur Williams, aged 82. It took us until his final episode to learn that his middle name is Arthur, poor Rory, but of course this is the same as actor Arthur Darvill's first name, but it could also be a nod to Mark Williams, who played Rory's dad, Brian, in his role of Arthur Weasley in the Harry Potter movies.
02:13Well, Amy's inscription gets zero mention of a middle name, despite the fact that it was revealed to be Jessica way back in her second episode, The Beast Below. Why no middle name for Amy? Who knows? Damn, gravestone double standards.
02:23Number 17. To kill or not to kill. Booting off a companion can't be an easy job for any showrunner, even if Russell T. Davis did it basically any chance he got. When the time came for Moffat to say goodbye to Amy and Rory, the weight of this decision really affected him. He told Radio Times in 2012 that he would back and forth several times over the couple's fate.
02:42How and why would they leave? And would they live or die? I wrote and rewrote. I had a completely different ending and threw it away. So many times over those mad few days, the fate of the pawns changed. Alive, dead, alive, dead. Nothing felt right. Nothing felt inevitable. In the end, he went for a halfway house. The couple were dead in the timeline of the show, but got to live out full lives in the past. It makes you wonder what the ending he threw away was like. Can't have been any sadder, surely.
03:07Number 16. Grail's grim alternate fate. When Amy and the Doctor first find River and Rory in the past, they've been captured by Julius Grail, an avid collector of artifacts. While his fate was left ambiguous in the final cut, there were initially plans to show what happened to him, and they weren't very nice.
03:23One early draft had him banished back to a workshop where he was forced to make the very items he had spent his life collecting. A second idea was to show him being sent to the past and then have him turn up in one of his own paintings.
03:33This painting would have revealed that the Angels had sent him back to the Renaissance where he was enslaved. The second idea was filmed, but was dropped during editing.
03:40Number 15. The jump was filmed first.
03:42It's no secret that TV shows and movies aren't usually filmed in story order. Sometimes, moments towards the end are among the first things captured.
03:50This is precisely what happened with The Angels Take Manhattan. The Ponds think that they've saved themselves when they jumped off Winter Key, killing Rory twice in one night and creating a paradox that defeats the Angels.
04:01The jump was filmed on the 23rd of March 2012, the very first day of recording for The Angels Take Manhattan.
04:06Meanwhile, the climactic graveyard sequence was filmed a few weeks later on the 19th of April 2012, making that a very sad day in Doctor Who history indeed.
04:15Number 14. Cherub Inspiration.
04:17The Angels Take Manhattan introduced infant versions of the Stone Assassins.
04:21Aww, how cute. Until they send you back to the Middle Ages.
04:25This type of angel didn't exist until director Nick Huron went on a location scouting trip to New York.
04:30Huron took pictures of various landmarks of the city, including the Bethsaida Fountain in Central Park,
04:35which has a huge angel statue as its centerpiece, and is surrounded by smaller cherub statues.
04:40When studying this photograph back in the UK, Moffat came up with the idea of a cherub variant of the Waking Angels,
04:46as he felt their childlike design made them incredibly creepy.
04:50And you know what? He was bang on the money for that one.
04:51Number 13. Karen Gillan Read the Afterword.
04:54The Angels Take Manhattan is bookended by the Doctor reading a novel written by River Song,
04:59which details the events of the episode before and after they happen.
05:02At the end, the Doctor reads the last page of the book, which turns out to be a special message written by Amy,
05:08to let him know that she and Rory lived a good life and still loved him always and forever.
05:12It's a heavy scene, one of the last bits of communication between the girl who waited and her raggedy man.
05:18So, Gillan felt it was important that they did as much possible to get it right.
05:21This resulted in Gillan sitting just off screen, reading the letter aloud to Smith to get as much emotion as possible out of his performance.
05:29Amy and the Doctor. Friends till the very end.
05:31Number 12. The letter scene's crazy filming conditions.
05:34Speaking of this scene, it was way more complicated to film than you'd think it would be.
05:39For this tearful farewell, Smith was afforded not three takes, not two, but one. One take.
05:45This is because it was shot on location in Central Park where hundreds of people had gathered to watch it being filmed.
05:51Imagine the stress the crew must have felt. It can't have been easy.
05:54Smith was given a different page of the book to hold in case somebody photographed the real one,
05:58and Gillan was forced to read her lines incredibly quietly in case she was recorded.
06:03Despite all this pressure, Smith pulled it off, which is a testament to just how blummin' good of an actor the man really is.
06:08Number 11. It was almost wibbly-wobblier.
06:11The Angels' first episode, Blink, gave the world one of the ultimate Doctor Who memes in the form of Ten's legendary
06:17wibbly-wobbly-timey-wimey speech, so it makes sense that such mind-bending concepts nearly made a return in one of the Angels' most prominent appearances.
06:26Plans for The Angels Take Manhattan originally featured a much more complex depiction of their time manipulation powers.
06:33Audiences would have seen even more versions of Rory running about the Winter Quay,
06:37as well as different incarnations of Sam Garner, the detective from the cold open.
06:41Additionally, the girl Garner sees in the window was to have been staring at an older, future version of herself.
06:48Eventually, it was decided to simplify things a bit, but this was probably for the best.
06:52Number 10. An important last-minute addition.
06:55The final recording for The Angels Take Manhattan was supposed to be a few pickup shots on the 30th of April 2012,
07:00but at the last minute, an extra day of filming was pencilled in for the 28th of June.
07:04It was decided that the Doctor needed to say why he couldn't take the TARDIS back to 1938 New York,
07:09so lines were written explaining how the timelines were all scrambled.
07:13This pickup was filmed at Box Cemetery in Linnelli, Wales, where the rest of the graveyard scene was shot.
07:18It was directed by Dinosaurs on a Spaceship and A Town Called Mercy's Sol Metstein,
07:23as The Angels Take Manhattan director Nick Huron was unavailable.
07:25It's a good job these lines were added, otherwise fans would have been even more confused
07:29why the Doctor couldn't go back and rescue the ponds all over again.
07:33Hmm.
07:34Number 9. Pond River Publishing.
07:36Spoiler alert, but everybody knows that River Song's real name
07:39is Melody Pond, and there's a subtle reference to both these monikers in The Angels Take Manhattan.
07:44The book that starts this whole mess, Melody Malone, Private Detective in Old New York Town,
07:49is written by River and published by Amy.
07:51As a result, the name of the publishing company is Pond River Publishing,
07:55a neat little nod to both mother and daughter.
07:57This detail isn't visible in the episode, but it was confirmed by some production artwork.
08:01The actual text inside the book was taken from a real novel called The Thin Man by Dashiell Hammett.
08:07Hammett was a famous detective writer in the 20s and 30s and was responsible for penning
08:10The Maltese Falcon, the film version of which heavily inspired The Angels Take Manhattan's
08:15tone and setting.
08:16Number 8.
08:17A Story of Lasts.
08:18Amy and Rory weren't the only ones saying goodbye in this episode.
08:22It was also the final appearance of the title sequence that had been used from The Eleven
08:26Doctor's first outing with the next episode, the 2012 Christmas special, The Snowmen, introducing
08:31a redesign.
08:31The Angels Take Manhattan is also the last time we saw Eleven's tweed jacket and his first
08:36TARDIS console room, both of which were also replaced in The Snowmen.
08:39The loss of the ponds truly was the end of an era.
08:42Number 7.
08:43The Epilogue That Almost Never Was.
08:45In The Power of Three, Rory's dad Brian makes The Doctor promise that he'll bring his
08:50son and daughter-in-law back safely.
08:51The Time Lord agrees, only to betray that trust one adventure later.
08:55Poor Brian had his entire world turned upside down with seemingly no explanation, that is
09:00until you watch PS.
09:02Premiering online shortly after The Angels Take Manhattan's broadcast, PS is a short animated
09:07scene of Brian receiving a letter from Amy and Rory delivered by their adopted son.
09:12This sequence, which was written by Chris Chibnall, was supposed to be filmed in live action,
09:16but Brian's actor, Mark Williams, was unavailable for the shoot.
09:19Rather than scrapping it entirely, the storybirds were animated and Arthur Darville was brought
09:23in to narrate, resulting in a heartfelt epilogue to The Ponds' journey.
09:27Number 6.
09:28It's fans' favourite episode of Series 7.
09:30Series 7 was a strange time for Doctor Who, as it was split into two distinctive parts,
09:35one with The Ponds and one without.
09:36There were some great episodes either side of the divide, but the one that Whovians thought
09:41was the best of the bunch was, you guessed it, The Angels Take Manhattan.
09:44On IMDb, the episode is the joint highest ranked along with The Name of the Doctor, both of
09:49which scored 9 out of 10.
09:51Though if you count the specials as part of the series, The Day of the Doctor tops them
09:54both with 9.3 out of 10.
09:56While the contenders for the top spot were Asylum of the Daleks at 8.5, The Bells of St. John
10:01at 7.8, and Hyde at 7.6.
10:04Number 5.
10:05Brightwell and Hyman.
10:06No, Brightwell and Hyman is not a firm of lawyers or estate agents, but rather the name
10:10of a company that makes matches.
10:12Rory uses a box of Brightwell and Hyman matches to fend off the cherub statues, but what you
10:17almost certainly didn't know is that this brand would appear in Doctor Who again.
10:21A few episodes later, in The Crimson Horror, a poster can be seen in the background of a
10:25shot advertising Brightwell and Hyman quality matches.
10:28This makes sense, seeing as how the setting of Sweetville centers around a giant match factory.
10:32Brightwell and Hyman is never once spoken on screen, making this quite possibly one of
10:36the most obscure connections in the show.
10:39Number 4.
10:41Why the Doctor can't visit the ponds.
10:42One of the biggest bugbears fans have with The Angels Take Manhattan is that, in theory,
10:46the Doctor could just hop in the TARDIS, choose a random city in the past and tell the ponds
10:50to meet him there.
10:51But unfortunately for a fez-loving hero, he's played fast and loose with the rules of time,
10:55and Amy and Rory's history was too wibbly wobbly to interfere with.
10:58At least, that's the explanation offered by Stephen Moffat, who said he can't interfere.
11:03In normal circumstances he might have gone back and said, look, we'll just put a headstone
11:06up and you'll write the book, but there is so much scar tissue and the number of paradoxes
11:10that have already been inflicted on that nexus of timelines that will rip apart if you try
11:14and do one more thing, he has to leave it alone.
11:17Considering how often Doctor interferes with those timelines and fixed points, it's an
11:20explanation that's unlikely to satisfy many fans.
11:23But over a decade later, it's the only explanation we're ever going to get.
11:26Number 3.
11:27It has a sequel.
11:28During the COVID-19 pandemic, Whovians around the world came together to watch old episodes
11:32of the show.
11:33To coincide with the screening of the Doctor's wife, a short film was produced called Rory's
11:37Story.
11:38Written by Neil Gaiman, it featured Mr. Pond talking to his soon-to-be adopted son Anthony
11:43from 1946.
11:44He's filming himself on a smartphone he'd carried from the future, just don't worry
11:48about how he might have charged it, okay?
11:49Rory recounts several of his and Amy's adventures, including how they ended up in the past, before
11:54his wife calls for him to come help paint the baby's room.
11:56It was lovely to check in on the ponds after so many years away, especially during those
12:00gloomy pandemic times.
12:02Number 2.
12:03Yowza.
12:04The Doctor has said and done many unfashionable things over the years, but uttering the word
12:07Yowza, that ranks up there with the cringiest.
12:10Eleven says it while reading Melody Malone, prompting Amy to call out his choice of words.
12:14She shouldn't have been too surprised though, as he'd actually said it before.
12:18In The Almost People, when looking for an escape route, the Doctor exclaims Yowza, but
12:22he finds one, much to Amy's confusion.
12:24Then, in the name of the Doctor, he says it again after avoiding the Great Intelligence's
12:28minions, the Whispermen.
12:30They've never said it since though, probably realized how uncool it was.
12:33Number 1.
12:34Amy's ending was years in the making.
12:36In December 2011, it was announced that Karen Gillan and Arthur Darvill were exiting Doctor
12:40Who, nearly an entire year before it actually happened.
12:43Moffat tried to throw viewers off the scent by introducing new companion Jenna Coleman early,
12:48but we all knew the inevitable was coming.
12:50Interestingly enough, Amy's swan song had actually been foretold much earlier.
12:54And by much earlier, we mean her very first episode.
12:57When a young Amelia is waiting for the Doctor to return in the 11th hour, there's a shot
13:01of her looking up at the sky as she hears the sound of the TARDIS.
13:04This seems a bit random at the time, as it was established that the Doctor never came back
13:08for her.
13:09And, in fact, that was an important part of Amy's character.
13:13She was the girl who waited, after all.
13:15In The Angels Take Manhattan, however, we learn that the Doctor did eventually go back for
13:19her, but only after Amy asks him to in her final letter.
13:23This is something Moffat had been planning to reveal from day one, as he revealed to the
13:27press before The Angels Take Manhattan debuted.
13:30After showing Amelia Pond in the garden as a young girl in the 11th hour, the final shot
13:34in The Angels Take Manhattan is a punchline I've been waiting to tell for two and a half
13:38years.
13:39One of the great things about The Eleventh Doctor's era is that it's one giant story
13:43arc from the first episode to the last.
13:45This payoff in particular was incredibly emotional for fans who'd stuck with Amy's journey from
13:50that very first shot of her lonely old house.
13:53That's everything for our list folks.
13:54What did you think of this episode and what did you think of this list?
13:57Let us know in the comments below.
13:58Please don't forget to follow us over on Twitter at WhoCulture, we're on Instagram at
14:01WhoCulture as well and we're also on TikTok.
14:04Thank you so much for your ongoing support, you are wonderful, you are brilliant.
14:08Look after yourselves and above all else until I'm talking to you again, keep things wibbly
14:11wobbly.